E533
v. 4
SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIET NAM
PECC I            ELECTRICITY OF VIET NAM
POW)%ER ENGINEERINGY CONSULTING COMI'ANY I
Project: 02.2001
PLAYCU - DUNG QUAT - DA NANG
500KV TRANSMISSION LINE
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
(Draft)
Project manager: Nguyen Duc Thanh
Chief of division: Nguyen Duc Thanh
Hanoi, January2> /, 2002
P.P. DIRECTOR
POWER EN,,  ?NG CONSULTING COMPANY 1
i/' -7 WE _- DIRECTOR
LE VAN LUC



x
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Executive sunmiiarv
Chapter 1 - Introductioii.
1.    Environmental Concern in Power Sector of Vietnam
2.    Legal and Administrative Framework
3.    Objectives ot Report
4.    Methodology
Chapter 2 - Project Description.
1.    Name of Pro'ject
2.    Implementing Agencies
3.    Socio-economic Targets of Project
4.    Main Features of Project
5.    Proposed Schedule of Project
6.    Budgetary
Chapter 3 - Present Status of Project Site.
1.    Physical Environmenit of Project
2.    Ecological Environment of Project
3.    Socio-economic Condition
Chapter 4 - Project Impact on Environment.
1.   Impact on Physical Environment.
2.    Impact on Biological Environment and Eco-System
3.   Impact on Human.
Chapter 5 - Analysis of Alternatives
Chapter 6 - Mitigation Measures for Negative Impacts on Environnient.
1.    General Measures
2



2.    Technical Measures
Chapter 7 - Public Consultationi aiid Information Dissemination
1.    Aims of pLublic consultation and information dissemination
2.    Public consultation and information dissemination during project
preparation sta2e
3.    Public consultation and information dissemination during project
implementation stage
Chapter 8 - Environmental Management Plan
1.    ETA participation and implementation
2.    Environmental impact and mitigation measures
3.    Monitoring
4.    Capacitv development and training
5.   Implementation schedule and cost estimate
Chapter 9 - Summary of Environmental Impact Assessment
Chapter 10 - Conclulsions
Annexes
Annex 1 - List of EIA report participants
Annex 2 - Reference documents
Annex 3 - Record ol' consultation meetings
Annex 4.- Relevant project dlata
I - Areas Tralversedi by the Transmission Line
2 - Statistics on Aft'ection within Project ROW
3 - Statistics on Temporary Land Requisition
4 - Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition
5 - Statistics on Affected Structur-es
6 - Natural Features of Concerned Districts
7 - Project Implementation Schedule
8 - Map of Line Route
Annex 5 - List of Associated Repor-ts
3



x
ABBREVIATIONS
EVN     - Electricity of Vietnam
WB      - World Bank
PECCI   - Power Engineering Consulting Company N"1
CPPMB - Central Vietnam Power Project Management Board
PPS     - Provincial Power Service
PMB     - Project Management Board
ROW     - Riglht-of-w\aly
T/L     - Transmission Line
HV      - High Voltage
EIA     - Environmental Impact Assessment
4



EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
VIETNAM
SYSTEM EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT, EQUITIZATION AND
RENEWABLE PROJECT
Introduction
The System Efficiency Improvement. Equitization and Renewable Project
is included of construction and rehabilitation of a number of power plants and
networks. The Government of Vietnam is seeking assistance from the World
Bank to improve the efficiency of its power sector so that poverty alleviation
programs can take root. One of the project component is the 500kV transmission
line from Playcu to Da Nang via Dung Quat.
According to the Bank's requirement. an environmental assessment of the
prOject proposed for Bani finan,ingto CllSUrC that the prOject is environmentally
sound and sustainable, and thus to improve decision making. The EIIA report
follow WB guidelines for mitigative strategies for the transmission line and WB
directives cover the folloving issucs:
Project Description:
This chapter concisely describes the proposed project and its g ographic,
ecological, social context. It also gives the project features, location,
implementation schedule and land requirement.
The line right-of-way (ROW) would be 38m wide for the 500kV voltage
T/L, from which all housing and buildings would be removed and all trees higher
than 4m must be cut. Construction access roads would be built frofr the main
roads as required. existing tracks would be used where possible. The
construction camp would be laid for workers and technicians in the heAdquarters
of the projecL commules.
The project will include the following items:
+ Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV phase line, ACSR 4x330,
313.6km long.
+ Dung Quat 500kV substation with capacity of 900MVA.
+ Expansion of Playcu and Da Nang 500kV substations.
5



x
Legal and Administration:
This chapter presents the policy, legal and administrative framework
within which the EIA is prepared. IR also mentions state pollution regulatory
framework. and the relevant environmental standards
Present Status of Project Site
This chapter assesses the dimillensions of' the study area and describes
relevant physical, biological and socio-economic conditions of the proj~ct areas
Project Impacts on Environment
Fundamentally, this chapter identifies expected positive and negative
impacts, in quantitative terms to the extend possible. It details the range of
environmental impacts associated with the transmission system, switchyards,
substations, line ROW, access roads, construction, operation and maintenance
activities. All of these issues will be addressed during the conceptual (design and
some will be addressed during the detailed design:
i.    transmission line ROW   and substation site impacts on land use:
residential, agricultural, forest areas, wrastelands, etc;
ii.   habitat fragmentation and invasion of exotic vegetation species;
iii.  access roads, increase in hunting, exploitation of forest resources,
induced development due to new access corridors, human settlement;
iv.   clearing (erosion, loss of habitat) and control of vegetation in ROW;
v.    impaired cultural or aesthetic resources because of visual impacts;
vi.  CerOSiOn (d.ing colst'ucliioII, and alonig access roads, substation and
transmission tower sites;
vii.  potential electrom-oagnetic treqiuency radiation effects, audiblc noise
along transmission line r oute. exposure of substation operation
personinel to poentiial EMF hazards:
viii.  aircraft hazards from transmission line and towers;
ix.   resettlement of project affected persons.
6



Mitigation Measur-es:
This chapter priimarilv deals with mitigation measures and any residual ot
irreversible nleg)ative Impacts thlalt can inot be mitigated. It also explores
opportunities for enrvironmental enhanccment and compensatory approaches.
The following route selection criteria used calls for the route sclection to
avoid the following types of environmentallv sensitive areas:
. Dense forest areas must be traversed, forest of low economic and
ecological value are preferred. (according to the law on Environment of
Vietnam, wood cutting is strictly controlled);
* Residential structures and settlements;
*  Holy places, archleologically sites and government sites;
*  Mangrove forests, national parks and other conservation areas;
*  Parallel with. or close to telephone and telegraph cables;
.  Airports.
Analysis of Alternatives:
This chapter svstematically compares feasible alternatives to the proposed
project site, technical aspects, management and operation - including the
',without project" situation - in terms of their potential environmental impacts,
the feasibility of mitigating these impacts. Each alternative quantifies the
environmental impacts basing on the investigation results. It explains the basis
and rationales for the selected routes and substation site.
Transmission line routes: some alternative routes were analysed for the
transmission line. The route that would cause minimum     impact on the
environment was selected, especially from the viewpoint of resettlement
limitation.
Location of substations and tower foundations: The substations and tower
foundations will be located in the wasteland or public land areas to avoid impact
on houses and properties.
7



Public Participation and Information Dissemination:
This chapter talks about aims of public participation and information
dissemination and how it takes place during different stages of project
implementation. It describes local public participation and disclosure processes.
Two public disclosure events are planned: the first soliciting comments for the
line route and TORs and the second, comments upon the conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and summarized in the draft EIA. It
also points out types and time of disclosure, and where the draft EIA is on
display for public review.
Environmental Management Plan
According to the WB OP. 4.01. the EMP is essential elements of EIA
report for category A projects. The EMP consists of mitigation, monitoring
measures to be taken during implementation and operation to eliminate adverse
environmental and social impacts, offset them, or reduce them to acceptable
levels. It also discusses needs for institutional strengthening such as training on
environmental issues.
Summary of EIA
This chapter summarises basic features of the project and comments of
environmental specialists. It also describes environmental concerns and gives
recommendations on mitigation measures.
Conclusions
Some conclusions have been made for the areas traversed by the line on
proiect topographv, construction of the oroiect. etc.



Chapter I
INTRODUCTION
1. Environmental Concern in Power Sector of Vietnam
Strategy for electricity industry development in Vietnam period 2000-2020
and beyond in recent master plan stated that electricity of Vietnam needs to
follow some strategic direction are outlined below:
* Hydro energy should be given first priority in energy development due
to the very large potential, however large scale hydro power plants
should not be very carefully considered because of the problems of
resettlements, submerged land...
Clean coal technology is being considered for both in the North and the
South. The North is endorsed with very available coal sources; the South is of
choice for imported coal case from Australia, Indonesia or others.
* Gas for electricity generation in the South is another important source
for energy planning.
* Nuclear energy is also to be considered as an option for long term
energy planning
From the viewpoint, it is believed that power sector of Vietnam has the target
c-f rcd!ucng the cnvironmcn!al impaclt by thc!'c ma:nly fro  thermal pnv!'e
station. Thermal power stations in Vietnam now are set in the plan for
rehabilitation, upgrading and retrofitting. New stations are to be equipped with
advanced technology such as PhaLai thermal station II, built with technology
that could limit the SOx, C02 to the very low level.
Thus development of power sector has received concerns on environment
among EVN executives. For overhead line project it could contribute very low
level of environmental emission but environmental impact on wvildlife, soil,
water.... Those are to be addressed in the assessment report.
2. Legal and Administrative Framework.
- The Law on Environmental Protection dated 27/7/1993 of the socialist
republic of Vietnam.
Ihis law stipulates the prevention from bad impacts on the environment and
environimental protection as well as improvement of ecological environmenlt.
"Environment" is defined as the natural environment and the one created by
humnan comprising air, water, sea, land, mineral mines, forests. grass fields,
9



wildlife, trees, natural and historical sites, natural conservation areas, places of
interest, cities, villages, etc.
- The Law on Forest Protection and Development issued in 1992.
This law regulates the forest management, protection, development and
exploitation, prevention of woodcutting, forest destroy. It also encourages
organizations and individuals to protect and develop forests so as to make more
benefit of the forest.
- Vietnamese Standard on Environment issued by MCOSTE in 1995
- The Government Decree N" 175/CP dated 18/10/1994 guiding the
implementation of the Law on Environmental Protection.
- The Government Decree N" 54/1999/ND-CP dated 08/07/1999 on
Protection of High Voltage Networks.
- The Decree N" 70-HDBT dated 30/4/1987 of the Council of Ministers
regulating the safety casement of the high transmission lines.
- The criteria on water quality TCVN 5942 - 1995, TCVN 5944 - 1995
- The criteria on air quality TCVN 5949 - 1995
- The criteria on noise TCVN 5949 - 1995
- The criteria on pollution TCVN 5937 - 1995
- The circular N" 490/1998f1T-BKHCMMT dated 29/4/1998 of MOSTE
guiding EIA preparation and appraisal.
- Ik   d oTI Electliiia Eqtiipinent Irnstallation - Part il Transmission 1tnes
11 TCN-1984.
- The preliminary survey report on the transmission line, which is planned to
be financed by the World Bank.
According to the Bank's requirement, an environmental assessment of the
project proposed for Bank financing to ensure that the project is environmentally
sound and sustainable, and thus to improve decision making. The EIA report
should follow WB guidelines for mitigative strategies for transmission lines and
WB directives:
+ Operational policies OP. 4.01: environmental assessment
+ Electric power transmission systems, environmental sourcebook. WB
technical paper No.154
3. Objectives of Report.
According to the stipulations of Ministry of Science. Technology and
Environment (MOSTE) of Vietnam. the 500kV power transmission lines are
10



x
classified as type A project in terms of environmental consideration. This
environmental evaluation aims at:
- Describing the environment of the project area.
- Identifying potential adverse impacts on the environment during the project
construction and operation.
- Classifying the project impacts.
- Proposing the mitigation measures for the negative impacts as a result of
the project development.
- Proposing an environmental management plan including mitigation
measures for negative impacts, measures for control of deforestation, pollution
control, resettlement action plan and environmental monitoring.
- Recommending on the monitoring and evaluation programme.
- Specifying the cost of mitigation measures.
- Preparation of EIA report following the guidelines of Vietnamese
government with modifications to meet the WB guidelines.
4. Methodology:
Basing on the WB guidelines OP. 4.01 and Decree N" 175/CP dated
18/10/1994 of the Prime Minister, the environmental impacts are classified as
follows:
> nm 11 inzignificpnt iact r small impact: for this type of impact, no
mitigation or protection measures are required.
b. Moderate impact: mitigation and protection measures are envisaged.
c. Major impact: a thorough study is needed to find optimal mitigation
measures.



Chapter 2
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
1. Name of project:
Playcu - Dung quat - D)A Nang 500kV transmission line
2. Implementing Agencies:
Investor           Electricity of Vietnam
Project Manager   : Central Vietnam Power Project Management Board
Consulting company: PECCI
3. Socio-economic Target of Project:
The Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line invested by
EVN is planned to supply electricity to Dung Quat Industrial Zone and central
provinces of Vietnam as well as to strengthen safely power supply capacity to the
central and the national power network. These provinces are facing difficulties in
developing their infrastructure as well as the economy, low population density.
Thus, EVN has considered and invested in these ones with WB' s loans.
The project aims are:
- to serve people living in tGa Lai, Kontum, QuAng Ngai, Quang Nam
provinces and DO Nang city. These central areas have low population density, the
economy mainly bases on agriculture and small business, exploitation of
breeding and forestall products. The industry of the central region develops more
slowly than others of the country and makes up a small part. This is a reason that
Vietnam Government lays down as policy development of Dung Quat Industrial
Zone so as to promote the regional development. The project to be constructed is
to supply electricity to Dung Quit Industrial Zone and central provinces as well
as reinforce the safety of Vietnam power networks.
- To intensify the power supply for the Central coastal area - one of the key
economic zones in the country by low-cost energy sources produced from
hydropower plants in the Central Highlands and thermo-electricity plant in the
South; to satisfy the rapidly increasing load demands of the area in the stagc of
2005-2010 and later.
- To reduce the power losses, energy losses on the network. contributing to
improvement of effective power business of EVN.
12



- To strengthen the reliability of the power supply for the Central network
compared to the case of one 500kV line.
- To create a strong coordination between the areas in Vietnamese power
system, strengthening the reliability and safe operation for the entire system.
4. Main Features of Project:
Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line is planned to supply
electricity to Dung Quat Industrial Park and Central provinces.
Areas affected by the project: localities along the transmission line: Gia lai,
Kon tum, Quang ngai, Quang nam provinces and Da nang city.
Areas served by the project: Dung Quat industrial zone and central
provinces.
Scope of the project covers:
- Construction of Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line:
313.6km
- Construction of Dung Quat 500/220 substation: 900MVA
- Expansion of 500kV outgoing feeders of Playcu, Oa Nang substations.
Impact scale:
- PAPs losing land: 15034
- PAPs losing houses: 297
Permanent acquisition of land:
- Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line: 113,085 m2
- Dung Quat 5OOkV substation                      : 103,676 m2
Temporarily requisition of land: 2,691,585 m2
Main features:
Pldvcu - Dung Qudt - Det NWg 500kV transmission line:
- Rated voltage   : 5OOkV
- Starting point   : Playcu 500kV substation
- Ending point     : Da Nang 1 lOkV substation
- Length of the line :313.6 km
- Number of circuits:
13



Conductor        : AC330 - 4-fibers/phase
Shield wires      TK- 70 and OPGW
Tower             steel
Line ROW         :38 m wide
Dung Quidci 500kV subslution:
Total capacity   : 2 x 450 MVA - one transformer installed at present.
Rated voltage    500/220/110Ok V
Acquisition area  68,000 m2
Transmission capacity: 400 MW by 2006 and 700MW by 2010
Energy: 1300 millions kWh by 2005 and 2000 millions by 2010.
5. Proposed Schedule of Project.
- Prefeasibility Study Preparation                 07/2001
- Approval of Prefeasibility Study                 01/2002
- Preparation of draft RAP, EIA                    11/2001
- Approval of RAP, EIA                             12/2001
- Feasibility Study Preparation                    03/2002
- Approval of Feasibility Study                    05/2002
- Preparation of Detailed Engineering Design  06/2002 + 06/2003
- Project Bidding                             06/2003 . 12/2003
- Site Clearance                               12/2002 .12/2003
- Construction                                01/2004 . 09/2005
- Completion                                  01/2004 + 12/2005
6. Project Budget.
The total investment for the project is estimated at:
* USD 63.20 millions for 500ikV transmission line. Of which:
- Cost for construction  : USD 44.84 millions
- Cost tor others       USD 12 92 millions
- Contingenc\         : USD  5.44 millions
* 500kV substation:
14



+ USD 42.94 millions for Dung Quat 500kV substation. Of which:
- Cost for equipment    USD 29.55 millions
- Cost for construction  : USD 5.27 millions
- Cost for others       USD 4.51 millions
- Contingency           USD 3.61 millions
+ USD 11.93 millions for expansion of Playcu 5OOkV substation. Of which:
- Cost for equipment   : USD 7.37 millions
- Cost foI construction  : USD 2.11 millions
- Cost for others      : USD 1.44 millions
- Contingency          : USD 1.01 millions
t USD 10.09 millions for expansion of DO  Nang 500kV substation. Of
wvhich:
- Cost for equipment   : USD 6.11 millions
- Cost for construction  : USD 1.81 millions
- Cost for others      : USD 1.32 millions
- Contingency          : USD 0.85 millions
15



Chapter 3
PRESENT STATtJS OF PROJECT SITE
The Playcu - Dung Quat - DOa Nang 500kV transmission line is planned to
supply electricity to Dung Quat Industrial Park and Central provinces of
Vietnam. The areas impacted by the project are the localities along the line.
Dung Qua't substation and expansion of Playcu, Da Nang substations, Gia Lai.
Kon tum, Qucilg Ngai, DO  Nang city. These provinices are facing difficulties in
developing their infrastructure as well as the economy, low population density.
1. Physical Environment of Project:
1.1. Topography, Geomorphology, Hydrogeology:
Topography of the traversed areas is rather complicated. There are mainly
high mountainous areas that are strongly divided. The elevations are lower from
the West to the East with the considerably divided topography.
The lines mainly pass erosion exhumed topographies (about 2/3 of the line)
concentrated in Gia Lai, Kon Tum, Quang Ngai. About one-third of the line
traverses relatively flat surfaces of Central coastal delta. The soil structure is
quarterly sediment composed of clay layer, loam, sandy clay with broken stone
and boulder.
Locating in the high mountainous areas, the regional hydrogeology is
sophisticated, too. These mainly are small streams and rivers that usually cause
. iG-6ay fioods in the rainy season. The water discharge in the dry season is
very low.
1.2. Meteorology:
The route belongs to the hot humid tropical weather, is insignificantly
directly affected by north-east monsoon in the winter.
The rainy season of the Central is from July to Novembers of the nest ycar.
In this time, the rainfall makes up to 80% of the whole year rainfall. There is
little rain in the winter, frequenit drought.
2. Ecological Environment of Project.
2.1. Featiures of Northern Provinces:
The populittion mainly concentrates in small villages in low valleys, narrow
delta baLnd along spring, stream and rivers where may supply water for rice.
subsidiary and industrial crops. The main kinds of trees are: coffee, rubber, rice
chiefly focussed on Western Plateau, particularly in Gia Lai, Kon Tum. The delta
16



areas of Quang Ngai, QuAng Nam provinces mainly are fields for rice, subsidiary
crops and low hills for timbers.
Though the northern provinces used to be covered with primitive forests with
precious timber species as: sequoia, dalbergia, sindora vietnamiensis, ironwood,
etc. as well as valuable animals such as tigers. bears, panthers, deers, wolves,
foxes in recent years, however, the forest have been destroyed badly. And as a
result, such precious trees and animals mainly exist in high mountains, isolated
and strongly divided areas without no access roads and human. Thus, these
ecological areas would not suffer from direct impacts of the projects.
2.2. Ecological Areas in Project ROW.
The Playcu - Dung Quat - DO  Nang 500kV transmission line traverse Gia
Lai, Kon Tum, QuAng Ngai, QuAng Nam provinces. The line ROW is 19m wide
on both sides of the central line, the width of ROW is 38m. The total area of
Dung Quat 500/220kV substation is 10,000m2 and the dimension of access road
to the substation is 50m x 8m, located on Binh Lo hamlet, Binh Thuan commune,
Binh San district, QuAng Ngai province. The substation is located on area for
pine and eucalyptus.
The line, in general, passes various kinds of topography, about one-fifth of
the line is strongly divided mountain forest consisting of Western Plateau hills,
mountains and thick forests. One-second passes trees-covered hills, one-third
passes coastal delta with weak geography.
The total area of ROW is 1,136.4 ha of which 66.14% is for agriculture
(Mainly land for rice, crops and fruits), 16.27% for forestry, 2.06% for residence,
and the rest (about 15.52%) is wasteland. About 35% of the area will be
temporarily affected when pulling line. erectina lower, vpl not .,ffpr-,q tPd  piant
under 4m after completion of construction. The permanent land acquisition area
of the project would be 252,437m2 in total. Of which:
- Statistics on Affection within Project ROW are detailed in Annex 4 - Table 2
- Statistics on Temporary Land Requisition are detailed in Annex 4 - Table 3
- Statistics on Permanent Land Acquisition are detailed in Annex 4 - Table 4
3. Socio-economic Condition.
The economies of the mountainous districts of the project provinces mainly
base on agriculture and forestry. Their industries are small with the main focuses
on processing of agricultural and forestall products, production of construction
material. The economic growth rate in recent years is much increased thanks to
the development of goods production, of some industrial trees, orchard trees with
high economic value, and local transportation network. Yet. some provinces are
still in difficulty with low income per- head.
Survey results on socio-economic characteristics of the locals
17



Population
The project areas are central provinces of Vietnam that are sparsely
inhabited. Population distribution: Gia lai province: Chui Pah 39 people/km2. Kon
tum province: Kon tum 165 people/kM2: Kon PLong 61 people/km2. Quang ngai
province: Ba to 37 people/ki2: Son ha 63 people/km2: Son tinh 526 people/km2;
Tra bong 60 people/km2; Binh soin 352 people/km2. Quang Nam province: Nui
thanh 274 people/kM2; Tam k' 338 people/km2; Thang binh 352 people/km2; Que'
son 160 people/km2-; Duy xuyen 374 people/kM2: Dien ban 482 people/km2. Da
nang city: Hoa vang 221 people/km2.
Household characteristics:
- The average number of people per household is 4.58, a bit lower than
that of the whole country (4.97). Large households usually comprise of 3÷4
generations.
- Most households (83.4%) are headed by men, female heads of
households are mostly windows (58%).
- Young people (0. 17 years) represent 47.56%.
- The productive age group (18÷54 years) accounts for 44.79%.
- Old people (over 55 years) take 7.65%.
Education:
About 80%, of household heads are literatc. Only 7.27% of males &
14.57% of females have no recorded level of education. However, the percentage
of high diploma is rather low; most diplomas are primary level (58.23%) or
secondary level (27.85%). Few people recorded vocational or university level.
Housing condition
The survey data show that few houses belong to class 3 (1.35%), 84.85%
of houses belong to class 4 and the remaining 13.8% houses are temporary ones
Plot size
Most households have large arable plots. About 67% of households have
garden area of over 10Orm-. Houses are usually constructed in this area therefore
sometimes it is difficult to identify residential & arable area. Generally the
project areas are sparsely  populated, the average residenitial area is
300.800m'2/household, very small compared to household garden area. Beside
garden, they also have 3000nm2.10000m2 agricultural land for cultivation.
Cultivation in this area is mainly on rice, maize, corn, industrial crops like tea,
coffee, rubber, cinnamon trees, etc.
18



Amenities
People's modern facilities are not much. 9.3% have motorbikes, 3.6%
have TV sets, 64% have bicycles, 47% have radios.
Stream water - the most common source accounts for 74% of the source.
while pumped water accounts for 0.4% and well water for 25.6%.
Few people in the project area have electricity, only 2.3%, the main
sources are small hydropower generators, batteries and diesel generators.
Economic activities
Agriculture
Farmers represent 93% of the locals. The line traverses low population
density area. The survey shows that people have large arable land, many have
over 50OOm2 of arable area. Their main cultivation is on rice, maize, cassava,
Besides, they also plant orchard trees, cashew, coffee, etc.
Through working sessions with local authorities, it is known that there are
relatively large wastelands in the project areas. Some areas are not fully
exploited. Water sources & initial investment capital (quite a big amount) for
industrial trees are main difficulties.
Trade
Households with income mainly from trade only account for 5.4%. These
mainly concentrate in the town center, along the highways. However, some
farmer families also make earning from trade but the quantity is not much.
Forestry
The affected forested land is scattered through out all the concerned
provinces. However, only few PAPs have gross income from forestry, they also
make income from agriculture. It is usually very difficult to point out the main
income source.
Income
* Source of income: People's mnain source of income is fiom agriculture
(60.88%) followed by livestock breeding (19.01%), salary (12.63 %) & trade
(5.4%). About 10% of survey people have secondary source of income. This
source accounts for 18% of the total income. Approximately 5% of people have
several sources of income that are nearly equal to each other.
* Level of income
It is vcry difficult to specify people exact income as pcople themselves
cannot point out their income exactly. People's income changes frequently when
the price of agricultural products, especially coffees change so much & so often.
19



x
The average monthly income of households is 303,000 VND. Some earn
over 1,500,000 VND/month. Meanwhilc many earn less than 200,000
VND/month.
The socio - natural features of the project are detailed in Annex 4 - Table 6.
20



Chapter 4
PROJECT IMPACTS ON ENVIRONMENT
The Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line traverse Gia
Lai, Kon Tum, Quang Ng,i, QuAng Nam provinces. These provinces are facing
difficulties in social and natural conditions due to sloping, strongly divided
topogr-aphy, undeveloped transportation and infrastructure.
As the project scope is large but the lines are long the project impacts on the
physical environment, biological sources, ecosystem are insignif'icant in terms of
the impact nature and scope. The specific impacts of the project on the
environment are:
1. Impact on Physical Environment:
The impact on physical environment considered herein are the affection on
water, air and hydrosphere.
According to the above mentioned characteristics and scope of the project,
the Playcu - Dung Qua't - DO Nang 500kV line would have almost no impact or
insignificantly small impact on physical environment.
According to the criteria on environment: quality of water, air and land, the
project would not produce waste that may pollute the water (surface and
underground water), air and soil in the vicinity of the project. The project
construction and operation would not result in a change of charactcristic. .,
value of land, water and air.
Nevertheless, the projcct construction may have impacts on land form due to
construction of tower foundations and substation.
2. Impact on Biological Environment and Eco-system:
The easement of the 500kV lines is limited by 2 parallel planes, 7m out of
the outer conductors when they are vertical. Trees outside the eascment must be
controlled to ensure 2m clearance in all condition. The clearance from conductor
to the tree top in the ROW must be > 6m.
All trees of or would be > 4m in the line ROW must be cut down. So if the
line routes pass natural and industrial forests with trees higher than the limit.
such trees must be cut down. This would have certain impact on the biological
and ecological environment. Nevertheless, the affected forest are in the ROW is
insigion ficantly small compared to the natural forest area: 0.01(.
21



Traversed locality  Province natural forest (ha)  Affected area (ha)
Gia Lai province               864,354.7                1.52
Kon Tum province               776,725.7               183.4
Quang Ngai province            126,457.9                 0
Quang Nam province             772,765.8                 0
Da Nang city                                             0
The cut-off involves:
- Coffee     4,288 trees
- Rubber    : 4,939 trees
- Pine      : 227,330 trees
- Eucalyptus 41,469 trees
- Orchards   22,804 trees
- Cashew    : 445 trees
All trees above are economically valuable and will be dully compensated at
the market price.
- Secondary natural forest: 1,834,070 m2
Besides, other crops in the line ROW such as rice, vegetables may be
affected as well during construction process (tower transport and wire pulling).
However, these impacts are temporary (for 3 - 6 months).
- Rice      :401,670 m2
- Crop     :458.744 m2
Line ROW
The total area of the project ROWs is 11.364,470 mi, of which 7,517.027
m2 is agricultural land (66.14%): 1.849.270 m2 is forestall land (16.27%),
234,213 m2 is garden and residential land (2.06%), the remaining 1,763,960 m2
is waste land and road-side (15.52%).
Statistics on the project line ROWs are in Annex 4.
22



Temporary land requisition
Land will be requisited temporarily 2 cases for: foundation works, tower
erection, material transport to the line route. Conductor and earthwire pulling and
stringing.
As the scope of the project is inconsiderable, each component can be
completed in 3-6 months. Thus the impact will be on one crop time. Consider
commencement right after harvest of annual crops, if possible, to minimize the
project impacts.
The total temporary requisition of the project is 2.691,585 m2, of which
1.780.349 m2 is agricultural land (66.14%); 437,985 m2 is forest land (16.27%);
55,472m2 is garden and residential land (2.06%); the remaining 417,780 m2 is
wasteland and road-side (15.52%).
Statistics on the project temporary acquired land are in Annex 4.
Impact on permanent land acquisition
The impact on permanent land acquisition is not much. The average
acquired area for transmission line is 160m2 for each 500kV tower foundation,
Dung Quat 500kV substation requires 6800Gm2, Playcu 500kV expansion
substation needs 20970 m2, Da Nang 500kV substation requircs 14706 m2.
The total permanent acquisition of the project is 216,761 m2, of which
178.476 m2 is agricultural land (82.34%); 18,402 m2 is forest land (8.49%);
2,331 m2 is garden and residential land (1.08%), the remaining 17,553 M2 is
wasteland and road-side (8.1 %).
Totaiy there are 74 PAPs of type 6 (loss of land) The impact on each PAP
will be of no significance, less than 20% of each PAP's total area. Therefore,
PAPs will not be influenced much.
Statistics on the project permanently acquired land are in Annex 4.
3. Impact on Human.
3.1. Impact on Residential Areas:
For a suitable network configuration and low investment, the line routes
must be closed to the residential areas and usually closed to transportation roads
so as to facilitate construction, operation and management. However, to avoid
much impact on residential areas, the line turns frequentlv to avoid houses.
The project constr-uction would cause impact on the residerntial areas due to
houses in the ROW. The survey data show that there would be 297 houses
affected in the ROW (see Annex 5).
3.2. Impact of Electric Field on Human and Animilals:
23



Basing on the criteria of the power sector: "Limitation for power frequency
electric field intensity" and stipulations on the working environment "Limitation
for electric field intensity, working time in the affected area".
The permissible working time per one day and night would be depend on the
electric intensity as the following table:
Electric intensity  <5     5    8   1    12   15  18   20  20< E < 25  > 25
(kV/m)                 5    8   1    2   t
Permissible
working time per  unlimited  8  4.25  3  2.2  1.33 0.8  0.5   1/6       0
day and night (h)
Accordingly, the electric field affected area is the area with the power
frequency electric field intensity of > 5kV/m. For inhabitants living under the
lines, the safe electric field intensity is < 5kV/m. However, the electric field of the
5OOkV line at the edge of the ROW will be kept below 5kV/m, which is
comparable to international standards. Internationally there is no research that
indicates health impacts result from exposure to electromagnetic fields; however,
research continues.
In design, for mountainous areas where no human living is present, the
designed conductor-to-ground clearance of 1Oim at minimum would ensure
electric field intensity < 6kV/m. For the line section nearby residential areas, the
designed conductor-to-ground clearance of 1 4m at minimum would ensure
electric field intensity < 5kV/m and no impact on human may occur.
3.3. Impact of Electric Field on Telecommunication Projects:
Telecommunication projects include:
- Communication lines going closed to or across the 500 kV line.
- Audio frequency, PLC telephone lines going closed to or along the line.
3.4. Imnpact on Landmarks, Historical Sites:
The project traverses areas of different localities. Thus, the impacts on the
lands, army sites, airports, historical sites and pagodas have been considered in the
survey and design stage and no historical sites would be affected by the project.
This is a criterion for the line route selection so such impacts would be avoided.
The line route has been consulted and agreed by relevant organizations and the
results are attached in documents at the end of this report.
3.5. Impact on Safety: Explosion anid Fire.
Explosive substances will not be used in construction, the only construction
measure is excavation. Ho\ever, fir e due to cooking must be taken into
consideration in the construction period.
24



3.6. Impact of Noise, Vibration, Pollution:
Machine operation during construction may cause noise and vibration. As
the designed voltages are mainly 500kV noise caused by arcing flashovcr in light
rain or moisture condition will not be considered as it is considerably small
(<cOdB under the line).
3.7. Impact on environment due to resettlement:
The project would have insignificant impact on households. Most households
have large residential area, thus, they may rearrange their houses within the
remaining area or move nearby the old location and no resettlement site shall be
needed.
25



Chapter 5
Analysis of Alternatives
During selection of line route and substation location, PECCI engineers had
carefully studied differcnt alternatives on map and at site and chose one route for
investigation. For complicated sections, two alternatives were chosen for
investigation for comparison.
Table below summarizes investigation as well as comparison results for the
transmission line route and Dung Quat substation.
In the first place there are two main options of OHL to be considered. One is
to built consistent 220 kV T/L, the second is to pay attcntion only on 500kV T/L.
Power flow analysis helped to reject the first option since power demand of the
area is forecasted much larger than the power 220kV lines transmitted.
The 500kV option then to be analyzed by alternatives: la, lb and 2, described
and follows:
* Alternative I (la, lb): Along the existing 500kV North-South, biuld a
single 500kV
o la: 260km 500kV DaNang-Playcu. lOOkm double circiut 220kV
DaNang-Dung Quat
^  ib: 260km 500kV DaNang-laycu, 180km double circiut 220kV
Playcu-Dung Quat
* Alternative 2: A new double circiut 500kV Playcu-DungQuat-DaNang
with 450MVA substation.
Not only technical, financial anf economic analysis revealed the option
(alternative 2) is the best practical option, but also option 2 is to bring the impact
of the project on the environment to the lowest level. The impacts mainly are
land occupation, going near or tillhoughl sensitive areas.... By selecting the
alternatives 2. it is obvious saving the environment from concerns of actions to be
taken reducing the possible attack.
This option to build double 5OOkV linc from Playcu to DaNang through Dung
Quat is definitely take advantage of environmental impact mitigation as
compared with building a power station provided power to the area as forecasted.
A power station occupies less land thanl the OHL. but constantly efnits a much
26



x
large emission even it is the gas-fired power plant. This consideration found very
difficult to accept, not less to say about technical advantage of system
integration.
27



Table
Line section                     Main features               Alterniative 1  Alternative 2   Selected option - Reason
Start - G66 (end)          Total length:                              183,246 m     206,520 in   Alternative 1 is selected because:
(Playcu - D6oc S6i section: go  Where:                                                          - Shorter line
through Gia Lai, Kon Tum                                                                        - Less crossings over forests,
and Quang Ngai provinces)  - Annual crop cultivation                   54,456 m      51,681 m     industrial trees
- Industrial tree plantation                31,812 m      69,372 m    - Less PAPs
- Planted forest                            22,046 m       400 n
- Secondary natural forest                  48,534 m      81,314 m
- Waste land                                26,398 m       1,328 m
- Garden land                                              2,425 m
Aftected houses:
- Total affection of structure                 94           200
- Partial affection of structure
Transportation                             Convenient    Convenienlt
Impact on other projects:
.                               ~       ~     ~~~~~~~~~~~~0  2
- Alrports
- Communication projects                  Small impact  Small impact
No impact     No impact
- Cultural projects, scenery
28



Line section                      Main features               Alternative 1  Alternative 2   Selected option - Reason
G54A - G(62B - End         Total length:                               22,318 m
(Connection section fronm G54  Where:
to Dung Quat: go tlhi-ough
Blinh Son district - Quaiing  - Annual crop cultivation                8.850 m
Ngal province)             - In(lustrial tree plantation               6,900 m
- Planted forest                               No
- Secondary natural forest                     No
- Waste land                                6,568 m
- Garden land
Affected houses:
- Total affection of structure
- Partial affection of structure               16
Transportation
Impact on other projects:
- Airports
- Communication projects
- Cultural projects, scenery
29



Line section                      Main featuies               Alternative t  Alternative 2   Selected option - Reason
Start - End                Total length:                              108,048 m     103,000 m    Alternative 1 is selected because:
(Dr'c S6i - Da nang section: go Where:                                                          - Shorter line
through Quang Ngai, QuTng - Annual crop cultivation                    50,759 m      39,95() in  - Less crossings over North -
Nat provinces and Da Nang - Industrial tree plantation                                            South railway.
- Planted forest                            39,034 m      37,400 mn  - Less crossings over
communication lines
- Secondary natural forest
- Waste land                                18,255 m      25.650 m
- Garden land
Affected houses:
z  - Total affection of structure              179          220
- Partial affection of structure               8             27
Transportation                              Normal       Convenient
Impact on other projects:
- Ail-ports                                    0             0
Communication projects                   Small impact  Great impact
-           .                              No impact     7 crossillnS
_ - C'ultural projects. scenery                         over ailways
30



Conclusion:
- The transmission line in alternative 2 has same ROW with 220kV
transmission line and is closed to the national roads so it is more
favourable for future operation.
- The transmission line in alternative 2 is about 30 km shorter than in
alternative 1. It would reduce: turning angles by 5-10 angles: structures
by 25-30 houses and avoid 2 airports.
In general, the line selection meets all economic and technical criteria.
Comparison and analysis of all options were carried out to choose the best option.
31



x
Chapter 6
MITIGATION MEASURES
FOR NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON ENVIRONMENT
1. General Measures:
1.1. Before EIA Preparation:
PECC I has conducted detailed survey on the project impacts, discussed and
agreed with the local authorities and relevant bodies on least-impact line route. A
harmonious application of Vietnamese and Bank's policies on compensation and
subsidies for the project affected persons for coping with impacts and restoring
life.
1.2. After EIA Preparation:
PECC I has consulted relevant bodies such as the provincial people's
committee, DOSTE and PAPs on EIA measures and policies so as to eliminate,
scope or mitigate social and environmental impacts and further modifies EIA
report.
2. Technical Measures:
2.1. Mitigation Measures In Design Stage
The mitigation measures for project impacts should be scrutinized during the
lt_Sigll SLdgC, cspecially for line route seiection. A well-selected route and
substation site would reduce much of the project cost as well as impacts on the
locals and environment.
- The route selected is as short as possible, the substation is suitably
designed for minimum construction cost and land acquisition.
- The transmission line and substations should avoid concentrated
residential and conservation areas by turnings. Though more turning
angles means high cost, the compensation cost and delay would be less.
- The transmission line should be as closed to the transportation roads as
possible to facilitate  material transport during  construction  and
management and operation, meanwhile reduce land acquisition for access
roads.
- The transmission line should avoid areas w\ith higFh trees such as
industrial trces, planted and natural forests so as not to impact the eco-
system.
32,



- The transmission line should not traverse or be closed to important
projects such as airports. mine warehouses, radio stations.
- The transmission line should avoid slope sides to reduce levelling.
- The transmission line should avoid turnings as much as possible due to
high cost of angle towcrs.
- The transmission line should use same ROW withi existing 110-220 kV
transmission lines in order to facilitate management and operation works.
During selection of line route and substation location, PECCI engineers had
carefully studied different alternatives on map and at site and chose one route for
investigation. For complicated sections, two alternatives were chosen for
investigation for comparison.
2.2. Mitigation Measures In Implementation Stage
In the next steps, the following mitigation measures should be considered
further:
- In detail engineering design stage: PECCI should study more carefully
about the investigated route and substation site and make necessary
modification to avoid residential houses.
-  It is necessary to mobilize workforce to construct complete line sections
and substation components to minimize temporary land requisition for
the project.
-  For annual tree areas. stringine wor-ks should be c:rried ott right after
harvest to minimize impact on crops.
- It is necessary to study carefully about access roads to minimize their
impact. For sections traversing forest, manual transport of materials
should be considered to minimize impact on the environment.
For Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV transmission line, many supply
options have been considered and analysed for different localities in the survey
design stage to ensure the techno-economic criteria of the project, meanwhile the
project impacts onl the environment have also been considered to find out
mitigation measures for negative impacts.
2.1.1. Lin2e Route.
Selection of the line routes and mitigation measures:
+ For ecological areas:
Cut all trees of potential impact in the line ROW. According to the law on
forest protection. ti-ee cutting is strictly under control. Thus, the line route tries to
avoid dense forests. The lines just traverse secondary forests, newly planted
33



The minimum line-to-ground clearance is designed as lOm for places far
from residential areas, 14m for residential areas, other clearances are in
compliant with the electrical regulations, as such, the electric field intensity
below the lines is much smaller than regulations of WHO and the sector (< S
kV/m).
+ As the design voltage level is 5OOkV, there would be noise due to arc
discharge in little rain or humid air. However, in design. the measure of multi-
wire for a phase is used to lower electric field intensity on conductor surface and
to mitigate arc discharge.
2.1.2. 500kV Substations:
2.1.2.1. Dung Qu&t 500kV substatio:l.
The Dung Quat 500kV substation is designed and operated at 3 voltage
levels: 5OOkV, 220kV, 11 OkV:
- 500kV side: Connected to Playcu 500kV and Da Nang 500kV substation
by two Playcu - Dung Quat and Oa NAng - Dung QuAt 500kV transmission lines.
Connection between 5OOkV side and 220kV of the substation bv 2 x 500kV -
(3x150) MVA, at present, one transformer will be installed. Diagram on 500kV
side of Dung Quat substation would be designed in quadrangle form. In this
stage, as there are only two incoming lines and one ATI transformer, diagram of
three circuit breakers would be selected.
- 220kV side : The 220kV side of the substation will be connected with the
22kV networks of the Central and it will be supply electricity to loads of Dung
Qu6t Industrial Park. A number of 220kV feeders in the stage by 2010 are: Two
220kV outgoing feeders to V)'V 9Aj 220kV substation, two 220kV 1feeders to the
steel Dung Quat 220kV substation, a feeder for 5OOkV transformer, one bustle
feeder, one feeder for 220kV transformer. Diagram on 220kV side of Dung Quat
500kV substation would be designed in diagram of couple busbar system.
- 110kV side : The 1 lOkV side of Dung Quat 5OOkV substation is planned to
supply electricity to 110kV substations in Dung Quat Industrial Park. The l lOkV
side will be supplied from the 220kV side by two power transformers of
220/110/22kV - 250MVA. in the short time, one power transformer of AT3
220kV - 250MVA will be installed. Diagram on llOkV side of the substation
will be designed in duplicate busbar- system (able to change into two diagrams of
busbar system with ring busbars).
The acquisition area of the suibstation is 300 x 300m. The substation is near
Dung Quat Industrial Park. on the white rocky hill of Binh L6 hamlet, Binh
Thuan commune, Binh Son district. Qu'ing Ngai province. The substation is
located on a hill for eucalyptus and causes no irnpact on houses and residential
areas.
2.1.2.2. Expans1xini of PItivuc 500kV' suibstaiti'on
35



Electric diagram on 500kV side of the Playcu substation is being operated
with one circuit breaker and a half (three circuit breaker units for protection of
two elements). The specific scope is : one compartment of line to DO Nang
500kV substation, two to Phui Lam 500kV substation, two to Yali hydropower
plant, one for transformer. Area for installation of 500kV equipment of Playcu -
Dung Quat 500kV transmission line is outside the existing substation ' s fence.
Thus, the extra area would be 20,970m2. Presently the area is covered with
eucalyptus and causes no impact on houses and residential areas.
.1.2.3. EXpansion of jDi NJb2g 500k`V siubstati'oln
Electric diagram on 500kV side of the Da Nang substation is being operated
in a quadrangle diagram of four circuit breakers. The specific scope is: one
compartment of line to Ha Tinh 500kV substation, one to Playcu 500kV
substation, two for transformer. Area for installation of 500kV equipment of
Playcu - Dung Quat 500kV transmission line is outside the existing substation ' s
fence. Thus, the extra area would be 14,706m2. Presently the area is covered
with eucalyptus and causes no impact on houses and residential areas.
- The substation will be protected by surrounding fence.
- In this project there is no transformers or capacitors to be replaced with
mineral oil, therefore transformers or capacitors will not contain PCB and
disposal of PCB is not required.
- Substations will be equipped with:
+ Drop-out fuses on transformer's HV and MV side for short circuit and
overcurrent protection.
+ Surge arresters for over voltage wave protection.
+ Circuit breaker on LV side for short circuit and overcurrent protection.
Thanks to the protection and automatic equipment, all faults occurring in the
operation stage would be eliminated at once, safety would be assured, dangers to
people living in the served areas would be mitigated.
2.2. In Colstruction Stage:
Mitigation Strategies for Construction are:
2.2.1. Construction Arranigemtenit:
Scientific arrangement. completion of separate project components and the
linc sections would minimize temporary requisition of land.
Construtiction activities such as tree cutting. ground clearance, foundation
excavation, material transportation; tower erection, wire tensioning. etc. would
have certain impacts on the environment. Therefore, concrete mitigation
measures required are:
36



-'Tree cutting, route clearance:
Apply measures of soil filling, tree and grass planting after construction,
minimize the impact of tree cutting to mitigate future impacts. For land supposed
to erosion, maintain trees with the allowable height in the ROW after cutting
high trees to keep soil.
- Construction of access roads.
Access roads for construction have been considered in the design stage and
specified before commencement. The main mitigation measures are
+ Access roads would originate from existing roads: main transportation
roads (national and provincial roads) etc. and as close to the nearest line as
possible. The temporary roads would meet the following criteria:
Avoid forests, conservation areas, lakes and ponds, etc.
Grade roads to retard erosion; compensate for lost farm production,
industrial trees, and land used temporarily or permanently for the line operations.
Discuss with local authorities involved.
- Safety measures:
Safety measures for construction must fully respect the safely regulations
and procedures:
+ Use specialized machines for transportation of tools, materials or heavy
equipments. Check the machines before use. Ligament must be strong. Respect
all reg lptilons on transportation saftVU
+ Foundation excavation must comply all safety measures. Since the tower
foundations are small, there would not be much excavation. Foundation works
would be carried out mainly by manual methods. The maximum unused soil
volume of < 1 m3, as a result of excavation, would be left in the surrounding areas
as agreed with the local authorities.
Any water pipes, underground sewcrs, communication or power cables
found during excavation must be reported to the concerned agency. Strictly
follow instructions of the agency.
+ Apply safety measures for tower erectioni, arm and insulator installation,
wire works and installation of other fittings.
Workers must respect the regulationis on works. safety. labour protection and
concentrate on their works. They will be given training on their jobs and safety
procedures.
37



Besides, conductor tensioning and tower transportation would be carried out
right after harvest of the annual crops to minimize the impact on crops in the
ROW.
2.2.2. Construction Camps:
As for the particular characteristics of the rural electrification project,
workers may set up camps in the commune or town centres for convenient access
to food, foodstuff, drinking water and communication means. However, they arc
not allowed to live together with local residents so as not to interfere people's
life.
For construction in difficult terrains, camps may be laid out near the lines
and workers would be carried out very quickly. Thus temporary tents for a
limited number of workers would be needed.
There are firm regulations on medical and sanitary measures to assure
workers' health. Each construction team would have one official specializing in
medical care to take care of the workers and treat common diseases as malaria.
typhoid fever, diarrhoea, etc.
2.2.3. Workers 'Health and Safety.
Operators and workers must strictly follow the state regulations on working
safety. Thoroughly consider the following safety measures for construction
workers:
- Mine and bomb clearing (if any) prior to construction
- Safety measures for equipment and material transportation
- Excavation and foundation construction.
- Tower erection, arm and insulator installation
- Wire stretching and tensioning, sagging, installation of other fittings.
Besides, consider sanitary and medical measures to prevent and treat
common diseases as: malaria, typhoid fever, diarrhoea, etc. Apply positive
measures to limit the impacts on worker's health during construction period.
2.2.4. Safety on Fire and Explosion.
Explosion substances xvill not used in construction works, manual excavation
and filling are main measures. Construction teams would not use forest resources
but kerosene for cooking. All substations would be equipped with fire and
explosion protection equipment.
2.2.5. Noise Polluction.
38



There may be noise and vibration from construction equipment. The small
arcing flashover noise occurring in light rain or humid days would not be taken
into account.
The impacts of noise, vibration on the environment in construction stage
would be insignificant.
In general, with the above mitigation measures, the project impacts would be
rendered as small impacts.
2.3. In Management and Operation Stage.
2.3.1. Management, Operation, Repair and Maintenance Works:
Scope of works includes: repair, periodical maintenance and fault treatment
for the transmission lines and substations. The PMB will undertake such tasks.
To mitigate the adverse impacts and limit the network faults, to ensure safe
operation, all workers must strictly follow regulations on safety for management,
operation, repair and maintenance of the lines and substations.
According to the project management scheme, PMB will sign contract with
local people on the project management. Prior to the project operation, training
on safety, basic techniques of the network operation and management should be
provided to the operators. Only the successful trainees with training certificate
can undertake the management and operation duty.
2.3.2. ROW Control:
PMB would monitor and control ROW within the province. detect violations
in the RCOW: houses, trees, etc. and find prompt resolutions for S'uch violations.
Local authorities and tree owners would supervise tree cutting. Take all cut
branches and trees out of the environmental ROW of the line and substations.
Random tree cutting under the name of network repair and maintenance is
prohibited.
2.3.3. Access Roads:
In general, the line go along the existing transportation routes and few
access roads will be needed.
All access roads would be revegetated after completion of the project.
Ground would be restored by filling soil. planting grass and trees, etc. some
roads along the lines that do not traverse conservation areas, however. would be
kept to serve the periodical maintenance, check and repair.
The above stipulations create bases for the management units to manage and
mitigate the environmental impacts.
39



Chapter 7
PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND
INFORMATION DISSEMINATION
World Bank (the Bank) policy regarding community involvement provided
in detail in the WB Environmental Assessment Source Book, Vol. 1 (1991). It is
summarized as follows.
Bank policy directs the borrower to publicly solicit, hear and consider the
concerns of the local community, other affected groups and local NGOs (non-
governmental organizations) and to fully incorporate into the design and
implementation of the project and the Environmental Assessment (EA). The
rationale for consideration and incorporation of the concerns affected parties is to
assure community acceptance and enhance the viability of the project. The Bank
has found that where such views have been successfully incorporated into the
design and plan of implementation, the projects are more likely to be successful.
The Bank has not found community participation to be an impediment to project
execution. On the contrary, projects in which affected parties views have been
excluded are more likely to suffer from delay and issues resulting from
community resistance.
Vietnam is a socialist country. The State is determined by the fundamental
principle "of people, firom people and for people". The democratic approach to
the social management of GOV is expressed in the basic principle of principle
"people know, people discuss and people control" all activities of the
Government.
To avoid negative impacts on project affected people. Governmental
Decree N 175/CP issued on 18 April 1994 requires that all projects in the
development of industry: energy, transport, water resource, agriculture, etc.
should conduct a compliant EIA study meeting the requirements of the
environmental management authorities and the contents of EIA reports include
predicted impacts and mitigation measures must be discussed with the PAP.
The PAP should submit their comments and concerns to the project
proponents through their authorized representatives, e.g. governmental agencies
(the people Committee. People Council) and/or socio-political organizations
(Fatherland Front, Farmers Association, Women Union etc.) or non-
governmental organizations (e.g. Vietnam Association for the Conservation of
the Nature and Environment. Biological Association, Economic Association,
Foresters Association etc.). These organizations should collect all comments
from the local people and send them to the environmental management
authorities (DOSTE at provincial level or MOSTE at central level) or even to
provincial People's Council or National Assembly. During the environmental
review process, all comuments and requirements of the PAP should be discussed
40



and conclusions reported to the project proponents, so that the project can
develop proper alternatives and implement measures for mitigation of the
negative impacts. The, project will receive an investment license, only after
appropriate modification of location, design, capacity and/or technology of the
project to meet the requirement of environmental protection and resettlement.
Involving affected people, especially the poor, often requires additional
expenditures. The costs include travel and subsistence for attendance at meetings.
Translation and expert advice that the community needs to help to formulate a
response to the proposal, etc. Such costs should be systematically budgeted. The
EA team must ensure that issues raised in affected communities are
communicated to the other participants in the EA process, including various
public agencies and NGOs that may be in the larger process pf public
consultation.
As the EA proceeds, the people in the affected area should be kept
informed routinely and systematically. Written material must be translated into
local languages. Where many are unable to read, oral discussion and visual
presentations sessions (often, by the resident social promoters or facilitators)
should be used. Throughout the EA process, the project agency should continue
seeking views from and providing feedback to the affected community.
Contents of Public Consultation meetings.
- PECC1 will inform the participants of the major technical and
environmental issued of the project and mitigation measures.
- In the meetings all questions of PAP should be addressed, all
recommendations and concerns of PAP and PC should be recorded.
- List of participant should be noted with their signatures.
- The llP nf video cameras, photo-camera and recorders is rccommcndedd.
Materials to be presented in the meetings.
The Consultants will present the following materials:
- Booklet/summery of pre F/S Report and EIA Report
- Maps of the project site
- Figures, tables, photos, pictures, etc. presenting the project activities.
1.    Aims of public consultation and information dissemination
Information dissemination to, consultation with and participation of
affected people and involved agencies (i) reduce the potential for conflicts, (ii)
minimize the risk of project delays, and (iii) enable the project to design the
resettlement and rehabilitation program as a comprehensive development
program to fit the needs and priorities of the affected people, thereby maximizing
the economic and social benefits of the project investment.
Aims of public consultation and information dissemination are:
- Share all project descriptions, components, purposes as well as project
negative impacts on environment and restoration and mitigation
measures.
41



- Collect information on project environment, local people's concern on
project in general and on environmental aspects in particular.
- Find coordination and participation of local people in realizing impact
risks as well as supervising the project activities.
- Reduce probability for social conflicts.
- Reduce risk for project delay.
- Help to establish a comprehensive environment management plan and
thus, maximize the project socio-economic benefit.
Public consultation and information dissemination are scheduled for 2
stages: project preparation and project implementation. Refer to the meeting list
attached for details.
2. Public consultation and information dissemination during project
preparation stage:
During project preparation stage, the following activities were carried out
sequentially:
Phase I-Activity 1: Information & discussion with local authorities on the
line route.
After studying maps and visiting the site, PECC I had envisaged a
preliminary route on 1/50,000 scale map. This map was sent to all locations
passed by the line and relevant local authorities. The local authorities have
agreed on the Droject line rouJte., This activity was carried Gut in -461-062001L
Phase I - Activity 2: Impact survey and statistics
Based on the agreed line route, survey teams had realized the route at site,
made the piling and coordinated with the commune officials to make a list of
PAPs' affected land and crops. The socio-economic survey forms were delivered
to affected households (for each commune) as basis for SLS. This activity was
carried out in 4÷.6/2001.
Phase I - Activity 3: Meetings with PAPs
When the survey finished. PECC 1 in coordination with the commune
officials held meetings with PAPs having land in the line ROW and with village
representatives. In these meetings, PECC 1 officials informed the participants of
the project purposes; presented the project impacts on land and crops in detail;
introduce the principles and policies of compensation and advised people not to
build new structures in the line ROW. PAPs were consulted on the entitlement
policy and the compensation in cash had been accepted.
Phase I - Activity 4: Meetings with the concerned PPCs
42



After working with the communes, in 6/2001 PECC 1 had sent missions to
work with the provincial functional agencies such as Financial and pricing
service, Planning and investment service, Agriculture and rural development
service, DOSTE, etc. and make the project purposes clear to PPCs; at the same
time discuss with local officials on the aims and principles of ground clearance,
on the proposed policies of EIA, legal and illegal issue and the local organization
working on resettlement and compensation; collect the local compensation rates
for land and crops.
Phase I - Activity 5: Consultation on EIA
Basing on the survey result, PECC1 shall prepare draft EIA to submit to
EVN, WB and concerned PPCs for revision. All comments shall be taken into
consideration, incorporated in the next version for approval by relevant
authorities.
Phase I - Activity 6: Approval of EIA
In 9-10/2001, PECCI had sent missions to work with the district people's
committees, DOSTEs on draft EIA. The revised EIA shall be submitted to WB
for approval. EVN shall ask MOSTE for approval of EIA policies to enforce them
in the province. This shall be legal basis for EIA implementation. After
preparation, the draft EIA report has been made available at DOSTEs in 2 months
for reference.
3. Public consultation and information dissemination during project
implementation stage:
Public consultation and infornation dissemination during project
implementation is of great importancc, as thie project imnpacts oi the environment
and people at the stage would be worst. The following information campaign
should be carried out:
* General description of project:
Right after signing of credit agreement and preparation of project
commencement, the first task for PMB is to held meetings with involved PPCs,
DPCs so as to inform them of the project policy and ask them for coordination in
resettlement activities.
* Information oin RAP:
Information campaigns on and public consultation about RAP should be
carried out continuously as envisaged in RAP report including: information on
RAP report. delivery of asset and crop inventory list, meetings with PAPs on
compensation, information on project schedule for local people and authorities,
etc.
* Information on EIA:
43



Another information campaign on environment impact mitigation shall
also be lounged beside the information campaign on RAP, the campaign shall
include:
I. Notification on local means of commutnication:
PMB shall coordinate with the local authorities in notifying on local
newspapers and television channel about project general information such as:
project implementation schedule, project components, informnation on RAP such
as project impacts on local people and compensation policies. Besides,
information on project environment should also be mentioned such as project
impacts on environment and mitigation measures.
2. Environment information booklet
An environment information booklet (EIB) on impact and mitigation
measures will be prepared by CPPMB basing on the approved EIA report. The
booklets will be displayed at offices of involved commune and district people's
committees, and will be distributed to local unions such as farmers' association,
women's association, all heads of project villages, all PAPs in the project area in
the initial duration of the implementation stage of the project.
The EIB contents are outlined below:
- Project basic description
- Description of the main project components to be constructed in the area
- Project design objectives
- Implementation schedule
- Project impacts
- Mitigation measures
- Institutions Responsible for EMP
- Monitoring
- Description of the detailed impact of the project on the specific
household
- Compensation rates for each types of impact
3. Notification for local aiutlhorities aboiut environment impacts:
All environment impacts induced during construction as well as operation of
the project, if any. will be announced in meetings with local authorities so as to
find prompt solution in order to avoid conflicts and implementation delays. All
problems will be solved in monthly meetings between local authorities, PMB,
contractors and consultants.
44



Chapter 8
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN (EMP)
The project environmental management plan consists of set of mitigation,
monitoring and institutional measures to be taken during implementation and
operation to eliminate adverse environmental and social impacts. offset them, or
reduce them to acceptable levels. The plan also includes actions needed to
implement these measures.
1.    EIA participation and implementation:
- GOV: is responsible for approving the project documents, authorizing
MOI for project implementation.
- MOI: is responsible for project implementation.
- EVN: is the project investor responsible for providing PMB with fund
and guidance on the project control and implementation as well as EIA
preparation and implementation.
- CPPMB: is the project manager responsible for the whole project
including resettlement, EMP, assignment for specialized bodies to prepare and
implement the project, submission to EVN for approval on decisions concerning
resettlement and environment policies submitted by PPSs, monitoring the
implementation activities.
- PECC 1:
+ Surveying, measuring and confirming AA
+ Coordinating with DRB in classification of affected property.
+ Studying and classifying affected people and houses.
+ Undertaking to collect data, plan EIA for the project basing on collected
data from RBs.
+ Coordinating with PMB in training enumerators
- Monitoring contractor: is responsible for direct monitor of
implementation of environment protection and impact mitigation.
- Construction contractor: is responsible for project construction works
and following all regulations in EIA.
- Transmission company: is responsible for Carrying out periodical and
sudden checks on the network operation; monitoring and prepare annual statistics
on the network incidents and faults: giving guidance and supervising the
implementation of the state regulations on the network protection and safety by the
local governments and people
45



- MOSTE: is responsible for appraising EIA report, stipulating
environment-related policies and regulations, giving implementation guidance
and training support.
- DOSTEs: is responsible for advising the provincial authorities on
environmental issues, giving comment on and verifying EIA, guidelining and
supervising EIA implementation in the province.
- Provincial people's committees: are responsible for
+ Guiding and monitoring EIA planning and implementation within the
province
+ Approving estimated compensation cost of the project for the province.
+ Establishing provincial resettlement boards and instructing their
activities
+ Guiding and leading the coordination between sectors, departments in
EIA implementation
- District cadastral department: undertakes the following duties
+ Studying maps of the line route, specifying permanent occupied land
(based on measurement given by PECC 1)
+ For important land, DCD can make measurement and cadastral map
itself, the findings will be included in land granting and acceptance minute.
- District resettlement board: is the key unit in commune planning and
management, its staff is specialized in statistics and data processing. The
commune representatives will take part in DRB. The unit is in charge of:
+ Organizing meetings with PPSs and consulting communes on EIA
+ Participating in the general census, together with the consulting
company to conduct detail censtis.
+ Collecting data on impact in the area and submitting them to PRB.
+ Coordinating with PMB on training enumerators
+ Confinming census result on affected assets (AA)
+ Acknowledging and resolving grievances and submitting the solution to
DPC
+ Monitoring EIA implementation in the area
+ Reporting to PRB by written document
- Commune people's committees: are responsible for
+ Confinning impact caused by the project in the commune
+ Monitoring EIA implementation in the commune
+ Organizinrg meetings at commune level
- Provincial environmental monitors: (interministrial) are responsible for:
+ Monitoring the implementation of mitigation measures to minimize the
project impacts in the construction and operation stage
46



+ Controlling and checking health of workers, operators and inhabitants
+ Managing and checking protection measures for plantations and animal
subject to the impact caused by the project.
- PAPs:
+ Directly participating in the survey on their duties and entitlements,
charged in returning the concerned site clearance in time.
+ Stating their requirement to the above institutions and supervising the
implementation.
2.    Environmental impact and mitigation measures
In general, the project impacts on environment are inconsiderable and are
scrutinized in chapter 4 of this report.
3.    Monitoring
- CPPMB and resettlement boards (to be set up) will be responsible for:
counting, verifying the affected assets and crops and compensation for assets and
crops.
- In construction stage, an environment monitoring board will be
established including staff of CPPMB, DOSTEs and contractors. The monitoring
board will have a monitoring plan with periodic checks taken place during
construction or operation stage covering:
* Monitoring the implementation of mitigation measures to minimize the
prj,ot imipacts in, tho oinstruction anad opcrati .T stag,
* Erosion along access roads, substation and transmission line foundations
* Trees cutting
* Controlling and checking health of workers, operators and inhabitants
* Managing and checking protection measures for plantations and animal
subject to the impact caused by the project.
- Transmission company undertakes to:
* Carry out periodical and sudden checks on the network operation,
especially after rains and storms for necessary solutions and good
operating conditions of the networks. These also help to find out and
prevent violations in the line ROW.
* Monitor and prepare annual statistics on the network incidents and
faults.
47



* Give guidance and supervise the implementation of the state regulations
on the network protection and safety by the local governments and
people. Meanwhile, stop the violations and report to the concerned
bodies for violation solving.
4.    Capacity development and training:
Environment management is a new task for the power sector, therefore,
prior to project implementation there should be training for staff that will
participate in EMP. Management staff will be equipped with knowledge on
mitigation measures for environmental impact and monitoring plan.
Training scope:
- Legal documents on environment
- WB stipulations on safeguard policies
- Responsibilities and rights of state functional bodies in environment
management
- Identification of typical impacts of power transmission line projects
and mitigation measures
Proposed trainees:
- EVN: Appraisal department, Cost and estimate department, Planning
department, International cooperation department, Power network
department, Power plant department : 1 staff/department
- CPPMB                            . 2 staffs
- PECCI                             4 staffs
- Contractors                      4 staffs
- Transmission companies           : 4 staffs
Training time and form: 3 + 4-day workshop co-organized by EVN and
WB.
Beside, there should be specifically in-deep trainings that would last
longer on different issues for specific trainees.
5.    Implementation schedule and cost estimate:
Total investment cost: USD 1,281.8 million (refer to Pre-FS report for
details)
Cost for EMP: see tables below
48



A. MITIGATION PLAN
Phase               Issue                                 Mitigating measure                          Cost (USD)             Institutional
resp nsibility
______________________________________  Install  Operate      Install    Operate
Design   Natural resource damage, habitat  - Select ROW  to avoid important natural areas and manage                     Designer   PMB/EVN
loss, invasion by exotic species  ROW to maximize wildlife benefits
along the ROW and access roads
and around substation sites
Habitat fragmentation or       - Select ROW   to amoid important natural areas such as                          Designer   PMB/EVN
disturbance                      wildlands and sensitive habitats
- Maintain habitat benzath the line                                                PTC
Increased access to wildlands  - Select ROW to avoio sensitive wildlands                                        Designer   PMB/EVN
Utilize existin roads to minimize new construction
Avian hazards from transmission  - Select ROW  to avoid important bird habitats and flight                      Designer   PMB/EVN
line and towers                  routes__
Aircraft haz7ards from         - Select ROW to avoid airport flight paths                                       Designer   PMB/EVN
transmission line and towers     Design lights to minimize risk of low-flying airplanes
Communication disturbance      - Select ROW to avoid communication lines                                        Designer   PMB/EVN
Corona discharge noise         - Suitable design with bundled conductors                                        Designer   PMB/EVN
Impaired cultural or aesthetic  - Select ROW to avoid sensitive areas including tourist sites                   Designer   PMB/EVN
resources because of visual      and vistas
impacts                        - Select appropriate support structure design, materials and
.      .--   .    .   .      - finishes                            ___
49



Phase              Issue                               Mitigating measure                        Cost (USD)            Institutional
responsiblity
Cons-    - Natural  resource  damage, - Use appropriate clearing techniques                                          Contractor    EVN
truction  habitat loss, invasion by exotic  _  .   .                        .                           l           (Regulated in
species along the ROW  and                                                                                  Bidding
access  roads  and  around - Replant disturbed sites                                                      Documents)
substation sites
- Dust from material transport  - Cover vehicles to prevent dust dispersion                                  Contractor   EVN
vehicles                    - Water construction sites for dust control during dry season                 (Regulated in
Bidding
- Locate concrete m;xing plants 200m from boundary of any                     Documents)
concentrated residential areas
- Noise from construction     - Carry out construcl ion works during normal working hours                    Contractor   EVN
machines                     for site nearby populated areas                                             (Regulated in
- Locate concrete mixing plants 200m from boundary of any                      Documents)
concentrated residential areas
- Waste                       - Collect and correctly dispose waste at approved sites                        Contractor   EVN
- Avoid discharge and disposal of domestic waste from                         (Regulated in
construction camps into water                                                 Bidding
_____ ____ Documnents)
- Soil erosion and soil loss  - Increased number of drain outlets/culverts                                   Contractor   EVN
- Plan for embankment, replant grass                                          (Regulated in
Bidding
Documents)
- Social impacts on local     - Locate camps separate from locals' shelters                                  Contractor   EVN
population                  - Avoid discharge and disposal of domestic waste from                         (Regulated in
-                                                          ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Bidding
construction camps into water                                                Documents)
50



Phase              Issue                                Mitigating measure                       Cost (ULSD)            Institutional
responsibil'ty
- Safety and health of workers  - Not use explosive substances                                               Contractor    EVN
- Workers are not allocwed to use forest resources for cooking                (Regulated in
Bidding
- Set up adequate camps and sanitation facilities                              Documents)
- Equip qualified working equipments and tools
- Give necessary training and guidelines on labor safety
- Provide medical first aid at site
- Carry out health check by existing local facilities
- Temporary requisition of land  - Scientific arrangement, accomplish complete components                    Contractor    EVN
(Regulated in
Bidding
Documents)
- Access roads                - Use existing roads Es much as possible                                       Contractor    EVN
- New roads would avoid forests, conservation areas and be                    (Regulated in
graded to retard erosion                                                       Bidding
Documents)
- Prompt restoration of roads that are not required for ongoing
operations by revegetation
- Hunting and wood cutting    - Workers must comply with regulation prohibiting hunting                      Contractor    EVN
and tree felling                                                            (Regulated in
Bidding
.      .-__ _ __ _ _Documents)
51



Phase       Issue                        Mitigating measure                    Cost (USD)       Institutional responsibi]ity
Opera-  - Noise     and - Use transformer type with permnitted noise level                     Transmission company   EVN
tio      vibrations
tion     vibrations     - Periodical examination of equipment for its appropriate
operation, lubricant and maintenance
- Install much vibration equipments on suitably large bases
and deep foundations
- Oil leakage   - Build an oil pit, use transformer without PCBs                       Transmission company   EVN
- Frequent examination of equipment for its appropriate
operation, lubricant and maintenance
- Appropriate oil discharge, stoiage and disposal
- Fire           - Substations are equipped with fire and explosion protection         Transmission company   EVN
equipments
- Safety and    - Comply strictly with operation regulations and working               Contractor (Regulated in  EVN
health of        time in electric field areas                                          Bidding Documents)
workers
- Induced effect  - Remove all objects that could be impacted out of the ROW           Transmission company   EVN
from
electromagnetic
field                                                                    _
- Line ROW      - Periodical checks and trim of trees that would be of                 Transmission company   EVN
mainternance     potential impact to the ROW
52



B. MONITORING PLAN
Phase          What          Where      How        When             Why           Annual Cost (USD)       Institutional
respons bility
Install   Operate   Install   Operate
Constructio  - Land slide,   Access       Visual       In      Ensure land to be    Included in  10000   Contractor PMB/EVN
n            erosion         roads,                construction embanked and          project
foundations Measuring    stage    replanted              budget     10000     Ditto      Ditto
- Noise           Excavation,              Ditto   Avoid excess limit as   Ditto
concreting                        regulated
sites      Measuring                                                10000     Ditto      Ditto
- Vibration       Ditto       Witness     Ditto    Ditto                   Ditto     50000     Ditto      Ditto
- Water sources   Ditto                   Ditto    Ensure no pollution by  Ditto
Visual              oil, chemicals                    25000      Ditto     Ditto
- Dust, waste     Ditto        Visual     Ditto    Gather and move out     Ditto     30000     Ditto      Ditto
- Deforestation  Ditto       Reporting    Ditto    Compliance with         Ditto
- Safety          Ditto                            regulation                        30000     Ditto      Ditto
Visual      Ditto    Ditto                   Ditto
- Landscape, visual Tents,                                                           30000     Ditto      Ditto
impacts         shelters    Interview  In & after  Ensure the locals'     Ditto
- Social impact   Local                 construction lifestyle are not
population,              stage    affected
nearby
villages,
towns
53



Phase          What          Where       How        When             Why            Annual Cost (USD)       Institutional
___________  _______________________                      respons ibility
Operation  - Land slide,    Foundations Inspection  Periodical  Avoid damages to eco-   Ditto     10000  Transmissio   EVN
erosion                                            system                                    n company
Line corona Measuring   Once in   Avoid negative effect    Ditto     15000     Ditto       Ditto
- Noise          location               rainy season to habitants
Line  ROW     Visual     Every 3   Ensure no overcutting   Ditto     25000     Ditto       Ditto
- Trees in ROW                             months   of trees
Along line  Measuring.  Big loads,  Protect human, animals  Ditto    15000      Ditto      Ditto
- Electromagnetic  At        calculation  once a year from dangerous area
field           substations   Visual   As regulated                         Ditto     15000     Ditto      Ditto
.  O'l of transformer _            .     _ 
54



Chapter 8
SUMMARY OF EIA
Transmission line design department - PECCI.
1'articipants:
- Nguyen Duc Thanh      : Manager
- Nguyen Minh Tuan       Deputy Manager
- Nguyen Vi Linh        Project Assistant
Major project components:
1.    500 kV transmission line  :313.6 km
2.    Substation             :450 MVA
Comments of environmental specialist:
The investor - PCI must advise construction units to strictly follow the
regulations on environmental protection and compensation policy so as to ensure
safety for construction and operation.
Environiiiental concerns and recommendations:
- The mitigation measures detailed in RAP would significantly mitigate
the environmental impacts on the project served inhabitants.
- Civil workers and operators must properly compile the safety regulations
during working to minimize bad impacts on health.
- The project manager and officials in charge of monitoring and
supervision must obey all regulations to minimize the environmental imnpacts.
Necessity for mnore detailed environmental examination: Not needed as
the measures already prescribed.
55



Chapter 9
CONCLUSIONS
Some conclusions can be made for the areas traversed by the lines:
- Topography: The areas traversed by the lines not diffcr much in elevation.
The line routes mainly go along transportation roads that make it easy for
transportation of material, construction, operation and management.
- Construction of the project will r esult in a number of environmental
impacts on the areas traversed by the lines.
- The environmental impacts are limited during the design, construction as
well as operation stages. The designers and environmental experts will co-
ordinate to solve problems and work out suitable measures.
- After completion, the project operation would leave certain impacts on the
environment but the impacts would be of no significance.
56



ANNEX 1- LIST OF LIA REPORT PARTICIPANTS
- Nguyen Duc Thanh      : Managcr
- Nguyen Minh Tuan      : Deputy Manager, Environmental Specialist
- Nguyen Vi Linh        : Project Assistant
57



ANNEX 2 - REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
1. Law on environmental protection of Vietnam, 10/1/1994
2. Government decree No. 175/CP, 18/10/1994
3. MOSTE. Vietnamese standards on environment, 1995
4. MOSTE. Circular No. 490/1998fFI'-KHCNMT, 29/4/1998
5. Government decree No. 22/CP, 24/4/1998
6. Government decree No. 54/1999/ND-CP, 8/7/1999
7. WB operational policies OP. 4.01, 1/1999
8. PECCI Prefeasibility study for Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV
transmission line
9. PECCI RAP report for Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV
transmission line
10. WB sourcebook of existing and proposed protected area in Vietnam,
2/2001
11. WB environmental sourcebook. Electric power transmission svstems.
technical paper No.154
12. Master plan for power sector development of Vietnam stage V
58



ANNEX 3 - RECORD OF CONSULTATION MEETINGIS
LIST OF MEETINGS ON LINE ROUTE
Date:          22/8/2001
Location:      Gia Lai PPC's office
Participants:  Vice-chairman: Pham Hong Nam
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relevant documents
Date:          30/8/2001
ILocation:     Kon Tum PPC's office
Participants:  Director of PPS: D60 Hoang Lien Son
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relcvant documents
Date:          4/9/2001
Location:      Kon Tum PPC's office
Participants:  Vice-chairman: Huynh Hao
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relevant documents
Date:          21/9/2001
Location:      Quang Ngai PPC's office
Participants:  Vice-chairman: Nguv8n Xuan Que'
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relevant documents
Date:          21/9/2001
Location:     DO Nang City PC's office
Participants:  Vice-chairman: Tran Phu6c Chinh
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relevant documents
Date:          23/10/2001
Location:      Quang Nam PPC's office
Participants:  Vice-chairman: Le Minh Anh
Experts of Construction Service, Power Service
Topic:         Consultation on the line route and TORs. These comments
have been recorded and incorporated into relevant documents
59



LIST OF MEETINGS ON EIA
Date:            23/8/2001
Location:        Chu Pah DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Kpa DO
Procurator of Forestry Department: Ta Quang BAo
Vice-director of Chu Pah rubber company: Le Kha Liem
PECCI: Nguyen Van DA
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            30/8/2001
Location:        Kon Phong DPC's office
Participants:    AdministrationVice-head: Chtrung Van Tan
PECCI: Nguyen Van Da
Topic:
Date:            30/8/2001
Location:        Kon Tum PPC's office
DOSTE's office
Participants:    Deputy Director: Nguyen Thi Nga
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            3 1/8/2001
Location:        Kon Tum towvn PC s office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Tran Vu Hung
PECCI: Nguyen Van DO
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            24/10/2001
Location:        Ho3 Vang DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairmain: Huynh Minh Nhan
Head of Administration Dept.: DOng ThLrong
Planing and Investment Dept.: Dang Phil Hanh
PECCI: Nguyen Huy Huan
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incor-porated into relevanit documents
Date:            24/10/2001
Location:        Quing Ngai PPC's office
DOSTE's office
60



Participants:    Deputy Director: Nguyen Manh Hung
Topic:
Date:            26/10/2001
Location:        Son Tinh DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Nguyen DOc Le
Planing and Investment Dept.: Pham DOng
PECCI: Bui HuIu Khu6ng
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP. conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            29/10/2001
Location:        Ba To DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Tran Trung Chinh
AdministrationVice-head: Dinh Tan Lac
Head of Industry and Construction Dept.: Ta Van Dong
PECCI: Bui Hfru Khuong
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            30/10/2001
Location:        Son Ha DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Dinh Van Dep
Dinh Van di
Phan Chau Trinh
PECCI: Bui Huu Khu6ng
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
FIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            31/10/2001
Location:        Binh Son DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Pham Truing Tho
Ngo Van Phuong
PECCI: Bui Hfru Khuong
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            31/10/2001
Location:        Tra Bong DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Pham Hong Thang
Pham Van Thu
PECCI: Bui Huu Khuong
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, coniclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
61



Date:            02/11/2001
Location:        Que' Son DPC's office
Participants:    Chairman: Vo Van Kinh
Expert: Nguyen Ngoc Anh
PECCI: Nguyen Huy Huan
PECCI: Bui HMu Khuong
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP. conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            02/11/2001
Location:        Duy Xuyen DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Nguyen Thanh Tai
Vice-head of Planning Dept.: Pham Van Sang
PECCI: Nguyen Huy Huan
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
ETA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            05/11/2001
Location:        Dien Ban DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Phan Quang Tran
AdministrationVice-head: V6 Hong
Vice-head of Planning Dept.: Nguyen Khoan
PECCI: Nguyen Huy Huan
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            05/11/2001
Location:        Nui Thanh DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairman: Nguyen Tien
Head of Resettlement Board: Bur Van Son
PECCI: Bui Htu Khuong
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            0-/1 1/2001
Location:        Thang Billh DPC's office
Participants:    Vice-chairmani: Nguyen Thuye't
AdministrationVice-head: Tran Thu
Vice-head of Planning Dept.: Tran Thi H6ng
PECCI: Bui Hf'u Khuong
Topic:           Solicit commelnts upon PreFS, RAP, cocIilusioi of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
Date:            06/11/12001
62



Location:        Tam Ky DPC's office
Participants:    Chairman: Bui Qu6c Dinh
Head of Management and Investment Dept.: DOng Ba Du
PECCI: Nguyen Huy Huan
PECCI: Bui Huu Khu6ng
Topic:           Solicit comments upon PreFS, RAP, conclusion of the draft
EIA. These comments have been recorded and
incorporated into relevant documents
63



ANNEX 4 - RELEVANT PROJECT DATA
64



1: AREAS TRAVERSERED BY THE TRANSMISSION LINE
No.              Location              Section      Length (km)    Remark
Gia Lai Province                                  16.950
1.1  ChwPah District             ____                  16.950   _
I Ph6 Hoa Town                 Start-G3      _      2.200
2 Hoa Phu Commune               G2-G6               4.000
3 Ea Khuon Commune              G5-G8              10.750
Kon Tum Province                                 89.300
11.1  Kon Tum Town     ___                      _      19.500
1 Hoa Binh Commune             G7-G1O               6.850
2 H'Reng Commune    __         G9-G1          _     2.950
3 Dak Wa Commune               GIO-GIl _        _   3.600
4 D)k PIa Commune              G10-G14              6.100
11.2  Kon PLong District                               69.800 __    _
1 Dak To Ve Commune            G13-G16             10.200
2 Dak Ru6ng Commune            G15-G18              5.900
3 Tan Lap Commune           _  G17-G20              8.000
4 Kon PLong Town               G19-G22              6.600   ___
5 Mang Canh Commune            G21-G23             10.500
6 Hi6u Commune                 G23-G28             15.700
7 P6 E Commune                 G27-G32             12.900      ._
III     Quang Ngaii Province        G33A-End            105.925 ____
I11.1  Ba ToDistrict             G33A-G36A             10.815    __
I Ba Tieu Commune            G33A-G34A              3.589
2 Ba Ngac Commune            G34A-G36A              7.226
111.2  Son H2 District           G36A-G48A             36.037
I Son Ba Commune __          G36A-G37A        _     5.207
2 Son Ky Commune             G37A-G40A              4.699
__ 3 Son Thuy Commune    _  _   G39A-G41A              5.110
_4 Son Cao_Commune         _   G41A-G44A             6.307
Sofn Giang Commune         G43A-G45A              5.167
6 Son Th'nh Commune       _  G45A-G47A              4.640
7 Son Ha Commune         __  G47A-G48A              4.907
111.3  Son Tinh District         G48A-G49A              4.854
I Tinh Giang Commune         G48A-G49A              4.854
65



No.              Location             Section     Length (km)     Remark
_11.4  Tra Bong District         G49A-G52A_ __          9.410  __
1 Tra Tan Commune            G49A-GSOA             4.484
2 Tra Binh Commune           G50A-G52A             4.926  __
111.5  Binh Son District         G51A-End             44.809
I B'nh My Commune            G51A-G52A             1.650
G51A-G55A,
2 Binh Minh Commune          G54A-G57B    _     _10.933
3 Binh KhLro-ng Commune      G54A-G56A             4.658
G55A-End,
4 B'inh Nguyen Commune         Start-G2           10.155
5 Binh Chtrong Commune       G56B-G59B             5.215
6 Binh Long Commune__        G59B-G61B             4.858 __  _   _
7 B'inh Phu6c Commune         G60B-End             5.080 __
8 Binh Thuan Commune          G62B-End             2.260
IV      Qu'ang Nam Province                             94.997_
IV. 1 Nuii Thanh District          G2-G12             28.973
I Tam Nghia Commune        _   G2-G4               6.310 __
2 Tam My Commune               G3-G6               5.565
3 Tamn Hiep Commune            G6-G8               3.250
4 Tam Anh Commune              G7-G1O              7.165
5 Tamn XuAn II Commune         G9-Gl l             4.483
6 Tam Xuan I Commune          Gl l-G12             2.200
IV.2  Tam Ky District        _     Gll-G20             17.218
1 Tam Ngoc Commune            G 11-G12             0.835
2 Tam Thai Commune            G12-G15              6.242
3 Tam Dan Commune         _   G14-G15              1.074
4 Tam Vinh Commune            G14-G16              2.074
5 Tam Phu6c Commune     _     G15-G20              4.341
6 Tam Loc Commune            _G19-G20              1.504
7 Tam Thnh Commune            G19-G20              1.148 _
IV.3  Thdng Binh District  _      G20-G29             12.513 _
1 BTBh Quy Commune            G20-G22              1.587 _
2 Binh Qu6 Commune            G21-G22    _         1.080
3 Binh Phu Commune            G21-G24              3.219
4 Binh Dinh Commune           G23-G29              6.627 __
IV.4  Que Son District            G28-G33              9.660
1 Phu Tho & ornmune           G28-G33              7.007
66



No.              Location             Section      Length (km)    Remark
2 Que Xuan Commune            G32-G33              2.653 ___
lV.5  Duy Xuyen District         _G32-G38             13.513
I Duy Trung Commune           G32-G34              3.283
2 Duy San Commune    __       G34-G35       _      5.140
3 Duy Chau Commune            G35-G38              5.090
IV.6  Dien Ban District           G37-G42             13.120
I Dien Quang Commune          G37-G39              3.210
2 Dien H6ng Commune           G38-G41              4.751
3 Dien Ti6n Commune           G40-G42              5.159
V       Da Nang City                                     6.440
V.1  Hoa Vang District   ___      G41-End              6.440
_____I HoA Tien_Commune             G41-G45              4.774
2 Hoa Tho Commune             G44-End              1.666
TOTAL                                 313.612
67



2:STATISTICS ON AFFECTION WITHIN PROJECT ROW
2
Unit: m
Agricultural land                                  Forest land
No.  Name                                                            Other ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  Nat~~~~~~al ~~Residetia Burial-
Rice    Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew   Coffee  Rubber    Pine   Eucalyptus |idustria                 I lande |Ground| Wildla
________       ~~~I_trees _ _ _ __                 _ _ _
Gia Lai Province       ___         85,671                  389,880  143,830                            15,200               9,519
1.1 Chu Pdh Distct c_                  85,671                  389,880  143,830                            15,200              9,519        1
I Phu Hoa Town           .           20,691                   11,210   49,400                        .           _           2,299
2 Hod Phd Commune                                            121,600   15,200                            15,200
3 Ea Khurcin Commune                 64,980 __               257,070   79,230                               _                7,220
Kon Tum Province                  654,520               _            76,760 562,286    174,040                 1,834,070   84,124  7,600
IIJ Kon Tum Town                      343,710                    _       23,560            174,040                  142,500    49,590  7,600     _
I Hoa BInh Commune                  109,440                   __                          16,530                  103,170   23,560   7,600
2 H'Reng Commune                     21,717                      __                       87,970                             2,413 __
3 DAk Wa Commune            __      123,120               _                                                                 13,680
4 Dak P1I Comrnmune                  89,433,                           23,560             69,540                   39,330    9,937
11.2 Kon PLong District               310,810                            53,200 562,286                            1,691,570   34,534
I Dak Ta Ve Communc                 120,008                            53,200        _        _                   201,058   13,334
2 Dak Ru6ng Commune_                                                                                              224,200
3 TAn LAp Commune                    91,382                   _                                                   202,464   10,154
4 KonPLong Town                      99,419               _                     _      _                          140,334   11,047
5 Mang Canh Commrune           _                                              361,000                              38,000
6 Hieti Commune                                   _                           201,286               __   _        395,314
7 Pd t Commune                                            _                                                       490,200
III  Quang NgAi Province     285,798   713,446   39,140      _                              434,606                            79,272            820,686
111.1 Ba To District          66,690    92,032  16,340 __                                                                      10,226           120,422
1 Ba Ti&u Commtine          4 560     3 420   4,940 _                                     _             _       _              380            17,822
2 BaNgac Commune           62,130    88,612   11,400          _      _____       ___     ____           _           _._      9,846            102,600



Agricultural land                                  Forest land
No.         Name                                                                                    Other Growth    Natural   I ltand  Grond Wild land
Rice    Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew   Coffee  Rubber    Pine   Eucalyptus industria foladeGrundWildlan
I  trees__      _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
III.2 Soz Ha District        169,708   262,314  19,000          __      _        _         335,806                             29,146           553,432
1 Son Ba Commune           19,000    37,620                                               15,200                             4,180           121,866
2 Son Ky Commune           11,400    17,100                    _                          68,400                             1,900             79,762
3 Son Thuy Commune         60,800    71,820   19,000              _                                                          7,980             34,580
4 Son Cao Commune          23,028                 _      _                                                                                    216,638
S Son Giang Commune         8,360  _                        _                            174,306 _    __             _                         13,680
6 Son ThSnh Commune        16,720    46,512 .                 _                           55,100          _                  5,168             52,820
7 Son Ha Commune           30,400    89,262                   _               _    _      22,800                             9,918             34,086
111.3 Son Tinh District        3,800   119,700              _                               26,600 _13,300                                       21,052
I inh Giang Commune         3,800   119,700                                              26,600              _              13,300            21,052
III.4 Tra Bong District        3,800   136,800   3,800       _                               72,200                            15,200           125,780
1 Tra Tan Commune           3,800   102,600                                              26,600 .            _              11,400            25,992
2 Tra Binh Commune                   34,200   3,800                                       45,600     __            _         3,800             99,788
III.5 Binh Son District       41,800   102,600                _                                                                11,400
1 Binh My Commune                    27,360    __                                     ___                                    3,040
2 Binh Minh Commtne        26,600    47,880                                                                                  5,320
3 Binh Khuong Commune       7,600    13,680            .         _                             _        _    _      .___     1,520
4 Binh Nguyen Commune       7,600    13,680                                        .                         _               1,520    _
I    Quang Ngai Province     254,600    51,300   24,700        _           3,800            258,400     _      _                 5,700           249,584
1.1 Binh Son District       254,600    51,300  24,700                     3,800            258,400_   __                       5,700           249,584
I Binh Minh Commune        89,300    15,390   9,500                     3,800             34,200                 _           1,710            32,490
2 Binh Chwrong Commune     45,600     6,840   7,600                  _   _        _       49,400                  _            760             87,970
3 Binh Long Commune        70,300    13,680       _          __     _                     53,200                             1,520             45,904
4Binh Phu6c Commune        30,400    15,390   3,800                                       91,200                             1,710             50,540
5 Binh Thuan Commune       19,000        _    3,800      _   _       __                   30,400                   _          ___    ___       32,680
69



Agrinultural land                                  Forest land      .        .
No.  Name                                                                ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Other  Residta Bra-Wild land
Rice    Vegetable  Fruit  Cashcw  Coffee   Rubber   Pine    Eucalyptus industria Gfrsth  fotresItlan    Ground
I    Quing Ngai Provincc       7,600     6,840   7,600                  - -   -            133,000                               760            95,418
1.1 Binh Son District         7,600     6,840   7,600                  .                  133,000                _7_ 760                       95,418
I Binh Nguyen Commune      7,600      6,840   7,600 _                                   133,000                               760 .          95,418
II   Quitng Nam Province     978,576   406,330 277,476 60,800 ___                        1,248,604   ___               _      45,148           592,952
H1.] NOi Thdnh District     237,500    37,620  26,600                                     546,858               _              4,180          248,216
1 Tam Nghia Commune       47,500      6,840  9_            _                              1,200                               760            93,480
2 Tam Mg Commune          121,600     6,840   7,600                                      50,350                               760            24,320
3 Tam Hiep Commune         15,200                                                        89,300                          _            _      19,000
4 Tam Anh Commune          45,600    23,940  19,000      _                              135,014                             2,660            46,056
5 Tam Xuan II Commune          _                            _       _                   104,994 __                                           65,360
6 Tam Xuan I Commune        7,600                               _                        76,000
11.2 Tam K_ District        310,916    85,466  53,238   7,600  _                          133,532     __ _                     9,496            54,036
1 Tam Ng=c Commune         7,600      6,840                   _     _                     7,600 _  _                          760             8,930
2 Tam Thai Commune         74,100    37,586  27,626                                      50,426          __                 4,176            43,282
3 Tam Dan Commune          19,000     6,840   3,800                                      10,412                               760
4 Tam Vinh Commune         49,4001   10,260   6,612  3,800        _          _            7,600     _           _           1,140
__5 Tam Phu6c Commune        107,616    13,680   7,600  3,800 _                             30,742                    .         1,520
6 Tam LOc Commune          34,200    10,260   7,600                                       3,952        _                    1,140
7 Tam Thanh Commune        19,000                             _                          22,800                                               1,824
II3 Thdng Binh District     123,500 _ 80,815    41,800 26,600    _                         98,800                              8,979           95,000
I Binh Quy Commune         7,600     13,235                                              1 _   _  19,000                    1,471            19,000
2 BiLh Qu6 Commune          3,800    12,996               ____                           22,800                             1,444       .
3 Blnh Phu Commune         68,400    14,330   3,800     .   _                            19,000                             1,592            15,200
4 Binh Dinh Commune        43,700    40,253  38,000 26,600                               38,000   _              _  _       4,473      .     60,800
11.4 Que Son District                  27,360   76,000 19,000  _                          211,280 _    _           __          3,040           30,400
70



Agncultural land                                   Forest land
No.         Name                                                                                   Othier GrwleNtra        scidetia Burial- Wild land
Rlicr   Vcgetable  Fruit  Cashew  Coffee   Rubber    Pine   Eucalyptus industia fGrewt  Natutr  al lan  Ground
___________                  ______________   ~~~~~~~I trees
1 PhM Tho Commune                    17,100  76,000                                     121,866                             1,90(            30,400
2 Qu6 Xufn Commune   _               10,260         19,000                               89,414                             1,140
11.5 Duy Xuyen District      82,460    71,820  30,400                _                    187,834           _                 7,980           133,000
I Duy Tnmng Commune        19,(00    6,840    7,600             _              _        90,554                               760
2 Du San Commune           32,300    61,560  19,000                              _       68,020  _     __                   6,840             7,600
3 Duy Chau Commune         31,160     3,420   3,800 _29,260                                                _                  380           125,400
11.6 Dien Ban District      224,200   103,250  49,438  7,600                               70 7 G ,300 _                     11,472            32,300
I Difn Quang Commune      22,800    49,932   19,000_                                                                        5,5481           24,700
2 Dien H6ng Commune       140,600 _  20,520  11,438                                                             _____       2,280             5,700
3 Dien Ti6n Commune        60,800    32,798  19,000  7,600 _                      _      70,300                             3,644             1,900
III  Da Nang City            169,366    18,810   8,360       .                              40,888 _      _       _            2,090             5,320
111.1 Hoa Vang District     169,366    18,810    8,360                                     4088_ 4,8                           2,090             5,320
1 Hoa Ti6n Commune        161,766   10,260    5,700     _  __                                                               1,140             2,660
2 Hoa Tho Commune           7,600     8,550   2,660                                      40,888                               950             2,660
TOTAL                    1,695,940 1,936,917 357,276160,80i 389,880 224,390 562,286,2,289,538           15,200 1,834,070   226,613   7,600.1,763,960
71



3: STATISCS ON TEMPORARY LAND REQUISITION
Unit: m2
Agrcultural land                                   Forest land
No.          Name                                                                                    Other                    Resideti Burial-  Wild
Rice   Vegetable   Fruit  Cashew  Coffee  Rubber     Pine   Eucalyptus industrial Greowt  Natural  al land Ground  land
trees                 _
I      :Gia Lai Province                 20,291                   92,340   34,065                      _        3,600             2,255 _
1.1  Chi Pdh District                  20,291 _                 92,340   34,065                               3,600             2,255
1 Phui Hoa Town                       4,901                    2,655   11,700                                          _       545
2 Hoa Phld Commune                               _   _        28,800    3,600                               3,600
3 Ea Khucrn Commune                  15,390                   60,885   18,765                                     _   _       1,710
II    Kon Tum Province            _             __    _ 155,018            18,180  133,173    41,220          _        434,385   19,924  1,800
IIJ  Kon Tum Town                  _    81,405                        .    5,580             41,220 _                  33,750   11,745  1,800
1 Hoa Binh Commune            2_25,920                             .                       3,915            _       24,435    5,580  1,800
2 H'Reng Commune                      5,144          _            - .             _       20,835                                572
3 Dak Wa Commune                _    29,160                ,                                                                  3,240
4 Dak Pla Comune                     21,182          _            _     5,580             16,470                     9,315    2,354
11.2 Kon PLong District                 73,613               _            12,600  133,173                             400,635    8,179      .   _
1 D5k Ta Ve Commune                  28,423    _                       12,600    .                                  47,619    3,158
2 Dak Ru6ng Commune                          _                       _           .             _        ___   _     53,100
3 Tan Lap Commune              _     21,643                                                                         47,952    2,405
4 Kon PLong Town                     23,547  3__                                                               _    33,237    2,616
5 Mang Canh Commune _ _._                                                       85,500             _                 9,000
6 Hi6u Commune                                                                  47,673        _                     93,627
_7 P6 t Comrnune               __               _       .                         _                                    116,100
IH    Quing Ngai Province      67,689   168,974    9,270                                     102,933  _     _                    18,775         194,373
III.I Ba ToDistrict            15,795 _ 21,797    3,870                                                                          2,422          28,521
1 Ba Tieu Commune           _ 1,080 _  810     1,170 _                                                                          90)           4,221
72



Agricultural land                                   Forest land    Residet Bunal-    Wild
No.          Name                                              iOther                                         Groth    NaturalRsdei       ura-   Wl
oRice  Vegetable   Fruit  Cashew  Coffee   Rubber     Pine   Eucalyptus industrial                al land Ground   land
Rice                                       Eucalyptus ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~res forest  forest
2 Ba Ngac Commune           14,715 _  20,987   2,700               _ _                                                         2,332           24,300
III.2 Son Ha District          40,194    62,127   4,500                                        79,533                     ____     6,903         131,076
__I Son Ba Commune              4,500     8,910         |  __            _        _   _         3,600                         _   __990            28,863
2 Son Ky Commune             2,700 _  4,050        __               _  _                   16,200 ___      _                     450           18,891
3 Son Thuy Commune          14,400   17,010    4,500                                     . -                _      _            1,890 _     _   8,190
4 Son Cao Commune            5,454 _                                                    . .                                                    51,309
5 Son Giang Commune          1,980                          .                              41,283 _    _ _                           _          3,240
6 SSon Thanh Commune         3,960   11,016 _                  .                           13,050         .                     1,224   _      12,510
7 Son Ha Commune            7,200    21,141      _   _        .       _        _            5,400                              2,349            8,073
11.3 Son Tinh District           900    28,350                                                 6,300                              3,150           4,986
1 Tinh Gian Commune           900    28,350                         . _                     6,300                              3,150            4,986
II.4 ira B6ng Dislrict           900    32,400     900                    .      _            17,100      _  _          _         3,600          29,790
I Tra Tan Commune             900    24,300                    .                            6,300                              2,700.          6,156
2 Tra Binh Commune                    8,100      900              _                        10,800    9     0    0        .        0            23,634
Ill.5 Binh Son District         9,900    24,300               _                                                                    2,700
I Binh My Commune                     6,480 _                                                                                    720
2 Blnh Minh Commune          6,300   11,340                _                                .                                   1,260 ___-
3 Binh Khurng Commune        1,800    3,240                                                                     _                360
4 Binh Nguy n Commune        1,800    3,240                        _                                                             360
I____ Quang Ngai Province       60,300    12,150   5,850                      900              61,200                               1,350          59,112
1.1  Binh Son District        60,300    12,150    5,850           _          900  _      _    61,200             _                1,350   __     59,112
I Binh Minh Commune        21,150     3,645    2,250           _          900 _       _     8,100       .                  _     405           7,695
2 Binh Chorcng Commune      10,800     1,620   1,800        _                              11,7(0     1_   _            _        180           20,835
3_ 5 Binh Long Communc      16,650    3,240                                                12,600                                360           10,872
'73



AEricultural land                                  Forest land    Resideti Burial-  Wild
No.  Name                                                                  ~~~~~~~~~        ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Other  ~   aua  lln  rud ln
No.          Name             Rice   Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew   Coffee  Rubber     Pine   Eucalyptus inidustrial Gfrowsth  Nfatresal  a land Ground  land
__________      ~~trees
4 Binh Phu6c Commune        7,200     3,645     900              __                       21,600                               405           11,970
5 Binh Thuan Commune        4,500               900                                        7,200                                              7,740
I     Quang Ngai Province       1,800     1,620    1,800      _   _                           31,500       _    _          _       180           22,599
l.1  Binh Son District         1,800    1,620    1,800     _                                31,500                    . _         180,         22,599
1 Binh Nguyen Commune       1,800     1,620   1,800                                       31,500                               180_          22,599
II    Quang Nam Province      231,768    96,236   65,718  14,400                             295,722   _                         l 0,693        140,436
11.1 Ntd Thanh District       56,250     8,910   6,300                             _        129,519                               990           58,788
1 Tam Nghia Commune        11,250     1,620                       _          _            21,600                               180           22,140
2 Tam My Commune           28,800     1,620    1,800          _                           11,925                                180           5,760
3 Tam Hiep Commune          3,600                                _                        21,150                                              4,500
4 Tam Anh Commune          10,800     5,670   4,500                                       31,977                               630           10,908
5 Tam Xuan 11 Commune          _ _                                                        24,867                                             15,480
6 Tam Xuan I Commune        1,800                         _                               18,000                              __
11.2 Tam JK District          73,638    20,242  12,609   1,800                               31,626                              2,249          12,798
1 Tam Ngoc Commune          1,800     1,620       _                                        1,800                               180            2,115
_ 2 Tam Thai Commune         17,550     8,902    6,543                                      11,943       ____                    989           10,251
3 1 am Dan Commune          4,500     1,620     900               _   _       _            2,466                       __      180
4 Tam Vinh Commune         11,700     2,430    1,566    900                                1,800                               270,
5 Tam Phir6e Commune       25,488     3,240    1,800    900                                7,281                               360 .
6 Tam Lc Commune           8,100     2,430    1,800                                         936                      ___      270
7 Tam Thalh Commune         4,500        _                  _                _             5,400                                               432
11.3 Thang Binh District      29,250    19,140   9,900   6,300    _                          23,400        _    _    _           2,127          22,500
1 Binh Quy Commune_         1,800     3,135  ._____                                        4,500                       _       348            4,500
2 Binh Qu6 Commune         _ 900      3,078                        . __. _                 5,400                               342 .
74



A dcultural land                                  Forest land
No._Nam      Arctlra                                                          Resideti Burial-  Wild
No.          Name         |  Rice    Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew  Coffee  Rubber    Pine   Eucalyptus itidustnalh frowth  Natua  al land Ground  land
trees
3 BiTh Phi Commune         16,200    3,394     900                   .                   4,500                               377           3,600
4 Binh Dinh Commune        10,350    9,534   9,000   6,300               _ _             9,000    __     __                1,059          14,400
I1.4 Qug'Son District        _          6,480  18,000   4,500               0_ _           5,040 __                            720            7,200
_   1 Phui Tho Commune                   4,050   18,000                      ____           28,863 .__                           450           7,200
2 Qu6 Xuan Commune            _      2,430           4,500        _         _           21,177 _                           _ 270
11.5 Duy Xuyen District       19,530   17,010   7,200     .              _     _           44,487  __      _        _   __    1,890          31,500
1 Duy Trung Commune    __ 4,500      1,620   1,800                                      21,447 .         _        _          180
2 Duy Son Commune           7,650   14,580   4,500   _. _                               16,110                             1,620           1,800
3 Duy ChAu Commune          7,380      810     900                 .                     6,930 _    __            _           90          29,700
11.6  )ien Ban District       53,100   24,454  11,709   1,800_                             16,650                             2,717           7,650
1 Dien Quang Commune       5,400    11,826   4,500                                                                         1,314           5,850
2 DiCn H6ng Commune        33,300    4,860   2,709       .                  _                                                540           1,350
3 Dien Ti6n Commune        14,400    7,768   4,500   1,800                              16,650                               863            450
Ill   Da Nang City             40,113    4,455    1,980                                      9,684                      _        495           1,260
111.1 Hod Vang District       40,113    4,455    1,980                                      9,684               _               495           1,260
1 HoA TiMn Commune    _   3_8,313    2,430   1,350                                                                          270             630
2 Hoa Tho Commune           1,800    2,025     630                                       9,684                               225            630
TOTAL       _          401,670  458,744   84,618 14,400   92,340   53,145  133,173  542,259            3,600  434,385   53,672 1,800 417,780
75



4: STATISTICS ON PERMANENT LAND ACQUISITION
2
Unit: m
Agncultural land                                   Forest land   Resideti Burial-  Wild
No.           Name              Rice   Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew  Coffee   Rubber     Pine   Eucalyptus  Other  Growth  Natural  al land Ground   land
R. ce   Vegetable                                                    industrial  forest  forest__
I     Gia Lai Province                       852                    3,880     22,401                               151               95
LI   Chic Pdh District                      852              _    3,880     22,401                               151               95
I Phu Hoa Town                           206                     112        492                                                 23
2 Hoa Pha Commune                                      __      1,210        151                               151                          __
3 Ea Khuatn Commune                      647                   2,558        788                                                  72
4 Chit Pah Rubber Farm                                                   20,970
II    Kon Tum Province                      6,513                               764    5,595     1,732                   18,250     837      76
I.l Kon Tum Town                         3,420                                234             1,732                     1,418     493      76
I Hoa Binh Commune                     1,089                  _                               164                     1,027    234      76
2 H'Reng Commune                         216                                                  875                                24
3 DAk Wa Commune                       1,225                                                                                    136
4 Dak PIA Commune                        890    _                           234               692                      391       99
11.2 Kon PLong Districi                   3,093             __                 529    5,595                             16,832     344
I D±k To Ve Commune            . _     1,194                                529                _              _ _    2,001      133
2 DAk Ru6ng Commune                               __                                                                  2,231
3 Tan Lap Commune                        909 _     _                                                                  2,015     101
4 Kon PLong Town                         989                                                                          1,396     110
5 Mang CAnh Commune                                                                3,592_                              378
6 Hi6u Commune                                            _                 _      2,003                              3,934
7 Pb t Commune                                        __                                                              4,878
76



No.            Name                                           Agricultural land                                  Forest land   Resideti Burial-  Wild
Rice   Vegetable  Fruit  Cashew  Coffee   Rubher     Pine   Eucalyptus  Other  Growth  Natural  al land  Ground  land
________________________                                                ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~ ~~industrial  forest  forest
III   Quiang Ngai Province        2,844     7,099     389                                        4,325                              789            8,166
1II I Ba TorDistrict               664      916      163                                                                           102            1,198
1 Ba Tieu Commune               45        34      49                        .                                                     4              177
2 Ba Ng4c Commune              618       882      113_|                                                                          98            1,021
111.2 Son Ha District            1,689     2,610     189   .    |                               3,342                              290            5,507
I Son Ba Commune               189       374                                                  151                                42            1,213
2 Scn Ky Commune        _      113       170                                     _            681           _      __            19              794
3 Son Thuy Commune             605       715 _    189___.                                                        _               79              344
4 Son Cao Commune              229____                                                                                                         2,156
5 Son Giang Commune             83                                                           1,734,                                              136
6 Son Thanh Commune            166       463                                                  548                                51             526
7 San Ha Commune               303       888                                                  227                                99              339
111.3 Son Tinh District             38     1,191                                          _      265    _      _                   132              209
I Tinh Giang Commune            38     1,191 _                                                265                               132             209
111.4 Trd Bdng District             38     1,361      38              .                           718    _         _               151            1,252
I Tr_ TAn Commune               38     1,021                                                  265                               113             259
2 Tr_ Binh Commune                       340      38                                          454               _                38             993
i11L5 Binh Son District            416     1,021-                                                                                  113
I Binh Mg Commune                        272                      _                                                              30
2 Blnh Minh Commune            265       476                                                                                     53
3 Binh Khuacng Commune          76       136                                                                 _            _      15
4 Binh Nguyen Commune           76       136           .                                                         _       _       15
Quang Ngai Province         2,533      510      246                        38            70,571              __ 57                           2,484
LI   Binh Son District          2,533       510     246 _                      38   __        70,571                          1    571           2,484
I Birnh Minh Commune           889       153      95   _                     38 _   __        340  _                             17             323
77



o  Agricultural land                                Forest land    Resideti Burial-   Wild
Rice   Vegetable   Fruit  Cashew  Coffee    Rubber     Pine   Eucalyptus industrial  forewsth  forest  al land  Ground  land
2 Binh Chtuong Commune          454 _       68 _    76        _         _                 _      492 _     =     =                     8              875
3 Binh Long Commune             700        136                                                   529                _                 15  __          457
4 Blnh Phu6c Commune             303       153      38                                           908                                  17              503
5 Binh Thuan Commune             189                38                                         68,303                                    _            325
1.1  Binh Son District               76    _68 __ 76 __         _   _|                            1,323                                   8              949
1 Binh Nguyen Commune            76        68       76     _                                    1,323 _     _                          8       _      949
11     Quang Nam Province           9,738    4,043    2,761    605                    _         _   12,425  ___         .     __         449      _      5,900
11.1  Nuii Thanh District         2,363       374     265                                  . _     5,442   ___                           42            2,470
I Tam Nghia Commune             473        68               _                                    908                                   8              930
2 Tam My Commune               1,210        68      76                                  _         501                                  8              242
3 Tam Hip Commune                151      _ .                                                     889                                                 189
4 Tam Anh Commune                454      238      189                                          1,343                                 26              458
5 Tam XuAn II Commune                                       .                                   1,045                                  _              650
6 Tam Xuan I Commune              76                    __                              _        756
11.2  Tam Ky District             3,094       850     530      76                                  1,329                                 94              538
1 Tam Ngoc Commune               76        68                     .       .                       76                                   8               89
2 Tam Thai Commune               737       374     275                                     _      502 .                               42              431
3 Tam Dan Commune                189       68       38                                            104                                  8
4 Tam Vinh Commune               492       102      66      38                                     76                                 11  _
S Tam PhLrdc Commune ___       1,071       136      76      38                                   306         _                        15  _
6 Tam Loc Commune                340       102      76      _                 .                    39                                 11
7 Tam Thanh Commune              189  ___                                     _                  227               _                                   18
11.3  T'hdng Binh District        1,229      804      416     265                     _    _        983        _       _  _      _       89       _      945
I Blnh Quy Commune               76       132      _                   . _                       189    _              __   __        15              189
2 Binh Quc Commune                38       129                                                   227 _                                14   ___
78



No._Name                         Agricultural land                                   Forest land   Resideti Burial-   Wild
Rice   Vegetable   Fruit  Cashew  Coffee   Rubber      Pine  Eucalyptus OndOuhstrral forest  fres   land  Ground    land
3 Binh Phu Commune       _      681       143       38       _                     _             189                     _           16             151
4Blnh Dinh Commune              435       401      378    2655                                   378                                45              605
11.4  Qu1Son District                        272      756    189                                  2,102                                30              303
I Phu Tho Commune                         170     756   __    t_1,213_                                                              19              303
2 Que Xuan Commune                        102             189                                    890                                 11
II.5  Duy Xuyen District  _        821       715      303 ___                                     1,869                                 79            1,323
1 Duy Trung Commune             189        68       76    _                                     901               __                 8
2Duy Scn Commune               321       613      189                                           677                                681              76
-3 Du Chau Commune              310        34       38     _                                     291 __   _                           4      _     1,248
11.6 Dien Ban District            2,231     1,027     492     76                                    700                               114              321
I Dien Quang Commune            227 _     497      189    _                                                                         55              246
2 Dien 16nCmu                  1,399      204      114                        __        _  _         __                             23    ___        57
3 ,Din Tirn Commune             605       326      189     76                  .                 700                                36               19
III  IDa NAng City                 1,685       187      83 ___              _                     15,113            _                    21               53
II.I  Hod Vang District           1,685      187       83             __                         15,113                                 21               53
I Hoa Ti6n Commune             1,610      102       57     _                                  14,706 __    _                        11               26
2 Hod Tho Commune                76        85       26      _                                    407       _     ___   _              9              26
TOTAL                                                                                     ______   _____    _____           _
16,876    19,274    3,555    605    3,880     23,203    5,595  105,489              151   18,250    2,255      76   17,553
79



5: STAT'ISTICS ON AFFECTED STRUCTURES
- ____             Complete affection                                  Partial affection
N   Total Total            Type of house                  Resid. Total           ype of hous              Resid
No.          Naiiic        ScClle>n tSttlt'ucholc                                  Aux                                              Aux.t  t
tur-es    7AYeaAea                  Area       Struc.             Area      Area      Area               2
holds AreaQuant     2   Quant'      Quant'      (in2   holds   2)QaQuant     uat      Quant'     (m)
I    Gia Lai Province                 14   14 _        _    354     7   328     7   122 ___
Li Chli Pah District        __       14   14               354      7   328    7   122               __
1 Ph Hoa Town                     5     5               206     3     168    2   122
2 Hoa Phu Commune                 9     9                148    4     160    5 _      _
II_ Kon_Tum Province                  65   65              2,002   41   855    24   977 22,995                                       _
11.1 Kon Tum Town                   21    21              1,035   17   134    4    461  18,695
1 Hoa Binh Commune                16   16               855    13      84    3   179  16,125            __    _
2 Chit H'Reng Commune             4     4              _ 180    4                242   2,170
3 Ddk PTh Commune                  I    1                              50    1    40     400
11.2 Kon PLong District              44    44               967    24   721   20   516   4,300   ___
1 D&k Tc Ve Commune               10   10                  80     4   160    6    90     400                       ____
2 Tan Lap Commune                 7     7             _  28     1     182    6    97    1,900            _          _
3 Kon PLong Town                  17    17              710    15      64    2   329   2,000                   _    __.
4 Hi6u Commune                    10    10       _       149    4     315    6
III Quang Ngai Province              15   15    40    1    589    11    80    3    250   3,050                   _
III.l Ba ToyDistrict                 3    3     40    1   _ 80    2                       800
1 Ba Ngac Commune                 3     3    40    1   _ 80     2             _          800                                     _
11.2 Son Ha District                1     1                            20     1  1       300 0 0
I San Thanh Commune               I     1                              20    1           300
I11.3 Son Tinh District              1     1                             20     1
1Tinh Giang Comm une              I I   1             _                20    1              _                                _        _



Complete affection                                 Partial affection
Total Total           Type of house                 Resid. Total _  __        of hous               Resid
jNo.        Name           Section |Sttruc-hhOude                      Te pce   Aux                                              A  . t
ueshouse  L-evel 3    Level 4                     area  house- Level 3   Level 4      Me3P. area
hueslolds Area      Area  Qt'Area          Struc.  -m2   od      ra     Ae    -   Area      Struc. (i2)
(rn2  Qunt'  Qurit'(M2  Quanit'   (i)hld        m  Quant' (2 Quant' (M)Quant' 
III.5 Binh Son District              10   10              509     9    40     1  250   1,950
1 Binh Minh Commune              5     5                179     4    40    1   120   1,110                _              _         __
2 Binh Nguyen Commune            5     5                330     5              130     840                        _
I   Quing Ngai Province             16   16   260    2   824    13    40    1    315   3,350                             _
L.I Binh Son District              16   16   260    2    824   13    40     1   315   3,350       __
1 Binh Minh Commune              1     1                 80     1 _             40    200                                 ___
2 Binh Chucrng Commune           6     6    260     2   280     4              120   1,050       _   _
3 Binh Long Commune              4     4                134     3    40    1    60     950
4 Binh Phu6c Commune             5     5                330     5               95   1,150       _
I   Quatng Ngai Province            7    6               107     3    65    3    80    767     1              50    1             50   100
L.1 Binh Son District              7     6               107    3    65    3     80    767     1             50    1             50   100
1 Binh Nguyen Commune            7     6                107    - 3   65    3    80    767    1              50     1    .       50   100
IV  Quang Nam Province              171  164             8,580   162    60    2 2,828 159,257    7            247    6   15    1  112 4,680
IV.J Niii Thanh District             5     5              320     5               110    650       __.
I Tam My Commune                 5   _ 5      _         320     5              110    650 __
IV.2 Tam Ky District                 61   59             3.039   57    60     2 1,016 58,343     2    _        50    2             70   480
1 Tam Ngoc Commune               2     2                114     2               70    693 __                   _              __
2 Tam Thai Commune               35   33               1,710   31    60    2   599 27,100    2              50    2             70   480
3 Tan- Dan Commune               2     2    =_=_       _110     2  __           40   7,000  ===
4 Tam Vinh Commune               8     8                290     8               96   6,450           _
5 Tam Phu6c Commune              10   10    _        _ 580     10              120 12,350 _                            .
6 Tam L6c Commune                4     4                235     4               91   4,750           _
IV.3 Thdag Binh District  _____     26    23              875    23          .   316 29,250      3    ___     130    2  15     1   20
81



Complete affection                                   Partial affection
No.  P'~~~me      Section S~Ttalc Total          T3 pe of house ______Resid. Total                    Tye of house               Resid
No.         Name           sLction   Sti-uc- hIouse  Level 3  Level 4    Ter       Aux    area  house- Level 3    Level 4    Temp    AUx- . area
tures hod    raArea                 Area Qun'Struc.      2   hls8,a          Area      Area       Struc-  M
holdsuaArea          Quant'   2  Qat(m                       I holdstAre   Quant'  2 Quant'(i)
I Binh Phi Commune                3     2                  38     2                18   2,500   1                         15    1         100
2 Binh Dinh Commune               23    21                837    21               298 26,750    2              130    2              20 2,500
IV.4 Que'Son District                 18   17                900    17              242 22,500      1             35     1             12 1,400
1 Phiu Tho Commune                18   17                 900    17               242 22,500    1               35     1             12 1,400
IV.5 Duy Xyn District            _    20   20              1,088   20               408 16,750        _ _                           _   _
1 Duy Trung Commune               2     2                 135 _   2 .              60   5,200
2 Duy Son Commune       __    _   12    12           _    675    12               276   7,100 _
3 Duy Chau Commune                 6    6                 278     6                72   4,450     _                 _
IV.6 Dien Ban District                41   40              2,358   40               736 31,764      1    _        32     1             10   200
1 Dian Quang Commune              10    10                580    10               166  11,750                       _
2 Dian H6ng Commune               22    22   _      _    1,343   22               493  15,590  _ 
3 Dian Tien Commune                9    8                 435     8                77   4,424   1               32     1             10   200
V   Da NMng City                       9     9  330     1    545     8               142   7,086      .
V.1 Hoa Vang                          9     9   330    1    545     8               142   7,086
Hoa Tidn Commune                 5    5             _   365     5               107   5,686                   .                 _
Hoa Tho Commune                  4    4     330     1   180     3                35   1,400                        _       .      _
Total                           297   289   630    4 13,001   245 1,428    40 4,714 196,505     8            297     7  15     1  162 4,780
82



6: NATURAL FEATURES OF CONCERNED DISTRICTS
Area (ha)                              Population and Labour
No.       Name                Agncultural      Residential     Population in No. of families  Employment Pop. growth
_  Total area  arca  Forestry are  area  Others  1999  ill 1999  Labours  (%)  rate(%)
I   Gia Lai Province   179,990   17,096  71,117   2,380  89,396   70,388   13,964   41,891
1.1 Chu Pah District  179,990   17,096  71,117   2,380  89,396   70,388    13,964  41,891  95.00    2.30
II  Kon Tum Province    90,240   21,101  36,372   1,770  30,997  100,756   19,312   60,734
11.1 Kon Tum Town      44,042   14,667   14,628   1,576  13,171  72,786    13,995  44,784   98.00    2.30
11.2 Kon PLong District  46,198  6,434   21,745    193   17,826  27,970     5,317   15,950  98.00    2.30
III Quang Ngai Province  384,298  57,356  114,516  3,110 209,317  515,887  111,233  337,918
III.1 Ba Ter District  111,657   5,210   18,852     161  87,434   41,477    8,056   24,168  95.00    2.20
111.2 ScTn Ha District  118,356  7,533   67,045     236  43,542   74,234   14,346   43,038  95.00    2.20
111.3 San Tinh District  35,247  21,513   2,975   1,353   9,407  185,464   40,062  120,185  95.00    1.85
E11.4 Tra B6ng District  69,933  3,678   19,050     336  46,870   41,958    8,437   29,529  93.00    2.00
M15 Binh Son District  49,105  19,423    6,594   1,024  22,064  172,755   40,333  120,998  95.00    1.90
IV  Quiang Nam Province  258,600  84,234  110,647  6,619  57,100  763,458  174,136  522,409
IV.1 NMi IThnh District  45,199  10,114  22,891     784  11,410  123,678   28,336   85,009  86.00    1.85
IV.2 Tam Ky District    34,869   16,377  11,778     875   5,840  117,932   28,830   86,490  85.00    1.80
IV.3 Thang Binh District  47,173  25,623  4,906   1,944  14,701  166,023   39,061  117,183  87.00    1.80
IV.4 Qu6 Son District   75,401   14,026  52,149     950   8,277  120,553   28,453   85,358  85.00    1.80
IV.5 Duy Xuyen District  31,695  11,544  10,575     777   8,799  118,431   26,987   80,961  85.00    1.85
IV.6 Dien Ban District  24,263    6,551   8,350   1,290   8,072  116,841   22,469   67,408  90.00    2.20
V   Oai Nitng City  X__  87,269  14,537  56,909   29484  13,340  193,295   42,894  128,681 _
V.1 Hoa Vang District   87,269  14,537   56,909   2,484  13,340 _ 193,295  42,894  128,681  80.00    2.00
TONG              1,000,397  194,325  389,561  16,362  400,149 1,643,784  361,539 1,091,633
83



7 - PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
No                   Item                 ___      2001            ___      2002           _       2003      ___2004                                2005
I  II  ~III   IV     I     II   III    IV    I     1I    III   IV     I     II   III   IV          II    III   IV
1 Survey for PFS, RAP, EIA
2 FS. RAP, EIA completion
3 Approval for FS, RAP, EIA
4 Survey for technical design
5 Bidding document preparation
6 Bidding for civil works
7   Establishment of PRBs, DRBs. CRBs.
8   Review of accurate compensation for
PAPs
9 Review of accurate compensation unit
10 Application of compensation unit price
for PAPs
I I Payment of compensation and allowanCe
12 Foundation construction
13 Tower erection
1 4Stringing works
15   Supervision___
16 AcceptaLnce
17 Reimbursement
84



w        et. g -  -  -      yez-  ; 
'i *% L; *                                              S             
5,     _  -4                                 N--2-~' 3
S~~~~~c ,':u .OK SRSTAT<)r*N                       -     _ -  4;SS__ _ _
9             .1- | r@- ,T 
.._ _                     -i   _     ; t/ ,
*t_ _ -'I        !   *'     2                       Y      L ieietr -eaLc_( ADUSAlNOIlN
-t             7
r I
I -~~~       J
- {-l - ' - j 1           .t- 8  - _MngrNueDcThn
-- __'-=i 4;uir}v wiI  rI                      4G7 ,g                              -  .-U.IChekVu -ragDu 
iG auT'Q SUBSTATION-ZZ
7_-'~     -  '   -   j 1-  *  We ;  ,  .  ,'  /  ChieftDiv  NguyenVanAn  _  frr,-FS | 7-2001 | zjz2.. 4D
-    8     Z ,  ChieftDiv. D aoQuangHan L *'r-qScale If50000 '
t ~~~K 74%
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
K~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
POWER ENGINREING CONSULTING COMPANY NOA
1OOKV TRANSMISSION LINLNEOTMA
Vice irecor L VanLuc  ND SUBSTATION POSITIONS
~~  ~~  'A~~~   Manager  NguyenDuccThan
-i ( ,cIKVSLDSIAT1ION  T'       _k_.___    gD-
Chieft Div.  Ngye  VaAnr      E     01     201 OD.01
Chift Div. DoQagHn           cl  5  0



ANNEX 5 - LIST OF ASSOCIATED REPORTS
PECCI. Prefeasibility study for Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang 500kV
transmission line
PECCI. Resettlement Action Plan report for Playcu - Dung Quat - Da Nang
500kV transmission line
86