3BiT # 39948-UA YKPAIHA 3BIT 3 OUIHKH 3AKYHIBEJIb B YKPAIHI 2006 piic 12 JnIcTouaAa 2006 poKy (oHoBsieHo 30 6epe3Hq 2007 p.) YUpaB3iuHH oaepailiuoH nOJUTHICH Ta nocayr PerioH CBpoHH i CepeAHboiA3iM Document of the World Bank BAJIIOTA BaMoTHa oAHHHUR = YI(aPiHCbKa rpHBHq (rpH.) I rpH. = 0,198 AojiapiB CLlA I Aonap CHlIA = 5,05 rpH. MIPH TA BArH MeTpH'Ha cHcTema 'IUHAHCOBHIR PIK I cisHR -31 rpyAHu AKPOHIMH TA AEPEBIATYPH AMKY AHTttmoHonon6HHA KOMiTeT YKpaiHH B,a3 BBiCHHX KAep,KaBRHx 3axyniaeilb" (iH~opMauirIHo-aHaaIiTHwHHA 6ioneTeHb) BP BepxosHa PaAa BOA BHwuHtl opraH ayArTy Aep)*KoMcTaT iepTeaBHHti KOMiTCT CTaThcCTIHKH YKpaiHni .3 JenapTaMeHT 3 nHTaHb KoopauHauii AepKaBHHX 3aKyniBenb Xi HeCM(aCHi fIAflPUMcTBa CKA "CBpOnIeiCbKe KOHcaJITHHroBe areHTCTBO", - npHBaTHme nianpHCMCTBO, Wo aOMiHyc B c~epi _aep)KaBHHX 3aKynienlb cC CBponeftcvlKwl Co003 3,3 3aKoH npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniii 303 3BiT 3 OW1iHC 3aKyniBejib B YKpaiHi KMY Ka6iHeT MiHiCTrPiB YKpaiH KPY KoHTponEHo-peBi3iiHe ynpaBhiiHHR MiHeKoHoMiKH MiHicTepCTDo eKOHOMiKH MiH4iH MiHicTepcTBo 4liHaHciB MCFI Mani i cepeAHi niAnuicMcTBa HBY HauioHanbHAm 6aHK YKpaiHH HYO HeypRAoBi opraHi3auii o6nacb aaMiHicTpaTHBHo-TepHTOpiajTbHa OAUIMHUS Pfl PaxyHKoBa nianaTa (aHwIHtl opraH ayJHTy) CKK CneuianbHa KOHTPOJIbHa KOMicis 3 nHTaHb6 AepXKaBHEX 3aKyniBeJ]b npH PaxyHKoBirt nanaTi YKpa!Hu COT CBiTona opraHi3anii TopriBni CTX0 CTaHAapTHa TeHAepHa AoKyMeHTatuiA TFIY TeHAepHa nanaTa YKpaIHH (cniAKa rpoMaAcbKHX opraHi3auig, 5Kiti nepeAaHo BHKOHaHHq psAY _YHK_IWAi B raniy3i Aep*KaBHHX 3aKyniBelb) Y,3 YroAa npo AepxCanii 3aKyisBJfi (6araToCTOpoHHiH iHCTpyMeHT CaiToBoi opralHi3auii TOpriBnIli) YA_ _ CCTeMa yfpaJIiHHx aep)KaBHHMH 4IiHaHCaMH Ltrn UeHTp TeHAePHHX npoueAyp (npHaaTHa yCTaHoBa, 19o B3acMOAiC 3 TeHAepHolo rlanaToio) DFID AgenapTaMeHT MiKHapoAHoro PO3BUTKy BemiKo6pHTaHif FIAS KoncynbTaTHBHa cityix6a 3 nUTaHL iHo3eMHHx iHBeCTHUiti OECD/DAC KoMiTeT niATpHMKH PO3BHTKY OpraHi3auif eKoHoMiqHoro cniBpo6iTHMUTBa Ta PO3BUTKY SIDA WBeA6cbKa AreHumi CniBpo6iTHHlRBa B ranIy3i MI)KHapoAHoro PO3BHTKY TACIS flporpaMa CaponeRicbKo! KOMiCii /CC 3 HBAaHHR TexHiqHoi AonoMorH KpaIHaM CXiAHO1 CBponH Ta ueHTpa]TbHoI A3ii UNCITRAL KoMicji OpraHi3auii 06'cAHaHHx Hauirl 3 nHTaHb 3aiOHoAaBCTra B rany3i MibKHapolwoi TOpriaBi USAID ArerrcTao mixcHapoaHoro Po3BsTKy CnonyqeHHx IlTaTiB AMepHKm Biue-npe3HAeHT Wllireo Kaily (Shigeo Katsu, ECAVP) no perioNy CHPOH0 i CepeAHboT A31i AInpe.cTop y cnpaBax YKpaTHi, Ioc SepmiHrem (Paul Bermingham, ECCU2) SECapyci Ta MOJIAOB 1HpeK-rop ceKTopy CyHjn GaTraiapin (Sunil Bhattacharya, ECSPS) KepinRHHc rpynH upoeKTy HaymaA A. XaH (Naushad A. Khan, ECSPS) YKPAIHA 3BIT 3 OUXIHKH 3AKYIIIBEJIb B YKPAIHI, 2006 piiC 3MiCT CTHCJI OF J or l ....................................................1 1. BCTyn .......................................................................4..4 2. HopMaTHBHo-npaBOBa 6a3a ................................................................................................... 7 3. IHCTUTyLtiHiHa CTpyKTypa i ynpaBJIiHCbKH nIOTeHi . ....................................1 3. IHCTHTyJiUHa CTpYKTypa i yrIpaBJIiHCbKHA IOTeHuia................................... I 4. 4>YHKIiOHYBaHHA CHCTeMH 3aKYniBenb ........................................................................ 19 5. ,lgo6poqeCHiCTbi nPO30piCTb CHCTeMH gepXKaBHHX 3aKyniBeinb ................................................. 33 6. EieKTPOHHi3aKyniBJi ........................................................................................36 7. BHKOHaHHS yroA npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyrnBJi ......................................... 38 8. 36Jm)KeHHs 3 AHpeKTHBaMH CC ILOAO 3aKYniBenJbi npHClHaHHH qO COT ..................40 9. AHa3i3 pH3HKiB i HJaH AiH 303 3a 2006 piK ......................................... 42 )o,AaTOK 1. )eTaj1bHHHi niiaH BnPOBaJPKeHHA_(Ha OCHOBi peKOMeH,AauirI 2001 i 2006 pp.).... 45 JlohIaTOK 2. KOHTPOJTbHi HOKa3HHKH ............................................. 48 ROAaTOK 3. CxeMa OpraHi3auirLHOI CTPYKTYPH CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejnb AO 3MiHH 3aKOHY .....................................................................50 ,aO,aaTOK 4. CxeMa OpraHi3aLuiiHOI CTPYKTYPH CHCTeMH ,Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb niCJI5 3MiHH 3aKOHY ..................................................................... 51 Y cKiiaAi rpynH CBiTOBoro 6aHKy npaujoBaJH: HayiiatA A. XaH, ECSPS (KePiBHHK rpynH npoeKTY), AHHa BeniorypCbKa, IPHHa WHMeJIboBa, BeHeal4KTa T. On;iBepoc- MipaHjia (ECSPS), KHYT Rlainonbng (OPCPR), KpicTi;aH X. Boncep (lopHcT- KOHCYJIbTaHT 3 nHTaHHb Mi)KHapOJIHHx 3aKyniBeiib) i ryJlbHapa Cycp6aCBa (KOHCyfbTaHT). 3eim 3 OZixHU 3aKynieellb f YKpaiHi - Cmuc.nu oa0M. YKpalHa 3BiT 3 OUiHKH 3aIyIIiBeJI6 B YKpaiHi - 2006 piK CTHCJIHI4 OfJ1FX TA AOaATOK BIA 30 EEPE3HA 2007 POKY. HoHaA 4 Mjipa. jioaapiB CWA, a6o 11pH6JIH3Ho 5 BiACOTKiB BiA CBoro BBIn BHTpaTHJIB YiCpaTHa Ha Aep)(aBHi 3aKyNiB3i B 2005 polti. FloqHHaioqH 3 1996 POKY pS4 M1lKHapORHHX opraHi3auir, 30KpeMa, CBiToBHI 6aHK, CC B paMKax nporpamii TACIS Ta USAID cniBnpaiUoBaanH 3 ypRSAOM YKpaTHH 3wAJn BnpOBaaweHHE qiTKof Ta 3araj1bHo0ocTynHHof CHCTeMH Alep)KaBHIx 3aKyniBenb B Kpa:Hi. 3aKoH npo Xaep)KaBHi 3aKyniBni, SRKUM 6yn1o BBefaeHO B UilO Hane)KHi nonIo)KeHHs, Ha6paB q'iHHOCTi B JniOTOMy 2000 pOKy. Y 2001 poui CBiTOBHH 6aHK 3RiiCHHB aHaJli3 4yHiCLtioHyBaHHSI CHCTeMH aepKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJib B YKpajHi Ta niAroTyBaBm OKJiaauHH 3BiT 3 OttiHiKH 3aKyniBejb B YicpafHi (303). Leri 3BiT Bi43Ha4HB A1K I1OCArHeHHSI, TaK i HeBHppiweHi nIHTaHHSq, 30KpeMa, noTpe6y B noaaJbwoMy yAOCKOHaJieHHi 3aKOHoAsaBqo1f 6a3i, B noJinwlUeHHi npoLueSD1yp Ta npaKT14Ki npOBeAJeHHS aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeilb, y BHKoHaHHi noJl)KeHHb iCHylOtlOrO 3aKoHy, y p036yaoBi KaBPOBOrO Ta iHCTHTyLxiAHoro nOTeHluiany, y CyMiCHOCTi 3 HariKpaigoIo Mi)KHapOAHOto nlpaKTHKOIO Ta y J]iKBiraLui KOpynIOiY. B 3BiTi 3ra,AyBanacb TaKOxK Heo6xi,1HiCTb BnpoBaBKeHHR npo30pHx ripaBHun, po3po6KH CTaH,aapTHO6 TeHAepHOi XOKyMeHTaUli, nocHneHHA iHcTHTyUiiHoro Ta opraHi3aLuirHoro nOTeHLuiajiy, P03WHpeHHR KOjla o6oB' 3KiB ynoBHoBawKeHoro opraHy (MacTbcX Ha yBa3i BiUiJI MiHicTepcTBa eKoHoMiKH, Uo 3,RiACHtOBaB HarnSlA Ta HaAlaBaB niA,TpHMKy B c4epi eplKaBHHx 3aKyniBeJlb), a TaKOwI pO3BHTOK CnpOMO)KHOCTi P03nOpRLHHKiB 6lopKeTHHx KOWITiB uoAlo npOBezgeHHA 3aKyniBeRb. HHHiWHiri 3BiT C teprOBHM BHeCKOM BaHKy y pe4opMyBaHHA raJny3i Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBe3lb B YKpaOHi 3 oriuAy Ha noJUiTHtHi Ta eKOHOMiqHi 3MiHH, LUO BiR6yJTcA npOTSroM MHHYJIHX n'iTH pOKiB. OiAiHKy npoBegeHo i3 3acTocyBaHHRM KOHTpOJ6bH4X noKa3HHKiB, po3po6JleHHx KoMiTeToM niRJTpHMKH PO3BHTKY OECD ARA AgOCniAPKeHHS c4epH JDepwaBHmX 3aKyniBenlb. CepeA qHcaeHHHX no3HTHBHHX nOAirt, HtO BiA6yJ1HCS B raJly3i Rep>caBHHX 3aKyniBeJI6b, y 3BiT; 3raJyCTbcS, 30KpeMa, Upo BnpoBaIxceHHHI HH3KH peKOMeH,a2Uif CBiToBoro 6aHKy 'iepe3 3MiHH AO 3aKoHy. B 2002 pouli inue 7 BiACoTKiB TeHaepiB (MeHUWe, HbK 50 BiJaCOTKiB y BapTicHoMy BupalKeHHi) 6yno npOBeAeHO i3 3aCTOCYBaHH31M npole,Ayp BitAKpHTHX TopriB, y TOH qac AK B 2005 poui wt wi4pa 3pociia xRo 26 BiRCOTKiB (69 BiUCOTKiB y BapTiCHoMy B4pa)xeHHi). BiACoToK yroa, yKiiaAeHHx 3a npoge,aypamH 3aKyniBejib B o0Horo yqacHHKa, 3MeHWHBcR, BianOBiAHO, 3 21 BiACOTKy B 2000 poui (24 BiRCOTKH y BapTicHoMy BHpaxKeHHi) ztO 10 BiaCOTKiB (15 BiACOTKiB y BapTicHoMy BHpa)KeHHi) B 2005 poui. nOfli6Hi nO3HTUBHi 3pyUeHH1 Bri6yJlHcs TaKolK i3 noKa3HHKaMH no npoLueAypax 3anflTy IiHOBHX npono3uLi4I Ta 3aKyniBenb 3 o6Me)KeHO[O yqacTio.2 Cepea noMAis, H1O ManMH HeraTHBHHHt BDJIHB, Ha3HBalOTbCSI 3MiHH AO 3aicoHy npo AepacaBHi 3aKyniBJIi BiR JnHCTonaaa 2004 poicy ri 'iepBH5I Ta rpyaHm 2005 poKy, UKi HPH3BeniH AO 3HasHoro nocJia6JIeHHSI i gpO6jeHHSi nOBHOBa5eeHb YpSUAy B raJny3i aepWaBHHX 3aKyniBeenb. CyrreBi 4yHKUil 1ep*KaBH 6yno nepejAaHo HeypJfoBHM opraHi3auiiM, 6e3 orinsAy Ha Te, aio ynoBHOBaxceHHui opraH B MiHicTepcTBi eKOHOMiKH A1K pa3 3XirHCHiOBaB neBHi KpOKH nO 3anpoBaalKeHHIO Mi)KHapoJAHix cTaHAapTiB. TaKa peopraHi3auix KowTyBania Kpa:Hi He JlHue BTpaTo1o 6araTopi4Horo xROCBiY,iy Ha6yToro ynOBHOBalKeHHM OpraHOM, ane i npuH3Bsena o panToBoro Bi11XORy BiA LLJIKOM npI4iH5THHX CTaHAapTiB. KpiM TOrO, nepegata 3yHKWtig HarsIRAy, KOHTPOJIIO Ta KOOPRHHauLf Ao KOH'rponbHo-peBi3i3iHoro ynpaBJliHH5 (KPY) Ta PaxyHKoBof nafiaTi4 cTBopHna cHryauilO KOH4diKTy iHTepeCiB, OCKin6bKH Ti )K CaMi c(DaxiBUi CBiToBoro 6aHKY BUCJIOBJUOIOTb nORRKY CBOIM KOjieraM i3 MiHicTepCTBa eKOHOMiKM, AKi i3 Ha6yrrAM 4UHHOCTi nonpaBKH ao 3axoHy npo 3aKyniBJIi TOnapiB, po6iT i nocnyr 3a Aep)KaBHi KOWITH BiA rpy;HA 2005 poKy aTpaTHjun XyHKuii YHOBHOBaweHOrO OpraHy B c4fepi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBemb. 'Daxisui SaHKY BARqHi TaKo)x 6araTmoM npeAcTaBHHKaM aepxBnHavx Ta HPHBaTHHX YCTaHOB 3a ix e4)eiTHBHe cniBpo6iTHHUTBo npH nimrorTOBi m,OrO 3BiTy. 2 BiACoToK 3aKyfliBeJlb B ojHoro yqaCHHKa Bce Iie e BHCOKHM B YKpaYHi. HaBeaeHi Lw4pH He oxonfloioTb yroAH, uto 6ynxo YKJIaAeHO 3a flpone2AypaMH 3aKynlBJIi B O2HOrO y'aCHHXKa Aep)XaBHHMH nliArpHcMCTBamH Ta yrOAH, yKJlaaaHHA AKHX He nianaaae niA Aiio 3aKoHy npo Aep)KaBHi 3axynisii. YKPAIHA 3BIT 3 OtXIHKIH 3AKYIIIBEJIb B YKPAIHI, 2006 piic 3MiCT CTHCJIHI oris .................................. .... ..........1 1.BcTyn ............................................ ....................4 2. HopMaTHBHO-nlpaBOBa 6a3a ...........................................................7 3. IHcTHTylAiiiHa cTpyKTypa i ynpaBJIiHCbKHhi noTeHLaiia .J1 ....................................... 1 3. IHCTHTyUirlHa CTPYKTypa i ynpaBJIiHcbKIHr nOTeHuai .....................................I1 4. 'DYHKLiOHYBaHHq CHCTeMH 3aKYniBenb ................................................. 19 5. Jgo6poqeCHiCTb i nPO30piCTb CHCTeMH ,AeP)xaBHHX 3aKyniBejb ............................ 33 6. EneKTPOHHi 3aKyniBi ............................................................... 36 7. BHKOHaHHA yro1 npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyIIiBJi . .................................. ............ 38 8. 36iiH)KeHHA 3 AHpeKTHBaMH CC I1OAO 3aKyYUiBenEb i npHCAHaHHSI AO COT .................... 40 9. AHani3 pH3HKiB i nnaHaH i 303 3a 2006 piK ............................................. 42 JoAaTOK I. AeTaAbHHA niiaH BnpOBal)KeHHR_(Ha OCHOBi peKOMeHAaIuiR 2001 i 2006 pp.).... 45 AOAaTOK 2. KoHTpoJIbHi nOKa3HHKH .................................................. 48 ,AOAaTOK 3. CxeMa OpraHi3aUi;IHOI CTPYKTYPH CHCTeMH Hlep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb ARO 3MiHH 3aKOHY ............................................................................. 50 ROAaTOK 4. CxeMa opraHi3aBLiAHOY CTPYKTYPH cHcTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb niCJSI 3MiHH 3aKOHY ......................................................................... 51 Y CKnaai rpyni CBiToBoro 6aHKy npa[lOBanH: HaywaA A. XaH, ECSPS (KepiBHHK rpynz4 npoeKTY), AHHa BenorypCbKa, IPHHa HUMenboBa, F;eHefaHKTa T. OJiiBepoC- MipaHma (ECSPS), KHYT Jlarino.nba (OPCPR), KpiCTiaH X. Boncep (iopHcT- KOHCYnbTaHT 3 nHTaHb Mi)KHapOWHHX 3aKynyiBejb) i rynJbHapa Cycp6aeBa (KoHCy.nbTaHT). 36im 3 oyirnKu 3aKyni6eeb e YKparHi - CmucAui oanAb. opraHH, HKi 3aJaiSHi B KOHTpOli pO3nOp5UIHHKiB 6io0xeTHHX KOlITiB Ha eTani npOBeeeHHs 3aKyniBeJlb, ni3Hile iue Hi 3,RiACHIOOTb ayIUHT npoBleaeH4X 3aKyHiBeJIb. )Aesnci KpaTHH, sKi HetROJIaBHO npHeCHaAHcSI AO CBpOneHiCbKOrO cHiBToBapHcTBa, iIeMOHCTpyIOTb npnKja,aH ycnitJHHX MoleJier npHBeAIeHHH HOpM HajioHa2jbHoro 32KOHO0RRBCTB3 3 nHT8Hb 3aKyniBeJib y BiAflOBiAHiCTb 40 peryJinTopHoi 6a3H CC. Lli Kpa7HH MalOTb KOpHCHHr JAOCBill Ha6JumweHHSI 3J3 ,Ao IpHU1HJTHHX HOpM CC, BKnioqaOo4H 3axoAH 3 HanaroJxeHHq OpraHi3aUiUHOY CTpyKTYPH A1ep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenEb Ta nOpRAAKY po3rJIXAy cKapr. YKpaliHa MaHl>e 3aBepUiuHia neperoBopH npo IJIeHCTBO B COT, i 3apa3 BiA(6yBaIoTbCsC neperoBopH ImOJlO npHCAHaHHM JO IqiCY opraHi3aU8-i. repi Hi-K HPHCJHaTHCR 11o YroIAH COT npo AepKaBHi 3aKyniBJli, YKpafHa Mae BUpiLIUHTH HH3Ky nHTaHb (npo HKi AAeTbCR B LIbOMY 3BiTi), S1Ki BHHHKJIH BHaciiiAOK CHTyauLif, 1uo cKnaJIaCA Ha CbOlOZIHi y c(epi ALep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. Ll,e JIocJiJIceHHR BKHo'qaC aHa3Ji3 qHHHOi HopMaTHBHo-npaBoBoY 6a3H, opraHi3aUiHHov CTpyKTypH 3a3KyHiBeb6, CUpOMONCHOCTi PO3nOpSiHHKiB 6Noam2eTHHX KODITiB 31XifCHlOBaTH 3aKyniBJdi opraHi3aUii BHyTpiulHboro i 3OBHiUIHbOrO KOHTpOJIJO, 3axoAiB HpOTHRiT npomBama KOpynfif Ta npak-THKH 3JAiOCHeHHsl aQep)KaBHHX 3aKyHiBenb. 3aranbHHA BHCHOBOK npoBeeeHoro ,roCjmlKeHHA BKa3YC Ha Te, lUo CTyniHb pH3HKY y c4)epi Rep?KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJLb YKpaYHH 3apa3 c "BHCOKHW". Hat6inuli BaroMy 3Alo6yTy iH4opMauilO Ta BiAnoBiAHi peKoMeHAaull niACyMOBaHO HH)K'e. ,O BBeCaHHI B 11hO HanpHUKiHui 2004 Ta 2005 pOKiB, a T8KO2K Ha nO'laTKy 2006 pOKy TpbOX CYTTCBHX 3MiH YKpaiHa Maia 3araniom UpHOHgTHHr 3aKoH npo QepiKaBHi 3aKyniBii. 3anpoBaJ1weHHa UHX 3MiH nPH3Beno Ao 3MiHU cHTyauif Ha npiSMo npoTune)KHy. 13 BBeAeHHSM B Ai1O 3MiHH BiA JINCTOnaaa 2004 pOKy p03noqanocSI noripweHHR cinTyauiY epe3 BHKJ]ioqeHHq HH3KH Ba2KniCHBHX (yHKuiu i3 KoMneTeHuili ynOBHOBBaIceHoro opraHy, HanpHKJIaJA, nOBHoBa)KeHb IuOO HaAaHHJ MeTOI1OJloriqHHX peKOMeHaauig Ta CTaHAapTHOY TeHAeepHof AOKyMeHTauiI pO3nOpRIHHKaM 6ioA1KeTHHX KOlJITiB. 13 BBeAeHHRM B AilO 3MiHH Big qepBHx 2005 pOKy HHU3KY yHKUii, 5Ki 3a3BHMagi BHKOHYC Aep)KaBa (Biiain aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJLb), 6y.no nepeAaHo TeHAepHiA nanaTi YKpafHH (TIY), iUo c HeypsxaoBolo opraHi3auie[o, aKa He ninflrac peryMpHoMy KOHTpOJIIO, Ha BiDMiHy BiaA BinoBiAaJbHHX opraHiB Ta oci6 CHCTeMH aepxKaBHoro ynpaBniHHsI. nIOnpaBKOIO BiA fpYlHSI 2005 poKy 6ynio BCTaHOBJIeHO HOBi npaBHna opraHi3auif, HarnmAy i KOHTPOJIO 3a 3AiHCHeHHAM AeplKaBHHX 3aKyniBejIb, IUO nPH3BenJioo aue 6inimuioro Apo6neHHA nOBHOBa*KeHb EIep2caBH y c4epi 3aKyniBejlb. ,CeKWibK8 nIPHBaTHHX opraHi3aUirt ROMiHyIOTb y cipepi ep;KcaBHHx 3aKyHiBenb. ,L{o HHX HanelKaTb HeypsuloBa opraHi3auix UeHTp TeHAepHHX npouexAyp Ta nJIaHyBaHHx 6i3Hecy (L"Tr) Ta nOB '3aHe 3 Heto npHBaTHe nianpHemcTBo TOB "CBponercbKe KoHcaJITHHroBe areHTCTBo" (CKA). UTH1 C O4iRiHHM BjiaCHHKOM naTeHTiB Ta aBTopCbKHX npaB Ha 4HCJIeHHi 3pa3KH TeHllepHOY AOKyMeHTaUif H MeToloJIorif, BKJIOLiaiOMH CTaHJa1PTHY TeHpepHy AOKyMeHTauiio, iKa C MaHrKe ilaeHT1'IHO10 CTaHAapTHii TeHAepHiri ,aoKyMeHTauiY CBiToBoro 6aHKy. YqaCHHKH PHHKY CTBepAl*ysoTb, l0o I1Tn BHMarac Bill HUX BHKOpHCTOBYBaTH 3a nnaTy came ui "3anaTeHTOBaHi" '1OKyMeHTH, i Ulo nOTeHUiriHi y'aCHHKH TopriB MYC3ITb CnnavIyBaTli L[TF 3a HaAaHHSI He3pO3yMiJIo SKHX riocJ]yr, BKjll0oqaf4H KOMiCiHiHi 3 nepeMo)KUiB TOpriB. PO30OPHAHHHKH 6(JoI2eTHHX KOIUTiB He MOCYTb e4eKTHBHO BHPOBaSJDyBaTH 3aKoH. 3rilHo i3 nOBHiCTIO AleueHTpaJli3oBaHOfo CHCTeMo0o Aep*KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJLb, 4)yHKL1iOHanbHi o6o0B'3KH PO3nOAiJXIOTbCR MilK PO3nOp3laHHKaMH 6ioapxeTHHx KOlITiB Ha BCiX piBHsX BnaAH. 3apa3 Ko)KeH 3 UHX PO3nOPSAHHKiB 3AiACHIOC 3aKyniBJi iepe3 nOCTiflHO AilO4HA TeHAepHHHi KOMiTeT, o0 cKjiaAacTbcS lpiUHaUMHi 3 5 JIneHiB, YKi npOXO,STb nHule ABOTH)KHeBHi KypC o60B'R3KOBOro HaBHaHHB. 3a TaKHX yMOB PO3nOpRALHHKH 6ioA)KeTHHx KOlUTiB He MalOTb HaroAm CTBOpHTH KalApOBHH noTeHuiaJi aHi Ha TpHBaniTu TepMiH, aHi CyTo cneUJiani3oBaHHAfl llI npOBeLeHHSI 3aKyniBenb. Y-aCTb B npoueci 3aKyniBejib AenapTaMeHTiB JnOriCTUKH BeJHKI4X Po3nOp3MHHKiB o6MeKycTLbC3, SWK npaBHno, npH3HaqeHHBM OllHOro rnpe,CTaBHHKa A1o nOCTiAHO Ailo4orO TeHAepHoro KOMiTeTy. nepea6a'aencrC, Ulo ui npH3HaqeHi oco6H BHKOHYBaTHmyTb CBOi 3BH4aHHi fyHKWioHanbHi o60B' I3KU Ha lAOEAaTOK AO (yHKUifi 'neHiB TeH1AePHHX KOMiTeTiB. npeaCTaBHHKH npHBaTHOrO ceKTOpa cTBepA)KylOTb, MO nOCTiuHO lAiIOMUHi TeHXACpHHi4 2 3eim 3 OZjiHKU 3aKynieelb e YKpaiHi - CmucAuu oznsm. KOMiTeT 36inbulyc MO)KMHBiCTb BHHHKHeHHA 3MOBH, KOpyniLif, He3aKOHHHX AOMoBneHOCTeH Ta KOH4RiKTy iHTepeciB. ICOHcy.16bTakHTH, niApSIHHKH Ta nOCTaqanbHHICH, siCi 6pa2H4 yqaCTb y o6rOBopeHHsX niiA qac OIIiHICH, BUCJIOBJIIOBaJIH CBOC He3aAOBOJieHHSI 3 nllHBOAY 6araTbOX 9BHHU, I1O iCHylOTb B Hpa2XTHUi AeP=aBHHX 3aKyniBe6b, a oco6.nIBo 3 npHBOAy niAWBHDieHSI CTaTyCy TeHAepHoT flaniaTH Ao piBHsI YHOBHOB2aIeHOrO opraHy Ta pO.i, 11O BiABeAeHO qiHl opraHi3aUli B upoueci po3rJisuAy cicapr. YqaCHHKH TopriB HaroJIOllUyoTb Ha Heo6xiHocTi iCHyBaHHA 6i.ibWoT KiJIbKOCTi ipiepen iH4¢opMaui1 npo TOprH i BHCJOBEIIOIOTb KpHTHqHi 3ayBa.KeHHA IUOAO TeHAepHOf AoKyMeHTaUii 3 HeqiTKo BH3HaqeHoIO TexHiqHOIO cneLtH4iKaLticio, CTHCJIHX TepMiHiB, WO BiABOARTbCSA Ha niAroToBKY TeHAePHHX nponO3HLLiH, Heo6rpyHTOBaHoro CKacyBaHHR9 TeHAePHHx npoueAyp, qacTHX BHnlaAKiB 3aTpHMKH 3i cniiaToIO 3a yKiaAeHHMH AOrOBOpaMH TOluO. TaKi RBHUIa B npaKTHUi Aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeenb nPH3BenJH AO noripwieHHA KoHKypeHLUif: B 2005 poui niune 2-3 nponO3HLil nPHXOAHIIHCb B Cep eAHbOMY Ha OAHY TeHAepHy npoLueAypy. Aep%KaBHi 3aKynisnJi C iHTeFPOBaHO1O SaCTHHO[O npoiecy nniaHyBaHHSI Ta BHKOHaHHs 6IOAXCeTy Kpalim, aine iqs acTuHa nOTpe6yC BAOCKOHaJleHHsi. HJiaHyBaHHS o6Me)KyCTbCS 3a3BHqaH cTBopeHHSM nepeniKy 3aKyniBeBnb Ta KOWITOpHCY BHTpaT 6e3 Hane)KHOI yBarH Ao TepMiHiB, naKeTyBaHHR, MeToAiB 3aKyfliBeJlb Ta KaJleHAapHOrO rpafiKy. 4aCTO pO3fopSIHHKH Aep)KaBHHX KOWTiB OTpUiMylOTb AOCTynl Ao 4iHaHcyBaHHS JIlHwe HanpHKiHUi nicTonaXa a6o y rpyAuHi, oTlKe, IM 6paKyc qacy Ana BHKOHaHHA 3aKyniBejlb A0 3aKiHqeHHS 6iojAeTHoro pOKy. IcHyIo'ia CHCTema KOHTpOJIIO Ta yALHTY 3aKyniBeyna c cra6Kolo, xoMa U1 siCiCTb nAi1BHIUyCT1C$. KoHI'poAbHo-peBi3igHe ynpaBniHHSI (KPY) Ka6iHeTy MiHiCTpiB, PaxyHKOBa nanaTa (BHUUHi opraH ayAHTy), Aep)KaBHe Ka3HaqeHCTBO Ta ynpaBsiiHHR BHyTpiWHbOrO ayAHTy pO3nopAAHHKa 610oAKerHHX KOWITIB BilnOBil1aMoTb 3a KOHTpOJIb Ta ayAlHT. 3aranoM, KOHTpOJIb Mo)Ke 3AliRcHtoBaTHcA AO t[H niciiA 3aBepuleHHA 3aKyniBenib, anie Ha npaKTHULi BiH tacTilwle BiA6yBaCTbCS niCJIA 3aKiHqeHHS npouecy. IDyHK1ii KPY i PaxyHKOBoif nanaTH 4aCTKOBO cniBnaAaiOTb, BTiM o6HrBi yCTaHOBH o6MexKyioTbcs nepeBipKOio npoLtecy 3aKyfliBejib Ha BiAfnOBi,LHiCTb BCTaHOBneHHM nojioKeHHAM Ta HopMaM. CHcTeMa ayAlHTy 3aKyniBenb Mac cepHO3Hi HeAojiiKH. Ha npaKTHui .iHwe Ka3Ha4eAicTBo 311iiHCHIOe cHcTeMaTHI4HHA KOHTpOflb npoutecy 3aKyniBeJIb, nepuW HiCK npOBeCTH nriaTi,K 3a yKiaA1eHHM AiOrOBOpOM. AHTHKCopynuiiiHi HOpMH TS nOJIOKeHHs C p03nopolmeHHMH nO pi3HUX 3aKOHoAaBqHX aICTaX, a TX BHKoHaHHS noTpe6yc BOCICOHaneHHR9. B 3aKOHOAaBcTBi, UxO Mac noJ1o)KeHHS npo aHTHKopynui4Hi 3aXOAH, He BH3HaqeHo nOHSTTS npo npaBonopyUIeHHM, Hajie)KHe CyA0O44HCTBO, caHKLXiY q14 npaKTUqHe 3aCTOCYBaHHA HOpM nipaBa. MiHicTepcTBo eKOHOMiKH yfpaBJUIRJO npotqecom MomepHi3aq;i CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyfliBeJlb, B TOMy quHCJi CHCTeMH eaieKTpoHuHx AepaKaBHHX 3aKyniBeib (CEA3). E.TeKTpoHHi TpaH3aKuii Ta pO3KpHTTr iH4)opMaaui Bi1nlOBiAalOTB BsUMoraM KOMniieKCHOf nporpaMH "EineKTpoHHa YKpala", qKa niATPHMYeTbCA nojio)KeHHRMH 3aKoHy npo AeplKaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i, 3aKoHOM npo eneKTpoHHHH niAnHlc, Luo nepe6yBae B cTaAif po3po6KH, Ta 3aKoHoM npo eJIeKTpOHHL4H iAoKyMeHTOo6ir. npOTIrOM 2000-2005 pp. BHKOpHcTaHSH Mepe2Ki IHTepHeT 3POCJIo 6iIbLu, HilK Ha 2500 BiACOTKiB. [IpoTe, AJI npoBeaeHHA eneKKTpOHHHX aepxKaBHHX 3aKyniBenb Heo6xiAHO CTBOpUTH MiLIHiwLy 6a3y Ta pO3po6HTH 4iTKi npoL1eAyPH Ta 4iopMH ny6niKauiri B peKtiMi peanjbHoro 'acy. JCeAKi TeXHit4Hi nHTaHHA, AKi PO3rnfAAalOTbCA B OCHOBHiH qacTiHi LUborO 3BiTy, noTpe6ytoTb BHpiweHHI, a6u YHHKHYTH BTpaTH Toro nporpecy, U{O BMKe 6yno AocMrHyro y uiri c4iepi. MHpOKOMaCMIITa6Ha icaMnaHig iH4)opMyBaHHR rpoMaACbKOCTi 3 HlHTaHb Aep>KaBHUX 3aKyniBeJIb C HeO6XiAHOO AIJI 11iABHuIeHH9 piBHR flOiHbOpMOBaHOCTi DK opHBaTHOrO CeKTOpy, TaIC i LUHpOKOrO 3araniy HaceneHHsm. TaKa KaMnaHiA Mana 6 BHcBiTJIIOBaTH CyTHiCTb, HacJiAKui Ta nepeBarH eC4eKTHBHO-; BiAKPHTOY CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb Ta CnpH1TH cTBopeHHlo niATPHMKH 3 6OKy noJliTHKiB. Ony6niKyBaHHA nHllme 04i1irlHHuX peryJ1MT14BHHX aKTiB He niABHIUYC PiBeHb nOiH4,opMoBaHOcTi rpoMa81H, B TOH qac RK oKpema nporpama iHcDOpMyBaHHA HacenJeHHR qepe3 ra3eTH, TeJie6aqeHHA Ta paAio Moriia 6 CnPHATH AocArHeHHIo uicf MeTri. YnoBHOBa)KeHHR opraH noTpe6yBaTiMe AIOnOMOrH ARA 1.ineu ynpaBniHHA TaKO1o WiHpOKOMacmTa6HO1O KaMnaHiClo. 3 3eim 3 O4iHKU 3aKyni6egb 6 YKpaiHi - CmucAuu oeAJO. PeKoMeHga[iY )OKJIaJGHN f MIaH BUpOBaAmceHHR 3aXoXiB, 3aflpOflOHOBaHHNf B tLbOMY 3BiTi BKJIIOCic KOpOTKO-, Cepe,QHbO- Ta AOBrOCTPOICOBi peicomeH,AaillL BTiM, HaHi6;inble 3aHenOKOCHH5 BHKJIHKaC 4HHHa npaBoBa 6a3a Ta iHcTHTyLliuHa cTpyKTypa 3aKyniBeiib. 5AK TiJIbKH Lii nHTaHHq npaBoBoi 6a3u Ta iHCTHTyLiriHOi CTpyKTypUH 6y11yrb BnOpJ.KOBaHi, Heo6xiAHo 6yjie 3MiLIHHTH CHCTeMy Zepx(aBHHX 3aKyniBeJib B uijoMy. cDaXiBUi BaHKY HanonJerj1HBO pexOMeHZYIOTb B)KHTH HacTynHi 3axo.IH ARA AOC2rHeHHS1 iei MCTU: HepwowepeoaipeKoMendagiY-ynop.doKy6amu npaeo6y, peZynxmopny ma incmumyli4fiy 6a3y > mOCJrru 3roAH4 BepXoBHof Pa.H Ha BiaKJiHKaHHS 3MiHH .1o 3aKoHy Bi, rPYAHA 2005 POKY AO 3aKOHy npo 3aKyniBJIIo ToBapiB, po6iT Ta nocjiyr 3a AepKaBHi KOIITH a6O Ha Wl iCTOTHe JlOonpaWOBaHHx, BpaxOByIoxnH, 3oKpeMa, HeAope4Hy pOEb TeHAepHoY nanaTH Ta iHIIIHX HYO B CHcTeMi Iep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejib. > PeopraHi3yBaTH iHCTHTYUi1HY CTrpyKTypy lep?KaBHHX 3aKyniiBeRE, 3a6e3neMlHBUIH 11 Bi,anOBiAHiCTb Mi)KHapoLHHM CTaHaapTaM Ta npHHULIny p03no,iny nOBHOBa)KeHb. > CTBOPUTH He3anje)KHHH MexaHi3M pO3rJIs,y cKapr yMaCHHKiB TopriB. > CTBOPHTH KepiBH4ri ynOBHOBazKeHHA opraH, 0o o6OB'S3KiB AKOrO BXOAHThMe po3po6Ka cTpaTeril y rany3i A1ep)KaBHI4X 3aKyniBeJIb, BiXUnOBi.1anbHiCTb 3a pO3po6Ky 3aKoHiB Ta niD3aKOHHHx aKTiB, niarOToBKa Ta OHOBj1eHHSI CTaHaapTHOi TeHaepHOl AOKyMeHTaUiY, 6e3KoUITOBHe HaJaHHS nopa, 3 npaBsBHX Ta npo0eciClHHx nHTaHb, ny6niKauis iH4)opMaLtiY npo 3aniaHoBaH0 ToprH Ta npo repeMo)KuiB TopriB, a TaKO)K KOHTPOjib i MOHiTOpHHr. TaKHi opraH Mo)Ke 6yTm niA3BiTHHM 6e3nocepeaHbo Ka6iHeTy MiHiCTPiB a6o BXO.1HTH AO cKJlaAy iHWiOrO aep)KaBHoro opraHy. > aopo6HTH Ta Ha.AaTH P03nOpA1AHHKaM 6tox)KeTHHX KOlUTiB CTaHAaPTHY TeHaepHy JIOKyMeHTauiio, niArOTOBneHy KOJIHUIHiM YnOBHOBawKeHHM opraHOM B MiHicTepeTBi eKOHOMiKH. > CTBOPHTH yMOBi4, I1o CnpHRTHMYTb PO3BHTKY KOHKypeHUiY Ha PHHKY 3aKyniBellb. Ti KOHCyJIbTaUiHiHi nocJIyrH, 11o He Ha0alOTbC31 Aep)KaBHHMH yCTaHOBaMH, MO)KyTb HanaBaTH rpHBaTHi 4ipMH, npoTe BiL6ip TaKHX f4pM Mae Bia6yBaTHCS Ha KOHKYPCHHX 3aca,ax, 3riXIHO i3 3aKOHOM ipo aep)KaBHi 3aKyniiBJi. jlooamKodi peKoMenoa4if- nocuwumu cucmemy depWaMHux 3aKyni8eeIb > CTBOPHTH nOCTiriHO JAilOtiH CTpyKTYpHHri niAPo3iR 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBeJIb B CTpyKTypi PO3nOpRAHHKiB 6foRpe'rHHx KOUITiB Ta 3anpOBaJHTH (4epe3 BiALIOBiUHi nono)KeHHR B fl0oOBHeHOMY 4H HOBOMY 3aKOHi) CHCTeMy CTB0pCHHS TeHaepHHX KOMiTeTiB niA neBHy 3aKyniBJIo. > 06'erHaTH 3aKOHoAaBCTBO Ta nia3aKOHHi aKTH 3 aHTHKopynUUiUHHx nllTaHb, BKJIlO9aIO9H npaBo3aCTOCyBaHHX. > 3anppOBa.HTU l nonepeaHiri KOHTpOJlb Ta HpO0OB)'YBaTH 3Air1CHIOBaTH KOHTpOJIb nicns npo0eBXeHHS 3aKyniBenib. > 3a6e3neiHTU B3HKKOHaHH CTpaTeril PO3BHTKy eJiCKTpOHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. > CTBOPHTH niA KOHTponjeM YnOBHOBa)KeHOrO opraHy CAXHHHri o0uHHr1 6e3KoUlToBHHri eJieKTpOHHHfl HopTa .aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejib i BiAnOBiAHe nanepoBe BHaaHH3. > HOCHJIHTH iHCTHTYi111rHe i KaapoBe 3a6e3ne9eHHI ynlOBHOBa)KCHoro opraHy 3 MeTOto nlpOBeAeHHa B KpafHi KaMnallHi iH(OpMyBaHHs rpOMaaCbKOCTi no nUHTaHHSX Aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBenEb. 4 3eim 3 O,iiLKU 3aKynieeAb 6 YKpaiH1i - Cmucauz oe.aa. CTaTyc CTaHOM Ha 30 6epe3ms 2007 poicy B rpyxHi 2006 poKy CBiTOBHi 6aHK nepeJaB Yp3ny YKpalHH nlpOeKT 3BiTy 3 OUiHKH 3aKyniBeiEb. HanpHKiHdui CiqHSA 2007 POKY MiHicTepcTBo eKoHoMiKH noiH4opMyBano BaHK npo Te, i4o axiBUi MiHicTepcTBa eKoHoMiKH, MiHicTepcTea 4iHaHCiB, MiHicTepCTBa OXOpOHH 3XAOpOB'A, Ha[fioHanbHoro 6aHKy Ta AHTHMOHOOJIEbHorO KOMiTeTy O3HaiOM1HnIHCs 3i 3BiTOM Ta roToBi 3yCTpiTHc.9 i3 axiBiLuMH EaHKy, iuo6 06rOBOpHTH CBOI 3ayBa)KeHHSI. MiHiCTepCTBo eKoHoMiKtl HaAano BaHKy TaKo)K AeTanbHi KoMeHTapi B nHCbMOBiH qOpMi. Y BCTynHiH qaCTHHi LborO A1OKyMeHTy 6yno cKa3aHo, UIo "iH#OpMauiA, SKa MiCTHT6CSq y 3BiTi, 3araniom BiAo6paxKac peaRbHHA CTaH cnpaB y c4fepi AepxKaBHHx 3aKyniBenb B YKpaYHi B 2006 poL.i". KpiM Toro, ,AOKyMeHT HOcHCaCTbcS Ha nOAanbui 3MiHH Ao 3aKoHy npo AepxKaBHi 3aKyniBJii, uAo 6ynH 3aTBepA)KeHi BepxoBHoEo Pagoto y rpy1AHi 2006 pOKy Ta Ha6yJlH q4HHOCTi 12 6epe3Hs 2007 poKy. EDaxiBui EaHKy npu6yrn AO YKpalHH 25 6epe3Hs, a 26 Ta 28 6epe3Hs o6roBopHnH i3 npeACTaBHHKaMH BHwe3a3HaqeHHX ypAAOBHX YCTaHOB iX KOMeHTapi Ao 3BiTy. npeACTaBHHK SIGMA TaKOx( 6paB y'aCTb B tUX o6roBopeHHAlx. FlIHTaHHS, luo o6roBoploBaJnHcb, CTOCyBaniHCb B OCHOBHOMy 3acTOcyBaHHH nonoceKHb 3aKoHy A1O nifAnpHCMCTB, JqKi 3HaXOATbCA y A-ep)KaBHiA BniacHocTi, Ta poni KoMepL1irHHx 6aHKiB y c4epi Llep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. KpiM Toro, o6roBoptoBaincb ocTaHHi 3MiHH A0 3aKoHy BiA rpyAHA 2006 POKY Ta peKoMeHAaLLii flpe3HAeHTa YKpaYHH uojRo po3po6KH HOBOrO npOeKTy 3aKoHy, HKHHi Mac 6yTH 3aTBepA)KeHo Ao 15 cepnHs 2007 p. Y goAaTKy BiA 30 6epe3Hs 2007 POKY pO3rJISAaIOTbCS 3MiHU go 3aKoHy sini I rpyAHA 2006 POKY Ta OCHOBHi KOMeHTapi, 14o 6yjio OTpHMaHO BiA YpsAAYy YKpalH4 Ha oCTaToqHHri npoeKT 3BiTy. EaHK cno1iBaeTbCR, u1o peKoMeH1aLaif Ltboro 3BiTy 6yAe BnpOBaAWeHo qepe3 npoeKT HOBOrO 3aKOHy npo A1epwKaBHi 3aKyniBni, 140 rOTyCTbCq. 5 3eim 3 OU HKU 3aKyfi6eilb f YKpaiNi - CmuCAuu oeUlc. gOgaTOK 30 6epe3Hm 2007 poicy nlicni Toro AK npOeKT 3BiTy 6ynio nepeAaHo YpsAAy Ha Po3rsn, Ta KOMeHTapi, BepXoBHa Paza YKpaHfiHu npHAHna 1 rpyjHs 2006 poKy 3aKoH N9 424-V, AKHM 6ynO BHeceHO 3MiHH iAo 3aKoHy npo 3aKyniiBJi. le1 3aKOH 6yjio niAnHcaHO Hpe3HAeHTOM YKpafHH, Ta 6inbibla MaCTHHa HOBHX 3MiH Ha6yJia qHHHOCTi 12 6epe3HR 2007 pOKy. ,iAIUHCy1O9H 3MiHU Ao 3aKoHy, Hpe3HAeHT HaronJocHB Ha HeO6xiAHOCTi noAanEiuoro BAOCKOHaJeHHA Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb Ta pUIHAHTH5TSl go 15 cepnHq 2007 pOKy HOBOro 3aKoHy, SIKHr 6a3yBaBcSl 6 Ha Mi)KHapOAHOMy AOCBiAi. rOJIOBa BepxoBHoi PaA1H BwKe C¢OPMYBaB po6o0y rpyny, i11o npaiioC HaA BAIOCKOHaneHHAM 3aKOHoAaBLIoi 6a3H B raJly3i Aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeJIb. B libOMy 0oAaTKY p03rJAlAaioTbCsi nITaHHS, flKi 6yjno nOCTaBJeHO YPslxOM niCJI.S 03HarioMneHHR i3 npoeKToM 3BiTy. rlpeXCTaBHHKH Yps,Ay Ta CBiToBoro 6aHKy o6roBopHnH Lui nHTaHHS1 ni, 4ac 3yCTpi'4i B KHeBi 26 Ta 28 6epe3Ha 2007 pOKy. KpiM TOrO, B JRoaTKy po3rnxAaIOTbCSI TaKOK CyTreBi oco6nHBocTi BHuAe3raAaHHX 3MiH A1o 3aKoHy BiA 1 rpyRHSi 2006 pOKy. ()axiBUi CBiToBoro 6aHKy BBa)KaEoTb, 111O 3MiHU ,o 3aKoHy Bi, rpyJ1HR 2006 POKY MaloTb HeraTHBHHr1 BnJ]HB Ha 3aKoH npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJIi, OCKibKH IX HacJiiAKOM C PO3L1HpeHHR r1OBHOBa)KeHb TeH11epHo flajiamT, RKa C HeypS10B0I0 opraHi3aiciCIo, Ta no0RaEtbu1e 36iJbwueHHS fI poJi B c4)epi gep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb. B LAbOMY AoAaTKy He po3rIiSAalOTbcR nonio)KeHHS 3aKoHy Bi, rpyAH3i 2006 pOKy, SKHR 6ynio 3aTBepA)KeHo nicisi nepezAaqi 3BiTy Ha pO3rn1J, Ypsuy. IlpoTe, TYT KOPOTKO OnHCY1OTbCS LABi OCHOBHHX HH3KH npo6J1eM, 14o 1OB'SI3aHi i3 OCTaHHiMH 3MiHaMH Ao 3aKoHy. * Ilepwua HH3Ka npo6iieM BHHHKaC BHacJiiRoK 3MiH ALO CTaTTi 3-3, SKi Hi6HTo CYTTEB0 peopraHi3y]o0H fYHKlIilO HarFJu5y 3a CHCTeMo0o Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJib, 3aMiHloloTb "CneLiiaJbHy KOHTPOJIbHy KOMiCilO (CKK) 3 ri1TaHb Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniiBeJb npH PaxyHKoBirl rlaiaaTi" Ha HOBOCTBopeHH1A opraH, I10 Ha3HBaCTbC5 "MixKBiAoMHa KOMiCiS 3 nHTaHb 11eP)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb". CKK, i10 6yjio yTBopeHO BHacJIiAOK nonepe11HbOf 3MiHUi 3aKoHy, qaCTKOBo nepe6pana Ha ce6e 4yHKLkii KOHWUIHbOrO YnoBHoBawKeHoro opraHy (AHB. naparpa# 20 LIboro 3BiTy). MibKBiAoMqa KOMiCiSi cKaAaeTbcq i3 TpbOX npeA1CTaBHHKiB TeHAepHoY rlanaTH, no OAHOMy npeCACTaBHHKY BiA PaXyHKOBoY lIanaTH, Lep)KaBHOi KOHTpOJnbHo-peBi3iHiHO cJiy)K6H, Aep)KaBHorO Ka3HaLieH-CTBa, AHTHMoHonoJIbHoro KoMiTeTy, MiHicTepcTBa eKOHOMiKH Ta lOTIpbOX ripeRCTaBHHKiB Bip, A1BOX pi3HHX KOMiTeTiB BepxoBHof ParH. 5AK i ff nonepeAHHK, MixKBiAoMqa KOMiCiS MO)Ke TaKO)K 3aRyLiaTH "nIpeACTaBHHKiB HeYPJq1OBHX OpraHi3auiri, BqeHHX i T. iH.". FIpOTe, He3po3yMiJIo Lit 6epyTb [Ii "npeAcTaBHIKH" ytiaCTb B npHHSrrri piWieHb Komicif, 51K I Te KOMY came c nlAnopsAKoBaHolo LIS HoBa KOMiCiS. KoMiCis (AHB. CT. 3-3 (7)) "3 MeToTO 3a6e3nemeHHs 3laiRcHeHHIs rpoMaACbKorO KOHTpOJIIO y cfepi AepXKaBHHX 3aKyniiBeRb...HaACHJiae TeHAepHirl alanaTi... Konif BCiX piwIIeHb Ta BHCHOBKiB nPOT31rOM 1ABOX po6oLHx A1HiB 3 AaTH X npHrHAsTTs". Ie O3Ha'aC, uio KoMicis, sKa C YPHROBHM opraHoM Mae 3BiTyBaTH npo CBOIO AiSqJbHiCTb HeypallOBiri opraHi3aiii (To6To TeHAlepHiHi nHanaTi). B UbOMY KOHTeKCTi, TeHAepHa rIanaTa HaBiTb Mae npaBO (RHB. CT. 17-3 (8)) "3 MeTO1O 3liriCHeHH1 rpoMa,ACbKorO KOHTpOJIIO... 3BePTaTHCS 1AO CYAY 3 nO3OBOM npo OCKap)KeHH5 piWieHb a6o BHCHOBKiB KoMici;". oAhaTKOBi 4)YHKUii HOBOI KoMici; BKjiioqaloTb: (i) BeAeHHS "pecCTpy He11o6pocoBiCHHX y4aCHHKiB" 6e3 6y1Ab-SKHX nOACHeHb XTO Ta 3a JIKHMH npaBHJIaMH rpHHiMae piweHHS 10A0 HeAo6pocoBicHOcTi yHacHHKa (A1HB. CT. 16-1 1U0A0 niACTaB An11 nporo0JoweHH1 HeAo6pOCOBiCHoCTi y'IaCHHKa) Ta (ii) BeAeHHl1 "peccTpy y-IaCHHKiB npouieAyp 3aKylIiBeJIb" (1AHB. CT. 16-1). I 3eim 3 OZinKU 3aKynieeJlb 6 YKparni - 2006piK 3BiT 3 ORiHKH 3aKyfliBeJm B YKpaiHi - 2006 piic 1. BCTYII IcTopisi DHTaHHR 1. KpauHH BHTpa4a T1Tb BiA 5 AO 15 BiACOTKiB CBOro BBn Ha 3aKynliBJli. E4eKTHBHa cHcTeMa Aep)KaBBH4X 3aKyniBeJlb ilae MoxmnIBiCTb iCTOTHO 3aoWaAUTH Aqep)KaBHi BHpaTKHi. CBiToBlH 6aHK perynsipHo 3XUircmHoe OUiHKY CHcTeM lepIKaBHHx 3aKyniBejlb B paMKaX HaAaHHA TexHiqHoIi 1OnoMOrH KpalHaM, B TOMy 'HCni YKpa!Hi. TaKi O4iHKH 'aCTO CnpHHSOTb pe1OPMYBaHH1O CHCTeMH Aep?KaBHHx 3aKyni3enb, 3OKpcMa, 3aKoHo.aBcTBa Ta niA3aKOHHHx aKTiB, a TaKOwK po36yIAoBi iHCTIrTyuiiHHHX MO)KUlBoCTerH. 2. 22 ilOToro 2000 pOIy B Y[CpaHi Ha6yB qHHHOCTi 3aiCOH YICpaTHH "llpo 3aKyniBJIIO ToBapiB, po6iT i nocayr 3a Aep2CaBHi KOIJITH". FlepunHti 3BiT CBiToBoro 6aHKy 3 OUiHKH 3aKyniBeJIb B YKpaBHi (303) 6yB 3aBepwlleHHA B JIicTonaAi 2001 pOKy i MiCTHB nniaH 3axoAiB 3 niABHUeHHx e4eKTHBHocTi CHCTMeH Aep)KaBHtIx 3aKyniBeCjb. 3 Yacy BHXO1Ay 303 B 2001 poui KpauHa 3a3Hana qHMJa1o nOJIiTHqHHX Ta eKoHoMiqHHx 3MiH, MO BiJAo6pa3Hnocs i Ha CHCTeMi AepxKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. Y CBiTji LIHX 3MiH Ypsg i CBiTOBHH 6aHK 3aifiCHHJIH OLiHKY HopMaTliBHo-npaBoBof 6a3H 3aKyniBellb, iHCTHTYUifiHHX MoKniHBocTeri, npaKTHKH npoBeAleHHa 3aKyniBeflb Ta npO3POcTi CHCTeMH B JinOMy. LIIO oLuiHKy npoBeAeHo 3aAJIU noAaJmilUoro B,OCKOHaMeHHA CHCTeMH. MeToJownoril 3. OjiHkny 6ynro npoBeAqeHo cnLIILHO 4axiBtIHMH CBiToBorO 6aHICy Ta Ypsuy. HlapTHepaMH BaHKy 3 yKpaBHCbKOi CTOpOHH 6ynuH npoBilHi cneLtianicTH JenapTaMeHTy 3 flHTaHb KOOpIlklHaLkii AepXKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb (KZK3), AKHH BHKOHYBaB 4yHKLUii YnOBHoBaBKeHoro opraHy (YO) B MiHicTepcTBi eKOHOMiKH. CniuJbHa rpyna eKcnepTiB npoaHaiii3yBana 3aKOHOlaBqy 6a3y B rany3i Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJTb Ta npoBena o6roBopeHHR i3 III1pOKHM KOJIoM npeADcTaBHHKiB po3nopRjIHHKiB 60oaceTHHx KOlWTiB Ta iHUIHX 3auiKaBJIeHHx CTOpiH. Cepe,a HHX: MiHiCTepCTBa, KOMiTeTH, MyHiUHnaiiiTeTH, AepxKaBHi nifnpH4CMCTBa, BHpo6HHK4, nOCTaBa4jbHHKH, niAPRAHHKt Ta npeACTaBHHKH rpoMaAcBKHx opraHi3auiH. 4BXaiBWi CBiToBoro 6aHKy npoBeniH oKpeMi 3yCTpi4i i3 P03nOPRALHHKaMH 61oJR7KeTHHX KOUITiB Ta npeACTaBHHKaMH npHBaTHOro ceKTopy. TaKi 3yCTpiqi Ta 6araTorpaHHi o6roBopeHHA .anH 3MOry OTPHMaTH UIHPOKe 6aqeHHA IOAlO 4yHKUiOHyBBaHHi CHCTCMU. Cno4aTKy nfiaHyNBOCA lIpOBeCTH AOCniAcKeHHS Ha KOHKpeTHHx npHKnaAax 3aKyniBeJIb neBHHX rpyn ToBapiB Ta nocnyr. [lpoTe, qepe3 CKaCyBaHHA 4yHKUiU AK3 MiHicTepcrBa eKOHOMiKH, 4axiBui BaHKY He 3Morn01 OTpHMaTH Heo6xiHi AaHi ARA TaKHX UinbOBHX aocJiiAeHb. 4. BHCHOBICH Ta peicoMeHtLkaaI1, 11MO MiCT9TbCU B tIbOMY 3BiTi 6yno 3po6jIeHO RIC Ha OCHOBi aHaJiby 3aICOHiB Ta flim3SKoHHUX aKTiB cijepH 4ep)KaBHHx 3alKyiBenib, TaKc i 3a pe3yJlbTaTaMH uponBeteHux 3yCTpireri Ta o6roBopeHb. OiliHKy npoBeAeHO i3 3aCTOCYBaHHSM KOHTpOJlbHUX noKa3HHKiB, po3po6JIeHHx KoMiTeToM niArTpHMKH pO3BHTKY OECD3 AJs AAOCJi1A)KeHHA cvepH Aep2KaBHHX 3aKyniBenbe, SKi rpyHTylOTbCR Ha 3aranbHonptHHsTiri MbKHapOAHiH[ npaKTui. Epyna (DaXiBLUiB, Uo roTByBana 303, TiCHO CniBnpa1toBania TaKOK i3 rpynoto 4baxiBuiB CBiToBoro 6aHKy 3 nUTaHb ynpaBjiiHHA Aep)KaBHHMH iHiaHClaMH, SKa niArOTyBaiia 3BiT 3 ynpaBniHHa Aep)KaBHHMN 1iHaHcaMH B YWpa:Ni. CniBnpausl AOHOPiB 3KepisaHi npHHLxHnu i cepiA AOBtiKOBKouX MaTepianiB KomiTeTy nirpHMKH po3BHTKY - rapMOHi3aUiR npaKTHwHHx ai1 23OHOPiB AJR eleKrHBHOrO HaAaHHA JIonoMorH (TOM 3). (OECD/DAC Guidelines and Reference Series-Harmonizing Donor Practices for Effective Aid Delivery (Volume 3). nlocHneHHA CHCTeMH 3aKyniBenb B KPaIHax, mO pO3BHBatoTbcR," Kpyrrnd cTinl OECD/DAC 3 nmTaHb 3aKyniBeJIb., JoKymeHT 6yno npeACTasJ1CHO Ha flapH3bKOMy 4)opyMi 3 IIHTaHb efeKTHBHOCTi AOnlOMOrm, tao npoxo,AHB Ha HarmBiHuOMy piBHi, y moToMy 2005 pOKy. 4 3Bim 3 ouiiHKU 3aKyni6eeb 6 YkpaiWi - 2006 piK 5. CBiTOBHii 6aHKC i "CirMa", snca C ClliJlbHOIO iHiIiaTHBOIO OECD-CC4, OAHOq2CHO Ta HeM3MI)KHO NpOBOJHJIH auaJli3 CHCTeMH AepmaBHHX 3aKyHiBeJmb B YicpaTHi. Mix opraHi3auiAMH BiA6yBaBcsI noCTiliHHA o6MiH 3Ao6yrolo iHc)OpMauiCIo Ta npoeKTaMH 3BiTiB. He3Ba)KajoMH Ha HC3HaxHy Bi.RMiHHiCTb B aKUeHTaX i AeTaJlAX, 3BiTU y3ro0DKylOTbCq B qaCTHHi OCHOBHHX BHCHOBKiB Ta peKoMeHnauiri. Jo npOBeoeHHA UidY OUiHKH faxiBUi EaHKy 3yCTpiJIHcR i3 OCHOBHHMH AOHOPCbKHMH opraHi3auIbMl B YKpaYHi, 3OKpeMa i3 YnpaBJiliHHJIM Mi)KHapo,4Horo pO3BHTKY (BemUKo6pumaHii) (DFID), LIHBenCbKHM areHTCTBOM Mi*KHaponHoro Po3BsTKY (SIDA), KOMiCiCIO CC, FIPOOH Ta USAID. Byno npoBe.AeHQ O3HafAoMneHHnl UHX opraHi3auirl i3 OCHOBHOIO 3,a06yTroo iH4)opMauieCo Ta nonepeAHiMH peKoMeHAauaMHt. AepKaBHi 3aicyliBJli B YKpalHi no i lliCJIH 3MiH 2004-2005 pp. go 3axoHy upo 3aKyniBJno ToBapiB, po6iT Ta HOCJYF 3a JepMKaBHi KOIITH 6. ALo BHeCCHHHH 3MiH aO 3aKouy y JnIcTonaRi 2004 poicy, 'epBHi Ri rpyAHi 2005 pONy 3A3 i cHcTeMa 3aKyniBejib B YKpaNHi BiAnOBiaanH B UiJnOMy Mi)KHapoAHiA npaKTHUi (AHB. JonaTOK 3). PO3noPSIAHHKH 6toxKeTHuX KOUITiB BiAnoBinajiH 3a npOBeAeHHA BjiaCHHX 3aKyniBeJib. XKC,43, 5K ynOBHOBaKweHHri opraH, HanaaBaB niiTpHMKy po3nop3lAHHKaM, BiAnoBigaB 3a HaBMaHHR Ta PO3rJiS cKapr y'aCHHKiB TopriB. Ls9 CHCTeMa CTa6inbHo p03BHBanacb 3 MeToio ,AoCxrHeHH51 Mi)KHapoUHHx cTaHnapTiB y rany3i 3aKyniBenb. 7. lIiCJIc 3MiH gO 3aKoUy AemKi *yHKIAiY YlOBHOBa)KCeHOrO oprany 6yjno nepenaHo HeypsioBiA opraHWauii "TemtepHa naJaTa"(AHB. ,og8aToic 4). TeHnepHiri naniaTi 6ynro nepeAaHo pSi noBHoBa)KeHb, 3oKpeMa, ny6JiiKauix iH4opMauiY npo ToprH ra ymnaaeHi goroBopH, po3rnn, cKapr y'aCHHKiB TopriB Ta Y3roA*eKHHA BHKOPHCTaHHS npoueAypH 3aKyniBeJTb B OAHoro ymacHHKa i npoue,aypu TopriB 3 o6MeKeHo1o y'acTIo. 14i 3MiHH npH3BeCJH AO Po3noAiOnY (YHKLiur B raJy3i 3aKyniBejib cepe, pi3HHX AepmKaBHHX Ta Heyp51OBHX opraHiB, B pe3yJlbTaTi nOBHOBaKeHHS nepmKaBH 6yno po3nropoLueHo. 3MiHM no 3aKoHy Bi, 15 rpyRaH 2005 pOKy Ha6panIH qHHHOCTi 17 6epe3Hs 2006 pOKy Ta nPH3BenJH go nepenaqi cyHKUifM Yn0BHOBa)KeHOO opraHy Big AICKJ3 Ao AHTHMOHonOJnbHoro KOMiTeTy Ta iHWIHX aepmaBHex opraHiB. BHacalinoK Uboro 6yno BTpa'eHO 3HaHHs cnpaBH, IuO pOKaMH Ha6yBanH crfBpo6iTHHKH W,1A3. CTaH BIIpOBBaUeHHH HilaHy gir, peKOMmeHAOBaHOFO B pamKcax 303 Bin 2001 poKy 8. 303 CBiToBoro 6auHIy Bin 2001 pOK-y MiCTHB iH4OpMauiio Fnpo nepeBarH Ta HeCoJillH CHCTeMH AepXCaBHUX 3aKyniaejlb. Y 3BiTi 6ynio 3anpoloHOBaHO nnJaH AiM lU0O°O BAOCKoHaneHHA CHCTeMH, BKjlloqaloqH 3MiLtHeHHA iHCTHTYLIiriHOY CTpyKTypH; PO3BHTOK 4yHKUiM )VJ3 B qacTHHi Harimnay, MOHiTOpHHry Ta MeTOnoJOlri4Ho0 niiTpHMKH; nOKpalleHHS npoueayp Ta npaKTHKH npoBeAeHH1s 3aKyniBeJib; nepena'y 6inbtuHx rOBHOBaxeHb PO3nOPsAHHKaM 6Io,leTHHx KOUITiB 4epe3 ;X iHCTNTYU;irHY pO36yA0By Ta nocHJIeHHS CTyneHIo BignoBinanbHOCTi AepmaBHHx c.nyK6oBuiB. 9. 3 tiacy nlpHflHHITTSI 3aXOHy YKpaiHH "IIpo 3aKyHiBJInO TOBapiB, po6iT i nOCJlyr 3a Aep)KaBHi KOMTIIH B 2000 poui BepXOBHa Pana 3aTBepAHJla neB SITb 3MiH Ao 3aKoHy. nepiua cyTreBa 3MiHa B 2001 poui 3anpoBaA)KyBaBa AegKi peKoMeHnauiY CBiToBoro 6aHKy. HacTynHi qOT0pH 3MiHH 6ynu pe3yJTbTaTOM npouecy nPHBeaeHH5i 3aKoHy y BinHOBinHiCTb n0 3MiH, 3aTBepr)KeHHX n0 iHIUHX 3aKoHonaB'Hx aKTiB. [Le oAHiCIo 3MiHolO no 3aKoHy 6ynio HaAaHO npe4epeHuiw BiTqH3H5HHUM cinbrocnBHpo6HHKaM. 3riAHO i3 OCTaHHiMH TpbOMa 3MiHaMH AO 3aKoHy, Ba)xnHBi c)yHKUif aepwae B rany3i 3aKyniBenb 6yno nepeaaHo npHBaTHOMy CeKTOpy. qOTHpI "nO34THBHi" 3MiHU BKnloqaloTb: (a) 3MiHH no 3aKoHy, CRpXIMOBaHi Ha CnpOUxeHHR npouenypH ny6.niKauiY oroJIonueHb npo TOprH Ta Yfx pe3YJEbTaTH B 6ionereHi npo RLiep)KaBHi 3aKyniBni; (6) Heo6XigHicTb OTpUMaHHS noroR)KeHHs YO nepeA 36inJbUueHHAM CyMH norOBOpy Ha BHKOHaHHJ9 6yaiBenbHHX po6iT 6e3 npoBeAeHH.R TOpriB 6ijlbul, Hi)K Ha 50 BinCOTKiB BiA noqaTKoBof BapTocTi; (B) CKaCyBaHHA CTaTri 35 3aKoHy, 3riAHO 3 3iKO10 3aMoBHHK MaB BinlilKonyBaTH BHKOHaBUIO "HeoTpHMaHHi" aoxoniu y pa3i pO3ipBaHH51 noroBOpy 3aMoBHHKoM; Ta (r) MO)KJnHBiCTb yKnaaaHH3 ,aorOBOpiB TepMiHOM Ha AeKinbKa pOKiB Ha BHKOHaHHS 6yniBenbHHx po6iT. "Cirma" I~iHaHCycTbcx rOnOBHuM HUHOM CC. [L. KOHKpCTHa po6oTa (iHaHcyBajlacb YnpaBJfiHHxM MbiKHapo,mHoro pO3BHTKy BemIKo6pumaHii (DFID) i I1Be1cbKHM areHTCTBOM MiMKHapoJHoro pO3BHTKy (SIDA). 5 3eim 3 oUiinKU 3aKyniBeeZb 6 YKpabji - 2006 piK 10. iab6iCTrb peKOMeCHaUifl MORO CTBOpeHHS iHCTHTY4i!HHX CUpOMO2HOCTeH B raniy3i aepXCBHHX 3alcyuiBeib 6yn4o BDpOBaAiKeHO. LUe BKjiio'ae CTBOpeHHR Mepe)Ki HaBManjbHHX LteHTpiB, niUrOTOBKy BHKnap,a4iB Ha 3araAbHoLep)KaBHOMy piBHi, po3po6Ky MaTepianisi Ta HaB4aHHA Ha BCiX piBHilx npauiBHHKiB pO3nopwHHKiB 6IozpeTHHx KOWlTiB. IL. Psu peKoMeH1aIIiA lIl.aIny Aiii 303 3a 2001 piK TaK i He 6yn1o BFlPOBahxCeHO CTaHOM Ha cepeZIHHy 2006 polcy. CepexR HHX: 3HH)KeHH3 BapTiCHHx nOKa3HHKiB Ha o6MexeHHR y4acTi iHo3eMHHX 4ipM y Toprax, CTBopeHHA He3aBieJKHoro areHTCTBa 3 nHTaHb Aep)KaBHHx 3aKynineJb npH Ka6iHeTi MiHicTpiB Ta nocHneHHq JA,KJA3. 3aKOHOM AlOCi He BCTaHOBJIeHO OKpeMHX npolte,ayp IISI BiJ.6opy KoHcyAbTaLUi"HHx nocnyr. He 6yno 3anpOBaBjKeHO CTaHXIapTHY TeHAepPHY ,oKyMeHTauito. He 6yno 3aKOHOaBqO BperynEoBaHo npoLteAypH 4OpMyBaHHR "topHoro cnHCKy" KoMnaHir, wo 6yrnH noMiqeHi y KOpynLiriHHX AiAx. HasBHicTb niueH3ir4 Ta AO3BOniB 1ROCi 3anHIIaeTbCSIa M yMoBoto .onyCKy AO TopriB, a He yMOBOIO pi,i yKJaAeHHM AoroBopiB. CTpy1-Typa ixborO 3BiTy 12. AHa21i3 Ta OCHOBHa 3lQO6yTa iH4pOpMauig npeIICTaBJIeHi B 3BiTi TaKHM 'HHOM: B PO3XIiJi 2 npe.AcTaBneHo aHani3 HopMaTHBHo-npaBoBoY 6a3H 3a nepioA 3 KiH[A 2005 pOKy Ro qacy HaniHCaHS UEbOrO 3BiTy B 2006 poui. B po3,aiii 3 npoaHaJIi3oBaHo iHCTHTyUiriHy CTPYKTYPY Ta ynpaBJ]iHCbKHri nOTeHCHiail B ranJy3ia ep)KaBHI4X 3aKyniBenlb. B Po3Aini 4 PO3rFjiAacTbCR npouec 3aKyniBenib, BKjito4aIoqti 4yHKWioHyBaHHs PHHKY Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenib, ynpaBjiiHHS AOrOBOpaMH Ta CHCTeMy BlipiUeHHA CnipHHX nHTaHb. J0ani y 3BiTi o6roBoptoioTbcs nHTaHHA Ao6potecHocTi Ta npo3opocTi CHCTeMUI (po3,iui 5), eJIeKTpOHHi 3aKyniBni (po3niin 6), flOKa3HMKH BHKOHaHHS yron npo epwKaBHi 3aKyniBjli (po3virl 7) Ta nHTaHHS nOCTynOBOf rapMOHh3aLf 3 AHpeKTHBaMH CC A ocTaTo4qHoro npH4HAHHSH no YroA.w COT (po3ain 8). Po3AiR 9 MiCTHTb aHani3 pU3HKiB i nnaH AiM CTaHOM Ha 2006 piK. PeKoMeHiauii y BiAnOBinHHX pO3.Ainax 3BiTy no3HaqeHi CTPiKaMH ( > ). HaHBaaKnHBiwli peKoMeHaauLil ni,LCyMoBaHo B pO3niJli 9 i BHKjiaAeHi B pO3AiAi CTHcnoro orIniy. 4qOTHpH XOAaTKH MiCTaTb 6inblu AeTaJIbHy iH4opMaLulio, a caMe: aeTaAbHHA rinnaH BnpOBa,AKeHHA (JtoAaToK 1), KOHTpOJIbHi nOKa3HtiKH, po3po6neHi KoMiTeToM niATPHMKH pO3BHTKY OECD AiiA AlociiA2IeHHM cvepH flep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeiIb (JloAaToK 2), CxeMa opraHi3auiHHOl CTPYKTYPH 3aKyniBeelb n0 3MiH no 3aKoHy, n0o 6yno npHAHATO y 2005 poUi (JgonaTOK 3) Ta CxeMa opraHi3auiriHo1 CTpYKTypH 3aKyniBenb niCJli 3MiH Ao 3aKoHy, tuo 6yno npHiHRTO y 2005 poLui (JAoAaToK 4). 6 3Bim 3 OWiHKU 3aKyni6eb 6 YKpawHi - 2006piK 2. HOPMATHBHO-IIPABOBA SA3A IlpoGieMH, nOB's93aHi 3 qHHHOIO 3aOlHoaaB'qIOO 6a3OIo 13. Ao nIHcTonana 2004 poiy YKpalHa Maia 3ara.ioM UpHHMITHHO 3aIcoH npo AepwaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i (3alcoH), SIKHU B IliJlOMy BiAHOBilaB 3araJIbHOnpHAHNTirl Mi2KHapoJHiR FIpaCrTHUi. O0IHaK TpH CyTreBi nonpaBKiu Ao 3aKoHy, HKi 6yno pO3po6jleHO KOMiTeTaMH BepXOBHOf PaAH (BP) Ta 3aTBepAweHo BP B 2004 i 2005 pp., npH3BeOJH AO 3HaqHHX 3MiH y 3aKOHoAaBCTBi. 13 BBeAeHH.RM B Aio 3MiHH 1o 3aKoHy BilA 18 nHcTonaAa 2004 POKy 6yno CKaCOBaHO AeSxKi (1yHKLii YO Ta 3aHPOBDaa*eHo KOH1Aeni1xito BHKOpHCTaHHq nriaTHHX KOHCyJ1ETaUii1HHX nocjiyr nig -iac npOBeAeHHq Aep2KaBHHX 3aKyeiBenb. 3MiHoIo Bi, 16 OepBHq 2005 pOKy HH3Ky 4yHKii AeplKaBHoro opraHy 6yno nepeAaHo Heyp.1AoBiR opraHi3auii "TeHAepHa naniaTa YKpaYHH". HacTynHa 3MiHa (3aTBepAweHa 15 rpyAHm 2005 pOKy, Ha6pana UHHHOCTi 17 6epe3Hs 2006 pOKy) 3anpOBaB1HJa HOBi noJIo)KeHHZ 114010 CTpyKTypHoI opraHi3auiil Aeps)KBHHX 3aKyniBenb Ta CHCTeMH Harnisy i KOHTpOJIlO, SKi e He3BHqHHMH, MaloTb Heo11HO3Ha'IHy TpaKTOBKY Ta He BiAnOBiA1alOTb 3aranbHonpHTHsTii MimHapOHirl npaKTHLUi. KpiM Toro, 3aKOHoAaB'HRi npouec Bi16yBCs 6e3 o6roBopeHB Ta yqaCTi B HbOMy alli 3aiiKaBneHHx CTOpiH, aHi AenapTaMeHTy, UWo Ha TOU iac BHKOHYBaB (IyHKL1ii YnOBHOBa)KeHoro opraFy B rany3i Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb. 14. HoBi nojiomceHH 3aKoHy liUJlIH Ha KOPHCTb ARBOM 3aItiiCaBJIeHHM cTopoHaM. Flo-neplne, THM, XTO CTBOpHB Ta ynpaBBJlc TeHAepHoIo naJiaTolo, a 3apa3 OTpMmanH HaB3BH'laRHO BeJIHKi nOBHOBaweHHA B CHCTeMi 1ep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBemb. Flo-Apyre, THM CrpyKTypam rIpHBaTHoro ceKTOpy, Ho MalOTb 3HCK 3a paxyHOK Aep)aKBH 3aB31KIi CBOIM 3BR3KaM i3 TeHaepHolo naJiaTolo. Hpo6.jeMH, IOB'H3aHi 3i 3MiHOIO ao 3akoHy BiR JIHcTonaAa 2004 poxy 15. 3MiHoio Bi, JIHCTonaAa 2004 poKy YO 6yjio no36aBjieHo HH3KH 06OB'lI3KiB, 3OcpeMa, H2AOHH%I KOHCyJ1bTaUiliH0Oi AOnOmOrH, MeTOAOaiorHHX peicOMeH1aUiIi, CT8H1apTHOi TeHAepHoT aoKyMeHTaUii Ta iHUIIOi iHlpOpMaUiT opraHi3aIIi9M, BICi 3a2fMl1OTbcH ceplaBHHMH 3aKlyniBJnMH. LJba 3MiHa 3anpOBaAqHJa 060B' 3KOBe BHKOpHCTaHHR "cepTHmiKoBaHHx` iH)opMauiRHHx CHcTeM tWn ny6niKauii TeH1AepHHX oro0Jow0eHb (He3BaxKalo4H Ha Te, I1O TaKi iHMopMauiriHi CHCTeMH HaBiTB He iCHyBanJt Ha TOg Lac), a TaKO)K o6oB's3KoBe BHeCeHHR nnaTH 3a TeHAePHy oKyMeHTaI1iIo. KpiM Toro, 6yno 3aKoHoAaBqo WB3BoneHO 3aaymaTH AO OL1iHKH TeHnePHHX nponO3HUirl "eKcnepTiB" 3riAHo i3 yKna1AeHHMH AOrOBopaMH (To6To 3a nnaTy). Hlpo6JIeMH, UOB's3aHi 31OflpaBKOI 10g0 3aKOHy Bil 'epBHH 2005 poK-y 16. TeHAepHa naniaTa BH3HaqacTbcH 3aICOHOM B nOJiOmKeHHS1X 10oA0 rpOMBACLKOrO KOHTPOJIIO B c4Cepi aepW8BHHX 3aKyniBeJIb HlK "HeHpH6yTKoBa cniiKa rpom)MaBCbKHX OpraHi3auir, 11KBa Ric 3riHO 3 MHHHUM 3aKoHolaBcTBoM YKpaTHH". CeHC uboro BH3HaqeHHA e cKiiaHHM RXS pO3yMiHHSl. HeM3aia!omH Ha HeOAHopa3oBi cnpo6H, 4)aXiBIIM EaHKy He Bsanoc31 OTpHMaTH aHi nepeniK qneHiB TeHzepHol naniaTH, aHi Konil cTaTyriB, SIKi peryEoiomTb MexaHi3MH npHRHqTrx piueHb TnHY [cTarrqs 17(4) 3A3]. 3MiHoo Ao 3aKoHy BiA qepBHS 2005 pOKy TeHAepHiri naJiaTi 6yno nepeAaHo TpH AepKaBHi 4iyHKuii (AHB. HHi'Ie). He3BamaioqH Ha To, luo Harxiilloaa papa TnHY Mae y CBoMmy cKmaai neBHy KiJlbKiCTb aenyraTiB BepxOBHOf Pa.H Ta IpeCACTaBHHKiB aep)KaBHHX opraHiB, BOHa Mae CTaTyC CyTO KOHCYJlbTaTHBHoro opraHy" [cTarr,i 17(4) i 17(6) 3Ja3], a iif qnJeHH npauLolOTb Ha "rpoMa1CbKHX 3acaAax " (cTaTTr 17.4 i 17.5). TaKa CTpyKrypa Mornia 6Hi 6yTm npHriHaTHOlo, SIK6H TeHaepHa nanaTa 6ynia 3BHMa1HWO1 Heyp%AOBOIO opraHi3auiclo, AISJbHICTb SKOI 6yna 6 THnOBOIO Ans 6yAb-iKorO HY0. npoTe, LteA BHnaLoK 3OBCiM iHWHr1, OCKiJ]bKH AO (JYHKUIi1 HYO "TeH1epHa nanaTa YKpaliHH" BXOAHTb po3po6Ka cTpaTeriY PO3BHTKy rany3i Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. BoHa Mae neBHi noBHOBa2KeHHM 10110 ynpaBJ]iHH. Aep KaBHHMH 3aKyniBJsnMH, xo'a He niinirae HarIJMAy Ta KOHT-pOnIO 3 60Ky Aep)KaBH. 17. no-nepmue, TeHuepHifl nanJaTi nepeaaHo npaBo HaBIB8TH PO3nOPAHHHKaM 60IIoKeTHHX KOlTiB AO3BOJIH Ha 3aCTOCYBaHHS upoue1yp TOpliB 3 o6MemKeHolO y-acTIo Ta 3aKyniBsni B OaHOrO y'aCHHKB. 5K6ii PO3nOpRAHHKH 610oAKeTHHX KOWTiB Ma3JH MO)KJIHBiCTb .1iMTH Ha BjnaCHHr p03CYA, He 3Ba)KafoHH Ha nono)KeHHS 3aKoHy npo 3aKyniBJi, TO 6iJlbtUiCT 3 HHX, HaneBHe, BHKOpHCTOBYBana 6 HaUMeHW KOHKypeHTHi MeTOAH 3aKyniBeiE. 3aKoHoM 6yKBanbHo BcTaHOBjieHO, uAo o6MewefHHR a6o 7 3fim 3 OZiHKU 3aKynieellb 6 YKpaini - 2006piK BiAMiHa KOHKypeHUif (3aKyniBni B oAHOro y-qaCHHIKa) Mo)Ke BiA6yTHcn nlHiue 3a Y3r0A)KeHHRM ynOBHOBax1eHOrO opraHy. KepiBHHIUTBo TeHAepHoY nanJaTH 3aneBHAe, IUO TaK BOHO i e. Pa3oM 3 THM, ''npaBo" TFY po6HTH TaKi y3roJmKeHHA niATBepAWKycTbcSi nHcToM JAep)KaBHoro Ka3Ha-4eACTBa BiA 12 cepnHSi 2005 pOKy, aApecoBaHoro periOHanbHHiM BiAAiJeHHAM, a TaKOK "BHCHOBKOM" THY BiA 15 cepnHH 2005, SKHR C, no CyTi, pO3'AcHeHHAM 3MiHH ao 3aKoHy BiA qepBHs 2005 poKy. 18. Ho-Apyre, TeHAepHSa naJnaTa OTPHManJ1S 4YHKUilO KOHTpOJ1IO HaR BHAaBHHUTBOM O41ilfiHoro 6ioueTeH9 AepXCaBHHX 3aEcyniBeJb. 3riAHo 3i 3MiHaMH Ao 3aKoHy BiJ 4epBHA 2005 poKy P03nOp1JHHKH 6ioAlpKeTHHx KOWITiB nOBHHHi ny6niKyBaTH oroPowJleHHS npO TOprH a6o y BicHuKy i)ep,caeinux 3axyni6eenb (wo ny6niiyKTbc EAAep)KaBHHM niAripHcMcTBoM nppH MiHicTepcTBi eKoHoMiKH), a6o B iH4opMagiriHOMy 6ioneTeHi TeHIepHoi nanaTH. TaKa ny6niKauix nepeAnye npoBeAeHHIo 3aKyniBenb 3a npoueAypaMH KOHKypeHTHHX TopriB. TaKHM HHOM, CAHHHM cnoco6oM Ai3HaTHCS npo BCi oronomeieHHn TeHAepiB c niAnHCKa Ha o6niBi ny6.niiKaLtif, wo nPH3BOJHTb Ao He6axcaHoro 36ijibIleHHA BHTpaT Jix y-qaCHHKiB TopriB. (,4q cHTyaLtis 3a3HaaI 3MiH BHacniJ1OK Ha6yTTAsl 4HHOCTi nonpaBKHA [O 3aKoHy BiA rpyJHA 2005 poKy, Ka po3rnsIAaerbcs HH)K4e). 19. f1o-TpeTC, TeluepHa naniaTa Mac HpaBo, 1Wo 3S3BHqaH HaineJKHTb YO, BHJABBTH ''BHCHOBlH cUno cacaprax He3aAoBoneHHUX yqaCHH[CiB. XoiaTaKi "BIICHOBKI4 He ManfH o6oB's3KoBoro xapaKTepy, i YO 36epiras CBoc nipaBo npH1MaTH Bj1acHe piuileHHHs, Lue nonjo1KeHHA 3aKoHy CTBOpHJnO cHTyaL.ilo HeBH3HaqeHOcTi. HaBiTb BKlUO "BUCHOBOK" TeHAepHoY nanJaTH MaB AOpaAqHA xapaKTep, nO3HTHBHa peKoMeHJlaLuiA, HaaaHa yqaCHHKy TOpriB, cnyryBaiia niAcTaBolo AnA OCKap4KeHHq HeraTHBHOrO piLweHHA YO 3 Toro caMoro nHTaHHq. FpH po3rJnn1i CnipHHX nHTaHb CyA LlacTo 3BalKC Ha BUCHOBKH TeHAepHoY naniaTH. OrAce, BHCHOBOK HeypSIAOBOi opraHi3aLlii, sKa 3BHqa1HO He niuiArac KOHTPOJ11O 3 6OKy Aep)KaBH, c niAcTaBoio ARA BiAXHeHHAS piiueHHA aep)KaBHoro opraHy. PeKoMeiLOaLq4 CKacyBaTH cTaTTi 17.1 - 17.5, a TaKO)K 6yAb-.-Ki iHWi nocnHaHHq Ha TeHAepHy naJiaTy, 'Y fiyHKuil A nOBHoBarKeHHA B 3aKoHi YKpaIHH "llpo 3aKyniBJIo ToBapiB, po6iT i nocaiyr 3a Aep)KaBHi KOI1ITH" BiA 22 uiioToro 2000 POKY (3i 3MiHaMH BiE 16 qepBHA i 15 rpyxHA 2005 poKy). B3araMi caMa iAeA L)epmcaeHux 3aKyniBejThBHKJoqac MolKuHBicTb nepeAaqi OCHOBHHX aep)KaBHHX 4yHKLtiA npHBaTHiH opraHi3awl, AKa He niA3BiTHa AepIKaBi. AoonpaU1OBaTH nojio)KeHHS cTaTTi 37, SKi i 3apa3 C npHHariMHi HeqiTKHMH, a cTaHyTb Ule nnyTaHiuHMH niCJIA BHnyqeHH1 3 LtiEI CTaTri tHcJIeHHHx nocHnaHb Ha TeHaepHy nianaTy. Ilpo6JieMH, NlOB'sI3aHi 3i 3MiHaMH [o 3aKOiHy Big rpyRHsi 2005 poicy 20. 15 rpyAjHn 2005 poiy BepXOBHa PaAa we p23 BHeCJIa 3MiHH ao 3aKoiOy. HHMH 6yno 3anPoBaA)KeHo HOBi Ta HeBIaCTHBi cHCTeMi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb npHHuHnH opraHi3auiiiHOi CTpyKTypH, HarJlALy Ui KOHTpOJIIO. HOBi HOpMH, SBKi )KOJHHM qHHOM He noKpa[LWyTOTb aHi npO3OpiCTb CHcTeMH, aHi e4CKTHBHiCTb iHCTHTyLiriHoro naAy, He BiAnOBiAalOTb AO TOrO )K 3araJbHonpHHHsToMy B JIeMOKPaTHqHHX KpaiHax npHHLxHny po3nofJlJY Bjia,LH. 3Ba)KHBUlH Ha 3aHenOKOCHH11 yKpa]HCbKHX lOpHCTiB BHULHX iHcTaHuiH UAOAO 3anponOHOBaHHX 3MiH 3 ornAAy Ha KOHCTHTYLIi;O, Hpe3HJieHT 3acToCyBaB 13 CiqHA 2006 poKY CBoc npaBo BeTo. HpoTe, Bwe 21 nioToro 2006 pOKy BepxoBHa PaAa noAonaJia LIe BeTo, a 10 6epe3HA 2006 pOKy npe3HuAeHT niAntHcaB 3aKoH npO 3MiHH Ao 3aKoHy npo 3aKyniBAlo ToBapiBe po6iT Ta nocnyr 3a AeplKaBHi KOurrI4, AK1Hr Ha6paB 41HHOCTi 17 6epe3HA 2006 pOKy. 21. OncpeMi nOJIOwIeHHR 3MiHH HO 3aKouy Big rpyAHH 2005 pOCy 3JiRCHHJIH HerSTHBHH!i BnJIUB Ha iHCTHTyUiJiHy UiJiCHiCTL Ta UpO3OpiCT6 Alep2KaBHHX 3acyniiBeiB6, a caMe: * 3MiHaMH oApa3y, 6e3 6yAb-sKoro nepexiAHoro nepioAy, 6yno CKacOBaHO BHKOHaHHS 4yHKULifl ynOBHOBa)KeHOrO opraHy ,LgenapTaMeHTOM 3 nHTaHb KooplHHaIJif DeplKaBHuX 3aKyniBeRb (,llK,;3) MiHiCTepcTBa eKOHoMiKH. 4aCTHHy 4yHKLXUi, wo Ix BHKOHYBaB ,l3, 6yno nepeLAaHO AHTHMoHonoubHoMy KoMiTeTy (AMKY), 1KHi 6yn1o 3aCHOBaHO 3riAHo 3 OKpeMHM 3aKOHOM 3 MeTo)O BHKOHaHHS 3OBCiM iHWIHX 3aAaq i AKHR MaB AOCHTb o6Me2KeHHH AOCBiA y c4)epi 3aKyniBeJlb. )KoAHa AepIKaBa, 3a BHRATKOM, MO2KJnHBO, OHiCl 4UH ABOX cBpOnlCeCbKHX Kpa;H, He HaATinHna 6 TaKHA opraH sBK AHTHMoHononbHuH4 KOMiTeT nIOBHOBa)KeHHAMH B rany3i AepKa3BHHX 3aKyniBenb, Ro TOrO X( HaAaBwiH riOMy HaCTiJIbKH o6Me)KeHi npaBa. BHKoHaBHi 4yHKWii, HK npaBBHAo, He BXOAATb AO KOnia KOMneTeHLli; OpraHy, UJO BiAnOBiAaC 3a CTpaTeriqHi nHTaHHS 8 3fim 3 OZfiHKU 3aKyni6eelb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK KOHKypeHTHOi nOIiTOHKH. glo Toro )K, efeKTHBHiCTb BHKOHaHHs1 TaKHX @YHKLJ.ir 3Ha4HHM 'WHOM 3HH)KYCTbC.R BHacniOKK iX P03nopolueHHq nOMiDK pi3HHMU BiAOMCTBaMH Ta CTpyKTypaMH. * BepXoBHa Pa,ga B3Jna Ha ce6e 4)yHKUiIo KOHTpOJIIO 3a Aep*KaBHHM HarnAOSM y c4)epi 3aKyniBeJIb. TaKa nepe1aa,a 3aKoHoXaBaMirl rini Bna,H noBHoBa)KeHbE, 11o 3a3BHMaH HaneanKTb BHKOHaB4Hi, CTBOpIOC CyT1CBHti KOH4niKT. * 3acHyBaHHA 3 MeTOlO 3,UircHeHHH HarnMay 3a 4)yHKLIioHyBaHHRM CHCTeMH aepXKaBHHx 3aKyniBenJb CnelliajbHO; KOHTpOJ16HOI KOMiCif (CKK) 3 nHTaHb AepwKaBHHx 3aKyniBeJb npH PaxyHKoBifl nanaTi nPH3BenJo Ao CTBOpeHHA CHTyaL1ii KOH4JiKTy iHTepeCiB. 3ajyqeHHa BHII'oro opraHy ayAwTy, ulo 3#1iHcH1OC He3ane)KHHA Harniji 3a BHKOHBHHqM gepwaBHoro 6io.Ke-ry, ,o camoro npoLlecy BHKOHaHHS 6io.iKeTy cynepemHTb MibKHapoAHiHr npaKTHli. * 31K 3a3HaanJIOCb BHWe, 3MiHOK0 Ao 3aKOHy Bi£ MepBHx 2005 poKy iH4opMauirlHoMy 6ioneTeHlo TeH)iepHoli naliaTH 6yno HaIaHO CTaTycy o04ititHoro BH21aHH3 B rany3i Aep2KaBHHx 3aKyniBeiib. 3MiHoFo Ao 3aKoHy Bi, rpygHS 2005 pOKy 6yno YCYHyTo 6yr6b-AKe nocHJ1aHH5 Ha o@iL1iAHH1l 6ioJneTeHb ynOBHoBa>KeHoro opraHy (nKHfl Bs,aaBano Aep)KaBHe aKLiioHepHe niLnpIcMcTBo npH MiHeKOHOMiKH), repeTBOpUIIBH, TaKMM 4HHOM, iH¢opMauiMHHH 6loneTeHb TeHgepHoY nanaTH Ha £wHHMA o60B'513KoBHA 3aci6 pO3MilIueHHS 0o4iljirlHoi iHcopMatilY. [UiCio 3MiHoio £1o 3aKoHy nepe,a6a4acTbcx MO)KJIHBiCTb BHHHKHeHHR HOBoro "cneuiani3oBaHoro gpyKOBaHOrO 3aco6y MaCOBOY iH()opMai1ii, Uo ny6niKye iH(opMaUHo BHKJHO'0HO 3 nHTaHb £epxKaBHHX 3aKynifenb" (AKHU, cxO)Ke, BHUaBaTHMe npHBaTHHII CeKTOp) 3a yMOB, 11O BCi oroJO1IeHHR ny6niKyBaTmMyTbcA B o6ox BHAaHHSX. TyT BUHHKae nHTaHHfl, SKe caMe BHaaHHSI BBa2KaTHMeTbcS npeBalmoBolO1MM y pa3i BHHHKHeHHA po36iKHOcTeri B TeKCTaX. Ile nHTaHHS c Ba)KRHBHM uie A TOMy, 110 TepMiH HaCTaHHS aeAKHX KiHUeBHX CTpOKiB BitpaXOByCTbCs came 3 E1aTH ny6niiKaLiY. OTKe, He AUHBHO, iuo TeHgepHa naniaTa OnpHmllOJHHfla cBiHl "BHCHOBOK" uoxAo o6oB'A3KOBOCTi ny6JniKauiY iH4OpMauiY came B cBocMy 6lon]eTeHi. * noro£PIeHH9 Ha 3acToCyBaHHR npoLleAypH 3aKyniBJIi B OtlHoro yLacHHKa Ta TOpriB 3 o6Me)KeHoIo yqaCTIO Ha,gacTbcA a6o AHTUMOHonojibHHM KOMiTeToM, a6o TeHl,epHoIo naJiaTolo. HpOTe, 6iIbIlliCTb PO3nIpIlgHH1KiB 6io0IKeTHHX KOIUTiB, 1iMOBipHO, 3BepTaTHMyTbC51 3a TaKHMH nOro,lUKeHHA1MH came go TeHAepHo naiiaTH, AKa MaC nOBHOBa)KeHHAI HazaBaTH HlorO BnaCHOpyq, a He jio AHTHMoHononbHoro KoMiTeTy, flKUi Mae cnepwi oTpHMaTH cxBaneHHA CnelianbHoY KOHTpOJIbHOY KOMiCiY (CKK)i TiJ;bKH niCMiA iUborO HaB£aaTH CBOc noroJKeHHA. * MexaHi3M 0CKap)KeHH.I npoueAyp 3aKyniBeiEb C HeCCHHM. CKapra HanpaBJIACTbC5I a6o 3aMoBHHKY (po3nopsurnHHKy 61ojKeTHHx KOuITiB), a6o CKK, a TaKo)K TeHuepHiri nanaTi. CKK npHiMae pilileHHAI "3 ypaXyBaHH51M BHCHOBKy TeHAepHOY naJaTH". 3 lOpUHIlHOY TO'qKH 30py HeACHO, 1H Uer BHCHOBOK Mae o6oB'5f3KOBHl xapaKTep, MH npOCTO KOHCyJIbTaTHBHHl. Lte CTaHOBHU1e uXe 6iibim6e YCKiia,HIOCTbC51 HaCTynHHMH gBOMa HeAICHHMH Ta cynepeqHMnBHMH ro0jo)KeHHA1MH IUOAO MO)KnHBOCTi 0CKap2KeHH51 a£IMiHiCTpaTHBHHX piileHb B Cy£1oBoMy HOpSI£IKy. * CTarrelo 17-3 (12) BCTaHOBJIIOCTbCfl, 1.O "i3lJlbHiCTb TeHgepHoY naHiaTH YKpaYHH, a TaKoK pe3ynbTaTH TaKoI iflAJbHOCTi, y TOMY IHCJIi BHCHOBKH, iHUli ,LOKyMeHTH TeHAepHoY naraTH YKpaYHH MO)KyTb 6yrt oCKap)KeHi BHKJIIO4HO y Cy£IOBOMY nOPHaKy BiAnOBiaHO go 3aKoHy." 3anpoBa.KeHHr1 Uief 3MiHH CnPH'IHH5C A110 CepA03HHX HaCniiiKiB. no CyTi uie noJowKeHHAl o3HaMae, UUO BHCHOBKH Ta pitueHHx TeHgepHoY nanaTH paxmu'iHO c o6oB'af3KOBHMUH ARA BHKOHaHH.q, RKIUO TiRbKH YX He ocKap)KeHO y CYRoBOMy nHOpAAlIKy. IHaKwIe Ka)KyqH, TeHgepHa naniaTa MowKe npHHMaTH "a:MiHiCTpaTI4BHi pilueHHA", ane, He 6ygy4H cy6'CKToM aRMiHicTpaTHBHoro npaBa, He BiJAnoBiUaTHMe 3a CBO; 1i 3riAHO 3 aRMiHiCTpaTHBHHM 3aKOHoRaBCTBOM MH KOgeKCOM. * noWHpeHHA1 Aif LbOrO 3MKOHY Ha BCi gep)KaBHi ni£npHEMCTBa (B flKHX gep)KaBHa macTKa aKuiri nepeBauiye 50 BiJICOTKiB) C HecyMiCHHM i3 3araF7bHHMH UpHHLXHHaMH cPYHKUiOHyBaHH31 Aep)KaBHHX niAnpHCMCTB, flKi Kepy1OTbCA npaBHjiaMH THnOBOi KoMepuliuHoY npaKTHKH B CBOi i5i1lJbHOCTi. 3anpoBa,IKeHHfl ZIoJaTKoBHx flK npHXOBaHHX, TaK i flBHHX npe4epeHUirl BiTqH3H5HOMy BHpo6HHKy, MowKe nO3Ha'HTHC51 Ha npoLieci npHcJHaHHA YKpaYHH ,go Yro£1H npo xiep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i (YJA3) flK ogHoro i3 3060B'5f3aHb B paMKaX COT. 9 3eim 3 O4iHKU 3aKyni6eJlb 6 YKpaini - 2006piK * IAoAaTKoBi 060B'S3KH B rany3i flep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJb 6yJo noKnaAeHO Ha pRAi iHIIHX Aep)KaBHHX opraHiB 3riAHo i3 cTaTr3iMH 3-2 Ta 17 ('acrHHa 2) 3aKoHy. FlpoTe, cne[tianbHe 3aKOHOAaBCTBO, IItO peryjlOc AiSbHiCTb uHX opraHiB He 6ynio npHBe.eHo y BiLAnOBiAHicTb A1O nono)KeHb L[Ux cTaTei. Ile CTBoploc cHTyaUilO HeBH3HaqeHOCTi iitOXo Kiona BiAInOBiAaflbHOCTi WUX OpraHiB. PemoMen6aL(ii > 3MiHU .AO 3aKOHy Bi, rpyAIHsA 2005 POKY MiCTrTb noJlo?KeHHA, Uso npH3BOI.Tb AO Hee4,eKTHBHoCTi gepXKaBHHX BHfaTKiB. [Ai nOno)KeHHS noTpi6Ho neperJlAHyTH. > OCKinbKH 3MiHH ARo 3aKoHy, Luo 6ynO 3anpOBaAxceHO y 2004 Tra 2005 poKax, iCTOTHO npeo6pa3HnH 3aKoH npo 3aKyniBni, niAroToBKa npoeKTy HOBoro TeKcTy 3aKoHy Aonomorna 6 pO3nOpR.AHHKaM 6toADKeTHHX KOllTiB 6inbul e(jeKTHBHO AUOTpHMyBaTHCb CBO;X npaBOBHX 3o6OB'A3aHb. Ile AO3BOfHno 6 TaKO)K BpaxyBaTH peKoMeHAaItii 303 3a 2001 piK Ta peKoMeHAaLOii IHIUHX Mi2KHapo.AH1X .AOHOPCbKHX opraHli3allir. 10 3eim 3 OljiHKU 3aKyni6ellb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006 piK 3. IHCTHTYIIIHHA CTPYKTYPA I Y11PABJIIHCbKIHI IOTEHIIAJI IHCTHTYIIiUH2 CTPYCTypa JxePXCaBHHX 3alCyniBenIb CTaHOM Ha 6epe3eHb 2006 poicy 22. 4)YHKUIY, HlKi ALenapTaMeHT 3 nHTahH ICoopAHHaUii ),epMaBHHX 3aKyniDeJ6b (IIK3) BHKOHYBaB A° TOMO, 9K HiOro 6yJIO YCYHYTO BiA Tx BHICOHaHHs, 6ynH iJilCOM xapaKTepHHMH 4)yHKUigMH aepWaBHOrO opra3y Ta, B WiJIOMy, Y3rOAKyBBaJIHCb i3 MiWHapoAHoIO npaITHcoJo. ,LAKJ13 BBOAHB B Ailo niA3aKoHHi aKTH, HaAaBaB MeTOAH4Hi peKOMeHAauiI Ta Heo6xiAHy AonoMory pO3nOpLAHHKaM 6o1A)KeTHHX KOUITiB, nOrOJPKyBaB BHKOpHCTaHHS1 HeKOHKypeHTHHX MeToAiB 3aKyniBJ]i, BiAnoBiAaB 3a ny6xiiKauilo iH4opMauiAHo-aHaJniTHMHoro 6ioa1eTeHsl 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBen6 Ta p03rnifAaB cKaprH ymacHHKiB TopriB. HH3KY 4YHKLiHl B rany3i 3aKyniBenb 6yno AeneroBaHo Ha MicueBHi piBeHb YnpaBJ1iHHAIM eKOHOMiKH npH o6nacHHx Jep)KaBHHX aAMiHicTpauiA1x. AepXKaBHe Ka3HalericTBo BiAInoBiAanO 3a nepeBipKy 3BiTiB 3 OLliHKH nponO3HuiM Ha npeAMeT Ha1BHOCTi B HHX TOMHOf i nOBHOI iH¢opMauilf, nepHU HII 3AMiCHIOBaTH BHrLiaTH 3a YKJ1aAeHHMM AorOBopaMH. JAep)KaBHHR KOMiTeT CTaTHCTHKH YKpafHH 36HpaB Ta o6po6miB iH¢opMauito npo aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJii. 23. B pe3yJlbTaTi BBeaeHH9 B AhlO TpbOX 3MiH 1qo 3aKoHy, PO3rJISIHYTHX B nonepeAHbOiMy po3AiJli, BiR6yJnHCb HaCTynHi nepeTBopeHHH: * TeHAepHa nanaTa cTaBJa HeBiA'eMHO1O CKJiaAOBOIO HaCTHHO1O CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJb. * IHCTuTTyuiHHa Ta opraHi3aUiHiHa CTPYKTypa cHcTeMH aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeiIb 3a3Hania AOKOpiHHHX 3MiH i3 PO3nOPOweHH3M nOBHOBa)ceHb Aep)KaBH B raiy3i 3aKyniBejnb rioMi)K pi3HUMU yCTaHOBaMH (AUB. AOjAaTOK 3 Ta 4). * HpHBaTH1H ceKTOP nepe HHfB Ha ce6e neBHi 4yHKUif AepwKaBH, SKi 3a3BH'aM BHKOHylOTb ypRfAoBi opraHH. 24. 13 BBeaeHHNMM B Ah1o 3MiHH AQo 3aKOHy Bij FPYAH%i 2005 poICy, 4YHIUfi AIQ3 6yno flOApi6HeHO Ta nepealHo, y HOpflKAy 3MeHCIeHHSI BarH Ta 3Ha2HMocTi UIHX *yHKllitr, TaBCHM OpraHb3auiglM: * TeHaepHiU nanaTi (HeypgoBi3i opraHi3auii) * CneliianbHiri KOHTpOJ]bHiri KOMiCif npH PaxyHKoBiri naniaTi * PaxyHKoBiri naniaTi * BepXoBHiri Pagi (sKa 3AiACHIoe ,AO TOrO )K 3aranbHHr HarIiHA) * AHTHMOHOnOJTbHOMy KOMiTeTy * LUeHTpaJTbHHM opraHaM BHKOHaBqOI BanaAH, BKjiOioaio4H Ka6iHeT MiHiCTPiB. ,l1HB. AoAaToK 4, B SKoMy CxeMaTH4HO 3o6pa)KeHO 3B'513KH MiM opraHi3aUisMH, IUO BXOAATb AO opraHi3auifflHO CTpyKTYPH CHCTeMH ,Aep2JaBHHX 3aKyniBe.nb nicJSi npHHSaTTS 3MiHH Ao 3aKoHy BiA rpYjH. 2005 POKY. 25. HoMiHaJIbHo yInOBHOBaXCeHHM opraHOM npH3Ha8eHo 3apa3 AHTHMOHonOJIbHHUi KOMiTeT, aAe Aoro (jyHKIIiY o6MrelcylOTbCg 3IIiAcHeHHgM 3arajnbHorO HarafAy 3a 24yHKUiOHyBaHH9M CHCTeMH CepOKSBHHX 3aKyriiBeJlb Ta CKJIaXaHHHNM 3BiTiB. AHTHMOHonojibHHu KOMiTeT Mo)Ke norOAHTH PO3nOPRZAHHKy 6ioa*KeTHHX KOUITiB npOBeAeHHq npoueaypH TOpriB 3 o6MeMCeHo1o y'aCTIo Ta 3aKyniBJn B OAHorO yLiaCHHKa nHwe nicJnS OTPHMaHHh BiAnOBiAHoro nO3HTHBHOrO BHCHOBKY BiA CKK a6o TeHAepHof nanaTHB. Po.b AHTHMoHonoiEHoro KOMiTeTy B npoueci po3rJIslAy cKapr o6Me)xycTbcg peecTpauicio pe3yJlbTaTiB TaKHX p03rnJISiB. 26. 3 ycboro BRAHO, wIo TeHaepHa nana-Ta nepe6pania Ha ce6e IcJloq0oBi *yHKlC"i ALQ3. TeHAepHa nanaTa noroA*pyc PO3fPS1lHHKaM 6toaxeTHHx KOWITiB npoueAypy TOpriB 3 o6MeaceHo1o y'aCT1O Ta 3aKyniBJ]i B OlAHOrO yMaCHHKa, IIy6JiiKyC iH¢opMauiHHo-aHajiiTHtHHA 6loneTeHb Ta Halac BHCHOBKH lUoAO po3rj7xAy cxapr yLaCHHKiB. BOHa TaKO)K p03po6jie MeTroAlHmi MaTepianMH jA pO3nOpXAHHKiB 6Eolo eTHHX KOWTiB, Ha,ae nponO3HUif UOA°O B1AOCKOHaiieHHR HopMaTHBHo-npaBoBHx aKTiB y c4epi ARep*aBHHX 3aKyniBejlb, HaAaC BHCHOBKH IuOAO AIOTpHMaHHS npoiLeAyp 3aMoBHHKoM Ta B3aranIi BHCHOBKH 3 nHTaHb haep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenEb. 11 3eim 3 OZiHKU 3aKyniaeeAb f YKpaini - 2006piK 27. 3r1iAo i3 nojio*eHHISMH 3aioOHy, TeHgepHa nanIaTa mac IopHAHIHuHii cTaryc HeupH6yTKOBOI CniiJlCH rpOMaC1bKCHX opraHi3auiI, sira He MaC nPBas HaA2BsTH 6yAb-suci I1naTHi noc.yru. O4iiUHo MeTobo 4YHKiOHyBaHHA TeHAepHof nafJaTH BH3HaCeHO cnpHAHHS npO3OpOCTi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeilb Ta niABHllteHHA e4eKTHBHOcTi BHTpa4aHHA9 Aep)KaBHHX KOWTiB. OAHaK, npeACTaBHHKH rpOMa8CbKHX opraHi3auiri, IUO BXOARTb Ao cKnaAy TeHAepHof naJIaTHi, HOBiaOMHju 4axiBw.SM EaHKy, llo MeTo1o iX AiSUbHOCTi C HaAaHHS niHTPHMKH KOMeptiriHHM iHTepecaM CBo1x BjnaCHHX LneHiB. TeHAepHa naniaTa Mae ile onpHnlOAHHTH nepeiiiK rpoMaAcbKHX opraHi3auir, LUO BXOAATb A°O i CKnaAy, qoro AOCi He 6ynO 3po6JieHo. KepiBHHLtTBo TeHAepHoi nanaTH Mae TiCHi 3B'A3KH 3 KOHCanTHHrOBHMH cfipMaMH, wo HaAalOTb nocniyrH 3 nflTaHb 3aKyniBeJib i 3 TiClO CAHHOIO KOMnaHiclo, AKy 6yno BH3HaMeHo SK TaKy, Mo BiAnOBi,ae BHMOraM 3aKoHy B 'aCTHHi iH4OpMaLuiHHX CUiCTeM B Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT AnA o6oB'A3KOBoro pO3MitueHHS orolouweHb npo 3aKyniBni. TaKi B3acMO3B'53KIi Aexao niAPHBaBoTb Te3y npo npO3OpicTb i Ao6poqecHicTb "BiAKKpHTOi cHcTeMH. 28. CeueaiabHa IOHTpOnbHa KOMiCig (CKK) c coaeKTHBHHM opraHoM. BoHa Mae y CBOCMY cKiiaii TpbOX npeACTaEHHKiB TeHAepHoY naJIaTH, TpbOX n1peAcTaBHHKiB BepXoBHof PaAU i no OAHOMY npe1cTaaHHKy BiA PaxyHKoBoY nanaTH, AepxKaBHoro Ka3HaqeCiCTBa i KPY. CKK 3 nHTaBHb Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb cTBopeHO npH PaxyHKoBiri nanaTi, oT)Ke ocTaHHA OAHOqaCHO 3AiMCHIOC AK KOHTpOJ1b, TaK i BHKOHaHH Aep)KaBHoro 6ioAKery, ixo npH3BOAHTb AO BHHIKHeHHA cwTyauiY KOH4RiKTy iHTepeCiB. B iHWIHX KpaiHaX KOHTPOJIb 3a ()yHKUioHyBaHH31M CHCTeMU1 Aep)KaBHIiX 3aKyniBeilb AOpyiaETbC3R OAHOMY Aep)KaBHOMy OpraHy - TaKOMy, IRK MiHiCTepCTBO, 411 OKpeMOMy areHTCTBy 3 nHTaHb fAepxaKBHHX 3aKyniBe.nb. 29. AlepKaBHHli HaFrjigA Ta KOHTPOJIb y c4bepi 3aicyniBeib 3AiMCHEOC psw aep2aBHHX opraHiB. 3oKpema, Ka6iHeT MiHiCTpiB, AepYCaBHe Ka3Ma4eHCTBO, Aep)KaBHHri KOMiTeT CTaTHCTHKH YKpaTHH, MiHicTepCrBo arpapHoi noniTHKH Ta opraHH npaBOnOpRAKy. BepXOBHa PaAa KOHTpOlOe AiAJIbHiCTb ynOBHOBEKeHHOro opraHy. 30. Po3UoAiaL IYHKWUR y c4bepi IxepiCaBHHX 3aKyniBeJib MDK TeHAeepHobo na.naioTo, Cneutiambioto KOHTpOJIbHOl0 KOMiCiClC Ta AHTHMoHonoJI6HHM KOMiTeTOM nPH3BOAHTb AO BHUHICNeHHEs cHTyauri KOH4AiKTy iHTepeCiB. rpoMaACbKi o6oB'A3KH TeHAeepHof naniaTH Ta ii pOjib iuojo 3axMcTy KoMepUliuHHx iHTepeCiB CBOiX qneHiB He MOYKyTb A03BOJInT14 i Cfnpl4STtf npO3OpOCTi Ta cnpaBeAnHBocTi y npoLteci AepraBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. BiAnoBiiaajbHicTb PaxyHKOBoY naniaTTi RK BLiugoro ayAjTopa KpaiHH BcTynaC B KOH4JiKT i3 TiClO HOBOO POJMIbO, AKY BoHa BiAirpac y npoueci BHKOHaHHA 6ioApieTy. KpiM Toro, 6e3nocepeAHC 3any4eHHm BepxoBHof PaAti Ao po6OTH BHKoHaBqoY riUKH cynepeqHTb npHHUHrUy p03noAiJy BJAH, npOrOnOUIeHOMY B cTaTri 6 KOHcTlTyuiY YKpaTHH. PexoMeniai4bx > Ha AOnaTOK AO peKOMeHAauiri PO3Ainiy 2, YpRA Mae HerarHo nepernmHyrU opraHi3aLuirHy CTpyKTypy CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHIX 3aKyniBeJIb 3 MeToio YCYHeHHA CUiTyaUiH, LUO CTBOpIOIOTb KOH4IiKT iHTepeciB. Y LUbOMY 3B'93Ky rapHHMH npHKnaAaMH MOC)yTb nOCJIY)'K)HT iHCTHTYL(iUHi CTpYKTYPH KilbKOX HOBUX KpaiH-qJieHiB CC, HanpHKnaA, ECTOHi;, YropluHH Ta HO.nbUi, HaBeAeHi y BcraBUi 1. 12 3eim 3 OZiHKU 3aKyni6eeib e YKpaiHi - 2006 piK BcmasKa 1. OpzaHi3at4iuHa cmpyKmypa cucmemu 6epjica6Iiux 3aKyniejlb 6 Ecmonii; Yzopu4uni ma Hl&UbU4i ECTOHiSi O;ic Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeCb (OJJ3), CTBOpeHHI B 6epe3Hi 1996 pOKy, BiAlnOBiAaC 3a BCi Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBnii 3 KiHUR 2002 0,13 e OKpeMHM JIepcKaBHHM opraHOM, RKHH 6e3nocepeAHbo niAnopRXAKoBaHHA MiHicTepcTBy 4iHaHCiB (MiH4iH). reHepanbHHA JAHpeKTop oc icy npH3Ha4aCTbcR (i 3BiJIbHBCTbCH) MiHiCTpOM ciHaHciB. Alo fYHKXir 0,13 BXOAHTb npOBe,eHHR OLWiHKH tyHKioHyBaHHa cHcTeMH, ni,roToBKa nponO3HiFi iQoLAo nOKpaUIeHHR piBHs po60TH; BrpoBaBJKeHH31 ri BeAeHHH iH¢opMaIIigHHx CHCTeM 3aKyniBejib (peecTp Aep*aBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb); cniBnpatg 3 iHWHIMH KpaiHaMH wJnqxOM o6MiHy aUaHHMH, BKR1OIaIoiH Mi*HapoAHi opraHi3auii, uo e yqaCHHKaMH Mi)KHapoaIHHx yroA; KOHCyJbTyBaHHA 3aMoBHHKiB Ta BHKOHaBUiB ao,o npoLueiyp; Po3rjiAA cKapr ytiaCHHKiB; KOHTpOJIb 3a npoLteAypaMH Aep*KaBHHX 3aXynieJlb; nPHnHHeHHX Aifl AoroBopiB, niIIHHcaHHx i3 nopylWeHHsIM npaBHJI Ta HOpM; iHiuiHOBaHHR AliCUHnniHapHHx po3rJIRAiB npOTH oci6 lH fiepcaBHIux ciiy*6oBuiB, RKi nopyWHJIH 3aKOH; Ta CT,rIHeHHR wTpafiB i3 3aMOBHHIKiB 3a CepAO3Hi nopyuweHHH npoueAyp. OJ13 CKjiaAaCTbCR 3 ABOX AenapraMeHTiB, KO)KHHA1 3 BKHX Mae ABa BiDAiJTN: IH4opMauiAHHHH enapTameHT (BiDaiii aHan;i3y Ta BiJAin peCCTpa1ii) i AenapTaMewT 3 nITaHb ynpaBniHHR (Bi.AiJ] 3 yupaBJ]iHHS Ta BiAAiJ 3 KOHTPOJnO). BijuiJI 3 aHaJIi3y roTyC JiOcn]iAKeHHR, OLIiHioBaHHB Ta Bi,AnoBiJlae 3a 3araj]bHHR MOHiTOpHHr CHCTCMH 3aKyniBeJIb. BiAjain peecTpalIiYi BiJQnOBiAIaC 3a BeAeHHSI eneKTpoHHOro pecCTpy 3aKyniBeJib, BKJnotlaIo'H BBe,AeHHH AiaHHx, nepeBipKy TOMHOCTi iHpopMauiI i TaKe iHwe. BiAAiiJ 3 ynpaBJliHHs BiAllnoBiAaC 3a po3rrsIa cKapr, noJAaHHX jAO 0J3. BiAiJ 3 KOHTpOJIIO 3AUiRCHioc nepeBipKy Aigi 3aMoBHHKiB fWOJO AiOTpHMaHHq npaBHJu 3aKyniBeJ]b. LU OCTaHHR YHKLkiKW e HOBOIO: fi 6ynio AOpy'eHO 0A3 y BepeCHi MHHYnJOFO POKY. YropUrHHa PaAia 3 nHTaHb aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJeb (PA3), CTBOpeHa B 1995 poui, 6e3nocepegHbo IUiA3BiTHa IlapnaMeHTy. BoHa MaC He3aBeNCKHe ynpaBJ]iHHq i AiC B sIKOCTi UeHTpaJIbHoro 6ioJD*CeTHoro opraHy. P,13 Mac y CBOCMY CKiTaAi PajAy, Ap6iTpaIKHHA KOMiTeT Ta CeKpeTapiaT. Paaa Mac CBOrO npe3HAeHTa, a MiCLUi B Hig PO3nOiRiSIOTbCS[ MiYK TpboMa rpynaMH, RKi npeAICTaBBJHlOTb iHTepeCm cycnijlbcTBa, pO3nOpRAHHKiB 6IoAiKeTHHx KOUITiB Ta ygaCHHKiB TOpriB, nO wiCTb npeACTaBHHKiB Bi, KO)KHO; rpynH. 3aKoH npo AepYKaBHi 3aKynisBJi BH3Haqac yMOBH, RKHM MaIOTb BiAInoBiJaTH opraHi3auil, lUO MOYKyTb nPH3HMaxTH CBOIX npeJICTaBHHKiB AO Pa,AH. TaKi npeACTaBHHKH fpH3Ha'alOTbCA npHHariMHi Ha ABa pOKH Ha 6e3oHniaTHig OCHOBi. PaAia o6Hpac npe3HAeHTa Ha nl' Tb pOKiB i3 MO)KJIHBiCTIO nepeBs60piB Ha JipyrHA TCpMiH. PaAa o6HpaC TaKO)K Biue-npe3HfeHTa Ha JABOpiNHHAi TepMiH. AAMiHicTpaTHBHHM opraHOM PaAu, IwO Aonomarac Yl y BHKOHyBaHHi o6oBa'3KiB, e CeKpeTapiaT Pa,AH 3 nHTaHb ACep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBe.9b. CeKpeTapiaT omonroe reHepanbHHri ceKpeTap, a rioro npaiiBHHKH C Aep)KaBHHMH cnymc6OBunMH npu Pa,Ai. Poab P,1A3 BN3HaqeHa nOJ7OKeHHJRMH cTarri 15 3aKOHY npo AepYKaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i, 3riAHo 3 SKHMH PlA3 3AiACHIOC MoHiTopHHr, KOHTPOJIOC BHKOHaHHR 3aKOHY Ta iHiAilOC 3MiHH Jo 3aKoHOAaBcTBa; iac OUiHKY 3aKOHonpoeKTaM npo JIep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJi Ta AiSiJbHOCTi PaJiH; HaAac pCKoMeHAauii UoJio nOKpaLueHHR BHKOHaHHR npaBHJI, BiaCJiliKOByC BHKOHaHHA KOHTpaKTiB tIiOo BiAnOBiAHOCTi nOJiO,KeHHIM 3aKoHy Ta BCTaHOBneHiM KBanifiKaLKiKHHM BHMOraM; Mac 6yTH npICYTHbOlO npH pO3KpHTTi nponO3HUiri, oTpHMaHHX 3aMOBHHKaMH, MO cy6cHAyCTbca 3 A,epKaBHoro 6ioSAKeTy; npH3Haqac i 3BiJIbHHC KepiBHHuTBO Ta iJieHiB Ap6iTpaxKHoro KOMiTeTy, BH3HaqaioqH Nx KiJTEKiCTb; BHHOCHTb Cy,21XeHHR LLJIOA HaRBHOCTI CITyaLiji KOHjN1iKTy iHTepeciB y mUeHiB PaAuH; ny6niKye 6iojleTeHb 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBenb, JAO unoro BXOASITb, 3oKpeMa, oroJiowIeHH3[, piweHHn Ap6iTpaxKHoro KOMiTeTy, peKoMeHAauii tloAo 3acTocyBaHHqs BilnlOBiJIHHx npaBHuI Ta 6yAb-snKi iHwi nOBiAoMJ]eHHx npo aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i; CTBOpIOC CnpHTSTnHBi yMOBH JAnJ rilirOTOBKH i HaBqaHHRf nepCoHaJly, 3ajiyleHoro AO ripoBCeAeHHq 3aKyniBenb; niAJTpHMyC 3B' H3KH 3 opraHamH 3 nHTaHb ICepKaBHHX 3aKyniiBeJb iHWIIX Kpa7H Ta Mi)KHapoAHHMH opraHi3auixMm; 3aTBepCAKye CBO; BHyTpiWHi nono0KeHHSI Ta cKJiaAaC 3BiT npo CBiH piNHHl 6toamceT; Be.e o6AiK AiepYKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb, BKJIo'OatoMH piqHlUH o6cqr 3acTocoBaHHx npolejAyp aep*aBHHX 3aKyniBeJib Ta cnJIa'eHHX UiH; BHKOHYC iHUWi 3aBAaHHS 3riAiHO '*HHOFO 3aKOHoAiaBCTBa. IlOJILWMa O;ic aeCpKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb (O,1A3) nloJblUi CTBOPCHO I Ci'HH 1995 POKy rliCJTA npmHIHTTS 3aKOHY npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBni 10 iepBHS 1994 pOKy Ha OCHOBi MoQejii UeHTpa8jbHHX opraHiB nlOJIbCbKOi aAMiHiCTpaWii. O,1A3 po3po6jIlc CTpaTerilO Ta KOOpRHHYC 4)yHKUioHyBaHHH CHCTeMH aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejib. BiH C OKpeMHM OpraHOM B CTpyKTypi BiaAui. Hpe3'iieHT 0,A3 npH3HaiaeTbcx Ha n'SlTb pOKiB npeM'cp-MiHiCTpoM lOJmbli, RKHl o6upae KaHAHAaTa Ha 3acaAax BiAKpHToro KOHKypCy. PJ iHwIHX opraHiB AOnOBHIOC Ai.RJbHiCTb 0,A3 LOAiO 3AiACHeHHSI KOHTpOJIO Ui HaBJaHHA 2iOnOMOrH B rany3i AepxKaBHHx 3aKyniBejib. HarlBaroMiwHMm cepe,A HHX c PaAa 3 niTaHb ACp)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJmb, ap6iTpaNiHi Ta HarJisgoBi opraHH. PaAa 3 rIHTaHb Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenib e KOHCyJIbTaTHBHHM U JiopamJmm opraHom npH npe3nAeHTi 0,A3, JKHi npH3Haiac qineHiB luie PaAu. OCHOBHHMH 060B'3I3KaMH 0A3 C BHnYCK O(0)iUiriHoro 6ioniereHn 3 nHTaHb Aep)KaBHHX 3aKynliBeJIb, B SKOMY ny6JliKyloTbC.q noBiLoMjieHHR npo 3aKyniBJli (BapTiCTb RKHX nepeBHuUyC Me)Ky, BCTaHOBJIeHy B 3aKoHi nlpO AepmCaBHi 3aKyniBni); nilrOTOBKa 3aKoHonpoeKTiB y c()epi ACpxcaBHHX 3aKyniBeJb; npHrIHqTrR piwleHb IcOAO MO)KJIHBOCTi BHKOpHCTaHHA npoueAypH, iHLWif, HiYK BiAKpHTi TOprU a6o TOprU 3 o6MexceHoto y4acTIo; PO3rJlRA aneaiAwiii 3riJiHO 3 3aKoHoM npo AeppKaBHi 3aKyniBJ]i; nepeBipKa npaBHJ]bHOCTi npoBeCJeHHS npotieayp; niAroToBKa HaBqanbHHX iTporpam y cfepi AepmicaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb, opraHi3auia i npoBeAieHHn HaB'iaHHh. ,ThKepeno: 3BiTH "CirMUi", qepBeHb 2003 pocy. 13 3eim 3 O?iHKU 3aKyniaeeb e YKpalni - 2006piK 4DyHKUii y c4iepi AepiCaBHHX 3aKyniBeCii y CTHCJi TepMiHH nepeJaHo npHBaTHOMY ceKiropy 31. Iic.iCsI BBeJeSHHR B JAilO BHWe3raAaHHX 3MiH Jo 3aKoHy AeKLIbIca B3aCMOHOB sl3aHHX IPHBaTHHX opraHi3aIUili OTpuMaln HIOMiHyIO'ie nojio2eeHHR y c4epi AepwaBHHX 3aEcyniBelBb. IeHTP TeHAePHHx npoueAyp i nraHyBaHHs 6i3Hecy, LIO Mae CTaTYC HeypRAoBoi opraHi3auil, C 3aCHOBHHKOM TemvepHoIf nanaTH Ta O4iUiHHM BnaCHHKOM naTeHTiB Ta aBTOpCbKHX npaB Ha 'UCJeHHi 3pa3KI TeHAepHOY AOKyMeHTauii H MeToAojiorit. 3apeecTpoBaHe niA Ha3BOIO "LteHTp TeHAePHHX npoueAyp" niAnPHCMCTBO MKTHBHO 3aUMaeTbCs "HaAaHHAM nopai" 3aMOBHHKaM Ta y'4aCHHKaM TopriB LUOAO nHTaHb Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeelb 4epe3 Mepe)Ky iHAHBiAyanbHHX KOHCynbTaHTiB. PeecTpalirHi AOKyMeHTH cBiAqaTm, U1O Ti IK caMi oco6H e IqH 6yInH 3aCHOBHHKaMH Ta KepiBHHKaMH i TeHAepHoiY nanaTH, i [teHTpy TeHAepHHx npoueeAyp Ta nnaHyBaHHA 6i3Hecy (HYO), i LeHTpy TeHAepHHX npoueAyp (niAnpleMcTa), i CBponercbKoro KOHCaJITHHrOBOrO areHTCTBa (KoHcyaITaLiiHHof 4ipMH), i iHuIHX nOB'I3aHHx i3 HHMH IOPH,AHqHHX cy6'cKTiB. rlpeAcTaBHHKH HpHBaTHOrO ceKTopa CKap2KHniHcb niA Mac npOBeAeHHX i3 HHMH o6roBopeHb Ha HeraTHBHHH BnnIHB AiREbHOCTi LUHX HPHBaTHHX yCTaHOB Ha BiAKpHTe Ta qecHe fyHKUiOHyBaHHR CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. 32. HpoTaroM 2003-2004 pOKiB 1leHTp TeHJepHHX npoueAyp Ta nOB'5s3aHi i3 HUM Heyp$]AOBi opraHi3awi cnpomorinuc OTPHMaTH "HSaTeHTH" Ta "aBTOpCbKi npasa" Ha 3P23KH CTaHIApTHHX TeHIepHnX AoicyMeHTiB Ta HOCiOHHIKH 3 HHTaH6 AepxcaBuHx 3MKyniBeJb. Lie B3arani He BiAlnoBiAac HiJKHM HOpMaM, OCKinEKH B yCiX iHHUIHX KpalHax TaKi AOKyMeHTH 6e3KoulToBHo pO3nOBC[O)IxyloTbCSI neBHHM Aep)KaBHHM OpraHoM. TaKa nocnyra, 3a3BHqai, BBa)KaCTbCS HeBiA'£MHoto 4aCTHHOO 4yHKYil HaAaHHs AOnOMOrH PO3nOpHIHHKaM 610oRxeTHHX KOWTiB. Biubw Toro, norin46neHIH aHani3 3axHLUeHoY aBTOpCbKHMH npaBamH TeHAepHOi AOKyMeHTauiY LTrl CBiAtIHTb npo r, MaarKe iaeHTHtHiCTb cTaHAapTHii TeHAepHiri AOKyMeHTaLui CBiToBoro 6aHKy, a AeMKi H p03AiRIH, 4)aKTHqHO, C BiABepTHM nepeKJlagoM. 33. 3a uiATpHMICH KiCJIbKOX BHCOKHX noca,oBuiB IteHTp TeHIRepHHX npoueAyp sBHO FPHMYCHB PO3nOpSlAHUKiB AepKaBHHX KCOllTiB BHICOpHCTOBYB8TU 3a niiaTy CBOi 3afaTeHTOBaHi joKoyMeHTH. DaxiBLti B)aHKy OTPHManH Konif npHHarMHi MOTHpbOX nHCTiB, Wo niaTBepA)KylOTb LteR 4aKT, a TaKO:K Korni AorOBOpiB, nianHcaHHX LUeHTpOM a6o Roro napTHepaMH, i3 SKHX BH,AHO, Ha RKHX YMOBaX 3)irCHIOIOTbCS npoueAyPH 3aKyniBenb. B 6inbmocTi BHnaAKiB KOHCyJIbTaHTH LeHTpy AonoMaraFoTb npOBOAHTH 3aKyniBJ]i. 3a OTPHMaHoio iH4)opMaLeio LUeHTp norpo)KyC 3BepHeHHAMI4 AO CyAy, AKLO PO3nOpRAHHKH 6to cKeTHHX KOIUTiB BHKOpHCTOBYBaTHMyTb 3anaTeHTOBaHy CTraHaPTHY TeHAepHy AoKyMeHTaLuio, He cniiatyioqH 3a ue. 34. 3a OTPUMaHOIO i4lpopMaCieco, tleHTp TeHAePHUX npotle,yp a6o KOHCyJIbTaHTH, u1o npaUIOIOTb ua nboro, HoBiAOMJnsIOTb nOTeHUiUUHHX y4aCHHKiB npO Heo6xiAHicTb KOPUCTYBaTTHCS nocJIyraMH lteHTpy, uio6 6paTH Y'ICT6 B TeHhlepax. YLiaCHHKaM, aKi nOroA)KYEOTbCAI KOpHCTYBaTHCS nocniyramH [teHTpy, BHcTaBJIACTbCg paXyHOK 3a "lOpAHw4HUH cynpoBiA", AKHH HacnpaBAi He 3AMiCHiouTbcS. KpiM niiaTH 3a 3anaTeHTOBaHy TeHAePHY AOKyMeHTauilo, nepemoKetb TopriB Mac CnHiaTHTH UeHTpy BiACOTOK BiA BapToCTi yKnaAeHOro AOrOBOpy. Ui BHTPaTH AOAatOTbCSI Ao CYMH KOHTpaKTy i nepeKJiaAaioTbCS ymaCHHKaMH TopriB Ha nOKynHU, To6TO Ha 61oApKeT, CnpHqHHAHOLI4U A0 Hee4)eKTHBHorO BHKOPHCTaHHSI Aep)KaBHHX KOIUTiB. Heo6xiaHicTb HaAaTH TeHAepHe 3a6e3ne'eHHAs (Wo Mae BHrnAA 3o6OB'S!3aHHS KoMepIIiHHoro 6aHKy BiAKPHTH KpeAHT y'aCHHKy TopriB 3a neBHHX YMOB Ta niA JIiKBiAHy 3acTaBy) TaKOw cTano 3aco6oM AicTaBaTH rpoLui. Konti [eHTp 3ajlytieHO Ao npOBeAeHHA TOpriB pO3lOpSlAHHKa 6ioxpeTHUHX KOUTiB, TO BiH yCiJIAKO ycKJIaAHioc npouec oTpHMaHHS yMaCHHKOM TeHAepHorO 3a6e3neMeHHR BiA 6aHKy, ge BiH o6c.myroByCTbc3[, Hanosiqraio'a4 Ha oTpHMaHHi AOKyMeHTiB, mKi 6inbuwicTb KpeAHTHHX YCTaHOB HaBpRA 41H HaAaAyTb CBOCMY KniCHTOBi. I TOAi y34aCHHKH TopriB MalOTb 3BepTaTHCS 3a o6oB '33KOBHM "TeHAepHHM 3a6e3ne'eHHAM" Ao 6aHKy TK-KpegwT, AKHr BHAae "3060BoSl3aHHs", I1O He MaIOTb nO3OBHOf cHAN i He 3aXHlUeHi aKTHBaMH. 35. Tort, XTO 6aiaKac no36yTHCI Heo6XiaiAHOCTi nipHkMaTH Y3aCTb B 3SKyUiBJIRX Ha YCT2JieHHX Ha npaiKTHUi CYMHiBHHX 3aCahaX, H2Bp8IA 'IN 3MO2Ke 3aRTH niATpHMICY B HOBiN iH4OpMaMiHIHiU CUCTeMi OHpUJlIlOAHeHHu iH41OpMaufl. y6niKauiA iH4)opMail npo 3aKyniBJIi B Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT C 3apa3 o6oB'A3KOBO1O (cTaT-rA 4-1). CBponeUcbKe KOHcaJITHHroBe areHTCTBO (CKA), KOMnaHiA, acOiuiroBaHa i3 LAeHTpoM TeHAepHHX npoLeAyp, c BnaCHHKOM IHTepHeT nopTaily, Ae pO3MiUlY£TbCS LUA iH4)opMauiA. FlepW Hi)K 3Ao6yTH AocTyn Ao "6e3KOWuTOBHoro" pO3MilueHHS iH4)OpMaUif B 14 3fim 3 OZjiHKU 3aKyni6eeb a YKpaiHi - 2006piK "cepTHUjiKoBaHirV' CHCTeMi IHTepHeT, pO3nOp3lAHMKH 6ioaweTHHX KOWTiB 3My7UeHi yKnaCTH AoroBip Ha oTpHMaHH.9 HHMH II1HPOKOrO KoJ1a nocniyr. LJS BHMOra raIbMye npOBeAeHH5I Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejTb, OCKiJTbKH nuHtWe He3HaqHa KiJ1bKiCTb pO3nopSRAHHKiB 6ioXKeTHHx KOlITiB Mae 3MOry cniaMyBaTH TaKHM 4HHOM 3a ny6niKauiio nOBiAOMjieHb. 36. IleBHi 3MiHeHi nojioce"HH 3aCoHy niaiKpinfjlOlOTb TalKy cHcTeMy. OT2Ke, sAKMuO PO3nOpRDlHHKH 6ioceTHHX KOlUTiB XOYTb 3AiMCHIoBaTH Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBni 3riHO i3 3aKOHOM, TO BOHU MajOTb HeCTH BiAnOBiAHi AoAaTKOBi BHTPaTi4, He MaiO'H npuH ubOMy aOJIaTKOBHX 6ioAKeTHI4x npH3HaqeHb. TaKHM MHHOM, 3aMOBHHKH 3MyineHi BH6HpaTH MH npOBOAUTH 3aKyniBni nO3a paMKaMH 3aKOHY tH 3OBCiM iX He npOBOAHTH. PeKoMendaLiif > CHTyauiio i3 y3AlTrxM CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejEb ni, KOHTPOJIb npHBaTHOrO CeKTOpy noTpi6Ho HerariHo 3MiHHTH. > Henwo,a=Hi cnpo6H AHTHMOHOnOJIbHorO KOMiTeTy 3yn'HHHTh 3ROB)KHBaHHAl CBponeRCbKOrO KOHCanTHHroBOrO areHTCTBa CBO;M MOHOnOjibHHM cTaHOBHweM c nO3HTHBHHMH RiAMH, npoTe KoMiTe-r Mae 3'ASCyBaTH, 51Ki iue iHlUi riiAnpHCMcTBa HPHBaTHOrO ceKTopy o6Me)KyloTm KOHKypeHLio B rainy3i Jep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. > PO3nIOP5IAHHKH 6ioAPKeTHHX KOUTiB He IlOBHHHi BHKOpHCTOB'YBaTH KOHCyJIbTaUiiiHi KoMIIaHiY B 5TKOCTi nocepeAHHKiB. BOHH He nOBHHHi TaKO)K CnpS1TUH PO3ROBc0oaxeHHIO CTaHAapTHoi TeH,AepHoi AOKyMeHTaiUi, 3anponOHoBaHoY KOMepuiriHHMH CTPYKTypaMH a6o a4JiniiOBaHHMH, acouiROBaHHMH 44 AKHMOCb iHWIHM 'HHOM ROB' 53aHHMm i3 HUMH cy6'CKTaMH. > YnoBHoBalKeHlH opraH Mae niAroTyBaTH KOMnneKT Ha6nbEw ylKHBaHOi cTaHDapTHoY TeHDepHOY AOKyMeHTaUif Ta PO3MiCTHTH AorO Ha Be6-caulTi i3 6e3KourrOBHHM AOCTynoM. 3o6oB' s3aTH PO3nOPSIDHHKiB 6ioApKeTH4X KOlIITiB BHKOPHCTOBYBaTH came u1i 2OKyMeHTH. > 5AKuRo 3anaTeHTOBaHi IleHTpOM TeHAePHHX npoueAyp TeH,AepHi AOKyMeHTH, 4OpMH Ta noci6HHKH e iACeHTIHHHMH cTaHAapTHiA TeHAepHiH aOKyMeHTauiY CBiToBoro 6aHKy a6o iHUIHM AoKyMeHTaM, Bi,QKpHTHM AAR 3aranJbHOrO KOpHcTyBaHHR, TO yCi TaKi aBTOpCbKi npaBa 'ii naTeHTH MalOTb 6yTU aHyJIbOBaHi. OcTaHHiA pO3BHTOK nOAiA BKa3YC Ha Te, Luo no4HHae PO3rnJs5AaTHC51 npo6leMa ,ae3iKHX HaN6ijibiu HenpUHrH.THHX acneKTiB OpraHi3auirlHOY CTpYKTypUH CHCTeMH aepx(aBHIX 3aKyniBenb. Ho-nepuie, oco6H, nOB' sl3aHi i3 KOMepUiAHHMH cTpyKTypaMU (npo IUo AmIocsq BHuAe), 3anH JIwHnH ni, iac OCTaHHbOro 3"'3Ay cBoi noca,DH y npaBJliHHi TeHJeepHoi nanaTH. HarnIsuAOBa paAa TeHAepHof nanaTH cKnaAacT6cs 3apa3 nHwLe i3 DenyTaTiB BepXoBHOY PaaH. Pa3oM 3 THM, DIXJbHICTb HeypSxaoBoY OpraHi3auif, LUO Ha3HBaETbCA He3aJle)KHOIO, KOHTPOJIIOCTbC1 rpe,ACTaBHHKxMH BepXoBHof PauH, JIKi i pOrOJIOCYBaiH 3a DoAy'IeHH31 uic'i opraHi3auiY Ao CHCTeMi RepwaKBHHX 3aKyniBenb. Y BepeCHi 2006 POKY npeM'ep-MiHicTp AOPYMqHB Ta ynOBHOBaBKHB Ka6iHeT MiHiCTpiB BDOCKOHaRHTHc CrCTeMy Rep*KaBHHX 3aKyniBellb. Biue- npeM'ep-MiHicTp riOBiAOMMB, iuo Ka6iHeT 3aTBepAHB 3aKOHonpoeKT npo Aep*aBHi 3aKyniB.li, XKHM "pyHHyeTbc51 a6conIoTHa BnaJaa TeHRepHOY' nanaTH Ta Henpo30pa CHCTeMa, CTBOpeHa niinpIHCMJIHBHMH 'iJeHaMH BepxoBHOY PaDH MHHyJnOrO CKnIHKaHHq". CrliKep n1iAnlH4CaB (29 BepeCH51 2006 pOKy) Po3nopAsIAxeHH5A npO CTBOpeHH51 po600qo r-pynlH 3 po3po6KH 3aKOHonpoeKTY npo ReplKaBHi 3aKyniBJli i3 3a8jyqeHH51M yCiX 3auiKasBjeHHX CTOpiH. OpiCHTaUiSl Ta iHTerpaLiS 3aKyniBeJuL go CHCTeMn gepxIaBHoro yupaBJ]iHHH 37. llriaHyBaHHH 3alCyfliBejib Ta CKxJaaHHM KO[WTOpHCY C iHTerpoea8olo qaCTHHOIO nlpouecy 4OpMyYaHH$i Ta BHKOHaHHH 6loaKeTy. BiAnoBiAzHO AO BioAKeTHorO KOAeKCy 6ioA2KeTHa CHCTeMa YKpaMHH CKJ1aa1CTbCA1 3 Aep*aBHoro 6ioDKeTy, SIKHU npHiMaeTbcS1 BepXOBHoio Pagoio Ha 11opiqHiU OCHOBi (3i 3MiHaMH, I11O BiA6yBaTOTbCAI nlpOTSTrOM 4)iHaHCOBoro pOKy), i MiCieBHx 61iO*eTiB, SnKi TaK came lIUOpiHO 3aTBepD)Ky1OTbC51 opr-aHaMH MicueBoro CaMOBp5AyBaHHA. P03nOpSIOAHHK4 6ioaKeTHHX KOUITiB, a6o 3aMOBHHKH CKJnaDaaOTb KOlUTOpUCH BHTpaT Ha TOBapH, po6OTH Ta nocnlyru, SlKi BOHH noTpe6yBaTHMyTb npoTSTrOM HacTyiHOrO 4 iHaHCOBoro poKy. BiAlHOBiDaJlbHi 3a 6iOAKeTHH i npouec BHKOpHCTOByIOTb 3rOAOM ui npOrHO3H JUlJ BH3HaqeHHSI npiopHTeTiB Ta npHriH51Tr51 piieHEb uOAO p03no,aiJiy ,epKaBHHX KOlUITiB MilK p03nopA1DHtlKaMi. 15 3eim 3 OyliKU 3aKynifeeIb 6 YKpafiti - 2006piK 38. ICHyc ABa THUH pO3nOpsiJHICiB 6roAueTHHx ICOUlTiB: roJIOBHi PO3UOPRAHHICH Ta PO3flOPSIWHIcH HH2WIOrO piBHR. rOnaOBHHHi pO3nOPSAHHK 6io=ceTHHx KOlUITiB pO3pO6JIRe nnaH 3axoAiB Ta t1POrHO3yC BHTpaTH Ha IX BnpoBa=KeHHM. Ha OCHOBi ui4X nonepelHix OLIiHOK PO3nopRDHHK noAae 6ioaKeTHHri 3anHT Ao MiHicTepcTBa 4iHaHciB (ARA AepxKaBHoro 61ogxeTy) q4 Micu.eBoro (iHaHcoBOro ynpaBniHHA (ARA MiCLeBHx 61oAIKeTiB). rOflOBHHri pO3nOpAAHHK OTpHMYC 3rOAOM 610)ieTHi nPH3HaqeHHS 3 Aep)KaBHoro qH MiCLIeBHx 6toA)KeTiB, 3aTBepAIKeHHX BiAnoBiAHlHMH 3aKoHioAaBqtiMH opraHaMli. Flicji L.borO BiH noainum KOlUTH 3 ypaxyBaHHAM CBONX BnaCHHX noTpe6 i noTpe6 PO3nopSAHHKiB HH4Kqoro piBHs. TaKtH Po3noAin KOLITiB 6a3yCTbcsu Ha noqaTKOBOMy nnaHi 3axoaiB, neperniiHyToMy i3 ypaxyBaHHAM HaBBHHx acHrHyBaHb. OcTaHHi 3MiHH Ao 3aKOHy (BiA 2005 poKy) BAOCKOHaiHAiH iteri npouec 3anpOBaBlKeHHRM BUMOrP I1oAO o6oB'su3KoBoro OnpHjilOLHeHHR ycima PO3nOPJWHHKaMH 6uoAweTH1x KOIUTiB CBOIX pi4HHX nnaHiB 3aKyniBeb npHOTSrOM OAHOrO MiCSIW nicnJ 3aTBepAmKe4HHR 6io0pKeTy. 39. llpoBeAe,He 6yRiBeabHnx po6UT qaCTO BHMarac ntaCHYBHHS1 3aicyHiBeBJ1b Ha AcidCiCiJca poaiB. BHAaTKH Ha 4iHaHcyBaHHS ToBapiB Ta nocnyr 3a3BIqag nflaHY1OTbCR Ha OAHH 6xoiweTHHri piK (AKUHr CniBnaAae i3 KaJieHAapHHM), 3a BHHSITKOM cneuiaJlbHHx Aep)KaBHHx nporpaM. Ue noninumno npouec, OCKiRbKH nnaHyBaHHS 3aKyniBenbe, SK inpaBsuO, o6Me)KyBanocR CTBOpeHHAM nepeniKy 3aKyniBeflb Ta KOUITOpHCY BHTpaT 6e3 Hane)KHoI yBarm AO TepMiHiB, naKeTyBaHHA, MeTOAiB 3aKyniBeJlb, KaneHAapHHx rpa4)iKiB Ta HaBiTb ypaXyBaHHS B3acMO3a8Je)KH1X 3aKyniBeJlb. JRA BHpiwIeHHAI Uid; npofi.neMH Heo6xiIHO BHeCTU 3MiHH ARO OCHOBHUX HOpMaTHBHHX aKTiB, iKi peryjnlOoTb 4YHKWOHYBaHHS 6to;pKeTHoif CHCTeMH YKpaiHH. 40. He3Bawialo4H Ha HaSSBHiCTb y3roAMeHoro piqHoro 6rommeTy Ta noJinlDeIHH9 CHTyaUii nporHo3OBaHocTi i3 BHALieHHgM ICOIITiB, CHCTeMa Bce 1ue Mac neBHi HeaOjilCH. -IHCJIeHHi OnHTyBaHHS cBiAJaTb 6npo OCi HeperyJI3pHe BH,ineHHR KOWIITiB Ha BHKOHaHHR OOBipHHx 3o6OB's3aHb. BHacniAoK uboro, cnnaTa Ta TOBapH, po6oTH Ta nocnyrH qaCTO 3aTpHMyeTbcR, Uao rOBOPHTb npo Te, io npo6neMH i3 naHKyBaHHAM 3aKynineslb, npo SKi HiLinOCSl B nonepeAHbomy 3BiTi 3 OUiHKH 3aKyniBeJb (2001 p.), xoTenep 3aIHIIIaIOTbCA HeBHpitueHHMH. 41. floMiqeHo, IQO noAekyaH PO3HOPSIAHHEH 6ioawceTHHx ICOWTiB OTpHMY1OTb AOCTYn ATO *piHaHCyBanHR nH4e B JIHcTonaai-rpyuHi, - To6TO HaNpHICiHU 4liHaHcoBoro poucy. 3a TaKHX yMOB iM noTpi6Ho UIBIIKKO BUKOpHcTaTH KOIIITH, ULo nO3HaqaCTbcJl Ha npHHLtHini HeYXHJ1bHOrO AoTpHMaHHA npoueAyp. BH6ip MCTOAiB 3aKyniBJli o6Me*ycTbcA 6paKoM qacy, Heo6xiAHoro ARA npOBeXeHHsA BiJKPRTHX TopriB. 5IKUO pO3nIIOpUHHK He OTpHMyc noroLAKeHHR Ha 3acToCyBaHHA MeHlu KOHKypeHTHHX npoueAyp (BiAcyTHicTb qacy e cJia6KHM MOTHByBaHHAM), TO BiH BTpa4aC TaKe 3ani3HO OTPHMaHe 4iHaHcyBaHsI. 42. B3acMo3B'931H MDi niiaHyBaHHsM 3axyniBeCb, 1J1BHyB2HHUM 6uoameTy, 63ioA%eTHHMH 1Hp3Ha-eHHSMH Ta 4IaITHqHHM BHRiJieHHsIM IOWTiB Heo6xiAuo nOCHniUHT. raJly3eBi MiHicTepCTBa Ta iHWli PO3HOpR2;HHKH 6ioA)KeTHHX KOllTiB BxKe y cepnHi-BepeCHi MalOTb nOAaTH 6iopxeTHi 3alnHTH Ta nnJaIHH 3aKyniBeJIb ToBapiB, po6iT Ta nocnyr Ha HaCTynHHri piK. LeTanmbHe rtaHyBaHHA Ta npoUeAypH 3aKyniBeib pO3nOqHHatOThCA JiHule niCJIS 3aTBepALKeHHA BepXoBHolo PaAouo Aep)KaBHoro 6toAxleTy, uo 4aKTHNHO BiA6yBaemcA B rpyAHi. He3BalKaioqH Ha 3aBqaCHO nipOBeCeHe nAiaHyBaHHH, MOlKJIHBiCTb noMiCIqHoro BHAiiieHHR KOUJTiB B nOBHOMY o6cA3i Ta BqacHO o6Me)KyeTbcR HeAoCTaTHiM o6cxroM AoxOAiB Ta qacToio 3MiHowo npiopHTeTiB. Pe3ynbTaToM C 3aTpHMKa i3 BHKOHaHHAM rpa43iKy 3aKyniBeJiE Ta BHHHKHeHHS cHTyauii, npo SKy ri4mOCA B nonepeAHboMy a63aui. PexoMeniaqu > YpaA Mae Po3rnsHYTH MO)KIHBiCTb 3aCTOCyBaHHA Tpl4piqHoro nOHOBJlOBanbHOrO lraHy 61oAieTHHx npH3HaqeHb, B SKOMy aCHrHyBaHHA Ha HacTynHHHi piK 3aTBepAJKyfOTbCS B )KOBTHi- JIHcTona,i i3 OAHoqaCHHM nonepeAHiM nepeA6aqeHHAM neBHHX KOWTiB Ha ABa HacTynHHX pOKH. ToAi MO)KHa 6yno 6 3AirCHtOBaTM 3aKyniBni niA AOBroTpHBaJii AOrOBOpH, 3OKpeMa, Ha BI4KOHaHHA 6yaiBejlbHHx po6iT. KpiM TOro, B 3anpoUweHHi A1O yqacTi B Toprax Mae MiCTHTtiCA iH4IopMaUiA wOAO nCBHOrO 610oxeTHorO 3060B'su3aHHA. Ue Aauo 6 3Mory nOTeHUir4HHM niaipAJHHKaM iAeHTH43iKyBaTH JA)Kepejio iHaHCyBaHHA Ta BiAnOBiAHi nocTaTe Hi npH3HaMeHHX, 3aoxoqy0oqH TaKHM qHHOM AO KoHKypeHULii. 16 3fim 3 OUliHKU 3aKyniaee1b 6 YKpatHi - 2006piK Po36Y11OBa iHCTHTyUIIHOrO DOTeHWiaJY PO3IOPSSIHHICiB 6ioJlxceTHHX KOUITiB 43. CHCTeMa )ep7caBHHX 3aKyniBeJb C IlOBHiCTIO aetxeHTpaJli30BaHO1O, i P03O3P1pHWHKH BCIX piBHiB BiRUlOBiaRlOTb 3a 31[ifiICHeHH5 BHRaTKiB 3rUiHO i3 3aKOHOM. KO7KHHA PO3nOHpAHHK 6ioAi7KeTHHx KOWITiB CTBOP[OC TeHAepHHA KOMiTeT, u10 cKJla1aCTbc.9, npHHariMHi, 3 n'SITH tiieHiB, BKJ1iO'iaOqH ceKpeTapsI. Xo4a PO3nOpsi1HHKH 6io0*eTHHX KOWITiB MaBOTb npaBo CTBOpiOBaTH CTiJIbKH TeH1ePHHX KoMiTeTiB, CKiJIbKH iM noTpi6HO, BOHH, 3a3BHMaH, o6Me*yIoTbC9 O11HHM nOCTiHHO Ai04Mm TeH1AePHHM KOMiTeTOM y CKiaaI n SITH a6o 6inbuie oci6. 31K npaBHuIo, roInOBOto KoMiTeTy e nepWHri 3aCTYIIHHK KepiBHHKa opraHi3auii, a iHUIHMH umeHaMH - npeACTaBHHKH IopMHAHHoro, eKOHOMi'Horo, 4)iHaHC0Boro Ta rocnoAapqoro BiUAiJiB. CeKpeTap KOMiTeTy 3a3BHM4a c npeACTaBHHKOM rocno11ap4oro 4H I$iHaHCOBoro BiALiLIy. 1iA qac nPOBe,1eHH.R CKJia1HHX Lim cneuiani3OBaHHx 3aKyniBeJIb MO)KHaao 1ya04TH Ha ,0onoMory eKCnepTiB Ta KOHCyJIETaHTiB Ha aoroBipHHX 3acafAax. repex6a'aecTbCx, iuo KO*KHHi q'ieH TeHAepHorO KOMiTeTy HpOXO1HTb ABOTH*KHeBHA KYPC HaBqaHHH npoTiroM 1uecTH MiCSiIiB BiA noiqaTKy CBOCI po6OTH B KOMiTeTi. 44. He3BaicaIo04 Ha Te, uo MamarKe ICOIKHHU BeJ1HKCHi pO33OpHRHHK 6ioJPIeTHHX KOUTiB MaC rocno,aap-Mfl BiPAiJ, pOJ1b ui6oro OCT3HHbOrO o6MeKycTbCS UnH3HaleHHSIM OjuHoro npeaCJTSBHHKa AO TeHhepHOrO KOMiTeTy. npaUiBHHKH, nIpH3HaMeHi AO cKJiaBy TeH1epHHX KOMiTeTiB, BHKOHY1OTb A1opy'leHi IM 4yHKUiI Ha RoAaTOK 1O CBO;X 3B1ar4HHx 060B'Si3KiB. ria iac 3yCTpitieH 4)aXiBUiB BaHKy i3 npeACTaBHHKaMH npHBaTHOro CeKTOpy 6ynio cKa3aHo, 11o icHyBaHHAI noCTiHHo 1ilO1HX TeHAePHHX KOMiTeTiB 36inbiuIye MOUKnHBiCTb BHHHKHeHHA 3MOBH, KOpynUif, He3aKOHHiix AOMOBjieHOCTeA Ta KOHmJiiKTy iHTepeciB, xoqa Ha UbOMY I He HarojiOlUyBajiocq hIK Ha nIIouHpeHOMY JIBHUMi. PeKoMeendat4if > BeCJHKi 3a KiJnbKiCTio npauiBHHKiB YCTaHOBH (TaKi S1K MiHicTepcTBa, MiCbKi Ta o6JiacHi aaMiHicTpa4iY TOiUO) ManH 6 OTPMHaTH 3aoxO4eHHsM 1o peopraHi3aLiY CBOCY rocnoAapcbKOYf Ai35JlbHOCTi 3 MeTolo CTBOpeHH.R BHYTPiUIHiX MOKJIHBOcTeA ynpaBniiHHsl 3aKyniBilAMH. LUboro MO)KHa 0oc1rT7H WJIsXOM npH3HameHH.R a1MiHicTpaTHBHoro, cjiHaHCoBoro su rocnoaapcbKoro aenapTameHTY BiQnOBiRaJbHHM 3a npOBeAeHHSI 3aKyniBenib. TaKHr fenapTaMeHT CTBOPIOBaB 6H TeHAepHi KOMiTCTH (1HB. 1aJli), rOTyBaB TeHAePHY AOKyMeHTaLiio, noAaBa BBorOBOPH Ha niAnHC Ta CynpOBOA*yBaB 6u BHKOHaHHSH 11oroBOpiB pa3oM i3 KiHLeBHMH CnO)KHBa'aMH. JgenapTaMeHTy, U1O BHKOHYC TaKy 4YHK4WO, Heo6xi11Ho MaTH KBaiii)iKOBaHHX Ta nCBHHM 4HHOM aTeCTOBaHHX 4axiBLiB. > CneuiabHHri TeHAepHHA KOMiTeT y cKJia1i Ao n'SITH 'UeHiB (KOKHHHl 3 SiKHX oaep*ye o6oB'af3KoBe HaBgaHHA) Heo6xiAiHo 4DopMyBaTH A1sA UpOBeaeHHS1 KOKHOY OKpeMO; 3aKyniBJli. JtO cKJiaBy TaKorO KOMiTeTy BXOAHTHMYTb (faxiBeub i3 3aKyniBeJIb, TexHitIHHHi cneixiaJiicT 4s iH*KeHep 3 BiAnOBi11HHM 4axOM, cneuiaJ1iCT 3 nUiTaHb fiHaHciB, eKOHOMiKH a6o o6niKy Ta npeACTaBHHK 3 BiAliJly KiHueBoro CnOX(HBa'a. JAeS1KHX tiJeHiB TeHAepHOrO KOMiTeTy 3aMiHBIoTE iHIUHMU B 3anieKHOCTi Bi1 npeAmeTy 3aKyniBenb. 45. 'RITHaliURTb 3aKJl2AiB MalOTb JIileH3ii MiHiCTepcTBa OCBiTH Ha NPOBe1eHHR HaBtaJlbHOI niarOTOBsKH 3 HHTaHb aepasBHHX 3aicyniiBeib, a T8KOW 3aTBepaweHy MiHiCTCPCTBOM CeCOHOMiKH y46oBy nporpaMy i nepeJiiK BHK.sa,4aqiB. Ha npaKTHili 6iJxbua KiJbKiCTb cJlyXatiB, o6Me*eHa r1peACTaBHHKaMH TeH1AePHHX KOMiTeTiB, npowulla HaBtianbHHA KYpC B 4OTHpbOX 3 n SlTHag11UTH cepTH4iKoBaHHx 3aKJ1aaiB. B3arani, lUiCTb ym6oBHX LIeHTpiB 3HaXO1A51TbCSI B KHeBi, a peWiTa - B iHWUHX MiCTax. BOHH iCHyIoTb a6o npH Bi.OMHX yHiBepcHTeTax, a6o npH perioHanbHHX 4Diniaix AKaAeMiY 1ep)KaBHoro ynpaBniHHM . Cnyxati oCep2ICYOTb cepTHmiKaTH Ta HaaalOTb Ao MiHicTepCTBa CBOi0 OLIiHKy SAKOCTi HaB4aHH3[. KiibKiCTb Aep*KaBHHX cjiyK6oBL[iB, 11o 3aKiHtHJH ABOTHWKHeBi KypCH , 3pocn1a 3 86 y 2002 pOLli 1o 3456 B 2003 ri 5489 B 2004 poKax. YKpaYHa BXOAHTb 1O 'HcCJa THX He6araTbOX KpaYH, iuo 3anpOBaEHnJ aKpe1HTaLtiLo i cepTH4iKailio BHKnaAa4iB, aie LUHX 3axO11iB HeAocTaTHbo. H0'Tpi6HO 36ijIblHTH MO)KJHBOCTi 1An11 npoXo0KceHH51 HaBqaHHAI y cq3epi 3aKyniiBeJb, iuo6 3aAOBOJ1bHHTI noTpe6H npH6jiH3Ho 80000 p03nOp3WHHKiB 610a)KeTHHX KOWTiB, He paxyloqi aep)KaBHi niAnpHcmcTBa. 17 3eim 3 OiZHiKU 3axynieeb e YKpaini - 2006piK 46. PeryAnPHO nPOBOJUHTH ICOPOTICi iHCTPYICTa2Xi Ta CeMiHapH 3 MeTO10 iH$OPMYBaHHR fl3JRpANHHUKiB, noCTaqaJlbHHICiB ri KOHCyJIaTiB u1OiO BHMor 3aKOHy npo 3aicyniBJni. Ue AonoMornJo 6 3a6e3nesHTH OTPHMaHHR KoOMrineKTHHX Ta 3arajioM npHMHSITHHX TeHAePHHX nponO3HLtiU. 3aBAsKH niABHuWeHHIO AKicHoro piBHA 3MeHlIHTbCA KiJIbKiCTb BiAxHUieHHx nponO3HWiiM. LAe TaKO)K 3B3y3HTb MOKIJIBOCTi AepLPKaBHHX cAyxK6oBIIiB ninlHCYBaTH AorOBOpH 3a HellOBHHMH 9H4 HeBiAnlOBiAHHMI npono3HLUiAMH. YnOBHOBa)KeHHr opraH npoBiB He6araTo TaKHX 3ycTpiqeri i3 noTeHLtiiHHMt y'aCHHKaMH TOpriB. PexoMeOat4if > FpoBeCTm aHani3 inoTpe6 y HaB9aHHi Ta 3anpOBaAHTHi KYPCUi aJU1 6a3oBoro, cepeAHborO Ta BHUlOrO piBHH niAroTOBKH. > FleperiiAHyrU iHCTHryuiriHy CnpOMO)KHiCTb KOnIHCb aKpeAt4TOBaHHX MiHicTepCTBoM eKoHOMiKH Ta MiHiCTepCTBOM OCBiTH HaBMaj1bHHX ueHTpiB. 3a6e3neqHTH aKpeAHTauilo JOAaTKOBHX AepxcaBHHX Ta npHBaTHHX 3aKJiaaiB. 3anpoBaaHTH KYPCH niAroTOBKH B3HKJ1aaaqiB =As aKpeZU4TOBaHHX 3aKiiaAiB. > OpraHi3yBaTH KOpOTKi iH4)opMamti4Hi Ta HaBManbHi 3axoaH ARA noTeHLtiiHHx yqacHHKiB TopriB. HiiA qac TaKHX 3axOAiB Heo6xiAHo pO3nOBicTH npo MowKnHBocTi ymacTi B TOprax, noICHHTH npoueAypH npOBe.eHH5l TopriB, O3HaMoMHTH i3 3aKOHoAaBcTBoM Ta HOBHMU niA3aKOHHHMU aKTaMH y c4fepi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb. HaBqHTH CKAiaAaHHIO npOnO3HLW, U1o BianoBiAac BCTaHOBjieHHM TeHAePHO1O AoKyMeHTaLuieo BHMoraM. 47. BAocICOHaJiHTH CHCTeMy Ta npOuej.ypy 360py H MOHiTOPHHrY AePacaBHHX CTaTHCTH9HHX ,IaHHX upo 3acyniBJli. JgepwKaBHIH4 KOMiTeT CTaTHCTHKH YKPafHH 36upaC Ta OnpaLubOBye AaHi npo 3aKyniBni 3a craTHCTHuHOo0 ckOpMOIO NO1 "TeHAepH". Po3nop tlKHK 6iozAKeTHHx KOlUITiB 3o6oB'sI3aHi 3arlOBHIOBaTH LUO 4fOpMy Ta peCYJIAPHo nOAaBaTH AaHi H iH4OpMaolllO Ao Aep)KKOMcTaTy. TaKa npou\eAypa He 3a6e3neqye noaHoro o6.niKy AepxKaBHHX 3aKyniBenb, OCKinEKH BOHa 3,AiACHIOCTbCJI Ha OCHOBi "CaMOBiTHOCTi'. loTpi6Ho 3anpOBaAHTH MooAepHi3oBaHy, aBTOMaTm3OBaHy CHCTeMy MOHiTOpHHry. 18 3eim 3 oliHKU 3aKyni6eeb a YKpaiHi - 2006piK 4. DYHK1IIOHYBAHHI CHCTEMH 3AKYHIBE]b Or.rs,1 48. HOpMaTHBHO-HpaBOBa 6a3a BH3Ha-iaC c4pepy 3aCTOCyB3HHH Ta nOWUHpeHHR npotte1yp 3acyniBeJb. JepxKaBHi 3aKyniBJIi B YKpaYHi peryrnoioTb TpH 3aKOHH: (a) 3aKoH YKpa]HH "npO 3aKyniBjiio ToBapiB, po6iT i riocnyr 3a Aep*KaBHi KOWITH" (3JA3), BBeJ1eHHR B 11jO 22 .J1oToro 2000 poKy (i3 ocTaHHiMH 3MiHaMH Bi, 15 rpyJIHA 2005 pOKy, flK 3a3HaJanOC3l BHmue); (b) 3aKoH YKpaNHH "Hpo nOCTaBKHI npo1yKlifl An aep*KaBHHx noTpe6", BBeAeHHr B Ailo 22 rpyIHS1 1995 POKY (Iuo nouInploerIcs Ha Aep)KaBHi pe3epBH, OCBiTy i neBHi nocjiyrH); Ta (c) 3aKoH YKPaYHH "Ipo AepxKaBHe o6opOHHe 3aMOBJ1eHH.I" (BBeAeHHA B Ailo 3 6epe3HA 1999 pOKy), IUo 3aCTOCOByCTbC flnpH 3aKyniBJ31X ARlA o6opoHHHx Ta BiHiCbKOBHX noTpe6. 3JA3 (3i 3MiHaMH Bi1 15 rpyAHSI 2005 pOKy) 3aCTOCOBYCTbCT 16 0 BCiX 3aKyniBeJ1b TOBapiB, po6iT i nocJlyr, 11o nOBHicTio a6o 4aCTKOBO 3AirHCH1OOTbCAl 3a paxyHOK Aep)KaBHHX KOUWTiB, 3a yMOBH, 11o BapTiCTb ToBapiB Ta nocnylr OpiBHioc a6o nepeBiuiye 30 THCX4 rpH. (US$6,000), a po6iT - 300 THCAl' (US$60,000). HiAnpHeMcTBa, Ha fiKHX LiaCTKa aK11iri AepwKamH nepeBHiUiye 50 BiJACOTKiB (nOUITOBa cny)K6a, B TOMy HHCJi), TaKO)K niAnaAaioTb ni, Aiso 3JA3. 3axoH He nl0lHpiocTbC51 Ha BOAO-, Tenjlo- Ta eHepronocTa'aHHsi; BO1OBi14BeA4eHH51 Ta o6cnyroByBaHHsi KaHaJIi3a.iiAHHX CHCTeM; riOIITOBi nocJIyrH, y TOMy t1HCJIi nOIIITOBi MapKH; 3aKyniiBJHO TOBapiB, po6iT i nocnyr 3aMoBHHKaMH, 11o 3HaxoAJlTbC3l 3a MewKaMH YKpaYHH; TeJleKOMyHiKaUiHlHi nocJnyrH, B TOMY qHCJ1i 0oA1o TpaHCji3iui pa1Aio- Ta TeJlecHrHaniB (3a BHHflTKOM nocnyr Mo6ijbHOro 3B'.93Ky Ta IHTepHeT-nocnyr); noc.nyrH aUoAo nepeBe3eHHA 3aJli3HwHHHM TpaHCnOpToM; npo0ecilHa niAroToBKa, nepeniAroToBKa Ta ni.ABHLueHHsi KBJaniiKaUii po6iTHHu4x KaApiB y Aep2KaBHHx npo4eciiHo-TexHi4HHx HaBJanbHHX 3aKnaJ4ax; niAroToBKa KaApiB BIU4XHMH HaBHaJIbHHMH 3MKJ1aRaMH I - IV piBHiB aKpeAHTaUiI; Ta 3aKyniBni ToBapiB, po6iT i nocJnyr, 4ao CTaHOBJISTb gep)KaBHy TacMHHUIo. PeKoMeuatilif uIogo mJIIO9OBHX eJieMeHTiB geCpaBHHX 3aicyniiBeAb Memowu 3aKynieJi 49. 3,L3 nepeI6aiaC 3aCTOCyBaHHMI UieCTH MeTORiB 3alCyniBJi, a caMe: BiJIKPHTHX TopriB, TOpriB 3 o6Me*KeHOlO yqacT1o, .ABoCTyneHCBHX TopriB, 3anHT1y UiHOBHx nponO3HUir (KOTHpyBaHb), 3aKyniBejlb B OAHOro y'aCHHKa Ta 3i 3MeHUeHHflM UiHH (pe1yKuioH) i3 3acTocyBaHH51M MO144iKoBaHoI JaBocTyneHeBoY npouejAypH. OCHOBHHMH npoueAypamH e TOprH 3i 3MeHLueHH31M UiHH (pe.AyKuioH) Ta BiAKPHTi ToprH. 3aCTOCyBaHHA iHIIHX "o6Me)KyioqHx" MeTOAiB peryjiioe-rbC BapTiCHHMH noporaMH, 1.o cTraHOBJfTb 500 THC519 rpH. (npllH61H3HO US$100,000) AJUJI 3aKyniEBJi TOBapiB, po6iT i nocSiyr y pa3i 3acToCyBaHHM MeTO14y TopriB 3 o6Me)KeHolo yqacTio Ta 30 THcfls rpH. (npH6iul3Ho US$6,000) ARA ToBapiB i nocjiyr rl 300 THCfl4 rPH. (npH6Rn3Ho US$60,000) Anfl po6iT npH 3aKyniBJnlx B OAHOrO y4aCHHKa. Y pa3i nepeBHILeHH1 uiiX BapTiCHHX IlOpOriB, BianOBiAHy npoileAypy Heo6xiAHo noroAHT i3 ynOBHOBa)KeHHM opraHom a6o TeHnepHo!o aianaTolo. BHKOpHcTaHH51 npoLIeAypH 3anHTy L4iHOBHX nponO3HUirl peryrnoecbCq BapTicHolo MexKeio (fKa He nepeBHU.1YC 100 THCfiq rpH. a6o npH6jIH3HO US$20,000). 50. KpiM THX '9ITH npotieixyp 3aKyniBeju6, WO BIe pO3rjnRRaJIHCb y 3BiTi 3a 2001 Pi;, 3MiHOIO lo 3a[COHy Big 16 qepBHn (CT2TTH 29-3) 6ynIo 3auponaaweHo we OiHy, - npoueAypy TOpriB i3 3MeHWeHHHIM UiHH (pelyIutioH). xli npouexypa 3aCTOCOBYCTbC51 AUl5 3aKyniBni ToBapiB qH nocjnyr, O4iKyBaHa BapTicTb flKHX nepeBHiUyc 100 THCJ1m rpH. (npH6nu3Ho US$20,000), Ta "Anl f1KHX iCHyC llOCTiHHO Ai24HA pHHOK i fIKi He B4po6jifflOTbCX 41 He BHKOHYlOTbC51 3a oKpemo po3pO6nIeHHMH cneIu4HiKauiflMH...." 1o cyTi, Lie npoueAypa B ABa eTanH, noAi6Ha Ao TidI, wo onHcaHa cTarreio 30 3aKoHy, 3 TiClO pi3HHueio, tuo no 3aKiH'eHHi Apyroro eTany BiA6yBacTbc51 ny6.niiHHA ayKUioH Ha 3MeHweHHX LiHH (pelyKUioH). Lle cxoxKe Ha npoixeaypy enieK`rpoHHoro ayKUiOHY Ha 3MeHweHHf,l anie cyrreBa pi3HHU51 noJnrae B TOMy, 1uo "peAyKIiOH" C ny6JiiMHHM, i aHOHiMHiCTb yqacHHKa He 36epiraeTbcS. PeKoMeI)aqg.A > 3acToCyBaHHl npoiieAypH peayKUioHY Mo)Ke nllH3BeCTlH Ao niABIHueHHA UiH Ta CnpUflTH TacMHiri 3MOBi Mi2K yqacHHKaMH TopriB. Y'aCHHKH, 3HatoMH, iUo niA 'ac peAyKLwoiy BOHUi, 19 3eiM 3 Olj*iWlU 3aKynieeAb 6 YKpaiLi - 2006 piK 3peurTolo, BHMyiueHi 6yAYyT6 3HH3HTH UiHy, SK nipaBHuO, IllTyqHO 3aBHMULVOTb noqaTKOBy UiHy cBoci nponO3HUiY. L1ert MeToA noTpe6yc iCTOTHOro AOOnpauEOBaHHA 3aJnJ 3a6e3neqeHHA aHOHiMHOCTi y4aCHHKiB. Hlpaeuwayiacmi ma AKiCnUUi eio6ip 51. HeAHcICpHMiHauis yiaCHHUlCiB nepe146a'eHa NeBHHMUH nonoKesiimH 3aKOHy (HanpHncnaA, cTaTTr 5). Pa3oM 3 THM, iHUHMH noflJoKeHHMMH BiJKPHTO 3anpOBaAIylOTbCJ nped3epeHUif BiTql3HAHHM TOBapOBHpo6HuKaM, 3OKpeMa, y pa3i 3aKyniBJIi CiUbCbKOroCnOAapCbKOf npoQnyKuif, yqacTb y TeHAepax MO)Kwyb 6paTH BHKJUlO'HO BiTqt{3HRHi ToBapOBHpo6HHKH. rlepeBara HalaeTbCs TaKO1K npono3Huif niAnpHcMCTB rpOMaACbKIX opraHi3auiri iHBaJiiAiB. KpiM Toro, 3aKoHoM nepeA6aqeHo npaBO 3aMOBHHKa BHMaraTH BiA iHo3eMHoro yqaCHHKa BHKOHaHHH nocnyr qH po6iT 3 BHKOpHCTaHHHM "BiT'qH3HAHHX CHpOBHHH, MaTepianiB Ta po6oqof cHun". 4e nonoXKeHHA AIBHO o6Mextye Ta CTpHMYC ytiaCTb iHo3eMHHx KOHKypeHTiB. PeKoMenOagiJ > noiorKeHHs 3aKoHy CTOCOBHO yqacTi B TeHAepax Ta BiUbHOi TOpriBni MalOTb 6yTH npO3OpHMH. (LI4 TeMa pO3rnIsaeTbCA HH2Kqe B po3p.ini, nipHCBAqeHOMy nHITaHHAM BCTyny flo COT.) Hpaeuaa ny6aiKat4ibozoAowuefb ma zpaNugwi mepmifu 52. Yci orojiomeHHs npo 3annJaHona2y 3aSCyniBJIIO '4 nPoBeCQeHH nonepeJHboi KCBa2Jl4iICaWi yqacHIlciB nifiisiralOTb OnpHJIIOAHeHHIO. CTaTTs 29.1 3aKoHy BHMarae orojioweHHH AeTaJIbHOif iH4lopMaIii npo "pe3yJIbTaTH TopriB" npoTAroM 10 KaJ1eHEaapHHX JHiB niCJIA yKnaLeHHS AorOBOpy. rly6niKauiA aHrniriCbKo1o MOBOIO e o6oB'A3KoBo1o lnA 3aKyniBenb ToBapiB BapTicTio nOHaR 200,000 CBpO, noclyU - noHa, 300,000 CBpO i po6iT - nOHaA 4 MJIH. CBpO. 53. 3ruHo i3 OCTaHHiMH 3MiHaMH Ao 3aiCOHy, OrOJIOweHHu MaOTb MiCTUTH Ioui, a6o lijxeHTH4idKaUiHHfl HOMep", IpHCBOCHHH CepTTHPiKCOBaHlo0 iH4opMaUiHHo1o CHCTeMoNo. Xo'a ue, cxo)Ke, c nepeABiCHHKOM 3anpOBa,)eHHS CHCTeMH eneKTpOHHHX 3aKyniBeJlb Ta cHcTeMaTH3oBaHOi peecTpauif 3aKyniBenib, BCTaHOBJ1eHHS TaKof o6oB'S3KoBoY BHMOrui 3a3HaqeHHS KOpy Mac 6yTm BiuKnaaeHIO AO 3aTBepAlKeHHA BepxoBHolo Paaoio 1OpHAHqHHX 3acag RAS CHCTeMH eiieKTpOHHHX 3aKyniBeJ]b. nOTO4HHUi npaBOBeHH cTaTyc CepTH4iKOBaHof iH41opMauiHlHoi CHCTeMH He3pO3yMiJHA, OCKinbKH CariT www.zakupivli.com BTpaTHB CBOEO .iiueH3itO. OcKinbKH orofljoweHHS He MO)KHa ApyKyBaTH B 6lOne'eTeHi 6e3 3a3HaqeHHS KOWy, IIpHCBOCHOrO iHMopMauiAHOIO CHCTeMOiO, TO 6LnbuiCTb po3nOpsVHHKiB 6toDxeTHmx KOUITiB npOCTO BHraAY1OTb co6i HOMep. PexoMtenia14 > Xo'a npHCBOCHHA KOWy KOlKHiH OKpeMirt 3aKyniBni C ABHO KOpHCHOEO cnpaBOlO, BtiAnOBiaTH 3a ue Mac ynOBHoBa)KeHHA opraH, a He KOMepLlirHe niAnpH4McTBo. Hly6nikagim iicppoMa4ui npo mop2u 54. 3miHMaHo j 3aiCOHy Bia 2005 pOICy BCTaHOBJieHO OrBOB'53KOBy yMOBy ny6JhiKlaui B mepemi IHTepHeT iH4opMaUff npO TOprH Ta ix pe3yjv6T2TH. Ue c npHXOBaH11M By3bKHM MicieM, OCKiJIbKH pO3MiuleHHs iH4lopMaUii AO3BOJ1SCTbCA J1H1ue Ha CepTH14iKOBaHHX 4U MalosHx aTeCTaT BiAnoBiAHOCTi iH4IOpMauiHHHx CHCTeMaX y Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT. HeAoTpHMaHHA Ltid BHMOrd e niAcTaBoto AnA BiAMiHH TOpriB. lAi nojio2IeHHsA MO2KYTb 3AaTHcS LtiLIKOM CnylUHHMH, npoTe y CBiTni iCHylOqHX o6Me)KeHb WUO,O Bi,AnOBiAHOCTi Be6-caHTy BCTaHOBneHHM KpHTepiAM, BiA6yBaCTbCS 3nOB)KHBaHHS uiaio BHMorolo. BoHa c npOCTO 3aco6oM OTpHMaHHA AOXOAy 3a gonoMoroio CTaTerl nojio)KeHb 3aKoHy npo 3aKyniBni. PeKoMeHndaqi > Heo6xiHo cnpocTHTH npoLleAypH oronoweHHS iHAWopMauii npo TOprH, ix pe3yflbTaTH Ta iHWIHX AaHHX npo 3aKyniBJIi. YnoBHoBaaeH1H opraH Mac ny6niKyBaTm CAuHHHA OiuiriHHtH 6ioneTeHb AK y ,LpyKOBaHirl, TaK i B eJieKTPOHHiri 4)OpMi B pexKHMi peajibHoro Hacy B SKOMY pO3riopSLaHHK 6loxweTHHx KOWlTiB pO3MiMyBaTHMyTb CBOf oroJoweHHA. JgocTyn nOTeHLIiiHHX yMaCHHKiB .AO iH4opMaauii npo 3aKyniBJi nOKpauHTbCA, SAKLO Ha JoLaTOK O o6oB' S3KOBO; ny6.riKauiY iH4¢opMauilf B o4iLirlHoMy 6loxieTeHi, pO3nOpRAHHKaM 6iojKeTHHx KOWlTiB 6yno 6 AO3BofleHO pO3MiUXyBaTH iH4)OpMauifO B WH4POKO p03noBcoQLKeH4HHx ra3eTax Ta Ha Bj1aCHHX Be6-caRTax. 20 36im 3 OZiHKU 3aKynifeeJb B YKpaiHi - 2006piK Tenoep Ha ooKyMeHmaa#ia i mexniqni cnequipiKas4if 55. SIKiCTb TeXHiqHHX cneUH*iKa1Uirf TeHaepHOY JloKyMeHTauff c ORHiCIO 3 Haikcjia6KiMHx CKJIaSROBHX ,riiioiY CHCTeMH. Xoqa B 3aKoHi MiCTSITECq AeTanbHi iHCTPYKWif 1IOJRO 3MiCTy i TeXHiqHHX cneuHd)iKaUiA TeH,lepHOY tOKyMeHTaUiI, ui nono&eHHSI He 3a3HaHU 3MiH B 2005 poUi. HisKy CTaHAapTHY TeHAePHY lloKyMeHTauiIo He 6yno po3noBctoApKeHo. HariqacTiwue nPHMqHHOO BHHHKHeHHA CnipHHX nHTaHb 3a faoroBOpaMH, a TaKOlK HPH3ynIHeHHS Ta Bi,aMiHH TeH,aepHHX npoueayp Ham3BaOTbCSi He1OCTaTHbO BH3Ha'qeHi TeXHiqHi cneLix~iKauiY. PeKoMeuoat4i. > HiAroTyBaTm nHCbMOBe KepiBHHUTBO luoAo cKflaAaHH.9 TeXHi'HHX cneUHCiKauiri Ta npOBeCTH HaB4aHHS Aep)KaBHHx cny)K6oBUiB 3 niArOTOBKH qiTKHX Ta J1aKOHiXlHHX TexHixHHx crieUH1 iKauirl. Tunosa men6epua ooKyMeematis 56. B 2001 POUi MiHiCTepCTBo eKOHOMiCH OHy6JIiKyB3JIO CTaHmIpTHy TeHAepHy ,aOKyMeHT8UilO Ha TOBapH, p060TH i nocJIyrH, B3HBIUH 3a OCHOBY h1oKcMeHTU CBiToBoro 6aHKy. jflenapTaMeHT 3 KOOpAHHaUiY Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeib (JAK3) niArOTyBaB, B paMKax roJnaHacbKOrO rpaHTy nporpaMHoY CHCTeMHof nO3HKH (HCrl), 3pa3KH cTaHaapTHOI TeHrepHOY ROKyMeHTaUif Ta pO3MiCTHB II Ha CBOCMY Be6-caATi fAnJ o6roBOpeHHJI. OAHaK i3 J1iKBi.auieco JJAKJ13 ,aoonpaLuoBaHHA uieC TCHAePHOY ADoKyMeHTaUiY TaK i He 6yno 3aBepUweHo. 3IK 3a3HaManocJl BHIue, oco6H, nOB 'R3aHi 3 [leHTpOM TeHfePHIx npouenyp (L{TFI), 3apecCTpyBanu npoTvroM 2002-2004 pp. "aBTOPCbKi npaBa" Ha JaOKyMeHTauilO Ta HaB' 3yBanH pO3nOpUHHKaM 61ioKeTHHX KOWTiB i; BHKOpHcTaHHA, 3aCTOCOBYlOMH nUiCTH Ta "peKOMeHaauii', niAnHcaHi nOCaaOBUJMH BHCOKOrO paHry. Jlo 4fyHKUirl AHTHMoHononbHoro KOMiTeTy He BXOUHTb 3anpoBa,PKeHHA cTaHAapTHoY TeHRepHOY JOKyMeHTaUif AO BHKOpHCTaHHS. PeKoMeHNagiA > 3amsHmar, 3a CKJIa,aHHn H PO3nOBCioAlKeHHR cTaHAapTHoi TeHfaepHOY fROKyMeHTaixiY cepeA pO3nOp5AHHKiB 6loapKeTHHx KOWlTiB BianOBi,AalOTb AeplKaBHi opraHH. BHKoHaHHsI uie; 4yHKui1 Aep)KaBHOIO YCTaHOBOo niB14BHIIrHTb ebCeKTHBHicTb Ta npO30piCTb CHCTCMH 3aKyniBeJib. HopiafAuHaN npono3ua4iu ma Kpumepii ot4inKu 57. KpHTepii OWiHKH 3aCTOCOByIoTLCH 3aJe1HO Big xapagrepy 3acyniBeyib. lUiHa C £XIHH4M KpHTepieM OLUiHKH .jHue y pa3i 3aKyniBJ]i TOBapiB, po6iT i noc.nyr, AnsI AKHX iCHyC nOCTiHHO 1ilO9UH pHHOK. Y pa3i 3aKyniBJli, flKa Mae cKJiaAHHrl a6o cneuiani3oBaHHAf xapaKTep (BKmo4alo'u nocnyrH KOHCyJTbTaHTiB) KpiM WiHH, 3acToCOBYlOTbC31 TaKi KpHTepii flK aOCBiA i KBanii4iKauisI y'acHHKa, eKcnJnyaTauiflHi BHTpaTH i nepeAaaa TeXHOJ1OriH. IHToMa Bara uHx "iHWIHX" KpHTepifB He MoAce CTaHOBHTH 6inbwe 30 BiACOTKiB y 3arajIbHirl OUiHUi TeHAepHoY npOnO3HLUi. PeKoMeHRyCETbC3 TaKOWK BKa3yBaTm B TeHaepHirH ROKyMeHTauiI ix "BapTiCHHri eKBiBarIeHT". OAHaK Hi 3aKoH, Hi niJ43aKoHHi aKTH He MiCTflTb AOKJ1aLHHX peKOMeH1awxif IluOAO 3acTocyBaHH31 KpHTepiYB MM BH3HaqeHHSi BapTiCHoro eKBiBaneHTa. 58. HafiiacTitue lCpHTepicM OIiHKCH EAJI BH3H2'ieHHR nepeMoNCaSI TeHilepy C HauHIHXla WHa. fpono3HLi.u, 31Ky BH3HaHO HaHKpatuolo 3a pe3ynJbTaTaM OLUiHKH, Mae He iiHiue BiAnoBiJaTH TeXHiqHHM BUMoraM TeHArepHOY 3AOKyMeHTaUif, ane A npOnOHyBaTH HaRHHuKmy uiHy Ha ToBapH, po6OTH i nocjiyrH. 5IKwo I.OrOBip yKia,aeHO Ha OCHOBi BH3Ha'eHH.9 HaAHHHK4Oi LiHH, TO Lue uonomarac PO3nOp5AAHKKaM 6lo,alKeTHIx KOUTTiB YHHKHYTH HeraTHBHHX BHCHOBKiB BHyTpilUHiX Ta 3OBHiUIHiX ayrAHTOpiB. AZo TOrO )K, Bia6ip 3a uiHOlO cnpoLUyC 3aBlaaHHS1 =Jl 3aMoBHHKiB, OCKiJIbKH 3acTOCYBaHH.9 iHIIUHX KpHTepifB OUiHKH Mo)Kce noTpe6yBaTH 3HaIHo 6inbwe qacy i 3yCHJb. 59. 3aCTOCyBa2HH JIHMe UiHOBOrO KpHTCpiiO AnH1 UOpiBHSHHHH fPOno3HIIiI MONe 6yTH BHHPaBIIaHHM KOJIH 32KYflOBYIOTbCH llpOCTi TOBapa 9U nocJIyrH, a He TO,JiI KOJIH haeTbC9 HnO cJicaiHe o6la2auHHu 9IH YCTaTKYB8HHS, HpH 3aKyniBJIi SICHX BHTP2TH IHTTCBOFO UHIKJIY C Haii6DibJ11 BI1KJIHBHM 4aICTOpaM. FIOpiBHAIHHA npOnO3HuXir 3a LIiHOBHMI @aKTOpaMH B WIHIPOKOMY po3yMiHHi BKmo9ac, cepe, iHiuoro, ypaXyBaHH51 TepMiHiB nOCTaBKH, BapTOCTi 3anHacTHH, HaB4aHH.9 Ta BHTpaT )KHTrCBOCO oUHKJTY TOBapy. HloJIoKeHHSI 3aKoHy c aOCTaTHbO rHyMKHMH JAnAl MONKIHBOrO 21 3fim 3 OyiiKU 3aKynieeab f YKpatHi - 2006 piK 3aCTOcyBaHHA UiHOBOrO 4aKTOpy B UWHPOKOMY po3yMiHHi, npoTe pO3nOpR,HHKH 6toLPKeTHHX KOWUTiB qaCTO 3HeBaBxatoTb TaKHM niAXOAOM 3a 6paKom MeTOaHqHHX peKoMeHAauirl UtO1O 3LiAcHeHHA KOMn1eKCHHX niApaXyHKiB. PexoMeu4)a4iA > Heo6xiAHo 32UiAcHlOBaTH nOpiBHAHHA LiH iHwLe THX nponO3HuLiH, SiKi B 3HaqHirH Mipi BiAnOBiAliOTb BCTaHOBjieHHM BHMoraM, i BiA6HpaTH nponO3ullf, sAKi C Ha4HH)HKqHMH 3a OUiHeHoIO BapTiCTIO. > KpHTepiY OLiHKH, HKi BHKOpHCTOBYlOTbCR AnA BH3HaHeHHA HariHH)K*40 oEiHeHoi BapTocTi, MaloTb 6yTH o6'CKTHBHHMH Ta niIRAraTH KinbKiCHOMY BH3Ha4eHHIO B rpOwOBOMy eKBiBanieHTi. ,lo 3aKoHy Heo6xiHo BKJIIO'HTH oKpeMi noflo)KeHHA Io,io o6oB'a3KoBoro pO3KpHTTS B TeHAepHirl UoKyMeHTaLui iH4opMaLuil npO KpHTepif OUiHKH Ta MeTOAH nepepaxyHKy HeuiHoBHx KpHTepiiB B rpOUWOBHri eKBiBaneHT. Ho6aHIuI, ompuMaiiHA i po3Kpumnu meuoepuux npono3u,4ifi 60. FIpH 3acTocyBaHHi npouCeXyp BiAKpHTTHX TopriB i TopriB 3 o6MewceHOIO ymacTno MiHiMaJIbHHi CTpOK BiABeIeHHri Ha niAroToBKy TeHLePHHX npOIIO3HUiH Mac 6yTH 45 KanieHaapHHX alliB. A1K1O BHnpaBA1aHo, Lefi CTpOK Mo)Ke 6yTH CKOpoqeHtHi io 21 A1HS (qH 15 A1HiB AnA TOpriB 3 o6MeiKeHolo ytacIo). Flpoue1aypa ABoCTyneHeBoli npoeieAypH "peAyKUioHy" nepeA6atiae CTpOK IIiarOTOBKH TeHAepHHx npOnO3HUiA Au nepLuoro i ARpyroro eTaniB MiHiMyM 21 i 10 AHiB BiAnOBiAHO, uo Aac 3MOry, 3acTocoBylO'qH WO npoae11ypy, 3MeHlU1HTH 3arajibHHH CTPOK HPOBeAeHHA TOpriB 6e3 6yAb-slKoro o6rpyHTyBaHHm. Lie MO)Ke flP3BeCTH AO HeAOCTaTHbOT KiJIbKOCTi oTpHMaHHX npono3HULil. HIiA qac npoUeiypH 1BoCTyneHeBHX TopriB ylaCHHKH Ha nepHluoMy eTani noBHHHi MaTH MiHiMyM 30 1HiB Ha nilrOTOBKY TeH1AepHHX nponO3HUil. 3aKoHoM BcTaHOBjieHO n.Hlue 15 .AHiB MaKcHMyM ARA niArOTOBKH nponO3HIiH Ao .0pyroro eTany, SKHM Mo0Ke 6yTH nepeA6ameHo MOfH4iKauiIo TeXHi4HI4X cnemw4iKaLuirl. TaKHH TepMiH BBaxKaeTbCS 3OBCiM HeAocTaTHiM. )nSA npoLeAypH 3anHTy LUiHOBHx nponO3HUiiH (KOTHpyBaHb) cTpOKH riiAroTOBKH npOnO3ULIiU He BH3HaqeHi. 61. HIonIO2eHHUIH 3aKoHy qiTKO BH3HSeHO Taaci acneiCTH miK nops0 ocK noAaNHHS Ta HenpuHHslTTR TeHIePHHX npOHo3HUili, wo HagilUJnH nic.lg 3aKiHqeHHsn TepMiHy Yx no1aHHSl, TepMiHH A11 nponO3UiM, HeMOWKAHBicTb BHeceHHI 3MiH AO npOnO3HIiU niCJl IX BiAIKpHTTS i TeHAepHe 3a6e3ne-leHnm. 3aKoHoM nepeA6aqeHo PO3KPHTAS TeHAepHHX nponOf3lUMi y AeHb 3aKiHqeHHS CTpoKy TX HlOAaHHS B llpHCYTHOCTi y'aCHHKiB. [IpOTe, npoMi)KOK 'acy MiK 3aKiHqeHHAM cTpOKy nOAaHHA TeHACPHHIX npOfl03HUiU Ta Ix ny6niiiHHM PO3KPH4TRSM c cjia6KHM MicueM, Wo MolKe CnpHSTH 3JoB)KNBaHHsM. 3aicoHoM nepeA6aieHo OnpJiO1HeHH5A npOTOKOJIY PO3KPHTrA TeHAepHHX nponO3HUiiH B iMdopMaIiHHIHx cHcTeMax, io Mor£3o 6 BBaBKaTHcS rapHHM npHKJlaAoM, AK6H ite HacnpaBAi He 6yno nOB '3aHo i3 BHTpaTaMH Ha BHKOPHCTaHHS TaKHX CHCTeM B Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT, npo LUo IuunocSI BHuJe. Byno OTPHMaHO iH4,OpMaitio npo noOAHHOKi BHnaAKH, KOJIH y4aCHHKaM He AajlH 3MOry yBiiTH A1o aJMiHicTpaTHBHHx npHMilueHb uJo6 B3STH yqaaCTb B po3KpHTri TeHAepHHX npOnO3HLUiA. OcKapicenn.A 62. nlpolleypa ocKapwKeHH9 3a3HanJa 3HaqHHX nepeTBOpeHb niCJn9 3MiHH Ao 3aKoHy Bi, qepBsH 2005 poKy, anie BOHa 3aJiHWacrbCR, B HaOKpalOMy pa3i, HeetleKTHBHolo, He'iTKOio i BHKJHICSC He11oBipy y4acHHKiB (AHB. H. 19). 3aKoHoM BH3HaIeHO u0o y'IaCHHK (a6o iHwla oco6a) Mae npaBo oCKap)KuTH piLueHHA, Ari a6o 6e3AisnbHicTb 3aMoBHHKa, 3BePHYBWIIHCb e0 camorO 3aMOBH4Ka a6o CneuiaJibHOY KOHTpOJlbHOi KOMiCil a6o Ao CyAy. Pa3oM 3 THM, 3aKoHoM o6yMoBneHo, 0uo cKapra HanpaBnSCTbCS a6O 3aMOBHHKy, a6o KoMicii, a maKowic TeHAepHiri nanaTi. HaaxoAxKeHHA cKaprH 3aMOBHHKy a6o KoMiciT 3yrnHHAe npoueAypy 3aKyHiBJIi Ha TepMiH A0 20 AHiB. Y pa3i HaAxoA0JKeHHA CKaprH Ao KoMicif LlA OCTaHHA Mae noiH4)opMyBaTH npo ue 3aMOBHHKa Ta TeHAepHy nanaTy, uLO C ABHO 3aABHM, OCKiRJbKH CKap2KHHK 3060B'A3aHHA 3 camoro no0aTKy riOAaTH cKapry Ao TeHAepHof nafJaTH. 63. BBe1eHHg nojiOWeHHSI npo 3ynHHKY npoueaypH 3aKyniBni Ha TepMiH A0 20 AHiB 1AOKH He 6y1e npuHiH% Te piuIeHHs no cKap3i C 30BCiM HenpaBHJ6bHHM. YqaCHHKH MO)KyTb BHKOpHCTOByBaTH Lie nono)KeHHS 3aKoHy luo6 OTpHMaTH AoAaTKOBHri qac Ha niAroTOBKY CBoix npOnO3HUirl, OCKinbKH Hi 22 36im 3 o0irHKU 3aKyni6eeb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK CyTHiCTb, Hi xapaKTep CKaprH He Ma}OTb Hi;KOFO 3HaUeHHA i BiACyrHi 6YAxu-sIKi BHMOr 1UO31O Ix o6rpynToBaHocTi. CKapra C JiHiue 3aco6oM BiAcTpo4eHHSI He3pyMHoro rpaHHqHOro TepMiHy. 64. TeHliepHa naniaT MaC B CBOCMY pO3nOpsiJA2eHHi aeCSRTb po60MXu JHiB 3 momeHTy OTPHMaHHH cKaprH, ULI6 HaAaTH BHCHOBOK i uxe OAHH eHl6, mUOr Ha;icjiaTU floro Ao KOMicii. B 3MiHax BiA qepBH5i 2005 POKY HaAaHHSI BHCHOBKiB TeH3AepHolo nanaToio npeACTaBj15jiocb X1K ii "npaBo". 3riAHo 3i 3MiHaMH BiA rpyiHR 2005 POKY TeH3epHa naJiaTa, qepe3 HaBaHH.R BHCHOBKiB, cTaiia o6oB'A3KOBHM y4aCHHKOM npouecy PO3rR313Y cKapr. BiA pO3nrOp3HHKiB 610oRKeTHHX KOUTiB Ta KoMiciY BUMaraeTbCI npUHpiMaTH piIueHHSI "3 ypaxyBaHHqM BUCHOBKy TeHxepHof naniaTTH 1o1O po3rnxa3y cKaprH". HoMiHanbHo, BHCHOBOK TeHlepHof naiaTH He c 060B'X3KOBHM AMS BHKOHaHHq, npoTe, 3riaHo 3i CTaTTeio 17-3 (12) 3aKOHy 'Ai3[nbHiCTb TeHAepHoYl nlaaTH, a TaKOW pe3ynjbTaTH TaKox AiAJIbHOCTi, y TOMy 'iHCJ1i BUCHOBKH, iHllli 31OKyMeHTH. . . MO)KyTb 6yTH ocKap)KeHi BHKJIIOqHO y CY,ROBoMy nOpxAKY BiAnOBiAHO AO 3aKoHy". OnocepeflKoBaHo, ue nepeTBoploC "Heo6OB'JX3KOBHA' xapaiTep BHCHOBKy Ha o6oB' 3KOBHU. AHTHMOHononbHHA KOMiTeT He BiAirpac iCTOTHOI po0Ii B npoueci po03rJIsy cKapr. 65. PimeHHul 3a pO3FJaIR0M CKaprH mome 6yTH occapceHO 40 cyiy. Konilo nO3OBHOi 3aABB Heo6xiAHo Ha3icJiaTH npfPT5FoM TpbOX AHiB 3Ao JAepKaBHoro Ka3HagercTBa, ynOBHOBa)KeHoro opraHy, 3aMoBHHKa, a TaKo0K TeHaepHoY nanaTH. KoniA yxBanJ cy,ty npo nopymueHH5i npOBag)KeHH51 y cnpaBi Ha3CtinaeTbCi nPOTXrOM 20 AHiB. B UboMy BHnafKY pO3n0pA1HHK 6ioAKeTHHx KOWTiB Mae nPH3ynHHHTH npoUeAypy 3aKyniBni. YKnaAeHHJI aorOBOpy TaKoK npH3ynfHH5CTbCq AO nppI iIHSITTIT piweHH.l KoMicielo. HpoLle.ypa 3aKyniBejib MOeKC npooB*KyBaTHc.S, .9KUIO 3aBipeHa KOfliA Cy,aOBoro YXBaneHH51 npo nopyuweHHA npOBaA*KeHHR y cnpaBi He 6yna HaaicnaHa npOTlroM 20 KaneH3aaPHHx 31HiB. 66. B 2004 poni 405 ccapr 6yao FO3oaHO AO MiHiCTepCTBa eKOHOMiKH. JlHwe 59 3 HHX 6ynro BHipiwleHO Ha KOpHCTb IO3HBaIiB. PewTy 6ynTo Bi3axHneHo a6o BH3HaHO Heo6rpyHToBaHHMH. FIpoTSIrOM nepuLioro niBpi9xi 2005 pOKy 6yno no03aHo 281 CKapry, 72 3 XKHX 6ynIo BHpilUeHO Ha KOpHCTb nO3HBaniB. J4aHMX mo.0o TOrO, HaCKinbKH rapHo npaUIiOBaB ueri MexaHi3M A1O BHeCeHHSI 3MiH 3Ao 3aKoHy He icHyC. TaK caMe HeMOKJIHBO BH3HaMHTH, HH nOKpauHnocb pO3yMiHHA CHcTeMH, 3a BHHATKOM "MexaHi3My npH3ynHHeHHR", XKHU 6inbimolo MipOlo BHKOPHICTOBYCTECq XlK 3aci6 noHAoB*KeHHA rpaHHWIHUX TepMiHiB. Be3CyMHiBHo, 3anpOBaA*eKHH5 o6'CKTmBHoro MexaHi3My p03rJi3Ay cKapr 6e3cTopoHHiM opraHOM, LUo He MaC HiAKHX KOpHCJIHBHX iHTepeCiB, cnpHuno 6 nocHneHHIO 31OBipU 3 6oKy y"acHHKiB Ta np3BJeno 6 ,3o 6i.nbWiof KoHKypeHUii. CJIyWHHA MexaHi3M po3x31,4y cKapr Mae BKntO4aTH TaKi KOMnOHeHTH: (i) ny6niKauilo a3eTan.bHOY iH4opMauil CTOCOBHO BH3HameHHA nepeMo*KLH5; (ii) AoCTyn A1R5 yCiX 3aUiKaBJIeHHX CTOpiH; (iii) 6e3npHcTpacHr4 ni AxiA; (iv) BmaCHHfl p03rnx,A cKapr, BKJUo'laIo4u Bi3AMiHy piwUeHb npo yKJa,l1eHi A1oroBopH; Ta (v) noluHpeHH5I Ha BCi acneKTH npouecy 3aMyniBenb, BKJ1OmatoqH BU6ip MCT031y 3aKyniBJ]i. PeKoAten6ag& ' '-HHHHU MexaHi3M ocKap*KeHH ,airl noTpe6ye nojiinwieHHH i3 BpaxyBaHHxM n 'XTH, 3a3HaqeHHX BHUte, KOMnOHeHTiB. Ypx31 YKpaYHU Mir 6u CKOpHCTaTHCA 3a=.n LibOro ,L1IpeKTHB0IO CC 0Uo0o 3aco6iB npaBOBorO 3aXHCTY (EU Remedy Directive), X1Ky 6yno npHAHATo qneHaMH CC B paMKax npouecy 36nJHeHHA 3aKOHo01aBIHX HOpM. Po3rnx,iAatoqH MexaHi3M OCKap*KeHHR A1iM, onHcaHHri B gHpeKTHBi, nloTpi6Ho 6yae 3Ba*KHTH Ha pi3Hi MO3ejli ruoro 3acTocyBaHHg. 31K npj4KjlaA, y BcTaBI.i 2 (31MB. HUH*qe) HaBegeHO Mo3eJIi, LUo BHKOPHCTOBylOTbC5 B C31oBeHiY, YropwuHi i HopMamu6Ho-npawo6i aKmu 67. Bci nl313aICOHHi awTH MaJIH 6yTH npHBe3eHi y BiAUlOBiAHiCTb i3 3aKOHOM IIPOTHrOM MiCHUH 3 A8TH rloro ony6jidCyBaHH5s 17 6epe3HU 2006 poicy. CTaBLuH YnOBH0Ba)KeHHM opraHOM, TaKa aeTanEbHa iH4opMauiA Maae BKinoiaTH: (a) iMS KO)KHoro yiacHHHKa; (6) UiHy npono3mui'; oronioLueHy nia 'ac pO3KpHTTA; (B) iMW KOKHoro yqaCHHKa pa30M i3 oHiHeHOJO BapriCTiTlo npono03Hiui mo 6yIH 3onyHLeHi 30 oLIiHKH; (r) iMR ypiaCHHKiB, qHi npono3HLiY 6ynio BiaxHieHO i3 3a3HaqeHHiM npH'qHH TaKOrO BiaXHIneHHA; Ta (A) iMx nepeMo)KLxS Ta 3anponoHoBaHy HHM liHy, a TaKo)K TpHBaJiiCTE r 3aranEHHH o6cAr nocTaBOK/po6iT 3a yKnJaeHHM JiorOBOpOM. 23 3eim 3 O4iHKU 3aKyniefleb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK AHTHMOHOnOJIbHHul KOMiTeT pO3MiCTHB 29 6epe3Hq Ha CBOCMY Be6-caHTi nAa npoeKTH HaKa3iB: FIpo 3aTBepAiceHHA 4OpM oroj1oiueHb Ta [pO 3aTBep)KCeHHR 4OpM 3BiTiB 3 O0iHKH. BOHU c iReHTH4HHMH HaKa3aM MiHicTepCTBa eKOHOMiKH N2130 Ta Ns129 BiAnOBiAHO, 3 TiCIO pi3HHueio, UAo BCi nocHnaHHA Ha MiHeKoHoMiKH 6yJIo 3aMiHeHO Ha AMKY. )4ns Ha6paHHs q4HHHOCTi 4i HaKa3H MalOTb 6yTH 3aTBepRWeHi AMKY Ta 3apeeCTpoBaHi MiHicTepCTBoM iOCTUUiI. Hpoqedypa nonepedIiboY meaan7i4imaI4iI 68. 3aKoHoM qiTKo He BH3H8qeHO, AiSn RIKHX CaMe BHUiB 3aicyniBeJIh 6yno 6 Aope-iHHM BHKOpHCTaHHR npotuejypH nonepeAHbOT ICBaJMiiKauiT y4aCHiciB. 4HHHHMH nono)KeHHRMH BH3HaqeHo AKi came KBanifiKaLtifiHi BHMorm MO)KyTb 6yTH 3acToCoBaHi. J0o fx qHncna BXOASTb: HaABHiCTb A03Bofly a6o nieiH3ii Ha npoBaAeKeHHA BiAnoBiAHOi AiXAbHOCTi Ta HaAaHHA nociyr, HaABHiCTb o6naiaHaHHA, a TaKoxK npauiBHHKiB BiRnOBiAHof KBanitiKaUii (Hi HaABHiCTb rpOLUOBHX KOIMTiB, Hi ciHaHcoBeH CTaH He 3raAyIOTbCA, xi6a UIO BHMaracTbC3 He 6yTH 6aHKpyToM) Ta niATBepA)KeHHA npo cnruaTy y4aCHHKaMH noAaTKiB i 36opiB (o6oB'R3KoBHx nJlaTe)KiB). 3aKoHoM BcTaHoBJIeHo, uiw KBani iKa4iiiHHi BHMorH 3a3HaqaioTbcS B TeHAepHirl AoKyMeHTaLIif. Ili nono[eKHHS CTBOpIOIOTb YMOBH AllR XH6HorO BHKOpHCTaHHS, OCKiJbKH 3aKOHOM TaKO* BH3HaqeHO, LO y4aCHHKI4 Mo)KyTb 6yTH BiAxHneHi y pa3i KOJIH BOHH He BiJnoBiAalOTb KBaJitiiKaWiHHHM BHMoraM. Heo6xixIHo po3po6HTH niA3aKoHHi aKTH, mKi 6 MicTHnH qiTKi iHCTpyK1iAMH Ta peKoMeHAauii W2oao npOBeaeHHSI nonepeAHboi KBani4JKauit niApRAHHKiB Ta nOCTaqanrbHHKiB. PexoamentI4Lu > BBecrT Ao 3axooHy nojioxceHH1, Mlo BH3Ha'anH 6 qiTKi KpHTepii ARA nonepeAHbO6 KBaiiiiKaLii ymacHHKiB. TaKi KpHTepi; MaloTm BKniOqaTH: ,IocBiA Ta iH4opMauiIo ripo BHKOHaHHS noti6HHX AorIBOpiB, CllpOMOXIHiCTb BHKOHaTh 3aBAaHHA, B TOMY qHCJIi HaSBHiCTb BiaXnoBilHoro nepcoHany, o6nnaAHaHHn, 6y1iBeebHoro qH BHpO6HHqoro OCHalUeHHS Ta 4iHaHCoBe cTaHOBHuXe. KpiM Toro, po3po6HTH Ta BBeCTH B alio niA3aKOHHi aKTH UROAO npOBeAeHHs nIpOUeCypH nonepeAmbol KBani4iaui.i. 24 3eim 3 OZjiHKU 3aKyfieez7b f YKpalHi - 2006 piK BcmaeKa 2. Po3ZJwI cKape e CAo6eeii, YZopuuHi i Ho.0zbu4i CjioBeHin 3aco6H npaBoBoro 3aXHCTY peryrotoTbca OKpeMHM 3aKOHOM - 3aKoH npo po3rFjI npoileayp flepKaBHHX 3aKyniBenb (450-02/99-10/2) BiA 22 JnUnHi 1999 pOKy. HHM, no cyTi, BCTaHOBJieHO ABoeTanHy npoueaiypy po3rnSAy. nlo-nepwe He3aAOBOJIeHHI y4acHHK no,Aae cKapry BjiaCHe 3aMoBHHKy. EKCnepT, AKHH po3rFjiAae cKapry, nOBHHeH HaaaTm BHCHOBOK npOTXrOM BOCbMH IHiB, niCnxA QbOrO 3aMoBHHK Mac TpU AHi Ha npHrIHHrrrs piuleHHx i3 ypaxyBaHHXM QbOro BHCHOBKy. 5IKILo 3aMOBHHK He 3MiHIOC CBOiO nfO3HuiO, TO y4aCHHK Mac tIe TpH .Hi, UtLO6 HaIicnaTH cKapry Jo iHcTaHuif BHI1OrO piBH$l - HauioHaJ9bHHoY KOHTpOJ1bHOf KOMiCii (HKK). HKK nOBHHHa npHAHRTH pilleHlq XKOMora cKopiLIIe, XK npaBm.no npoTsroM 15 AHiB, xo0a, 3a neBHHX o6cTaBHH, ueri TepMiH MowKe 6yTH nOaOB)KeHAH iite Ha 20 AHiB. PiWIIeHHq C OCTaTOIHHM i ocKapAceHHIO He nifxirac. YropMuHHa Ap6iTpa)KHHA KOMiTeT nopyuwyc cnpaBy no HaAxoAPKeHHlO cKapri. CKapra Mo)Ke nOAaBaTHCSl 3aMOBHHKOM, y4aCHHKOM 4H iHUOlO 3auiKaBJIeHoIo CTOpOHoIO. AKIQO MO30B He noAacTbmc npoTHroM 15 AHiB 3 2iaTH OTpHMaHHR iH4opMauili npo npaBonopymiUeHHR i He ni3Hitue, HihK 4epe3 90 ,HiB nicinx niAO3pH Ha nopywIeHHR, npaBO Ha nojAa4y cKapri MHHae. KoMiTeT MoIKe Ha npOXaHHX 6yab-uxoi 3aiKaBJIeHOi CTOpOHH npOBeCTH ny6Ai4Hi cJIyxaHHSI. PiweHHq o0iIliAiHO nepeAacTbcs y4aCHHiKaM cynepe'IKH i ny6IiKycTbCs B 6iojieTeHi AepAKaBHHx 3aKyniBenb. FlpXMe OCKap)KeHHq Ha piUweHHA KOMiTeTy He MoAKHa noaaTm. Cya Moice neperiniHYTH npHIH)lTe piweICHHJI Ha niJacTaBi nO3OBHOi 3asBH. CyA Mo)Ke CKaCyBaTH piweHHH KOMiTeTy Ta npHIHATH CBOC BjiacHe, SKe MowKe 6yTH ocKapiKeHe BnpOJiOB)K BOCbMH aHiB. floaajmbWi OCKapeKeHHR He A0o3Bo0JI3OTbCR. floibuwa npoueAypa po3rinxAy CKaprH Mo)Ke CKia,AaTHCdi 3 TpbOX eTaniB, KOJ1H OpiCHTOBHa BapTiCTb 3aKyniBJin nepeBHuwye 30 THCA4 cBpo. Ha nepwomy eTani noaaeTbcR cKapra 3aMoBHHKy, Ha ApyroMy - Ao ap6iTpa*Horo KoMiTeTy i Ha TpeTbOMY - Ao cyqy. CKapra nflAaCTbCR npOTXrOM CCMH aHiB BiAKOnH y4aCHHK Di3HaBca npo o6CTaBHHH, LDo AaioTb ni.cTaBy Anx OCKapeKCHH3 i nHwue go npHcyaeKCHHA KOHTpaKTy. 3aMoBHHK nOBHHeH PO3rPAHyHTH cKapry npoTiroM CeMH ,AHiB 3 AaTH 'i HaAxoI)KeHHA i nPH3yHHHHTH npouexypy TOpriB Ha nepioA po03rJAAy CKaprH Ta npHMHrTTrr ocTaTO4Horo piuleHHsI. JlHpeKTOp YnpaBJiHHJ qep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb (YJA3) MooKe 3a neBHHx yMOB Ha8aTH AO3BijI Ha yKJIanaHHA KOHTpaKTy. Y pa3i, KOJnu OpiCHTOBHa BapTiCTb 3aKyniBJli MeHilie 30 THCSI4 CBpO, TO JilOTb JIlHIe 3BHMaHi npaBoBi 3aco6u BHpiweHHR CnipHHx ntlTaHb, 3ri.1Ho i3 LtHBi4JbHHM 3aKoHoAaBcTBoM. }ThepeJio: Ha OCHOBi iH4opMauiY 3BiTiB "CirMH", tCepBeHb 2003 pOKy. 17potjeOypu 3aKynieai iHmeieKmyaJlbHux noc,'yz 69. 3aouH MiCTHTb nojio)4eHHSI npo 3aICyniBJIi ToBapiB, pO6iT i nociyr He 3ruayIo0fH npo iHTeJieKTyaJIbHi nOCJIyrH. Lle BHKnHKac TpyAHOWi, OCKiJbKH MeTORH 3aKyniBejib, BKnioqeHi Ao 3aKoHy, )IOXHHM qHHOM He ni4XOAATb JIA 3aKyniiBeJb iHTeJIeKTyaJIbHHx nocnyr. 3a BiACyTHOCTi Haiie)KHHX nojio)KeHb, pO3nOp3WHHKH 6ioIKeTHl4x KOIUTiB BHKOPHCTOBylOTb MeTOAU4, IpTl3Ha-1eHi Anm 3aKynisni TOBapiB Ta po6iT. Ile Mo)Ke npH3BeCTH Ao He6a)KaHoro 3aCTOCYBaHHA uHX MeTOZiB Ha npaKTHli, - HanpHKJIa, 3aHaATO HpsAMORiHirlHHrH niAXiA Ao BIKOpHCTaHH IUiHOBoro 4aKTopy MK OCHOBHOFO tiHHHHKa OliHKH, BCTaHOBJ1eHHM BHMor iuoao TeHiAepHoro 3a6e3ne4eHHs Ta 3a6e3rie4eHHR BHKOHaHHM aoroBopy TOIUO. PeKoMeHbat(iR > Heo6xiAHo BKRIOUiTH Ao 3aKoHy OKpeMi nonio2KeHH.A UlOAO 3aKyniBni iHTealeKryanbHHx nocnAyr. BCTaBKa 3 MiCTHTb npHKJiaAH BiAlnOBiLAHHX THIIOBHX noJIo)KeHb. 25 3eiM 3 OU,iHKU 3aKynlieeAb e YKpaiHi - 2006piK Bcmaexa 3. Tunosi no.7oxeHHIJ npo 3axynieAIo iumezeKlmyaJibUux nocryz Cmanmvx 1. "IHTeneKTyajibHi nocnyru" - .aiJnbHicTb iHTeJieKTyanbHoro Ta HeMaTepiajibHoro xapaKTepy, pe3ynJbTaTH AKOI He Mo)KHa o6MipATH. BOHH BKJloqatOTb HaBqaHHA, ayaHT, pO3po6Ky nporpaMHoro 3a6e3ne'eHHa Ta iHlWi noj.i6Hi nocJIyrH. ,TorOBopi Ha HaAaHHa TaKHx nocniyr YKJIa8aJOTbCR Ha OCHOBi KOHKYPCY nOnepeAHbo BiAi6paHHX KaHAH)aTiB 3 ypaxyBaHHAm nOJO1KeHb cTaTFi 6. CmamnL 2. KOPOTKHU nepeJliK noneperHbo BiAi6paHHX KaHLLHaaTiB cKniaAaeTbcA nic.ia BiAKPHToro 3anpO[llCHHA A0 BHSBJIeHHA 3auiKaBJIeHOCTi, ony6niKOBaHorO 3riAHO 3 noFio0ceHHAIMH 3aKOHy. KaHAHAJaTH BiJI6HpalOTbcA KOMnCTeHTHHM TeHAepHHM KOMiTeTOM Ha OCHOBi OUiHKH IX CHpOMo4CHOCTi BHKOHYBaTH HeO6xiAlHi nOcJIyrH, SK BCTaHoBj1eHO B fOKyMeHTi npo nonepeAHIo KmaniJiKauio. Cmwmmm 3. BizR6ip KOHCYJ1bTaHTa 3AiMCHIOCrbC0 Ha OCHOBi KpHTepiiB, BHKnaAeHHX B 3anpoweHHi Ao BHsBjieHHA 3aUiKaBneHocTi. B 3anHTi Ha nO,aHHB nPOnO3HIHi MiCTHTbCA AeTaTbHa iH¢opMauiA npo cnoci6 3acTocyBaHHA KpHTepi4B BiA6opy 3acTocoByIOTbCA Ta npoeKT 2oroBopy. B 3anHTi Ha uoAaHHA npfono3HUiii MiCTHTbCA TaKOWK iH+opMaauii utoAo Mo0ncj1HBdi AHCKBaMi4iKaWi; Bi, y'aCTi B npoleAypax 3aKyniBni ToBapiB, nocnyr MH 6yAiBenJbHHx po6iT, sKi MOlKyTh 6yTH IOB' 3aHi i3 UHM 3aBnaHHNM. Cmamn 4. Bia6ip nepeMoicwl npote1ypH 3AiriHIoctrcI Ha OCHOBi TexHiqHol AKocTi IlpOnO3HIW, TO6TO BiABoBiAHoro AocBily KoucyjwTaHTa, JocBiAy Horo nepcoHany Ta 3anponoHOBsaH0 MeCOAOJIOrI BHKOHaHH1 pO60TH, a Taiow hiHH npOflO3Hui. KpiM Toro, BiA6ip Moxe mifijCHiOBaTHCI Ha OCHOBi mKOCTi TeXHiqH0; npOO3miti B MeXBX caxonepeAHbo BH3HaqeHOro 4ixcoBaHoro 6ioAxery 'H Ha niAcTaBi HaiiKpagol 4iHaHcoBoI upono3lHif, noAaHno xaH,AH.LaTaMH, AKi OTpHManR AOcTTHio KiJlbKiCTb TeXHiqHHX 6amin, BH3HaqeHHX B 3alHTi Ha DOaaHHS nponolHuii. CO ammlu 5. RKuX nocayrH MaJOT HaAtBHqarHO CKJIaAHHR xapKrep HU cnpaEiAnoT iCToTHHri BHnHB Ha Marl6yTHi npoexTm a6o AKcuO BOHM MOXcTb npiBecTH no tiIoaHHA npO1103RUii, AKi CKjIaAHO nOpiBHXTH, KOHCyjibTaHT MOCe 6yrH BiAi6pHaHI BHKXlO'HO Ha OCHOBi TeXHiqHdI SlOCTi npono3HIlt. Cmaatm 6. Ho3aKoHKypCHe yKuaHaRa AoroBOpiB BHXOpNCrOByChCA, AKLiO BHKOHaHHR nocnyrH BHMarac 3any'eHHx neBHoro, Haa3BHMa"HO KBaaji4biKoBaHoro KoHCyJlBTaHTa, qH RKUtO BHHHKac Heo6Xi,aHiCm B TIpOAoBxCeHHi Bxce pO3no4maTOi pO6O01 Tmm CaMHM KOHCyJIbTaIITOM. Cmntam 7. bnnmHcaHHA AoroBopy Mac o6roBopmOaaTCm nHtIe 3 BiAi6paHHM KaHAHAaTOM. He MoxHa oAHo'acHo Beem neperOBOpH 3 iinBKoMa KaHAHAaTaMH. Cmammx 8. JloroBopH, npO AKi HPAeCA B craTrAx 5 i 6, yKaB4alOThCR J4HiC 3 THMH KaHAHAaTaMH, RKi 3rOAHi Ha npoeAeHHe nepeBipKH LHiHy nia 'ac HaAaHHA nocjiyr 3riAHO 3 InOJIO)KeHHRMH CTarri .... floio)KeHHR CTaTri ... 3aCToCOBOTbCR A0 JOrOBOpiBs, yKnaAeHHX Ha OCHOBi cTaTel I i 4. Hoci6nUK xopucmyeaYa qU iHcmpyKL4iY ORu 3aMOEHUxis 70. He3Bna2XOqU Ha AeTajbHi iHCTpyicUi B 3aKoHi inoRo 3AirtcneHHhl npogejypH 3aIyniBetjb, 6araTo nHTSHb 3aJIHUISEOTbCg BiJIICpHTHMU AJ8Jl TpaKTyBSHHI. HaA3BHqaiHHo npo6neMaTw4HOtO C BliACyTHiCTb ioci6HHKa, RKAHM 9TKO nOSCHioe npoLteAypH 3aCToCyBaHHS 3aKOHoaLaBCTBa, 3OKpeMa, B HacTu4Hi o0iHKH nponof3ILir Ta niArTBep)IeHHA KBaniiiKaLui;. KomueIHif ),IKJ3 4aKTHMHO niWroTyBaB TaKHr noci6HHK (3a ,0onoMorwo0 SIDA) B 2002 POLti Ta P03nOBCIO,AB Horo cepep. p03nopsA1HuKiB 6ioxpHeTHHX KOUIlTiB. OAHaK noJIo)KeHHR, SKi AO3BOJIRlOTb ynIOBHOBa)KeHOMY opraHy HaAaBaTH TaKi iHCTPyKLUi, 6yno BHJny4eHO i3 3aKOHy B nJIcTonaAi 2004 pOKy. l0o 4iyHK[tibo 6yno nepeAaHo TeH.epHiA naJlaTi, a oco6H, noB'53aHi 3 TeHAepHO10 naJiaTOlo, OTpHMallH aBTOpChKi npaBa Ha TaKi MeTOAN4Hi MaTepia$nH. PeKomeu4ai.A > YnOBHOBa)xeHHA opraH Mae TepmiHoBo niArOTyBaTm noci6HUK 3 nlHTaHb 3aKyniBeJn i 6e3KOuITOBHO nepe.aTH uoro B KOpHCTyBaHHA PO3OpfSVAHHKaM 61oAxeTHI4X KOWTiB. 26 3eim 3 OZUiHKU 3aKyniBeeb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK 36epkaHUH doKyAMenmaI4iT3 3aKynienb 71. nHCbMOBi MaTepiaJIH, 11O CTOCYIOTbCSI yCiX eTaniB 3aKYDiBJli, 36epiralOTbcs NPOTSrOM TplOX pOKiB. J0OKyMeHTH C AOCTynHHMH UIA rpOMa,AcbKOCTi, KpiM pO3KPHfSA iH¢OpMaUI;, xKa momKe 3anoAiUTH WKOJY aep*KaBi, Ta iHc¢opMaaui1, nOB'3aHoI 3 BHB'eHHAM, OUiHKOIO Ta IOpiBHqHHAM nponO3HUfl. 3aKyniBxIi BapTicTIO MeHuIe Hi*K 610,000 He MalOTb o6oBe'3KOBO JOKyMeHTyBaTHCa. ,LxoKyMeHTH, nOB' H3aHi 3 npoueCRypo1o TopriB, 3a3BHMaA 36epiraioTbcsI B cerh)ax, OCKinbKH WI iH7opMaUii BBaBKaeTbcA KOH4HiaeHLIiAiHoO. PH3HKH BHHHKHeHHS1 HeC1PUHSTJIHBHX 3aCajx NpOBemeHHHI 3alyCniBenb 72. E(oeKTHBHiCTb CHCTeMH AeP*aBHHX 3aKeyniBenb 6yJlO PeTenjilHO npOaHaJli3OBaHO, BKJjOqalO'H PH3HKH BHHHKHeHHSI HeCnpHHTJIHBHX 3acajq npoBejieHHs 3aKyniBeib. HpoTRrOM nHcTonaAa 2005 pOKy - nloToro 2006 poKy 6yno npoBe2ReHo pRAJ 3yCTpiMert i3 llpeACTaBHHKaMH PO3nflOpAHHKiB 6to0pKeTHHx KOUITiB, KOHCyJT6TaHTaMH, nOCTaqan6bHHKaMm, CninKaMH ni,IpsqJHHKiB, nianpUHHCMULMH, OnTOBHMH TOprOBURMH JiKiB Ta BHpo6HHKaMH. BHCHOBKH, HaBeJIeHi B ULbOMY po3,Uini, rpyHTYloTbcA Ha oTpHMaHir niA Mac UHX 3ycTpiMeH iHcopMaui1. 73. AeRKi He6aMaHi HaCJIiIIKH, HaBeJeHi B Ta6JIHUi 1, CUpUH'IH eHi HBHHMU HeROJIiKaMH 3aicoHy. IHUIi He6a)KaHi HaCniKH c pe3YRbTaToM He,XOCTaTHbOrO HaBMaHHR y c4epi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeRb, HeHOBHOrO pO3yMiHHI nOJIO)KeHb 3aKoHy i cna6Koro KOHTPOJIIO Ta Harniay 3a (IyHKLIioHyBaHHAM CHCTeMH. Ili HaCiiJiKH BIIHBaiOTb Ha eq)eKTHBHiCTb CHCTeMH i nPH3BOARTE AO MapHOTpaTCTBa B CHCTeMi Xep)asBHHX BHAaTKiB. HH)KMe HaBeJReHO pH3HKH i 3axOJH UO1AO YCYHeHHSI HeJIOniKiB. AeAKi HacJiiiKH, HaBeaeHi HH)KMe, BMKe eTajbHO po3r In1ajaHCq B nonepe,rHix naparpa4ax, ane TyT BOHH niiCyMOBaHi JnS WiJIiCHOCTi 3o6pawKeHHA. 27 3eim 3 O4LiHKU 3aKynieellb 8 YKpazii - 2006piK Ta6rnuus 1. CTHCJIHi nepeniK pH3HKiB y c4epi 3aKyniiBejib Ta peRoMeHAatjii wor O IX yCyHeHHi PH3HK HaCJAICHK YCyHeHHSI HeLOJIiKiB (peKoMetiAauii) 3aranbHMik pH3HK HeAocTaTHA B3aemolis i BiACyTHiCTb He.oTpHMaHHA nO1O)KeHb YO iCTOTHO nOKpaLiUHTH B3aeMoAiLo i3 peryniipHoro AiaAory MbiK YO Ai 3aKOHY Ta niq3aKOHHHX PO3nOPSAHHKaMH 6toR)KeTHtx KOWITiB PO3nOpfAHHKaMm 6toRIKeTHHx KOWIlTiB 3 aKTiB, IUo cnpHLIHHsC Ao Ta aKTHBi3yB3aTH ianor i3 npHBaTHHM oltHoro 60Ky Ta npHBaTHHM CeKTOpOM 3 BTpaTi eKOHOMitiHoro ceKTopoM. iHUloro; cnJa6xHir HarnI i KOHTpOEnb 3a e4eKTy BiRR JOLinbHHX Ta npoLiecoM npoBeAeHHA Aep)KaBHHX CejeKTHBHHX 3aKyrniBejib. 3aKyniBenlb. Po3nopsuHHKH 6toA)KeTHHX KOWITiB 3a 6paKoM qacy (KOUTH HlepernsiHyT 6toAiKeTHHA KOAeKC 3 iHoAi OTpHMYIOTb 6tojpKeTHi KOIIITH noTpi6Ho BHTpaTHTH AO MeTOKO BAOCKOHajieHHA 6toAKeTHoro HanpHKiHui iHaHCOBoro pOKy (y KiHLuA 4iHaHcoBoro poKy) LHKHJIy, BKJ1IOqalOMHU nnJaHyBaHHS jiicTona,ai - rpyAlHi). nOCniWIHe nponeAeHHA 3aKyniBeslb, wo6 3a6e3rie4HTH BqaCHe npolueAyp 3aKyniBeJlb, HaAxoalKeHHq KOWTiB AO BKJllOqaaio'H BHKOpHCTaHHA pO3nOpSLHHKiB 6io0)KeTHHX KOWTiB. HeBiAnOBiAHHX MeTOUiB 3aKyniBiBI, MalOTb HaCJIIAKOM BeJlHKi 3anpOnOHOBaHi LIiHH. qaCTo pO3nOp2AHHKH 6ioAKxeTHHx HecBoeqacHi BHnfnaTH BcTaHOBHTH KpalUHri 3B'A30K Mi)K KOlWTiB oroiOluliOTb TOprH, npti3BOATb A BiACyTHOCTi ()aKTHtH4HMH noTpe6aMH O2ep)KYlOTb Ta O0iHiOIOTh npono3HiWl i AOBipH ao aep)KaBHHX po3nopAAHHKiB 6ioAlKeTHHx KOLLTiB Ta yKnIaaloTb AOrOBOpH, He MalO'H 3aKyniBelb 3 60Ky BHiaineHHAM KOWITiB Ka3HaqegCTBOM BneBHeHOCTi, MO OTpHMaIOTh KOWITH nOTeHCHiuHHX yqaCHHKiB Ta, AMT BHKOHaHHR 3060B' s3aHb, To6To, AnJ 3,aiH4cHeIHA BHIniaT 3a AK HacJiLOK, AO BiACyTHoCTi 3a6e3neq[iTH nepeAaqy KOWITiB KOHTpaKTaMH. KoHKypeHLti;. Ka3HaqegcTBoM 3riAHO 3 aXmTH4HHMf noTpe6aMH, Ha OCHOBi yKiaAeHHx yroa, a He 3anjiaHoBaHux noKa3HHKiB. OronowieHH. npo TOprH He MO)KJIBO iH4opMauia npo KpiM ny6riKauiii B Cneuiafli3OBaHmX ny6niKyloTbca B ra3eTax i3 TeHAepH He AOXOflHT6 AbO 6ioJIeTeHAX 3 nUiTaHb 3aKyniBejlb, 3arajibHoHauiOHanbHHM ycix noTeHWijHHx yyqaCHlKiB iHcopMauito npo TeHlaepH Ta po3nFoBCIOAKeHHAM, a TiJbKH B B KpaIHi, tUO tpH3BOUHTbAO npcHcyA)KeHHi KOHTpaKTi Heo6xiAHo cneLuiani3o8aHHx 6ioneTeHax 3 HeAOCTaTHbdf KOHKypeHLii. ny6niKyBaTH npftHaHMHi B oAHig 3aKyniBeilb. HaliOHaJbHir ra3eTi. Heo6xijlHi ,nIA y'aCTi B Toprax BiACyTHiCTb KOHKypeHuiY. CTBOpUTU cnpoLueHy npoixeAypy o4 ifiUli AOKYMCHTH OTpMHaTH AOCHTb OTpHMaHHA i noAaHHR Heo6xiRH1x Ba)KKO. TaK, HanpHKiaAi, ARA AOKyMeHTiB UOTCHLtiUHHMH OTpuMaHHA AOBiAKH npo BiACyTHiCTb yiaCHHKaMH TOpriB. 60priB yqaCHHKH MalOTb 3BepTaTHCS 20 nloAaTKOB0f iHcneKtIii 3a TpH TH)KHi TexHiqHi cneH44iKaLuiY He MaKOTb Flpono3muLiY CKjiaAaOTbCA Ha PO3po6HTU JeTarlbHi peKoMeHAauii oAHo3Ha4HOi TpaKTOBKH; BUMorH C OCHOBi HeqKiCHo L11oa0o nigrOTOBKH TeXHi4HHX HeqiTKHMH a6o HepeajiicTTqHHMH, BCTaHoBhIeHHX BHMOr, i, AK CneulHiKauiH. lpoBecTH HaBqaHHq 3OKpeMa, TaKi aK TepMiHH nOCTaBKH pe3yjibTaT, AeleBi TOBapH, nepcoHaniy 3 nHTaHb niirOTOBKx qiTKO Ta/a6o BHxOHaHHA, AKi He MOXCHBO po6oTH i HeKBaniIliKOBaHa BH3HaqeHHX TeXHiqHHX CneLuHiKauir. 3a1BOJBo6bHHTH, B TOU qac AK BHMorH po6oqa ciiuna lpOllOHY0OTbCSA CTBOpUTU i 3a6e3neqHTH BeAeHHS 6a3H 1l1O0O KBani4)iKauii i AocBi2y qaCTO HeKOMneTeHTHHMH Ta AaHHX THROBHX CneLt4ikaUiri Ta Bi2CyTHi. HeAocBiaqeHHMH niiArOTyBaTH CTaHAapTHi TeXHiqHi yqacHHKaMm. cneIHliKaLuif An Hag6inbw PO3nOBctoALKeHHx npeaMeTiB 3aKyniBJli. 28 3eim 3 oliHKcu 3aKyni6eejb e YKpaw'i - 2006 piK PH3HIC HacaIhIKm YCyHeHHS HeColiiiciB (peicoMeHaauili) 4acTO yqaCHHKaM 6paKyC iacy Ha O6MeiKeHa y'aCTb y Toprax BHMaraTH BiA pO3nOpJRfHHKiB ni-ArOTOBKy nponO3uuiu, OCKiJTbKH npHBOAHTb AO 3aBBHueHHX 6IoAKeTHsx KOLUTiB BiApaxoByBaTH AeflKi PO3nOpsAHHKH 6toR*KeTHHx tiH Ta BTpaTH BuHia. KiHueBHi TepMiH nOLIaHHS9 nponO3HULii KOWTiB HaBalOTb TeHAepHy 3 AaTH, KOJTH TeHAepHa ,AOxyMeHTaUix IOKyMeHTauiiO, 9epe3 AOBrHA qac aKTHHHO Ha1racTbcs y'aCHHKaM. nicsnnq ony6siKyiaHHs orojOWLeHHq npo FIOCHnuTH KOHTPORb YO 3a TOprH. IHO2i Ha nizrOTOBKy TeHAepHHX AOTpUMaHHHM TepMiHiB niArOTOBKH nponO3MUiu 3a8JHWaCTbCq nJIHwe npono3Hlir, nepeA6ageHHx 3aKoHoM Ta 9I0THpH Hi. npOrOnOWyBaTH BiAMiHy TOpriB, KOJH yqaCHHKaM He HazaeTbCs AOCTaTHbO qacy Ha niAroToBKY npOflO3HUii. BCTaHOBjieHa 3aKoHoAaaB4o Ile He 3axu4uac iHTepeciB MOKJIHBiCTb oniiaTH 3a6e3ne9eHHn MO)*JUiBiCTb OnJiaTH TeHAepHoro pO3[0pRAHHKiB 6tOA)KeTHHX TpeTbOIO CTOpOHO10 Mae 6yTH 3a6e3neqeHHH oco6o0o, iHWOIO1 Hi)IC KOWTiB i nPH3BOAHTb hO CKaCOBaHa. BHMora HaAaHHA CaM yaCHHHK TOpriB. HenoTpi6HOrO yCKJ1aAHeHHR TeHAepHorO 3a6e3nemeHHS Ta npoueAypn 3aKyniJni. KpiM 3a6e3ne4eHHH BHKOHaHHA AOrOBOpy TOrO, BHMOra UgoAo Mac HOCHTU o6OB' 3KOBHr xapaxTep 060B'R3KOBOCTi HaAaHHI JHuIe AIJS BenHKHX 3a o6cRroM TeH.AepHorO 3a6e3nemeHHA C .AOroBOpiB. HaAMipHHM Tsrapem anA ylaCHHKiB Ta o6Me)Kyc KOHKypeHUilO. ,TJeaKi pO3nOpOa,IHHKH 6toAjKeTHHx BiAcyrHicTb KOHKypeHWii i BHMaraTH BiA pO3nOpRAHHKiB KOUITiB CTBOpIOITb TaKi yMOBu, LuO He npO3OpOCTi, OCKiJIbKH ui, 6to03KeTHHx KOWITiB B1KHBaTT JIO3BOMJ]IOTb BCiM y4aCHHKaM noAaTH omeBH2HO HaBMHCHi JiU Heo6XiAHi 3axoJIH, J3tn CBOi nponO3HUiY oco6HcTo Ha AaTy MO2KyTb nepewKOAHTH 6e3nepeCUKOAHoro AOCTyny y'aCHHKiB BCTaHOBj1eHOrO KiHueBoro TepMiHy Yx AOnyCKy y4aCHHKiB Ta Yx Ao ny6,iiHoro pO3KpHTwr TeHRepHHX nOJaHHM Ta 6paTH yiaCTb BYX npOIf T0O3HWi AO KOHKypCy. npono3HUi9. pO3KpT-ri. 3oKpeMa, ue nornnrae y BiACyTHOCTi MO)KJ1HBOCTi OTpMmaTH nepenyCTKI iAo aaMiHiCTpaTHBHHX 6yAiBejlb, Ta 6e3niJICTaBHOMy nepeHeceHHi 'lacy Ta aaTH pO3KpHTTHR npono3HUIiA. HeCOCTaTHi Ta HepeanicTH'1Hi TepMiHH Y'laCHHKH noJaloTb HaAaTH AOCTaTHbO 'acy ian nOCTaBKH nOCTaBKH CKJIaAHHX TOBapiB Ta npono3HUi; Ha HiLCTaBi 'iTKO BH3HalHTH BiAnOBiAHi TCpMiHH y BHKOHaHHR po6iT. HanpHKnazI, B HepeaniCTH4HHx TepMiHiB TeHAepHiA JrOKyMeHTani;. yMOBaX ,lOrOBOpy, U1O MiCTHTbCR B nOCTaBKH TOBapiB a6o TeHIaepHiAi JlOKyMeHTauiY He BH3HaqeHo BHKOHaHHSI po6iT, wuo6 TepMiHH nOcTaBKH ToBapiB a6o nepeMor-rH y KOHKypci, a BHKOHaHHR po6iT. KOJIH x BH3Ha,alOTb nepeMo)KIIeM, TO BOHH He BHKOHylOTb 3060B'93aHb a6o BHKOHylOTbY X He3aAOBiJ]bHO. Po3nopRAHuHKH 6lopIKeTHHX KOWTiB floTeHliriHi yqaCHHKH BCTaHOBHTH 'iTKi npaBtiia LOJrO BiRMiHaIOT6 TOprH, He iH(jopMyloqH BTpaqalOTb JOBipy Ao yrojt i3 MOmKuHBOCTi BiJMiHHH TOpriB. y'laCHHKiB npo nPH44HH TaKof BiJAMiHH. YpRAOM i He 6epyTb yiaCTi B [Ia MO)KJIHBiCTb nepe,A6a'eHa CTaTreio aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBJIRx. LIe 27 (2) 3Jl3. nroJCHI0C HH3bKy cepeAHuo KiJ]bKiCTb npono3Hulii (3) niA qac TOpriB B YKpaYHi. 29 3eim 3 OyiHKU 3axyni6eeZb f YKpaZHi - 2006piK PH3UIC HaCaiQICH YCYHeHHSI HeaOaiiciB (peicomeHAauri) BH3HaeHHS1 nepeMOaKWA TopriB HH3bKa gKiCTb ToBapiB, po6iT 3a6opoHHTH PO3nOpfWHHKaM 3'RiACHHOCTbCS BHKJIIOqHO Ha OCHOBi i nocjiyr, OTpMHaHHX B 60oa*KeTHHX KOWTiB aKIernTYBaTH Hai HHAK40oi 3anponOHoBaHoi uiHH Y 6e3 pe3ynibTaTi AepKXaBHHX npono3Hili, 51Ki He BiAnoBiaalOTb ypaXyBaHHA iHWIHX KoMepL(iriHHX Ta 3aKyniBeJlb. BHMoraM TexHi'HHx cneLXuHIiKauig. TexHiqHHx 4aKwopiB OUiHKXH. 4acTo OCHOBHHM KpHTepieM Biai6opy Mac npOnO3HUri He BiAJiOBiAalOTb BHMOraM 6yTr HariMeHwa ouiHeHa BaprriCTb TCH,aepHOi oKyMeHTauif. nponol3uwi;, a He HaiMeHwa 3anponOnoBaHa niHa. YrcaaAeHHS yroA CTaHaapTHHX opM maorOBOpiB aJA He3a4oBiJlbHi Ta PO3po6HTH CTaHaapTHi ()OpMH Jaep)KaBHHX 3aKyniaenb ToBapiB, po6iT i He36anaHcoBaHi YMOBi AOrOBOpiB AJIS 3aKyniBJi ToBapiB, po6iT nocjiyr He icHyc. KOWKHHA JoroBopiB nPH3BOAJTb ,o i nocniyr Ta BKJ1O4HTH iX ao PO3nOpSUlHHK 61Q1AKeTHHX KOWlTiB Hee4)eKTHBHHX 3aKyniBejib CTaHaapTHOY TeHaepHO; aoKyMeHTaUif. BuKopHCToByC CBOIO cFopMY m oroBopy. BHacIiioiK noTeHLtiiHoro BHHHKHeHHSl ClOpiB 3a yKJaaeHRMH yrOaaMH. Po3nopsAHHKH 61OAKeTHHX KOWITiB CKacyBaH HA Aif AtorOBOpy 3anpoBaRuHT npo1te,4ypu, AKi iHOJi CKaCOBylOTb )LIO JAOrOBOpiB 6e3 6e3 o6rpyHTyBaHnn BKa3yc BHMaralOTh BiUl pO3nOp3WHHKiB 6yAb-AKoro o6rpyHTyBaHHr. HecepAo3HHAi niaxiaX AIO 6toJAKeTHHx KOWITiB o6rpyHTyBaHHs ,aep)Ka3HUX 3aKyniBeJib. CKaCyBaHHA Ai; JOrOBOpiB JyHKnllpUHKic tCepmcasnUX 3axyniae.Jb 74. qIHHH2 iHcTMTyIifHa 6a3a He 3a6e3ne4yc MexaHi3My e4peKCTHBHOrO napTHePCTB8 MiK gCepamiBHRM i HpUBaTHUM CeCTOpOM. )KOAHHri KOIHUWHiri YO TaK CaMO AK OpraHH, Aoj1y4eHi .ao JUJibHOCTi IIOTOqHOi iHcrHfry1uiHoi CTpyKTypH, He Ba1BHnH 6a)KaHHS 3a6e3neqHTH TaKy B3acMoaXo, He Ka*Ky'1H Bice npo cTBopeHOHA BiAlnOBiRHoro MeXaHi3My. BHHATKOM e npOBeAeHHA nepiORHq4HHX KpyriiHx CTOjiiB KoJTHmiHiM YO Ta nponO3HLXiA TeHaepHoY naiaTH tuoaon pOBeAeHHS HUi3KH nniaTHux CeMiHapiB 3 nHTaHb fepxcaBHHX 3aKynisBejb. PeKoMeih&at4im > AHTHMoHonoJnbHuHi KOMiTeT Mac pO3po6HTH i BnpOBa,HTH npOrpaMy napTHepCTBa 3 npHBaTHHiM CeKTOpoM. 75. flpaKTHKa .coMepWilHHx 3aK-yniBei6b KoMnaHiX o6yMoBJleHa £AiJOBOIO aKTHBHiCTIO, pO3MipoM i BapTiC-lo yro,. B 6inbinocri BHna,KiB KOMnaHil, 3 HKHMHn pOBOaHUHCb iHTepB o ARns uied OIiHKH, BHKOpHCTOByBaBJH CTpyKTypU i npoLtexypu 3aKyniB3li, 51Ki BiAnOBiaalOTb rapHiiH MiDKHapOAHir npaKTHUi. HaA6inbWi KoMnaHif MalOTb cneuiaflbHO CTBOpeHi BipAiSIH 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBenb qH efenapTaMeHTr, npHqOMy AeAKi 3 HHX cneLiajii3yfOTbCJq Ha 3aKyniBJlRX neBHoro aCOpTHMeHTy npOARyKTiB (CHpOBHHa, 3a[fl4CTHHH TOiIIO); OCHOBHHX 4)OHmiB (6y,4iBni, BHpo6HH4i npHMilieHHA TOIUO); Ta MaTepiaj6bHo-TexHi4Horo 3a6e3neqeHHsI 41 BHTpaTHHX MaTepiaaiiB. 3pocTae KinbKiCTb KOMnaHiri, AKi OTPHMyIoTb cepT4m iKaT ISO 9000 i BnpOBaa)KYlOTb OnTHMallbHi Ci4CTeMH ynlpaBJliHHA AKiCTIo. BiJiu6iCTb 4ipM BHKOpHCTOBYC npaKT14KY 3aKyniBJIi, SIKiH npHTaMaHHi HacTynHi XapaKTepUCTHKl4: * flpuHHuIn KopnopaT1BHof eTHKH, nOJIiTHKH i npoLeJqyp, BK111oqa0o4 H OnpHJIIORHeHi BHyTpiUIHi npfHHUHnH q4 nOp51JOK 3LiiHCHeHHS 3aKyniBejib npaLtiBHHKaMUi KoMnaHif * ABToMaT3oBaHi cHcTeMH ynpaBniHHA 3aKyniBJIsMH B OKpeMHx BHjnaAKax * YKiiaLeHHA yro, UWUIXOM KBa3iKOHKypeHTHoro TeHAepy, B SKOMY, AK npaBHno, 6epyTb yqaCTb BiA TpbOX Ao n 'TH 4ipM (6irlbuia KinbKiCTb AnA yroR 3 BHUWOIO BapTiCTHo), Ha OCHOBi noecHaHHq LliHH, AKOCTi, po6OTH4, oCTaBKH Ta KOMepLiiHH1X YMOB * goMOBneHocTi niCnS KOTHPYBaHHA 3 ABoMa 41 6inbuEWO) KiJlbKiCTio 4ipM * BHKopHcTaHHS CTaHLAapTHHX YMOB yKnaJeHHA1 yroa. 30 3eim 3 OZjiHKU 3aKynieeilb 8 YkpaWi - 2006piK 76. KoMnaHiY 3HaXORHT6 6iJ1bliCTb HOBHX nOcTaIanJIbHHKiB nepeBa?KHo 4epe3 KoMepWiiHi KypHaJIH, BiABiJAHHfl cneuiaJIbHHx BHCTSBOK i RpMIapKiB Ta 4epe3 IHTepHeT. EinbIwIiCTb Be3HKHX KoMnaHiiH nepioH'iHo OrOnOWIylOTb TeHAepH B HaLiOHaMbHHX .ApYKOBaHHX 3aco6ax MacOBOf iH¢opMauil. MeHuhi KOMnaHif 'aCTO yK ialOTb yroJU4 UJIxXOM npxMHX neperoBopiB. 77. KoHcaJITHHroBa iHRyCTpi9 3Lle6iJbwmoro OXOAilOC Api6Hi *pipMH, ICLUbECiCTb 4paxiBqiB B HIICHX He nepeBHniyc 10 oci6, SKii 3anyla2lOTb nO3aUITSTHHX npaUiBHHKiB. BiIIcyTHicTb cneuianbHHX npoue,ayp 3aKyniiJi nocnyr KOHCyJIbTaHTiB i BHKOpHCTaHHX HaToMiCTb npoLie,ypH BiAKPHTHX TOpriB 3aUlKOlHJIO KOHCaJITHHrOBif iHAIyCTpif, OCKiEbKH 4UiHH nepeBa>KaioTb HBA flKiCTio. KpiM TOrO, ripH HarMaHHi KOHCyJbTaHTiB nepeBaKalOTb npoueiAypH TOpriB 3 o6Me*KeHoXo yqacTio (npHJz6aHHA nocnyr B OAHoro "yacHHKa). 78. KijmIa nepeucKoL FOCTirlHO 3SB2aKaIOT6 BxoI2eHHIO npHBaTHoro cecTopa B pHHOIC 3aicyniBeim. CTaTHCTH4Hi AaHi FIAS Wuo,o "BeAeHHA 6i3Hecy B YKpaYHi" BKa3yTOTb Ha cepAo3Hi npo6neMH i3 3anoqaTKYBaHHRM 6i3Hecy. 3riwgHo 3 iH4opMaLxieIo 3a 2005 piK 3anoqaTKYBaHHx 6i3Hecy BHMarac 15 npoue.ayp i, npHHaAiMHi, 34 AHi. OTpHMaHHa iiueH3if 4H AO3BOny - zo 18 npoueayp i 265 JIHIB. 79. FIAS T8K1o2 eHnnBHa cepfio3Hi nepemicowa inH peecTpaYif HepyxoMocTi (10 npoueRyp i 93 ,1Hi). niiKmlOieHHX LAO KOMYHanbHHX MepeK BHqBHAOCb TaKO)K HaAJTo npo6neMaTH'HHM i BHMarano "BHnIiaT 3a CnpUAHHxI." 3ri,zAHo 3 nonepeEqHiMH oUiHKaMH, Anx niRfKiioqeHHA EAo eiieKTpHqHoI Mepe)Ki noTpi6Ho 22 ,LHiB, AO Tene4)oHHO J niHii - 19 ,AHiB. ,ZO TOrO m, iCHyC BiJHOCHO He3HaqHa KiJIbKiCTb ToproBo-npoMHCnIOBHx OpraHi3auiri 3 HeBenHKOlO KiJ]bKiCTio qnIeHiB. 80. 3arajiom, OnHTaHi ICOMiaHul pO3yMiJnH IpHHUHNH i nparKTHICy, MO peryJIONOTL Aepa8BHi 3aKyniBJ]i, i 6yJIH )Jo6pe UOiHOpOPMOBaHi [pO HeIo.JiKH Rli0O0Y cHCTeMH. Flpo6neMoio e Te, luo 3aKoHoaaBqa 6a3a AOCi HenOBHa - HanpHKnaA, BiACYTHiCTb cTaHAapTHof TeHAepHOf AOKyMeHTaIlif, Iuo HaAaCTbCA 6e3nnaTHo. 3aranbHe yXBneHHA CBiAqHTb, IUO Aep)KaBHUHP CeKTOp He 3anpoBaAHB CAHHHri niaxia AlO 3aKyniBealb. LAe CnpHqHHaC ARO BiRCyTHOCTi KOHKypeHLtii. AgOCBiA nOKa3ye, UO piBeHb KoHKypeHTocnpoMomHOcTi AOCHTh HH3bKHA. B 2004 i 2005 pp. cepeAHA Kij1bKiCTb nponro3HLxir Ha TeH,Aep cKnaAana 3 nponO3H4Li1, To6To TPOXH Kpalie, Hi* 2,3 fpono3Huii B 2003 poui. floAZaHHx nponO3HUiH n'sTbMa y'aCHHKaMH BBa)Kacrbcfl npHr1HSTHHM piBHeM KoHKypeHUiI. ( ,JHB. JOAaTOK 2). 81. (IipMm, Hici onepwKyloTb KOHCyJIbTaUif, BICB3YIOTb Ha Te, 11O BOHH peryjisipHo CJiKYlOTb 3a OrOJOioeHHHMH HpO ToprH. OARHaK BOHH, AK npasuIo, noBiAoMnAlOTb rnpo HaCTynHi npo6neMH: * HH3Ka XKiCTb TeH.aepHHX cneUH4)iKaUiA B TeHAgepHiri aoKyMeHTaUif (Uerl acneKT BHKnHKae HaN6inbUIe HapiKaHb). * BHKOpHCTaHHli cy6'CKTHBHHX BHMor AO roonepeHWboi KBani4iKauil Ta cy6'CKT4BHHX KPHTepifB OUiHKH nponO3HWjiA Ha OCHOBi 6aniB. * MeHWii 4ipMU He 6epyTb yqaCTi y BiAKpHTHX TeHAepax 4epe3 HeCnpoMO?KHicTb OTpHMaTH 6aHKiBCbKe 3a6e3neqeHHfl. TeHAepHa tOKyMeHTaUiA qaCTO BHCyBaC HepeaniCTH'qHi BHMOrH Ao 0oKyMeHTiB, XKi MaloTb npeAcTaBHTH 6aHKH. * HaA3BH4aAHo BHCOKa nnaTa 3a TeHAepHy AOKyMeHTaUiho pa3OM 3 He6axcaHHM i 6e3niAcTaBHHM BTpyMaHHAM "KOHCYJIbTaTHBH4X KOMnaHiri' y npoueiiypy TOpriB. * A6coJllOTHO UICKpeUirlHa npoueAypa yKJIa.LeHHIl yroA, BKJmlO'aio4H iHOdi HaBiTb omoMOBJieHOCTi 1LOEO 3HH)KeHHAI UiHH niCnA TOpriB. (HHHi ue A03BOneHO O4)iLiAHO mepe3 TaK 3BaHy npoueAypy "peAyKLXioHy"). * HeBiaCHi BHiniiaTH B riOpyweHHA aoroBipHHX yMOB. AMdiiCmpySaHHmyeod ma eupiueHii cnipuux numaHb 82. IFiCJISI HiAUHCa1HH1 yroIH WS lOTpi6HO 3apeCCTpyBaTH B MiCueBoMy yHpaBJiiHHi ca3Ha8ercTBa. LJo 4)yHKUitO Mae BUKOHYBaTH 6yxraniTepiA 3aKyniBenbHoY opraHi3aLii, AKa TaKom) 31 3eim 3 OZiHKU 3aKyniee.7b f YKpairi - 2006piK BiAnOBiAae 3a Orlpa8OBaHH nIJlaTe)KiB. OTpHMaHHS Ta aKuenT ToBapiB, po6iT i nocniyr e 4yHKuicio a6o AenapTaMeHTy JOriCT4KH, a6o niApo3Ainy, SKHrU C KiHueBHM KOpHCTyBaqem npllp6aHHx ToBapiB, po6iT i nocjnyr. 83. CTaHaapTHoi 4OpMH yroaH 3 BiAIUOBiAHHMH nOjOioeHHHMH 10110 BHpiwueHHSI clipHHX nHTaHb HeMaC. CnipHi nlHTaHH5 Mi)K BiTqH3HSHtMI4 nOCTaqaJ]bH4KaMi, 3aMOBHHKaMH i KOHCyJIbTaHTaMH 3B3H8arHO BHpiWlIOTbCA BiAnlOB3iHO 0 HaUiOHaJIbHorO 3aKOHOAaBcTBa. Ap6iTpa)KHi HOpMH UNCITRAL 3aCTOCOByloTbCS AO iHo3eMHHx nocTaqaJibHHKiB, 3aMoBHHKiB i KoHcyJThTaHTiB. 32 3fim 3 OyiHKU 3aKynieelb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006 piK 5. AOBPOqECHICTb I lIPO30PICTb CHCTEMH AEPWABHHX 3AKYIIIBEJIb CucmeMu KOHmpOmo ma aytumy 84. YICpaTHa MaC BHyTpiMuHIo i 30BHiUHIO CHCTeMH KOHTpOJIIO Ta CHCTeMH ayuHTy uponeCJypH aepKaBHHX 3aKyniDeab. TeopeTH4HO KOHTpOJ1b i ayAHT oxoniiioioTb yci acneKTH npoueAypH 3aKyniini. LUi MexaHi3MH nepexA6aMaJoTb nonepeRHil po3rnillA, po3risui nOTOMHHx npoUeflyp Ta pO3rnJlA nicnIA 3aKyniBeJb (3a Aonomoroio noulHpeHoro MexaHi3My). JAep*aBHi opraHH peani3ytoTb cfyHKiito BHyTpIwHbOro i 3OBHiu1HbOrO ayAHTy TaKHM qHHOM: * KoHTponbHo-peBi3iAHe ynpaBjliHHA Ka6iHeTy MiHiCTpiB BiAnoBi,aC 3a BHyTpiIHiHi ay,AHT. B HbOMy HaiJiyeCTbCS 27 BiAAiJeHb Ha periOHaJlbHOMy (o6JiaCHOMy) piBHi i 588 Bi=iJliB B paHoHax i MicTax. * PaxyHKoBa nanaTa e BHlUOIO OpraHOM ayAHTy B YKpaYHi. BoHa 3BiTyc BepxoBHirH PaAi i BilAnoBi,Jae 3a 30BHiWHiHi ayAHT, BKjlOqato4H MOHiTOpHHr BiAnOBiAHOCTi BHMOraM 3A3. * JAep)KaBHe Ka3Ha4eACTBO YKpalHH BHKOHYC neBHi cjyHKHii ay,AHTy npH BHnniaTi KOWITiB 3a yroAaMH 3riAHO 3 HaKa3oM Ka3HaMerlcTBa N289. Ka3Ha'eHcTBo Mae 129 MicueBHx 4iniHI Ha perioHanbHoMy (o6.nacHoMy) piBHi i 27 BIZIAiAiB B paHOHax i MiCTax. nonpanKa Ao 3)13 Bi, rpyAHR 2005 pOKy nocHiuHna pOJlb Ka3HamerlcTa y cfepi 3aKyniBenlb. * Jlo 3MiHH JIo 3aKoHy Bi, rpyAHAI 2005 POKY MiHicTepCTBo eKOHOMiKH (JIKA3) AiAno fK ynOBHOBaxKeHHrl aep)KaBHHrl opraH y cfepi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBejlb 3ri,AHO 3 HaKa3OM MiHeKOHOMiKH Ns238. * BHyTpiuIHi peBi3itiHi BiJAiJIH B KO2KHir 3aKyniBeJIbHiA opraHi3auil rOjiOBHHM I4HOM Bi,anOBiJIalOTb 3a 4)iHaHcoBHfA KOHTPOJb Ta ayallT. 85. Ao JiKBiRaUiI B rpyAHi 2005 poicy AIQ3 BitAOBi.aB 3a nonepeRHifl pO3rFJIM 3aKyniBeJlb. LUi pO3rnJIflH 3ocepeAlKyBanH yBary rOnOBHHM HHHOM Ha npoHO3HHIiHx IU°.0 3aKyniBJi B OAlHoro ymaCHHKa i Toprax 3 o6MexKeHoTo yiacT1o. 3 J]iKBiAaLLieio JCK,3 ui PO3rnflRlH npHnHHHuHCb. Ka3Haqe;icTBo BHKOHye ayAUHT npoueAypH 3aKyniBeJIb AO 3AirCHeHH.9 BHrIJIaT 3a yKna,AeHHMH yroaaMH. HaKa3 X289 (n. 12.3) ReplKaBHoro Ka3HaqeHcTBa BHMarae BiA noca,RBLliB, AKi onpauboByIoTb onepaiiif, nepeBipAlTH HacTynHi JAOKyMeHTH: 3BiTH 3 OUiHKH, yrOAH, npIHiManbHi BiARoMOCTi, 3aTBepAweHH.R YO npouefAypH 3aKyniBJ]i B O0AHOro yqacHHKa Ta TopriB 3 o6MeKeHoIo yqacT1o, paxyHKH-4aKTypH TOIUO. 86. 3aramoM Ka3Ha%eficTBo UpOBOAHTTb eIjeKTHBHi ayAHTH UpH onpaUlIoBaHHi IOrOBipHHX BHuJnaT. BHypiU]Hiri Ta 3OBHilUHiH4 ayAUJTOpH Kpa7HH (KPY i PaxyHKOBa nanaTa) nOCHJIIO*OTb CBO1O CnpOMO)KHiCTb WJIAXOM npHAHSfl1TT Mi)KHapoAHHx cTaHMapTiB ayJlHTy, HaBMaHH3[ CBOIX npaUiBHHKiB Ta 3anpOBsaAKeHH31 CygaCHHX MeToRiB. 3anpoBa.WKeHHfl MeToAiB Ha OCHOBi OUiHKH pH3HKiB 3a6e3ne4ye 3ocepeAxceHHf yBarH ayAHTopiB Ha cq)epax 3 Hart6iJ1bW rHMOBipHHMH npo6neMaMH, a He Ha npOCT0rMy npoBeAeHHi nOTomHHx nepeBipoK 3riAHO 3 HOpMaTHBHHMH RoKyMeHTaMH. 3aKyniBeni BHMaraloTb UiJIbOBOf yBarm, OCKiJbKH HHHi BOHH c c4)epolo BHCOKOro pH3HKy. 87. 06roBopeHH9 3 KPY i 3BiT PaXyHnKOBOT uaaTH CBiA4aTb, UI ii 0Bi opraHi3aBiY;y6JnlOlOTb CBOI 43yHIKUi. 06HABi opraHi3aLii npoBoaRTb aygHTH niCflI 3aKyniBeJlb, JIKi rOJIOBHHM 4HHOM o6Me)KyloTbcm nepeBipKaMH BiAROBiAHOCTi. LliJIbOBi ayAHTH 3aKyniBeeib c HenOUIHpeHHM MBHIlueM. AygHT 3aKyniBeJ]b BHKOHYCTbC5I B paMKaX 3aranJbHoro ayaHTy niAnlpHcMcTBa. KPY nPOBOJAHTb uli ayAHTH 3riIIHO 3 rpa4 iKoM. PaxyHKoBa naJiaTa, f1K npaBH.jo, nPOBOfHTb iX B paMKax ULJibOBHX aOCnJiKeHb. 88. BHICOHaHH8 peicoMeHmmaui caa6ke BHaCJ1iWOK HeeCeKCTHBHOrO ylpaBJliiHHH Ta o6MeceHoro KOHTpOJlio. KPY i PaxyHKoBa naniaTa HaAajiiH BaHKy iH¢opMauiho npO HaH6inbUw nowlHpeHi nopywIIeHHH, BHABJIeHi niA qac ocTaHHbOrO nfnaHOBOrO KOHTpOjUo. AHajli3 CBiA'HTL, tuo 6araTbox npo6JleM MO)KHa 6ynio 6 YHI4KHYTH, AIKilO 6 PO3n10pAHHKH 610X*KeTHHX KOWTiB 3HaJnH 6inbiEe npo 3A3 i BKluO 6 YO 33 3fim 3 oiLHKU 3aKynieeqb f YKpaiui - 2006 piK HaAaBaB Kpani peKoMeHAa4i; LUOAO BnpOBawKeHHI. PaXyHKOBa ariaaTa He p03KpHBac iH4opMaLito npo BHKoHaHHH; i KPY piAKo KOHTpOJllOC BHKOHaHHR, ZKIUO, cfaKTWMHo, He peKOMeHAOBaHO 3acTocyBaHHR caHKLtir (te BHMaraC 3BiTyBaHHX nepeA 3aKoHoaaB3qHMH opraHaMH). Ka3HaqeAcTBo noBiLoMnAC, uo Bi,aMoBa B 3AiACHeHHi BHninaT C HaH6iJbmu ceeKTHBHOlO i nowu;peHoio caHKLtiClo Ka3HaqeHcTBa. 3pO3yMino, 11o B eASKHX BHIaAjKaX BHHlJaTH He 3Ai4CHIOIOTbCI; OAHaK aaHi Ka3HaqeriCTBa He nOKa3ytOTh, AK qacTo 3AiACHIOBaJiOCb nloBTOpHe nOAaHHA 3aABOK Ao nlpOBeaeHHX BHIInnaT. 89. HonpaBKoCo Bij rpyAHg 2005 poKiy peopraHi30BaHo KOHTPOJlb 3a 3aKyIiBIUMH i CTpyKTYpY ayRHTy. 3aranoM nonpaBKa iCTOTHo nocJia6Hna XyHKLiXf KOHTPOji1o i HariiAy BHacJiiaoK pO3nOAiIly 4YHKUiH 3aKyniBfii cepeA pi3HHX OpraHiB BnaJH. HaBeAeHHri aHani3 AeMOHCTpyc npaKTHMHi Hacni.aKH p03no3iniy (DyHKUir. 90. Xoga AHTHMOHOHOJIlbHUH icoMiTeT c YnOBHOBaSCeHHM OpraHOM, BiH BiaIIOBiac J[HWe 3a KoopA1HHaRito i MOHiTOpHHr. I4oro pOllb o6Me)KyCTbCs (a) 3aTBepAwKeHHAM npouetlypH 3aKyniBni B OlaHoro yqacHHKa i TOpriB 3 o6MexceHolo yqacTto (3roaoM - nHiue 3a nonepeAHiM BHCHOBKOM CKK) Ta (b) P03rnWAoM BiAnoBiAHOCTi 3aKyniBeJIbHol opraHi3aLTiI BHMOraM 3JA3. KPY HHHi BiAnoBilaC 3a BiAnlOBiAHiCTb pO3nOpRLIHHKiB 6jo;meTHHX KOUITiB BHMoraM 3A3, TOAi 5K iHWli OpraHH TaKO)K 3AiRCH101OTh HarjlAA. AJep)KaBHe Ka3Ha4eACTB0 3fnikCHlOC KOHTrpob 3a 6ioAKeroM. JAepwKaBHHR KOMiTeT CTaTHCTHKH YKpaTHH 36Hpac i BeAe peeceTpailo tiaHUx npo 3aKyniuAi. MiHicTepcTBo arpapHo; nOJiiTUKHi CTBOOpOC YMOBH pnx 3aXHC1y BiT-H3HsRHHX CiJbrocnToBWpOBHpo6HHKiB lSnXOM B3acMoAif 3 YO, iHWI£MH opraHamH BEaAH Ta 3aMoBt-HKaMH. OpraHH npaBonopSAKy BiAnOBialOTb 3a MOHiTOP1HHr He3aKoHHHx 3aKyniBeb. CKK BHIlac BHCHOBKH AHTHMOHOnOJIlbHOMy KOMiTeTy i 3aKyniBeJIbHiI4 opraHi3aliT uoAo 3aKyniBeJlb 3 o6Me)KeHoio y'acno Ta B OAHoro yqaCHHKa. CKK po3rnsiAae cKaprH npo nopyLueHH2. TeHwepHiri naanaTi HaAaHO HagBa2KnHBiIIi ()yHKhlI, ziKi 3BH4aAHi Hane)KaTb YO - HaAaHHS meToAHUHx peKomeHlaaitii, 3aTBrep)eHHZ npouegypH TroprB 3 o6Me)KeHO10 yqacTto i KnlO4B3a pOllb B po3rsAi CnipHHX nHTaHH.. 91. K23aqeCTrBO noTpe6yc IOlaJlWiIUO 3MiUHeHHU T2 iHITeFpyBaHHn B CHCTeMy ytlpaBJIiHHSI Aepm;aslrMm iHaHCaMH. Ba3H AaH yCTaHOB, 1Ki BinIlOBiAalTb 3a Aep)KaBHi 43iHaHcH, noTpi6Ho iffrerpyBnaH. HanpHmnaA, Ka3HaqeilcTBo Mac 6yTH cnpoMoxHe niATBepalKyBaTH iCHyBaHHS TeHaepHHUX HOBiAOWIeHb B pe2HMi on-line i noTiM nepeBipNrH OCHOBHi KOHTeKCTyaBJbHi AaHi. B ubOMY BHnaaKY pimemn moAo npo2teryp TrOpriB 3 o6MexceHoio yqacro MoxHa 6yno 6 peccTpyBaTH B YO. Ka3Hawelicmo morno 6 niureepxjKyBaT iH4xopMagilo aBToMaTH9Ho. licn51 ny6MiKaliY Ka3HaqeiCTBO mor.no 6 MaTH AocTyn Ao iH4opMauiY npo BapTicTb KoHTpaxTiB. [IpH peccTpaiuii yroA Ka3HaMeACTBoM pO3HOpimHxCH 6oflx*eTHlmx KolUTiB MOrCJli 6 OTpiMyBaTH peCypcH BqaCHO. PeKOAeeH6at4& > locHNUTm Ka3HaqeNcTBo uIXOM 3anpoBaJKeHHI iHTerpOBaHoi cHcTeMH ynpaBJ]iHHS AeplKaBHHMH 4iHaHcaMH. Ka3HaseAcTBo Ta iHWli AepXKaBHi opraHH nOBHHHi BnpOBaLHTH MOAy.nb B3aCMOli MUiK iCHYIOqHMH iH4)OpMauiHHHMH cHCTeMaMH. Hoatezwuelim oocmyny oo iM0opmatil 92. Heo6xinHO ObitAifiHo OflpHJIIOHHTUH 3aKOHO09B-ii iHCTpyMeHTH, Sii OXOllJIIOIOTh npaBa, CBo60,RH Ta 060B'931CH Jl1o0RHHH. A1KMO noio)KeHHAMH 3aKOHY He nepeA6aMeHo iHwe, 3aKOH Ha6upae tHHHiCTb qepe3 10 RHiB nicnA ny6niKauiY. HOoJiTHKa YPARAY 1o00 p03KpHTTS iHd)opMauf BsHMarac, u1o6 yCi 3aKoHoEaBqi i peryJIATHBHi AOKyMeHTH onpHJlIOAHIOBaIIHCb B 3MI. ,AesKi ny6niKauii MiCTSTb HOBi 3aKoHH, AIHpeKTHBH Ta iHUli HOpMaTHBHi aKTH. 3aKoH YKpaYHH npo Mi)KHapOAHi yroAH (L1906-IV Bii 29 qepBHA 2004 poKy; cTarrA 21, n. 1) 3o6oB's3yC, *uo6 yci 3aKOHH i MbKHapoAHi yroAu 6yrnu ony6xniKoBaHi B cneuiaJi3OBaHHX BHAaHHJX. 93. 3P,3 BUMarac ONPHJIIOJIHHHSJ iH4)opMaatM npo 32KIyniBJsi B OiuiriHHX ,ypHna.ax i B Mepe2Ki IHTepHeT. OaHaK )KOAHa iHiuiaTHBa 3MI He noiH4bOpMyBana rpoMaLWH i niAnPHCMCTBa npo BHrOAH i HaciiiaKH pe4XopM y c4bepi Alep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenlb. ,AAS Toro, luo6 nlOKpaULHTH iH4¢OpMOBaHiCTb rpoMaAIH, YO Mae lipOBeCTH KaMriaHil iHd)opMyBaHHS HaCeJieHHS 3a AOflOMOrOlO BAOCKOHaJIeHHX APYKOBaHHX 3aco6iB MaCOBOY iH4opMauif, TeJne6ateHHs, paAio Ta iHWHX 3MI. 34 3sim 3 0yiHKU 3aKynieeilb e YKpawHi - 2006pix PemoMeHdagif > HoKpaiUHTH iHCTHTyLtirlHHvl noTeHL1ia8 i KOMyHiKai1iUHi BMiHHS B YO ARns npOBeAleHHA e4eKTHBHHX npOCBiTHHbLKHX KaMTiaHirl. > 3anpoBaAHuT KaMnaHilo iH4)opMyBaHHq rpoMaJACbKOCTi B KpalHi 3a AlOnOMOr0io paJRio, TeJIe6ameHHR, Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT i ApyKoBaHHx 3MI. Ile nepexa6a'ae perynsipHe nOBioMJieHHS iH4fopMaau1, npOBeAeHHS ceMiHapiB i 4)OpyMiB. ETHKa i 3aXO,A UpOTHAuii KOpyUJJiJ 94. B aeniCHX 32KOH2X MiCTHTbCH OKpeMi IOCHJiaHHH H2a KOpyniUiiO, B TOMy qHCJli B TaKHX 3aIcoH2X i CTarTTHX: * KapHHi Ko,aeKC YKPaYHH 3aCTOCOyBC caHKUif npOTH oci6, LUo B,aIoTbCR A1o AIaBaHHSi xa6apiB (cTarsl 368) Ta ix npAHHRTrs (uTawri 369). * CTarrA 7.2 3.Z3 BH3HMa4c YMOBH BiaXHiieHHS nponO3HUl, SIKIXO yMaCHHK 3anponOHYBaB xa6ap (HeMae nonocKeHHA npo IOpMyBaHHA 'OpHoro cnIHcKy yMacHHKiB). * 3aKoH YKpaYHH npo 6opOTb6y 3 KopynrAiClo BiA 1995 pOKy (He 3raAyeTbca B 303 Bi, 2001 poKy) 3aCTOCOBYC caHKLli f npOTH KOpyMnOBaHHX aUi Lep)KaBHHx cnyK6oB0UiB, anie )KOAHHM 'HHOM He nOCHJIaCTbCS Ha ymaCHHKiB TopriB. 95. Yica3 lpe3HAqeHTa npo upiOpHTeTHi 38XORH 60pOTb6H 3 TiHi3a8iciO eICOHOMiKH Ta Kopynilicio Bin 18 HncTonajxa 2005 pOxy 3060B'R3ye Ka6iHeT MiHiCTPiB nogmTH Ha p03FlAa Hpe3HAeHTy "HeBiKnamHi npoeKTH 3aKoHiB" 3 TaKHX nHTaHb, RK: (a) BH3HaqeHHfl KopynUii i THniB KOpyMnoBaHoI npaKTHKH; (b) BH3HateHHA KOH(MJ]KTiB iHTepeCiB )1nSl aep2KaBHHX cnyxc6oBuiB; (c) B,UOCKOHaneHHx npouejyp Iao0o AeK apyBaHHA aep)KaBHHMH CJIY)K6OBI5MH CBO;x ,OXo0iB i HepyxoMoro MaHlHa; Ta (d) "3a6e3netieHHs HaAaHHA aep)KaBHHX nocjiyr 41i3HqHHM Ta IOPHRlHmHHM oco6aM... 3a JlonoMoroio eJieKTpOHHHX iH4¢opMauiHiHHx CHcTeM". L1erl yKa3 (n. 2.4) TaKo)K 3ammnuae Ano 3anymeHHSI, KpiM iHWIHX, Mi)KHapoaHHX OpraHi3auill =A niArOTOBKH HeO6xiHoro 3aKOHoJaBcTBa. BnpoBa,IKeHHs i npaKTM4He BHKOHaHHJI 3axo1iB 6OpoTb6H 3 KOpynuiCio C c()epolo, A0o nliATPHMKH SKOf Mo)Ke AOJy'qHTHC.9 BaHK. PeKoMeHoagif > C4opMyJIIoBaTH qiTKO BH3Ha4eHy nOJIiTHKy u0oAo nopyuleHHH npoLleAypH 3aKyniBenb, sIKa oxonrnoe: (a) BH3Ha'eHHiI KOHKpeTHHX nopyUieHb (TaKHx ilK TaeMHa 3MOBa, HeBiAnOBiAHe pO3KpHTTS iHcFopMauiY npo pe3yJlbTaTm MHHyj1OrO AOCBiAy); (b) 1H4)epeHLxiaLXilO 3aKOHoAaBqBX iHcTpyMeHTiB (KapHHU Ko11eKc, 3aKOH, SIKJi peryjiioe IiRJbHiCTb 1ep)KaBHHX cjiyw60BUiB, 3aKOH npo 3aKyniBni); (c) Kpalue BH3HageHHx nOB S13aHHx caHKuiri (HaripHmuIa, 4OpMyBaHHA qOpHoro cnucKy); (d) HaJem)KHy npoueAypy 3aCToCyBaHHil caHKUiU; i (e) cripaBeZuIHBe BMKOHaHHS caHKUiri. F lOCJIIiTH 3ano6iraHHA BLIHHeHHIO AiMi UJRXOM OllpHJIlO1HeHH1 yCiX BHnlaaKiB riopyweHb B eCJeKTPOHHHX i nanepoBHx BepciAx BiCHUKa 6epoicaeHux 3aKyni6eeb. 5AKIuo MOKMHBO, OHPHJIIO1AHHTH Ha3BH nOpYWIHHKiB i 4IopMyritoBaHHI BHHeceHHx nOKapaHb. B HeiUoaaBHiri TeJieBi3iriHiri nporpaMi npo Kopynuilo y KOHTeKCTi npoeKTiy "YKpaHa-CC" MiHiCTp BHyTpilWHiX cnpaB 1Opiri IyLIeHKo 3a3HaMHB, lUo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJIi e KnaCHUHHM npHKnaLOM TOrO, AK BHCOKOnOCa,0OB11i 3aXHiuaiOTb iHTepeCH CBOrO TiHbOBOrO 6i3Hecy. BiH onHcaB BHriaHOK, KOjiH BiH oTpHMaB CBiaqeHHA Toro, luo TeHnepHa nanaTa 36Hpac i nepepaxoBye rpomi 3a aonoMOrOio KBa3i4)ipM. 3 uorO CJIiB, BiH HalIpaBHB npaUiBHHKiB AJIA BHJiyqeHHA AOKyMeHTiB, wo6 nepeHaTH ix ao reHepajibHoY npoKypaTypH. Ha *anb, r1oMy nOBiaOMHJIH, l10o m'ieHH BepxoBHOY PaHr Bme BHuJIYMHJIH Ui AOKyMeHTH, RKi Mae P03rnilHYTH cneuianbHa KOHTpOJbHa KOMiCiS. KojiH BiH no0aaB 3anHT 1UO110 UiCi KOMiCiY cniKepy BepxoBHoY Pa,aH, UOMy BiarioBLnIH, U10 KOMiCiA npHnuHHHHJa CBOC iCHyBaHH.9 0o 3HHKHeHHS .AOKyMeHTiB. 35 3eim 3 OU,iHKU 3aKynieeAb 6 YKparHi - 2006piK 6. EJIEXTPOHHI 3AKYHIBJII 96. BaraToo6iU9oqi ICpOICH 3PO6aeHi B Htnp9MIKY PO3ropTaHHSI CHCTeMH eJieKCrpOHHUX ,aepWaBHHX 3aIyniBeji6 B YKpapHi. LA OLIiHKa 30cepeApKeHa Ha HaCTYnHHX cKiiaAoBHx: AnepxKa3He KepiBHHLtTBo, noniTtIKa i HOpMaTHBHa 6a3a, aKTHBi3auiW nOKyniLUB i noCTa'IanbHHKiB, iH4)paCrpyKTypa i CTaH,RapTT Ta CHCTCMH i ripoLueypH.6 97. EaraTHi A1OCBi1 BKa3YC Ha Heo6xiQHiCT6 nOTY>KHoro AePxeaBHoro EepiBHUHuTBa RiC OCHOBHoro MexaHi3My peaji3auri CHCTeMH eCJeIcTpOHHHX aepwaBHUX 3aKyniBenb. HIocTaHoBa Ka6iHeTy MiHicTPiB N21469 noKnana Ha KonIHUHirl )AKA3 OCHOBHi 4yHKuii KepiBHHLtTBa. BoHa BH3Haqana nPOBiAHY POnb MiHicTePCTBa eKOHOMiKU B MOARCpHi3auif CHCTeMH Laep)KaBH4X 3aKyniBeJ]b, BKJIOqalO0H CHCTTMey eneKTpOHHHX Rep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeilb. flpoeKT cTpaTerif pe4OpMyBaHHs CHCTeMUi ArepKaBHHux 3aKyniBeJb JmOpyqusHB AKJA3 yHKuilo BianOBiLaJabHOCTi 3a iH4)opMauir4Hi TexHonoril. Yci AepwlaBHi opraHli, onHTaHi AnA LiJIeri uie; oliHKH, BH3HanJ npiOBiAHY ponb JtKJA3 y c4epi eCieKTpOHHHX faepaKaBHHX 3aKynimeib. BHacniiloK 3MiHH ao 3aKOHy BiAI rpyLHS 2005 pOKy He3po3yMiLJo, AKHri opraH (AUXWO BiH e) HHHi 3,AiICHI0C KepiBHHUTBo CeiKTPOHHHMHa 1ePxcaBHHMH 3aKynIiBJAMi. Pexomen6a&u > flocHnHTH 4yHKxLil YO ('iH 6y,Lb-SKoro iHroro opraHy, Ha AKUHi 6yae noKnaleHo OCHOBHy BihnoBiJanibHicT6) y c4epi 3anpoBajpKeHHA CH4CTeMH CeJeKTPOHHHx Repl)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. ,AOnywHTm BCiX BUIHOBiAHHX yqaCHHKiB RO AIOBrOCTPOKOBOrO npoulecy nIaHyBaHHS. 98. 'qHuHa HOJliTHIkS i HOPM2THBH2 6a3a CTBOPIOI0Tb MiuHe uiJfrpyHTa IJISI juHpoj oro 3anposa=ceHen iH#opMauiruux TeXHoJoriOi. rlporpaMa Airi YPsAY "Ha3yCTpi4 JIOLIAM" HaAae BeKnuKOro 3HaCeHHx KoMnneKcHiA nporpaMi "EneiKTpoHHa YKpafHa". 3oKpeMa, npoeKT cTpaTerii pe4opMyBaHA cHcTeml Aep)JaBHHX 3aKyniiBeJb nepea6aqac cTpaTerilo BnpoBaB)KeHHM Ce1iKTpOHHHX ALepxKaBHHX 3aKyniBejvb i cTBopeHHs ClAHHoro nopaiiy 3aKyniBeJlb B pe)Ki4Mi on-line. )IjihomH1i 3JA3 6e3nocepeAHbo nocuiaeTbcA Ha eneKTpOHHi 3aco6H pO3KpHTrA iH4)opMauif npo lep)KaBHi 3aKyniB.ii Ta eileKTpOHHi 3aKyniBnii B paMKax TpaHcaKLtii. OLIHaK IOpHAH4Ha BHMora wowo CTBopCHHS CnPHMTJIHBHX YMOB AM KoHKypeHLii 4HCJ1eHHHX iHmopMairiHHX CHCTem niATPHMKH eCieKTpOHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBC1b He Bi.noBillaC HaflKpal1iHi npaKTHLli. ICHyIOTb noTeHLUiHHi YMOB14 AM 3pocTaHHA rUTyTaHHHyH, aAMiHiCTpaTHBHHX BHTpaT, huy6lOBaHHA 3yCHnb i TpyAHO11liB. rpaBoBi acneKTm 3anpoBa,)KeHHA eneKTpoHHOi AOKyMeHTaI.if npo 3aKyniBJi BHpililye AlOfaTKOBe 3aKOHo0aBCTBO y Ltiu c4)epi, 3OKpeMa, 3aKOH npo eneIKTpoHHY AoKyMeHTaBiio 'H 3aKOH npo eneKTpoHHHri ninuHC, AKHH reHepyC Bu4ro'u4 3aBlAIKH nepexoAy BiA lt4poBHX Ao CJleKTpOHHHX nliAnHCiB. PeKoMena&4 > PO3po6UTU cTpaTeriio BnpOBalKeHHA CHCTCMU eiieKTpOHHHX aep)KaBHHX 3aKyni3eJlb, BKJIioxiaJ04H noeTauHHn nmaH Airu, Ta opraHi3yBaTr HaBIaJIbHHrt ceMiHap 3 nflTaHb eJIeKTpOHHHX Aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeJIb 3a y'acTIo Mi)KHapO11HHX opraHi3auil Ao o4 opM1iCHHA OCTaTO'HOI BepCii cTpaTerii. > HlepernsHy-rH BiRnOBiaHi nonoKceHHA 10o,o eCIeKTPOHHHX aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBellb B 3J43. Po3rnsiHyTH MO)KJ1HBiCTb BKjHOqeHHS aeTaJbHHX nocHIIaHb Ha yMOBm BI4KOpCTaHHA iH4)opMaauitHHX cHcTeM B npoLjeaypax lepc)KaBHHX 3aKyniBCJEb B niA3aKoHHe 3aKOHoRaBCTBO. > Po3r.ruHyTr MO)KCJHBiCTb BHKOpuCTaHHS CUHHoro nopT8aJy eCJeKTpOHHHX aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBellb Ans o6oBsA3KOBHX ny6&iKaLtifi i TpaHCaKUtir. > HpI4 p03r1lRAi 3A3 i 3aKOHy npo eneKTpOHHIH4 niAnLiC BpaxyBaTH BiAnOBiAHe 3aKOHoAaBcTBO CC npo enieKTpOHHi AlepxKaBHi 3aKyniB.ni. 6OLQiHKa no6yuoBaHa Ha iHcTpyMeHTi BH3HaMeHHA roToBHoCTi AO BanpOBa.LKeHHA CHCTeMH CeJeKTPOHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyriiBenb, po3po6&eHoMy po6otio rpynoio 6araToCTOpOHHix 6aHKiB pO3BHTKy Ha OCHOBi CniJIbHHX 3yCHJ1b (http://www.mdb-egp.org/data/docs/Ouestionnaire.pdf). 36 3eim 3 O0iHKU 3aKyniBeeJb 6 YKpalHi - 2006piK 99. BIAoclcOHSJHTH CHCTeMH i npoiieiAypH eCeJTpOHHHX ,AepcasBHHX 3acynisejib. 3JA3 BHMarac Bi, 3aMOBHHKiB pO3MiI1myBaTn oroJiomueHHq "npHHaRMHi B OAHiri iH4OpMauirmHir CHCTeMi B Mepe)Ki IHTepHeT" 3riRHO 3 npOueAypaMH, BCTaHOBJleHHMH UiCIO CHCTeMoIO. Jaiii 3aKOH (cTa-rr 4-2, 3anpoBaa)KeHa nonpaBKOIO B JiHcTonai 2004 pOKy) nepexA6aqac cepTm4iKauiio iH4opMaHixiHOY CHCTeMH 3 ypaXyBaHH1M Bce6i'qHHX 3acTepemeHEi, po3po6ineHHx genapTaMeHTOM 3 nHTaHb cneuiajibHHx CHCTeM 3B'313Ky Ta 3axHcTy iH¢opMauiY B CEY. OAHaK CEY (B JiHCTi, AaTOBaHOMy 28 rpyAHs 2005 poKy) 3a3Haqac, uao Aiio'i yKpaIHCbKi cariTH (,QBa Ma8oTb aApecy: www.zakupivli.com CKA i www.tender.net.ua BicHUKa 6ep3CaeHUX 3aKynieeJJb) BiRnOBiatOTb BHMOraM cTaTri 4-1, n. 2 i crarri 4-2, n. 1. Lie OAHH Be6-caAT www.e-tenders.kiev.ua o6'CJaHaHo 3 CariTOM www.zakupivli.com. BepyqH jao yBarH, LUO iHIi nopTaJIH TaKO)K pO3MiILyIOTb noBiAoMjeHHA npo Aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBrli, HeneBHicTb cHTyauif AnAx nOKyniiB i nocTa'ianbHiHKiB 3pocTae. PeKomeHdatif > YO Mae 3MeHUIHTTH BenJHKY KiJbKicCTb Be6-caAiTiB LIAR Xep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb laO OAHOrO OfilirfHoro nOpTany eneKTpOHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeab, 311KHU Bi,AnoBiJaae BHMOraM KOpHcTyBaqiB. > YO Mae 36inbuiIHTH KiJIbKiCTb onufLi B TpaHCaKUiAlX, TaKHX AK eIieIKTpOHHi TOpru, eneKTpOHHa peecmpauiA, eJ1eKTpOHHHri 3BOpOTHHri ayKUiOH, enJeKTPOHHe ynOPAAKYBaHHR 3aMOBneHb Ta eneKTpoHHi nnaTe)Ki 3riLRHO 3i cTpaTerieCO 3anpoBaaqLKeHHH KOMnHIeKCHOY CHCTeMH eiJeKTPOHHHX AepwKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJnb. 37 3eim 3 OZiHKU 3aKynieellb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK 7. BHKOHAHHH yrola,IPO ,TEPXCABHI 3AKYHIBJII 100. KiuusiCT]6 i BapTicTb BiACKpHTnX (KOnHcypeHTHux) TOpriB HeBUHHHO 3pOcTac. B 2002 poLai flHwe 7 BiCOTKiB TeHwxepiB (MeHwle Hi)K 50 BiACOTKiB y BapTiCHoMy Bipa)KeHHi) npoBeAeHo 3a npoueAypolo BixUpK4THx TopriB. go 2005 POKY UA uH#pa 3pocna 4o 26 BiACOTKiB (69 BiACOTKiB Y BapTicHoMy BHpaxceHHi). BinnoBiAHo, 3MeHLIIHBC BiCOTOK yroA, yKJ1aAeHHX 3a 3aKyniBJIAMi4 B OAHoro ymaCHHKa 3 21 Ao 10 Bi,COTKiB nrpoTrom 2000-2005 pp. (3 24 Ao 15 BiACOTKiB y BapTiCHOMy BHpa>KeHHi). AHanoriqHe 3MeHUeHHA piBHA BiA6yjiOCA 3a npouLeAypaMH LtiHOBHX KOTHpyBaHb Ta 3aKyniBJIAMH 3 o6me)KeHo1o y-lacTio. OaHaK ili LkH44pH He OXOnnIOIOTb yrOQLH 3a 3aKyni3J]AMM B O0,HorO y4acHHKa, yKnaAeHi Aep)KaBHHMH m niAnpticMCTBaMH, Ta 3aKyniBfli, BHny4eHi 3riAHO 3 nono)KeHHAMh4 CraTri 2 (3) 3J3. 101. Ta6JnMl 2 OK-a3yC 3MiHU i TeHAeHUi; y BHKOpUCT3HHi n' 9TH MeToJIiB 3aCyfliBhJi. Ba31JHBHM 3acTepe)KeHHSM C Te, 10o AaHi Rep)KaBHoro KOMiTeTy CTaTHCTHKH He MiCTRTb nOBHOi iH+opMaigilf npo BCi PO3HOPRJAHHKH 6IoAceTHmX KOulTiB. Ta6aHKu 2. Teaeentii- BHKopRCTraHHSi Me-oAliB 3alCyniBJi B 2002-2005 pp. (y BiJcoTTKax) 2002 2003 2004 2005 3a 3& 32 3a 3a 3a 3a 3a KlAi,KkTMO BpTXl KhiKbieTIC WpT KUiLiT BIPnCTI KUabKiCTO D1pTiCTio BiA,cHTi ToprH 7,1 49,7 11,2 56,0 11,9 50,4 25,8 68,9 ToprH 3 o6Mec)KeHOio 1,6 6,7 1,1 4,9 2,3 5,3 2,5 3,4 yqaCTIO BoeaHi TOprm 0,1 0,5 0,i 0,5 0,1 2,0 0,1 1,3 3ajHT riHoBsx 70,5 18,7 71,1 14,8 74,0 15,9 63,1 11,4 KOTHPYBWHb OJIHOF yiacBui a 20,8 23,3 16,5 23,9 11,7 26,3 8,5 15,3 A NqeAe: JCPZ3BUI KOM= CraTHCnH. 102. Ta6anulg 2 meMoncTpyC TeHJteHnLiNo 3POCT2HHU B HanPflMKY BHKopnCTaHHg 6ijibUI ICOHKypeHTHuX meTojin. He3BaKawioqH Ha tie, BHKOpHCTaHHI MeTOAa 3aKynifni B OAHoro y4acHHKa e BiAHOCHO BHCOKHM - 15,3 BiACOTKiB BiA 3aranibHoro o6cAry B 2005 poUi (3a nonepeAHiMH oLIiHKaMH 4,1 m.np.A.ojion. CIUA). Ui aaHi He oXoniUioJoTh BHsiyqeHi nyHKTH B cTaT'i 2, n. 3 3A3. [Ji u114)pH TaKO)K He OXOImIOIOTb BenMHKH o6cmr 3aKyniBeMb, 3AiricHeHi{x Aep)KaBHHM4 niAnpHCMcTBaMH, JKi 3 TO; qli iHUWOi npHqHHH He 3aB)KIH AOTpHMYIOTbCS npoueayp 3J3. AKLUO B rOBHiH Mipi BpaxyBaTH BiaCOTOK 3aKyniBejlb B ORHOrO y'aCHHKa y Aep)KaBHOMy ceKTopi YKpadHi, BiAnOBiRHHrl nOKa3HI4K MarlKC HaneBHe HenpHIHSATHO 3poCTe. 103. Aoj1aToK 2 MiCTHTb HOKB3HHKH BHKOHaHHSI, 3a BKHMH OIIiHIOeTbcTeSU eeKTHBHiCTb CHCTeMH )xepC2IBHHX 3alKyniBeJb. Li nOKa3HHKH OXOrlrIiOlOTb BaxKJiBi 4HHHHKH, TaKi AK LtHKJ1 3aKyniBeJib, BHKOpiCTaHHA MeToAiB 3aKyniBJi, yKiiaAeHHA npRMHX yroA, npoLieAypy OCKap)KeHHSI, 3aTpHMKY BHnJIaT, niABHiueHHS LtiH Ta MeTOAH Biz6opy KOHCyJIbTaHTiB. HOpiBHAHHS 4,aKTH4HHX piBHiB, AOCAHrHyT11X B YKpaYHi, 3 rpHriHATHHMHI nOKa3HHKaMI BapTiCHOi MeeKi nOKa3yc, LUO KpadHa MYCHTb BAOCKOHanHTH CBO; npoaieAypH i npaKT1K4K. 104. B npO3Opifl i BiIKpHTiM CHCTemi 3aKyniBeAb HpHHaHMHi noHaa 95 BiACOTKiB TeHAepHHX oro.JoweHb i pe3yJibTaTiB TopriB onpHJlOHIXeOCTbCg. B 2004 pOLti B YKpaYHi ony6.niKoBaHo oronoweHb 3a 70 BiACOTKaMH TeHAepiB i pe3yiibTaTiB TOpriB. HlepioA BiA oroiOuleHHA TopriB Ao pO3KpHTA5 nponO3HLXiri Mae CTaHOBHTH MiHiMyM 21 AeHb. 3,43 nepeA6aqeHo 45 KaneHAap H4 Hif3, iAeu 38 3sim 3 OyiHKU 3aKyniseelb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK CTpOK Mo)Ke 6yTH 3MellWeHeHi Ao 21 KaneHRapHoro AHSI (9H AO 10 KanieHAaPHHX AHiB, KOmH BHKOpuCTOByeTbCH npoiiexypa TopriB 3 06Me)KeHOI0 y9acrio). PexoMenoaqig > YO CTBOpHTH CHCTeMy 360py i BeaeHHSI AaHHX Ha OCHOBi IIOKa3HHKiB BHKOHaHHR, HaBeAeHHX B VOAaTKy 2. Ili nOKa3HHKH llOBHHHi BHKOpHCTOBYBaTHCSI ARM OLiHKH TOrO, HaCKiJIbKH rapHo (yHKLliOHyC CHcTeMa i rlepioJHqHoro 3acToCyBaHHSI KOPHryBaJIbHHX A0iH. 39 3eim 3 OZjiHiKU 3aKynieeilb e YKpazHi - 2006piK 8. 3BJAHKEHHA 3 THPERTHBAMH CC 1l0O,O 3AIYHIBERJI I IIPHC,AHAHHAH 0 COT HpalCTHra 3aKCyIiBJIi B CC 105. YucpaiHa lgocJiatAaC 3yCHJI6, CnPSMOBaHHX Ha 3a6ae3ueleHHSl BiIWOBiIHOCTi 3alcoHoIaBcTBa y c4epi AepCKaBHHX 3aKcyniBe6b CBponericiciii npaicTHii y paMIcax CBOIX uparHeHb Ao iHTerpalWii. AK noKa3yc OCTaHHiri A0CBiAl, 36nH)KeHHSl y c(epi 3aKyniBe.nb 3 CBpOnet4CbKHMH npaKTHKaMH 3BH4aHiHo Bitg6yBaCTbCA BHPOAOB)K KiJ]bKOX pOKiB, nepiLu Hi)K KpaNHa-KaHA[HaT CK0P4CTaCTbCS i3 B3acMOif 3 iHIIHWMH KpaiHaMH CC. He3eawatotm Ha Te, 11o ,aipeKTHBH CC 3060B'S3ylOTb AR0TpHMyBaTHCq uiber i CTpOKiB, KpaiHH MaIOTb 3Mory BH3HaHaTH 4opMy i 3aco6Hu LOTPHMaHHA LLHX BHMOr. 106. TaKi KpalH SAK YropuHHa, HOJnblLa i CnOBaM4HHa BBenJH B Rilo CBO; 3MKOHH npO Zaep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJIi Ha noqaTKY 90-x pp. MHHyflOrO CTOJ]iTTs Ha OCHOBi THnoBoro 3aKOHY npo 3aKyniBnIo TOBapiB, 6ylliBenbHHX po6iT i noc.nyr UNCITRAL Ta AHpeKTHB CC. [lpouec AROCArHeHHs BinIOBiJHOCTi 6yB nOCTynOBHrl. KpaYHH BHOCHJIH 3MiHH y CBOf BiAHOBiAHi 3,X3, neplU Hi2K CnPoMornJHCS CTaTH nOBHonpaBHIMH LJ1eHaMH CC. PeKomern6aq& > HiuiloBaTH BHB4IeHHA npofecy 36nHlKeHHSl Ha AOCBiAi KpalH, AKi HeiUoLaBHO IPHCUEHaJiHCb g0 CBponericbKOi CcniJbHOTI4, BKJnotiaOoqH YropLuHHy, CnoBaq'I4HHy i rOnbiny. Bcryn B COT, Bi"IbHa TOpriBJuI i AepcaBHi niJWPHCMCTBa 107. YKpaTHa nORaJ]a 3aHBK-Y Ha BCTyn B COT 30 JIHcTonaiaa 1993 poicy. gZo 2006 poKy YKpaYHa MaHlKe nOBHiCTIO 3aBepmiHna neperoBopH tuolo qneHCTBa B COT. OAHaK BHKOHaHHIo ii 3060B' 3aHb SK qneHa COT i, 3oKpeMa, neperOBOpaM L.uoxo GPA MOlKyTb 3aWlKO,4HTH KUibKa aCneKTiB B 3,13, B SKmg BHeceHi 3MiHM. 108. nepize, npe4)epeHwigHi nonpaBICHA0 KUiHH, nepei6a4eHi B cTaTTi 6, 3oKpeMa, nojio)IeHHU UiOjO 32axHcTy ciLibrocnToBapoBHpo6HHKiB, BB2KaalOTbCgI HMATO o6MeWKyBaJilbHHMH. 5K 3a3HaTlano0CA BHIie, nono)KeHHA, J1Ke nepeA6atac npaso pO3nOpslAHHKiB 6to0)KeTHHX KOWTiB BHMaraTH BHKopHcTaHHS MicLueBHX ToBapiB i po6oqof CHJH ARAs BHKOHaHHS po6iT B YKpaYHi, Mo)Ke 6yT4 HenpI41HJTHHM IA qneHiB GPA. 109. lonioiceHHsI, siKe noniHpIoC 3aCTOCyBaHHsi 31A3 Ha AepKcaBHi HeKcopnopaTHBHi KoMyHanbHi ni[tpUCMcTBa i niAnpHCMcTBa, B SIKHX qaCTKa aKLliii )Iep)KaBH CTaHOBHTb noHaA 50 BiACcoTKiB, MoxCe 6yTU NOTeHUjiHHO 6iJIbW 3Ha9ytUHM. 4JICHH COT MOAyTb 6yTH 3aHenOKoCHi nOiuHpeHHqM Ha ui nialnpHCMcTBa 3BHqarlHof npaKTHKH lepwKaBHHx 3aKyniBeseb,. Ka o6me)Kyc ix 3aKynisni 3LIe6inbuloro a6o BHKJIOqHO TOBapaMH, nocsiyramH Ta po6oTaMH BiT4H3HSHorO BHpO6HHuTBa. 1i nianpHeMCTBa 3BH4aHHO 3Iir4CHK)IOTb 3aKyniBni JR KOMepLtiriHHx LnLYeri, a He AiSA tirneri lep)KaBHoi IIOJIiTHKH. L|e nIUTaHHS MYCHTb 6yTH Bi4pimeHe 3a X1onoMoro0o nonpaBKH, sKa nepe,n6a,aC 3acToCyBaHHS ilaHoro 3MKOHY nulwe ,ao 3aKyniBen6 [I1aRepxKaBHHx noTpe6. 110. llotupemHsari; 3A3 Ha yci AepmKaBHi nliUpHCMCTBS Mome noripmiNHTH IX e4)eKTHBHicTb i 3aBiaTH IWIKOAH HalioHaJibHifi eKOHOMitli. 3 4acoM Aep*KaBHi nianpHcMcTBa npHCTOCYBanJHCb A0 HOpMan6bHHX KoMepuiriHHmx npoleZAyp npHA6aHHs OCHOBHOi CHpOBHHH. HOCHHIeHHA B 3,R3 npecDepeHUuii ARA1 BiTqH3HJIHHX ylaCHHKiB CnpHI14HHHTb RO 3pocTaHHA ifH)flIUuii. Le npilBelle [10 niLIBUuteHHS BaPTOCTi CHpOBHHH i KiHLIeBoi LIiHH Ha ToBaPH BUpo6Hi4LITBa. KpiM Toro, aoTpHMaHHAl npOLleLIypHHX BHMor 3aKOHY Mo)Ke CTBOpHTH HecnoiiBaHi TpyLlHOUii ARA5 BHpo6HHKiB 3a 6paKoM "AOcTaTHboro" qacy B yqacHHKiB Ha BHKOHaHHS. FloA[aTIbli 3aTpHMKH Mo0yrTb 6yTH CflpH4HHeHi npHMYCOBiM [pti3yflHHeHHAM npouenyp Ha 20-,aeHHHri CTpOK BHaCIiiLOK pO3rnAay CKapr, SKe Ha6yAe noiuHpeHHA. 40 3eim 3 OlJiHKU 3aKynieeilb 6 YKpaiii - 2006piK 111. YpgA nnIaHyC no'aTH neperoBopH o0,RO FPHCURHaHHSI Ao Yro,qu npo AepXCaBHi 3aICyniBAi (GPA) nicjsi BCTyny YKcpaTuH B COT. 40o 3aBepwueHH. OCHOBHHX neperoBopiB u4o,io BCTyny B COT YKpaNHa Mae rIpeacTaBHTH Ha pO3MrfA 4faKTI4HiHi 3BiT, BiAOMH1 flK KOHTPOJIbHIHr nepeniK. Uerl KOHTpOJ1bHIH nepeJliK MiCTUTb JiaHi npo .aep*KaBHi 3aKyniBJIi 3a OCTaHHi TpH pOKH Ta onHc ycix J1itO'HX 3aKoHiB i HOpM. 112. flpoeK-T AMP CIWA 3 BCTYHY B COT CTBOPIOC CUpHRTJIUBi YMOBH ,141 4lOpMyB8HH9 ypHAuOM N"KoHTpo.lbHoro nepeniiicy", i OCTaTO4Ha Bepcig npoeKTy ulboro jioKyMeHTa O'flIKycTbCR B 2006 pOUi. IcHyC Mana HiMOBipHiCTb Toro, TUO ypRA niAroTyC 3BiT AO 3aBepUeHHfr neperoBopiB npo BcTyn. rIoTeHrWiHHMH c4epamtH npo6AeM e, HanpHKJ1aA, ToMHe BH3HaqeHHSI lOPHA.HiHOi TepMiHoJIorfl, iuo6 3a6e3netiHTH npO30piCTb, o6Me)KHTH npe4epeHuigHi yMOBH, BH3HamHTH CTpOKH no0aHHfl npOno3HUiA (flKi He BiAnOBiJaaiOTb BHMOraM GPA) Ta yCyHyTH aRMiHiCTpaTHBHi npo6neMH nicnH yKJJaAeHHR yroA. 113. IHlIi qJ1eHH GPA MaloTb npaBo CTaBHTH YKpaiuHi 3anHTaHHH nO 3MiCTy Ti 4)aKTHqHorO 3BiTy, TaK HlK ue po6HJIOCb 110 Bi1HomeHHIO 2O OCHOBHorO TOprOBeJIbHOrO 3aKoHo21aBcTBa. BTiM, IaxiBUiB SaHKy noiH(opMoBaHo, iuo GPA He e npiOpHTeTHHM HanlpflMKOM iriH ypSIA1y. GPA e xlo6poBiRbHo1o yroAloio, npHC2AHaHHSI AO flKOi MO)KnHBe niCJDA BCTyny Ha OCHOBi BiAnOBiAHHX 21OMoBjieHocTei. LUer npoLuec noTpe6ye 'tacy Ta iCTOTHHX 3yCHJIb. 41 3eim 3 O4iHKU 3aKynieeAb 8 YKpaiHi - 2006piK 9. AHAJII3 PH3HKIB I IIJIAH olIh 303 3A 2006 PIK Anaji3 PH3HKIB 114. AHaAi3 HOAirl B ycix nonepeAHix po3minax iAborO 3BiTy aac cepIio3Hi niRCTaBH BBa)KaTH, wO cepeAoBuine W.rD AepXlaBHHx 3aKyniBejil6 B YKpaliHi HHHi 3H2XORHTbCg B 30Hi BHCOICOrO pH3HKy. He3BaxiatoqH Ha nO3HTHBHi KpOKH ypsvy YKpaiHH niCIAf BHlnyCKy 303 B 2001 poui, Leri npoLtec Ha6yB 3BOpOTHOrO pyxy i3 3anpOBaJ.KeHHAM opraHi3auiriHof CTpyKTyp4, sKa C HaciiAKOM 3MiH Bi, 2005 i 2006 pp. KopoTlue KaxKyIH, HOBa CHCTeMa yHeMo0KEHBamoc e4)eKTHBHe Ta eKOHOMiqHe BHKOpHCTaHHA Aep2KaBHHX KOUITIB. I I S. Po3nopoweHHn AepwaBHHx 4pymcuirt, sKe BIA6y.J1ocU OCTaHHiM 'lacoM - 3 BiWnOBiAH0lo BTPaTol0 4)yHKllii AePWKaBH EOAO KOHTPOJIlO i fliRTpHMICH - C IP1DMHM HBaCJliACOM 3MiH Ao 3A3 BiA 2005 poKy. AeAKi npHBaTHi opraHi3auil HHHi MaEOTb cPyHKLtil i n0BH0Ba*eHHA aLoAo Aep*aBHHx 3aKyniieBlb, SKi 3BHqaUHO HaBJe)KaTb Aep)KaBHOMy opraHy. HeAeplKaBHHri opraH CTaB 4~aKTHqHO ynOBHOBaBKeHHM OpraHOM, XH6Ho nepe6paBuWH Ha ce6e u4oro cTaTyc, 4yHKLtiY i noBHoBa)KeHHAs, BHnJyqeHi B ,3 B MiHicTepcTBi eKoHoMiKH, SKe BiAnoBi3iajio 3a Lti 4yHKUfi. LLM peopraHi3auiA KOwl1TyBana YKpalHi pOKiB npaKTHqHOrO QtCBiAy, Ha6yToro JIAKJA3, SKHH npHnHHHB CBOC iCHyBaHHS AK YO. KpiM Toro, nepejaqa neBHHnx ynHKLliu KOHTpO.ruO 3a Aep)KaBHHMH 3aKyniBJIAMH KPY i PaxyHKOBir4 naniaTi CTBOpHna 4iTKO OKpecJ1eHi KOH(bJiKTH iHTepeciB, B YMOBax SIKHX LUi OpraHH HHHi BHKOHYIOTb ayAHT Ai5UIbHOCTi PO3flOpSAAHKIB 61OfKeTHHX KOUTiB BKJIIO'HO 3 HarfllAOM. HenpHHiHATHa CHTyaLliA, iuo cKJanacA, BHMarae HeBiaKARWHNX KOpHryBaHb. 116. YpgA Mac ynopPsUKyBaTH AepxcaBHy CHCTeMy 3aICyfiBeCJb. Uen 3BiT MiCTHTb aeTanIbHHiH LnnaH BfPOBaAPKeHHX (AoAaTOK 1), SKHH InOCZAHYC He BnpoBaALKceHi peKOMeHAai;ii 303 3a 2001 piK i peKoMeHiaLaiI 3a pe3yjiiTaTaMH tuei OUiHKH. FeplumM KpOKOM Mac 6yTH YlOPAAKYBaHHLi 4HHHOf HOpMaTHBHO-npanOBoY 6a3u. Ue BHMarae KopHryBaHHS npo6neMaTH4HHx nollo)KeHb B 3JA3 Ta 0orO nonpaBKax i, 3roJloM, Haiie*KHOT peopraHi3auif 4yHKUiYa ep2KaBHHx 3aKyniBenb. JJnA AoCSArHeHHS Lied MeTH nponOHOBaHa OUiHKa peKOMeH,Ayc ypPiAy AlBa naKeTa 3axOLiB - OCHOBHi peKOMeHAauif AIJ ynopAAKyBaHHJ1 HOpMaTHBHOY, peryniSTopHof Ta iHCTHTyLtiriHoY 6a3H i no6iqHi peKOMeHlauif Ansx noCHneHHS CiCTeMH. 117. nlepmoqeproBi peKoMeHIwauif - ynopRLIKyBaTH npaBoBy, peryniSITopHy Ta iHCTHTYUiHHY 6a3y > 3a6e3nequHT BiAKJlHKaHHA a6o iCTOTHe aoonpauLU0BaHHS 3MiH Ao 3aKOHy BiA rpyaH.I 2005 pOKy. Lje 6yno 6 Kpaiue 3po6HTH tIJIASXOM BBeAeHHA B.Aito a6CORnOTHO HOBOrO 3aKOHy, npHnHHBBWH TaKHM q'iHOM He6a)KaHy npaKTHKY nOCTir4HorO BHeceHHA 3MiH Ao 3aKoHy Ta noB'3I3aHHX 3 HHM fliA3aKoHHpIX aKTiB. 3oKpeMa, pont, TeHtepHOYf nanaTH Heo6xi)lHo neperJlAHyTH. HpilBaTHy HeypSLAtOBY opraHi3autilO He MO)KHa HaAiEJITH YHKUiAMH nOBHicTio niH3BiTHOro AepxKaBHoro opraHy. OTnKe, cTarri 17.1-17.5 3aKOHy (3i 3MiHaMH BiA 16 qepBHA i 15 rpyxHAE 2005 poKy) noTpi6Ho CKaCyBaTH pa3oM 3 yciMa iHUEHMH noloO)KeHHS[MH, SKHMH 3apa3 BH3HataBOTbCA 43yHKUiI i nOBHOBa)KeHHA TCHAepHOi riaJIaTH. > PeopraHi3yBaTH iHCTHTyLiriHy CTPYKTYPY Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJb. rlicCnsA BHeCeHHA 3MiH aO 3aKOHy CTBOpHTH HatiriHy, rijtHy AOBipt iHCTHTyUiiHy CTpyKTypy, AKa Bino]3Bitac Mi)KHapo.aHHM CTaHaapTaM B c4epi iAep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb, yCyHyTU PO3nopou]eHHS i noApi6HeHH 4)YHKLlig, i BiAHOBHTH npHHLtHn po3nofiJly BJIa,H Mi2K rinKaMi. > CTBOPHTH He3anexcHHA MexaHi3M po03risAy cKapr. npH BHeceHHi 3MiH Ao 3aKoHy nepeg6amuTi npHRHRTHi nono)KeHHA, BCTaHOB3IO1O0H qiTKO BH3HaqeHHri, e4JeKTHBHHr1, HeynepeAweHuu i riAHHil AOBipH MexaHi3M po3rnsiAy cKapr. BiH Mae 6yTH BiAOKpeMjieHHri BiA 4)yHKUMi ynOBHOBa)KeHO0rO opraHy. > CTBOPHTH [teHTpajibHHA ynoBHOBa)KeHHU opraH. HOBHH ynoBHoBanceHIH4 opraH Mae 6yTH OKpeMHM OpraHOM, i3 yciMa npaBaMH H 4)yHKLtiAEMH, SKi 3a3BHqaH HaAatOTbCA TaKOMY opraHy. 3oKpeMa, po3po6Ka cTpaTerif rany3i, noBHoBaxKcHHAU pO3po6nAlTH 3aKoH Ta niA3aKOHHi aKTU, 42 3eiM 3 OZ1iHKU 3aKynieeAb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK ni,aroTOBKa Ta OHOBneHHR cTaHlapTHOf TeHAepHO1 AoKyMeHTaLlil, 6e3KoulToBHe HaBaHHJI KOHcyJ1bTatiAi 3 npaBOBHX i npoFeciriHHx nHTaHb, ny6niiKaLi. oroioluieHb npo Topra Ta iH¢opMauilf npo yKiiaAeHi AorOBOpH, a TaKO)K MOHiTOpHHr Ta 3arajibHHHrd HarnJIA 3a npouecoM aep)KaBHHx 3aKyniBeJlb. TaKtHi opraH Mae 6yTH a6o 6e3nocepexwHbo nia3BiTHHM Ka6iHeTy MiHicTpiB, a6O BXOMTH ,ao cKniaAy iHworo AIep)KaBHoro opraHy (noz.i6HO Qo KOJHUIIHbOrO ynOBHOBaKeHoro opraHy npH MiHicTepCTBi eKOHOMiKH). > Jgopo6HTH TeHaepHy 0oKyMeHTaui[o, niH4roToBneHy KOJIHIDHiM YOBHOBa)KeHHM OpraHOM B MiHicTepcTBi eKOHOMiKH. PO3MiCTHTH tlO .AOKyMeHTaLtilO Ha Be6-carlTi i3 BinbHHM Ta 6e3KOUIJTOBHHM IOCTYnOM AtO Hel Ta BlMaraTH BiU PO3HOPMIAHHKiB 6ioawKeTHHx KOUITiB Hi BHKOpHCTaHHS . > CTBOPHTH CHPHSITnHBi yMOBH, ARAUl KOHKypeHTHOrO pHHKy KOHCyJ1bTauiiiHHHX nocjiyr 3 3aKyniaenb. KoHcyj1bTauiiiHi nocaIyrH 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBeJIb, - flKi He Ha,LalOTbC3i aep)KaBHHMH ycTaHOBaMH, a oTlxe MOKYTb HagaBaTamcm npHBaTHHMH IipMaMH, - MalOTE 6yTH npeAMeTOM KOHKYPCHOrO Bifl6opy, 3riAHO i3 no0jo)KeHHmlMH 3aKoffy. 118. AoR8aTKoBi peKoMeHIatuil- HOCHJIHTH CHCTeMy AepHC8BHHX 3aKyniBeJIb > IOCHnHTH iHcTHTyyLiriHe i KKaBpOBe 3a6e3nemeHH5I YnOBHoBaBKeHoro opraHy 3 MeToJo npOBe,aeHH31 B KpaiHi KaMnaHiY iH4¢opMyBaHHf rpOMa,JcbKOcTi no nHTaHHqX AepwKaBHHX 3aKyniBeJib. Le aaCTb 3Mory noiH¢OpMyBaTH flK WJHpOKHi 3aran HacenJeHHA, TaK i npe,aCTaBHHKiB npHBaTHOrO CeKTOpy npO 3MiCT, HaCJiiiKH Ta eKOHOMit1HHri e4eKT 3anpoBaAxKeHHA 3aKOHy npo Aep)xaBHi 3aKyniBjii. > CTBOPHTH B CTpyKTypi pO3nOflOpaHHKiB 6lojweTHHx KOlITiB nOCTirlHHrl niapo3.iR 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBeJib Ta 3anpOBaaHTH CHCTeMy CTBopeHHA TeHaepHHX KOMiTeTiB ARlA KOWKHOY 3aKyniBjii, LUJIJXOM BHeCeHHR BianOBiJaHUX nojio)KeHb B HOBHi iM RonoBHCHHi 3aKOH. > 06'CRHaTH 3aKOHoAaBCTBO Ta niHJ3aKOHHi aKTH 3 aHTHKOpynUiriHHX nHTaHb. 3acTocyBaHHfl 3axOEiB npOTHIiY KopynliI TaKOlK nOCHJI4Tb CHCTeMy 3aKyniiBeIEb 4epe3 nOKpatUaHH.I piBHfl Bi,aOBiJaJIbHOCTi iaep)KaBHHX cnyx6oBUIiB 3aranoM. > nocinHTH KOHTpOJ1b, LUO npOBOAHTbcS nO 3axiHseHHio npoLeCy 3aKyniBeJlb. KPY, PaxyHKOBiri naJiaTi i Ka3HameriCTBy BiAtirpalOTb BalKJnHBy pOnb B 3a6e3neseHHi nin43BiTHOCTi zep)KaBHHX cj1y)K6oB0LiB. FOCHUIHTH Lui YCTaHOBH B paMKaX JIiXlAbHOCTi Mi)KHapOJIHHx i aBOCTOPOHHiX AOHOpiB, HOB'A3aHOI 3 ynpaBJiiHHsIM aep)KaBHHMH 1fiHaHCaMH B YKpaYHi, BKUOimaioIH AiAJIbHiCTb CBiToBoro 6aHKy. > 3anpoBaaHTH cTpaTerifo pO3BHTKy eiieKTpOHHHX Rep)KaBHHX 3aKyrniBeJIb. 3anpoBaaJUeHHA eJIeKTpOHHHX 3aKyniBejnb cnpfH3THMe npO3opocTi npouecy 3aKyniBenJb Ta 3aoiixa=eHHio JIeplKaBHMX BHRaTKiB. > CTBOPHTH CAUHHH O43iUiHHi 6e3nniaTHHH eCieKTpOHHHr1 nopTaJI Ta nanepoBe BHIaHHAI 3 nHTaHb Jaep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJIb. TaKHri noparan Mae ynpaBn9THCfA YnOBHOBa)KeHHM OpraHoM. 119. B.poBaAKeHHH 1HX OCHOBHHX peicoMeHatui i nHJaHy BnpoBaweKeHHSI B L,ojaTKy A R2CTb 3MOry BiAHOBHTH Haair]Hy OpraHi3a8ifiHy CTpyKTypy aepwaBHHX 3aKyniBeJib B YKpaTHi. YnOBHOBaaKeHHiu opraH MoKe 6yTH a6o OKpeMmM OpraHoM, 6e3nocepeaHbO niA3BiTHHM Ka6iHe-ty MiHiCTPiB, fK y 6araTbox CBpOneH1CbKHX KpaYHax, a6o BXOHTH 40o cKhia,y icHyio'oro jtepxcaBHoro opraHy. BnpOBaaweHHA 3axOaiB 3 peopraHi3auLI CTpYKTYp pO3nOpSlItHHKiB 6foALKeTHHx KOUITiB 3a6e3ne'HTb p036yUOBy ix nOTeHuiaJny AJl 3AirHcieHHA e4)eKTHBHHX i BqaCHHX 3aKyniBeJlb 3riXHO 3 BHMOraMH 3aKOHy npo 3aKyniBJIi. BnpOBaAmKeHHfl peKOMeHaauif 10o.ao eneKTpOHHHX 3aKyniBenb 3a6e3neqHTb Kpaluy npO30piCTb 1, 3peLlITOIo, 3aO1uaa)KeHH51 Aep)KaBHHX BHaaTKiB. 120. OpraHH BHyTpiliIHbOrO i 3OBHiWUHbOrO KOHTpOJIIO (ICPY, PaxyHcoBa nanaTa i Ka3Ha2erfcTBo) BiairpaioTb BaSUHBY Ta el4eKTHBHY pOJlb y 3a6e3ne'IeHHi niA3BiTHOCTi nocaJIoBtliB, BillnoBiaaJIbHHX 3a AIepwKaBHi 3aKyniBJIi. nnaHH 0uo0o nOCHJieHHA LUHX OpraHiB e CKJiaAOBOIo AfiAIbHOCTi CBiToBoro 6aHKy B raJly3i ynpaBJIiHH.9 gep)KaBHHMH ciHaHCaMH B YKpaYHi. 43 3eim 3 OZjiHKU 3aKynieeib e YKpaini - 2006 piK KoHConiAaLwiA i UpaBKTHqHe 3aCTOcyBaHHA PO3nOpOWeHOrO 3aKOHOAaBCTBa i HOpM nlpOTHaif nlpOXBaM KOpynuif nlOKpai1aTb AKiCTb npoBeAeHHI npouejyp Aeep)EaBHHX 3aKyniBeJI. 121. HacaMicieuEb, nOCHJIeHHS ynoBnoBaxceHoro opraHy ,JIJI uineeu pO3pO61cH Ta ynp2BJ]iIHH HaqiOHanbHOIO ICaMnaHiClO iH4lopMyBaHHI rpOMaRCbICOCTi nOIPpalUHTb IOiH4*OPMOBaHiCTb rpomaARiH Ta nusHBaTHHX niInpHCMCTB DOJrO 3MiCTy, HacJiiUciB Ta ecKOHOMiHoro e43pekry 3anpoBaANceHHSl 3aKOHy npo IAep2KaaHi 3aIyniBsni. 3pel'ToIO, noiHc¢opMoBaHa Ta 3auiKaBjieHa rpoMaACbKiCTb, iKa BHMarac AoTpHMaHHR Ha$BHsUHx cTaHArapTiB, C HaiKpaWumM iHCTpyMeHTOM 3a6e3neqeHHX e(3eKTHBHocTi B cHcTeMi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKylliBeJlb. 44 3eim 3 OUSiHKU 3aKynieeizb 6 YKpaiHi - 2006piK -,o(amoK K 14O0RATOK 1. IETAAbHHFI HJIAH BHPOBA4KEHHR (HA OCHOBI PEKOMEH)JAUIR 2001 1 2006 Pp.) HopMaTHBHo-npaBoBa 6a3a BHecTH 3MiHH o 3aKoHy npo 3aKyniBJIi: * BHJIy'HTH i3 3aKoHy 6yE,b-3lKi nocHnaHHAI Ha TeHlepHy nanaTy Ta Tf 6}oieTeHb (6e3 6yAb- flKHX 3aMiH). * YnopfRKyBaTH oronouieHHfi npo ToprH, ix pe3yJbTaTH Ta iHlUi iaHi. BHMaraTH ix ony6niKyBaHHM B ArPYKOBaHOMy 6loJIeTeHi Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenEb Ta B peiKHMi on-line; AO3BOflHTH pO3n1Op$AHHKaM 6jonAeTHHx KOlUTiB ny6niKyBaTH CBO; orOJolueHHSI npHHaHMHi B oAHirl 3aranbHoHauioHaJIbHiPI ra3eTi. * BHnyMHTH nonoe)KHHA npo nonepenHe 3aTBepE)KeHHAl npoBeAeHHM 3aKyuiBejib B oAHoro y4aCHHKa, TOpriB 3 o6Me)eHolo ymacTlO i AO3BOJ1HTH PO3nopxAHHKaM 6ionKeTHIx KOUITiB BH6mpmTH Haf6inbuT npHAH3ITHMri MeToa 3aKyniBni BnaCHOpy'i Ha YMOBaX nOBHOi BiAnoBiaanbHocTi 3a TaKHfi BH6ip. * BHMaraTH Bin po3nopfsaHHKiB 61oApIeTHHx KOUITiB CTBOpeHHJI B CBOiH CTpyKTypi ninpO3Aniy 3 nIHTaHb 3aKynliBeJ]b. * FOCHJ1HTH nOBHOBaBKeHH fynOBHOBa)eKHOrO opraHy. * BH.IyuHTH nonio)KeHH3i npo npouenypy peAyKUioHy. * BmKopHcTOByBaTH enAHHHr ejIeKTpOHHH4 nopTan ,gep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb B pe)KHMi on-line Ann1 po3MiLueHHsI o6o0B f3KOBOY iHDopMaui1 Ta npOBeeeHH31 iHIIIHX TpaHCaKUiri wuoAO aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJnb. * BKnIO4HTH4 iTKo BH3HaHeHi KpHTepiY nonepeAHboi KBanifiKauii yT4aCHHKiB. * BKJIIo0HTH MeTOAH BiA6opy KoHcyJ]bTaHTiB (303 3a 2001 piK). * 3anpoBaanTH MexaHi3M po3rnIsiny CnipHHX nHTaHb, fKiHH aRMiHiCTpye He3ane)KHHA HerTpajTbHHfi opraH y cKMnii ynOBHOBaxceHHX oci6, flKi He MaEOTb KOPHCJIHBHX iHTepeciB. * 3MeHluHTH BapTiCHi MewKi anJI y'acTi iHo3eMHHx 43ipM (303 3a 2001 piK). * BHeCTH 3MiHH B MeTOa 3aKyniBenb "3 o6Me)KeHoio ymaCTtO", ,nojaBWHU 4OpMyJIfOBaHH3l, Lo no yHacTi B npouenypi 3aKyniBem, "3 o6Me)KeHoEo yqacTmO 3anpoluyloTbCA BCi BinOMi cneuiani3oBaHi (FipMM (3033a 2001 piK). * AaTH ICHiWe Ta TOIHiwe BH3HaqeHHS TOpriB 3 o6MexceHoIo ymaCTIO i aBOCTyneHeBHx TopriB (3033a 2001 piK). * IoAaTH nOjiO)KeHH.9 npo Heo6xinHiCTb nonepenHboro 3aTBepwKeHHA ynOBHOBa)KeHHM opraHom nOIROB)KeHHX KoHTpaKTiB Ha BHKOHaHHA po6iT, BapTiCTb AKHX 36inbUIycTbCq Ha 50 % no BiAHowUeHH0o no HaMJaIbHof BapTocTi (303 3a 2001 piK). * nOJIOBMKHTH TepMiHH niaroToBKH 3aflBOK Ha yqaCTb y nponeaypi nonepeAHEoi KBanifiKauif (3033a 2001 piK). * BH3HaMTH cCHcTeMy OUiHKH Ta o6Me)KHTu 3acToCyBaHH.9 KpHTepiiB TiJIbKH TaKHMH, fKi MO)KHa KOHBepTyBaTH y rpoUWOBHfi eKBiBaJeHT, yHHKaio4H BTpy4aHH5I 6yAb-flKoro cy6'CKTHBHoro 3aiTopy (3033a 2001 piK). * HnOAOB)KHTH TepMiH nOAaHHH nponO3HUiA y pa3i, KOJIH PO3nOpflAHK 6ion*eTHHx KOILTiB BHOCMTb nonpaBKH Ao TeHAepHoi AoKyMeHTaI-iY (3033a 2001 piK). BHJIy'qHTH nOnO)KeHHSI iuoAo (3033a 2001 piK): * BUMor npo BHKOp4cTaHH3I MicueBHx MaTepiariiB i po6oioY CHJIH iHo3eMHHMH4 ipMaMH. * KpHTepifB OUiHKH, flKi pO3nOpSA1HHKH 6ton2KeTHHX KOlUTiB HecnpoMo)KHi 3aCTOCYBaTH o6'CKTHBHO. * HloAaHH1 TeH,AepHOrO 3a6e3netieHH31 iHUIOEO oco6oio BiA iMeHi yqaCHHKa * ojio)KeHH1, wuo po6HTb HaAlBHiCTb nilIeH3if a6o AO3BOny a6o peccTpauii YMOBOiO y'acTi B 45 3fim 3 OzjiHKU 3aKyni6eelb f YKpaiHi - 2006piK -,JoaamoK I Toprax , a He YMOBOIO niAnHcaHHXal oroBopy. YnOBHOBaXeHOMy opraHy: * jopo6HTH CTTaHAaPTHY TeHACPHY ROKyMeHTatlho, BKa MiCTHTb 4,OpMy THnOBOrO KoHTpaKTy. * Po3po6HTH i 3anpoBa.HTH naKeT 4iTKO BH3HateHuHX nPO3OPHx npaBuH i npoLLeayp 3aCTOCyBaHHs% 3aKOHy (303 3a 2001 piK). * HaAaTH peKoMeHAaLLii i0oAo OLUiHKH nponO3WuiA. * YnOp3WKYBaTH i P03nOBCfOAHTH noci6HHK 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBeJIb. * HaAaTH p03'SICHeHHS LIOAO npHtHAITHocTi Ta npaKTHmHoro 3acToCyBaHHA npe4epeHIUirHoY nonpaBKH Anl MicleBIHx ysacHHKiB, 3rifAHO 3 nonowKeHHMMH 3aKoHy (303 3a 2001 piK). * PO3po6HTH 4iTKi peKoMeHaauii uloAo niaroToBKH TeXHiIHHx cneuHwiKauir. * PO3po6HTH cTpaTeriio BnpOBaAIKeHHA CHCTeMH eneKTpOHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. * PO3PO6HTU B cHcTeMi eneKT-OHHHX Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBeJlb nporpaMy niABHUEeHHAI noiH4opMoBaHocTi Ta pO36yfOBH iHcTHTyLjirHoro noTeHUtiany. * BHB4HTH MoxKU1BoCTi napTHepCbKoro cTBopeHHA mepexKi 6i3Hec-ueHTpiB y BiALaneHHX perioHax AMuE 3a6e3ne4eHHRM AocTyny Ao MepewKi IHTepHeT, 3oKpeMa, AnJl ManorO Ta cepeAHboro 6i3Hecy. AIr IoAo nIoc ncugHH iHCTTryqiriHo? 6a3H TaCDpOMO2CHROCTi yDpaBJIiHHs * Po3po6lru OHoBnIOBaMHi TpHpi4HHi nnaH po3noAiny 6ioJKeTHHX KoiUTiB (303 3a 2001 pic) AWA B'aCHrO BHicmHHN HaBBHHX KOuiB pO3nOpAAHHKaM; L1e BKJEO'0ac neperniAA 6ioweTHoro uwmny ra npouAecy nnaHyBaHHn 3aKcyiBeiEb. * 3anpoBaAHT KOMIrLeKCHy CHCTeMy ynpaBMiHHR AepxcaBHMH 4 iHaHcaMH, 11Kg 3a6e3ne'yBaJla 3B'A130X MiU OCHOBHHMH Cy6'cKTaMH CHCeTMH yripaBjiHH11 Aep)KaBHHMH 4liHaHcaMH, BKJUO'alOqN BAOCKOHaneHHSI 3aco6in KCOHTpOmO 3a 3aKyniBJIAMH B Ka3wafeiicui. * YB'A3aTH 4aiHTHi rnoTpe6Hp PO3nOpWHKiB 6oAXCemHHx IKOWTiB (Ha niacTaBi yKnaaeHHx AoroBopiB) 3 HaxBHHmH B Ka3HaqeriCTBi KOluTaMh AnA 3a6e3neYeHH5I BHKOHaHHSH 3060B'r3aHb. * Po3WnHPHTH Ai5mbHiCTb PaxyHKOBoi nanaTH uEoAo ayAHrTy 3aKyniBejlb (303 3a 2001 piK). * flpoBecm HaBeaHHA Hpa1iBHMKiB PaxyHKKoBoi nanaTH 3 nHTaHb Mi)KHapoAHof rpaKTHKH, cTaHAapTiB i meToAiB ayAmTy Ta 3acToCyBaHHS 3aKoHy npo aep)KaBHi 3aKyniBJIi (303 3a 2001 piK). * C4OPMYJ11OBaTH 'iTKO BH3HaqeHy cTpaTeriio niaXoay ao nopywIeHb y c)epi 3aKyniBeJIb, BKnltoqaioqi: (a) BH3HaBeHHS KOHKpeTHHX nlOpyiueHb B CHCTeMi 3aKyniBenIb, TaKHX AK TacMHa 3MOBa, noAaqa HeBipHol iH4bopMauif utoAo noCBiAy; (b) aH4)epeHuiauiho HasBHHX iHCTpyMeHTiB, BKJlOMaoqiC KapHaH Ko)jeKC, KoAeKc AepKaBHoro cJy)K6oB0BL, 3aKoH npo 3aKyniBni; (c) BH3Ha4eHHA i 3aCTOCyBaHHS BiAnOBiRHHX CaHKLdi, BKJIIO4ajOq'H 4)opMyBaHHA 'OpHOrO CnHCKy; (d) o6'CKT4BHy npouteiypy npaBO3aCTOCyBaHH1 caHKLuiH; i (e) Hane)KHy npoueaypyYiX HaKmagLeHHA. AOpy4HTU YHOBHOBa)KeHOMY opraHy BHKOHaHH1 BCiX BiRUIOBiaHHX 4yHKLirL, BKJI[OqaiO4H: * FpaBo ynpaBjiiHH1 BHAaBHHIJTBOM AJlA po3MiuAeHHA Heo6xiAHHx glaHHx npo 3aKyniBfIi B OAHOMy cUiLeianbHOMY MiCUi (ApyKoBaHi MaTepiaiH maTepianH B pe)KHMi on-line). * rIpaBo i 4yHKLilO HaAaHHA KOHCynbTauiri uoAO MeTOAiB 3aKyniBenb i npoueLyp 3aCTOCyBaHH1 BiAnOBiAHflX [OpHRUqHHX nono)KeHb. * rlpaBo i 3060B'A3aHHA pO3po6nTH TeHepHYAOKyMeHTauilo (303 3a 2001 piK) * 3a6e3ne9eHHA HaBqaHHA 3 niArOTOBKH TeHAepHHX cneLtH4iKauirI, CTBOpeHHJq i BeaeHHS 46 3fim 3 OtjiHKU 3aKynieeilb 6 YKpaifHi - 2006piK -,4o6amOK I 6a3H AaHHx THnOBHX cneuH1iKauifl Ta niRrOTOBKa CTaHRaPTHHX TexHiqHHX cneUuH4iKauir AnII Hag6inbiuJ nolIUHpeHHx npegMeTiB 3aKyniBni. * npoBeaeHHa aHaJii3y noTpe6 y HaBiaHHi, BKI0otIaioLH HaBmaHHM npeAcTaBHHKiB npHBaTHOrO ceKTopy. * nepernsiHyTH CnpOMO)KHicTb 6aKpeAHTOBaHHX yCTaHOB 1OA0JO IpOBeAeHHS HaBMaHHSi nOUIHUHTH aKpeAH1TauilO Ha 6ijbIlly KiJIbKiCTb AIep)KaBHHX Ta npHBaTHHX 3aKJlaAiB ,uu PO3U1HPeHHS MOmnmBOCTeH OTpHMaHHS HaBxiaHHA. 4yUHKICiOHyBRHHU CHCTeMH 3aKyniDejib Ta pHHcOBa CHCTeMa YnoBHOBaxeHOMy opraHy: * AKTHBi3yBaTH Ta iHTeHCHfiKyBaTH cniBnpauTo i3 pO3nOpRSHHKaMH 6toLaKeTHHx KOUlTiB nO BCiH KpaIHi. * PeryriapHo npOBOXUHTH CeMiHapH JUTh npHBaTHHX KOMnaHirH i Ha6yBaTH BaKJIHBi HaBH'KH KoMyHiKaUiL Pun1 pO3po6JIeHHR Ta npOBeAeHHJ 3axo,AiB iH()opMyBaHHa rpOMaaCbKOCTi npo 4YHKUiOHYBaHHA CHCTeMH Aep)KaBHHX 3aKyniBenb. * 3a6e3ne4HTH ny6JliKauilo iH4opMauilf npo TOprm Ta fx pe3yjbTaTH npHHaHiMHi B OJRHOMY .ApyKOBaHOMy 3aco6i MaCOBOi iHcjOpMauii, KpiM OflLiriHHX iH4opMaUiAHo-aHaniTHqHHX 6IoMereHiB 3 nHTaHb 3aKyniBenb. * 3a6opoHHTH PO3nOpAAHHKaM 6lopaeTHHx KOlITiB aKUeCITyBaTH nponO3HLIif, SIKi He Bi,rnOBiAgalOTb BHMoraM 060B'53KOBHX TeXHi'qHHX cneUHH4iKaLxiA. P03nOpsuAHHKaM 61oAKeTHHX KOIUTiB: * B)KHTH HeO6XirHHX 3axoaisB XAnq YCYHeHHH nepeWuKo,4, uo o6Me)KyloTb yxaCTb B npoue,aypi pO3KpHTTS1 TeHzlepHHX nponO3HLuiH. * ByTH B nOBHIH Mipi BiJnOBiaanbHHMH Ta nir3BiTHHMH 3a BiJI6ip MeTOAaa 3aKyniBJli (BKnlo'alo4H TOprH 3 o6Me*eHo1o y-iaciio). * lepeBipsTH HaJiHHiCTb 3a6e3neqeHHS. * OHiHIOBaTH nponO3HUif Ha OCHOBi 3acToCyBaHHR KpHTepifB HariMeHI1Of oUiHeHof BapTOCTi, a He HaHMeHUOIf UiHH. * iaBaT4 nOBHe o6rpyHTyBaHHsi niaCTaB An3l CKaCyBaHH51 Aif AOrOBOpiB. * 3a6e3ne'HTH JOCTaTHi TepMiHH AnJi niarOTOBKH i HaaaHHA TeHaepHOl xoKyMeHTaui. npouenypH nOaaHH.1 nponO3HLlirl MalOTb BKJlIOqaTH: * BiapaxyBaHHA KiHueBoro TepMiHy noRaaqi flponO3Hlir 3 AIaTH, KOJ1U TeHalepHa AOKyMeHTaui.q 4)aKTH'lHO HanaHa yHaCHHKaM. * BcTaHOBueHHSI npHHariMHi 30-,aeHHoro TepMiHy niArOToBKH nponO3lUiM, 3a BHH5TKOM Ha43BHqariHHX o6CTaBHH. * BH3HaHHS1 npoueRypH HeAiACHotO,. qKLUO ynoBHOBaKCHHHI opraH BCTaHOBJIIOC, UAO yHaCHHKH He MaJIH AOCTaTHbO qtacy nepexA6aqeHoro 3aKoHoM Ha nifRrOTOBKY CBO;X TeHJepHHX npOnO3HUir. 47 3eim 3 OZ,ifKU 3aKynieeJ?b f YKpaLHi - 2006 piK -gTodamoK 2 ,Op,ATOK 2. KOHTPOJI6HI fIOKCA3HHIH IHAJiKBTOP 11O BH3Haqac B SIKUx nlOa3HHKSX 4CaiCTrN'HO B 2005 poui BUMipIOCTbCSl OnpHJno,HeHHs orojiouleHb flpO30piCTb Ta KijxbKicTb TeHJlepiB (%) 3a Flpm6nH3Ho 70% npo TOprui Ta iH¢OpMauwii npo BiQKpHTiCTb orojioweHHMH TOpraMH Ta IX pe3yJ1bTaTH CHCTeMH OflPHJ1IO2HeHHMH pe3ynJbTaTaMH (3a6oei4bUo: nOHaA 95%) CTpoKH nolaHHR TeH2ePHHX PeanbHi KijibKiCTh 2RHiB Bi, AaTH 3aranioM 21 AeHb (Moice 6yTH npono3wtirl MOIKJlHBOCTi AJIR BianpaBneHHn 3aflpoweHHS MeHIle). BinoBiAHuo ,ao 3JA3 nOAlaHHA qo yqacTi B TOprax ao CTpOK noAtaHNA TeH)xepHHX nponom3uiH pO3KpUITTR npono3HLlirf onO3HUiH Mac CTaHOBHTi y4aCHHKaMH (3a6oefi7bmo: 6inbile Hi)K 21 45 KajieHapHHx AHiB, aiie ReHb) Horo MoxKe 6yTH 3MeHuweHo Ao 21 AH5s (Ao 15 KaAeHIapHHx 11HiB y pa3i 3aCTOCYBaHHR npoueAypH TopriB 3 o6MexKeHoIo yqacTto) CTPOKH oL1iHKH fp0o103Huiri E4eKTmBHiCTb KinbKicTm ,1HiB Bia AaTH 3aKoH He BH3Haqac CTpOK, npot1e2yp1 pO3KpHTrTR TeHAepHUX BnP02OB)K sKoro nOTpi6HO TopriB nponO3HLuir 2Ro BHKOHaTH OLiHKy. ny6JiiKauiY iH¢opMarii npo BH3HaMeHH3I nepemomiin (3aooiAbHo: 0,ao 90%) YqaCTb B Toprax PiBeHb 20BipH KiJlbKicTb yqaCHHKiB, RKi B CePe,2HboMy 3 npono3HuiY npiBaTHoro no2alOTb nponO34uif npH (B 2003 poui - 2,3 ceKTropa o KOWHOMY 3AiACHeHHi npono3Huii) npolle2yp npoueAyp (3a6ooeibHo: 6inbwe HiK 5 nponoMuMi) 3acToconaHri MeToA 3aKyui3.rni PiBeHin KinbKicTb TOpriB, npuH )KoAHOrO KOHKypeHHil 33,jir4cHeHHi RKHX BHKOpHCTOBYCTbCR MCHII KOHKypeHTHUH MCTOA, HilK npouegypa, peKoMeHLoBaHa AnR AQaH2 nonepefAHbo OWiHeHoi yroaH. YKnaA1eHHR npARMHx yroA 2lpo3opicTb i Bi2COTOK YrOA (3a 8,4% yroa i 21% CyKynHHol piBeHb KiJIbKiCTIO i BapTiCTto), BapTOCTi yroA. KOHKypeHwli YKJIBaAeHHX 3a MCTO2OM 3aKyniBni B OaHOrO yqacHHKa (3aOofiAbHo: aO 10% KiJIbKOCTi yro, i Ao 5% CyKynHOl BapTocTi yroa) 48 3eim 3 OuiHKU 3aKyni6eenb 6 YKpaMii -,iooamoK 2 Bi,gXiueHHS npouelyp 3IKiCTb KiJlbKicTb (%) BiUIXHuneHHX 5% (BHacniiox TCHaepHHx TeH1!epHHX npoue0yp xAo He0ocToBipHUX ,gaHHX LIer npouleAyp yKJaAIJeHHR yro, BiflCOTOK Mowe 6yTH (3abo6b'bHo: Ao 5%) BIIWHi) KilbKicCTb cKapr 5AKiCTb Ta CniBBiAHoweHHA (%) MhK AaHHX HeMae. o6' KTHBHiCTb KiJHKiCTIO rioAaHHX cKapr npouecy TeHgepHHX npOno3HuuiH (3ado6i]lbuo: B Mexcax Bi, 10% go 50%) CTPOKU npHiimHmTs piiueHb no E¢eKTHBHiCTb Ta KinIbKicTb AHiB Mi)K AaHHx HeMae a6o BOHU4 cKaprax o6'CKTtIBHiCTb nOgaHHAM CKaprH i HeCQOCToBipHi. leri CTpOK CHCTeMH OTpHMaHHAM OCTaTO4Horo MowKe 6ym TLOBrH A ocKapiKeHHs agiA piLueHH-H no cKaprax BHacjiilOK 3POCTaHHS (3a0obiAbHo: 21 gemb) KidlbKOCTi y'laCHUKiB cygoBoro npoLtecy, Ao sKorO cnpHWHHHjia nonpaBKa Ao 3)13 Bia 2005 pOKy. OcKap)KeHHA pe3ynbTaTiB E¢eKTHBHiCTb KiLrbKicTb (%) yroA 3i )KOJIHHX gaHMX. CHCTeMH 3MiHaMH y 4opMyJIioBaHHi, OCKap)KeHHX peKoMeHAOBaHHMH 3a pe3y.nbTaTaMH OCKap)KCHHM gig (3aO06iAfbHo: MeHwe Hi)K 5%) IpOCTpotieHHS nJlaTe)KiB 5IKiCTb i KijbKicTb (%) nilaTe)KiB, )KO(,HHX aaHHX. Ane CTa6iJIbHiCTb npOCTpo'eHHX 6iJmlb SqK Ha yqaCHHKH He cxap)KHJiHCb, npoUeegypH 45 gHiB IUO CBi'qHTb npo, 3aranoM, BHnJnaT (3a6o6ubbHo: MeHwle Hi)K B'aCHe 3giICHeHH.9 BHUnnaT. 10%) 3pOCTaHHa UiH 5IKiCTb 3pocTaHHs y BiICoTKaX 3rigHo 3 3aKOHOM CTpOKH Ta npouegypH KiHLeBOI CyMH yro,gH yMoBe yroA npo 3aKyniBni TopriB Ta BHacniioK 3MiH i 3MiH 3MiHFO[OTbCA BHKJIIOqHO Ha ynpaBniHHsl (3a6OeiAbHO: MeHwle Hi)K niACTaBi IOpHAINHO BHKOHaHHAM 15%) o6rpyHToBaHHX BHHATKiB. yrog O6Me)KeHa KOHKypeHUisl IAl 5iKiCTb KijlbKicTb npoi.eAyp (%) 3JA3 He nepeA6aqeHo KOHCyJnbTaHTiB KOHCYJ]bTaiUi Big6opy KOHCyJ]bTaHTiB Ha npHiHqTHHX nono)KeHb OCHOBi BiAKpHTHX TOpriB, LIo0o Big6opy 3aMiCTb Big6opy 3a KOHCyJIbTaHTiB, TOMy KOpOTKHM nepeJliKoM npHA6aHH5H nocJIyr (3adoeiAbHo: go 5%) KOHCynbTaHTiB 3AiCHIKocTbCJ9 y cnoci6, aHanoriNHIA npHg6aHHIo TOBapiB i po6iT. MeToA Big6opy KOHCyJ]bTaHTiB BiA6ip Ha OCHOBi KiJbKicTb (%) npouegyp AHB. BHUeC. 3BazKeHoro Big60py KOHCyqbTaHTiB 3a CniBBi,aHoweHHB 3Ba)KeHoIO LiHO10, WO s1KOCTi i LWiHH cnazac nfOHag 20% Bi, CyKynHoi KinbKOCTi 6aniB. 49 jIOJATOK 3. CXEMA OPFAHI3AUIliHOJ CTPYKTYPH CUCTEMH [EPZABHHX 3AKYTIBEJlb OpraHi3auHilHa cTpyKTypa CHCTCMH 1RepxC2BHHX 3a0yUl1eJ6 a YPSPaTHi (AO iOnPAliWc S4 16 uPYAHn 2005 POicY) 3B1T3 OflHKH3AIRFJ3 YKPAJI . o oTpoaiop ynqi opraHhu u b napTaMeHT 3 nuTaHb Hoop uUAl SolT yeppaSHsu 3muBennbm BlOw5ac 4BIaALnH l7aabS. 'PaX"KIoB2 nHaRTa ~wUhoaeaam Oexuwm ope awayx-lwnri F7W - BOCUM lEHR p nputO-b )M 3AILWdbO66dCPcn O ldfic humD awOIa npwai nopip, *~Bcw tam Rhaerpanoa 4ymcudwhfblH - - * Mr.wmwpii.a & 44aiawanh C7W VFJI. *o~vw IHIw,h4dv^4^ c l.a feHSi l f I I I omVpo6nwo-peabigue YPpBRAiRHH * ULwi rWomIR L aut lW nIAeFrn'b I .Ji nF BMWIH 3 p mt Meal Ta cows Ir. 1wn: IDIIpa iam I (KmY) lca VTOSML pinoi l 0hCorwm UI 20.bo oi Jan,PaI wpNr y jft'tpn T pi i am Ka6cmn Mo.qM Lm 1 Omlllb MCTCl^HWV ews sd"ue 3|BCW -LAOh fXHM P7pX6S f)epSU6Rl WrpolK^T Uymcnil xom -. - m eou a woy nopHOW a&S ua K;oHxp7emme npam . )Mp,s. . m oH1010 op?ae) e&mwmvaru npo4ec * ~poict (1S39 27 *OOJOCRHX nipo2nLplB MiltiTeIpI!S eKOHOMiUJIf *1 iHuicJepcTfo e I;OHuOMisat A4BTOHpOM6OpvA caa 5o.ly6 .pwnM EKoHomiHni ynlpaBainnH KeTBCb6:oT i CeBat-ronon.CbeCOT MiCbhHe DepVkBHX 5 aiMiminiTpauill BliXOH\Brb 2eaeHTpBM30MIU OpHlWh a iHaqeic^Tso *~~~~~~piR Ha L.-f@p 4mm.XiNNlf t1hf 30[CeM dcM7a ia t rlaoehE-u * ) ~OftbNJLhsaH r roZ. w rw ah7 >oodD pwac-Ka; deDfan f7MC7Nb )'IrC oibmsumo rN Ihpma47l it mim 13 TOO |JPIIW MYta KMX me niepeatiRw ip 201 (0 mBPAmrs n;Ir i 4 M UP AM p01T| * oqiKti, a nwoC hfaJmcmh Amf- a otD' pyfihgt *ng f eD.-ZA nfrtWlr^m UjLA fWWJiNVOII q *Nr'Aie" 2W p ,Xpa'S/ AnTi-7e-l'b, -pn6im. y3koA emHm qpowcSp mn-mKr a O03nff2gpicmxol YS^Opm If * cmenpafzcy cep* 30cnoCy6arn4A a1m0KopyrnihNux N ,omeX. ePowadrfr wooie; l uffla * 3J*iic04w xommpo.A 70a nawrewnum 3acmo4yEanNuA IOKoHIoelcmeray C4epi eolOMivfOi K0ofKypCflIil: * eiknoeso ra 3 Arnapoone cmepo6mnuu4m*o 6a ay3l: ^ Na0ac donomoy i ni0mpu.wy d m47um4r4uu moeapo6upo6uPar1A. I 51 I i l I I i I I Ii I I i