- 2 I DI; t-3 o 0- =o CD~~~~~~~~~C o~~~~~~~~~~~~t (D~~~~~0 300 0 * U - - H~3 0~~~ ____ L. o3 z C 2000 BCEMHPHbIf4 BAHK 1818 H Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A. Bce npaBa 3aLwHweHbI. Ony6nHKoBaHo a CoegrHHeHHbx IIITaTax AMepHKH. BrepBbie HeqaTaeTCd B HIonIe 2000 roga. CogepwaiHeca B HaCTOuIIleM gmoiage MHeHHH MOryT He OTpa)KaTb MHeHHH BceMnpHoro 6aHKa HnH npaBHTeJIbCTB ero cTpaH-MJIeHoB. BceMHpHbia 6aHK He rapaHTHpyeT TOMHOCTH gaHHbix, rHipBegeHHbIx B HaCTo$lizerH riy6JIHKaUHH, H He lipHHHMaCT Ha ce6A KaKofi-1H6o oTHeTcTBeHHocTH 3a nocJiegCTBH5 HX HCOnoIb3oBaHHa. rlepeneqaTKa MaTepHaJIOB HaCTOHWeH ny6rn-KaurHH aanpentaeTc$l. 3anBKH Ha nony"eHHe pa3pemeHHn Ha nepeneqaTKy cneAyeT HaHipaBuITb B YnpaBneHHe H3aaTemT I no yKa3aHHOMY bimLe aapecy. BceMHp- HblH 6aHK HooWpHeT pacnpocTpaHeHHe pe3yJIbTaTOB cBoei pa6oTb1 H B 6onbmIHHcTBe cIiyaeB npe- AocTaBJIleT TaKHe pa3peiueHHw 6e3 HpoMewIeHHA. Korga MaTepHaBibl BOCipOH3BOXtTCH B HeKoMMep- 'ecKHx xennix, pa3pemeHHe npegocTaBaieTca 6ecnnaTHo. Pa3pem-UeHHa Ha neperiemaTKy oTAeIbHbTX 'aCTel rry6JIHKaBLHH gnA HCHOJlb3OBaHHH B yle6Hom iponecce npegOCTaBnsnOTca Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., Suite 910,222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, Massachusetts 01923, U.S.A. ISBN 0-8213-4788-7 ii CoAepxKaHle BinarogapcTBeHHoe CJIOBO . iv P ealoM e .1.............................................................................................. H4CTOpHB Bonpoca ........................................................................................... 6 MOHHTOpHHr KaqeCTBa Bo3ayxa ............................................................................. 9 HIpHMeHAeMbie npoijeaypbI .............................................................................. 10 PeKOMeHga HH n o MOHHTOPHHry K eCTBa B03Xa .........................................................HOM HHT 10 ABTOMo6HJhHTbAa flapK H TexHoJiorHA aBToMo6HieCTpoeHHj .................................................... 13 XapaKTepHcTxKH aBToMo6HAbHoro napKa .................................................................. 13 HeKoTopbie npo6neMbi, CB53aHHbIe C HCHoJIb3oBaHHeM 3THIHPOBaHHOro 6eH3aHia ........................... 14 rIoTpe6neHNie TorHiHBa B 6ygyweM H Tpe6oBaHHJ K ero OKTaHOBbIM xapaKTepiCT4Kam ...................... 14 MOHuTOpwHr BbI6poCa aBTOMo6HJIbHbIX ABHraTeiew ........................................................ 17 ABToMo6HJIH C J(BHraTeCiHMl, pa6oTaionMMH Ha a)ibTepHaTHBHbIX BHgaX TOHAWBa ............................... 18 PeKoMeHgaUHHl no MOHHTOPHHry H coKpaWeHHIO BbI6pOCOB aBToMo6HIIbHbIX gBHraTeIieH ........................ 19 CeXTop c6blTa He4fTenpogyKToB H KwieCTBO TonIHBa .............................................................. 21 KaeCTBO pa3 HbIX BHAOB MOTOpHorO TOnJB a ...........................................................HbIXBH BO 22 C rieinH(p Kaijm l ............................................................................... . . 22 MOH-TopHHr KaMeCTBa ToHiJIHBa ...................................................................... 23 I4Cnonb3oBaHHe 6onee IHCTbIX BHJAOB TOrHJIIBa H cXeMbI HF13: B03MO)KHOCTH perNoAHa ........................... 24 HOJIHTHKa B ceKTope c6bITa HeclTenpogyKToB: cJep)KHBaioWime 4aKTopbl - nepecopTmqa H KoHTpa6aHga . .......... 25 PeKoMeHXaUHH no yiy"mIeHHro Ka'ieCTBa TorJImBa B 6yJyigeM ................................................ 27 BbIBOXUl H peKomeHHa]NH ...................................................................................H . 29 CIIHCOK HcHoJSb3oBaHHoH i)ITepaTyphi ....................................................................... 31 nHpioKeHe A. CoepKaHHe H aKTyaEHOCTb HccieoBaHH ...................................................peHKTuHC HCC OHH 32 flporpaMMbi permOHiJabHbIX CeMHHapOB ................................................................... 32 HpHIoxKeHNe B. Boa3eAcTBHe BbI6pOCOB aBToMo6HJTbHbix AHBHraTe)ielk Ha 39opoBemoAeA.36 HpanoAceHHe C. MOHHTOpHHr yXa B iK y (A3ep6aaRpKaH) H TaamIKeHTe (Y36eKHcTaH) ................ 38 JJaHHbIe, co6paHHbIe C IIOMOHbio aBToMaTHHeCKHX npo6oOT6OpHHKOB B Baxy (A3ep6aflw)KaH) ................... 38 TaHHbIe, CO6paHHbIe C ClOMOIlbio aBTOMaTHqCKHX Hpo600T6opHHKoB B TaH.IKeHTe (Y36eKHCTaH) ................. 39 ConocTaBneHHe gaHHbIX ................................................................................. 41 HIpHIoxKeHHe D. KaqecTBo MOTOPHorO TOflJHBa H MOAH4)HI[pBHOBaHHOe TOHJIHBo ................................. 42 l~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1 bAarojrapCTBeHHoe CJIOBO B HacToHIIeH pa6oTe H3iiaraeTcq cojep>KaHme peruoHa.ib- ItIHI HacTOzwero McCneAoBaHam, c6ope H aHaIH3e gaHHbIX B Horo Hcc)iegOBaHHq ((Ho6biweHue Katlecmea eOpOOCK020 803- BOCbMH cTpaHax-y'IacTHHxaX rIpHHHMa)im yiaCTme npea- dyxa B cmpaiax IJeHmpaAbliou A3UU u KaBKa3a nymeM ne- CTaBHTeJIH 4nHpMbl "AEA Technology, MHHHCTepCTBa oxpa- pesooa a6momo6uAbHoeo napKa na 6oAee qucmbte BUObl Hbl oKpy(aioigeAi cpegbi KaHaAbl, 4HpMbI "SNC- monnuaa>o, KOTOpOe tIpOB04HJIOCb COBMeCTHO OTgXeJaMH Lavalin*Comcept Canada', a TaKIKe MHoro'iHcneHHbie 3HepreTHKH H1 OXpaHbl oKpy)KaioaieH cpexibl YnpaBneHwi MeCTHbie cnefl4aHIHCTbl B o6nacTH oxpanbi OKpy>Aaion4efl EBporibl H CpeAHefl A3HH, ,TefiapTaMeHTOM OXpaHbI OKpy- CpeAbI, 3HepreTHKIH H TpaHCrIOpTa. B MHcnio ylaCTHHKOB }Kaioutei CpeJbI H He4Tera3oxMwimecKHM HeiapTaMeHTOM BXOXRT TaKCC ripeCcTaBHTeJIH rocyMapCTBeHHbIX OpraHOB, rpynibl opraHn3aafun BceMHpHoro 6aHKa HpH COBMeCTHoHt HecrTeHepepa6aTbIBaiouHx npegrHpHhTHt!f, HayMHbIX yqpeoK- uoggepxKKe HporpaMMbl OOH no pa3BHTH1O (HPOOH) H geHHa H HeHpaBHTe.IbcTBeHHbIx opraHH3atgHa. flporpaMMbl BceMHpHoro 6aHKa no OKa3aHHIO COgeICTBHIq ABTOpbl BbIpa)KaKOT 6narojjapHocTb XocceWHy Pa3aam, ynpaBBieHHIO 3HepreTHMeCKH4M CeKTOpOM (ESMAP), a TaKxKe XHpeCKTOPY 3HepreTwiecKoro genapTameHTa YHpaBJieHHH KaHaxCKoro AreHTCTBa MeCKAyHapOJHoro pa3BHTHJL. Mbl EBponbi H CpegHef4 A3HH, 1H KeBHHy KmiHBepy, JHppeKTOpy BbIpa)KaeM 6onbulybo 6naroxapHocTb lpaBHTenbcTBy BeCA- TheriapTaMeHTa 3KoJIorHmecKH H COUHIanbHO yCTOffMHBoro Ro6pHTaH4H 3a MMHaHCOByO rioAAepAKKY iTporpammbi pa3BHTHH YnpaBieH-ixq EBponbi H CpegHefl A3HH, 3a ix pe- ESMAP flpH BbIrIOJIHeHHIHS 3TOIi iacTH iccJieJIoBaHHAI. KoMeHgaLHH B xoAe BbIIOJIHeHHH HacToqLnuero HccIieJoBa- rpynny opraHH3atIHH BceMHpHoro 6aHKa npegCTaBJII- HHI. ABTOpbI TaKA(e BbIpa)KaKOT 6naromapHOCTb Toxgy IOT MacaMm KO3HMa (pyKOBOAIlTeii npoeKTa), Po6epT JIJ)KOHCOHY H A93BHAy Kpetiry 3a 3aMe'aH1Ma H peKoMeHha- B3BfKOH (He(tTera3oxnMmmecKHx AenapTaMeHT), MapTHH IXH1; fIlHTepy ToMCOHY, MHilIeIo ge HeBepy H KoHpaxy 40OH Doglop H Marga JoBefl (BTOpOhl PYKOBOAHTeJIb npoeKTa) PHTTepy 3a HoACep)KKY H ueiHHbie 3aMeMaHHI4; a TaKxce H3H- (NenaPTaMeHT OXpaHbI oKpy)KaiOTeai CpegAbI). B pean13a- CH JIHBaHH 3a fOMOlb B peCa(THPOBaHI4H MaTepHa)IoB. iv Pe3JOMe l l - po6neMa 3arPA3HeHHZ ropoACKoro BO3gyXa BbI3bIBaeT pacTymee 6ecrioxoacTBo BO MHOrHX HOBbIX He3aBHCHMbIX rocyjapCTBax (HHr). B ropogax 6bICTpO yBelHIHHBaeTcsL iHC)IeHHOCTb aBTOMo6H4JIbHoro niapKa, OJHaKO cjnyx6bI perHcTpaiH¶, TeXOCMOTpa H TeXo6CJIy)KHBaHHH aBTO- Mo6ieu He B COCTOsAH4HH o6ecnetHTb rioAe,gpKKy rIpOrpaMMaM HIOBbIiIeHH5 Ka'eCTBa B0o3ayxa. Hn3Koe KaMeCTBo rIoTpe6JIAeMoro TOHJIHBa ycyry6aleT nipo6nieMy 60pb6bI C BpegHbIMH BbI6poCaMH. XOTI HeKo- TOpbIe BH)TbI Bpe,HbIX BbI6pOCOB (HanpHMep, IIapHHKOBbIe ra3bI) HBJISIOTCS1 HiPeCMeTOM 6eCHOKOarCTBa B rno6anbHoM MacIlTa6e, HaH6oJIbmlHA ypoH 3,aopOBblO HaX ymeHblmHIoCb, 'ITO flPHBCeJO K CHm)KeHHio YPOBHH Bpeg- mHogeIl HaHocHT 3arpa3HeHme Bo3AgymLHoro 6accetiHa Ha HbIX Bbi6pOCOB, o6ycJIoBIieHHbIx c)KHraHHeM HcKoiaCMbIx MeCTHOM ypoBHe. HIo HeKOTOPbIM OLIeHKaM, B KPyHHbIX BH,OB ToHriHBa. XOTH B KpaTKoCpoxHoa4 IIepCfleKTHBe 3TO H ropogax Ha BCCM npocTpaHcTBe HHF Bo3eCHCTBHe 'pe3- HplHBOAHT K CHH)KCHHIO HHTeHCHBHOCTH aarPa3CeHmi ropog- MepHO 3MrpA3HeHHOIO BO3pyxa e)KeroCHo HOpIBOHT K ripe)K- cKoro B03gyxa, 3KOHoMHMeCKHl cnag o6ycJIoBH4I TaK)Ke XWBpeMeHHOfY CMCpTH OKOno 40 TbIC. H 3a6oneBaHn10 OKOJIO COKpaWeHHe peCypCOB, BbigCJIAeMbIX Ha 60pb6y C BpeCHbIMH 100 TbMC. 'eJIoBeK (Hughes and Lovei, 1999 r.). 3KoHoMHmec- BbI6pocaMH, H CTanT npwIHHofI 3aMeCJeHHqR npoiecca o6HoB- KHC nOTePH OT TaKoro poga BpCeHbIX B03geflCTBUH$ oT4eHHBa- nIeHHA napKa aBToMo6HieCf, 'ITO B goJIroCpoMHoal nepcieKTH- IOTCH B 5% ropoAcKoro 6iogJKeTa. HlpHMeM CTenCHb B03OefC- Be OTPHUaTeCJbHO cKa)KeTcH Ha MeporIPHRTHHX no yny'i"ie- CTBHAI Ha 3J0POBbe mogefi He6oIbHllI{x 14 paCCpegOTO'eHHbIX HHIO KaleCTBa ropoAcKoro Bo3gyXa. ECIIH He iiCpegp4HHTb HCTOIHHKOB 3arpHA3HeHaH, TaKHX KaK aBTOTpaHCHOpTHbIe HeO6xo4HMbIX Mep HO H3MCHeHHIO HbIHCLulHeC nO)IHTHKH B CpeCCTBa, oKa3bIBaCTcH BblIme, 'eM HX o0In5 B CyMMapHOM OTHoLHeHHH TexHmeCKHX Tpe6OBaHHa K pa3JIHMHbIM BH1a1M KoJIWIeCTBe Bbi6poCOB. Han6onee BpegHbiMH B 3TOM OTHO- TOrUIHBa H HopMaTHBOB Bbi6pOCOB aBToMo6HJIbHbIx gBHra- IHCeHHH HqBJI5IOTCA TOHKogiHCnepCHbIe B3BeUIeHHbIe 'IaCTH- TeCeJl, TO B TeMCHHe nociiCeyioigHx 10 - 15 neT pOCT 'IHcJia IAbI, BbISblBaIOlIHe 3a6oieBaHHA AbIxaTeCJbHbIX nyTeff, H CBH- aBToMo6H4Aei H riOBbIUICHHe HHTeHCHBHOCTH HX 3Kcnfiya- Hei, KOTOpblH OKa3bIBaeT nary6Hoe Bo3geHCTBHe Ha TaUHH flpHBeCyT K yCToWIHBoMy yBeCiHMeHH1O o6'beMOB yMCTBeHHoC pa3BHTHe gCeTeC H, ABJIAHCb CTOHKHM 3arpM3HA- BbI6poCOB BpeCHbIX BeiieCTB. IOWHM BeCieCTBOM, HaKaHrn4BaeTcq B OKpypKaiomeCf cpege. Bo H36e>KaHHe TaKoro pa3BHTHH CO6bITHH Heo6xo4HMo Oco6eHHO OCTPO npo6neMbI 3arph3HeHH osy3AyXa OIepTHTb paMKH KpaTKOCpOMHbIX H cpegHeCpoMHbIx Mepo- TPaHCnOPTHbIMH cpCgcTBaMH CTOAT nepeg HHr,FTO o6yc- ripHlTHA no yAJinelCHHIO KaHeCTBa TonJIHBa H XapaKTepHC- JIOBJIeHO H3HolmeHHocTbMO HX aBTOMo6HJIbHbIx riapKOB H THKH Bbl6pOcoB aBToMo6HJIbHbIx ABHraTeHCi1. JJOCTHwKeHHe OTCYTCTBHeM pa3BHTOfI nHHpaCTpyicTypM pacnpeCeCieHHRH JH4Ub OXjHOf4 143 3THX geCJeCV gaCT BeCbMa orpaHHMCHHbIt TonHJIBa, aBToMo6HRbHoro cepBHca, a TaKone CHCTeMbI TeXO- pe3yJIbTaT. ,JuH orpeCeJIeHHH TeMriOB peaJIH3agHH TaKOiH CMOTpa H Texo6cHY)IyKBaHHH. HIo HeKOTOpbIM coo6LieHHlM HporpaMMbI Ba)KHO BbICHHTb xapaKTep H MaCm-UTa6bI BO MHOr1HX ropogax A3ep6aftixKaHa, Ka3axcTaHa H Y36eKHC- 3arpH3HeHHH Bo3gyxa, HHaMc roBopA, BCO6XogHMo o6ecne- TaHa TpaHCnOpT ABJI$eTCA OCHOBHbIM HCTOMHH4KOM 3arpf3He- '4IHTb Hage)KHblA MOHHTOpHHr KameCTBa B03gyxa. MepbI no HHH BO3Jyxa, rpIHMp M B HeKOTOpbIX MeCTaX Ha ero gonio BBgeCHH10 HM co6mogeHHIO 6onee KeCTKHX HopMaTHBoB nIpHXOAHTCA 3HalHTTeJbHaH qaCTb cyMMapHoro o6'beMa 3arPH3HeHH no3agyxa OTpa3HTCA Ha geSTeJIbHocTH OTeCeCT- Bbi6pOCOB. B CeBIIHOCTbIX rogax B pe3ynJbTaTe 3KOHoMH'Iec- BeHHbIX HeC4Tenepepa6aTbIBaiomHx 3aBOJOB, Ha pe>KHMe Koro cnaga CyMMapHoe roTpe6JIeHHe 3HeprHH B STHX cTpa- nanoroo6no)KeHHA 1H TapHTHKaUHH, a TaK)Ke Ha opraHH3a- 1 FIpHMeHeHwe 6onee qHCTbIX MOTOPHUX TOri)HB gna o6ecneqeHUn MHCTOTbl BO3flyXa B CTpaHaX CpefHeA A3HH 14H KaBxa3a I4HH gopoKHoro ABH)KeHHq. JpyrHMH cIOBaMH, Bce 9TH npO- 6eHHo eo111 IIPHHATb BO BHHMaHHe, 'TO He(4)Tenepepa6aTbI- 6neMbI HOCHT MHoronpo4MIbHbIR xapaKTep, HOCKOhIbKy OHH Ba1OilaH OTpaCJIb B gaHHOM perHoHe HaXOgHTCH B ripoiecce TaK HHI HHaie 3aTparHBaioT 3HepreTHKy, 3KOIOrH4IO H TpaHC- CepbeSHOH peopraHH3aLijHH. Tpe6oBaHHa K Ka'eCTBY TOnlIH- rOpT. K 'IHCJIy nO3STHBHbIX 43aKTOpOB cniegyeT OTHeCTH: Ba, B CBOIO oiepegb, AO0DKHbl 6blTb TeCHO YBS3aHbl C 6onee HaJImme 3KojiornqecCKH HCToro ToUJIHBa, KaKHM HBJHCeTCS LUHpoKok nporpaMMoai nOBbImieHHI KwaiecTBa Bo3xyxa, npH- IIpHpOJHbHi ra3, B HeKOTOpbIX H3 BTHX CTpaH; B03MO)KHOCTb 3BaHHoH o6ecneHlTb y4eT peHTa6e)IbHoCTH H KOOpgHHa- OTXO,)a OT cTapoii TexHoJIorHH; H B03MOAKHOCTH nepegaaxH 1 4H0 HAeTeCJbHOCTH pa3JIH4HbIX oTpacIiefl npoMbIluJieHHoc- HpHM4eHeHH OrIbITa no o6ecneqeHHIO Tpe6yeMoro KaHeCTBa TH H 3aHHTepCCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH. Bo Bcex CTpaiHax gaHHoro B03gyxa, HaKOHrIeHHOrO B JpyrlHX CTpaHaX B 06)IaCTH opra- pern4oHa 3KOuiOrH,IecKHe ripo6neMbI, HopMaTHBHaA 6a3a H HH3aUHH. peaibHa5i npaKTHKa B o6AaCTH 3KOhIorHH H TOnIHUBa, a TaKiCe Bopb6a C 3arpq3HeHHeM BO34yXa He OrpaHH'IHBaeTCAI CHCTeMbI MOHHTOpHHra KaHeCTBa B03,yXa B 3HaMuTeJbHOH fpOCTbIM BBegeHHeM 6onee )K&CTKHX HOpM Ho THniy HMCeO- CTeHeHH m1meOT MHOrO o6uwero. Hoa3ToMy HpH paCCMOTpe- H1HXC3 B CeBepHoB AMepHKe M EBponeflCKOM Co0B3e. 3TH HHm npo6neM OXpaHbI oKpyKaKioweh cpegbi H 1aKeCTBa TOn- HOpMbI nOAKpenHIASOTCA HopMaTHBHO-npaBOBOf4 H MaTepH- JIHBa HMeeTCH B03MO)KHOCTb HCnOIJb3OBaTb 3KOHOMH40 3a anbHOI 4H4paCTpyKTypOfl, KOTopau gaanexo He Bcerga Hme- cMeT MaCmTa6a HpOH3BOgCTBa, H36eraTb gy6nHpoBaHHn, eTCH B CTPaHax, nepexogAiuHx OT UeHTpaB)bHOFO nrIaHHpOBa- o6MeHHBaTbCI OnbITOM H C3OaBaTb 6uiarOHpHHTHbIe ycno- HHH K pbIHO'IHOH 3KOHOMHKe. HlpOBowMai rIOJIHTHKa, BH5 AnI BHyTpHperHoHa)IbHOil ToprOBJIH He4YTerIpO4yK- HOpMaTHBHO-HpaBOBaH 6a3a H HHBeCTHqUH AOJIDKHbI OTpa- TaMm. AKaTb 3KOHoMmieCKHe H 3KH IorqeCKHe yChOBHA H HHCTHTy- B xogje HccCTejOBaHHA1 bIbCHHJIOCb, 'TO cTpaHbi I eHT- niHOHaIbHbIe orpaHH'IeHHSI CTpaH lJeHTpaJTbHoa3HaTCKoro H pauibHOti A3HH H KaBKa3a CTOJIKHYJIHCb C genIbIM pAAOM CTa- KaBKa3cKoro perHOHOB. pbIX H HOBbIX HpeCHITCTBHl B xeiie 60pb6bi C 3arpH3HeHHeM ,LHpeKTHBHbIe OpraHbl B 3THX CTpaHaX OCO3HaJOT Heo6- B031yXa BbIXlIOUIHbiMH ra3aMH: XOXHMOCTb IpHHSTHH Mep no 60pb6e C 3arpA3HeHReM B03- *43HomleH-bIbl napK aBToMo6Hnefa, KOTOpbIH4 K TOMy gyxa. CBHgeTeJTbCTBOM Hx 6ecnoKoBIcTBa ABJmeTCH Hx rOTOB- )Ke, 'laCTO coAepA(HTCh B HeYBOBiCTBOP14TenbHOM HOCTb OTKa3aTbCH OT 14CHIO)lb3OBaHHA CBHHUa B 6eri3HHe. COCTOAHHH; 3Ta rOTOBHOCTb OCHOBaHa Ha MHOrOHHCJIeHHbIX Hai4HO- HeCOBepmeHHan CHCTeMa perHCTpaiLHH TpaHCnOpT- HaJIbHbIX H per4OHaOIbHbHX HccCieJOBaHHHX H CTpaTerHHx, HbIX CpeACTB; paBHO KaK H Ha riporpaMMax, 4fHHaHCHpyeMbIX AOHOpaMm, a HeCOBepLueHHaA npOH3BOACTBeHHaq 6a3a gan nIpOBe- TaK>Ke IPOCBeTHTeJIbCKHX nporpaMMax. Ha IV KOH4epeH- XeHWH TeXOCMOTpa H peMOHTa; IUHH MHHHCTpOB ripHpO4OOXpaHHbIX BeCOMCTB «(OKpyxKaio- HecoBepneHHama CHCTeMa MOHHTOp"Hra Ka'eCTBa B03- igaM cpeRa gni EBpOnbl», COcTOHBmsei4CH B 1998 r. B r. Opxyc gyxa; (JJaHHH), BCe 'ineHbI EBporieaCKOfl 3KOHoMHHeCKOH KOMHC- HeCOBepmieHHaA CHCTeMa MOHHTOpHHra H co6mnoge- CHHm OpraHH3auHH O6'0,bemuHlHHbix Hawm4i4 (E3KOOH), HpE- HlHH Tpe6OBaHHI no KaMeCTBY TonnHBa; HHMaBLu-He yaCTHe B KOH4epeHLIHH, HpEHHIHl perH4oHaJib- Heo6xojHmoCTb o MoWepHHB3aE4H4 Hec+Tenepepa6aTbI- HYEO CTpaTerHiO, HMCIOHiyiO ueC)bIO OTKa3 OT H4CHOJIb30BaHH31 BaIOWHlMX ripegiJ-pHAITHfl; CBI4fHga B 6eH314He K 2005 r.' * paKTHKa ixeHOO6pa30BaHHA, KOTopaAI no6yxKKy YCH4JIH4Ml 3THX CTpaH BceMHpHbIf4 6aHK 4anbCi4iHKagiHH (Hi11m He3aKOHHOMY o6opoTy) 6eH- ripeJLnPHHAJI perHI HaHIbHoe HcchIeCOBsaHHe >,r no Kxiacci- H4CTOLHH4KII 3arpH13HeHHH»>>. 4nHKaT4HH B03, 3arp53HHsTeiief4 c iJeJblo IIpOBegeHHH Yny-uwenue xapaKmepucmuK monnusa. HaR6onee cyige- HeHOCcpeACTBeHHOrO CO0fOCTaBhIeHHH C Me)KgyHapog- CTBeHHbIMH4 H3MeHeHHAMI4, KOTOpbIe, KaK o)KI4gaeTCA, 6ygyT HbIMH peKOMeHgaijHAMH 4 HopMaMl. 1HMeloiuu-ecA HMeTb MeCTO B gaHHOM perHoHe B npegcToAruee geCATHiie- pecypcbi MO)KHO H4CflOJb3OBaTb 6onee pa4uHoHa5bHO TiRe, 3IBJIqIOTCH nepesoA 6onbmierpy3Hblx aBTomO6HIIeI4 c nyTeM COKpa5LeH1HHH q4c.ia KOHTpoJiEpyeMbIX 3arpa3- 6eH3vHroBbIx gBHiraTeneie Ha qH33eCbHbie H OTKa3 OT ICHOIIOb- HH4TeJiei. 3OBaHHII HH3KOOKTaHOBoro 6eH3HHa B BH1raTeJ131X uierKo- * OcyHeCTBJIITb MOHH1TOpHIHr He cyMMapHbIX B3BeIHeH- BbiX aBTOMo6HJIefi B HOJTb3y BbICOKOOKTaHOBoro 6ei3svia. B HbiX a3po3oneaf (CBA), a TOJIbKO TOHKOHcriepCHbMX pe3ynIbTaTe 3THX HSMCeHeHHI'I HpOH3O14eT pe3xoe rIOBbILne- a3posonelt flOCKOJIbKy HMeHHO OHH1 OKa3bIBaIOT Bpeg- HHe cnpoca Ha AH3eSIbHoe TOnrLIHBO, 3aMegmHTCh nOBblIneHHe Hoe Bo3geHlCTBHe Ha 3AOPOBbe niogefi. cnpoca Ha 6eH3wH 14 HaIHCT 6bICTpO yBC3eJIHBaTbCA gaona * B Tex ropoAax, rge no HacTonigee BpeMai rpHMHeHleTCl BbICOKOOKTaHOBOrO 6eH3rHa. 3aMegneHne pocTa noTpe6ne- 3THI4HnpOBaHHbIfl 6eH31H, MOHHlTOpEHr CB14HHa npo- H14R 6eH3MHa UO3BOJHlT OTKa3aTbCH OT H4CIIOIb3OBaHH1A CBHH- BOAHTb nocpegCTBoM 6onee ITPOTO)I)KH4TeIbHbIX pa3o- ua H Hal'aTb BbIrlOflHATb Tpe6oBaHHSI K OKTaHOBbIM xapaKTe- BbIX ceaHCOB, a He tIOJIb3OBaTbCH CpegHeMeCSiqHbIMi1 p14CTH1KaM aBTOMo6H4IbHbIX napKOB C MHHMmaJIbHbIMH 3HaMeHHAHMH HCKpeTHbix 20-M1HyTTHbIx 3aMepoB. 3aTpaTaMH glII nOTpe6HTeJIefi. PeKoMeHgyeMbie TexHWHeCKH4e * B ropogax C BbICOKHM YPOBHeM 030HOBbIX BbI6pOCOB Tpe6oBaHHlI K KaMeCTBy 6eH3s1Ha H AHS3eCIbHoro T0rUIHBa Co- yBehiHEMHTb '-H1CIO HOCTOB, Ha KOTOpbIX IIPOBOAHTCA gep)KaT ciiegyioigile MaKCHIMaJbHO gO1TYCTH4MbIe npegenlbl: MOHHTOPEHr O3OHa B IPEH3eMHOM cuioe. CnunceHue unmencuenocmu obt6pOCOa a6mOMO6UAbIibLX PeKOMeHAyeMbIe TeXH44eCK4e Tpe6OBaHI4sl aauamenef. CornacHo HeKOTOpLIM nporHo3aM, no mepe cnr- K Ka4eCTBy 6eH3HHaB A43enlbHorO TOfJllJBa CaHHA rpy3oBbix aBTOMo6HJIeHi C 6eH3SHHOBbIM14 gBHraTeiA- (MaKCHMaJ1bHO AOnyCT[IMbIe npeAenbl) MR, KOTOPbIe B HacToAiiee BpeMA HaXOgATCA B 3KCnhiyaTa- TonnuBo MapKa HapaMemp 2005 e. 2015 .a I4HH, HOTpe6neHHe AH3eCIbHOrO TOrIHBa 6ygeeT pe3so BeH3HH Bce MapKH CBHHeul 0,0 13 nrl 0,0 13 r/n Bs3paCTaTb. HIoABninonjanca 3rHgeMHonIorIHeCKaII iHt)Op- Bce MapKH 1 ieH30n 5 o6. % 2 o6. % ma44HA CBH,AeTe)bCTBYeT O TOM, MITO KaHneporeHHbIM gei4CT- Bce MapKH Cepa Be3 H3MeHeHHH 0,03 Bec. % MBHem o6FiagaCOTCCTaKwT 0 TOM,HKITO K1IHcriepCCHHbiM XWOCT- A76/80 ApoMaTHKa HlpeAen He 35 o6. % BE4eM O6nagaaOT TaK)Ke E4 TOHKO,rHCIICCHbIC BbI6pOCbIlC~0JC YCTaHOBjieH H53eJIbHbIX gBHraTeIieIi. C/legOBaTenbHO, YlnOMHHyTbI14 pOCT A9 1/93/95 ApoMaTHKa Hpegen He 45 o6. % nOTpe6neHH4A JSC3e]IbHOFo TOnnsHBa, CKOpee Bcero, OKa)KeT YCTaHOBjieH cymIeCTBeHHoe BO3gef4CTB14e Ha 35qOlOBbe HaceneH4lA. gene- rHS3eCIbHoe MOTopHaA Cepa 0,2 BeC. % 0,05 Bec. % coo6pa3Ho 6bIno 6bl ylpefllTb 3S4eKTH4BHyO nporpammy TOnHHBO MapKa TeXOCMOTpa H4 TeXO6CJIY)KHBaHHII. XOT51 B HaCTOAIiee BpeMi HIpuMeqaHue: r/n - rpaMMOB Ha flHTp; o6. % - o6¶beMHbIx npo0eH- TOB; BeC. % - BeCOBbIX HpOUeHTOB. HMmeT mCCTO HeXBaTKa o6opygoBaH4q AJ~IA HI3mepeHHH a. BpeMA H rioCTaTeHHbIe 3HaHIeHH ripegeCiOB HIO;gARKaT riepeCMOT- Bbl6pOCOB, cama no ce6e 3axynKa gOOIIIH14TeJibHoro o6opy- py iepe3 HeCKOJTbKO ieT. 3 HpMmeHeHHe 6onee IHCTbIX MOTOPHBIX TOHiiHB fAil o6ecneqeHUA WHCTOTbI BO3fyXa B CTpaHax CpeRHeh A3HH U KaBxa3a KOHKpeTHO, iHMeCTCS B BHgy: * PaccmOTpeTbi Aenecoo6pa3HOCTb CTpOHTe)IbCTBa H30- ' K 2005 r. H4CKJ0oHllTb MCIIOJIb3OBaHme CBHHia B 6eH- MepH3alBHOHHbIX YCTaHOBOK H 3aKyflKH OKHCAIHTeieHf C 3HHe; geJIbIO orpaHHweHlAi npegeJIbHOtI KOHiLeHTpaBiHH 6eH- * K 2015 r. orpaHHMHTb cogep)KaHHe CepbI B 6eH3sHe go0 3aoa H apOMaTHKH; YPOBHH1 COBMeCTHMorO C 434e(KTlHBHOf1 pa6oTOfi KaTa- H rIepeCMOTpeTb pOJb He4)Tenepepa6aTbIBaIoLuHx MH- )IHTH'leCKHX npeo6pa3aBaTeiedl; HH-3aBO4OB B rHpOH3BOgCTBe 6eH31tHa; * He rIo3aiHee 2015 r. ocyWCeCTBHTb CHH)KeHHC KOHieHT- BK,HO1HTb HbIHe geflCTBy1oalHe H nocneieyioiHe Tex- pauB4ii 6eH3saa H a6rtew$ apOMaTHKH, C TeM 'ITa6bI y HHxeCKHe CrHeUH43HKaIIHH KaMeCTBa TOHJIHBa B rlpH- He4YTeriepepa6aTbIBaiotgHx ripegflpHsITH4f XBaTHJIO BaTH3aIIH0HHY1O OKyMeHTaIAHIO H KOHTpaKTbI, C TCM BpeMCHH Ha H3MeHeHHe TeXHOHOrHH C eC]IbO OTKa3a OT 'ITo6bi a6ecneHm`b npegCKa3yemOCTb Ho0MaTHBHOro 3TH4X CoeCllHeHHIH; peryJIHpOBaHHIA. * K 2005 r. CHH13HTb Co0ep>KaHiHe CepbI B H03eJIbHOM TOR- CoeAiacooannocmb U compyOnuzecmoo 6 peeuoHe. )IAAn JIHBe, a x 2015 r. BBeCT14 B XeH4CTBHe TaKH4e )Ke TeXHHMe- OCylWeCTBJIeHH14 OrHTHMaJIbHOHl HOJIH1TlHKH B a6naCTH 60pb6bl CKHe YCIOBH51 Ha cogep)KaHHe cepbl B 4H3TOrJIHBe, C 3arpH3HeHHeM OKpy)KaBoiLweaf Cpegbi 6OnbmlIoe 3HaMeHHle KOTOpbIe 6bIJIH BBegCHbI B Coeg4HHHHbIX lITaTax H B HMeIOT corIacoBaHHbie gf4CTBHHI BHYTpH Ka)KgofI CTpaHbI H EBponeticKoM Caoa3e B 90-x rr.; Me)Kqy CTpaHaMH. CTpaHaM-y}aCTHHUaM peKOMeH4OBaHO: * B perHOHax c TiDKCJiOH xKoaorWieCKoa CHTyaLuHea pac- PaccMOTpeTb iuenecoo6pa3HOcTb npHHHqTH5 e4HHoo6- CMOTpeTb B03MO)KHOCTb cKopef4merO BBegeHHA B geH1- pa3HbIX HOpM B OTHOmleHHH TOHIIHBa no BCeMy perHo- CTBHe gaHHbIX TeXHHHeCCKHX yCJIOBHH, hiH60 gAnrIOHe- Hy, C TeM FTO6bi ocna6HTb CTHMYhIbI K erO He3aKOHHO- HHSI HX HOpMaMH, HMmeoruHMH qenbIo CHH)KeHHe My o6OpOTy, YrpOCTHTb KOHTpOhIb KaqeCTBa To0IIJHBa H YPOBHH1 KOHUeHTpaBIHH a3OHa B JieTHee BpeMA. fOlayIHHTb rlpH6bJlb OT yBe)IH'eHHH BHyTpHperHo- * YCOBeplmleHCTBOBaTb CHCTeMy MOHHTOpHHra1 H Bbl- HaAbHOaf TOprFOBIH; 1OhIHeHHSI YCTaHOB)1eHHbMX HOpM Ha pa3)IH'HbIe BHJbl * 43y'nHTb BO3MO)KHOCTb nepegaiH B IaCTHbIlH CeKTOp, TOnIJIHBa. BKIIMIaal HeipaBHTehIbCTBeHHbie opraHH3aljHH, HeKo- Peazu3a4us npOepaMMbi. rfiaBHOa$ 3agauefl 4151 He4)TeHe- TOpbIX 4)yHKIIHA 1o MOHHTOpHHry H ipeTBopeHHIO B pepa6aTblBalouAHx ripeCgrpHITHH lB)IIAeTCSI OTKa3 OT HCIIOllb- )KH3Hb YCTaHOB)ieHHbIX HOpMaTHBOB, OCBo6O0HB upa- 3oBaHHH CBHHIXa, yBeJiH'eHHe cpeAHero OKTaHOBarO IHcnJa H BHTenJbCTBeHHbie opraHbI OT BbInOJIHeHHH 3TH{X 3ag4aM; cHHAKeHHe KOHUeHTpaiu4H 6eH3iona H o6nlea apOMaTHKH. Cne- HlaIIApalTb TecHyla KoopA4HHa4H0o AeeCTBHA Ho peaJIH- AyeT rleO,epKHyTb, 'ITO MepOllpHITHSA 1o BbIrOJIHCHHIO nepe- 3almHH CTpaTerHH rioggep)KaHH5l Tpe6yeMorO KwaeCTBa MHCJeHHMX Bblme peKOMeHJauH$i HeO6XO4HMO 6yxeT BKJIIO- Bo3gyxa Me)Kgy MHHHCTpaMH oXpaHbl OKYpy)KaoIaef HHTb B nJIaH pa6OT rio CHCTeMaTH'eCKOf4 peKOHCTPYKLIHH H CpeAbI, TpaHCrIOpTa H 3HepreTHKH, a TaKxKe HX B3aHMO- MoJepHH3aAHH He4lTenepepa6aTbIBalowHx npegiipHSITHfl. AeC4CTBHm C 0opraHaMH XopaHbI flpaBon0fl;OKa H gpyrH- CornaCHO HeKOTOpblM oaeHKaM, goOIHHTeCJbHbiC 3aTpaTbl, MH BegOMCTBaMH; CBsI3aHHbie C YAOBhIeTBopeHHeM MeH5AlHOeroc0C cnpoca Ha PacnpocTpaHnTb 1pH0pogooxpaHHY1O HHclopMaiIHio, a pbIHKe H nHiaHHpyCMbIM nOBbILneHHeM KaqeCTBa TOHIUHBa, TaK>Kie OOWPHTb H CTHMY)IH"OBaTb o6iWeCTBeHHO-HpO- COCTaBIASIOT naps3aKa 0,01 Aoanapa Ha JIHTp 6eH3rHHa. B 3aBH- CBCTHTe)IbCKyIO geIeTeJlbHOCTb H fpoa4eccCoHaHbHoe CHMOCTH OT COCTOHHHH Toro HnH HHorO He4)Teriepepa6aTbl- o6y'eHHe B o6nacTH peMOHTa H o6cpy>KHBaHnlr cpegCTB Baiowero npeAnpHsATHsA, CTaPTOBbie HHBeCTHJAHOHHbIe 3a- TpaHcnopTa, HpaBHhIbHoro HCnrIOb3oBaHHsl TOrLiiHBa H TpaTbl, KaK ripaBHnO, Kaoe6rnOTCl OT 20 MJH 40 50 MnIH 0O1n. CaHHTapHOro COCTOAHIIH oaxpyAKaionefl CpegbI. CIIIA. B TeX cTpaHax, rg;e OTe'eCTBeHHblH He(4Tenepepa6aTbl- Cos3aHue opeanU3at4uoHHo-mexHuieCKOU 6a3b1 U pOfAb BaioI4Hi CCKTOp HaxoqHTCA B cO6CTBeHHOCTH roCy4apCTBa, aOnopOe0. rIOBbriileHHe KaqeCTBa Ba3,JyXa B ropoaax A1B1IA- co6paTb KaHHTanI, HeO6xO4HMbiH 4A1s1 Mo4CPHH3aBLHH He(1Te- eTCH Ba)KHbIM 3aIeMeHTOM ynJyIq1ICeHHS Ka'eCTBa )KH3HH H nepepa6aTbIBaiowix npegnpHAlTHa, no BceH BHAHMOCTH, 6y- OXpaHbl 3AOpOBb51 ropo)KaH. C03SaHHe opraHH3aLIHOHHO- geT HejIerKO. rlpenaionlaraeTCA, 'ITO YMCHbLlleHHe CTerieHH ro- TeXHHieCKOI 6a3bI 1H HO4FOTOBjIeHHOCTb K IplIHH1THIO Heo6- CyJApCTBeHHOFO perymnpOBaHHA H rpOHHKHoBeHHe 'iaCTHorO XO4HMbiX Mep nOTpe6yeT COrITaCOBaHHbIX yCHJIHf MHOrHX ceKTopa OKa)KYT 6narOTBOpHoe BJIHIIHHe He TOJIbKO Ha flpOH3- 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX CTOpOH, BKJH1O'la31 rpaxKgaHcKoe o6iLeCT- BO4CTBeHHbie ntoKa3aTeJIH4 gaHHOH OTpaCJIH ripoMbiimeHHO- BO, HlpaBHTe)JbCTBeHHbie OpraHbI 14 rHpOMbILlHIeHHOCTb. B CTH, HO 1H Ha ee CHOCO6HOCTb 11pOH3BOAHTb TOlIJI4BO rIOBbI- 3TOM OTHOlIeHHH BCe Te, KTO 3aHHMaeTCSI pa3BHTHeM, MOryT iueHHOE qI4CTOTbI. CpeCH peKoMeHgaluHfl Fp[OBegeHHOra CbirpaTb Ba)KHyIO pO1Ib B OKa3aHHH riO4,epJKKH CTpaHaM HCCIICJOBaHHH$ MO)KHO OTMCTHTb CJIeylOLIlHe: 4aHHOrO perHOHa B HX YCHhIHHXr IOCpeACTBOM: 4 Pe3io Me *flepegawH KOHKpeTHOrO onbITa no riogXep)KaHBH1O H 1OKa3aHHA noMepnKKH B geCle )opMHpOBaHHM rIporHo3H- MOHHTOpHHry KaMecTBa B03gyxa, peryJIHpoBaHHIO H pyeMofl rIOJIHTHKH H HopMaTHBHOa 6a3bi, KOTOpbIe ripH- KOHTPOJI1O KaHecTBa TOHJIHBa H ocyWIIeCTBJIeHHIO npo- 3BaHbI o6IeflMHTb rpI4BJieCeHHle qaCTHoro ceKTopa K BbI- rpamm perynnpoBaHaI4 H 60pb6bI C BbI6pOcaMH aBTO- geWIeHH1O n1HHaHCOBbIX Cpe,CTB Ha peain-3aqLo 3THX Mo6HJIbHbIX JABHraTeneHi; peKoMeHAailHA wA He4xTenepepa6aTblBalowe$i OTpacmJ; * OKa3aHHAI nOMOWH B C03gaHHH CHCTeMbI o6yMeHHiI, C*J3AaHHH 6naronp1s.THbIx yCJIoBHHi XV CHHTHII Be- ycmneHHHH MeCTHbIx HHCTHTyTOB H CO3gaHJ1HH opraHH3a- AOMCTBeHHbIX H pbIHOHHblX 6apbepoB Ha 1yTH K p314- UHoHHo-TexHHiecKofl 6a3bl; BJIeieHHIo iacTHoro CeKTOpa B TaKHX o6JIaCTqIX, KaK * Onpo6oBaHIHa MexaHHI3MOB 1H peimeHHl 1J2151 noggep- MOHHTOPHHr Ka'ecTBa pa3aHH'HbIX BHXOB TOrHsBa, MO- )KaHHII Tpe6yeMorO Ka'eCTBa B03gyXa, HipHMeHHMbIX K HHTOpHHr Ka'eCTBa B03gyXa H peaJIH3aUH5 nporpamm MCCTHbIM yCJIOBH51M; TeXOCMOTpa H Texo6C)Iy)KHBaHHii aBToMo6HiieH. 5 H4CTOpHH,q BOIHpOCa 3 arp5A13HeHe rOpOxCKorO B03JyXa CTaJio HipeMeTOM 6ecriOKOaCTBa B CTpaHaX IeHTpaJIbHO0 l1 BOCTOMHOa EBpOnIbI H4 B HOBbIX He3aBHCHMbIX rocygapCTBax (HHr). LJHTeHCHBHOCTb TpaHCnopT- HOrO BiH)KeHHhI B ropogax paCTeT, napK aBToMo6HJieH nO HaCToaigee BpeMA pa6oTaeT Ha HH3KO- KaTieCTBeHHOM TOrJI11HBe, a yHaciieaOBaHHbie CHCTeMbI MOHHTOpHHra H BbII0)IHeHHA geeCTByIOIUHX HOpM HeIIpHrOAHbI AIM pemeHnni HOBbIX ripo66eM. MeTOAbl MOHHTOpHHra KaqeCTBa BO3gyXa HO-HpeAKHeMy He COOTBeTCTByIOT peKomeHAaijmm BCeMHpHOh OpraHM3aHm 3gpaBooxpaHeHIS (B03), 'TO 3aTpyJHZeT COnOCTaBJIeHHe KaMeCTBa B039YXa B gaHHOM perHoHe C Me)K- HON lipOrpaMMbI IIPHBep)KeHHOCTH K OTKa3y OT HCnOJIb3OBa- gyHapOAHbIMH peKOMeHgaiAHHMH. HHH 3THhIHpOBaHHOrO 6eH3uHa B A3ep6aM;)xaHe, Ka3aXCTa- Bonee Bcero OT 3arpI3HCHHA BO3yXya CTpaaeT 3ag0pOBbe He H Y36eKHCTaHe. nKoaea. Me)KqyHapogHbIA OHibIT cBHJeTCJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, 'TO B paMKax 3TOll rlporpaMMbl, KOTOpaA 6blia iiOMAep)Ka- caMoe 6OnbuHoe 6eCnOKOACTBO B 3TOM cMbicJie O6bHIHO Bbl- Ha YnpaBneHHeM OxpaHbI oKpy)KaKHaJo4i cpejmbl )aHH4H, 6bljiH 3bIBalOT TaKiHe 3arpA3HHTehi4 ropOgCKOfl Cpegbl, KaK counetq U HpOBeCeHbl npeABapuTenbHble HccneAOBaHHHA, HCO6XOgHMbIe moHKoaucnepcHbIe a3po3o0u. B03MOAKHO, 3aaMef4 ilepBOCTe- gnI OUeHKH4 YPOBHJI 3arpJ3HeHHu1 OKpy)KaioiijeCt cpegbi neHHOHl Ba)KHOCTH B gene peiieHHq 3aKoJiorH'iecKxx nipo- CBHHIJOM H aHa)H13a pa3JIHMHbIX BapHaHTOB OTKa3a OT 6neM ropOpOB g BJIHeTCA OTKa3 OT HCIIO)lb3OBaHHH CB1HHa HCnOJIb3OBaHHH CB14Hua B 6eH3avHe B 3THX TpCX CTpaHax. (CM. BCTaBKY 1). B 1996 r. EBponea4CKan 3KOHOMHIeCKaI Hlony'ieHHbie pe3ynJbTaTbi o6cyKgann4cb Ha peiCFoHanbHOM KOMHCCH.1 OOH (ESKOOH) y'peAHna OnepaTl4BHyio rpyn- ceMlfHape, COCTOABlmeMCH B Mae 1998 r. B r. AiMaTbI (Ka3ax- ny no HHKBH4gaaHH HCUIOJIb3OBaHHH1 3TEHJH4OBaHHoro 6eH3H- CTaH), Ha KOTOpOM 6bma 1InPHHATa pe3OhHlOUH5I 0 HOJHOM Ha, B pa6oTe KOTOpOE4 npHlHHIn4 y'IaCTHe 3aHagHoeBporieH - OTKa3e OT HCHOJIb3OBaHHA CBI4HHa B 6eH3aiHe K 2005 r. B CKHe CTpaHbl, CTpaHbl UeHTpanIbHOf4 Hi BOCTO'rHOfi EBponbI, A3ep6aMnKaHe H Ka3aXCTaHe H1 K 2008 r. - B Y36eKHCTaHe. HOBbie He3aBHCHMbie rocygapCTBa C nepexoAHoil 9KOHOM14- Me)KayHapOgHbxH OHbIT CBiHgeTejibCTByeT 0 TOM, HTO KOfl, BceMHpHbIaE 6aHK, EBponCefCKHia 6aHK peKOHCTPYKI4EH npouecc OTKa3a OT HCHIOHb3OBaHHZA CB4HHia B 6eH3a4He gon- H pa3BH4THH (EBPP), EBpOrieflCKHfl COKO3 H HenpaBHTeJTbCT- iKeH npOTeKaTb B paMKax 6onee imHpOKOt iiporpaMMbi Ho- BeHHbIe opraHH3aauHH (HIIO). ,JaHHaA OnepaTHBHaa rpyn- BblILueHHH1 KaMeCTBa TOHJIHBa H1 o6ecneHeHiHz Tpe6yeMoro na pa3pa6OTana perHoHaanbHyio cTpaTerHno oTEa3a OT KaHeCTBa B03agyxa. FI0oTOMy perCoHanIbHOC nlccnegoBaHale HCnOJIb3OBaHHH CBHHlaa B 6eH3r4He K 2005 r. Hi HaMeTHIia >, npegnpHHuToe Bce- peHLHUH MHHHCTpOB npHpOgoOxpaHHbIX BegOMCTB Ha TeMy ME4pHbHM 6aHKoM, TaK)Ke 6bIno npOBegeHO B 6onee uHHpOKOM 00OKpyKaioiuaA cpega B EBpone)>, COCTOABmleECA B Hi-oHe KoHTeKCTe. B 3TOM HccCieCOBaHH4H, KOTopoe oxBaTbIBano Ap- 1998 r. B r. Opxyc (AaHH4A). MeHH1LO, A3ep6aagwaH, rpy3rno, Ka3aXCTaH, Pecny6nHKy B CBS3H1 c o6pa3oBaHH4eM OnepaTHlBHOf4 rpynnbi EBPO- Kbiprbi3CTaH, TaPKE4KlKCTaH, TypKMeHlHCTaH H4 Y36eKHcTaH, neEfCKOE4 3KOHoMHiMeCKOHl KOMH1CCH4E4 OOH H nogqCp)KKOfl 143yaIanC4Cb pa3JIHMHbMe (4aKTOpbI, BO3geefCTByIOl1He Ha Ka'e- BceMHpHoro 6aHKa B caepe nOgrOTOBKII nporpaMM nprppo- CTBO Bo3gyxa B ropogax, H1 6blur4 BbIpa6oTaHbl peKOMeHga- XLooxpaHHbIX geHCTBHfl K BceMHppHoMy 6aHKy o6paTH4AHMCb C U4H no 3KOHOMHMHIHM MepaM HX HeflTpaJM3alIHH. Pe3ynbTa- rIpOCb6oa4 OKa3aTb COaefHCTBHe B peaCJ3auIBH HalHoHaub- TbI 3TorO HCCAeAOBaHHA H311IO)KeHbI B HaCTOHAI4eH pa6OTe. 6 HCTOpnH Bonpoca BcTaBKa 1. MexqAyiapoAHbig onbIT B o6nacTm oTKa3a OT npfMeHeHNS CBHHLWa B 6eH3NHe BBHay HCKJIOqIHTeCJbHO BbICOKOA TOKCHIHOCTH CBHHBa, BO BCeM MHpe BBOq3ITCH 3aflpeTbl Ha ripHMeHeH-He 3THAHsPOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa. B HaCTOHICee BpeMH 6onee TpeX 'IeTBepTefi npoAaBaemOro B MEpe 6eH3HHa flPEXOAHTCA Ha HC3THJIHpOBaHHbih 6eH- 3HH. TexHonorHma He(cTeriepepa6OTKH, Heo6xogmMasA ii nepeBoga HpOH3BOACTBeHHbIX MOWHOCTeC C 3TH1HPOBaBHHoro 6eH- 3afHa Ha He3THJpoBaHHblfl, HIIHPOKO H3BeCTHa H anpo6l1pOBaHa B IIpOMbIHuIJeHHbIX MaCmTa6ax. K KOHIUY 1999 r. oKoJIo 35 npo- MbiLHmeHHO pa3BHTbIX H pa3BHBaIOIHXCH CTpaH HPHHHuIH pelmeHE4e 0 3anpeweHHH MCnOJIb3OBaHHH CBHHua B 6eH3HHe. K rmncny pa3BHBaIOwlfmxCni CTpaH, OTKa3aBmKHXCSI OT ripi4MCHeHeH CBHHUa, OTHOCMTCH BaHriagem, Bpa3ana,H BraTeMana, BeHr- pHSE, HHAlBHH, CIOBaUjKaH Pecny6]HmKa H TaHIaHA. B CpegHea3HaTcKoM H KaBKa3CKOM perlOHe 3aanpeT Ha npHMeHeHH4e CBHH- uxa B 6eH314He, Ha3qHHaA C AHBapH 2000 r., BBeaeH B Fpy3H4H. HecMoTpsl Ha 3HaliHTeJIbHble ycnexn, 4aOCTHrHyTbie B geJI oTKa3a OT HipHMCeHeHHH 3TIHpOBaHHOrO 6eH3avHa, no HaCTO- HILee BpeMH coxpaHSeTCA pa1g HeipaBHJIbHbix HpegCTaBieHHfl 0 He3THJHPOBaHHoM 6eH3HHe. CornacHo OAHOMY H3 HHX, Ha HC3THuIHMOBaHHoM 6eH3HHe MOryT pa6OTaTb TOJIbKO aBTOMo6IH, o6OpyAOBaHHbie KaTaIIHTH'ICCKHMH lipeo6pa3OBaTeIiLMH1. B gCe4CTBHTeCfbHOCTH >Ke, He3THMIHpoBaHHblf 6eH3rHn Mo)KeT HcHOJIb3OBaTbcAE Ha BCCX aBTOMo6HiHnx c 6eH3HHOBbIMH gBHra- TeniMH. Ewe OAHO 3a6JyAgeHHe: 6onbmuoe KOnIWqeCTBO CTapbiX aBToMo6HJeIH, pa6OTalowwc Ha 3THJpOBaHHOM 6eH3HHe, flpH nepexoge Ha He3THJIHPOBaHHblfi 6eH3HH nocTpagaeT B pe3ynibTaTe BblKpaliHHBaHH4HI cegen IKiiariaHOB. JIa6opaTOpHbie iCdibITa- HH31i noKa3aim4, 'ITO B OTCYTCTBHe CBHHIia (KOTOpbIH geC4CTByeT KaK cMa3OIHbIH MaTepHaIi) BbIKipaJIHBaHH4e li(anaHHbIX cegeni MoXKeT HMeTb MeCTO TOhIbKo flpH pa6OTe JBHmraTeJIA B TIDKe)Iblx pe)KHMax, T.e. HpH 6OnbmUwX Harpy3Kax 11 BbICOKHX CKOpOCTSIX. OwHaKO Ha ripaKTH4Ke B 60IbImHHCTBe CTpaH, OTKa3aBLUII-XCH OT HpHMCHeHHII CBH4Hua, BeCbMa pegKO cJJyqaaoCb CTaJIKHBaTb- cSE c npo6neMofl BbIKpaiBHHBaHHA cigen KnianaHoB. HH B OAHOH E3 CTpaH RlaTHHcKof4 AMepHKH4 H KapH6cnoro 6accedHa, rge B nocieCHH4e roJbi 6blCTpbIMH TeMnaMHl HJJ&T npoiecc OTKa3a OT HlpHM4eHeHH1 CB14HUa, He Ha6iTIOga)IOCb CKOnbKO-Hn46yxb 3Ha- 'IHTeCbHbIX npo6)ieM, CBIS3aHHbIX C BblKpaUlHHBaHl4eM cegen KiaHaHoB. Ha HananbHblx 3Tatiax OTKa3 OT ripHMeHeHH4H1 CBHHua B HeKOTOpb1X cnyqaAx IpOTeKauI B TeHieHHe HeCKOJIbKHx eCCHTHICe- Ti14l (KaK HanpHMep, B COeXL1HHHHMX LlTaTax). Ho Ha 6onee HO3JHH4X WTanax HeKOTOpbie CTpaHbI (B TOM IHCYICe CnOBagKaA Pe- cny6nImKa H TaHiiaH) 3aBeplIlJHJI BblIIoJIHeHHe HiporpaMMbi OTKa3a OT UplmeHeHCHA CBHH4a B TeCeHHie 4 - 5 neT. A Te cTpa- Hbl, KOTOpbie B 3HalmTeCbHOf4 CTenlCHH 3aBHCJIT OT HMfIOpTa TOnIiHBa, MOPYT liepeHTH Ha He3THJLpOBaHHbfl4 6eH3HH eua 6blcTpee. HanpiHMep, Hi baHrnageiu, H CanbBagop, pacnonaraiowvme co6CTBeHHOa4 He4rTenepepa6aTblBaloweH npoMbILhIeH- HOCTbIO, OTKa3aJI4Cb OT HpHM4eHeHHH 3THJIl4pOBaHHOrO 6eH3HHa MeHee qeM 3a rog. CTOnb 6bICTpble TeMnbl nepexoga Ha He- 3THJLHpOBaHHbfL4 6eH31HH gaiOT Lgenbif p3ig HpeCHMyWeCTB. TaK, He Tpe6yeTca rIpaKTHIeCKH HHKaKHx KaIIHTanIOBAo)KeHHlI B TOn- JmBO3anpaBOIqHyuO 14HHpaCTpyKTypy, nOCKOJIbKy HeT Heo6xogHMoCTHI B co3gaHH4IH CABOeHHOiI CHCTeMbl TOHJIHBO3aIIpaBKH gnu pa3geneHi-rn 3THJHMOBaHHoro H He3THJIHnOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa. KpoMe Toro, CBegeHHie K MHlHHMyMy nepexogHoro riepHoga, BO BpeMHq KOTOPOFO Ha PbIHKe TIPHCYTCTBYeT OAHOBpeMeHHO H 9THJ14pOBaHHbIfa, H He3THJIHpOBaHHbif4 6eH3HH, CHH)KaeT Bepo- SETHOCTb nepemp&THoro 3arpH3HeHH Hf OmHu6o0HOH4 3aflpaBKH 3THJIHpOBaHHblM 6eH3HHOM gABHraTenen, OCHameHHbIX KaTa- JIHTHM4eCKH4MH ripeo6pa3OBaTeJiAMH4. MOHHTOpH4Hr Ka'IeCTBa Bo0ayxa, TeXOCMOTp H4 Texo6- rpA3HeHl4E. OgHaKO 3aTpaTbl Ha nOBbIleHHle KaMeCTBa TOn- C)yOKH4BaHHe aBToMo6HIIef Ha npeH MeT oleHKH Bbi6pOCOB H mIHBa 4aAyT BeCbMa orpaHHHeHHbIf1 pe3yJIbTaT, eCmIH He 6ygeT nOBbItHeHH4e KaHCCTBa TOIIH4Ba o6pa3yloT TpH B3aHlMoCBA- o6ecne'ieHo HaaaewKamee TeXHH'eCKOe o6CJIy)KHBaHHe aBTO- 3aHHbIX HaHpaB)IeHH4 ilpOrpaMMbl o6ecne'IeHH4H Tpe6yeMo- Mo6Hief, pa6oTaioru-x Ha 3TOM ToniIHBe. BcM 3TO nOTpe6y- ro KaMeCTBa ropoAcKoro B03gyXa B TpaHCriOpTHOf OTpaciHi. eT Bbipa6OTKH cOOTBeTcTByIOMHx HOpM Bbi6pOCOB aBTOMO- Ha OCHOBC qaHHbiX Ho MOHHTOPHHry KaMeCTBa BO3Ayxa 6H111bHbIX gBHraTenef, BbHIBieHCHHH rpy6blX HapyIlHTeiefl MO)KHO BblIHBH4Tb 3arpH3H1HoflmHe BemeCTBa, KOHUeHTpaLRUHA HOpM Bbi6pOCOB H CBoeBpeMeHHoro peMOHTa TpaHcrnOpT- KOTOpbIX ripeBbiimaCT HagHOHanbHbie HOpMbl H CaHHTapHO- HbIX CpegCTB, He npomuegmIlux TCXOCMOTp no KOJiH'eCTBy H rHrHeHm,eCKHCe me>KgyHapOgHbIe peKoMeHgaIHl4H. BbI6op TO- KaMeCTBY BbIXIIOrHbIX ra3OB. ro HilJI HHOFO 3arp3H3HH4TeCJI B KaieCTBe o6'beKTa CHH)KeHHH aJlH Toro 'ITo6bi MO)KHO 6buio "eCTb BCe 9TH Tpm ac- HHTeHCHBHOCTH ero BbI6pOCOB 6ygeT 3aBH4CeTb OT ero KOH- neKTa CTpaTer14E 60pb6bl C BbI6pocaMl4 TpaHCnOpTHbIx uxeHTpa1ixHH B aTMOCtCepHOM Bo3gyxe, a TaKwKe OT ero TOKCEH1- CpeACTB, B gaHHOM H4cc.ieCOBaHH4H oTeHHBaJiH: HOCTH. B CBOIO oMepegb, ripeACTaBIAOIIOWHe OnaCHOCTb Aii5* HbiHemIIHee COCTOAHHle KaieCTBa Bo3gyxa; 3raOPOBbq 1iiogefl 3arpSI3HHTeCu4 6ygyT onpegenalTb napaMe- * HbIHeIHHe H 6ygywilHe xapaKTCpHCTH4KH riapKOB aBTO- Tpbl TOHIIHBa, roAgewxatgNe y)KeCTO'IeHHIO B TeX ropogax, Mo6HieH H Tpe6OBaHH4H K TOI)IuHBy gJIiE HH1X; rAe TpaHCIIOpT ABJSIeTCA CyTWCCTBeHHbIM HCTOMHHKOM 3a- BI114IHHHe KaHecTBeHHbIx xapaKTepHCTHK pa3JIHMHbX 7 HlpHMeHeHHe 6onee MHCTMX MOTOPHbIX TODI;HB ARR o6ecnieMeHiH MHCTOTbI BO3AYXa B CTpaiax CpeAHetk A3HH H KaBKa3a BH4OB TorLII4Ba Ha Bbl6pocbl aBToMo6HJIbHbIx BwHraTe- TeH4eHLT44H - no BBeCeHH1IO B geWCTBHe BHyTpeHHHX nieE4 1 KaqeCTBO Bo03yxa; CTaHgapTOB. CTpaHbI LeHTpanbHoE A314E4 H KaBKa3a * 3HaMeHe H43MeHeH14H cnpoca H4 KWMeCTBa TOrUIHBa gifl MorJl 6bl Ha3BJIeb BbIroAY 13 exlHHoo6pa3Horo noxxo- He(4TeHepepa6aTbIBaioigeH OTpaCJIH; ga K BOflpOCaM o6ecneMeHE4H KaMecTMa TOHJiHBa, BBHAY * TexHwHecKaa BO3MO)KHOCTb i4CIIOlIHCHI4$ 1H CTOHMOCTb HXeHTHMHOCTH4 CTOJUJ4HX nepe, HHMH rpo6JieM 3arpsA3- pa3JIHH'HbIX BapHaHTOB HOBbImeHHH Ka'neCTBa TOn- HCHHE$ ropoAcKorFO Bo3gyXa 14 H epCeKTH1B yBejiHMe- JIHBa; HHH1 BHyTpHperHOHaJIbHOa TOprOBJIH. * H3MeHeHHHA B CTpaTerHH He41Texgo6blBaKiolero CCKTO- He4imenepepa6ambasoaouAefi npoMbiwAennocmu neo6- pa, BKJIIONla3I BOrlpOCbi geHoo6pa3oBaHHq, (cl4CKaJIb- xoaUMo umemb opuenmupononHbue OaHHbie o 6yayu4ux Hbie mepbi )iH6epamH3auEHIo TOprOBEIH Hec+TenpogyK- cmaHaapmax no pu3AUqHbM ouaaM monAuea, qmo6bi TaMH, CO3ga4oB04H 6naronpHnITHbile YChIOBHH AJIA UMemb e03MojIHoCmb nAanupoeamb KanumaAoooM-ce- BHeApeH4HH 6onee mIHcTorO TorIIHBa. HUM. He4Tenepepa6aTbBaboiwaA ripOMbmEinIIeHHOCTb B AHaJIH3 KaMecTBeHHbIXxapaKTep4CT lK pa3hIWI-HbIX BH- gaHHOM perHoHe HaxogW4TcC Ha CTagHH 1peopraHH3aaIEi{ gOB TOnrIHBa Ha periOHaHIbHOM ypOBHe IBJIIeTCSI oco6eHHO H npIHBaTHaagHH, riplHUM CyH4eCTByeT MHo)KecTBO CBOeBpeMeHHbIM 1o CAne,ylO1J4HM rIp14E,HaM: ripeO)jnKeHHI4 OTHOCH4TeCbHO CxeM Mo4CepHH43aEH * B 6nuvca4uwem 6yayu4eM noAnemcam nepecmompy mexHu- He4+Tenepepa6aTbIBaioUn4x 3aBOgOB. 14HBeCTOpaM He- qeCKue cne4uq'iUKazAuu pa3AUYHbtX ouaoe monAuaa. o6xogHMo HMeTb &IeTKHC pa3'bSACHeHIA HpaBHTeJlbcT- rlpeAxHHe coBeTcKH4e CTaHMapTbl Ha TOHEIHBO y)Ke He BeHHbIX Be,OMCTB OTHocHTeJbHo 6ygyi4iHx crieTHcll4- OTBeqalOT Tpe6OBaHHASM MeHHI014HXCAI aBTOMo6HAib- KaILJ14f Ha TOnJI14BO, C TeM qTO6bl O144 MOrIH HbIX iiapKOB H HaCTO0HTCIbHOfH Heo6xOgHlMOCTH oxpaHbl HaBH1I4MulHM o6pa3oM pacriOpqglHTbC1 CBOHM1H KaIllTa- 3,OpOBb51 HacejieHHsl. BO Bcex HOBbIX He3aBHCHMbIX JIOBJIO)KeHHHM14, CpOK KOTOpbIX rnpeArOJIO)KHTeJIbHO rocygapcTBax fnpOHCXOA4T iepeCMOTP CTaHgapTOB Ha MO)KeT COCTaBAJITb 20 14 6onee neT. Be3 TaKlHX opHeHTH4- pa3JIH'Hbie B14Hbl TOnUIHBa H HOpM BbI6pOCOB aBTOMO- pOB pemmeHm- HHBeCTOPOB 0 KaII4TaIOBJIO)KeHHsAX He 6wHIbHbIX ABHraTe)iefl, yHachiegOBaHHbIX OT 6blBmero 6yAyT OrITHmMaIbHbiM14, a 3aga'n oxpaHbi OKpy)Kaio- COBeTCKoro Cob03a. B MaPTe 1992 r. 6bm11 yqpe)KgCH nefa cpeabI 6yAyT BblnojiHeHbl He IIOJIHOCTbIO, B cnyiae MeCKrocyXapCTBeHHbIfl KOMHTeT, B KOTOpbltk BOuhJIO BO3H14KHOBeHHII IIpOTHBoge4CTBH11 B OTHOiiieHHH4 6onbmHnIcHTBo CTpaH gaHHoro perHloHa, gnq peeieHna nepecMoTpa cneLIjHc14KaixllHl Ha pa3JIHMHbIe B14Hb Ton- BOnpOCOB, CBH3aHHbIX C CTaHgapTH3agHef, MeTpoJiorH- AIMa, BBegeHHbIX B Aef4CTBHe y)Ke nocne Haiajia peaJnH- efi 14 cepTH4)HKaulHefh. DiaBbi rocygapcTB nogrHmcani 3aLIHH riporpamm MOepHH3aULLHH HecjTenepepa6aTbl- coriiamelHe, cOrnIaCHo KOTOpOMy Ha nepexogHblf4 He- BaKoi0UHX 3aBogoB. pHOg Heonpege1I&HHofI4 IpOAO1DKHTC)ebHOCTH rplHHH- flp143HaBaa Heo6xogHMOCTb B Me)KOTpaCJIeBOM COTpyg- MaKOTCsI CTaHBapTbI 6blBmIero CoBeTcKoro Co0o3a. B HHqeCTBe, K COBMeCTHOHl pa6oTe B paMKaX HacTo3iiuero perH- HeKOTOpb1X CTpaHaX 6bi11H C03gaHbI co6CTBeHHbie Me- OHaJbHOrO HccJIeg0BaHHH 6bI)lH Ip1HB)IeCeHbi cnyxKanHe xaHH3Mbl nepecMoTpa CTaHgapTOB, HO, nOXO)Ke, nOKa B IIpHpogooxpaHHblX, 3HepreTHMeCKHX 14 TpaHCnOpTHbix rocy- 3TOM HaipaBJIeHHH HeT iipaKTHMeCKH HHKaKl4X HO- aapCTBeHHbIX BegOMCTB, a TaKioe ripegCTaBHTeiH ripOMbIuI- gBH)KeK. JIeHHOCTH, HayIHbiX yqpe)KgeHHl 14 HeiiHpaBITeJIbCTBeHHbIX * Heo6xoauMopaccMompemb aonpocynU4bUKal4uu cman- opraHaUaujnl. HlOMHiMO HpsOBseeHHA cHieiH4aIbHbIX 14ccIe- aapmoo Ha pa3AU'Hbie BUaOb monAuoa. Becb OcTaibHOf4 AOBaHH4H no MOHHTIOPHHrY KaMeCTBa ropoAcxoro Bo0ayxa, MHp ,BH4)KCTCSI B HaripaBnehIH yHH4(3HKauHH CTaHgap- BbI6pOcaM aBTOMo6HJIbHblIx BHraTeliefl H HefTrrenepepa6a- TOB Ha BHAbI TOHJI4Ba H HOpM BbI6pOCOB aBToMo6HJIb- TbiBaKo11eMy ceKTopy, gaaHHa riporpaMMa nO3BojIHhia co- HbIX ,BHraTeJIe4. TaKoro poga yHHI4IKaIgHH rHipBOAHT 3,aTb cpegy gnu o6MeHa MHeHHHf1M14 Me>Kgy nOnHTHKaMH, K nOBbIlmieHHbo 3N4eKTHBHOCTH Il4H ripOH3BOCTBe 'iaCTHbIM CeKTOpOM, MHorOHaLUHOHa8bHbMMH 6aHKaMH, opra- aBToMo614AefH H cnoco6CTByeT BHeApeHHIO o1HmeH- HH3aUHHMH no ripegoCTaBBieHHIO HOMOW1H H 41HHaHCHCTaMH HbIX npO,yKTOB. XOTH B HacTo03uee BpeMSI CTpaHbI, 0 nO BOUpOCy HogagCepKK egCHHoro nogxoga K rOrOTOBKe KOTOpbIX H,4eT pexb B gaHHOM HlcciegOBaHHH, 14 HBJIqI- CTaHjapTOB Hi 4opMHpoBaHHKO CTpaTerlllH B perHoHe B 6ygy- IOTCA ineHaMH4 Me)KrocyAapcTBeHHoro KOMH4TeTa ro beM. Bonee nogpo6Hoe omHcaHHe MeponpHH1TIHt4, npegnpm- cTaHgapTH3auinH, a HiX Crieu114KaiLaH Ha BHfbl TOnIH- HATbIX B paMKaX BbIoJiHeHHJI AaHHOi4 HpOrpaMMbi, npHBo- Ba y)Ke B aHaHITeJbHOR CTeHeH14 yHH4)HI4HpoBaHbI, AHTC3H B flpVrOnKemHI A. rpe,npHHHmaloTCAl mar14 - BoHpeKK cyweCTBybOI4ef4 8 MOH4TOpH1Hr Ka'IeCTBa BO3NYXa eaJIH3aLU4J 3KOHOMHqHOH riporpaMMbi CoKpanweHHA KO0iH'ieCTBa BpCeHbIX BbI6pOCoB H CHH)KeHH3 ynjep6a 3W0POBbIO JIiojiea Tpe6yeT KOMflJIeKCHOrO nioxxoga K riogep)KaHHIo Tpe6yeMoro KaMeCTBa BO3JayXa B ropoxgax. BaxKHbIM 3JIeMeHTOM B pa3pa6OTKe cTpaTern4 rioqaep)KaHHjI Tpe6yeMoro Ka- 'ieCTBa ropogcKorO BO3gyXa IBJIHieTCa CIIoco6HOCTb ocyLeCTBJIATb MOHHTOpHHF H OiLeHKY KaMeCTBa Bo3Jgyxa. )Iq IIH H HHTITH4 peiiieHfli, rJIaBHoH LeWIbIO KOTOpbIX AIBhIeTCuI oxpaHa 3AOpOBbA }iioieg, Heo6xo- AHMO MMeTb oTpa6oTaHHylo CHCTeMy MOHHTOPHHra H MoJeJIHpOBaHHH. TaKoro poxa CHCTeMa MOHHTOpHH- ra AOJDKHa pe-I4ITb pRJJ KJiOioeBbIX 3agaai: C6op aaHHblX 0 KOHt4eHmpat4UXx 3aepM3HumeAefl amMo- AAA HPOBeCeHH51 cpaBHeHHH, MOHITOpHHr qOJDKeH BeCTHCb c4fepHoeo oo3syxa. HHwe flIP4BeCeHbI iHeCTb HaH6onee BpeC- HOCTOHHHO. HbIX 3arp13HHHTeniet4, HioJIe>KaiU4HX peryJiHpHOMy MOHIITO- Hn6eHmapu3a4usr 6bl6pOCOB. BbMHBJIeHHIKO riogie)KaT Bce pllHry, KOTOpbIe B03 KJiaCCH14H14UpyeT B Ka'ieCTBe HCTOMHHKH BpeCHbIX Bbi6pOCOB - KaK nogBH)KHbie, TaK H «(KnaccmwIeCKHx>> 3arpA3HHTeJIeH: CTauHoOHapHbie. O6brrIHO HHTeHCHBHOCTb BbI6poCOB Bblpa- * CBHrHeu; )KaeTCA B TOHHaX 3arpI3HHTel)I B rog. Ecrni H3MepATb Bbl- * PM2 5/PMIO (ToHKoHcicnepcHble a9po30aoJ, aapoAwHa- 6pOCbl B TOHHaX, TO HO 3TOMy nOKa3aTeJIO CO, KaK npaBHIIO, MlIleCKI(fH gHlMaeTp KOTOpbIX COCTaBBJICT MeHee 2,5 U HaMHOFO rpCBOCXOXIHT BCe OCTa)IbHbie 3arp33HHTeJiH; OXHa- 10 MHKpOHOB, COOTBeTCTBeHHO); KO, 3WeCb cnegyeT HMeTb B BHAy, ITO ero TOKCW-IHOCTb Ha * MOHOKCHAI yrnepoga (CO); HeCKOJTbKO HOpHAKOB MeHbIHe, 'leM TOKCWIHOCTb xpyrHx 3a- * XJHOKCH19 Cepbi (SO2); rpA3HlTenefE HeKOTOpbie AOJI>KHOCTHbie in4ua OIHH6OI'HO * JIIOKCHgJ a3oTa (NO2); CYMMHpyIOT B peeCTpe Bbi6pOCOB Beca BCeX 3arp3I3Hl4Teieaf, * 030H. OTMeMaJOT, HTO BbI6pOCbI CO n13 aBTOMO6HIIbHbIX ABwHraTeJieH MOHHITOpH4Hr KaieCTBa B03yXBa IHIHHATo rpOBOXEHTb B COCTaBnIslOT OWLYTHMYIO AO)TOO B CyMMapHOM KOWICveCTBe pa3HbIX MeCTaX, BKJIOMaSI «ropAHtie TOIKH>> B ropogax (3oHbl, BbI6pOCOB n npH4XOIqT, HanpHmep, K TaKOMY BbIBOgy: <KHJibie pafno- Bo3gyxa»>. TaKoHi HOIXOq He Y'4HTbIBaeT TOKCHMHOCTb, B03- Hbl, rgle MO)KHO Orlpege)I4Tb B3Oef4CTBHe Bbi6pOCOB Ha XKii- AealCTBH4e Ha 3J0pOBbe JHOJelC H1 gaIbHOCTb pacipoCTpaHe- TenIeE ropoga; H CeCJbCKyIO MeCTHOCTb (sBnnnOwpyOCA nOKa- HHH pa3hIHMHbX 3arpHA3HHTeJieE H MO)KeT ipEHBeCTH4 K He- 3aTeJeM OrOHOBbIX KOHiAeHTpaLU4Ii). flonyieHHbie AaHHble ripaBBHbHbIM BbIBOAaM npH paCCTaHOBKe npHOpH1TeTOB. lPEH3BaHbi noMOMb B BbIHBJieHHHI Tex 3arpH3HHTeJIefI, KOH- NpooeeHue Moaenupo6aHusr aaAbHocmu pacnpocmpatie- geHTpaBrtI KOTOpbIX iipeBbIHBaeT HailHoHanfbHbIe n Me)Kgy- HUA 3aeps3HumeAeai. MogeJIfpOBaHr4e aJ)IbHOCTH pacnipoCT- HapOAHble HOpMbl E peKOMeHgalBUHH HO KBMICTBY B03ayXa, paHeHH3H 3arpHA3HTeJieH HO3BOJIAeT BbMABHTb H1CTOMHH1KH KaK, HanpilMep, CaHHTapHO-rHrHeHH4MeCKHe peKomeHaIauHH BbI6pOCOB, OKa3blBaiOWHe HaH6oJIbmLee BJIHqHHe Ha KOH- B03 no KaqeCTBy B03gyXa. STH MeCKg;yHapOgHble HOpMbl H UeHTpaUHIO 3arp3HHHTeJIefl B aTMoc4fepe. TaKan EwHHOpMa- PieKOMeHWaiHH pacnpoCTpaHAlOTC1 Ha cpexHi4e 3HaMeHMA UI4 HMCeeT H1CKhOMHTehIbHYIO iLeHHOCTb fpfH pa3pa6OTKe KOHUeHTpa-HH4 3a nepHoj He MeHee o0Horo roga, HO3TOMY cTpaTerHn 6opb6blI 3a o6ecne4eHne Tpe6yeMorO KaMwCTBa 9 HpHMeHeHme 6onee YIHCTblX MOTOpHblX TOIlJHB ABA o6ecneHeHHa 'HCTOTbI B031YXa B CTpaHaX CpeAHeR A3Hs4 KaBKa3a Bo3xgyxa. Hpi 3TOM OCHOBHbIM KPHTepC1eM AB)ISCeTCA CTe- aHaJIH3aTOpOB, O6ecneClHBa1oHIHX HCipepbIBHblIl c6op HH- riCHb BO3geHiCTB1A Ha 3AOPOBbe 'IeIIOBeKa. BbI6pocbo 113 BbI- 4opMajHH, ocyIeCTBJIASICA MOHHTOpHHr N02, CO, o3oHa H COKHX ,qbIMOBbIX Tpy6 pacHpOCTpaH1IOTCA1 Ha ropa3A0 6onb- CBH; KOHLUeHTpailiO CBHHqa OllpeAenulH HIHAHBHgyaJIb- mHe paCcTOAHHA, HeCKeiiH BbI6pOCbi 113 HH3KHX HCTOWHHKOB HbiM ripH66opoM. AAI c6opa AaHHbIX no N02, S02 H 030Hy Ha (HanpHMep, aBToMo6imefl), flO3TOMy HpH paBHOM BeCOBOM o6r-u11pHblX TeppHTOpH1X Ka)KJIoro ropoga 4criOJb3OBaJIH KO)iHMeCTBe yMep6 OT BbI6pOCOB H3 aBToMo6HJIbHbIx jB4ra- naCdHBHbIe IIpo6OOT6OpHHKH B BH4Ce 4HJTbTpOCHbIX Tpy6OK TeielH HaMHOrO HpeBOCXOW4T yiep6 OT BbI6pOCOB 113 BbICO- (CM. BCTaBKy 2). KHX TabIMOBbIX Tpy6. PEKOMEHAAI4UI no MOHUTOPUHIY nPIMEHSIEMbIE nPOLEAYPbI KAHECTBA BO3YXA TpawmwyOHHO MOHHTOp14HF KaqeCTBa Bo3gyxa B CTpaHax ConocTanneHrle gaHHbIX OT6opa npo6, HpOBeCgHHbIX UeHTpanbHoh A34H n KaBa3a flPOBOAH4JICH I1no 3r4go RFo- BceMHpHbiM 6aHKOM B BaKy i TamKeHTe, C gaHHbiMi4 rngpo- CygapCTBeHIOFO KOMHTeTa CCCP no ri4gpomeTeoponornn H MmeTeopoJIorHeCKHX BCeOMCTB CBH4eTeCIbCTBYeT 0 TOM, 'ITO KOHTpOJ1O OKpyXKaioniefl cpexbI (TocKoMeuOpoMema). B Ha- B gaHHbIX FOcKOMrw4poMeTa B 6OnbLU1HcTBe cIy-qaeB 3aHH- CTOJiJee BpeMH, no)io)KeHH4e gen B pa3IH'qHbIX CTpaHaX ,gaH- >KeHbl KOHiLeHTpaUHlH CO, 3aBbHlllHbl KOHljeHTpaqiH4 CB' Hl HOrO perFHoHa oTJIHqaeTCH: B Y36eKcwcTaHe Ho-npe)KHeMy CHNJIbHO 3aH4)KeHbI KOHueHTpaiAiH CBHHUa. ,Ja)Ke npn Hbl- 4yHKIIHOHHpyeT pa3BepHyTa3 CeTb CTaHLjHH MOHHTOpHH- HeIHUHeH BeCbMa HH3KOH 3KOHoMH'I1eCKOI aKTHBHOCTH KOH- ra, a ApMeHuH H Fpy3irm ripOBCeeHH MOHHTOpHHra KameCT- AeHTpaUHA HeKOTOpbIX 3arpf3HHTeJiea B aTMoc4 epHOM B03- Ba BO3gyXa IIOIHOCTbO rpeKpaTHJIOCb B KOHUe 80-x 14111 Ha- gayxe yKe npeBbllIaeT peKOMeHaBUIHm B03. A B pe3yIbTaTe qane 90-x rr. 3KOHOMW1eCKoro pOCTa B TeMeHHe riocCehyioCgIxOIH 10 CeT, B HlpHMeHaeMbie B HaCTOHI4ee BpeMH npoi4eJypbl MOHM- YCJIOBHAX HOpMaIbHOf4 geJIOBOf4 aKTHBHOCTH 6ygeT HMeTb TOprnHra Ka-ieCTBa BO3Xy aABJIAIOTCA HgeHTHl'HblMH no BCe- MeCTO CyHeCTBeHHOe ripeblbiueHme 3THX peKoMCHrOBaHHbIX My perHoHy. 3Ta MeTOAl4Ka yHacnexoBaHa eiJi C COBCTCK1X 3HaMeHH4f. OrpaHwieHHbnt o6ibeM Honiy'eHHbIX gaHHbIX ga- BpeMCH 1 3aKaInoaeTcA B npOBegeHHHH 20-MHHyTHbMX 3aMe- eT OCHOBaHHAr npegronaraTb, 'ITO BO MHOrIHX cRyiaAx 3amep pOB 3 pa3a B XeHb (KaK iTpaBHhIO, B 7 MacOB, B 13 'aCOB H B 19 KOHUeHTpaiUHH 3arpA13HHTeiefl HPOH43BO4HhICH HenpaBHJIbHO. 'JaCOB) 6 AHeH B HeeiiiorI. HPH 3TOM MOHHTOpI1Hry HOJBepra- )Ji5z COBepCieHCTBOBaHHH cyweCTByOlO4efl CHCTeMbI MOH1H- IOTCS He BCe HopMHpyeMb1A 3arpA3HHTeiH. HanpHMep, MOHH- TopHHra MO)KHO peKOMeH4OBaTb CiegyIoH4ee: TOP14HH 03OHa npOBOJTHTCH JIH4lb B He6OJIbUlOM KO)Hu4eCTBe TexHuqecKue So3MoZcHocmu annapamypbt. CTpaTeriui OT- MeCT. Ha 6OnblllHHcTBe CTaHLAiHM MOHHTOpHHra, HO Bcei4 BH- 6opa npo6 npH MOHHTOPHHre (20-M4HnyTHbie CeaHCbI TpU rHMOCTH, perynApHo rHPOBOXATCA1 H3MepeHHJ1 CO 1H CyM- pa3a B geHb) He ripeACTaBhIHeTCT 344eKTHBHOHl aI3 onpeae- MapHbIX B3BeCLHeHHbIX qaCTHI (CB', 'ITO O3HaMaeT maCTHUbI JieHHI4 cpeAHHX HNA HeCTaiUHOHapHblX rIOKa3aTeJIeH KaMCCT- Bcex pa3MepoB). Oco6oe 6eCrOKOflCTBO B OTHoLHeHHH1 3A0- Ba BO3gyxa. TaKa3 CTpaTerH oco6eHHo Henpi-irogHa B TeX 30- pOBb li1OgeeH BbI3bIBaCT TOT (4aKT, 'TO B gaHHOM peCMOHe He Hax, rge MmeeT MCCTO 6bJCTpoe H3MeHeCHe KOHTCHTpaiLIMH OCyILeCTBJIAeTCA MOHHTOpHHF PMIO 1H PM2.5, XOTSI 3TH 3a- 3arpA3H14TeCJei4. CTpaHbI-y"acTHllbI AOJDKHbl CTpCM14TbCH rPH3HMTeCiH OKa3bIBaIOT Ha 3AOpOBbe JHoJeCi HaMHOro 6onee K OTKa3y OT HbIHeClHeC4 CHCTeMbI B IlO)Ib3y MeTOgX1a Henpe- nary6Hoe BO3)WHiCTBHe, ,eM CBH (CM. HppmoxKeHi4e B). Co- pbIBHOrO MOHHTOpHHra, 'ITO rIO3BOJlHT rpOBOAHTb COnOC- 6paHHbie HO TaKOH cxeMe gaHHbie TpY,jHO COnOCTaBJIATb C TaBJIeHHC HOnI"eHHbIX aHHbIX C peKoMCH,r ;AHIMH B03 no PeKOMeHMaHHMmH B03, KOTOpaR, KaK npaBMHIO, Tpe6yeT KaqCCTBY BO3gyxa. HIpH HbMHeClHCe CHCTCMe KOHiLeHTpa1HIO ripeCCTaB)1eHHA Cpe,CHMX gOHyCTHMbIX ypoBHeft 3a 1,8 Hxun 24 CBHHIJa MOWKHO KOHTpO1IHpOBaTb TOhIbKO C rIOMOMb1O HaKO- Maca, a TaKKCe 3a rog. HTeCJibHbIX 4IHJbTpOB a3po3aoeie B TeCeHHCe OgHoro MecAla. JleTOM 1999 r., B xoAe ripOBeCeHHHI4 nccne,oBaHHA Bce- Heo6xoHMmo o6ecne'nHTb B03MO)KHOCTb flno)iCHHH agaH- MHpHoro 6aHKa B BaKy (A3ep6aif4pKaH) H TalIIKeHTe (Y36e- HbIX HO KOHiUeHTpaUMH CBHHT4a C pa3pemieHH4em no BpeMeHM, KHCTaH) B Te'eHMH eHpMepHO 10 AHeCi B KawMom ropoge a He B BH,ae 3HaCeHHil, yCpeC;HCHHbIX 3a Mecag. IpOBOAHJCH MOHHTOpHHr KaWeCTBa BO3ayxa. IJCeJb aToro Me- Om6op 3aaepM3aumeAeC, noaAeYfaU4ux MoHumopuney. Pe- pOrpHAHTHA 3aKajiioaiaCb B flOJIy"eHHM 3aHHbIX, KOTOpbIe ryuIipAHbie 1H3MepeHHM PM10 1411IH PM2.5 oKa3anncb 6bl Ha- Hanpsimyo MO)KHO 6buio 6bl cpaBHH1BaTb C peKoMeHgaalUHHM MHOro 6onee HiOKa3aTe1bHbbIMH, He)Ke1iH 3aMepbi CB'L. Ilep- B03, a TaK>Ie COIJOCTaBJIBTb 9TH 3aMepbi C 3aMepaMH, Bbl- BOCTereHHOe 3HaieHile HMCeeT BO3JJeHCTBHe 3arp13HeHH1 HOIIHeHHbIMH MeCTHbIMH rHgpoMeTeopoiorMieCKHMMI4 Be- Bo3,ayxa Ha 3XDOpOBbe niogefi, a KPYRHOHCiepCHbie MaCTHUbl, AOMCTBaMM. C rioMoHib1o aBTOMaTHiMecKMx HO1TaTMBHbIX KOTOpbIe MBIBH1OTCM 'iaCTblO 3amepoB CB'I, KaK OKa3anJoCb, He 10 MOHNTOpiur KiveCTBa B03ByXa BCTaBKa 2. l3MepeHme Ka4eCTBa B03AyXa B BaKy U TawKeHTe Thlnq rioJIyCeHi4 gaHHbIX, KOTOpbIe MO)KHO 6brno 6bl HCHO)Tb3OBaTb gnA oUCeHK14 cyIgeCTBy1O14HX MeTOgOB MOHHTOpHH- ra Ka'ieCTBa BO3gyXa B A3ep6aflxpKaHe ii Y36eKiu-cTaHe, B BaKy Hi TalmKeHTe Ha FH4ApoMeTeopOnrIOFMeCKHX Ha6nIogaTenbHbIX HoCTax, pacriohioAKeHHbIX B AOCTaTOqHOf4 6JIH3OCTH OT KpylTHbIX gopor, 6bLiuH yCTaHOBnieHbi HOpTaTHBHbIe aHaJI43aTOpbl C BbICOKOHl pa3pemaiornea CiiOCo6HOCTbIO. MOKHo 6bIno oAKHgaTb, 'qTO lplH flOrOXHbIX yCHOBHIHX, npeo6naqaiownx B 3TMX MeCTaX, KOHUeHTpagHUH 3arpH3HHTeJiefl aTMOC4)epbl Ha irpoT5AKeH(H4H neploga MOHHTOP1HHra 6ygyT HH3KHMH B BaKy 14 Bbl- COKHMH B TalInKeHTe. HlacCHBHbIe MHJIbTpOCHbie Tpy6KH, YCTaHOBhieHHbie B 20 TOIKaX B o6oHx ropogax, perHCTpHpOBamu COBOKyrIHbie cpeAHHe KOHUeHTpaUHH4 3arpHs3HHTeJieti B TeC'eHHC ripHMepHO OXHOHi HeAeenl4. B o6o0x ropoqax YPOBHH KOHUeHTpaUHH S02 6bIIH4 H143KHMM. YpOBHH KOHUeHTpaLH4H 03oHa B TalmKeHTe 6bUJIH HaMHoro Bblllme, HeM B BaKy. ConocmafneHue cpeKoMeHuaL4ufJMu B03. HlOny'eHHbie faHHbie CBHCeTeAbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, -TO B BaKy peKomeHgyembie HopMaTHBbi B03 no N02 B TeCHeHHe 10 AHeH ripeBbIiila)IHCb gBa)Kgbi. B TamKeHTe Ha nIpOTJIKeHHH 8 AHeCH peKoMeHAyeMbie HopMaTHBbi B03 no 030Hy IipeBblIHuhIHCb 15 pa3, a no NO2 - B o6ewfl CJIO)KHOCTH 7 pa3. YPOBHH KOHi4eHTpaUHH CO B o6o0x ropogax HaxoqUAHCb B npegenax peKOMeHgyeMbIX HOpMaTHBOB B03. B BaKy YPOBHH KOHueHTpa1IHH CB'-J 6bIi npH- eMJIeMbiMH. (B TamxIKeHTe nIpOBO4HTb H3MepeHHHl KOHUeHTpaUfHH CB'I 6bino HeBO3MOAKHO, HOCKO)TbKy aHahIH3aTOp CB'- 6bm1 noBpe)KgeH BO BpeMH TpaHCHopTHpOBKH.) YPOBHHl KOH14eHTpaLIHH CBHHga B BaKy H3MeHIiJIHCb B npegeenax OT 0,03 go 0,1 MHKPorpaMMOB Ha Ky6HieCKHfl MeTp (MKr/M3, a B TamIKefTe COCTaBJIHJIH 0,15 MKr/M3. CpaBHeHue C HblHeuiHUMU memoaamu MoHumopuHea. COIIOCTaBJIeHH4e aHHbIX, HOiJI"eHHbIX C ilOMOii4biO aBTOMaTHqe- CKHX HeHpepblBHbIX aHaJIu3aTopoB, C gaHHbIMH, CO6paHHbIMH KoMHTeTaMHr no rHgpoMeTeoponorin, o6HapypK4BaeT HH- TepBai OT 6Hn3Koro COBniageIHn go 7-KpaTHoro paCXoAKgeHHq. 3HaieHMA KOHJeHTpaiHa, flOJ1"eHHbIe C cIOMOIUbJO Henipe- pbIBHbIX aHaJIH3aTopoB, oTJiH'iwaIoTCs OT 3HaqeHHHi, rioJIIyqeHHbIX KOMIHTeTaMH Ho rHqpoMeTeopoJIorHH: no N02 -noqT B 3 pa3a, no CO - HOqTH B 5 pa3 H no CBH H CBHHUy -Ha flOpAAOK BeCJH414HbI. HaM npegcTaBneeTCa q,TO YPOBHH KOH- UeHTpaHIHH B3BemLueHHOrO CBHHUa B 3TOM pernoHe TpagHIHOHHO 3aHH)KaJIlCb. HIOcKonbKy meTOnHKa ipOBCegeHHA MOHH- TopHHra ABJIAeTCA eAgHoo6pa3Hoa no BceMy pernoHy CpegHei A3HH H KaBKa3a, 9THI pe3yJbTaTbl CBiHgeTeJbCTBYIOT o6 aHa- AOrMHqHOM 3aHHAKeHHH gaHHbIX Ha 6onee o611IpHo04 TeppH4TOpHH. HIog6opKa HCKOTOpbIX gaHHbIX npegcTaBneiHa B HlpHJIO>KeHHH C. Bo3MOXKH51OCb TeM, -TO pe3yJlbTaTbl npegCTaBhIeHHbIe KOMHTeTaMH no rHgpoMeTeopoJIorHH, Haxo- AATCA Ha nopore yBCTBHTeJIbHOCTH MCHOThb3yeMolT H3MepHTCeIbHofi annapaTypbl. HanpHMep, B cny'ae CBM BeCbl HMeCIH HH3KY1O pa3peuiaionpyio cHoco6HOCTb, H03TOMY ITpeICTasBheHHbie 3HaqeHHA HaXOgHTCH Ha nopore MyBCTBHTenlbHOCTH HTHX BeCOB. KpoMe TOrO, O Bcel BHAHMOCT, HMeeT MeCTO HeYOBeTBOPHTebHa rnogroToBKa IHJIbTpoB, a caMH 43H11b- Tpbl HerHiHrOHbl nn c6opa a3po3oJIefl HpH npeo6nagaionIQx 3HaueHHiX pacxoga BO3gyXa. OMmHMO aToro, HCHOJIb3yeMaA B HaacTonAee BpeMH annapaTypa He rO1HTCH ARn H3MepeHHR PMlo H PM25, T.e. a3po3onef, rnpegcTaBnnIAonHx HaH6oJIbnlyO oiaCHoCTb Agn 3ROPOBbA liogell. OKa3blBaJOT CKOJIbKO-HH6yAb BpegHOrO BJIHiHH4A. KOHUeHT- Bbl6op mecma npooeOeHus MOHumopuHea. HocKonbKy B pauHn oaoHa H3mepneTcn TOJIbKO Ha OAHOM Ha6niogaTenb- HacTongee BpeMH 6onblHHcTBo CTaHUHh MOHHTOpHHra HOM HoCTe B TamKeHTe, rge, KaK noKa3aaio HccuiegoBaHie, HaxOHTCH B AKWIbiX paaOHax, TO HeBO3MO)KHO HlOAy'IHTb rpeBblimaloTcA peKomeHgaUHnn B03. HpHHHMaS BO BHHMa- HO'ITH HHKaKOH 1H(HopMaiu4H 0 KOHUeHTpaIUHH 3arp33Hm- HHe pe3ynIbTaTbl HccJiegOBaHHfl HeTpepblBHoro MOHHTOp4H- TenIeH4 B «> H1H 0 (OHOBOH KOHUeHTpagHH. ra H iaCCHBHoro OT6opa npo6, HeO6Xog4Mo yBenlP-rnTb q4C- B axuHTenbHOf4 nepcneKTHBee g;n co3aaaHmn 6onee nouiHoro no Ha6JiogaTeJIbHbIX HOCTOB gRn H3MepeHHI4 KOHUeHTpaq4HH npegcTaBneHi4n 0 Ka-eCTBe Boagyxa ienecoo6pa3Ho 6bu1o 03OHa B Tex ropoAax, rge HMeCOTCA HIH3HaKH nOBbIUeHHbIX 6bI pa3BepHyTb ceTb KOHTPOhIbHbix HOCTOB Ha goporax, a KOHUeHTpaiHfi O3OHa B aTMocl2epe. Ha HaaJIbHoM WTane co- TaK>Ke B ripOMbiuhJeHHbIX 3OHaX H B ceCIbCKOH MeCTHOCTH. BeplCeHCTBOBaHHH CHCTeMbi MOHHTOpI4HIa HipaBHTe)IbCTBa Ha3CepWCKU om peaAluat(uu 3mux peKoMe-ua4uia eat3a Au MOryT paCCMOTpeTb B03MO)KHOCTb COKpaiienHHi qHcuia 3a- 6y)ym 3atiaumeAbHbiMu. Aawe HpH Ip4HHATHH CaMoH pa3- rpn3HHTeJIeH, nogneoawnx peryulApHOMy H3MepeHHIO, C TeM BepHyTO ilporpaMmbi, o6opyAoBaHie CTaHLMJH HenpepblB- oTo6bi KOMieHCHpOBaTb yBe)iHHeHHe paCXOAOB Ha MOgepHH- Horo MOHHTOpHHra KaqeCTBa Bo3gyxa, o6ecHe'iHBaiomeie 3aUH1o o6opyAoBaHiH. H3MepeHHe BCeX ueCTH HOpMHpyeMbIX 3arpA3HHTenefl, 11 HpHMmeHeHHe 6onee 'HCTbIX MOTOpHbIX TOrijAHB AJIH O6eCDeMeHHH 'HCTOTbl B03)yxa B CTpaHax CpeAHeta A3MH 14 KaBKa3a o6oflk&rCA MeHeei 'eM B 300 TbIC. ,Toui. CIIA. Ha Hawa)IbHOfl CIIA. CTOHMOCTb pa3BCpTbIBaHHHI H 3-neTHea4 3KcdnyaTa- CTaJLHH MoAepHH3agLLH CHCTeMbi, B03MO)KHO, LeJIecoo6pa3- LIHH OAHO1 CTaHIWHU4 HeripepbIBHOFO MOHHTOp14Hra IIeCTH HO 6buio 6bI OrpaHHlHTb 'ICHIO 3arpa3HwTeireH H 3aHHMaTb- » 3arpH3HHTeJIef, goHOJIHeHHO14 HeCKOJbKH4- CH, HanplHMep, TO)IbKO TOHKOlHCfIepCHbIMH a3pO3OIAHM1 H MH caTeCJIHTHbIMH HOCTaMH H3MepeHHH TOJIbKO PMIO H CBHHUOM. flopTaTnBHbIe npH6OpbI HenpepbIBHoro MOHHTO- CBHHUa, 060)AWTCH, BepOAITHO, B CyMMy lopAHgKa 1,5 MJIH - pHHra ARn H3MepeHHR PM1O npoaKOTCA no iWHe 3000 ,oan. 2,5 MJH ,oan. CIIIA. 12 ABTOMo6,4IAbHbIf H4apK H TeXHOJIOrTH5 aBToMo6H)IeCTpoeHHI4 E CTb OCHOBaHH I ipegnOjiaraTb, T4TO B HaCTyiaolmM geCATHiieTHH B CTpaHaX UeHTpaJIbHOH A314 Hi KaBKa3a npOHI3ORAYT ABa KapqT4HalIbHbIX H3MCHeHCH4: repexog 6OJIbmerpy3HbIx aBTOMo6HJIeH c 6eH3HHOBbIM ABHraTe)ieM Ha AH3eJIbHbIH H OTKa3 OT IierKOBbIX aBTOM06HJIeH, ABi4raTeJIH KOTOpbIX pa6oTalOT Ha HH3KOOKTaHOBOM 6eH31He. 06a H43MeHeHHlA OKa)KYT CyWi4CTBeHHOe BJIHM1HHC Ha He TOJIb- KO Ha KOjiHIeCTBO H B149 nOTpe6JIAeMOrO TOHJIHBa, HO H Ha o6&beMbl BbI6pOCOB aBTOMo6H4IbHbIX BBHra- Te.nefi. Pacimi4peHme iiapKa AH3eAJbHbIX TpaHCrIOpTHbIX CpegCTB 6ygeT 03HaIaTb yBeiHqMeHle KOJIHMeCTBa TOHKO)IHCrlePCHbIX IaCTHU H OK1C4IOB a3oTa (NOX). CoKpa- Ao 1,4 MJTH egHHHL B Ka3axcTaHe. B 60nbmHHCTBe CTpaH HmeHHe napKa aBToMo6Hiefi, o6opyAoBaHubIx 6CH31HOBbIMH OKORO OqHOH 4leTBepTil aBToMo6HJIbHoro rapia COCTaBJIIfOT 4BfaMTrnxMm C H143KO1 CTeneHbIO c>KaTHSI, rIoBJie4eT 3a CO- 60JIbimlerpy3Hbie aBTOMo6HJII4. XOTH MbI He pacnoniaraem no- 6o0 CHIi)KeH4e noTpe6JieHHiL TonHJ4Ba, 'TO HlI4 TeX )Ke 3Ha- qpO6HbIM4 CBeTkeH4HJMl o pacipegenern- aBTOMo6HJIeA no '1eHH41X npo6era TpaHCnOpTHOrO cpegCTBa, B ripHHUnuie, 4 HX CPOKaM cuIyK6bI, O4HaKO, MO)KHO rpep4OJIO)KHTb, 'ITO AODKHO IPHBeCT14 K yMeHbLueHi4O KO)iwieCTBa BbI6pOCOB He cpegHifl B03paCT 4X IIBJSIeTC% AOCTaTOqHO 6o)TbunMm, npH- TOJbKO CO, yrnICBOAOPOAOB iH NOx, XapaKTepHbIX gAnq 6eH3H- 'HeM 3HawHTeRbHa3i go0)15 aBTOMo6HIIbHoro napKa pEHxoAHT- HOBbIX ABHraTe)1eH, HO H iiaPHHKOBbIx ra3OB. CS Ha aBTOMo6]VJIM, BblnIymeHHbIe 20 H 6o0iee nieT Ha3ag. B no- C)iegHHe rOgbI CyMMapHOe KOJIHWeCTBO TpaHCHOPTHbIX XAPAKTEPUCThKU ABTOMOBIJlbHOrO nlAPKA CpegCTB B fiapKax aBToMo6HJiCe yBenIHl4)IOCb He3HaqHTe)nb- KoawHeCTBO TPaHCriOPTHbIX CpeqCTB B o6cnegyeMoM HO, a B HeKOTOpbIx CJPJIax ga)Ke HeCKOJIbKO COKpaTHWOCb, 'TO PeFHOHe KOiJe6)IeTCA OT 250 TbIC. B He6oJIbuil{x rocygapcTBax o6 b3iCHqeTCq o6mHM COCTOHHmeM 3KOHOM14KH B 3TMX CTpa- Ta6nmLla 1. CTaTCumecKle AaHHbie no KOJH4necTBy aBToMo6unefi B cTpaHax LIeHTpanbHOu A3um U KaBKa3a (no COCTOfHIIO Ha 1998 r.) HIpomx.eHHoHCMb 06u4ee KOq-6O 06uiee KOA-6O a6momoM6UAbHblX 3opo2 (a KM) 06u4ee KOA-80 Ae2KoebtX epy306biX CmpaHa C noKpblmueM FpyHmoable Bceeo aamOM06uAeu aemoMo6uwefu aemoMo6wze( ApMeHHHsa 8 560 0 8 580 A3ep6afigwaH 54 188 3 582 57 770 365 782 272 092 93 690 Fpy3Hu 19 354 1 346 20 700 406 733 340 407 66 326 Ka3aXcTaHb 104 200 36 800 141000 1 496 969 1 098 548 398 421 Pecny6ii4Ka Kblprbl3cTaH 16 854 1 646 18 500 Tag>KHKl4CTaH 11 330 2 370 13 700 329 996 120 819 209 177 TypKMeHHCTaH 19 488 4 512 24 000 314 990 252 082 62 908 Y36eKHCTaH 71237 10 363 81 600 1139 849 889 286 250 563 a. K MoMeHTy rIy6JIHKaLu4H 4aHHbie n0 COCTaBy napKOB aBTmO6HJIeH 113 ApMeHHH H PeCny6nmaH Kblprbl3CTaHHe HOCTyr4HIH. b. KaaaXCTaHe 67 630 aBToMo6HIefi OTHeCeHbl K KaTeropiHH <. 13 I1pHMeHeHHe 6onee tIHCTbIX MOTOpHbIX TOII)IHB AJIH o6eCClemeHHR '{HCTOTbl BO3XyXa B CTpaHax CpeCHeCH A3HH H KaBKa3a naX B 90-x rr. O4HrlmanbHbIe CTaTHcTHMqecKHe gaHHbIe no cpegHee oKTaHoBoe qHicno 6eH3HHa, c+aKTHMecKH HMeioIuero- KOJTiHeCTBy aBToMo6HHefl, HaxOgAl1HXCH Ha ye'e, I npHBO- CA Ha pblHKe, OCTaCTCH HH3KHM, 'ITO 06'bhCHneTCqr HeCOBep- ,51TCA B Ta6JHLqe 1. ITueHCTBOM OTeMeCTBeHHbLX He4)TeHepepa6aTbIBalolgHx 3aao- OAHHM H3 Ba)KHeCHmllHx (4aKTOpOB, OT KOTOpbIX 3aBIHCHIT ,lOB H yBeai'eHHeM paCXOjOB npH HcHOJIb3oBaHHH 6eH31Ha CH4)KeHme KoJIH,IeCTBa BbI6pOCOB XLBHraTeCeiC aBToMO6eCHn , c 6onee BbICOK14MH OKTaHOBbIMH4 xapaKTepHCTH4KaMH. B He- HaxoA5IH"HXCH B 'iaCTHOM BJIageHHH, HB3IBIeTCA HaJHi'iHe KOTOpbIX CTpaHaX 3TO CTHMyhIHpyeT He3aKOHHOe BBegeHHe B peMoHTHO-TexHi-IecKoal 6a3bI, OCHaIIeHHOi4 COBepCIIeHHbIM 6eH3HH CBHHLLOBHCTbIX npHca,gOK Ha YPOBHe po3HHxIHOfl JAi4arHOCTHMeCKHM o6opygoBaHneM H yKOMrl)IeKTOBaHHOfI TOprOBJIH, WITO BJie'IeT cepbe3HbIe He6JiarOnpHhITHbie nocnee- KBaH4HImJ4HpoBaHHbIM o6cnyxKHBaIonUHM nepCOHaYIoM. B CTBHH AnI 34OpOBbH noAefl. HaCTrOHmee BpeMH HannmEle TaKOH 6a3bl B CTpaHaX I4eHT- HaH6onee 3O4eKTHBHbIM CpegCTBOM CHH)KeHHH Bbl- pa)IbHofi A3HH H KaBKa3a MBJIHeTCA orpaHH'4eHHbIM. )ItaKe B 6pocoB yrIieBOxOpOwoB, CO H NOx H3 6eH31HHOBbIx ABHraTe- KpyfHbIX ropoxax 6b111O TPYAHO o6ecne'IHTb HaAnmKawee nefl sIBJIOTC3H KaTaJIHTHmieCKle npeo6pa3oBaTenH. OXLHaKO, TexHHieCKoe o6CJI}yKHBaHHe aBTOMo6HJIeH, a B CeCIbCKOII CBHHLeL Heo6paTHMO 3arpAl3HiseT KaTanH3aTop, a Ha 6eH3o3a- MeCTHOCTH OHO npaKTH'IeCKH UOJIHOCTbIO OTCyTCTBoBa)Jo. B npaBOMIHbIX CTaHUHAX 4aHHOrO perioHa B HaCToHWAee BpeMI fCpe>KHHEe rOgbI BO MHOrHX cnyiaAx aBToMo6HiHi HOCTaB)IH- He pa3geJIHIOT 6eH3HH Ha 3THR1HpOBaHHbla H He3THhpOBaH- JHCICb c Ao6pOTHblM Ha6opoM HHCTpyMeHTOB, TaK 'ITO Ka)K- HbIl. TaK ETO BHepeH4HHe KaTaJiHTHtieCKHx ripeo6pa30oaTeneiH bIH BJILaJenei caM BbInOJIHHI o6Cny)KHBaHHe H peMOHT nPHAHTCH OThIO)KHTb %O nOJIHOrO OTKa3a OT HCHIOJb3OBaHEHH4 CBoero aBToMo6HAH. ABTOMO6HJIH, KaK npaBHnO, HMeJIH npo- CBHHUa B 6eH3HHe H Torga aBHraTeiH, o6OpygOBaHHbie KaTa- CTyIO H exlHHOo6pa3HyIo KOHCTpyKUHIO. JIHTH'ieCKHMH npeo6pa3OBaTenTMnm, y)Ke He 6yxyT 3aanpaB- IfIpeo6naqaioman 'aCTb TpaHCHOpTHbMX Cpe4CTB, KOTO- JIHTbCH 3THIHPOBaHHblM 6eH3HHoM. pble B HaCTOH1LJCee BpeMA HaXOAJWTCH B aKcnriyaTaiuHH B CTpa- BBH4y HH1POKoro npHmeHeHHHH 3aKaJeHHbIx cegen cKia- Hax IleHTpanbHoi4 A3HH H KaHKa3a, 6blma H3rOTOBJieHa B iaHOB BO BCex HHr, yganieHHe CBHHUa U3 6eH3HHa He 4onxK- 6blBniieM COBeTCKOM Coma3e B 80-e rr. B OTWIV He OT CHTya- HO HpHBeCTH K HX BblKpalmEHBaHHIo. 14 AefeCTBHTeJIbHO, B IHH, CJIOXKHBHIeHCA B ApyrTx CTpaHax, rge rpy3OBbIe aBTOMO- A3ep6aig>KaHe, rge C 1997 r. HcHO)Tb3yeTCM HCKJHoMI4TeJIbHO 6HiH o6opyxyloTca AH3eJIbHbIMH J BHraTenIHMH, 3AeCb Ha He3THJIHpOBaHHbia 6eH3HH, HeT HHKaKI4X coo6iUeHHIY 0 B03- rpy3OBbIx aBToMo6HnJIx YCTaHaBJIHBaBOTCA CpaBHHTenJbHO HHKHOBeHHH CKOJIbKO-HH6yXb Cepbe3HbIX npO6nIeM, CBH3aH- He6OJIbmHe 6eH3nHoBBbe 4BHraTeJIH. 3To - ABnraTejiH C HbIX C BblKpaIH1HBaHHeM KJianiaHHbIX c~eni. OTKa3 OT HC- HH3KOH CTeHeHbIO cOKaTHHE, pa6oTaionHe Ha HH3KOOKTaHO- HOJIb3OBaHHsA CBHHIa AaeT onpeAelIeHHbie BbirOgbi BOM 6eH3HHe (KaK npaBwIO, C OH/M2, paBHbM 76 nyHKTaM). noTpe6HTenio: yBenEH'eHHe pecypca grBHraTenai H CpOKa lipH paBHOM npo6ere OHH HMeKOT 6onee BbLICOKHH ygelIb- cJIy)K6bI BbiXrOnHOrO KnianaHa, 3HaMIHTenbHOe yBenHIeHHe HblH pacxoa TOnJIHBa, 6onee HH3KHH aHepreTHieCKHf KHrJ H cpOKa cnyxK6bl BbiX)IOHHOH CHCTeMbi H COKpaWeHHCe IHCcIa 6onee BbMCOKHi4 YPOBeHb BbI6pOCOB AHOKCHWa yrnepoqa (nap- onepaLuHw no CMeHe Macna H 3aMeHe CBeeil 3a)KHraHHs4. He- HHKOBoro ra3a) H Jpyr4X 3arpH3HHTeJIeH, MeM gBHraTejiH C O6xoAiHMo HH(tOpMHpOBaTb o6reCTBeHHOCTb o6o Bcex 3THX BbICOKOH CTeneHbIO C)KaTHHq. 3TH aBTOMO6HJIH O6OpyJJOBaHbl npeHMym eCTBax, C TeM 'To6bI pa3BeqTb Hegopa3yMeHHH, 0 o6bl EnbIM Kap6iopaTOpHbIM ABHraTenieM H He HMeCOT KOTOpblX rOBOPHIOCb BO BcTaBKe 1. cperCTB HefiTpaiH3agAHH Bpe)Hb1X BbI6pOCOB, HanpHMep, Ka- TaJHTH'IeCKHX Hpeo6pa3OBaTeiiefi. TpaqmHUHOHHaS TexHoio- floTpe6neHe TonnlNBa B 6yAyu4eM UI TpeOoBaHII rH1A IpOH3BO)CTBa OTeqeCTBeHHbIx aBTOMo6HJIeH aHanorHi- K ero oKTcaHOBbM xapaicrepNcTnKam Ha o6menpvHsrTOh B CeBepHoa4 AMepHKe H XpyriHx CTpaHax ABToMo6HiHE C 6eH3HHOBbIMH ABHraTeJlMH, KOTOpbIe B B nepNog go CepeCaHbi 80-x rr. HacToAngee BpeMH COCTaBAIIOT 3HaHHTeC)bHYHIO iaCTb napKa 6onbmLuerpy3HbIx TpaHCHOpTHbHX CpeACTB, B OCHOBHOM 6brnH HeKoTopbMe npo6neMbl, CBRSUHHbie paCC'nITaHbI Ha pa6oTy c 6eH3HHoM 76 OH/M. 9THq BnraTe- C Ncnonb3oBaHIeM 3THnJ1pOBaHHoro 6eH3iHa nTH paHo MIH riO3JHO 6y4yT 3aMeHeHbI JW3eJIbHbIMH ABHraTe- B nocnegHile rogbl B pe3ynbTaTe noABHseHHA COBpeMeH- JiHMH. CornacHo HH±OpMaTjHH, nonyiyeeHHOHi B TpaHCHOpT- HbIX aBToMo6HJief CnpOC Ha 6eH3HH c 6onee BblCOKHM OKTa- HbIX MHHHCTepCTBax xaHHoro perHoHa, nOTpe6neHHe HOBbIM IHCAOM B gaHHOM perHoHe Bo3pacTaeT. OAHaKO 91H3enbHorO ToIJIBa riapKOM rpy3OBbIX aBToMo6H4IeH B03- OH/M HBJIHeTc1 MepOi CTOHKOCTH 6eH3HHa K caMOBOcHLiaMeHeHHIO (neTOHagHH), KorgAa ABHraTenJb pa6OTaeT B pe)KHMax, KOppeCJHpPYOWHX C xapaKTepHCTHKaMH, KxTopbie jBHraTe7Ib HMeeT HpH flBH)KeHHH aBTOMo6HJH rio aBTOcTpaxe. 14 ABTOMO6H1b11I riapKi 1 H TexHoInOrHIl aBToMo66I]eCrpoeHl4| BcTaBKa 3. PacLieT 3aKOHoMepHocTeN noTpe6n1eHNU TonnMBa AiAn OgeHKH rIoTpe6HoCTeli B OKTaHOBbIX xapaKTepCTHKaX ToTIjIBa ARA HbIHeulHero riapKa aBToMo6HJeH H rIOTpe6- JieHHI3 ToIUIHBa B 6ygyigeM 6bmna rIOCTpoeHa KOMnblOTepHaA Mo,eJIb, B KOTOpyiO 6bI)1 BBeAeHbl: THflbI H Mo,genH aBTOMO- 6HieH; OKTaHOBbIe xapaKTepHCTHKH TonIIHBa, OFOBOpeHHble 3aBOAOM-H3rOTOBHTeneM; ygelfbHbii npo6er aBToMo6H4)A (T.e. npo6er B KIOnMCeTpaX Ha J4HTP TOHiHnBa); H opHeHTHpOBOIHbIe 3HaneHH4I ro)JOBoro npo6era TpaHCrOPTHOrO CpeJACT- Ba B KHAOMeTpax (rITCK). Heo6xolHMaa HH4HOpMaUHI4 6bUia iioyMeHa KaK riocpegCTBOM )T1PHbIX KOHTaKTOB, TaK H H3 OT- KpbITof )I1TepaTypbi. floTpe6HocTIH B TOIITHBe ini ino6oro KOHKpeTHoro roAa paCC'IHTaHbl HICXOAA 13 OHeHOK roqoBoro (ITCK) no KJiaccaM aBTOMo6HJieH: 40 TbIC. KM XVISi rpy30BHKOB, 50 TbIC. KM qJIA aBTo6ycoB, 15 TbIC. KM AnI )ierKOBbIX H 10 TbIC. KM ,JA5I cneLxHaJLbHbix aBToMo6HiieH. BenHHHbi HITCK 6paIHcb OAHHaKOBbIMH 97131 BCeX BOCbMU CTpaH. PacMeTbl BbIHOJIHA)IH4Cb nO KaBKAOMY THfy TpaHCIIOpTHOrO cpe,;cTBa, a pe3y)IbTaTbi 6buiHi riollyieHbI ARA TpeX KaTero- pHJ4 TorHIHBa: HH3KOOKTaHOBbIH 6eH3MH (O1/M 76 ITYHKTOB H O11/14 80 nlyHKTOB); BbICOKOOKTaHOBbIH 6eH3HH (O-/II 91 H 6o0ee nyHKTOB); 1H gH3eJIbHoe TOUnHBo. B riporHo3HbIX RaHHbIX Ha 2005 H 2010 rr. B MoAeniil HPHHnITO gonyWeHHe o ewKe- rOjHOM 5%-HoM CHH)KeHHH roTpe6)ieHHSA HH3KOOKTaHOBoro 6eH3HHa 60ojberpy3HblMH H jiCrKOBbiMH aBToMo6HnJIAMH, ABHraTeJIH KOTOpbIX pa6OTalOT Ha HH3KOOKTaHOBOM 6eH3HHe. rlpH rpOBegeHHm aHaJIH3a IyBCTBHTeJIbHOCTH HCrIOjIb3OBa- nHlcb 7,5%-HbIe e>KerOgHbIe TeMribI CHH)KeHH5A noTpe6)ieHHII HH3KOOKTaHOBOro 6eH3HHa, BMeCTO 5%-Hbix. Ha noTpe6jIeHHe AH3eJIbHoro TOnJIHBa H BbICOKOOKTaHOBoro 6eH3MHa 6bmna BBe;ieHa nonpaBKa 3a cieT COOTHeCeHHA pOCTa CyMMapHOrO fITCK C ripOrHO3HpyeMbiM pOCTOM BBfI B Ka)KAOH CTpaHe. Temrnbl pOCTa cyMMapioro fTCK 6buiiH ipHH5ITbi npriMO npo- riopivHoHa)IbHbIMH TeMiTaM pocTa BBrl B KOHTpOJIbHOM cnyiae. B aHaniH3e '4yBCTBHTeJIbHoCTH HcroJIb3OBanc5I TaK)Ke MO- ;HIHX1HPOBaHHbIH KO3044HLHeHT HPOrIOPL9HOHa)JbHOCTH (1,25). paCTaeT, 'TO o6 bACHAeTcA ero 6o0iee HH3KOi CTOHMOCTbIO H CHIbHoe BJH4HHHe Ha HOMeHKIiaTypy OKTaHOBbIX 'HceJI BCe- 6o0ee npOAO))KHTenibHbIM pecypcom AH3eJIbHbIx UBH4raTe- ro aBTOMo6H)IbHoro iiapKa. B HacTOAHeM HcCJiegOBaHHH nTei. TeMnbI pocTa noTpe6ieHHHl AH3enbHorO TOrIJIHBa 6oJIb- UPH4BOgATCA OgeHKH HOTpe6JieHHH ToruIHBa B 6yqymeM (CM. lIuerpy3HbIMH TpaHCrIOPTHbIMH CpegCTBaMH OKa3blBaIOT BCTaBKy 3). PUCYHOK 1. flporHo3upyeMblU COBOKyllHbiU pOCT BBI1, noTpe6JieHNa 6eH3mHa U noTpe6neHrS AH3enlbHOrO TolnUIBa B nepuo, c 1998 no 2005 rr. 120- 100 - 80- .-R 60-,F B o 40- 20- QM* ,1,3TOnfl6 Bo -20 z; I I:; I I I I I CO F~~~- I- - CD >1 U C)~~~ 0 0 0 HeHHH~ ~~~ gnH 3TH COpa He lleCaH bB3OKbM OL LIO ciiCO) L CO Q~~~~~~~~~~~~- HpumewiHue: B rnoia3aTeiqx poCTa BBrl xvaR A3ep6af4g)KaHa HHlKaK He OTpa)KaeTCA CBoeBpemeHHoe 3aBepmueffle CTPOHTeJIbCTBa 3KCHIOPTHbI( He4~TeHpoBOxAOB. 1IOCKonIbKy MbI He pacnouiara)rn aaHHbLMHo0 napKax aBTOmo6Himef4 )'eH HPcIy6LH IIprIcTH H ABO4T BbIHC JieHHA P)TH 3THX CTpaH He HpeACTaB)TA1JOCb B03MOACHbIM. HcmoiHuKu unoopMat4uu: Ho BBH - BCeMHpHbTI 6aHK; Ho rOTpe6iIeHHlo 6eH3HHa H RI3e)IbHOrO TOHJiHBa - MHHHCTepCTBO OxpaHbl OKpy- >KaiOljeH CpelbI KaHaxbi. 15s FlpHMeHeHHe 6onee HHCTbIX MOTOpHblX TOlJIHB ABji o6eciiegeHHlA '{HCTOTbI BO3RyXa B CTpaHaX CpeRHeHi A3HH H KaBKa3a PmCyHOK 2. flporno3MpyeMbMi COBOKylnHblI pOCT BBn, noTpe6neH1si 6eH3HHa H noTpe6neHmg Am3elJbHOrO ronnm8a BanepoR c 1 998 no 2010 rr. 180 - 160 - 140 - 120 -_ _ _ _ 100 - F- DBBnl 80 E U eH3eH 60 - I *AM3TOr1imBo 20 - . - 5 liii -20 3; co CZ coI I I 11 0. X E) ° s S '0 5~~~o .0 1 a) a a)c l L )C 0-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I HpuMenaHue: B noKa3aTensLx pocTa BBHI vni A3ep6afkx)KaHa HHKaK He OTpa)KaeTCB CBOeBpeMeHHOC 3aBepmeHme CTpOHTeCJbCTBa 3KCnopiTHbx HeJTenpOBOxAOB. nOCKOnbKy Mbl He pacioiiaraniH AaHHbIMH o napKax aBToMo6HJCH ApMeHHH H PecHy6MHKH KbIprbl3CTaH, rpOBO,HTb BbI 4HC- nieHHH giinf 3THX CTpaH He rIpe,CTaBsJfIOCb B03MO)KHblM. HCMOIHUKU uHmiopMaquu: Ho BBr - BceMHpHbliH 6aHK; no noTpe6nenrno 6eH3HHa H Am3enfbHOrO TOnfJIBa - MHHHCTepCTBO OXpaHbl OKpy- waioulek cpegbi KaHaAbi. PHCyHOK3. AOJISI BbICoKoOKTaHoBoro 6eH3HHa B CYMMapHoM noTpe6neHI TonnHBa B 1998, 2005 U 2010 rr. 70 60 - E ctDaKTWieCKoe nOTpe6JleHme B 1998 50 l tloTpe6HoCTw B 1998 0;[ 40 -=N n E U flporHO3 Ha 2005 30 2 jnporHo3 Ha 2010 U; ~~~~~~~I I I I I I a H H H H H C . Ca y. Ca z > < F 1 D 1C _- 0 r --~~a)- n C',- - C') oo C ( cl)~~~~~~~~~~~~I Hpue'ii-ie: X~H-1CBCHbIM CCX~HHBH KTO~IMHMbIpaconran noAae6aH~an H ypKeHHTBy, b1){ )~HHIC npHC.)H Te'CHcT e4Tneep6TbBIoHx BBXOHa~epcinaaHop6JeHB6H3Han OTHObM inia~ )BHbX oApeHCH 61 nop3HBHn oCaoBI IHJa. Iia p3H en6nK bIrIcTHHTB CZ Caa aHIe m C-JCHb0B BCO~H4K TH'ec(oerITpeJIHH Bc98r» BIHTRoeo'IbM 16~~~~~~~LC ABTOMo6HnbHblf napK u TexHoJIorFH aEToMo6HjIecTpoeHHa Ha pEfc. 1 Ei 2 gae&Ci rpac4)MecKoe 1ipeACTaBICeHHe rpynnamn MaiHHH, TO npHBeCJHHbIe BbImieCpe3yJbTaTbI eCiI TeMnIOB COBOKynHoro pOCTa (B %) Ba)IoBoro BHYTpeHHero 6O0bLuCe YCHUIT iiaJeHHe cnpoca Ha 6eH3SHH B 6ygyneM gAn npogyKTa (BBH), niOTpe6CieHHnu 6eH3n Ha H HoTpe6iCeHEA 3TOA KaTerop4HH aBToMo6HJeIC. A143eJbHorO TOHJHBa AOpO)KHbIMH TpaHCHOpTHbIMH CpeCCT- Pa3Hi4ua Me)K4y baKTHMeCKHM OKTaHOBbIM mICiOM no- BaMH B riepHoA C 1998 no 2005 r. H C 1998 no 2010 r., C HC- Tpe6iMCMoro 6eH3HiHa H ero 3HaICHHeM,orOBopeHHbIM B cCe- IOJTb3OBaHBHeM paCleTOB no KOHTpO)IbHOMY c)yiaio. B 60nb- I4H4ThKaUj4X 3aBOAa-HS3rOTOB4TeJAI, CHJTbHO KOCe6ieTCA B pa3- HJHHCTBe o6cCeJJOBaHHbIx CTpaH B pe3ylhbTaTe riepeBoga AHMHbIX CTpaHaX gaHHoro perHoHa. Ha 6a3e orpaHH-reHHOfi aBToMo6HJIbHoro napKa C 6eH3aHHa na lH3eCIbHoe TOTrIHBO HIH4opMaauHH, HMeioHeCHCH B A3ep6aVpKaHe H rpy3si1H, He HC- nOTpe6JIeHHe 6eH3xHHa fnpaKTHmeCKE He MeHCeTCsI, a B Tag- KnKOCeHO, 'ITO B 3THX CTpaHaX 6Onbruioe 'HCJIO aBTOMo6HJeIC, >KHIKHwCTaHe E1 Y36eKHICTaHe OTMeMBeTCH gaaKe ero coKpawe- paCClHTaHHbIX Ha HH3KOOKTaHOBbiH 6eH3a4H, pa6oTaIoT Ha Bbl- HHe. HOTpe6AeHHe AH3eCJbHorO TO1TIJIHBa B HiepHoH C 1998 no COKOOKTaHOBoM 6eH34He. B HCHOJIb3OBaHHH4 BbICOKOOKTaHo- 2010 r. paCTeT OwCHb 6blCTpO (B cnyxae TaJpKl4KHCTaHa H Y3- Boro 6eH3HHa B BH1raeTCeC C HH43KOR CTeCieHbMO c)KaTHA HeT 6eKHCTaHa) - B 4 pa3a 6bIcTpee, 'eM BBHI. B HCpegCTOhIHe Hwiero njoxoro, ogHaKo, H BOA1HTeJI1O OT 3TOrO HeT HHKaKOHl rOgbi 3TO AOJDKHO Hnp1BeCTH K CyWeCTBeHHOMY yBeCjiHICeHHIO BbIrOAbI, rlOCKOAbKy BbICOKOOKTaHOBbUf4 6eH3HH 06XOgnTCA KoJIHIqeCTBa BbI6pOCOB TOHKOAHCnepCHbiX a3pO3oieC H NOx. jopoxKe. boabmiiaq gonJa HOTpe6JInCMorO BbICOKOOKTaHOBOrO Ha pHC. 3 HpHBOAlHTCH OpEHeHTHpOBOMHHaB gona (B %) BbICO- 6eH31Ha, BO3MO)KHO,. IBJiHeTCH 3aBbImeHHOHl, HOCKOJ1bKy gaH- KOOKTaHOBoro 6eH3nHa B CyMMapHoM nOTpe6JIeHHH TOriIi- Hbie no A3ep6aElgKaHy 6a3avpyloTCA HCKJHOMfTeCIbHO Ha npo- Ba B 1998 r., rioACqlHTaHHani HCXOAA H3 COCTaBa aBTOMo6I4JIb- H3BOgHTeCJbHOCTH HeCTernepepa6aTbIBaioiiUHx 3aBOgOB, XOTAI HbIX napKOB H peKOMeHgaglHHE aBToMo6HJeCCTpOITeCJeC no BIpEH 3TOM H3BeCTHO, qTO B npllrpaHWfqHbie 3OHbi A3ep6afgxca- OKTaHOBbIM xapaKTepE CT HOKam HOTpe6jiiHMoro HMH4 TOnIIH- Ha BB0314TCA KOHTpa6aHAHbnIl 6eH314H. A gons KOHTpa6aH;HO- Ba, a TaK)Ke flpOrHC3bI Ha 2005 H 2010 rr., OCHOBaHHbie Ha ro 6eH3BiHa B rpy3HH B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT ME1pOBbIX 4eH Ha He- 3THX peKOMeHgaL4EHx. ro, MO)KCT, no HeKOTOpbiM oieHKaM, AOCTH4raTb 50%. Y HaC He 6bu1O B03MOAKHOCTH nOJIy'lHTb TOIHyIo HH- B OCTaJIbHbIx CTpaHax o6CneAOBaHHoro perHCOHa BblIB- 4OpMagino o HbIHeIUHCM COCTaBe aBTOMo6HIAbHbIx rapKOB. iieH CyLeCTBeHHbIfl < OKTaHOBbIX xapaKTepHCTHK: Ha "M&Te BCe ewe HaxoQATCH TpaHCHOpTHbie CpegCTBa, KOTO- nOTpe6ieHi4e BbICOKOOKTaHOBOrO 6eH3HHa 3AeCb HHAKe (a B PbIe 6bIHE gaBHO CInICaHbl. B HeKOTOpbIX CTpaHax gona aBTO- HeKOTOpbIX c7iyaix - 3HalH4TeCTbHO HHI>Ke) 3HaIeHCHH$, pac- Mo6HeCf, HaxogHM4HXCH Ha yqeT, HO dJaKTHNeCKH He 3KcLTiy- CMHTaHHbIX HCXOHR H3 COCTaBa aBTOMo6HJTbHbix rIapKOB H aTHpyeMbIx, oI4eHHBaeTCSI HOMTH B 40%. 143BeCTHO, 'ITO peKOMeHMaiH4hE 3aBOCOB-H3FrOTOBHTeCje. B 6ygynJeM yno- HMeeT MeCTO HiocieCipoga)KHaH nepeAeBca 6eH3avHoBbIx Mh1HYTa5 BbIrCe pa3H4ua 6ygeT yBeCiEH'-BaTbCSI, Ho Mepe TO- gBHraTeCeiC Ha 6oniee HH3KYIO CTeCeHb c)KaTHH, HO HHKaKHX ro KaK aBTOMo6Hii4 C gBH4raTeCTIMH, pa6OTaiowEHMH Ha BB3- CTaTHCTH'-eCKBX 1aHHbIX 0 KOJIHNeCTBe HOABepruni'JXCH Cepe- KOOKTaHOBOM 6eH3HHe, 6ygyT 3aMeHHTbCH B CnEHCblBaTbCH, a )IeCiKe gBHraTeCJeC He HMeeTCA. He BeCgTCA c6op CHCTeMaTB- OTKa3 OT HCHOII)b3BaHHA CBHBiLa BOTpe6yeT IIOBbll{CeHB4Hq 'IeCKHX AaHHbIX HH o rOgOBOM npo6ere TpaHCHOpTHOrO cpeg- cpeCHero OKTaHOBOFO ro cJIa. 3To CKaKeTCTH Ha CTpaTerCHH B CTBa B KHJOMCeTpaX (ITCK), HH o 4raKTHwieCKOM ygeChbHOM OTHoIeHIC1H BbI6pOCOB CB14HI4a, BOCKOJIbKy, HeCMOTp31 Ha TO, npo6ere (T.e. npo6ere aBToMo6HJIR Ha 1 JIHTp TorlHiBa). OT- HITO noTpe6JIeHHe 6CH3HHa, B03MO)KHO, H1 He Bo3paCTeT, KOJI1- CYTCTBBCe BCeCB 3T01 ElHH)opMaUHH41 B HMeIOmeMCSI MaCCHBe 'IeCTBO CBHHUa, KOTOpOC Mo)KeT 6blTb HcrIOAb3OBaHO gAJIJ gaHHbLX BHOCHT B pacieTbi 6onbm-ybo norpCllIHOCTb. noriyiCeH Tpe6yCMbIx OKTaHOBbIX xapaKTepHCTHK, 6ygeT Hlo CpaBHeHIK0 C gpyrHml KaTerOpHHMH TpaHCHOpT- 3HaMHTCeIbHO BblIHe. HeKOTOpbIe CTpaHbl gaHHoro perCOHa HbIX CpegCTB, 6onbm-uerpy3Hbie aBToMo6HJu noTpe6JIIHOT (oco6eHHo Te, B KOTOpbIX HMCeeTC gOCTaTOqHO KpyrIHaH 3HaillTeCIbHyIO 'qaCTb 6eH3HHa, 1TO 06'bIACHHeTCH IIX HH3KOi HeCTeCiepepa6aTbIBaioJaH OTpaCJTb) CT031T iepeC cepbea- TOnHJBHOH 3KOHOMB'-THOCTbIO H 6onbUInMH4 BeCiHMHHaMH HOTI ripo6eCMof: rIOTpe6HOCTb B riOBblIiieHIC OKTaHOBbIX rogoBoro IITCK. rIepeBOg 3THx aBToMo6JICeH C 6eH3HHa Ha mIHcen MOTOpHbIX 6eH3HHOB CTaHeT gOHOIIHHTCJIbHbIM 6pe- HC3e)IbHOe TOII)IHBO 6ygeT 03Ha'aTb, 'ITO B o6C3pHMOM 6ygy- MeHeM glli HeC4Tenepepa6aTbIBaiolmHx 3aBCgOB, KOTOpbIe LeM He chIeCyeT O)KAHaTb CKOJIbKO-HH6yAb 3HaSMTeJIbHoro y)KC H TaK He o6ecCnCeHBaIoT noiy-eICHHH Heo6XogmMbiX OKTa- POCTa nOTpe6JIeHHHi 6eH3SHa B STOM perHOHe. BO BCeX cJy-Ia- HOBbIX xapaKTepHCTHK. AX (BKrnKolan M TOT, KOTOpbIfi 6bmn HpOCIlHTaH B aHan)H3e qyB- CTBHTeJIbHOCTH) pOCT HOTpe6JIeHBH 6eH3HHa OKa3bIBaeTCH MOHITOPIHr BbI5POCAABTOMObUJlbHbIX HH)Ke POCTa BBIHI. 3geCb, OgHaKo, HMeeTCA ogHa orOBOpKa: ec- gBHrATEnEA nn 'i4cCio 6OnbmiCerpy3Hblx aBTOMo6HJeiC C 6eH3SHOBbIMH HIOCTynaToiIHe CO Bcero mipa gaHHbIe CBHgeTeCIbCTBY- ABHraTeChlMH B MoenCI4 3aBbIIueHO no CpaBHeHH1O C TpyrHmH IOT 0 TOM, -TO, KaK IlpaBH4)TO, TeXHOJiOrTH aBTOMO6BiJeCTpO- 17 fIpHMeHeHne 6oiee 'IHCTbIX MOTOpHbIX TOHllHB A7a o6ecneMeHuM MHCTOThI B03AyXa B CTpaHaX CpeCHeH A3HH H KaBKa3a eHHA 1H TeXHHieCKOe COCTO51HHe TpaHCIOpTHbLX CpegCTB OKa- HpaBHW1ax, BOBCe He o6H3aTeCIbHO oKa3bIBaeTCq ge4HCTBeH- 3blBa1OT ropa3go 601buCCee B1UlHHHe Ha WHTeHCHBHOCTb Bbl- HOW.3 flOCxKO1bKy Raa peanHa43aULH TaKOW npOrpaMMbl, KaK 6pocoB, 'eM Ka'eCTBO TOfl11HBa (3TO He OTHOCHTCI K CBWHIUY npanWno, HeT HW norixoxqwero o6OpyAOBaHH5,q HH o6y"eH- H cepe, Konrm1eCTBO KOTOpb1X B BbIX1OnHbIX ra3ax ABHraTeCelH HOrO nepCOHaTia, B JeLiCTBHTeCIbHOCTH H pOBO4ATCA HaMHOPO Hpl5MO HpOnIOP¾HOHan1bHO HX coCep)KaHHIO B TOHIHBCe). 3To MeHbIHCe ipOBCepOK, HeM ecCiW 6bl 3TH npaBmna CTporo co6n1o- oco6eHHo KacaeTC51 TaKHX BbI6pOCOB, KaK a3po3oAHl, yrneBo- xarni4Cb. )Io pacnaxla COBeTcKoro Co0o3a rocygapCTBeHHbifl gopo0bi, CO H NO.. B 3TOM CMbic1ie peluaioMyio pO1Ib B CH11- KOMWTCT CTaH4apTOB (rOCCTaHgapT) OKa3blBaJi rioCgep)KKY B )KeHHH YPOBHR BbI6pOCOB aBTOMo6HW1bHbIx RBWraTeC1ef Br- POBCeCeHHH eCKerOAHbIX rIOBepOK annapaTypbi AAA H3Mepe- paeT nx HaJne)Kailee TeXHH1IeCKoe cogep>KaH4e. O4HHM 143 HBHJ BbI6pOCOB H B o6yeHCHH rIepCOHa11a. C TeX nop CBR311 C cnoco6oB o6ecneieHinix perynJIpHoro TeXHICCeCKoro o6cny- rOCCTaHAapTOM nOWITH4 HO1HOCTbIO npepBanmCb, a HOBble Be- )KHBaHHA aRTOMo66HeAC BRi1eTC1TC51 pOReCe4HHe HepHog4Hec- 4OMCTBa C034aHbl He 6bUJH. KHX fpOBepOK Bbix)iona ABHraTeCefC, C TeM 1TO6bI HaxogA- OTCyTCTBHe nogpo6HOfI OTMeTHOCTH no BbiriO)IHeHI4IO iiLHeCC B 3KCHJAyaTalHH4 aBTOMo6H1uH COOTBeTCTBOBaJIH nporpamM TexOCMOTpa/Texo6CJIyAHBaHH5 JB11AeTC5 BeCKHM HOpMaM. npIE3HaKOM TOrO, ITO 3TH IIpOrpaMMbl «He 4OTSIrHBaIOT»> 4O 3aMepbl cogep)KaHBH CO H yrjeCBOJOPOqOB B BbIX11Or- HOpMaTWBOB. YM&T 'iHc1ia aBToMo6W1Cerl, HpOXOR4BIllX H HbIX ra3ax 6eH3wHOBblX 4BHraTeC1eC H AbIMHOCTW BbIXaOna Bbigep>KaB]LHX HCHbITaHHH (ecrn4 TaKOBOH BOo6We BReTC5C), E4H3eCbHbIX 4BHEraTeCICW 5BJ13HOTC31 B HOBbIX He3aBWCHMbIX HMeeTCH, nO-BWHHMOMy, TOJIbKO 415 o6LIACfl 'InHcJCHHOCTH rocygapcTBax 'iaCTbIO o6513aTenbHblx HCepHO4WICeCKHX TeX- rIapKOB aBTOMo6H41eCf, 6e3 pa36H4BKHi no roaaM BbflIYCKa 1EiH HHiCeCKHX OCMOTpOB AOpO)KHbIX TpaHCnOPTHbIX cpegCTB. TWHiaM. BegeHHie cpaBHBITeJIbHO HeCO)KHOH4 CTaTWICTiKWI Ho [lpHMCeHwFTeCbHO K 6eH3WHOBbIM aBWiraTeC1SM HOpMbI COOTHoiCeHW1M BbiCep>KaBJE4X 14He BbiCep)KaBB1EHWX HCHbITa- BbI6pOCOB CO (3% Ha XOJIOCTOM xogy) fIO3BO)IKOT cpa3y HHIM aBTOMo6HICeWf pa3HbIX Mo4eCICH H rOgOB BbIriyCKa 6brno BbIABHITb o6iyIo HeCTpaBBHbHYIO perymIpOBKY COCTaBa TOn- 6bl iepBbIM imaroM Ha HyTH K OUCMHKe aKTya)1bHOCTH npo- JIHBOBO3TYIHIHO41 CMeCCi. HlpiMCeHeHCe 3T4X HOpM MoAKeT CO- rpamM TCxOCMOTpa/Texo6CJIy)iKBaHI5q A41 CeneJC o6ecCie- Ae4CCTBOBaTb CHMCKeHHIO o60beMa TOKCH1'HbIX Bbi6pOCOB, ec- CeHH51 Ka'-eCTBa BO3gyxa. 14H(HopMaUHIKo, noiyCeHHyIO no 1n1 3TO TaKoro poga 3aMeHO K 6eH3BHOBbIM RBH4raTeCi1M pe3yhIbTaTaM peryCIAPHbIX HcnbITaHE4fI, MO)KHO 6bu1o 6bI nC- HOpMbl BbI6pOCOB CO (3% Ha XOIOCTOM xoqy) flO3BOJIIHOT lOJTb3OBaTb 41IA Bbl35B1ieHH41 aBTOMo66H1eC - CWInbHbIX 3a- cpa3y BbIAlHWTb o6ryio HeCipaBHIbHYEO peryJInpOBKy COCTa- rp3l3HH4TeChIC BO BpeM5 4OpO)KHbbIX rpOBepOK, C TeM 'lTo6bI Ba Ton1I4BOBO3RyAIIHO4 CMmCcW. HpWIMeHeCHCe 3TWX HOpM MO- OrpaHRI1eHHOe IgHcTo ripOBepOK CTaJIo 6o0nee 394eKTH4B- )KeT COAe4CCTBOBaTb CHM)KeHHI0 o6'beMa TOKCW14HbIX BbI6pO- HbIM. COB, ecCiH 3TO TaKoro poAa 3aMeCIO BeCeIC. HeCMOTp51 Ha TO, CiCegCTBeHM inO1yICeHH43 HeyAOB11eTBOp14TeCbHOf4 OueH- 'TO ripeCeCbHbie 3HawCHEIH BbIXJIOHOB yr1eCBO4OpOOR HeCfpo- KIH B xoCe rIpOBepK14 BbI6pOCOB npn rCepHoHiOMCcKoM 1nI HOPLIHOHaMJbHO BbICOKII, H4MeHHo annapaTypa 4)15 WiMCepe- AOpO)KHOM KOHTpO1e 31BRI3110TCA1 CeHe)KHbie lHTpa4)bi, KOTO- HHI4 KOHUeHTpaEI4H1 CO o6bIHO BMCeTCA B 6onbmCeM KO14H- pbie B3aHMaIOTCH Ha MeCTe, 6e3 HPWIHA1THA KaKWX 6bl TO H11 6bi- 'eCTBe, B CBR3E4 C 'eM 3HRaeH'ICH KOHLIeHTpaUHH4 CO n1o Mep HO YCTpaHeHHIO HeCWcnpaBHOCTeCH. HeCMOTp5 Ha TO, cbaKTHCqeCKn onpeHeCChlOT Cpege)TbHoe KO11W'1eCTBO Bbi6pO- 'ITO 3TH mlTpa4~bi o6bPIHO 4OCTaTOMHO BeIKIHKH, OH4 MOrYT COB. HIpHMeHlTeJIbHO K HC3eJIbHbIM ABWIraTeCiM HIpHMeHAeT- 6blTb HRlKe CTOHMOCTHI TexHH'-eCKoro o6C11y>KHBaHH5i aBTO- CH HI3MepeHWie 4bIMHOCTW BbIxJiona MpHi pe3KOM pa3rOHe. Mo6Win5 HEH gpyroro, HeO(IHuWa11bHOrO, UlTpacba. Bo rnaBy 3TOT IKe MCTO4 6bli OCHOBHbIM MeTO4OM KOHTpOJI51 BpeCHbLX yrna 'iaCTO CTaBBTCH ynriaTa mTpa(4a, a He Mepbi HO yCTpaHe- BbI6pOCOB B CeBepHot4 AMepHKe. TaKHM o6pa3oM, MO)KHO HHIO Hero1agoK, KOTOpbIe MoranI 6bi CHEI3HITb HOBbiiueHHYIO KOHCTaTHpOBaTb, 'ITO B HaCTOAmee BpCM51, B np1MHuIHne, Cy- HIHTeHCW4BHOCTb BbI6pOCOB. iiWeCTBYCT y4OB11eTBOpHITeCbHbIfI peC)KWM TeXOCMOTpa/Texo6- C11KICWBaHRHW51 I 411 4W3CebHbix aBTOMo6H1e1C p4H YC1OBRHW ABTOMOBIJUI CABIrATEnSIMH, PABOTAIOLLIMI o6ecCeMeHHH ero peaCRH3agI4H H Co6nKOpeH4WH. HA AnbTEPHATIBHbIX BHAAX TOIiJlIBA XOT51 Cy1eCTBYIOT HpaBH1a, Tpe6y1OT4He ripOBCeeHH4CW ]onI aBTOMo6HiCei, OCHaWCeHHbX gBHraTeCi3MH, pa6o- 3aMepOB He pe)Ke OAHOFO pa3a B KBapTa1i, rpOBeCCHHbie Ha- TaiO1HMIW Ha anibTePHaTHBHbIX BHAaX TOHIJHBa, BeCbMa Ma- 6riiogClHHA rIOKa3alIH, HTO Ta Ham 14 HaB 3j4CeKTHBHa5 npo- na, rIp WMeM, KaK ripaBHO0, 3TH BHEraTeCiH ripeACTaB1IAIOT CO- rpamma TexoCMOTpaITexo6C1IyACHBaHW41, OCHOBaHHaA Ha 9TIIX 6of0 MO4+HIKKaUHIO HaXO4HM4HXC5 B 3KCniyaTaRuHm4 HrpOBepKM C HMHTepBaROM B TpH MmCec51a HeBbIHO11WHHMbI, He rOBOpa yMCe 0 TOM, 'ITO 11,1B hierKOBbx aBTOMO6HAeCH OHRB H HyyKHbl. 18 ABTOMo6H/lbHbifi HapK H TeXHOJOrH$1 aBToMo6Hi4eCTpoeHHSl 6eH3HHOBbIX XBi4raTeCefi. ,llo pacnaga CoBeTcKoro Co0o3a, He ToHrI4BHbIe 6aKI4 H KOMHiieKTbI D;nH riepeOCHaLHeHHH TOn- cymIeCTBOBano OTAeCJbHOrO rIPOH3BOACTBa aBToMo6ICHef4 C )IHBHbIX C14CTeM no pa3OMKHyTOf4 cXeMe, 14MHOPTHIpyeMbIe 143 AXBHraTeCiJIMi4, pa6OTaloiwiHMn4 Ha anibTepHaTHBHOM TOrLIHBe POCCUI4). Pea113aarln KpyrIHoMaCmTa6HOtY KOHBepCI4OHHOf4 3a HCKjiO'-eHI4eM cieuiHaIH43H4POBaHHbMX MaJIOMO4HbIx rpy- riporpaMMbI HOTpe6yeT BJio)KeHI4H cpeACTB B y36eKCKyIO 3OBHKOB AAA rOPOACKH1X Hy)KA. CpegH1 CTpaH pern4oHa I4eHT- rpOMblIuJIeHHOCTb Ans1 Hajia)K14BaHHII HPOI13BOACTBa o6ner- pa)IbHoa4 A314HH KaBKa3a oco6yio 3aHlHTepeCOBaHHOCTb B HC- qIHHLIX TOHIJ4BHbIx 6aKoB 143 KOMlO3H4THbIX MaTepIaJIOB H1 nOJIb3OBaHHH14 c)KaToro npH4pOOHOrO ra3a B KaMeCTBe KOMiIJeKTOB AII riepeOCHaiiWeHIIH C 3JieKTpOHHbIM ynpaB- MOTOpHOrO TOHUIHBa HpOIBJiHeT Y36eKH4CTaH, o6nawaiowruiE IieHleM, cnoco6HbIX pa6oTaTb C 3JJeKTPOHHbIMH CHCTeMaMiH 3HaWIHTeCbHbIMH4 3aHaCaMHa flI1POJHoro ra3a. Y36eKxCTaH per"HPOBaHI4A COCTaBa ropioMeia cMecH no 3aMKHyTOEi cxe- niiaHnpyeT paCIH14pHTb HCIOJIb3OBaHeC C)KaTOrO npHpog- Me. HpaB4TeCJbCTBeHHbIMH4 opraHami4 ogo6peHo CO3ThaHHe Horo ra3a B aBTOMo6HIIbHOM CeKTOpe (B TOM qi4cJie - 14 B rIPO13BOACTBeHHbIX MOIIHOCTeC 4jiA 143rOTOBieHIHA pegyK- IierKOBbIx aBTOMo6147lAX), a TaK)Ke HaiaTb 1CIHOJhb3OBaHi4e TOpOB gaB)ieHHA H CMeCHTeC)eIC, TorJIlBHbix 6aKoB n3 KOMnO- C)IKKe CBOH4X HpOeKTHbIX BO3MO)KHOCTef4, PEKOMEHAA4LIH no MOHLTOPIHrY AAH o6cnxy1K4BaH41H yBeC4flHBBaiomerocH napia TpaHCropT- 14 COKPAL4EHIIO BbIBPOCOB HbIX CpegCTB, pa6OTalolU4nx Ha c)KaTOM pII14pOAHOM ra3e, 3a- ABTOMOELIJlbHbIX ABHrATEJIEA nUiaHHpOBaHbI 11 p?Ke HaXOJITC5I B CTagW41 CTPOHTeJIbCTBa MoaepHuWatus o6opyaoeaHuAu He COBceM 3CHO, KaKH1M eiue 32 CTaHIH1H. o6pa3oM HanIqI4He OnOHOAHHTeChbHoro o6OpyMOBaHI4H WHR Te- Ha c)KaTOM flI1PHOjHoM ra3e B Y36eKH4CTaHe pa6OTaIOT XOCMOTpa/TeXo6CJIy)KI1BaHI4H ,DO)DKHO HlpIBeCTH4 K TpaHC- -HOqTH1 HCKJIOMH4TeJIbHO -TOIbKO MO1IHbie aBToMo6HInI4 4bopMaHI4H1 HbIHeIIIHHX nporpaMM B 6onee 3j4eKTHBHbIe II aBTo6yCbI, Ha KOTOpbIe IIpH4XOA1HTCH 4,3% i4 3,6% COOTBeT- HpOrpaMMbI TeXOCMOTpa/TeXO6CJTY)KI4BaHHH1. COKpaCeHHe CTByIOHIU4X fiapKOB (USTDA, 1997 r.). B 60IbmlIHHCTBe CBOCM o6beMa BbI6pOCOB aBTOMo6H)IbHbIX aBIraTeCJIC4 3aBHC11T OT Ha 3TI4X aBTOMo6I4HIAX YCTaHOBieHbI riepegehIaHHbie nog c>Ka- o6LerO COCTOSH1H3 HH4paCTpyKTypbI TexHl1'ecxoro o6cny- TbI HpIplOpOJHbifT ra3 6eH3HHOBbIe BTHraTeCJl. B aBTOMo6n- )KHBaHHH4 aBTOMO6i4HheI Hi COCTOHTeCIbHOCT14 HOBbIX BapnaH- nAx, o6OpyAOBaHHbIX MOAL1±41I14POBaHHbIMH (noA c)KaTbIf4 TOB SKOHOMWIHOrO peCIIeHH5I 3a4aL TexoCMOTpa/Texo6cay- fpIHpOAHbIlf ra3) j143eChbHbIMH gBHraTeCAHMH, HCHOhIb3yCTCH )IKHBaH131. TaKHM o6pa3oM, MOJepHH3aTn4H o6Opyx;OBaHI4z, CMeCb LH3CAebHorO TOHUI4Ba H cwKaTOrO npHPpoUHoro ra3a. 6yx"yi4 OJHOf4 143 repBOWlepegHbIX 3aJaM, 9OI)KHa ocywe- KOMHIIeKTbI TOiJIHBHbIX C14CTeM JLA nepeCoCga Ha c)KH)KeH- CTBIIATbCA OAHOBpeMeHHO C pacluHpeHCHeM npO113BOJJCTBeH- HbIA flpH4pOxHbIaf ra3 H1MHOpTHpyOTCTH 113 POCCHH4. TonHIHB- HO-TeXHHiCecKoCI 6a3bI o6CHyAKH4BaHH4A i4 peMOHTa. HbIe 6aKI4, OT 8 JO 10 Ha Ka)KqOM aBTOMO6I4Ce, BbIHO)IHJIOT- HIpoU3oaocmeeHuo-mexHuqeCKas 6a3a o6cAymncu6anuA U C3 113 TOJICTOJIHCTOBOH CTaAmH, 'ITO npHIBOAX4T K yBeCIHieHI4C O peMoHma. OAHH4M 143 Ba)KHef4IIIHx (jaKTOpOB CHH4)KeHHA TOK- BeCa TpaHCnOPTHOrO CpeACTBa Ha 600-1000 Kr H o6ecrieqH- CH4qHOCTH BbI6pOCOB napKa 'aCTHbIx aBTOMo6HJIef4 ABIAIeT- BaeT cpeAHHf4 3ianac xoga B 250 KM. CH HaIHqi4e 11C AOCTYHHOCTb o6rbeKTOB o6CJIy>Kl4BaHH4M H4 pe- B HaCTOI4Cee BpeMA nporpamma riepeBODa aBToMo611Jb- MOHTa C Hagie)KHbIM qI1arHOCTH4MeCKi4M o6OpyJOBaHHeM I4 HbIX )jBHraTeieJ4 Ha c)Ki4)KeHHbit4 npvlpOJHblI4 ra3 HaXOJHTCA KBaJIHIHqI4HpOBaHHbIM TeXHHMeCKIlM riepCOHa)IoM. IJeHTpa- B 3aCToe. B TeMeHHe 1997-1998 rr. qiHcJio Mogl4(I4U14pOBaH- JH13OBaHHbIe riporpaMMbi T/T c o6OpyxnOBaHI4eM, npeCHa3Ha- HbIX aBI4raTeief4 COCTaBHJIO Bcero 168 eCJHHU. JJIA cpaBHe- MCHHbIM <>, o6blqHO CHI4TaIOTCH 6onee HIHA MO)KHO yKa3aTb, 'TO B 1995 r. 6bu1o MogI4wHIHuHPOBaHO 34)CeKTHBHbIMH, 'ieM geCIeHTpaJIH3OBaHHbIe riOprpaMMbi 1430 ABi4raTeCief4, a H1pOI43BOA11TeCIbHOCTb KOHBepCHOHHbIX T/T c o6beKTaMi4 <>, BBHXgy IOTeHIM4- MOWqHOCTeC4 B MaCmlTa6aX Bcef4 CTpaHbI COCTaBJmeT OKOno 12 a)ibHoro KOH(4JIHKTa H1HTepeCOB BO BTOpOM cnypae. OjHaKo TbIC. egC4HH14 B rox (YJMJIAqeB, 1999). HbIHeCIHee COCTOAHiHe B c)IMCae OTCYTCTB14A XOpOIIIO OCHaT4eHHOVI H HOJIHOCTbIO npOrpaMMbl nepeoCHaLICeHl4H JBHraTeCief4, BepORTHO, OTpa- yKoMHiieKTOBaHHOTh KBaJIi4(ni4n14pOBaHHbIM14 KagpaMHi npo- )KaeT HeCoCTaTKH1 cyeCTBYIOWCef TeXHoJIorHl4 (cTanbHbIe H3BOACTBeHHO-TexHIHMeCKOfl 6a3bI o6CJI)KIHBaHI4H 1 peMOH- 19 flpMMeHeHHe 6onee IHCTLIX MOTOPHbIX TOJIUIB AAA o6eCieMBHHH 'IHCTOTLI BO3fyXa B CTpaHaX CpezAHef A3HH H KaBKa3a Ta CTporO BbInOJHHeMaA nporpamma <) gopore HCflo0)b3ylfOTC$1 IpHHLIHrbl 11H(HpaKpaCHOH cHeKTpO- BHOnHe Mo>KCT OKa3aTbCH CTOIb )KC Ma)Io 34eKTHBHOH, KaKI CKOHHH. OgHoBpeMeHHo MO)KHO perHCTpMpOBaTb CKOpOCTb H ripaKTHKa B3MmaHMHI ruTpa4OB. Ilo mepe 6biCTporo pOCTa H YCKOpeHHe aBToMo6HJSI C H3o6pa)KeHHeM ero rocygapCT- roTpe6iCeHHH AH3eCTbHorO TorilHBa TpaHCIIOpTHbIM CeKTO- BeHHorO HOMepHOrO 3HaKa, 'ITO gacT B03MOAKHOCTb HAeHTH- pOM gaHHOrO perHoHa B 6niHxKamiuHe rOgbI BCe 6onbiiCee 3Ha- 4UIHPOBaTb aBTOMo6HnJH H oHipeqeICHTb pe)KHMbI, HpH KO- TIeHHe 6ygeT npHo6peTaTb TeXHHMeCKOe o6CyI>KHBaHHle TOpbIX BbInoIHIHJIHCb H3MepeHHI3. CepHAHO BbIIIYCKaeMbie aBToMo6HJieC. KaK oKa3aJioCb, a3po3soJH, BbI6paCbIBaCMbIe npn6opbi AICTaHlHOHHoro KOHTpORA, no3BoTiHoiinHe DH3CJThHbIMH ABHraTeniMH, OKa3blBaIOT OCO6eHHo ry6HTenb- OCyWeCTB)IATb HCeipepblBHoe H3MepeHHe 6onee 4000 aBTO- Hoe BIHAHHHe Ha 3AOPOBbe moHefl (CM. HIpHJIoKeHHe B), a Mo6HJeIC B Mac, CTaHOBHTCH MOWHbIM CpegCTBOM gJIA onpe- HCTOMHHKOM 6onbmwHX o6bCMOB BbI6pOCOB a3po30oieui BIJI- eCieHHq COCTaBa BbI6pOCOB aBToMo6HJIbHoro napKa, 3KCrnly- IOTCI AH3eChbHbie ABHraTeCiH, cogepAK. aBTOMo6HJIbHbIx napKOB H B pa3BHBaiOHimHXCH CTpaHax. B Peeucmpaius aomoMo6uAeu. HaJ&KHaH CH4CTeMa yleTa H HCeplHO C 1997 no 1999 r. Ha TaifBaHe (KHTafl) 6bmia peanH30- peFHCTpaiiHH aBToMo6HIeHl HBJIHeTCH HeCpeMeHHbIM ycilo- BaHa nporpamma AHCTaHH14OHHOrO KOHTpOhII Ha 6a3e ceTH BHeM OCyIeCCTBJTeHHH 34I4eKTHBHOH nPOrPaMMbI T/T. Ho- H3 10 CTaHUH4H. 14HTepeCHo 6buio 6bI HpoaHaJIH3HPOBaTb 3Ty BefIimaA 6a3a gaHHbIX, BO3OlIIOLUaH ocyWeCTBJIATb KOM- ipaKTHKY IIpH pacCMOTpeHHH KaKOrO-HH6yAb OrIbITHOrO rlb1OTepHbif4 HOHCK (co CHSTiHeM CcnHCaHHbiX aBTOMo6HICef C npOeKTa B CTpaHaX IlJeHTpanbHOa3HaTcKOrO H KaBRa3cKoro ytIeTa), no3BO)IHJIa 6bl BbIHB)IHTb HaH6oiCee CHIbHbCe HICTOM- perHlOHOB. BHegpeHHeC aH)aIorH1HHbiX riporpamm AHCTaHgH- HHKH 3arpAI3HeHHH oKpy>AaomeCi CpceJbI. TeM CaMbIM yga- OHHOrO KOHTpOJA rnIiaHHpyeTC5 H B gpyrHX CTOJWIHbIX Me- IOCb 6bl Haf4TH caMoe 394eKTHBHOe upiHMeHeHHe TeM orpa- ranoInHcax, HaHpHMep, rIeKHHe, BaHrKOKe O H CeynIe. HHMeHHbIM pecypcaM, KOTOpbIe MmeCOTC gAnR KOHTpOJA IlpOBegRHHbie OgeHKH 3aTpaT Ha opraHH13auHo CTaiAH- BbI6pOCOB. CO3gaHHe TaKoH 6a3bl 4aHHbLX ABJIHeTCA cpaBHH1- OHapHbIX H Mo6HJIbHbIX CTaHUH4l AHCTaHL{HOHHOrO KOHTpO- TeCJbHO HpOCTOii 3aagaeCl, peLHHITb KOTOpyIO Mo)KHO ga)KCe An, BKnIOMaA o06yeHi4e nCepCOHanIa, COCTaBHAH OT 90 TbIC. go flpH HMeiOT4HXCH CKpOMHbIX pecypcax. A 6ygy'rn C03gaH- 140 TbIC. ,oaTO. NInA 6onee TO'IHOi KaJIbKYJIHUHH H opraHH3a- HOM, OHa 6narOTBOpHo CKa>KeTCH Ha BceCi pa6OTe, CBH3aHHOfi 1H4 BbIrIOJIHeHHH OrbITHOrO ripoeKTa MOryT HOTpe6OBaTb- C BeCeCHHeM y'IeTa. CA CCeperOBOpbI C ripOMbbIILieHHbIM HOCTaBMI4KoM. HeCMOT- ,fJucmaHrnuoHHblu KoumpoAb AeZKO8bLx a6omoMo6uweu C p5 Ha 3HaMHTeJIbHbIHf o6'beM 3THX 3aTpaT, IMCeeT CMbIClI 6eh3UH-oblM asueameAeM. C yMCTOM MCIOmLC1erOCH B HaCTOH- COHOCTaBHTb C 3aTPaTaMH Ha opraHH3aUHio 6onblO0ro KOIH- ICCee BpeMA HeCOCTaTKa peCypCOB, B03MO)KHO, i4eCIecoo6pa3- 'ieCTBa Tpaa4H{OHHbIX CTaHif4H T/T, CHiOCo6HblX o6c7y- HO 6b1no 6bl paCCMOTpeTb a1TbTepHaTHBbl npHHUUy <>. OgHIM 143 BO3MO)KHblX 1H4cnOJb3OBaHHCe gCTaH4HOHHorO KOHTpO)IA B KaeCCTBe BaPHaHTOB HBJIAeTCH iPOBepKa 6OnbuIorO KOJi4MeCTBa aBTO- CpeCCTBa T/T HAH < aBToMo6HJeIC Tpe6yeT Ha- Mo6HneC C IeCJIWbO BblHBiCeHHn HaH6oiCee CHIbHbIX 3arpn3HH- JIHMHI 344eKTHBHoHi 6a3bl gaHHbIX C HgCeHTHRiHKaUHOHHOi4 TeCeIC gun HpOBCeCeHH 6onee HHTeHCHBHbIX H4cHblTaHHA. peCHCTpaaHCe4 aBTOMo6HJiCe, unA Toro 'ITo6bI MO)KHO 6bi1io JIerKOBbIe aBToMo6HJIH MO>KHO « MeTO9OM COHOCTaBHTb HOMepHbIe 3HaKH C AJPYrHMH CBeeHHAMMH o6 aB- ,HCTaHUHOHHOrO KOHTpORA, B KOTOpOM gAn 3aMepa KOH- ToMo6HJie. KaK y)Ke rOBOpHJIOCb BbIIHlC, B nKo6oM cAiyMae Ta- UeHTpa1U4H yrIieBOgOpoAOB, CO, H NO, B BH4AHMOM KOHType Kan 6a3a qaHHbIX Heo6XOgHMa WM1 TOH 149IH HHOI4 ripOrpaMMbI BbIXJIOrHbIX ra3OB aBTOMo6HAH BO BpeMA ero BH)iKeHHq no T/T, CnoCo6CTBYIOLeUC CHH)KeHH1IO 3arPH3HeHHH Bo3fgyxa. 20 CeKTOp c6bITa HedTeHIpONyKTOB H Ka1IeCTBO TOrJIHBa G TCpaHbI J4eHTpaJIbHOh4 A31HH H KaBKa3a MO)KHO YCJIOBHO pa3JeJIHTb Ha jABe rpynnbI: CTpaHbi, pac- nonaraiowne ZOBOJIbHO KpyIfHbIMH MOWHOCTAMH no He4YTenepepa6oTKe (A3ep6af4gfaH, Ka3ax- CTaH, TypKMeHHCTaH ii Y36eKx4CTaH), H CTpaHbI, He HMeIOWHe TaKOBbIX. CTpaHaM-4MropTepaM HeITerIpO,fyKTOB (BTopaa rpyIria), iKaK ipaBHIO, nIpowe peCfIHTb 3a,jamy flOBbIiiieHH1 KaMeCTBa TOnrIKIBa, rIOCKOJIbKy HM He rIpHXOflHTCA JJeJIaTb 6oImbmIIX KariHTaJIOBHo)KeHHH B MoJePHH43a4LHIO He±TeIIepepa6aTbi- BaiOWHX 3aBOJ;OB. 14 He BbI3bIBaeT y914BJIeHHu TOT (J)aKT, 'TO rpy3aH, eAHHCTBeHHaSI CTpaHa B [jaHHOM perHoHe, O4ZmIahIbHO 3anpeTlnmaA HcnrOJb3OBaHHe 3TH- CTyH K HeCcTH, Teriepb BbIHy>KgeHbl HMflOPTHPOBaTb i nna- JIMPOBaHHoro 6eH3vHa, MMTIOPTHPYeT IIOqTH BeCb nOTpe6- THTb 3a Hec. llawroJapcKHui Hfl3 B Ka3axcTaHe iepe)KHi" JIHeMbll B CTpaHe 6eH3HH. CpexH CTpaH, pacnonaraiouMx oco6eHHO TpyAHbHf4 nepHOA B o6ecnCHeCHHH HeCfTbiO H B no- KpyrHbIMH Hel3Teriepepa6aTbIBaioiHMH MOLUHOCTHMI4, cjieAHHe roabi pa6oTan C OIeHb HH3KHM KoS34HU4ieHToM 3a- Asep6afigrpaH, TypKMeHHCTaH H Y36eKHCTaH lo6HnHcb ca- rpy3Ka MOIHOCTeC. Hl13 B Mapg>Koy (TypKMeHHcTaH), xO- Moo6ecneMeHHiu 6eH3HHoM H AH3enJbHbIM TOrJIHBOM. Ka3ax- TOpbIfl 6bIn 3anpoeKTHPOBaH Ha nepepa6oTxy He4)TH H3 CTaH pacnonaraeT MOIHOCTHMH HO HecjTenepepa6oTKe, Ao- Y36eKHcTaHa, B rIoCiCJHlHe rOabI TaK)Ke BCTpeTHuCH C Tpyg- CTaTO'HbIMH )JRI caMoo6ecne'-eHHH 6eH3HHoM, HO 3aecb HOCTAM4 B o6ecneCeHIHH He3TbMO, B pe3y)IbTaTe qero 3HaMiH- Koa4HmuHeHT 3arpy3Ka Mo4HoCTeHl HeTerienepepa6aTbIBa- TeCIbHyIO qaCTb BpeMeHH He pa6oTan. EiM OAHOH ripHqH- IOLHX 3aBOJOB 0OB0)TbHO HU30K, H 3Ha'HlrTeJIbHoe KOJIHMeCT- HOM MaJiof 3arpy3Kaf Hf3 HBJiHeTCA pe3Koe CHHKeH)He BO 6eH3niHa cTpaHa BB03HT H3-3a rpaHHubl. cnpoca Ha He()TeflpoJyKTbl C Hamaiia 90-x rr., o6ycnoBneHHoe He4xTenepepa6aTbIBaloruHe 3aBOJbI (HrI3) aaHHoro 3KOHOMH'eCKHM cragoM. HanpHMep, HOBo6aKHHCKHaf HII3 pervioHa pa3aTHiaioTcA no cxeme -OT rpOCTbIX He(4TeHepe- B A3ep6aaxpKaHe CTOJIKHyJICH C Cepbe3HbIM CHH)KeHmeM rOHHbIX 3aBO90B (npOCTef4iuaH H3 BO3MO)KHbIX cxeM) ao cnpoca Ha 6CH34H, TaK WTO B riocIieCHee BpeMA YCTaHOBKa Ka- KpyrIHbIX He(PTeHepepa6aTbIBaIolHx rpegnpHHTHl C Kpe- TaI4HTH4IecKorO KpeKxHra '4V0oHg4" (KK$) pa6oTanao x0Bonb- KHHr-yCTaHOBKaMm.K KIHcJyKpyKIHb1X He(cTenepepa6aTblBa- HO peAKO. PyKOBOAHTeCTH Hfl3 yTBepxKAa1OT, 'TO yInA B03o6- Io4Hx KoMinieKCOB OTHOCJTCH rHaBJ1ogapCKH4f Hfl3 B Ka3ax- HoBI3eHHH peryJIapHOfl pa6oTbI YCTaHOBKH KKI) cnpoc Ha cTaHe, HOBo6aKHHCKHa HH3 B A3ep6a$uxpKaHe H HH3 B 6eH3HHaH oJLOAKCH HO'qTH yaBOHTbCA. TypKMeH6auH (TypKMeHHCTaH). MeCTa pa3Me[eHHI4H HeKO- Hfl3 B A3ep6afxgpKaHe, TypKMeHHCTaHeC Y36eKHCTaHe TOpbIX H3 3THXrH13 HeJIb3As Ha3BaTb oHTHMaJIbHbIMH. BOJIb- Haxo9zqcTC UOA KOHTpOJieM roCyaapCTBa, XOTH flipaBilTeJIb- mIUHCTBO H4 HX HOCTPOeHO B COBeTcKoe BpeMA, Korga rocy- CTBO Y36eKHCTaHa B HaCTOHiT4ee BpeMH H ripOBORI4T nlpnBa- gapCTBO KOHTPO)IHPOBaBIo H rapaHTHpOBanO 11OCTaBKY THSaBuHo H13 B cDepraHe. B cTpaHax c KpyrIHOfl He+TeJo- He4TrH H c6bIT rpOJ4yKTOB. Co BpeMeHH pacnaxa COBeTCKO- 6blBaaloiea IpOMbll)IeHHOCTbIO (K KOTOpbIM OTHOCHTCI ro Coio3a HeKOTOpbIe HH3 OKa3aanaCb OTpe3aHHbIMH OT nC- A3ep6ahjpvKaH H Ka3axCTaH), HHTepec K HPHBaTH3aiuH rocy- TO'HIHKOB HeckTH H CTOJIKHYJIHCb C TpygHOCTqMH c6blTa Ha gapCTBeHHoro ceKTopa COCpeAoTO'eH npex-gC Bcero Ha go6bl- pbIHKax, oKa3aBHIHxCA Tenepb B Jpyr)HX CTpaHax. BaK3oIee oTpacni, 'TO 3aTpyAHHeT npHBjie'eHRe KariHTaJia B HacTonuAee BpeMA 3HaBHTeCbHoe 'IHCJIO KPYIHbIX g4A MogepHH3aUHH HrI3. Havi6onee epbe3Han nporpamma HrH3 3arpyiKeHa C 5 ,o 1 o6. %. HepeA CTpaHaMH4 1JeHT- HIoKa3aTenvI KaqeCTBa ToJIHMBa, KOTOpbie cICegyeT y'14- pa)bHoHf A3I4I H 4 lHaBKa3a CTO1T npo6neMa no3TanHoro TbIBaTb npf paCCMOTpeCHH flpo6JIeMbI OXpaHbI Bo3SyUiHofa y>KeCToMeHMH Tpe6oBaHHM4 K Ka'eCTBy TOnJIMBa. cpeAbI B CTpaHax IJeHTpalbHofl A3I4I4 H KaBa3a, BKJiiOliaIOT 0301. XlaBneHMe napoB no Pealgy (RVP) onpeqenieT B ce6a: coCep>KaHMe CBIUHMa, cepbl, apOMaTKI4, 6eH3ona, one- neTy4eCTb 6eH3HHa, a cJiegoBaTenbHo, H BbI6pOC ero (pHHOB H KHCAopoaCoAep)KaLu4x COeCl4HeHHMi B 6eH34He; ne- napoB. rlpegenbHaA BeC11H'ql4Ha RVP, YCTaHOB1eHI5HaI B Ty-eCTb 6eH3EHa; E4 xapaKTCPMCTH4KI4 pa3roHKH. Ha npMBe- gaHHOM periHOHe Ha nIeTHee BpeMA (o3oHo-onacHbIfl ACHHbIe 3,eCb noKa3aTeJIM KaMeCTBa ToHiHHBa BJIHM4OT H Tf4H Ce3SH), COCTaBJIAeT 66,7 KHa. YMeHbiIIeHHe RVP BJIS- nepepa6aTbIBaeMoA He(aTH, H cXeMa HH3, M )K&CTKOCTb Tex- eTCA OAHHMM S3 CaMbIX 3KOHOMHMHbIX cfloco6OB CHM)Ke- HonorHMqeCKoro pe>KHMa Ha yCTaHOBKaX HHl3, H Ha6op npo- H1HA o6pa3oBaHM4a 03oHa, HOCKOJIbKy TaKMM cnoco6oM AYKTOB HII3. MO)KHO CHH3I4Tb BbI6poCbI yrJIeBoAopogoB, BCTynaIo- IIUMX B peaKUMMHEr noA BO39ef CTBHeM CoIHeMHoro CBeTa. CneIw404wKaqun 3TOT MeTOA, B03MO)KHO, 3aMHTepeCyeT BJIaCTH ropo- B o6CnegOBaHHOM perHOHe HaHMHaIOT pa3pa6aTbIBaTb- AOB, B KOTOpbIX cogep)KaHiCe O3OHa B aTMoc4lepe Ha CArCHCenUH4iKaUMIM Ha TorulIBO, HO B OCHOBHOM JeLCtCTByIOT YPOBHe 3eMJIH yKce Co3,aeT npo6)ieMbI. CTaHgapTbI, YCTaHOBJIeHHbIe B COBCTCKMfl nepH4og. Cepa. rpegenbHoe coCep)KaHHe CCpbI B 6eH3w He orpa- C CuHete. M4CnOJb3OBaHi4e 3THJIHpOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa B HHqHBaeTCH1 BeCJHIMHHOH 0,1 BeCOBbIX % (BeC. %). Hlo- HaCTOHiCee BpeMH 3anpeleHo TOJIbKo B rpy3I4M, XOT3 B CKOJIbKy cepa o6paTHMo OTpaBJIHeT KaTaJIH3aTopbI, B A3ep6af4,hw aHe OH He BbInlyCKaeTCA C 1997 r. BO Bcex o6cneayeMblx CTpaHax cIiegyeT paCCMOTpeTb BOnpOC CTpaHax, KpOMC rpy3HH, ,oriyCKaCTCH HPHCYTCTBIHe go o6 y>KeCToMeHHM4 3TOH4 HOpMbI, HOCKOJIbKy B perHoHe 0,17 r CB14HHia B 1 )IMTpe (r/n) 6eH3r Ha C O-/M 76 paCTCT iM4CJIO 6eH3HMOBbIx aBToMo6HiefI, CHa6)KeH- IIyHKTOB H go 0,37 r/n 6eH3MHa C OH no i4cciiegoBa- HbIX KaTaIMHTHMeCKIHMM Uipeo6pa3oBaTeJHlMH (HeaTpa- TeCIbCKOMY MeTOAY (OH/14) 93 HYHKTa4. 14CKI1O0eHCHe JIH3aTOpaMM BbIXJIOHHbIX ra3oB). 4MO/H1 HBJiCeTCA MepoM CTOHKOCTH 6eH3HHa K CaMoBocHIIaMeHeHHIO (geTOHaUHH) HpH ABH)KeHHH aBToMo6H)nA C Ma)Ofl CKOpOCTbMO B ropogCKxHX yCIOBHqX. 22 CeKTop c6b[Ta He4JTefIrpOeyKTOB M KaHeCTBO TOnIlJHBa BCTaBKa 4. Pe3ynibTaTbmi 3y'eHNS o6pa3soB TOnJimBa B pamKax gaHHoro perHoHaJIbHoro HccnegOBaHHA BO Bcex CTpaHax, Kpome TypKMeHHCTaHa, OT64pau4cb npo6bi 6eH- 3HHa H H143eJbHorO TonIlnHla BO MHoriix ropogax pernoHa. Han6onee HHTeHCHBHO npo6bl OT6HpaJHlcb B Aaep6aflgxaHe, rge 6bizll 1y43eHbl 15 npo6 6eH3nHa H 7 npo6 JLH3eCJbHOFO TOtTJIHBa. Pe3yaubTaTbi aHa)1H3a BblHBHJIH cyIIeCTBeHHble oTIIH- 'H-n B KaMeCTBe 6eH3HHa H W-H3enbHorO TOHJIHBa B pa3JIHMHbIx rIyHKTax AaHHoro pernoHa. qacmo iapyumaiomcs mpe6oeanusr no OKmaOOobM xapaKmepucmuKaM 6en3uHa. B OAHOfl CTpaHe 5H13 6 npo6 76-ro 6eH- 3i-Ha (O/M) He BbIJepCKaXJIH HcnbITaHHe Ho rioKa3aTeino «MHHHMaJbHoe OJ/M»,. B qpyrof CTpaHe jBe HccJiegOBaHHbie ripo6bi 76-ro 6eH3arHa HMeJIH OH/1 75 HyHKTOB, a OI/M -cero 70 HyHKTOB. OwHa npo6a 6eH3SHa A93 mmena OH/H 83 nyHKTa H OH/M 78 HyHKTOB. IMmeOTCA CBHgeTenubCTBa TOrO, 'ITO HeKOTOpbie O6pa3ubI 6eH3iHa cogep>Kann HpHMeCH Ke- pocHHa. * Co3epwaHue coun4a B 6eH3uHe He npeobitusa.o npe3eAbHo aonycmuMoeo ypo6HA, 3a HCKHO'ICeHlHeM OQHOH npo6bI 76-ro 6eH3wiHa, B KOTOpOfi ero coWepKaHHCe COcTaBHnHo 0,3 rpaMMOB Ha JIHTp (rhi), H xpyroi npo6bl, oTo6paHHOfH B ropoge C HaceJieHmeM CBbHJIe 1 MnH qem., B KOTOpOI4 6bmi npeBbnLneH HopMaTHBHblf npeenen 0,013 rln. B pqqe cnyqaeB B 6eH- 3H4He 6b)1O o6Hapy>KeHo 6Onblmoe KOJImieCTBO Ao6aBoK, cogepxKawmx )KeJIe3o, ITO gaeT OCHOBaHHB IqpeaHnOOAUHTb HaJTHqiHe go6aBOK B 6eH3axHe, BBegeHHbIX nocne ero nOKy1fKH Ha HH13. * BbtCOKoe coaepmcanue apomamuKu 6 aatcOKOOKmano6om 6eH3uHe - go 59 BCC. % apoMaTHKH H 5.3 Bec. % 6eH3onoa. 3To - pe3ynJbTaT HcnOJIb3yeMOfl CXeMbi Hl3: 6eH3HH pHcfOpMHHra IBJimeTCA OCHOBHbIM BbICOKOOKTaHOBbIM KOMHOHeH- TOM. AJmH 3aIJHTbI 3AOpOBbH HaceieHHA CJieCyeT B HepBsyO o'epegb CHH)KaTb COJ;epJAaHHe 6eH3ona H apOMaTHKH. * Coiepjcanue cepbl 6 6eH3uHe 6 pxiae c7ypaeo npeabiwaAo aonycmumuii npeaeA. MaKcHManbHoe coqep>KaHHe cepbI CO- CTaBn]iiJIO 0,14 Bec. % (HopMaTH4BHblP4 npeeien - 0,1 Bec. %). HIpo6bl OUl3eAbHOeO monAuga, f OCH-OBHOM, yOOBAemBopAAu 6ceM mpe6o3aHus3im, KpOMe coaepmaHuA cepbl. MaKcHMaRbHOe cogepxKaHme cepbI B H3enJbHOM TOrAHlBe npeBbiLtiano 0,9 Bec. %, '-TO 6bl3O 3a(4HKCH4pOBaHO B AByX CTpaHax. B 6OnbmHH- CTBe CTpaH Bn RH3ebHOM TonIHUe cogepxKanocb He 6onee 0,2 Bec. % cepbI. BbIiH OTMe'eHbl HpH3HaKH 3arpas3HeHHA AH3enJb- HOrO TOHJIHBa He4ITbIO. * Bu3bt au3eAbnoeo moninu6a. OCHOBHbIMH HOKa3aTeJia- TSDKeibIe MeTaJijibi, gnnH OBbllImeHHA ero OKTaHoBOro m'Hcia. MH B cieLLH4IHKaLJHIx Ha qH3eJIbHoe TonnI1BO iBIHEOT- He3aKOHHoe BBegeHHe CBnHHia B 6eH3aH flpH OTCYTCTBMH cAi M1HHMaJIbHoe ueTaionoe qHcJIo (45 nlyHKTOB), MaK- KOHTpOuIH 3a OKpy>xaiOef1 cpegowa C03oaeT cepbe3Hno yrpo- cHMaJIbHoe cogep>KaHle cepbi (0,5 Bec. % gJnJ TonrIHBa 3y 3AOpOBbIO JiHu, 3aHHMaKomHxcH 3TOH geATeflbHOCTbIO. THna II H 0,2 Bec. % AAn TOUInIJBa THna I), a TaKiKe T96 OAHy H3 npo6 6eH3HHa, OTo6paHHblx B paMKaX HacToiuiAei (TeMnepaTypa, ¶p31 KOTOpOI4 OTrOHBeTCA 96% JH3eJIb- HporpaMMbl, He yanooCb iipoaHaIH3HPoBaTb Ha CBHHeCI H3- Horo TOnJHBa) B JieTHIfHH nepmog (360°C). CTaHAapTbl 3a HaJIHIHR B HeH ipe3mepnoro KonwiiecTa >ene3a (BepoaT- no ueTaHoBoMy 'iHcJIy, T96 H cogep>KaHHKO cepbi g1H HO, B BHJLe 4eppoUeHa). TorLIiHBa THna I ABJHHOTCa HpHeMneMbiMHl. ECn)H TpaHC- CornacoBaHHble yCHJIH4H no 6onee TIaTenJbHOMY Ha- HOpTHbIe cpegRTBa pa6OTaloT Ha 4H3e)JbHOM TorLInHBe 6rnogeHMKo 3a IIPHCYTCTBHeM CBHHUa B 6eH3iHHe npegn;pH- TiE1a II, cnexyeT paccMoTpeTb Bonpoc o CHH)KeHHH co- HATbl B AiMaTbI, rge B Hio)le 1998 r. 6bIna coa3aHa MeA>Be- gep)KaHHA cepbi. gOMCTBeHHaa KOMHCCH3 no oIxeHKe KaIeCTBa 6eH3H-Ha. B xoge gaHHoro HccJIegOBaHHHq npOBOAEwOCb HCnblTaHHe MOHHTOpHHr cogepKaHnHA CBn4HLUa B 6eH3HHe, npoBoiHB- o6pa3auoB TonrIHBa B cOHOCTaBJieHHH c Aef4CTByIoHLHMH HOp- mHHcEiLC B iepHog c 1997 r. go HaMalla 1998 r., noKa3ani, ITO 4O MaMH (CM. BCTaBKy 4). OAHOtf TpeTH pean}H3yeMoro 6eH3MHa HPHXOA4TCH Ha 3THJH- pOBaHHbIl- 6eH3HH, XOTSJ B AnMaTbI, c ero 6onee 'em MHJIJH- MOHHTOPHHr KaHeCTBa TOnnIBa OHHbIM HaceJIeHHeM, no.Jara)ioCb npogaBaTb TOJIbKO He3TH- O6ibeM pa6oT no MOHHTOPJHHry KaiaecTBa ToiJIHBa B EIHpOBaHHbIa 6eH3HH. KOMHccHH coo6agaeT, 'TO efl yganocb gaHHOM perioHe HeBeiiHK. HpegCTaBJhleTCz, 'ITO caMoHf cepb- 3a6nOKHpOBaTb UeHTpaHn3OBaHHYIO AocTaBKy T3C Ha )Ke- eanoi npo6neMofl B 3TOM cmbicJle JBJHAeTCH claJbCHcH4mKa- JIe3HOJO)OAKHbie CTaH14HH, KKeT y4ep)KaTb 4OHO7IHHTeCIbHbIe 3aTpaTbl Ha HH3KOM ypOBHe. CTpaHbl C HaH607TblmHM O)KH- CaeMbIM pOCTOM noTpe6neHMHS 6eH3HHa (A3ep6atiY4KaH, Fpy3Ha H TypKMeHHCTaH) He CTO1IKHYTCST C orpaHHMCeHHSMirMH, o6ycnoBneHHbIMH pa6oToP HII3; HOBo6aKHHCKHP HHI3 B A3ep6af4xiKeTCa1 TA)KeCIbIM 6peMeHeM 71aST aBTOMo6H11HCTOB. 24 CeKTOp c6blTa He(4TeHpOgyITOB H KaMeCTBO TOflIHBa TypKMeH6aimn (TypKMeHrrcTaH) - HMCeOTCA YCTaHOBKH Te ocna6nTeH1 KOHTpOJIH 3a CeKTOpOM c6blTa He(pTenpogyK- KK(D. BeH314H KKD rpegCTaBanneT co6of aJIbTepHaTH{BHbI4 TOB CO CTOpOHbI rocywapcTBa HPHBCAYT K pe3KOMy pOCTy BbICOKOOKTaHOBbIM KOMIIOHeHT. OxHaxo YCTaHOBKH KK$D 3a- BO3MO)KHOCTeCf HPHBAneleHHA KaHHTaJJOB, Heo6xOJJHMbIX AnA '1aCTYIO He pa6oTaboT 1l3-3a CHH)KeHHA cupoca Ha 6eH3SH MoCepHH3aLqHH H 3KcUJIyaTaUHH HH 3 PerHOHa. MeCTHOFO HPOH3BOJCTBa HM4 H3-3a TpyJHOCTefl, CBH3aHHbIX c HOCTaBKaMM HecjTM. nOJlITLKA B CEKTOPE CESbITA HE0TEnPOAYKTOB: YlpexnonaraeTca, 'ITO HH3 B TypKMeH6amH cMoCKeT CAEP)KHBAIOUAHE 0AKTOPbI - nEPECOPTI4A U HORHOCTbIO OTKa3aTbCn OT T3C 1H CHH3HTb coCepKaH(He 6eH- KOHTPABAHAA 3soua ii CyMMapHoff apoMaTHKH AO ipHMJeMOTeoro YPOBHA FJIaBHbIMMH HCTpyMeHTaMM rIOJIMTHKH B CeKTOpe C6bITa cpa3y nocnie 3aBepCeHHMH peanH3yemoro B HaCTohWee BpeMH He(CTenpo,gyKToB ABJHIIOTCH (4)KcaUM4A (HIM rnI6epanM3a- npoeKTa no COBepCIeHCTBOBaHIIO CxeMbi. BCeM OCTaJIbHbIM w'A) ueH H BBeXeHMe aKUH30B, fOUlOIHH H HaJIoroB. XOTA HHI3 nplTgeTCA npH4HHMaTb Mepbi rio cHAKeHCHMO cogepwKa- gAn CTHMYMhIPOBaHHIA BBegeHMH TOHMBSa 6onee BbICOKOH HHH 6eH3ona Ii CyMMapHofl apoMaTHKH. 3gecb BO3MOAKHbl O-H4CTKH HoLUIAHHaMH H HaJIoraMH, KaK rIpaBHBIO, He nOJTb3y- pa3sn"HHble peimeHMi4, KaK-TO: YCTaHOBKa KOJIOHHbl pa3rOHKM LOTCH, OHM MOryT OKa3aTb cepbe3Hoe BJLMHHHe B 3TOM Ha- HacfTbl nepeg yCTaHOBKOa4 pH4ipopMHHra gnAi oTgeneHIA rpaBjieHHH. lpaB4TeCIbCTBO OTHyCKaeT geHbl, 3aCTaBJIAH HpeCmHeCTBeHHHKOB 6eH3ona; MOHTaw YCTaHOBKH 43oMepH- KOHKypeHUMiO HpHHOCHTb BbirogbI, H TaM, rge iiH6epaJIH3a- 3aJlHM; H 3aKynKa 3TaHoJia HAM HpOCTbIX 34)HpOB, HaripH- MH1 I4eH geCfCTByeT 34(MeKTHBHO, UeHbl BHYTpeHHerO pbIH- mep, MeTHMTpeTM'Ho6yTHJIOBoro X4mpa (MTB3). AJnA HHl3 Ka cne IyIOT 3a MHpOBbIMM LeHaMM Ha HpOAYKTbl. IIocne 3TO- C YCTaHOBKaMH KK$) eCTb Apyrofl BapaHHT pemeH4A, a HMeH- ro HpaBHTCeTbCTBO HoCpegCTBOM HauoroB HOgHHMaeT HO aJIKHRMpOBaHHe, XOTA CTPOHTeCIbCTBO YCTaHOBKH aKIKHJH- BHYTPeHHHC g4eHbl Hag MHpOBbIMM (K KOTOpbIM glo6aBAH- pOBaHHHq o6xogHTCn goporo. IOTCH TPaHCHOPTHbIe paCxOgbi) H{ TeM CaMbIM CO3gaCT Ba)K- B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT THHa nepepa6aTbIaaeMofi He4TH, MO- Hbll HCTOMHMK rioHeOAHHMSe 6iojpKeTa. AKeT HOTpe6oBaTbCH OHlHCTKa gM3enbHorO TOruUlBa OT cepbl. TaM, rme ieHbl (jO pMMpylOTCA He pbIHKOM, a yCTaHaBJIH- CnegOBaTe)bHo, BO3HMKHeT HeO6XogHMOCTb B rHgpOo'HHCT- BaIOTCH ripaBHTeCJbCTBOM, OHH He MeHAIOTCH B COOTBCTCTBMM Ke. Ha (DepraHCKOM HFI3 B Y36eKMCTaHe, nepepa6aTbiBaao- C ICeHaMM MHpOBOrO pbIHKa, a cuiegyloT 3a MHpOBbIMH ueHa- 14eM BbICOKOCepHHCTYIO HeC4Tb, CMOHTHpOBaMH YCTaHOBKY MH 'iepe3 J1MCKpeTHbIe MHTepBaJIbI BpeMeHH, Korga iipaBH- rFHpOO'IHCTKH4 H3eCbHoro TOHIHBa, Hocnie nycKa KOTOpOfi TeCbCTBO HpHHMaeT pelieHi4e o peryJIHpOBaHHM BHyTpeH- HHI3 cMo)KeT Bbir1yCKaTb MH3eCAbHoe TorIIJlBO, OTBeCqaiowee HHX UeH. CTa6M4IbHOCTb, KOTOpyIO TaKaA CH4CTeMa Tpe6OBaHHIM Ho coCep)KaHiHHo Cepbi. CeHoo6pa3OBaHHAI HPMHOCHT rIOTpe6HTCTJIAM, Mo>KeT HpH- HeCMOTPR Ha TO, HITO gAn HoTpe6HTCeiefl TorJIMBa ynyn- HeCTH y6blTKM npogaAam npOAyKTa, KOTOpbie gOAAKHbI no- niieHHOrO Ka'eCTBa MTOJOBbie 3aTpaTbl MOFYT 6blTb He6OAb- KynaTb ero no WeHaM MH4pOBOrO pbIHKa. TombKO B TOM CJIy- IHMMH no CpaBHeHHIO C HbIHeCLHHMMH pO3HHMHbIMH ueHaMM, Mae, Korga CTpaHa nO)IHOCTbIO o6ecneIHHBaeT ce6S HeCTeCiepepa6aTblBaioi4MM ipeCgrpIHITHS1M BCe KCe HpHAeT- co6CTBeHHbIM npOgyKTOM (T.e. Korga oHa pacnonaraeT co6- CA HaXOgHTb CTapTOBbll KaHHTaA, Heo6xogHMbif4 gAn pacuiH- CTBeHHOH4 He(CTb1O H B COCTOIHHHM nepepa6aTbIBaTb ee XOTA peHMH HM1 MoCepHH3aL54HH TexHoAorHMeCKMx 0o6'beKTOB. B 6bl Ao ypOBHA, YJOBCeTBopHoliCerO co6CTBeHHbie HOTpe6HO- 3aBMCHMOCTH OT HIpOM3BOgCTBeHHOA MOLHOCTH, CTOHMOCTb CTH), H npOH3BogHTeuH, H nOTpe6HTeCuH OKa3bIBaIOTCH 3aUH4- YCTaHOBKH M3oMepH3aIJH gAil orpaHlnqeHHAH COgepCKaHHH MeHHblMH OT KOJIe6aHlM MHpOBbIX LJeH. HO B 3TOM cny'ae 6eH3ona H cyMMapHol apoMaTHKH B 6eH314He oCeHMBaeTCH B CTpaHa nOCTpagaeT OT Heymeuoro MCnOJIb3OBaHHH pecyp- 20-40 MJIH Ao0n. YCTaHOBKM rM4pOOHMCTKH KpeKHHr-6eH3S- COB, rOCKOJIbKy LeHbl He 6yqyT COOTBeTCTBOBaTb BO3MO)K- Ha, KOTOpbIif CTaHeT CbIpbCM pH14OpMHHra, o6xogrTCn rIpH- HblM 3aTpaTaM. MepHO B 10-30 MJIH goun. BanoBbie gOHOAHHTeCIbHbie 3KC- B o6cJiegyeMoM perHoHe TOJIbKo Asep6aigwaH, TypKMe- flJyaTaLuHOHHbIe pacXoAbI KOne6inoTCn B npeejenax OT MeHee HHCTaH H Y36eKMCTaH paCHoniaraKOT HPOM3BOgCTBeHHbIMH '1eM 0,5 MJIH go 2,5 MJIH goniAapOB. MOMHOCTHMM HO HeCTenepepa6oTKe, KOTOpbIX AOCTaTo0HO HlOCKOnbKy HH3 pexKo riOJIHOCTbIO OKynaiOT MHBeCTM- JIH;n caMoo6ecneMeHHM HeCpTenpOgyKTaMM. HlpaBl4TeAbCTBO UMH, HanpaBseHHbie Ha yjiyquIeHMCe KwaeCTBa TonMB4a, BCC A3ep6aaxpxaHa YCTaHOBHhIO cJ3KCHpOBaHHbie pO3HHqHbIe 6Onbmee 3HaMeHHe HpHo6peTaeT HIOBbIImCeHMe 3944eKTMB- geHbI Ha AgUITeJIbHbIoi nepHog. OgHaKo, Korga LeHbI BHyT- HOCTH pa6OTbI HHI3 B npouecce peaJHU3aiHM COBpeMeHHbIX peHHero pbIHKa, BKJHoiaA HaJIorH, HaIMHaIOT CHJbHO iipeBbl- CxeM, npH43BaHHbIX o6ecCeqCTb BbIIIOJIHeHHe 3KOJIorHIec- I[aTb nOTeHTmaJIbHbIe HMHOpTHbIe geHbI, Io0HBJIHeTCH KWHX Tpe6oBaHH4h. Hlepexog Co6CTBeHHOCTH OT rocygapcTBa K CTpeMJIeHCe cKopee HMnOpTMpoBaTb HeCTenpOgyKTbI, '1eM 'IaCTHbIM B)AialeCbUaM H yCHJieHMe KOHKypeHT4HM B pe3ynJbTa- HCrOJTb3OBaTb npOAYKTbI co6cTBeHHoro IpoM3BOgCTBa. AK- 25 lIpHMeHeHHe 6onee qHCTbIX MOTOPHbIX TOHIRIHB A1TH o6eCrieMeHHH q4CTOTTI B03fyXa B CTpatax Cpe1THefl A3Un H KaBKa3a EH3bI H HMIIOPTHbIe rIOLEHJHbI YCTaHOBACHbI Ha BbICOKOM CeTb pOS3HEI4HOi ripoga)KH4, ImTpa4l, HaJIo)KeHHbiH4 Ha Bna- ypOBHe, 3aTpyHuilOIeM JieranbHblu4 HMHOpT, HO TaKaA CTpa- geClbia OJHOH4 aBTO3aHpaBO'1HOt cTaHUHH, CO3gaCT nnoxyio TermH caenana HeCiera]IbHbIH HMnOpT ewe 6onee HplHBJeKa- penyTaiEnKo BCeM aBTO3aflpaBO'lHbIM CTaHHl4AM, npx-Hawe- TeCbHbIM. )Kai4HM gaHHof 4(HpMe, a 3TO cTaHeT IOBOgOM anf npOBege- B perHoHe BCTpeCMaOTCA caMbIC pa3Hoo6pa3HbIe He3a- H14H 11pOBepoK. fIogO6HbIM we o6pa3oM, BepTHKaJIbHaA KOHHbie rlpHCMbi peaJC3alHBHH TOrIMIBa, BK)IKOMaA KOHTpa- 14HTerpaum4H 'lepe3 CHCTeMy RbrOT MC)KAy OIITOBbIMH TOp- 6aHgy, iCepeCOPTHI4Y Ha Ka'eCTBe H GaJbcCH4HwKauH41O TOnJH4- FOBiLMaH ('rncnO KOTOpbIX riOCTOAHHO coKparlaeTcA) H po3- Ba. Bce OH14 HCflOJIb3yKOTCAH A1 yBeCiHMeHHq pa3mepa HHEqHbIMH TOPrOBiIaMl Mo)KeT lo6yAXHTb np1OH3BOAH4TeCIA K npH6bIIE4B a gaHHOR TOqKe cHa6)KeHMecKOa L CenI. 3a'acTylo opraHH3aBxHH caMOKOHTpOrnH. rIpHMeHAIOTCHq KoM6HHH4poBaHHbIe npHeMbl: HanpHMep, HIPH4 pOCTe cupoca Ha TorunmBO nOBbICLueHHOrO KaIeCTBa KOHTpa6aHAHbIf4 BB03 HH13KOOKTaHOBoro 6eH3SHa B CTpaHy ('acTHMHO B pe3yJIbTaTe yBeCJIiHCHH HAHcJia HOBbIX aBTOMO- (ann H1CKJHoiCeHI4H aKHH3a), a 3aTeM npoqa>Ka 3Toro 6eH3HHa 6wrnef4) pbIHOK 6yxeT pearHpoBaTb, Bo3gaBaa AOJDKHOe TeM KaK BbIcOKOOKTaHOBOFO, 'ITO XaCT JoLOOIHHTCeIbHbIiH rip4- pO3HH'IHbIM TOprOBTaM, KOTOpbIe 3aBO1OOT peCIyTaH4iO iio- pOCT HpEH6bI)IE. CTaB1IJHKa HaB1X(HbIX rIpOjyKTOB. B TO Ke BpeCMA niOTpe6- Co6na3H 3aHaTbCH TaKHM 6H3HeCOM 3aBHCHT OT riOTeH- HOCTb B rIPOBepKe KaieCTBa npOAyxTa co3gaeT KOMMepiec- UH4anbHoro pa3mepa npH6bI)14, BepOATHOcTH 6bITb yJiHMeH- KHe B03MO>KHOCTH4 AnI CO34aHHH na6opaTOpx4i. B KaqeCTBe HbIM H BeCIH'l4HbI ylep6a, HOHeceHHoro ripH o6HapywKe- HpHMepa MO)KHO IpHBeCCTH pbIHOK peaKTHBHOFO TOnrIlBa. HE114 qaHHoro 6143Heca. 'eM 344eKTHBHee TaMo)KeHHbie ABHaKoMHaHHH, 3KCHJIyaBTHPYIOWHe COBpeMeHHbie caMolIe- npoUCegypbl Ino rIpoBepKe o6&biMa H4 KamecTBa HMHOpTTHpye- Tbl, 3anpaBfIHloT HX B TOR H1JIHl HHOH CTpaHe TOhIbKo fpl4 yc- Moro ITpOAyKTa H1eM 3(14CKTH1BHee Ha6jnoCeHHCe 3a ero Ka- )IOBHI4M 10Hof4 rapaHT041 H KaqeCTBa TorIIHlBa. HIOcKOnbKy pe- 'eCTBOM B pOS3HHlqHOa ToproBnie, TeM pe)Ke 6yxyT BCTpe- aKTIfBHoe TOfITHBO HaxogHT BbirOAHbIHE C6bIT, HeKOTOPbIe qaTbcAI 3TTH npOTHBo3aKOHHbIe yJIOBKHl. BbIcoKxe aKIA43bI Hl MeCTHbIe HOCTaBWHKH4 yKe YCTaHaBBETBaBOT H141H opraH1H3Y1OT IoOUUIHHbI, KaK npaBH)IO, IpIMCeHHeMbIe B AaHHOM peCFHOHe COOTBeTCTBYLOIUHCe HcnbITaTeJlbHbIe ueHTpbI, ARiA Toro ITO- B Ka'eCTBe, Ka3anocb 6bl, Hage)KHoro 14cTO'IHHKa 6iowaKeT- 6bl C BblrOgO14 HdnllOb3OBaTb 3Ty B03MO)KHOCTb. HbIX AOXOAOB, CO3xa1OT CHIIbHbIl Co6JIa3H KoHTpa6aHAbI, KO- CTpaHbI, flpaKTH'meCKH4 IlOJIHOCTbIO 3aBHll4CHIie OT HM- TOpbIIl eiW 60nbume YCH)I4HBaeTC5 BBO3HbIMH HOLIHlHaMH nopTa HeC4TeCpOgyKTOB, 3aXOTAIT HOKyiaTb H4X y caMoro Bbl- (BHpO4eM, H4X 3JeCb I1OCTeCieHHO OTMeHHTOT). flpH MajiOM roaHoro HOCTaBWHKa. YxKe C4OpMHpOBaJicJIOBOJIbHO MOI- o6i,Me peaIlH3aaHHi, o6ycfOBIeHHoM O6igHM pOCTOM MH4- HbIf HOTOK HpOAYKTOB (KaK neraJIbHbIX, TaK H HenIeraJnbHbIx) pOBbIX H periHoHa.IbHbIX UeH Ha HePTeCnpOcyKTbl, ipogaBlIbI H13 POCCHi4CKOf1 $DeAepauHm. BBHJJy Toro, 'TO PoccHl$cxaA CTapaIOTC51 KoMneHCHPOBaTb TaKoro poAa yMeHbiCeHHCe o6b- CXegepaUHH ABH)KCeTC5 B CTOpOHy y)KeCToIeHCHA Tpe6OBaHHai CMOB yBeJIH'eHC4eM co6cTBeHHoI1 lOJIW iipH6bIIH C HOMO- K Ka'eCTBy ToHJIHBa, H, B IaCTHOCTH, BBH4gy OTKa3a OT HC- Mb1O He3aKOHHbIX UpHeMOB. HoJlb3OBaHHA T3C B pOCCHACKHX 6eH3H1HaX, BO3HHKaeT HlepecOpTHua OTHOCE4TCH K qlHciy caMbix rpOCTbIX pe- OriaCHOCTb TOrO, 'ITO HeKOTOpbIe pOCCHf4CKHe Hfl3 COBMeCT- m[eHl4f4 JHf nIocTaBWH4Ka, 1IOTOMY ITO C ITpOXYKTOM HHiCero HO C i1po%aBiTaMH T3C HBIHYT c6paCblBaTb B CTpaHbl IeCH- He HaJo geinaTb. CYWeCTByeT CyWeCTBeHHOe pa3JiH'He Me>K- TpaAbHofl A3414 EH KaBKa3a npOJyKTbl, KOTOpbIe OH1 6Onbme gy riepeCOpTHliCei no OKTaHOBOMy 'HCJry 1 iCepeCOPTH4Cef4 HO He CMOryT peaC143OBaTb 3aKOHHbIM flyT`M. BHyTpeHHHe rio- HPIHCYTCTBi4HO T3C. HloKynaTe)Ib ierwe 3aMeTE4T nepBoe, Ho- LUJlHbI H4 HaJIorH 6yAyT 14 B ga)IbHefCmIIeM ilOO1pATb KOH- TOMy 'ITO ACeHa BbIuIe, a MaIuHHa pa6oTaeT Xy)KCe ,qeM xOnA)K- Tpa6aHAy, CTHMYJIHEpyf ITOibITKEH IIOJTHOCTbIO "HTH OT yrina- HO 6bITb AnIA ToHi1HBa gaHHoro COpTa. flepecopTm4uy C HIC- Tbi riOIHiiHH. HOCKOnbKy aKLUE43 H BBO3HbIe rIIOJIHIHbl nOIb3OBaHHeM 3THJI4POBaHHoro 6eH3HHa 'aCTHoMy co6HpaIOT B nIHKTe BBO3a B CTpaHy, TO 'eM BbiiiCe HlOIHIHHbI IIOTpe6HTeCJHo npOKOHTPOnlHPOBaTb HaMHorO TPYAHee. A H HaJTorH, TeM CH)TbHee co6JIa3H KOHTpa6aHAbI npOmyKTOB. ABWraTeCHO aBToMo6HnAH 6e3 KaTaJIHTH'IeCKorO Hei4TpaJIH3a- lpHppoAa TOHAH4BHOrO pbIHKa B3aHMogeflCTByeT C 3THMH Topa H1CHOJb3oBaHHe 3THJInpOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa He HaHO- TeHmeHSIARMHl. Cnoco6HocTb nOJIb3OBaTeCIefH nogMeHhTb OA- C14T HpaKTH,MeCKH HHKaKoro yuwep6a; BO3,ef4CTBHe Ha HOfIb- HO TOnJIHBO apyrHm (HaMCpeHHO 1H6o c)y'aflHO) CO3gaeT 3oBaTenfA oKa3bIBaeTCH1 B rCepBy1o o'CepeCb H3BHe. XJOnOJIHHTeCIbHY1O CBo6ogy MaHeBpa gnn He3aKOHHbIx rlpl- CTPYKTypa pO3H4'qHOrO pbIHKa CKa3bIBaeTCH Ha cno- CMOB, MaCTb KOTOpbIX cepbe3HO TOpM034T YCHJHlEH 1o yJIy{- co6HOCTw iipaBBHTe)CbCTBeHHbIX opraHoB OTcJIe)KH4BaTb ICeHHIO Ka'eCTBa TOnlllBa. B TeX ciyiaqx, Korga pa3JI'IMHbIe noAo6Hyio HpaKTHKy. HeM 6Onbmie M14chO HC3aBHCHMbIX pbI- BHXgbl TOIJI1HBa no csoef4 3C4CeKTHBHOCTH1 COBCpIleHHO HO'-HbIX TOprOBLueB, TeM TpyCHee 6OpOTbCfl C ( JaJIbCH4HIKa- EmeCHTHIHbI AIRA nOJb3OBaTeJil (HaHpHMep, ripH cOHOCTaBjie- H4efMl H iiepeCOpTHiCefl. TaM, rge cymecTByCT pa3BCTBJiCHHaA 1 HH414 He3THI,1HPOBaHHoro H 3THAHpOBaHHOrO 6eH3HHa C oRH- 26 CeKTOp c6blTa He3TeCUpOAyKTOB H KaieCTBO TOHJ)IJBa Ta6nJMa 2. AeuBcTyIowe cneg14mmaK811 Ha 6eH3HH ui AaenbHoe ToNrilNo - npeAFinbHO AonyCTMbIe9 KOHLteHTpaLIMH Hpeaexbno aonycmumaA Tonnueo Copm Ilapamemp KoHAeHmpaquA HlpumeqaHuns BeH3HH 76 3THJBp. CBHHeU 0,17 r/n B ApMeHHrn-0,15 r/n c mapTa 2000 r. 93 9THAMp. CB1sHHe 0,37 r/n B ropoAax c HaceCieHHeM 93 3TH]IHp. CBHHCU 0,37 rAn 6onee 1 MJTH. 'eA. - Becb He3THJ. CBHHefl 0,013 r/n TOJIbKO He3THJHpOBaHHbTH. BcecopTa Cepa 0,1 Bec. % Bce copTa BeH30n - Hlpeeen He ycTaHonieH Bce copTa ApoMaTHKa - rpeglen He yCTaHoBJJeH ,LJH3eJIbHOe TOTInHHo THn I Cepa 0,2 Bec. % THn II Cepa 0,5 Bec. % HaKOBbIMH 0H), rOHbITKH BocHiperCHTcTBOBaTb HcrHOJb3OBa- CHHAKeHHIO BbI6poca 6eH3ona. B Ta6JI. 2 CBCeeHbl BoeCHHO HHIO 3TJIHnpOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa C nOMOH4bIO HaJIorOBoro CieIH4HIKaL1HH Ha TonJI4HBO, Lef1CTByKOH41e B perHoHe B Ha- 6peMeHH HIpOCTO Bbl3OByT CTpeMJieHHe MapKHpOBaTb JTHJIH- CToA11mee BpeMhI, 'TO o6JlerMaeT HX cOnOCTaBJTeHHe C peKo- pOBaHHblI 6eH3HH KaK He3TH1JHpOBaHHblA, HIOCKOIbKy giEl MeH4YeMbIMH HOpMaTHBaMH, KOTOpbIe IIPHBQ4BuLTC B Ta6Ji. 3THIH4pOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa CTOHMOCTb HlpOH3BOACTBa HJHT 4. B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT TOl HJIH HHOH cTpaHbl, HMeeT MeCTO BB03a HeHaMHOrO MeHbule, HeM ARA He3THJIHpOBaHHOrO. H p4Me'iaTenbHO, 'TO B rpy3avH 3TH pa3nIH'aM B Ha)JOrOBbIX Ta6rnuaa 3. Cnei.$nqwKaLu EBponeicKoro Coo3a - cTaBKax OTMeHHiH ei4e AO Toro, KaK 6buTo rIO)IHOCTbIO 3a- npeAeWbHO AonycTHMbIe KOHIAeHTpaBLUI ripemeHO HCHOJIb3OBaHHe 3THAHpOBaHHoro 6eH3HHa. 40 KOHI4a B Tex cJy'iaHix, Korga pa3sJHMHbIe BHAbI TOIHHBa orpaHH- Tonnuso Copm Hlapamemp 1999 e. 2000 a ,ieHHO B3aHMO3aMeHneMbl (HanpilMep, B cAy"ae 6eH3HHa C BeH3HH He3THRHpOB. CBHHeA 0,013 r/n 0,013 r/n pa3HbIMH OH), B03HHKaeT CTHMyJI BbigaBaTb HH3KOOKTaHO- 3THpOBaH. CBHHu 0,15 rAn 3anpeuWH Boe ToTLTHBO 3a 6eH3HH c 6onee BbICOKHIM OH, ecun nepecop- TH4y He yjjaeTCii o6HapyKnnTb. HeM 6onbmIe pa3HHUa B He- Bce copTa Cepa 0,05 BeC. % 0,015 Bec. % Hax, TeM CHIbHee Co6JIa3H. Bce copTa BeH30 5 o6. % 1 o6. % 3aMeHa HS3eCJbHorO TOHJTHBa 6eH3iHHoM H HaO6OpOT MO- Bce copTa ApoMaTHKa - 42 o6. % )KeT HMeTb MeCTO TOJIbKO fpH 3aMeHe 4aHHOFO aBTOMo6HYII MaLrnIHOH, pa6OTaiouAef Ha ;PYFOM TornIHBe. Pa3HHaia B Ka- ,HJI;3eIbHoe MoTopHbie nHTaAbHOH CTOHMOCTH aBTOMo6HJIea (KOTOpYIO HpHXOAHT- CH Orlna'HBaTb aBaHCOM) 6y4eT 4OMHHHpOBaTb Hag rno6on 3KOHOMHeh B CTOHMOCTH TOnJnHBa Ha 1 KM npo6era (KOTOpaA Ta6nnqa 4. PeKoMeHAyeMbwe cneLlH4rmKaLAMH Ha 6eH3aH u pacTArHBaeTCA Ha BeCb CpOK cJly)K6bI TpaHCnOpTHOrO cpe,- Al3enbHoe TOnnfBO - npeAGnbHo ApOnycTTMbe KOHLJeHTPa8IAH CTBa), ecJIH TO)IbKO UeHbI Ha TOHuiHBO He 6yayT CHAbHO OTAH- Tonnueo Copm HapaMemp 2005 . 2015 a. 'laTbC31. 3jjeCb HanioroBaA HOnIHTHKa MO)KeT CbIrpaTb 3Ha'-mH- BeH3HH Bce copTa CHHHeU 0,0 13 r/n 0,0 13 r/n Te)IbHy1O pOJIb. 06bHIHO HaJIor Ha 6eH3nHi BbilIe HaJIora Ha AH3e-nbHoe TOHJIHBO, H 3TO cIIoco6CTByeT yXoxiy OT 3TH)IHpO- Bce copTa BeH3ao 5 o6. % 2 o6. % BaHHOrO 6eH31Ha, HO 3a CIeT 9KO)IOrHMeCKOrO ywep6a B pe- Bce copTa Cepa Be3 H3MHeHHHf 0,03 Bec. % 3YJIbTaTe yBeIH'-eHHH BbI6pOCOB 3arpA3HHTejieH, o6yCnIoB- Hpeezen He JIeHHoro 1CH0o]b3OBaHHeM 4H3eJIbHOrO TonHJlBa. A76/80 ApoMaTHKa YCTaHOHJIeH 35 o6. % H-pegren He PEKOMEHAAI4HI no YJ1YLIWEHIIO KAHECTBA A91/93/95 ApOMaTHKa yCTaHoBneH 45 o6. % TonniJiBA B BYAIYIEM gaH3enbHOe MoTopHble fIpH BBeaeHHH 6o0ee )KeCTKHX Tpe6OBaHHII K Ka'eCTBy TOIIJIHBO copTa Cepa 0,2 Bec. % 0,05 Bec. % pasJI-IqHbIX BH4OB MOTOPHor'O TOHJIHBa H gLaHHOM pernoHie Hlpumenaue: BpeMsl H nOCTaTet4Hble 3HaMieHHH npeneio3 Ha 2015 r. flpHOpHTeT OTgaeTCn OTKa3y OT HCIOJlb3OBaHHH CBHH4a H n iiepeCMOTpy iepea HeCKoHbKO IeT. 27 HpnMeHeHHe 6onee qHCTblX MOTOpHbIX TOfIAHB gAS o6ecieqeHeM 'IHCTOTbl BO39yXa B CTpaHaX CpeaHea A3HH H KasKa3a HeKOTOpoe pacxoxKAeHnie Me)Ky9 3TH4MH HopMaTHBaMHl. Ha- rilgpE4pOBaHHio 6eH3ona. HlpegeahbHo ao0yCTHMaS KOHueHT- npHMep, B ApMeHHH 0orpaHH eHiH Ha cogep)KaHne CB4HHia B paiulsA cepbI B 6eH3aHe (0,03 Bec. % K 2015 r.) HpH3BaHa o6ec- 6eH3aHHe (0,15 r/n) BBOE4TC C mapTa 2000 r., a B ]py3an HC- iieC'IHTb a4xeKTTHBHy¶o pa6oTy KaTaiiHTHMeCK(Hx HelTpannl3a- noJIb3oBaHHe 3THJIEpOBaHHOrO 6eH3HHa 3anpenneHo C HHBa- TOpOB, KOTOpbie MOryT Hi 6ygyyT yCTaHaBEHHBaTbCH, KOJIb CKOpO p.i 2000 r. B BbMCOKOOKTaHOBOM 6eH3a4He AonycKaeTcA cpaB- CBHeHA IOJIHOCTbIO HcHe3HeT H3 6eH3HHa. Noini CyMMapHofi HHTeCJbHO BbICOKoe coAepKaHune CBHHIJa. apoMaTHKH4 B 2015 r. orpaHH4HBaeTCH BeCIH'-IHOHt 35 o6. % B 1n4H cpaBHeHHHi B Ta6n. 3 HpH4BOAHTCA HeKOTOpbie napa- HH3KooKTaHoBoM 6eH3HHe Hi 45 o6. % - B BbICOKOOKTaHO- MeTpbI ToHAH4Ba B CTpaHax EBponeh4cKoro Co0o3a Ha ABa He- BOM. HpOTHBKAHHbIlR CpOK BBegeHlAS HOBbIX HOpM gaeT HII3 pi4oga BpeMeHHr: go KoHiLa 1999 r. H Haql4HaA C AHBapH 2000 BpeMA gnA Ha)Ia)KHBaHHH HX pa6oTb H gnHa nepexoga OT p1- r. 3geCb iipege4TbHO AoIIyCT4mag KOHiUeHTpaI4HA CB4HHEa B 4iOpMHHra, KaK eCHHCTBeHHOrO CpegCTBa, K ApyrnM BapHaH- 6eH3aHe CoCTaBJiHeT 0,15 r/n Hi HOAHOCTbIO 3anpeEuaeTcs C TaM TexHoJIorHH. BBeCeHH4e 3THX orpaHnmeHnll no 6eH3ony, HaqaJia 2000 r. OrpaHH4meHA ri no 6eH3ony (5 o6. %) H cepe apomaTHKe H cepe K OAHOMY H TOMY)Ke roay flO3BOJIHT OrITH- (0,05 Bec. %) geC4CTByOT Ao KOHI4a 1999 r. Ha4HHaA C qHBa- M1H3HpOBaTb nIiaHbI Hfl3 no HHBeCTH4HHlqM. pg 2000 roga, Tpe6oBaHHJI K Ka'eCTBY TorinjiBa: no KoHueH- HpegenbHo gonyCTHlMas KOHueHTpaEAU4H cepbl B ga43eJIb- TpaiAHH cepbl B 6eH3Hne 3HaHE4TenbHo y)KeCToMa1OTC3H - HOM ToHJiHBe (0,05 Bec. %), HaMeMeHHaA Ha 2015 r., ananorwi- cHHl)KeHHe 6onee HeM BTpoe 11 no KOHUeHTpaglHH 6eH3ona Ha HopMe, BBegeHHOH B CIIA B 1993 r. H1 B CTpaHaX EBponetl- - BnriTepo, IIpHMCM BHepBbie BBOA1HTCH orpaHn4neHnne no CKoro Cnoa3a B 1996 r. HIpHHHTHle 3TO04 HOpMbI B EBpone 1H B cyMMapHofi apoMaTHlKe. HlpeAenbHo AOnYCTHM4aA KOHUeHT- CeBepHoa AMepHKe AOnDKHo 6blno IpEHBeCTH1 K yMeHbieI- paiEwA cepbl B AH3e)IbHOM TOHJIH4Be CHH4)KaeTCH Ha 30%. HH4IO BbI6poca CyJnb(paTHbix a3po3oiehe H3 HaH3eJIbHbIX ABi4ra- rIp14HH4MaA BO BHHMaHHe coo6paxKeHEsi OXpaHbl 3g0- Teiefl. HlepBoonepegHoai 3agaqea4 wAR pernloHa IleHTpanb- pOBbA H HHCTOTbI Bo3gyxa, a TaKowe CTpyKTypy ceKTopa c6bi- HoEi A3S4HH Hi KaBKa3a 6ygeT goeengeHe cogepcKaHnna Cepbl B Ta He(pTenpOgyKTOB B CTpaHax I|eHTpanbHOE4 A3H4H HE KaBKa- AH3eCIbHOM TonIIHBe go HOpMbi, AeACTByiowqeil B HacToawee 3a, paBHO KaK H4 TeHCeHL4HH B coceAHgx CTpaHaX, B gaHHOM BpeMAu ARA TonHmBa THrna 1 (0,2 Bec. %). PeKoMeHgyeMoe Bpe- HCChIeOBaHEHH4 peKoMeHAYLOTCA HOPMaTHBbl KaHeCTBa TOIIJ4- MSA BBeCeHHH1 cTaHgapTa B AeC4CTB4e - 2005 r. Ba, CHCTemaTH3HPOBaHHbie B Ta6n. 3. B cTpaHax, CTOJIKHyBLUHIIIXCH c cepbi3HbIMH npo6neMaMH PeKoMeHgyeTCA IlO1IHOCTbIO OTKa3aTbCg OT HICnoIb3oBa- 3arpAa3HeHnnq aTMoc4 epioro Bo03yxa, MOAKHO paCCMOTpeTb HHAH CB4HHIa K 2005 r. HopMbi no 6eH3ony YCTaHOBHeHbI Ha BBegeHHe 6onee )KeCTKHX HopM, qeM peKoMeHAyeTCTu B HaCTO- ypOBHe He BbIlle 5 o6. % B 2005 r. H He Bbliue 2 o6. % B 2015 Awefi pa6oTe. B 3TOM cMbic)e, OEHHM H3 B03MOXKeCToIeHHEe npeAena no RVP B 03OHO- poneflcKoro Co0m3a, B03MO)KHo, noTpe6yeTcfl HpH6erHyTb K onaCHbifH nepHfog. 28 BbIBONbI H PeKOMeHjagm4 G eJ[bIo Bbipa6oTKHl peKOMeHJLaLi4fl Ha 6nx4aailuee )eCSITHJIeTHe B HaCTOHWeM 4ccJIeAoBaHH H3y-4eHO HbIHemIHee COCTOSIHHe OCHOBHbIX 4naKTOpOB, TeCHO CBH3aHHbIx c o6ecneqeH4eM KaUeCT- Ba ropoxcKoro B03Ayxa: MOHHTOpHHr KaqeCTBa B03gyXa, 60pb6a C BbI6pocaMH aBTOMo6HJbHbIX ABHraTeieIC H Ka'eCTBo TOHIIHBa. Pe3yubTaTbl c6opa ii aHaIH3a gaHHbIX HoWIO epKHBalOT HIOTpe6HOCTb B 6o- nIee H4HTeHCHBHOH H CH4CTeMaTHMecKoH KOMfIHJHIJHH1 CTaTHCTHCeCKHx WaHHbIX 0 KOHLJeHTpaIJHHX 3arpA3- HHITeJIeHi aTMoccepbI, COCTaBe riapKOB aBToMo6HJIeC4, pe3yTIbTaTaX IIpOBepOK TpaHCrIOpTHbIX CpegCTB Ha HH- TeHCHLBHOCTb BbI6pOCOB, IIOTpe6JIeHHH TOIIJIHBa (BKiIIo'aa COpTHOCTb nIO OKTaHOBbIM xapaKTepHCT4KaM) 14 KaieCTBe B}HAOB TOImHBa, HMeCOMIUXCA Ha pblHKe. HoTpe6- 3gaH 34R¢eKTMBHbIM MeXaHH3M ripeTBOpeHHH B )KH3Hb 3TIHX HOCTb B TaKHX gaHHbIX flpH3HaCTCH CHCeIHaAMCTaMH H rocy- HOBbIX HOpM. OJHOBpeMeHHOe HpHHHTHe 3THX HOpM BO BCeM JapCTBeHHbIMH IH4HOBHMKaMH gaHHOro perHoHa IIOBCeMeCT- perHOHe CHH3HT BepO5THOCTb KOHTpa6aHgHOrO BBO3a He- HO. HaiM'IHC TaKMX gaHHbIx lO3Bom4no 6bl fpOBOJLHTb 6onee KaMeCTBeHHbIX HpOAyKTOB B Ty HAH HHyIO CTpaHy H YIIpOCTHT CTpOryIO olIeHKy HbIHermHIIX H 6yxywgHx niporpamm o6ecne- ocyWeCTBACeHHe KOHTpOnIA 3a Ka'ieCTBOM TOHAnE,Ba. 'IeHHA KaqecTBa Bo03ayxa rfyTeM BbIHBACeHMI4 oco6o oriaCHbIX HIpOTHBo3aKOHHOe BBegeHHCe Ao6aBOK 6eH3ona H apoMa- 3arp,q3HHTeCeH H KlpylHbLX HCTOMHHKOB 3arp1I3HeH1H (a B03- THKH B 6eH3HH BCTpeCaeCTCH HaMHoro pe>KeC, eM pa36aBCe- MOiKHO, H 6yyruHx HCTOWIHHKOB 3arpII3HeHHqs) Hi o6ecne,4e- HHe 6eH3HHa KePOCHHOM HA14 BBeAeHHe CBHHUHa H pyrHx HHEs B03MO)KHOCTH HPOBegeHHH 3KCHoMMMHoro aHaTa43a pa3- TiDKeJIbIx MeTaJI0OB B 6eH3HH. B OTHOLueHHH 6eH3oTa H apo- JIMIIHbIX BapH4aHTOB 6opb6bl C 3arp3H3HeHmeM Bo3)jyxa. MaTEKH B 6OnblflicTBe cAyiqaeB BfnOAHe gOCTaTOIHbIM 90oA- BaxoHyio pOIb )Ji rocyWapCTBeHHbix opraHOB HMeeT HaATH- )KeH 6blTb KOHTpOAb Ka'eCTBa Ha CTaaLHH He4TeCHepepa6OT- IMCe ,aOCTOBepHbIX CTaTHCTHHeCKHX JaHHbIX 0 riapKax aBTO- KM4. A )Jni TOrO HTO6bI 60pOTbCn c ao6aBAieHHeM KepOCHHa Mo6HAHe H UnOTpe6ieHH4 TOnnIHBa, HOCKOIbKy TaKoro pojaa HAH CBHHga, HpaBHTeCbCTBeHHbIM opraHaM B AaIHHOM perH- 14H(HOpMaaUHS cnoco6cTByeT IIpOBeCeHHIO pa3yMHOH4 HHBe- OHe HpHAeTCHq yKperIMTb CBOIO CHCTeMy MOHHTOpHHra Ka Ie- CTHI40HHOHI HO1IHTHKH KaK rocyAapCTBeHHbIM, TaK H 'IaCT- CTBa TOHIMBa. HblM CeKTOpOM. O'eHb 6blCTpbIH pOCT nlOTpe6JIeHHME AH3eSCbHOrO TOHJTH- HaCTorUee CmCCJIegOBaHHe noKa3aio, 'ITO HMeeTCH B03- Ba B TeCeHHe HocACjeyboMHx 10 AeT npHBeCeT K cyLeCTBeH- MOXKHOCTb ygaACeHHH1 CBHHLAa H3 6eH3HHa, HOBbmiCHHHA cpe,- HOMy UOBblimCHHIo KOHLIeHTpaLM14 TOHKOEMCiiepCHblX a3- Hero OKTaHOBOrO 'iHcia H yMeHbIueHI4IH KOHIUCHTpaEIHH 6eH- po3OAelf H NO, B aTMOc4Iepe. flocKOnbKy NO, ABsIBeTCS 30oa B gaHHOM perCHOHe K 2005 r. ripM He3Ha'HTeCIbHbIX npe4IuieCTBeHHHKOM 03OHa, YPOBHHH KoHUeHTpalUH14 03oHa 3aTpaTax CO CTOpOHbI roTpe6HTeCAH (IopAgiwa 0,01 JoLA. TaK)Ke MOryT BO3paCTH, B 3aBH4CHMOCTM OT MeTeOpOAOrH'Ie- CIlIA Ha HTp). OCo6blIf ynop B pe3yAbTaTax MCCAegOBaHHJ4 CKMX H gpyri7xH yCAOBHHi. BbI6pocbI H3CebHbX XIBHraTeCeH JqenaeTC$I Ha Heo6xogHMOCTH peryC4poBaHOBHM coCep)KaHHA 6yRyT, BepORTHO, B 6o)Abmeai CTeCieHM 3aBHCeTb OT TeXHMiC,e- 6eH3oAa H cyMMapHOH apoMaTHlKH< B 6eH3SHC B yCAOBM4AX CKoro COCTOAHHH aBTOMo6MH)4, 'ICM OT KaMeCTBa J1H3eCbHOrO OTKa3a OT HCfIOAb3OBaHHH1 CBHHUa nIplH OaHOBpeMeHHOM o6- TOHAMBa, 'ITO AHIIHHH14 pa3 rIo0IepKHBaeT Heo6xOJlHMOCTb iiJeM nOBbImCeHHH OKTaHOBbIX XapaKTepHCTHK. CAJLiyeT nog- peaAH3aiIHH4 344eKTMBHOf llOprpaMMbI T/T aBToMo6HAeCH. '-epKHyTb, 'ETO npOCToe 3anpeleHHeHC HC1nC)b3oBaHH431 CBHH- IAim 6onee 3(4eKTHBHOrO BBeAeHHMH B AeLHCTBMe KaK ua B 6eH3MHe 14 HIP1HAhTHe jpyrnix Mep BOBCe He o6A3aTeAbHO HbIHeIUHHX, TaK H 6ypyww4X HOpM, HOTpC6ylOTCBq MogepHn3a- IpEHBeCyT K 3al1HTe 3S0POBbH HaceAHHeHA, eCCHl He 6yxgeT CO- IMIIA o6Opy)4oBaHHlq H 06yIqeHHe nepCOHaAa. FOcyAapCTBeH- 29 RLpHMeHeCHe 6onee MHCTbIX MOTOpHbIX TOnlIBB AJIA o6ecneMeHn3 'IHCTOTbl B03Jyxa B CTpaHaX CpegineA A3qHI H KaBxa3a HbM OpraHaM, B03MO)KHO, 6ygeT He nOA CHJIY Hn14 He)KeJia- KaIeCTBO BO3Jyxa) B OLHOH HRn ABYX CTpaHaX 'epe3 oKa3a- TeIbHO peryJIHpOBaTb Bce acneKTbl MOHHTOpHHra 14 ripeTBO- Hi-He TexHHWecKoro cogefHCTBH1I H BbIJeJIeHHA y'e6HO-HHHoBa- peHHII B )KH3Hb gefHCTBYIOM4HX HOpM. Heo6xogwMo TtaTeJTb- UHOHHbIX 3af4MOB (YH3). Konb CKOpO TaKan nporpamma oKa- HO ipoaHanH3HpOBaTb pOib qaCTHoro CeKTOpa, B TOM qHc1ie )KeTCH yCneHlHoHa, e MO>KHO 6bio 6bl fiOpy6fi1pOBaTb B HGIO. ANR ycnelmHOa peanuH3aauir CTpaTCri1H o6eCneMeHHn Apyr4x CTpaHaX gaHHoro perHoHa. EcniH JJJIH BbiHOJIHHeHHA KaqeCTBa Bos3yxa HeO6XoUHMO B paMKax rOCygapCTBeHHbIX TeX HnH1 1HbIX MeponpIsTHt nOTpe6yeTCH flp14BJIeCeH14e op- CTpyKTyp go6HTbCa TeCHOH KOOPA14HaUi4H Me)KXiy ilplpO- raH143aiAHH1 H3 'IaCTHOFO CeKTOpa, MexsKyHapOgHan (4HHaHCO- gOOxpaHHbM14, TpaHCHOpTHbIM1 H 3HepreT14MqCcK4Mm4 MH- Baf KOpnOpaLgHR Fpynnbl opraHH3agnHn BceMHpHoro 6aHKa HHCTepCTBaMH, C OUHOI4 CTOpOHbl, 14 TaMo)KeHHbIMH 14 a14KUH3- Movia 6bl fP14HHATb B 3TOM yIaCT1e HyTeM BbigeCIeHHA 3aA- HbIMH cJIyxK6aMH1, floJImeC H JpyriTM1 BegoMCTBaMH, C MOB. B cnyiae, ecrn aHanH3 3KOHOMHNeCKOrO COCTOslIHHA He1- gpyroa. Tenepepa6aTbIBalotero ceKTopa noKaxKeT, 'ITO AJnI nprOH3- rpyrina opraHna3auHrf BceMnpHoro 6aHKa, B03MO)KHO, BOACTBa 6onee 'IHCTbIX BJIqOB MOTOpHOrO ToninHBa Moria 6bl IlOMOMb B pea)IH3agnH HeKOTOpbLX I3 peKOMeHgO- 3KOHOM'qeCKM nepCrieKT14BHOf4 MOCKeT OKa3aTbCsl peaJIH3a- BaHHbIX 3,qeCb Mep nIyTeM rpOBeAeHHH ri4nHOTHOrO TeCTHpO- 1J1 ripOCKTa MOgi441HKaLr41H CXeMbI HI3 np14 He3HaIHTeJIb- BaHHHl YCOBeplIheHCTBOBaHHbIX CHCTeM MOH14TOPH1Hra (Ha Ka- HbIX AOnOnHIHTeJIbHbIX HHBeCTHL4HAX, TO K BbIIOn-HeHH110 Ta- MeCTBO TOrnn4Ba, BbI6pOCbI aBTOMo6HJbHbIX gBnraTeneft 1Hn Koro npoeKTa TaK)Ke MO)KHO 6bulo 6bl HpHBJBCieb MODK. 30 CHH4COK 14COIOJIb30BaHHOI4 1TepaTYPb1 Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Research Program. 1997. Converting Uzbekistan Transportation Fleets to Natural Gas "Program Final Report, January 1997." Operation." Washington, D.C. Hughes, Gordon, and Magda Lovei, 1999. Economic Reform World Bank. 1997. "Elimination of Lead in Gasoline in Latin and Environmental Performance in Transition Economies. America and the Caribbean: Status Report, December 1997.' Technical Paper 446. Washington D.C.: World Bank. ESMAP Report No. 200/97EN. Washington, D.C. Kojima, Masami, and Eleodoro Mayorga-Alba, 1998. "Cleaner 1998. "Harmonization of Fuels Specifications in Transportation Fuels for Air Quality Management." Energy Latin America and the Caribbean." ESMAP Report No. Issues No. 13 (July). World Bank, Washington, D.C. 203/98EN. June. Washington, D.C. Lovei, Magda, ed. 1997. Phasing Out Lead from Gasoline in 2000a. "Air Quality Monitoring in Central Asia and Central and Eastern Europe. Health Issues, Feasibility, and the Caucasus: Report for the Regional Study on Cleaner Policies. World Bank: Washington D.C. [14MeeTcs pyccKxli Transportation Fuels for Urban Air Quality Improvement in nepeBoA B siepHOBOM BapHaHTe] Central Asia and the Caucasus." Washington, D.C. [4MmeeT- Lovei, Magda. 1998. Phasing Out Lead from Gasoline. cA pyCCKrlnr nepeBoA] Worldwide Experience and Policy Implications. Technical 2000b. "Vehicle Fleet Characterization in Central Paper 307. Washington D.C.: World Bank. Asia and the Caucasus: Report for the Regional Study on National Commitment Building Program to Phase Out Lead Cleaner Transportation Fuels for Urban Air Quality from Gasoline in Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan. Improvement in Central Asia and the Caucasus." Document ARH. CONF/BD.45. Prepared for the Fourth Washington, D.C. [MmeeTcH pyccKHl nepeBog] Ministerial Conference, Environment for Europe, Arhus, 2000c. "Downstream Petroleum Sector Analysis in Denmark, June 23-25. Central Asia and the Caucasus: Report for the Regional Pyadichev, E. 1999. Personal communication. Study on Cleaner Transportation Fuels for Urban Air Quality USTDA (U.S. Trade and Development Agency). 1997. Improvement in Central Asia and the Caucasus." "Technical, Economic, and Environmental Impact Study of Washington, D.C. [H4MeeTCA pyccKHil nepeBoq] 3 1 HlpwIioAKeHHe flpwloxeHne A. CogepiaHNe u aKTyanbHOCTb HccneAoOaHB S K COBMeCTHOH peaCIH3aUHH iporpaMMbi BceMHpHoro eAHHO Bce rionyeHHbIe pe3y)IbTaTbI H peKoMeHgaUHH. Hpo- 6aHKa > 6bmiH npHBJIe- B xoge peanii3aalHn HaCTo3HLuA1 r0porpaMMbi 6bmIH Bbl- leHbl 3aHHTepeC0BaHHbie CTOpOHbli npHpoooxpaHHofl, nOJIHeHbI TpH HccJiegoBaHHH: TpaHCHOpTHOti H He(4Tego6blBaiowea oTpacneHi ApMeHHH, MOHHrTOpHHr KaMecTBa BO3/yXa B baKy (Aaep6afig- A3ep6alpsKaHa, Lpy3au, Ka3aXcTaHa, Pecny6nnxH KblprbI3- )KaH) H TalHKeHTe (Y36ex'CcTaH), KOTOpbil rpOBoAHJI- cTaH, TaJpKHKHCTaHa, TypKMeHHCTaHa H Y36eKHCTaHa. B pe- Cq 4mpMon "AEA Technology" M COOTBCTCTBYIOWHMH aBIH3aSiHH iporpaMMbi rIPHHHMaJiH yyiacTHe TaKwe ripHpo- KoMHTeTaMH no rnApoMeTeoponorHH; gooxpaHHble, TpaHCIOpTHbIe H Hel5TeMo6bBalowHe* AHaJ1H3 aBToMo6HIbHbIx napKoB, BKHoMaH hlporoH0- BeCoMCTBa BCeX BOCbMH cTpaH-yMacTHHu. K fPOBegeH1Io Hbie RaHHbie no HoTpe6jieHHIO TornnHBa, KOTOpblH npo- aHaiH3a ripHBuIeKaBICb KaHa4CKHe H 6pHTaHCKHe KOHCyJIb- BOgHJICA MHHHCTepCTBOM OXpaHbI oKpy)Ka1oLeiAe4 cpe- TaHTbl, a TaKiKe MeCTHbie crieiHaJIHcTbl. gbi KaHaJbi H rpynnoH MCCTHbIX cHeUHaiaHcToB; Haaiano peaaI3Bi4HH rOirpaMMbI 6buio nono>KeHo B H1O- * AHan1H3 ceKTOpa c6blTa He4YTenpoAyKToB, KOTOpbIH He 1999 r. Ha ceMHHape B T6HiHCH (rpy3sna). Cnegyioruish pe- rpOBOAHAC5 COTPYqHHKaMH 'SNC-Lavalin*Comcept rmoHasabHbla ceMHHap, noCBHlgeHHbIl B OCHOBHOM Ise4rTene- Canada" H rpynnoHr MeeCTHbIX cnei4HamicToB. pepa6aTbiBaiouAefl npoMbIuHIneHHOCTH, COCToH0ICH B H0io6pe UTorOBbie OT'ITbl B HacTonwee BpeMS HaXOXVTCS Ha CTa- 1999 r. B Amixa6age (TypKMeHHcTaH). Ha KOHeA 2000 r. HaMe- XlHH nepeBoga Ha pyCCKHiH JS3bIK H B COOTBeTCTByIOIAee BpCM5 'eHO HTOrOBOe coBeixaHme, Ha KOTOpOM 6ygyT CBeAeHbl BO- 6yayT pa3ocJiaHbl BceM 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIM CTOpOHaM. HIporpaMMbi perHOHa)TbHbix CeMHHapOB OpraHH3auHOHHblfl peFHOHaJIbHbll ceMHHHap 10-11 11oHs 1999 r., T6HiHcH, rpy3Hs 10 HnOHrI 1999 r. Tema ,IiocaOmtUK BBe,qHHe rHBH KanaHAag3e rlpegcTaBneHine yMaCTHH1KOB H nOBeCTKH AHH cemHHapa MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHb1 oKpy)KaioLuefl cpeAbi rpy3HH BcTyrniTenbHble cIoBo 3ypa6 TaBapTKHnaA3e HpHBeTCTBeHHoe o6paxeHHe H KOMMeHTapHH K ceMHHapy. 1-4s 3aMecTHTenb MHHHCTpa oxpanbs oKpyxKaiowei 1ccne4oBaHHe <> H ero 3HaneHHe cpegbi rpy3HH Bo3BpaigeHHe K Pe3soinoAH, npHHATOA B AnMaTbl rHBH KanaHgag3e HanoMIsHaHHe o Pe3aofiogHis, npHHITOl4 B AnMaTbl, H o6 MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHbi oKpy)KaloIAea cpegbl rpy3HH HccneAoBaHHH <> KaK ocHoBe giiz HCCh1eXOBaHHHH <» rloBblbmeHHe KaMecTBa Bo3AyXa B ropogax Marga JIOBefl Flpo6neMbl 3arpB3HeHH51 ropogcKoro B03oyxa. Hogxogbl BceMHpHEsh 6aHK K CTpaTerHH H1 HpHOpHTeTbI. Hlpo6neMbi OTKa3a OT HCHoJIb3oBaHH1 3THIHPOBaHHoro 6eH3sMHa iH ero IoCICeXLCTBHI5. FIoTpe6HocTb B perHOHa)IbHO$i KoonepaUHH FlOBeCTKa JHU H 3ajalaH ceMIHHapa MapTHH 'DoRop 3agasmi H iemi ceMHHapa B CBeTe HccuiegoBaHHqs BceMHpHbi$1 6aHK <0MHcToe TOHnHBO>> 32 HP nnoKeHHe l OHIOHAI 1 999r. Tema aOKAaa3UK MnpoBbIe TeH4eHUHH B 40opMlpoBaHHH cneuHMIHKaUHf Ha MacaMH Koga3HMa pa3JH4HbIe BHAbI ToUJIHBa B yBH3Ke C BbI6pocaMH BceMHpHblmi 6aHKx aBToMo6lJbHbIxjLBHraTeIeH H1 KaBeCTBOM B03gyxa HlocneiHe pa3pa6oTKH B o6nacTn cneinlwxaniA Ha pa3nwIHbIe BHajbl TorLmTBa; B3a4MOCBH3b MeCKAy cieileu- 4lKaLuHiR Ha BH,lbl ToruiHsBa, Bbi6pocaMH aBToMo6HIbHbIx RBHBraTeJieiH H KaIeCTBOM pa3JlqHbie BHgOM Tonn4Ba CHCTeMa MOHHTOpHHra KaqecTBa ropogax perHOHa - Ha Dlapxag Ca6npoB npMmepe Y36eKHCTaHa FocygapCTBeHHblr KoMHTeT oxpaHbi ripHpo0bi COCTOHHHe CHcTeMbi MOHH1TOPHra - flpo6neMbl H Y36eKxcTaHa OCIO)KHeHH5 CpegCTBa TpaHCflopTa H KaqeCTBO ropogcKoro BO34yxa rper PauAayT H AileK POCTKOBCKHhl 3(S eKTHBHOCTb Cpe,CTB TpaHCHopTa, CTpyKTypa MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHbI oKpynKaioweH aBToMo6HJnbHoro napKa, BbI6pocbl aBToMo6HMbHbIx Cpeabi KaHagbl gBHraTeJeHl, Tpe6oBaHHH K Ka4eCTBY TOruIJHBa, flOAXOgbI K peuICeHHIO saaWH CHH)KeHHH YPOBHA BpeCHbHX BbI6pOCOB ABToMo6HJIHbIl flapK B pern-oHe - Ha npHmepe rpy3SHH 3Sna36apn 4apMHamsBHIH ABTOMo6HHbIHA napK B rpy3Hl - flocnegrHHe pa3pa6oTKH, MHHHCTepCTBO TpaHCHOpTa rpy3ain- nepcneKTHBbI Ha 6ygywee H HX BJIHIHHHe Ha Tpe60BaHHH K KaieCTBy TOIIJIHB I IHMOHR 1999 r. TeMa goKAaanUK PerHoHanbHble riPOrPaMMbI OTKa3a OT HCHOJIb3oBaHHIT CBHuga Ynma BeHACTeH B 6eH3nHe YnpaBneHle oxpaHbi oKpy)Kaionmefi cpegbi JJaHHI OnubT pa6OTbl qByCTOPOHH4X opraHOB B gene peanns3atAH per4HOHaIbHbIX nporpamm OTKa3a OT HCIOJIb3oBaHHM CBHHia B 6eH3nHe foBbIlmeHHe KaIeCTBa TonUIHBa B CTpaHaX JIaTHHCKOti MacaMH KOg3nMa AMepHlKH H KapH6cKoro 6acceflHa BCeMHpHbEif 6aHK flpaKlTmKa H onbIT, HaKonrieHHblH B geene oTKa3a OT HCnonb30BaHH5 3THJIHpOBaHHOro 6eH34Hia, H Bceo6'beMnouIoaa perHoHalibHan nporpamma OTKa3 OT mcnIOnb3oBaH4a CBHHAa B 6eH3HHe B gaHHOM pern-oHe Payq MypagoB flocnegHrAA HH4opMauiH3 o xoge pa6oTbl no OTKa3y OT KooPgHHaTop HaAHOHanbHoh riporpaMMbi HCHoAb3oBaHHH CBHHjBa B HCCJIegoBaHHH <>: Ycnexn, npo6neMbl, MaM6eT MaHHM6aeB owepegAHbie 3aag'm KoOPg-rHaTop ripOrPaMMbI OTKaSa OT HcnoJIb30BaHHH CBHHUa B 6en31Hne, Ka3aXcTaH Ko6HAx)KOH A6gyXaMHTOBH4 H6parHMoB, Y36eKHCTaH FIpoeKT HIPOOH no OTKa3Y OT HcHonJb3oBaHHM CBnnHa B Fpy3HH FHBH KanaHgaa3e MHHHCTepCTBO OXpaHbI OKpy)KaioieI cperbi rpy3SHH 33 HlpHMeHeHHe 6onee IHCTbIX MOTOpHbIX TOHnHB fiTH o6ecneMeHHA '{HCTOTbI BO3fyXa B CTpaHaX CpeAHeH A3HH H KaBKa3a 11 HoHN 1999 r. TeMa qOKAaO'UK CTaHxlapTbl Ha pa3JIHMHbie BHAbI TOnIHBa B perHoHe BuIaAHMHp ByAaTHHKOB CocToAxHHe CTaHgapTTH3agHHf pa3JIHHbIX BHAOB TorLIHBa B MexKrocyxlapcTBeHHbIii KOMHTeT no gaHHOM perwoHe, pa6oTa Me)KrocygapCTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa CTaHAaPTH3auHH, POCCHA H HRaBHOHa)IbHbIX OpraHOB CTaHgapTH3a14HH PerHoHanbnble npo6neMbI o6ecneteHHH Ka'eCTBa pa3JIW{HbIX flpegcTaBHTenH OT ApMeHHII-1, PecCiy6JIHKH Kbiprbl3CTaH BHAOB TOHJIHBBa H TaW)KHKHCTaHa MepOnIPrTHrnI H LjiaHbl, CBA3aHHbIe C OTKa3OM OT NCHoJIb3oBaHHA CBHHWa B 6eH3HHe H nOTpe6JIeHHeM TOnHJIBa riOBbiliLeHHOa 'II4CTOThI B CTpaHaX peronHa 06ecne'ieHH4e 'IHCTOTbI aTMoCc)epHOrO BO3gyXa 3a CMCT Marga iIoBe$i, MacaMfi KoA3nMa H MapTHH 'DoAop HCoImb3oBaHHA 6onee -IHCTbMX BIIAOB TonrIHBa BceM4pHbIii 6aHK floxpo6Hoe I43JIo)KeHme WTanoB peanIH3aaH perHoHaOIbHorO HCcflegoBaHHH, IIOTpe6HoCTH B lHHlopMaai-H H 4aHHbIx, BegOMCTBeHHaAl noMepAKKa, COTpyJHWeCTBO H opraHH3aUHOHHbIe npo6neMbl, 6yJlyi4iHe ceMHHapbi, flpHsBYMCeHme KOHcyJIbTaHTOB, omepegHbie 3agaMqH 3aKxnomeeHHe rHBH KanaHga43e MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHbi oKpy)KaioiLiefi cpegbi rpy3MH Perl4oHanbHbli4 ceMHHap 1o He4rTeriepepa6aTblBaiouleMy CeKTOpy 4-5 HoA6pa 1999 r., Amuxa6ag, TypKMeHHCTaH 4 HoA6pn 1999 r. TeMa aiozaciUK BCTyriHTeJIbHOe CJIOBO Xomurengbl Ba6aeB 3aMecTHTenb MHHHCTpa HeC4TY H ra3a, TypKMeHHCTaH OKiinag o perHoHa.IbHoM HccIIeqoBaHlH <>, nOBeCTKa JHI H OpraHH3al1HH cemlHapa BceMHpHbia 6aHK AoKJiag o xoge pa6oTbl no BbUioJIHeHHIo perHoHanbHoro MapTHH (Dogop Hcciie,aaHoAn BceMHpHbifa 6aHK Tpe6oBaHnHa K Ka-ieCTBy TonhrHBa aBToMo6HJbHbIX napKOB AlgeK POCTKOBCKHU gaHHoro perHoHa MHHHCTepCTBO oxpaHbl oKpy>Kaiou4ea Cpegbi KaHaqbi TexHonorwiecKxe ripoieccbi H ycoBCpuIIeHcTBoBaHHIA, ThKOH KnlapK HaripaBBJeHHbie Ha flOBbileHme KaMeCTBa TorinBa: SNC Lavalin*Comcept 06naropaxKUBaHne Hac)Tbi KoKcoBaHHH, pH43opMHHr H H3oMepH3aLuHH, go6aBJeHHCe TaHoJia B 6eH3arH AHaJIH3 COCTORHHH Hed3Tenepepa6aTbIBaioweA OTpacom 7A)KOH KJIapK B A3ep6af4g>KaHe, Ka3axcTaHe H Y36eKHcTaHe: SNC Lavalin*Comcept HIpegBapwTenbIHbie pCe3yibTaTbI 34 rIpHnioxKeHne 4 Hon6pA 1999 r. TeMa aOKAaatIUK O6cyx 35 rIpHMeHeHHe 6onee YHCTbIX MOTOpHblIX TODJTHB gnsi o6ecieMeHHeu 'HCTOTI B03oayxa B CTpaHax CpeaHeA A3HH H KaBKa3a flpbnoxeHNe B. BOAelkcTUe Bbw6pOCOB aBToMo6NnJbHbIX ABNraTenel Ha 3AOpOBbe rnouiei MeMy1IHapoAHbIf4 OIbIT CBHXeTe)IbCTBYeT 0 TOM, 'ITO, CJIeAHHe rOgbI IIOHBHJIHCb H nOCTOHIHHO yBeCJ2lHHBaIOTCH 3nlH- KaK HpaBHIIO, HaH6OJIbHIyIO yrpo3y AA 3AgOpOBbA niioAef4 B AeMHonorH4'eCKHe gaHHble o TOM, 'ITO BbIXJIOH r4H3eIbHbIX rOpogcKOai cpege HpeACTaBAJl1OT C6UHeq U mOHKOOucnepcHbLe gBllraTeflefl BbI3blBaeT cepbe3HyIO OnaCHOCTb 3a6oJIeBaHH3I a3po3oGnu. B CTpaHaX LJeHTpaJIbHOI A33HH H KaBKa3a CBHHeiL, paKoM. COeACHeHHA1 KOTOpOro pEHMmeHJHOTCsI JUl51 rOBbluleHCHR OKTa- Bce HPpoLeccbi ropeH1 H meaeTannyprHiecKHe nporieccbl, HOBOrO MHcJIa 6eH3nHa, ABJAeTCH OAHHM 143 caMbix OnaCHbIX a TaKoKe MHOrH4e TexHOJOrFHiecKKHe oHepauHH4 B rIpOMbIUi- 3arpH3HHTeJIefl, KOTOpblI4 Bce ewe HaXOgHT IHMpOKOe npHMe- IieHHOcTH COrIPOBo)KalOTCH BbI6pOCOM MeJIKOAHcnepCHbIX HeHHe. B03Aef4CTBixe CBHHqa Ha 'eJIOBeMeCKHf4 OpraHH3M 'aCTH4U B aTMOc4lepy. Aapo3on0r, nonagaiowue B BO3AYX He- InP4BOJEHT K ocna6neHHlo YMCTBeHHbIX cnoco6HOcTef4, B03- HOCpeACTBeHHO OT H4CTO'IHH4Ka Bbi6pOCOB, Ha3blBaIOTcH nep- HHKHOBeHHIo nOBegeHMecKHx 14 o6pa3oBaTeJIbHblX npo6neM, 6U'HbiMU. A3pO3OnlH, o6pa3OBaBmHecn B aTMoc4)epe, rJiaB- CHI4)KeHHIO HpOH3BOAH4TeCbHOCTH Tpyaa H rBehiHqeHH4IO pac- HbIM O6pa3OM B pe3ylbTaTe OKHcneHE4H ra3soB B BO3AyXe, XOXOB Ha MeCJ4uHHCKoe o6CIy>KH4BaHHe. Oco6eHHO BpeCHOC Ha3bIBaTOTCH OmOpUqHbUMU. OKCHEbl CepbI H a3OTa OTHOCHT- BO3geCHCTBHC CBHHeUj OKa3biBaeT Ha pa3BHBaioWHqflcH M03r H CA K COeJAEHeHH45M, CnOCo6CTBysowH14M O6pa3OBaHH4IO BTO- HepBHyIO CHCTeMy MaHoJIeTH14X ge'eTCI, B opraHH3Me KOTO- pH'MHbiX a9pO3oief4. pbIX 3aaepK(HBaeTCH 3HaI4HTeJIbHo 6Onbuiee KOJIH'ieCTBO )Jpyrt4MH 3arpH3HHlO14HMH Bbi6pOCaMH aBTOMo6HHnb- CBHHUa, weM B OpraHH43Me B3pOCJbIX iiogeH4. BpeAHoe BO3Je14- HbIX JEBHraTeIie14, Bo3WefHCTBYIOWH4MH Ha 3JtOpOBbe JnKoefH, CTBHe CBHHLIOBoro OTpaBJIeHHH Ha 6egHble CHOW HaceCJeHHA ABJIAIOTCA OKCHJi yrnepoga (CO), OKCHEAbI a3oTa (NO.), OKCH- BO3paCTaeT Hecopa3MepHO; HeMCIOIUHeCC gaHHbie HO3BOHIAHOT gbI cepbi (SO), 030H 1 TOKCH'IHbie npHiMeCH, B3BemileHHbIe B ripeAUIOHO)KHTb, 'ITO fPl4 HexBaTKe B OpraHH33Me Kenie3a H4 BO3)IyXe. KahbUHH H4HTeHCHBHOCTb norJIoWeHHH CBHH4Ha BO3paCTaeT, CO - ra3 6e3 ABeTa H 3aanaxa, nOgaBnKollOlH cnoco6- npHqieM KOJIHMeCTBO riorJToleHHOrO CBHHLa pe3KO yBeJIMlH- HOCTb KpOBH riepCHOCHTb KHGChOpOJ K opraHam H TKa- BaeTCH flpi He3aIIOJIHeHHOM KenygKe. B OTJIH4Me OT 7pyFH4X Ha1M, ABJTICTcA rIpOAyKTOM HenoiiHoro cropaHEii HCKO- 3arp.13HIlHOI4HX Bei4eCTB, CB14HeH He pa3naraeTcA H, eCfIH He naeMbIX BHJ4OB TOrInIHBa. OCHOBHbIM H4CTO'IHMKOM ripeKpaTHTb ero HCnOJIb3OBaHHe, OH 6yweT HenpepblBHO Ha- BbI6pOCOB CO B 6onbllmHHcTBe ropOAOBq JBJIIOTcH aB- KaHIHnBaTbCAI B OKpypKaioMef cpege. ToMo6lHAEH c 6eH3HHoBbIMH1 ABHraTeJ1MHl. Hlpll BbICO- CnexylorwHM nocne CBHHBa 3arpA3HHTeCheM (no TIDKec- KOM coCep)KaHH4H CO B BO3yXCe JHOJH, CTpaaaIOwHe TM ywep6a q)13I 3XOpOBbH ropo)KaH) 3BHHIAOTCS TOHKOgHC- XpOHH'IeCKOE4 cepgxleHof4 HeROCTaTOIHOCTbIO, MoryT nepcHbie a3po3on.4 Aapo3onEH C caCTHi4aMH pa3MepoM MeHee HicHbITbIBaTb 6o05b B rpyEH. 10 MKM (PM1o) H oco6eHHo c IaCTHUlaMH pa3MepoM MeHee SO. - ripOJYKT cropaHnRR cogepKauaero cepy 1CKoria- 2,5 MKM (PM2.5) OqeHb 'aCTO qBHIROTCA HpHqHHOfl pecnHpa- eMoro TOIIJIHBa. rlepHoH'MecKH Ha6nTogaeMble cny'iaH TOpHbIX HH4eKUHa, KOTOpbie npTHBOflHT K HOTepHM pa6o'e- BbICOKHX KOHueHTpauHa 4HOKCHTHa cepbi (SO2) 'ipeBa- ro BpeMeHH, rOCnIHTaJIH3aaHH H npe>KxeBpeMeHHlO4 CMepTH. Tbl ocna6neHHeM ferO'HHO4 4yHK4HH y aCTMaTHKOB H C'qHTaeTCII, 'ITO KpyIHbIe 'aCTHLbl cna6ee B03)eWhCTByIOT Ha o6ocTpeHieM peCrHipaTOpHbIX CHMflTOMOB y nlogea C 3xOpOBbe, H HO3TOMY H3MepeHHC coAep)KaHHA lfbl'IH HnTH peaKTHBHOfl Jb1XaTe]IbHOf4 CHCTeMOE4. SO2 cnoco6CTBy- CyMMapHoro coCep>KaHHl B3BemieHHbIx xiaCTHI (CBMI) MeHee eT o6pa3oBaHHIo BTOpH'IHbIX a3pO3oniei4 TaK KaK OH aKTyalIbHO, 'eM onpeAeneiH4e KOHLeHTpaUHH MeJIKHIX qac- BCTyraeT B peaKliHIo C ApyrHMH ripHMCCJIMH B aTMO- THL4. Bbl6poc a3po3onee4 C npOqyKTaMH cropaHRA, B TOM 'IHC- c4epe c o6pa3oBaHieM CyJb4aaTHbIX a3pO3oiet4, sAB- ne C HpOXYKTaMH cropaHHA )KHAKOrO TOrHJiBa B ABgraTejie nsnowHxcq -iaCTblO a3po3oJIea PM2.5. SO2 pacnpOCTpa- aBTOMO6HJIA, npHXOA;HTCq B OCHOBHOM Ha xlaCTH4bI PM2.5. HReTCH Ha 6onbln-He paCCTOJ1HH4 H cnoco6cTByeT BblxnonHble ra3bl J4H3CHbHb1X AJBHraTeneHl HBJISHOTCH CyygeCT- o6pa3oBaHnro KHCIOTHbIX AO)Kgef4, HaHOCRlWlHX Bpex BeHHbIM HCTOMHHKOM TaKHX BbI6pOCOB. 3To BbI3blBaeT OCO- paCTHTeJIbHOCTH (BKAioqaa neca H ceJIbcKOxO3sH4cT- 6yIO TpeBOry, nOCKOJIbKy HOTpe6HOCTb B MH3eJIbHOM TOrijiH- BeHHbIe KyJIbTypbl) H nonajaioijHX B ipecHOBOjHbiC Be B CTpaHax I-JeHTpanbHOai A3HH H KaBKa3a 6blCTpO 03epa. BO3paCTaCT BBHHyr nepeBogja 6onbLmerpy3Hblx aBToMo6HIei * NO - cnoco6cTByeT o6pa3OBaHHbo KHCJIOTHbIX ,O0K- c 6eH3-HHa Ha JlH3e)IbHoe TOiJIHBO, KOTOpOe aeT 6OnbmHyMo jCet n BTOpHqHbIX aapO3oJTet4, a TaKoKe ABJiACTCHr npexx- 3KOHOMHIO 3aTpaT Ha TOHJIHBO H CyL4eCTBeHHoe yBeCIHMe4HHC meCTBeHHHKOM O3OHa B HpH3eMHOM cioe aTMOC4Ie- 3KcnniyaTa4HOHHoro pecypca gBHraTenA. KpoMe TOrO, B no- pbl. )JHOKCHJ4 a3oTa (NO2), BbI6paCblBaeMbIf4 KaK 36 rIpwnoxeHHe A4H3eCbiHblMH, TaK H 6eH314HOBblMn ABiHraTeJIHMH, Bbl- TalOT ocna6fleHHe iieroMHolo 4YHKHJHH y fioeIVH fIpH 3bIBaeT ocia6ieHHe neroWlHO4 y-yHixu y aCTMaTHKOB. nlKo6blx 4r3HMeCKHX Harpy3Kax - OT He3HaMHTeIbHblIX 030H - o6pa3yeTca npH B3aHMOXLeaCTBHH NOx c op- Ao TSDKC)Th1X. rlO mepe noBbILWeHHH YPOBHR 4OXOOB raHH11ecKiHMH Coe4HHeHHH1MH, BCTynaIomHMH B IO- HC)Io BJiageCbI4eB IierKOBbIx aBToMo6HJieH Bo3pacTaeT, ToxHMH'IecKHe peaKUHH H o6birHo HMeHyeMbiMH )ICTy- TaK WITO nplH Oripege)ieHHbIX MeTeOpOJIOrHMeCKHX ycuio- 4iHe opraHHMecKHe coeCHH4HHH (IOC). K HX IH4CJIy BH3JX 030H Mo)KeT CTaTb cepbeSHoH npo6jieMo%. OTHOC3ITCJi aIIbgerHabi, one4HHbl H apomaTHwecKHe yr- * K MHcny TOKCHWHbIX Bbl6poCOB n3 aBToMo6HJIbHbIx JIeBOgOpObI c He MeHee HeM gWyMH aJIKHJbHbiMH rpyri- gBHraTed)eH OTHOCATCH 6eH3O0n, mHoroncepHan apoMa- iiaMH, flpHteM Bce 3TH coeCXHHeHHR IIB)J3IOTCI npipe;ge- THKa, 6yTaJLHeH- 1,3 (MOuIHbIl KaHLeporeH) H aIbgerH- CTBeHHHKaMH 03oHa. 030H HBJIMeTCRf npH'IHHOf Abl. BccMHpHaI opraHH3aUHa 33paBooxpaHeHHH BKnIIo- nOHBjIeHHH 4qOTOJcHMHmecKoro cMora, H ero CBH3blBaIOT 'nuia aiieTaIbJAerHg, 6eH3on, BbIXJIOriHbIe ra3bl C flepeXOgHbIMH HBJIeHHJiMH4 B gbiXaTeIbHOH CHCTeMe AH3eJIbHbIX ABHraTejien H MHOrOnCepHyio apOMaTHXy B qenoBeKa. 113 iHcuia 3aper1HCTpHpOBaHHbIX rFaKTOB CrIHCOK KaHUepOreHOB H YTBepAHIia HX npeHeCIbHO AO- BpeD;Horo BO3geCHCTBHM O3OHa CaMbIM Cepbe3HbIM C111- flyCTHMbie KOHUCHTpaHE1H B oKpy>KaioiLeH cpexe. 37 HpnMeHeHHe 6onee MHCTbIX MOTOpHbiX TOHIHIIB AniH o6ecniemeHai 'IMCTOTbl Bo3agyXa B CTpaHax CpeAiea A3HH H KaBKa3a flpnnoxeHne C. MOHATOpNHr KaqecTBa Bo3AyXa B BaKy (A3ep6ainaH) U TawKeHTe (Y36eKIcTaH) JAHHbIE, COEPAHHblE C nlOMOLLIbIO BbIIIBHTb 3Ty 3aKOHOMepHOCTb He i1peACTasB)IeTCH B03- ABTOMATUHECKUX flPObOOT5OPHUKOB MO>KHbIM. B BAKY (A3EP5AAWKAH) )JaHHbie co6wpann B baKy Ha OAHOM M3 Ha6JiioThaTenb- HbIX rOCTOB, HaxOAflIIHxCA B BegeHHH KoMMTeTa no r14r1po- Ta6inLa C- 1. CBOAHbIe cTamCTHmecKe AaHHbie no BaKy MeTeOpOJIorHM. HIpoBeAeHMe MOH14TOPMHra B nyHKTe, Ha KO- N02, Co, 03, A3po3onu TOpOM pa3BepHyTO TaKA(e H1 MeCTHOe 03SHMeTpHW1eCKOe MC2/M3 M2/M3 MKX/M3 (nbnb), MKS/M3 o6opyAoBaHHe, gaBanO BO3MO)KHOCTb cpaBHMBaTb gaaHHble, CpeaHee noJIn eHHbIe c MCcnOIb3OBaHHeM o6eux MeTOgHK. )IaHHbi 3HaqeHM4e 88 2 73 38 Ha6JlogaTeJIbHbflM IOCT 6bm11 pacnOIO0>KeH B )KHMJoM paHlOHe 3HaHeHoe SHanmHH B BaKy (TaK Ha3bIBaeMoM <>) npH6ns31Tenb- TeqeHHe 1 iaca 212 5,2 95 124 HO B 5 meTpax OT KpaH wOporn H B 15 meTpax OT OCM4 goporF. MaKcHManbHoe Co6paHHboe AaHHbie rpa4lMMecKH ripe)CTaBBhIeHbI Ha pnc. C- I 3HaHeHHe B H CMCTeMaTM3SpOBaHbl B Ta6n. C-1. TeeMHHe 8 'acoB 176 4,2 88 94 43 rpa4nneCKoro ipeHCTaBBeHIH4 gaHHbIX cnegyeT, 'ITO MaKcxManbHoe MHaIeHme B rPOipooIKeHM MCCccIeAOBaHM1H YPOBHM BCeX 3arp33HHTeuiei 3a CyTKH 121 2,9 83 64 H3MeHH1JIMCb BeCbMa CymgeCTBeHHO. CnegyeT OTMeTHTb, WITO C I7puMeqaHue: MKr/M3_ MHKporpaMMOB Ha Ky6HHeCKHHf MeTp; Mr/M' flOMOMbIO CMCTeMbI MOHHTOpHHra, KOTOpaS B HaCTOAWee - MHnJMrpaMMOB Ha Ky6mHeCKmfH MeTp BpeMH MCHOJTb3yeTCA KoMHTeTOM nO rMFpOMeTeOpoJiorMH, PNc. C- 1 . AaHHbae no Ka4ecTmy osonyxa Ani BaKy (A3ep6aigWaH) 250 6 200 - 6 A 4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 0 150 -.Apon z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~AT/pM CyToKJl CO CO -CO 0 0 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00 00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00 00 09/07/99 10/07/99 11/07/99 12/07/99 13/07/99 14/07/99 15/07/99 16/07/99 17/07/99 18/07/99 19/07/99 AaTa/Bpemsi CyrOK 38 Iflpwio*eHne AHan14 3THX JgaHHbIX nOKa3bIBaeT, 'ITO OpUCHTHpOBOH- BO BpeMA TpaHCfOPTHPOBKH B Y36eKHcTaH 6bIml IIOBpe>K- HbIe caH4TapHO-rHrHeHwiecKHe HOpMaTHBbi B03 6bullrnpe- JgH. Kpome Toro, B pe3y)ibTaTeC acTbIx riepepbIBOB B 3JIeKT- BbimueHbl B XBYX cny-ianx: ini NO2, xorgaa MaKCHMmaIbHa3 pOcHa6AKeHHH Ha6JogaTeJIbHoro ITocTa o6i,bm co6paHHblx 'acOBanf yCpegHCHHaA KOHUeHTpaiUHH AocTrana 212 MHKpO- gaHHbIX ('HcIo JLOCTOBepHbIX 3KcriepH MeHTa3hbHbIX ToHeK) rpaMMOB Ha Ky61iecKu4 MeTp (MKr/MD), B TO BpeMH KaK inH jpyrax 3arpn3HHTeJleH oKa3aaiC3I 3HaMhlTeJIbHO MeHbme, HOpMaTHBHoe 3HaMeHIIe cOcTaBrnSeT 200 MKr/M3. B xogega H- HeM 9TO HMeJIo MeCTO BO BpeMA HCCheIRCOBaHHH B BaKy. B Tex HOrO HCCAneAOBaHHH HH 1o OJHOMY 13 gpyrux 3arPH3HHTeCJefI cjiyqaAx, Korja 143-3a OTKJIOoeHH4 3jieKTpO3HeprU4H aHaIIi- He 6bu1O o6HapyKeHo flpeBbIH1CeHHH HOpMaTHBHbIX 3HaMe- 3aTOp 6e3ageicTBOBan, cOOTBeTcTByIOHUge 3KcnepH4MeHTaJIb- HUU111 B03. Hbie TOHKU nIpH BbMi4ciCeHHH cpeC/HIX U cTaTHCTHqecKHx 3Ha'-eHl4lA He y'fHTbIBaJIHcb. Co6paHHb ICqaHHbie rpa(H4'ec- AAHHbIE, CO5PAHHbIE C nOMOLALbIO ABTOMATUHIECKUX nPOSOOTBOPHIKOB B TAWKEHTE (Y3BEKHCTAH) TS1a6nmLIa C-2. CBOAHIIe cTaTUCTHeCKUe AaHHbIe KaK H B ciyliae npOBegeHUH MOH14TOPI1Hra B BaKy, aBTO- no TawKeHTY MaTI4'eCKHe aHaJIIl3aTOpbI B TaunmKeHTe 6bvrn YCTaHOBJIeHbi Ha Ha6JiJogaTeJIbHoM rlOCTY COBMeCTHO c o6opyAOBaHueM NO2 CO 03 KoMHTeTa iio mgpome'eoponormi. B KaqecTBe IIOCTa Ha- MKI2/M M2/M MK2/M3 6rnO,JeHri4 6bmI BbI6paH TOT, KOTOpblU B ripoiLecce MOHHTO- CpextHee 3Ha'eHHe 90 4,2 72 px-Hra gaCT, KaKx ipegrnoJIaraJIOcb, HaHBblcIcIe 3Ha'ICHHH KOH- MaKcHManbHoe 3Ha'eHHe ueHTpaiAilj4 'po6)ieMHIX 3arPAHl4Tejief OCT 6bI B TeMqHHe' I aca 250 13,9 218 14CHTpaLLHH npO6neMHblx 3arpn3HHTeJIet. 3TOT IIOCT 6bl) urHaBO 3aeH MaxcH4ma)mnoe 3Ha'ICHHC pacrloJIoCKeH Ha O)KHBJeHHOM CepeKpeCTTKe B iIeHTpe ropoJLa. B TCeHHHe 8 8iacoB 171 8,7 162 JJaHHbIX rO KOHjeHTpaUHH a3pO3OJIefu He HMeeTC31, HOCKOIb- MaKciManbHoe 3HaCeHHe Ky aHaJII3aTOp,l pegHa3HaleHHbIPl VIIA c6opa 3T4X JaaHHbIx, 3a CyTKH 109 5,7 75 PNC. C-2. AaHHbe no KaHecTBy BO3A4XW An4 TawKeHTa (Y36eKMCTaH) 300 1 6 250 1 2 200- o 10 I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0O Z 150- 5 00 v ~~~2 0 V~ 0 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 30/07/99 31/07/99 01/08/99 02/08/99 03/08/99 04/08/99 05/08/99 06/08/99 07/08/99 AaTa/BpeMu cyyroK 39 rpHMeHeHHe 6onee qHCTMX MOTOpHbIX TOnI]HB AnsI o6ecne'eHms 4HCTOTbl B03Ayxa B CTpaHaX CpegHefi A3HH H KaBKa3a KH fipe,CTaBnBeHbl Ha pHc. C-2. B Ta6ji. C-2 IIpHBO,HTCAI CBO,- AHaJI43 3THX gaHHbiX rIOKa3bIBaeT, ITO OpmeHTHpOBOq- Hbie CTaTICTHIeCKHe AaHHbie. KaK H B cJiyqae Jnq BaKy, gaH- HbIe caHHTapHO-rHrHeHHmIecKHe HopMaTHBbi B03 6bmiH npe- Hbie no TaLnKeHTy CBMAeTeflbCTByIOT 0 TOM, 'ITO B xoge HccJie- BbiifeHbl B 7 cAyqaAix gRq NO2 H B 15 ciiyaqx An3i O3OHa. 9OBaHHM YPOBHM BceX 3aFPA3HHTenieif H3MeH5lJIHCb BeCbMa MaKcHMaJlbHaH 3aperHCTPPOBaHHa acOBaiI ycpeHiHeHHaH cyigecTBeHHO. KOHUeHTpaAHU4 cOcTaBHna 250 MKr/M' (npOTHB HopMaTHBH0- Puc. C-3. ConocTaBneHHe CyToqHbIX AaHHbIX no NO2 B 5aKy. 150 S 100 -- o Puc. ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0-4 -OlCaleM CyTHHJ Ca i no- CO BD 6 4- 2 Fvg | rlwApoMeT 1 -: *~~~~~~~~~~~AEA CD 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) CD 0 0) 0 0 i: l r; .i ,z r- r , ._4 0 0 0 0 0 0D 0 0 0) 0) ow C') z aU CO N) rv N LO (D i R S J,aTa Puc. C-5. ConocTaaneHne cyrO4HIbX AaHHbix no C3pO SaKyM B Baky. 250 - 20 0E 50 W 1*, SAEA 0 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) CY) 0) 0 CY) 0) 0) 0) 0 C) C C) C ) 0C 00) 0 0D 0 0 0 0Y) CD co) LO) D A~aTa 400 HpHnorceHHe ro 3HaB'eHHM B 200 MKr/M3). HIpeBbIrneHHIa no MaKcHMaJIbHO4 coHocTaBJIAIoTcH c gaHHbIMH, IIoJryTeHHbIMH MeCTHbIMH Ko- 3aperHCTpHIpOBaHHOf ycpegHeHHot KOHLeHTpa&HH o3oHa MHTeTaMH Ho r}HpOMeTeOPOJIOFHH Ha OAHHX H Tex Ke Ha- 3a 8 'acoB COCTaBHJIH 162 MKr/M3 rIpOTHB HopMaTHBHoro 6niogaTenbHbIX IIOCTaX B TeCeHHe TOFO AKe nepnoga BpeMeHH. 3HaqeHHI4 B 120 MKr/M3. ConOCTaBJIeHHe pe3y)ibTaTOB no N02, npegocTaBneH- B xoge IPOBCegHHoro HCCiie,OBaHHH HopMaTHBHbIC 3Ha- HblX KOMHTeTOM Ho rmpomeTeopowrim H (4HpMOfi AEA, MeHHi" no CO He 6bIJlH npeBbHuIeHbI, XOTH B HeCKO)IbKHX cny- noKa3bIBaeT, YTO corIiacHe LaBHHbIX KoJIe6JieTCH OT OMeHb 'aax MaKcHMaJIbHaH KOHUeHTpaBi4H (8,7 Mr/M3) npn46nTHKa- 6nH3Koro coBnageHHq (10 H4OnjI) Ao ABynpaTHoro pacxoK,ge- niacb K CKOJIb35HiijMy cpegHeMy rioporOBOMy 3HaMeHHIO 3a 8 H1H4 (15 HoIJIH). ConocTaBneHime KOHUeHTpamIHa CO H a3po- macOB, KOTOpoe CoCTaBmIeT 10 MHJnIJIHrpaMMOB Ha xy6Hwec- 3oGieU4 oKa3aJJoCb 3aTPYAHHTeCTbHbIM H3-3a TOrO, YTO pe3yfIb- KHHf MeTp (Mr/M3). TaTbl, floJIy'eHHbIe OT KoMUTeTa no rHgpoMeTeopoJIormH, HaXOA5HTCH Ha nopore JyBCTBHTeCJbHOCTH rIpHMCeHBIIMeAcH COnlOCTABJlEHUE AAHHbIX ainnapaTypbl, B TO BpeMA KaK nipH6opbI, HCrIIO1b3OBaBniHeCC Ha pvc. C-3-C-5 ,IaHHbie, co6paHHbxe 4mpMOU "AEA dpHpMOi AEA, ropa3go 'IyBCTBHTeJIbHee K HH3KHM KOHUeH- Technology" c floMoIlJbio aBToMaTHiCeCKHx aHarnn3aTopoB, Tpai4xAM. 41 flpHMeHeHHe 6onee MHCTbIX MOTOpHblX TOHnIHB Alin O6eCflleMHI{H qHCTOTbl B03yXa B CTpaHaX CpexHeie A3FH H KaBxa3a nlpnnoxeHie D. Ka4ecTBo MOTOPHOrO TonNHBa U MOM414NLHpOBaHHOe TOnHNBO B HaCTO5l1ICeM flpwioxeeHHH IlpHBOMHTCA pAR coo6paKe- BbI6pOca 6eH3ona C BblXJIOHHbIMH ra3aMH. C TOMKH 3peHHH HH, KOTopbie ciiegoBanio 6bl "MeCTb npn pacCMOTpeHHH 3KOHOMHKH HrI3, BbirojHee orpaHWIHBaTb KOH4eHTpaIHIO npo6neMbI Ka'ecTBa TonnHBa, H KJlOMeBbIx IIPHHLIHHOB pa3- CO6CTBeHHo 6eH3ona, 'jeM cyMMapHoa apoMaTHKH. OrpaHH- pa6oTKH Tpe6OBaHHI4 K KwMeCTBY TOHnIHBa. leHHe cyMMapHoA apoMaTHKH, o6pa3yloireicH B peaKTope CoegHHeHHH CBHHI4a C gaBHHX nop BBOqRT B 6eH3HH pH(4OpMHHra, HeraTHBIo CKa>KeTCH Ha 3KOHOMHKe HH3, Ana HOBbIlUeHHA ero oKTaHoBoro MHcia H o6ecne'eHHA flOCKO)IbKy no6o'mHbIM lPOMYKToM rIoJIyIeHCHH apoMaTHKH iLJIaBHOrO ropemHH TorLnIHBa. OTKa3 OT 3THMipOBaHmH 6eH3H- HBJHieTC3 Bogopog, Heo6xoXLHMbil gnR OMHCTKH 6eH3nHa H Ha flpeACTaBnHieT co6oft rlepBbIfl mar Ha nyTTH K nOBbIIneHrnO gH3eiIbHorO TOnulMBa OT CepbI. CaMbIM geileBbIM HCTOMHH- KaHeCTBa MOTOPHorOITorTOiMBa. MHoroJieTHHfl onbIT y6eAH- KOM Bogopoxa ABIAHIOTCH YCTaHOBKH pH(popMHHra. TeiIbHO CBMAeTeCJbCTByCT 0 TOM, 'TO ygaJieHHC CBHHga H3 rlpegLmeCTBeHHKaMH 03OHaHBJIAIOTCR apoMaTHMeCKHe 6eH3nHa AO)DKHO JPOBOXJHTbCS B paMKax 6onee UHpoKoH yrne1ioegopogbI C ABYMA H 6onee aJIKHHbHbIMH 3aMeCTHTeCji- riporpaMMbiInoBbliueHaH Ka'ecTBa TonHJIBa m peaBJH3ajH4 MH. HccneaoBaaH4e, HipoBegHHoe B He4)Tenepepa6aTblBaio- CHCTeMHoro norixoga K ripo6neMe 3arps3HeHHr Bo03yxa. r4eH H aBTOMo6HYIbHOH rpOMbIlHiJeHHOCTH CilA, noroKaao, TaKofl BbIBOM O6ycnOBneH TeM, 'ITO Beu4eCTBa, KOTOpbIe npH- OAHaKO, 'ITO J)I aBTOMO6HlieR C KaTaIHTH'ieCKHMH4Mie HflTpa- XOAEHTCR BBOAMTb B 6eH3SHH ARH KOMneHcaCi4H CHHEKeHH4 JIH3aTOpaMH CHH)KeHHle goJIH apoMaTHKH B 6eH3aHHe C 45 go OKTaHoBoro 'mEcna B pe3ynibTaTe OTKa3a OT T3C, caMH oKa3bI- 20% He HOBJIHRJIO Ha KOHleHTpag1HIo o3oHa B HpHS3eMHOM BalOT BpelHoe BO3MeHCTBHe Ha oKpyxKaiotuyio cpegy. ECTb cioe BO3gyXa (<»). 3KOHOMHImHbIM CHoco6oM TaIOILHX B 6onee TKeCTKOM pe)KHMe) H MHoroIAepHaBq apoMa- CHH)KCHHA MaCCbI npegIlueCTBeHHUKOB 03oHa, B IHCIIO KOTO- TH4Ka (C YCTaHOBOK KaTaJIHTH14eCKOrO KpeKHHra). EmW rio- pbIX BXO4HT OAe(4EHHbl, IIBJIIeTCII OrpaHwHIeHHe hIeTyeCTH TeHiHanIbHa3n OraCHOCTb - TaKKC ripeIIIeCTBeHHHKH O3OHa, 6eH3HHa. CoKpaiweHme goJIH JIrKHx OJie43HHOB (KaK pe3yiib- KaK one4iHmbi (C YCTaHOBOK KaTaJIHTHIIeCKOrO KpeKHHra), TaT yMeHbueHHAl gaBneHHA napoB no PeMigy) cepbe3Ho BaEH- DH- H Tpi4anKHnapomaTHKa (c YCTaHOBOK pH44OpMHHra, pa- ReT Ha o6pa3oBaHi4e O3OHa B HpH3eMHOM cJIoe Bo3gyxa. 6OTalorgaEx B 6onee )K&CTKOM pe)KHMe) Hf NOx (B pe3ynbTaTe OicCHreHaTbI o6ecneMHBaIoT 6onee rioinHoe cropaHHe CrOpaHH$I 6eH3E{Ha C UOBbiiueHHbIM cogep)KaHEleM apoMa- 6eH3HHa, HTO npHBOMHT K yMCHbreHHHIO BbI6pOCOB CO H THKH4 H4 OjieCHHOB, oco6eHHo B OTCYTCTBHe KaTaJIH4TH'eCKH4X yrTeJoCopoPoB H3 aBToMo6HJIbHbIx ABHraTeCICH, He o6opygo- Het4TpaJIH3aTOpOB). Ia3-3a npeo6nagaHmH3 TemiepaTypHoii BaHHbIX gaT'HEaMH KHClIOpoga. KpoMe TOrO, OHH geflCTBYIOT HHBepcECH H 6onbmLoro 'IHcJIa COJIHe'HbIX gHef, a TaK)Ke B pe- KaK pa36aBHETenb, CHiiKaa KOH1eHTpaiAiHO apOMaTHKH, one- 3yJIbTaTe pe3Koro HOBbIIeHHRA HHTeHCHBHOCTH1 AOPO)KHoro 4JHHOB H1 6eH3ona B 6eH3HHe. OKcHreHaTbI o6nagaaoT O'eHb ABH)KeHHR Cepbe3Hofl npo6neMoh BO MHorH4x ropogax gaH- BbICOKHMH OKTaHOBbIMH mHCJIaMH, 'ITO O6ner'IaeT OTKa3 OT Horo perHona Mo)KeT CTaTb 030H. B HCKOTOpbIX ropogax (B T3C. flo 3TOHf HpH'qHHe c 70-x rr. B 6eH3H4H HaiaJIH BBOJHTb TOM imHCJIe B TaUIKeHTe) yxKe Ha6nioganaH nOlBAieHHe (bOTOXH- npOCTbIC 34)HpbI H4 CnHpTbl. CaMbiM pacripOCTpaHCHHbIM M3 MHiqeCKorO CMora. B xoge Mo4ePHH3ag4UHH Hl13 B HanpaBile- HPOCTbIX 3aHpOB, go6aBnneMbIx B 6eH3rH, AIBJIHeTCH MTB3, HHH OTKa3a OT HCIHIOb3OBaHHRI CBHHLa B 6eH3Hne 3KOHO- KOTOpbIEf H1MeeT CpaBHHTelubHO HH13KOe XaBJIeHHe napoB no MH'meCKH BblrO4HO 6ygeT OgHOBpeMeHHO peumlaTb BOflpOCbl Pe$igy (RVP) H BbICOKOe OKTaHOBOe 'IHC1IO H4, KaK npaBHInO, MoAH4)HIJHpoBaHHi 6eH3EHa, gnR Toro 'lTo6bI oHTHMH43HpO- 03H1pyeTCR B KoiHiqeCTBe go 15 o6. %. HegoCTaTKoM oKCH1re- BaTb H1HBeCTHEH4OHHbIe nniaHbI Hfl3. HaTOB ABuHeTCH HX cMeHIH4BaeMoCTb C BOA0I-. He TaK gaBHO BeH3On HaxOgHTCR B (pOKyce pacTyIuero BHHMaHHA BO B CiIIA BO3HHlKJ1H onaceHnHa B CBR3H C TeM, 'ITO o6Hapy)KH4- BCeM MHpe. ABToMo6HilH c 6eH3HHOBbIMH ABHramTCIMHf HB- JIOCb 3arpl3HeHHe rpyHTOBbaX BOA 3(pHpOM (MTBS), nonaAa- IIRIOTCJI OCHOBHbIM HCTO'IHHKOM 6eH3ona, fionagaioigero B KOI4HM B HHX H3 gbIp3lBbIX flOA3eMHbIX pe3epByapOB. BbIAB- BO3MyX MBYMA HyTRMH: 3a C'WT HCriapeHHR H BbI6poCa Hecro- )ieHHbIfl YPOBeHb 3arpR3HeHEHR oKa3aJICA 3HaMlHTeAbHO H4)Ke peBiinero 6eH3ona C BbIXIOnHbIMH ra3aMM H B pe3ynibTaTe TOrO, KOTOpblH TOKcHKoJIoriH IpH3HaniH 4O11YCTHMbIM nocne HienonHoro cropaHHR aJIKHn6eH3OHoB, npHWICM Ha 6eH3onI, OIbITOB Ha )KHBOTHbIX. MTB3, ogHaKo, H4MeeT O'eHb HH3KHH cogepAca(ai4iHc B 6eH3rfHe, rHpXOJHTCR B 10-20 pa3 6OnbImue nopor 'IyBCTBHTeIbHOCTHf no 3anaxy H4 BKyCy; ero o6Hapy- BbI6pOCOB, 'eM Ha HenonHoe cropaHme aJIKHA6eH3OJIOB. Ka- )KHBaIOT B KOHiAeHTpaJHHRx, KOTOpble ropa3so HHDKe noporo- TanHTH'IeCKHe HefiTpanH3aTopbI cHoco6CTByIOT cHH4)KeHHIo BbIX 3HaHeHHH (c TOK'IK 3peHHRJ1 yrpo3bI 3aopOBblO), Ha 'TO 42 rpHnoxceHHe )Ka)IyIOTCH rIOTpe6HTeJIH. Emig OJgHOH aJIbTepHaTHBOflHBJIA- iipeXCTaBBIHeT co6ofl BpCMeHHbll 3xg; eC ge3aKTHBHpyioiWee eTcA 3TaHOJ, HO HO fpHlRHHe ero JOpOrOBH3HbI B CeBepHofl BO3geWCTBHe Ha KaTaJIH3aTOp B 3HaMHTeCJbHOC! CTeneHH o6pa- AMepnxe, gwiq HCHOhb3oBaHHH ero B KwHeCTBe rHpiBcaKH K THMO. ,JJ o6ecrieeHCI4H 3c44eKTHBHOfl pa6oTbl KaTaJM3aTo- 6eH3aiHy noTpe6oBanncb npaBHTJeIbCTBCHHbie cy6cnginm. B pa JOnYCTHMoe cogepxKaHile CepbI B 6eH3HHe cieigyeT CHHf3HTb HH3KHX KOHiUeHTpaUHAX 3TaHoA CHJIbHO HOBbrILuaeT gaBaIe- Ao 0,05 BeC. %, a )KeIIaTeJIbHO -H euAe HHAKe. HHCe uapoB 6eH3aIHa, TaK 'ITO ero BBegeHHe B 6eH3HH 3aTpyA- BO3MO)KHO, CO BpeMeHCM 6ecrioKoflcTBo 6yJeT Bbl3bl- HHeT HCnOnJb3OBaHHe TaKOrO gemLueBoro BbICOKOOKTaHOBOrO BaTb 3arpH3HeHHe BO3AyXa TOHKOJHCnepCHbIMH a3po30- KoMnOHCHTa, Ka(K 6yTaH. AiHMH, cepbM3HbIM HCTOIHHKOM KOTOpbIX ABJIICOTCH ;H- OJHHM H3 HaH6oJree a eKx1THBHbIX cnoco6oB cHH)Ke- 3eCIbHbie 4BHraTCHH. KaiecTBo AH3enbHorO TonJrIBa, H14A Bbi6pOca 3arpH3HHTeJIefl C BbIXJIOIIHbIMH ra3aMH HBIHeT- UipHMCHHeMOrO B gaHHOM perHoHe, C'IHTaIOT Ba)KHbIM (FaK- CH 4cnOJIb3OBaHHe KaTa)IHTHIecKHx npeo6pa3oBaTeneai (Heti- TOpOM, BJIHASOMHM Ha BbI6pOc a3po3onefi. 14 3SeCb B riepBylO TpaJIH3aTOpOB). flpi4 3TOM, OAHaKO, BO3MOAKHO OTpaBJieHHe o'epexb riOTpe6yeTcH orpaHllIHTb cogep)KaHHe Cepbl. Ilpeg- KaTaJHI3aTOpOB. CBHHIe HCo6paTHMo OTpaBBIAeT KaTaJIH3a- HOiaraeTCH, HITO KmHo-eByIO pOIb B MHHHMH3aiHH Bbi6pOca TOp, TaK 'ITO 3THJIHpOBaHHblfl 6CH3HH HH rlIH KaKHX o6CTo- a3pO3oneie 143 WH3eIbHbIX BHraTeJieih CbirpalOT COBeplmeH- HTeCIbCTBaX HeJIb3H dCnOnb3OBaTb B aBToMo6HJHX, o6opygo- Hoe TeXHH'IeCKoe o6cJnluy-BaHiie H yIy'iuIeHHaH KOHCTpyK- BaHHbIX KaTaIHTi4HeCK14MH HeHTpaJI43aTopaMl4. Cepa UNA AlBHraTeniH. 43 CII14COK YCJIOBHbIX COKpaMeHHH JJBE U eHTpaAbHaq H BocTorqHaa EBporia OH/1t OKTaHOBoe 'HcJIo iio HcCieCoBaTeCIbcKoMy cHrF CxKaTblfl pHpOXLHbli ra3 MeTOJy CO MOHOKCHIA yrnepoga (oxnCb yrnepowa) RVP IaBnIeHHe HaCbllIeHHbiX napoB (no PehxAy) YOOC,D YnpaBneHHe OXpaHbI oKpy)Kaioiiea4 cpe4bi SO2 JIHOKCHA Cepbl (nByOKHCb cepbi) AaHHH SoX OKHCJIb Cepbi EEPP EBporietcKHf 6aHK peKOHCTPYKUHXMH H4 pa3- T96 TeMriepaTypa, nPH KOTOpOti ncnapAeTCn BHTHA 96% TorTinBa EC EBponecxCHfl CO0O3 CBH CyMMapHbie B3BemieHHbIe laCTHl;ubl KKHIC YCTaHOBKa KaTali4THMecKoro KpeK4Hra B IIPOOH lIporpaMMa pa3BHTHH OpraHs3au4nH 06%be- nceBAOC)KHDKeHHOM cnoe 9HHeHHbiX HauiHa BBHI BanoBofk BHyTpeHHHiH rIpOAyKT ESKOOH EBponeaicKaa 3KoHOMH4mCcKaA KOMHCCHA M(DK MeIKqyHapo,uHan 4nHHaiCOBaa KopnoparunA OprafHH3a1iAH O6rbeAHHuHHbIx Ha4HH (rpyrnbl OpraHI3auHfl BceMHpHoro 6arnca) ,Zjonn. CIIJA Joviapbi CHIA T/T TexoCMOTp / Texo6CJy)KHBaHi4e HTCK Hlpo6er TpaHCriOpTHOrO CcpeACTBa B KHIO- YI43 YMe6Ho-HHHoBagHOHHbIl 3aeM MeTpaX cUFr CKH)AeHHblfl IapHpOAHbif4 ra3 )O1C JleTyMHe opraHriviecKIe coegmHeHHH OV-I/M OKTaHoBoe HcJIo 110 MOTOpHOMy MeTOgy o6. % 06%,eMHbl HpoUeHT MTBE MeTlf11TpeTl4qHo6yTllHIOBbflI 3(pHp B03 BCeMHpHaS opraHH3aLa ax 3gpaBooxpaHemnrn HIIHIM Ha4noHanbHaA nporpaMMa npHpojDooxpaH- BeC. % BecoBoai 1POUeHT HbiX Mep rln FpaMMOB Ha JIHTp HHF HOBble He3aBHCdHMbIe rocygapcTBa Kr KiHJOrpaMM HHIO HeCrpaBHTe)IbCTBeHHaH opraHm3auHH KM KnjioMeTp NO2 NlHOKCHa a3oTa (xBByoKHcb a3oTa) KIla KHnonacKanb NOx OKHCJibI a3oTa Mr MHJiJiHrpaMM, 10 3rpaMMa PM2,5 ToHKno4cinepcHaA 'lacTH`a C a3poJ,HHaMH- Mr/M3 MHJUiHrpaMMOB Ha Ky6HMeCKH$i MeTp eCcKHM ,HaMeTpOM MeHee 2,5 MHKpOHa MKr MHKporpaMM, 10-6 rpamma PM10 ToHKoAiHcnepcHan maCTHIia c a3po04HaMH- MKr/M3 M xKPorpaMMOB Ha Ky6HCeCKHH qeCKHM JHaMeTPOM MeHee 10 MHKpOHOB MeTp vI1 V - II F I 51: HTV 42 D 9~32C0R H C 4 3tx2 .-, ,, ; z? I - 3l^t .;C)) St)F~L, Ctleane- transp:ort fuekol ftc:u" cleaner air in Central-.0. PAi..; and te Cat.tc,Aus / (Urn CErPbi;HnyCTr1 aeCqTb nieT nocnie riajeHHH 6ep)IHHCKO4 B C E M H P H blfi 5 A H K CTeHbI CTpaHbI L"eHTpaIbHOf4 H1 BOCTO'HHOH EBpOnbI, 1818 H Street, N.W. a TaKoKe CHF no-lpe>KHeMy cTajiKHBaIOTcH C Cepbe3- Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A. HbIMH IPO6JeMaMH: XOT5 MHOrOe H 6bI¶O WCTHrHy- TO B npouecce riepexo)ja R pbIHOHHOH4 3KOHOMHKe, TeJiedF0o: 202 477 1234 MHoroe ewe npe,ACTOHT ceienaTb. BceMHpHbIU 6aHK Teae(,aKc: 202 477 6391 H1BJIqeTCq aKTHBHbIM ilapTHepOM, co,AeHCTBY1OWI4M TeneKc: MCI 64145 WORLDBANK CTpaHaM B pa3pa6OTKe H ocyIeCTBjieHHH pec1opM. MCI 248423 WORLDBANK B riepHog nepexo,a K PbIHKy CTpaHbI perHOHa ,jo6H- Internet: www.worldbank.org JIHCb MHOrOviHCJIeHHbIX yCrieXOB, HO H rIoTepnenii pnq Heygaq,ra. taHHasl cepHq riy6jiHKaLjI4AqBnSqeTC3H BK)ia- E. noqTa: books@worldbank.org AOM BaaHKa B 9HCKYCCH1O 0 He3aBepiHeHHOA npOrpaM- Me pe4opM H BO3MO>KHbIX no,xoAax K pemleHHIO 6ygyini4x npo6ieM. HacTomwaq cepwn, COCTOA1Wa H3 14 ny6&IHKaiHI4, r1OCB5iIteHa BOnpOCaM BHOBb B03- HHKillefi 6egHOCTH H HepaBeHCTBa, CO4HaJIbHOH 3aWHTbI H 3aLHTbI oKpyKaioiUefH cpeJabI, CO3jaHHl14 HHCTHTy"HOHanbHOrO noTeH4HaJIa, a TaK>Ke 3Haqe- HHKO KOpriOpaTHBHOR OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH, CTpaTerHs!M COBepIIweHCTBOBaHHSI CHCTeM o6pa3OBaHH51, HHBeCTH- [1H43M H rOpogI!aM, ipHirOJgHbIM JIR5 >KH3HH. AaHHa51 cepmn Hy6)iHKaUHiH 6bIJIa rogrOTOB3ieHa c ULeJIblO o6jierieHi4Ja J4HCKyCCHH B paMKaX TeMaTHIHec- KHX CeMHHapOB B xoge COBMeCTHbIx e)KerOAHbIx COBeWaHHli BceMHpHoro 6aHKa H MetK,gyHapOj,HOrO BaoTiOTHOrO bOHna 2000 rojga B flpare H iocnegy1o- mero ilHpOKOwrO gHaj1ora. 4+ I Canadian Agened ne de I ~~~International canadienned Development d6veloppement 0-8213-4788-8 Agency international .