Decision-Maker's Guide to Solid Waste Landfills - . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ , .r,' . I_- W- - >*e ,. _ _, ! "t-c. e x r * - ,_ . - -V~~I tC- -..+# ,1& A .y S U M M A R Y DECIS$ON-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLiD WYASTE LANDFILLS This report is a summary of a technical document on the planning, siting, design and operation of landfills in middle and lower-income countries. The full technical report is intended for professional waste managers. This summary aims to identify the most important factors involved in decision-making, and is a guide for local politicians and others. The practice of open dumping must be stopped on the grounds of public health and safety. A higher standard of waste disposal is achievable at affordable cost by moving towards sanitary landfilling. Practical guidance is available to waste managers to achieve these standards. It requires only the political will to lead a municipality away from open dumping. Author Notes This Summary was compiled by Maggie Thurgood from the full text of the 'Decision Maker's Guide on the Planning, Siting, Design and Operation of Landfills in Middle- and Lower-income Countries' written by Philip Rushbrook and Mike Pugh, WHO Nancy Project Office, France. Additional material for this Summary was provided by them, together with further com- ments and suggestions from: Carl Bartone, Gabriela Boyer, Lars Mikkel Johannessen, and colleagues at the World Bank, Washington DC, USA; Jurg Christen and colleagues at SKAT, St Gallen, Switzerland; and various other individuals and organisations. Specialist assistance to enhance further the practical information presented was provided by Binnie, Black & Veatch. Fund- ing for this project was provided for the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation and the World Bank. IB 1649 Where will all the waste go? The conversion of the open dumps character- istic of many cities around the world to controlled and sanitary landfills is a critical step for protecting public health and the environment. As cities grow and produce more waste, and their waste collection systems become more efficient, open dumping becomes increasingly intolerable. This guide serves as a tool for decision-makers in the solid waste management policy dis- course to make gradual improvements in the short term by upgrading dis- posal of wastes at modest cost while still providing acceptable levels of en- vironmental protection. In the medium to long term, the target should be to achieve full sanitary landfilling together with comprehensive policies and programs to reduce waste generation and increase recycling when it is eco- nomically viable. A more comprehensive technical document on landfill siting, design, construction, operation and closure, which is aimed at pro- fessional waste managers, will also be published. In releasing this publication jointly, the World Bank, the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC), the World Health Organization Re- gional Office for Europe, and the Swiss Centre for Development Cooperation in Technology and Management (SKAT) hope to guide local politicians and decision-makers with the planning, siting, design and operational aspects of waste disposal. We must all cultivate the political will to stop open dumping, and promote an affordable and higher standard of waste disposal while pro- tecting human health and the environment. Anthony Pellegrini Dr. Gunter Klein Director Director Environment and Health Transport, Water and Urban World Health Organization Development Division Regional Office for Europe The World Bank Copenhagen Washington, DC Denmark USA 3 Disposal of waste to land is an inevi- service is to be provided and main- table part of every solid waste man- tained. agement system. Even where waste is processed in some way, for example for recycling or energy recovery, there PROBLE1IS WIAM [RUScC.I1URE DM0AL will still always be a residue which needs land disposal. Wastes which are When wastes are dumped along incorrectly disposed of cause many problems. This Guide aims to help municipali- ties make improvements in solid * Landfill will always be needed waste management by upgrading the * Support of political leaders vital standard of land disposal of wastes at modest cost while still providing * Open dumping damages human acceptable levels of environmental health protection. It should also aid in stra- tegic decision-making on what stan- * Upgraded landfills protect health and the environment dards are to be adopted, what capac- ity is needed, and whether in-house * Improvements can be achieved at technical resources are available. modest cost Many current problems with waste have resulted from increased urban roads and riverbanks, or in aban- population with its inevitable increase doned quarries, it is inevitable that the in waste generation. In addition, there contaminants in that waste will affect are often less resources provided for human health and pollute water sup- solid waste management, and waste plies as well as affect the aquatic food management staff often have a low chain. Grazing animals on dumps can professional status. pass diseases via the terrestrial food Waste management is a vitally impor- chain, as well as by pests through in- tant municipal service and it requires festation. People living on or near a high-calibre managers able to make dump are also at risk. Open dump- decisions if a good quality ing is thus mistakenly believed to be the cheapest disposal method. Adopting a general philosoph.y that open dumping is acceptable because Wastemanagersneedthesupportof "we cannot afford to do anything their political leaders to achieve and else" is wrong. maintain real improvements in the standard of service they provide. It is not acceptable to protect the I health of the majority, by taking away 4 SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 5 WVAY L5 [21' SIU ftLYR I. 1 xPiL DL l o Sanitary landfills are sites where waste is isolated from the environment until it is safe. It is considered safe when it has completely degraded biologically, chemically and physically. In high-income countries, the level of isolation achieved may be high. However, such an expensive high level of isolation may not be technically necessary to protect public health. Four basic conditions should be met before a site canbe regarded as a sanitary landfill (see below). The ways of doing this should be adapted to local conditions. The immediate goal is to meet, to the best extent possible, the four stated basic sanitary landfill conditions, with a longer term goal to meet them eventually in full. Small incrernenal lmorcvelments in lan fill dfsigrn and operation over several years a-e more likely t- succeed tha te af Xe e p-^p 'c make a single, large leap in engineering expectations. Large landfills will require more investment to improve standards than smaller sites. However, the unit cost of these improvements (measured per tonne of waste landfilled or per head of population served) will decrease with increasing site size. There are financial and other benefits to sites with long operating lifetimes (ten years or more). Large regional sites serving two or more cities could be eco- nomically beneficial, providing waste transport costs are not too high. Basic remulnenern's As a minimum, four basic conditions should be met by any site design and opera- tion before it can be regarded as a sanitary landfill: Full or partial hydrogeological isolation - if a site cannot be located on land which naturally contains leachate securely, additional lining materials should be brought to the site to reduce leakage from the base of the site (leachate) and help reduce contamination of groundwater and surrounding soil. If a liner - impermeable or semi-permeable - is provided without a system for leachate collection, all leachate will eventually reach the surrounding environment. Leachate collection and treat- ment must be stressed as a basic requirement. Formal engineering preparations - designs should be developed from local geo- logical and hydrogeological investigations. A waste tipping plan and a final res- toration plan should also be developed. Permanent control - trained staff should be based at the landfill to supervise site preparation and construction, the depositing of waste and the regular operation and maintenance. Planned waste emplacement and covering - waste should be spread in layers and compacted. A small working area which is covered daily helps make the waste less accessible to pests and vermin. In all communities, people generate den wastes, old clothes and furniture, domestic wastes. At the most basic abandoned equipment, packaging level, these consist of food wastes, ani- and newsprint. mal manure, ashes, broken tools and utensils, and old clothing. In an agri- In lower-income countries, domestic cultural community this waste is waste is dominated largely by food readily absorbed into the natural cycle. and ash wastes, while in middle- and However, since the last century, there has been an increase in the number of people living in towns. Urbanisation and industrial development have rap- To manage wastes properly, it is im- idly increased the range and the di- portant to know: versity, as well as the quantity, of * how much waste is being wastes being produced which require produced collection and disposal. * the composition of wastes from Within a municipality there are seven each of the different sources main sources of waste which require (residential, commercial, industrial management. If the community has etc) only a landfill for disposal, all of these how the quantity and composition wastes will need to be landfilled. The of wastes might change in waste manager needs to know about the future the sources and types of waste in the town, as well as the quantities, in or- der to dispose of the wastes safely higher-income countries there is a larger proportion of paper, plastic, metal, glass and discarded manufac- Wastes produced from household ac- tured items. tivities, including food preparation, ,/ _ - , cleaning and fuel burning plus gar- Wastes from shops, offices, restau- Domestic waste (also called residen- rants, hotels and similar commercial tial or household waste) consists of a establishments. The waste typically wide variety of materials. These in- consists of packaging materials, of- clude: fice supplies, and food wastes, and * food wastes * metal has a close similarity to domestic • plastics * glass waste. In lower-income countries, * paper * rubber food markets may contribute a large * leather and hide * textiles proportion of commercial waste. * ash, soil, pottery and china 6 SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 7 I--sf -, - - . 1:/-~..- - Waste from schools, hospitals, gov- : Ui H-I, ernment offices, military bases. Insti- After assessing the quantity, the tutional waste is similar to both do- other characteristics of waste needed mestic and commercial waste, al- to select the most appropriate waste though there is generally a larger pro- disposal option include: moisture portion of paper than food waste. content, potential to biodegrade, Hospital wastes inevitably include heating value and density potentially infectious and hazardous Moisture content - the percentage of materials such as used bandages, the weight of wastes which is water. sharp objects like syringes and This can be determined by drying a needles, and items contaminated with known weight of waste and measur- body fluids. It is important to sepa- ing the weight change. rate the hazardous and non-hazard- ous components in healthcare waste Biodegradable material - the proportion to reduce the risk to health. of biodegradable material in the waste can be calculated by first re- __ ._ee: -<-.iTee,ir.gs moving non-biodegradable organic wastes like plastics and rubber, and Dominated by dust and soil, together then drying the waste at a tempera- with varying amounts of paper, metal ture high enough to burn off the re- and other litter that is picked up from maining organics. the streets. In some countries street Calorific value - this is the amount of sweepings may also include drain heat energy that can be produced if cleanings, plus varying amounts of all of the combustible parts of the household waste dumped at the side waste are burned. If a town or city is of the road, plant remains and animal considering waste incineration, this manure. information is crucial to establish whether the waste will burn without 2 '- CC o T E _ - = G the use of additional fuel such as oil or gas. The composition depends on the type Waste density - this is important at each Thebuildingmaderialssends in te ypae stage in collection and disposal. For of building materials used in a par- planning waste collection, the density ticular area but is typically soil, stone, achieved in each collection vehicle in- brick, wood, clay, reinforced concrete fluences how many are needed to col- and ceramic materials. Inevitably lect the waste in a particular area. some construction waste will need disposal, even though some may be Waste density is also important at the recycled within the construction site. landfill site, as an indication of how recycled within the construction site. much space each delivery of waste , _ . . - . c<\ will take before and after compaction and as a consequence, how long the Where no sewage networks exist total landfill space will last. within towns human waste may be 8 WASTE CHARACTERISTICS collected separately and used for ag- cant when a municipality is making riculture or disposed of in landfills. If decisions about the suitability of a improperly disposed of, this material specific treatment or disposal method, can contaminate water courses and be such as composting or incineration. a source of infectious diseases. It is important for a waste manager 7. Industrial YWJaste in a city to have an indication of the composition of waste in the locality. The composition of industrial waste Sampling of the wastes is not techni- depends on the industries involved. cally difficult, and must be done in Much industrial waste is relatively one or more areas which are statisti- similar to waste from commercial and cally representative. domestic sources, and includes pack- aging, plastics, paper and metal items. In this way, information on waste However, wastes from some indus- composition and characteristics can tries are chemically hazardous. Dis- be obtained to aid in decision-mak- posal routes for hazardous wastes are ing about the viability of waste treat- usually different from those for non- ment processes, collection equipment hazardous wastes, and depend on the changes and recycling initiatives. composition of each waste type. Haz- ardous wastes pose a risk of pollut- ing drinking water supplies, water- courses or land, or harming waste * In general, waste generation per workers, and may need pre-treatment person in high-income countries is to reduce their toxicity if they are to much greater than in lower-income be disposed of on land. countries * Typically, wastes as collected in high-income countries are less dense, as more packaging and lighter materials are discarded, and The compositions of the seven solid less ash and food waste. waste types are highly variable. They are influenced strongly by: climate * Moisture content is higher in and seasonal variation, the economy lower-income countries because of of the region, the physical character- the water in food wastes. Wastes istics of the city, and social and reli- from higher-income countries with gious customs. Variations in solid proportionately less food waste waste composition are most signifi- have lower moisture levels. SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 9 7:C[. ` !]eXr L-ti I-.>II 1gl - R; 3 'S. • How much waste is being produced in the area? It is helpful if this is further broken down into districts and different sources of waste e.g. households, industry, shops and institutions * What is its general composition? * How might the amount or general composition of wastes change in the future? §7iA''s fu-]ll, \.1 C[ F738 %%rC --in SeX,700.A-ILL,7u,D3 Ij r DI L'V. L - 0 :E r 0 S , L perLUS31 'Ilr-.U)LR3YsWikq rg * Waste should be compacted in * Frequent collection of litter from thin bands up to 0.5m which the site helps convey an impres- should be built up into a layer sion of a well-managed site. about 2m deep. This reduces the likelihood of instability and * Drainage ditches should be kept settlement problems in the future clear to avoid problems during wet weather * Compacted waste should be cov- ered daily with 15cm of soil to de- * Site access roads should be kept ter flies and other insects from in good condition to allow breeding in waste, as well as re- vehicles to deposit their waste ducing wind-blown waste and loads quickly and efficiently. Bro- improving the surface for waste ken fences should be repaired vehicles and maintained to prevent ani- mals coming onto the site. * No biodegradable waste should be deposited in water * The general public should be ex- cluded from the site for their own * Open burning should not be per- safety. mitted. Fires can cause hollows in the waste, encouraging instabil- * Records of waste deliveries to the ity, and they could ignite pockets site should be kept, showing who of landfill gas, causing explo- delivered the waste, of what type, sions.Ifnotquicklyextinguished, how much and when. These fires can become deep seated and records are particularly impor- smoulder for many years. tant if the municipality decides to charge waste generators for their * Frequent inspections for vermin waste service. (rodents, other animals, birds and flies) should be made and mea- * Environmental monitoring sures taken to prevent infesta- (which may be simple visual in- tions in order to reduce health spections, or more complex sam- risks. pling and chemical analysis) must be carried out to a regular schedule, and records kept. 20 LANDFILL SITE OPERATION seeing the work to ensure that stan- dards are met. The landfill site manager should re- There is a minimum staffing require- port directly to the chief officer re- ment for a well-managed site where sponsible for all waste management. either manual spreading or mechani- cal waste placement and compaction is undertaken. c MY If machines are used, the minimum The operation of a better managed staffing is: landfill site will, in almost all circum- * a landfill manager based at the site stances, cost more than open dump- *a gate man/office clerk ing. It will, however, avoid money being * a security guard or night watch- man spent at a later date to remediate harm caused by the open dump. * a traffic controller, for organising vehicles at large busy sites It may be possible to meet some of these costs with savings resulting * landfill equipment drivers from improved efficiency within the . me within te waste * a maintenance fitter (iF equipment municipality or within the waste is maintained at the site) management organisation. * manual labourers Costs can also be met by charging commercial waste producers, such as It is crucial that sufficient funds are shops, hotels and industry, for provid- identified to enable the site operation ing them with a waste disposal ser- to be correctly managed vice, and indirectly by charging resi- dents through property taxes or util- A well-managed landfill site can ity charges. minimise operational problems. * Who should operate the new landfill site? Are there enough suitably skilled personnel within the municipality, in the waste or other sections? Alternatively, should the operation be contracted out to the private sector? * Is there enough money allocated to the project for it to be done properly? Funds can be raised by cost-cutting elsewhere, or by charging waste producers for the waste service. 7f?- [I r K> Many kinds of industrial wastes can FU%£L be safely landfilled. There are advan- tages to the landfilling of industrial Planned mixing of hazardous indus- waste in middle- and lower-income trial wastes with municipal wastes countries, since landfill represents a relies on the processes which the mu- widely available, long term disposal nicipal waste undergoes to stabilise method which offers a low cost dis- posal route. INA Fml § Disposing of hazardous industrial wastes in landfill sites can also be * Landfill is a widely available done in some circumstances, but it disposal method and a safe requires special procedures to be un- disposal option for many industrial dertaken, and careful management wastes and operation. Where sanitary land- * Separation from other wastes, or fill site management principles are in some form of pre-treatment, may use, disposal of hazardous, or special, be necessary for the hazardous wastes can usually be undertaken. components Where such principles are not yet be- ing applied, hazardous industrial the industrial waste. It is important waste should not be landfilled. that co-disposal is carefully managed to ensure that the rate of input of haz- There are three basic apprroaches to adu nutilwsede o landfilling haz rdosidsrr ardous industrial waste does not landfilling hazardous industrial oewemtemncplwse wastes: separate disposal in a site overwhelm the municipal waste. which takes only this type of waste (a Direct disposal of liquid industrial mono-fill); disposal together with hazardous wastes is sometimes municipal wastes in a co-disposal site;e or pre-treatment of wastes before ei- provi ing thest ieant agd ther mono- or co-disposal landfill. providing the site iS well-managed. At a co-disposal site it is inevitable that different types of hazardous in- MO.111112551 0-41 dustrial wastes will come into con- tact. It is therefore important to ensure Wastes which have the same overall that incompatible wastes are not dis- physical and chemical characteristics posed of together, to avoid unwanted and which are stable can be disposed chemical reactions. of together, but separately from other wastes. 21 22 HAZARDOUS WASTES Pre-treatment of hazardous industrial a well-designed anld managed waste reduces the bulk or the hazards associated with handling, transport- ing and landfilling the waste. * a continuing supply of municipal waste properly placed Some industrial hazardous wastes * a trained landfill manager and are completely unacceptable in a co- operational staff disposal landfill because of their * snfficient mobile eqniipment to highly reactive chemical nature or thi souilt. prepare the site their solublity. * no scavenging directly on the landfill if hazardous waste is accepted The costs of treatment technologies * no burning of waste directly on the may be too high in many middle- and landfill lower-income countries, and co-dis- posal may be the compromise neces- * a means of ensuring that only sary to improve crude dumping or suitable types of industrial wastes stockpiling of hazardous industrial are deposited wastes. There may also be too few in- * regular inspection to check that dustrial operations to justify invest- industrial wastes are not leaching ment in treatment technologies. Providing there is already a good standard of design and operation, a In addition, a check must be made at decision must be made on which the landfill entrance of the composi- types of waste will be allowed in the tion of industrial waste being re- landfill, and how they are to be ceived, and a record kept of that handled. Deciding which wastes are waste and its location in the site. handled. Deciding which wastes are acceptable must be done on a site-by- site basis, as landfills vary in their suitability for co-disposal. Some wastes should definitely be landfilled, as no other option exists. An example of this is asbestos. Other wastes which are readily bio- degradable without pretreatment could be accepted, such as food pro- cessing wastes and oily sludges. SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 23 * Landfill may be the only or best disposal option in a locality for industrial wastes * In this case, which wastes will be accepted? * How will they be handled? MuE COS$URE _11TjA AUUTRCARE Once the filling of a landfill is com- mise - to a greater or lesser extenit - plete, the waste is covered with a the environmental protection systems thicker layer of soil, and other surface incorporated in the design. Inspection capping systems are installed, in and nonitoring programmes can help readiness for the site's after-use. On identify any necessary maintenance large sites, the final cover may be or repair of systems. placed in stages, with areas of land restored for use while other areas con- tinue to be filled with waste. This helps to reduce the amount of rain- fall entering the site, and reduces leachate. * Correct covering of completed Although the site may be filled and site is vital capped, there may still be many de- * Acceptable uses for a former cades before all of the waste has de- landfill can be found, once restored composed and stabilised. Monitoring *Need for continued environmental and control systems should be main- tained during this aftercare period. protection * Settlement will disrupt the final The final cover of the waste has sev- cover and repairs will be necessary eral functions to perform while the waste completes its decomposition * Need to check if closure plan still and settlement processes: applicable * reducing rainfall infiltration * reducing surface erosion Leachate will continue to be gener- ated, so in sites where leachate is con- * providing surface drainage tained it will continue to be necessary systems to collect and treat it as long as it poses a threat to the ground and surface * controlling migration of gas and water. leachate Although a site closure plan will have * preparing the site for its planned been part of the original design, it will after-use be necessary to check its continued relevance, after so many years. In the Unfortunately, landfills cannot be re- .reevance,oaf ter o m ears n lied upon to behave exactly as they intervening period, stricter environ- wier deintobed.Upedixacted as ette mental legislation may be in place, ment, weaknesesi d inpsruction andtle land use plans may have changed and ment weaknesses in construction an the intended after-use of the site may nature itself will inevitably compro- no longer be appropriate. 24 SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 25 It may also be necessary to examine also at risk of damage from settlement the cost implications of the closure of the waste. since the preparation of the replace- ment sanitary landfill should be well Final cover from natural materials is under way by this time, which may often better at self-sealing if disrupted be competing for financial resources. by waste settlement, Budgetary constraints may force the Whatever the intended after-use, the waste manager to choose between, for early establishment of grass or other example, maintaining the integrity of vegetation will help protect the cap the cap or doing groundwater moni- from erosion. toring. Should priority be given to fill- ing low spots or to repairing storm drainage? AMR u$Es A primary aim of the final cap is to Recreation may, in many cases, be a minimise leachate generation by ex- beneficial after-use of a completed cluding rainwater and other surface landfill. Only small, light construc- water. tions, such as equipment storage sheds, are needed. The best caps are constructed from around one metre of natural soil ma- If the site's after-use is grassland, then terials, such as clay. A cap is usually a light topsoil dressing over the cap domed or contoured into a slope to will promote the rapid growth of further encourage the run-off of sur- grass. If it is planned for arable uses, face water. a total soil depth of up to Im over the clay cap may be needed to prevent A well-compacted and drained clay ploughing from damaging the cap. cap that is protected from soil ero- sion by vegetation will inhibit sur- The use of completed sites for con- face water entering the waste. struction or urban development should be discouraged because of a Synthetic materials, similar to those number of constraints including: which can be used as liners for land- fill sites, can be used in the final cap, * low load-bearing capacity but these are more expensive and are extensive and uneven settling Amenity: open space, buffer zones, airport runways Recreation: parks, playing fields, tracks and golf courses Agriculture: arable land, grazing Forestation: woodland, tree screens, nature reserves Habitation: gardens, play areas Industry: open storage areas, parking, open fabrication areas, open air markets 26 SITE CLOSURE AND AFTERCARE * presence of combustible and Gas venting trenches in and around potentially explosive gases the final cover can allow landfill gas migration to atmosphere if there is no * corrosive character of waste pumped gas flaring or utilisation on decomposition products and of site. Where there is a pumped gas the internal landfill environ- management system in place, it will ment in general need to be maintained, and probably continuously staffed, during the after- care period. Failure of a pumped sys- These constraints continue long after ternw ill lead to gas migration off-site. the filling has been completed. However, there is a growing land shortage in some cities, especially in - - lower- and middle- income countries To maintain the effectiveness of the where rural to urban migration has environmental protection measures exacerbated the situation. built into the landfill after closure, If pressures on land availability force regular checking of the site is neces- sarv. This is termed 'after-care' and the use of a completed site for build- involves erosion control, observation ng development, extensiveprecau -settlement, groundwater monitor- tionary measures must be included to of 010 control associated hazards. ing, leachate and gas control, obser- vation of the condition of vegetation and presence of vermin and odours. Funds should be set aside for these zc,! rurrLlal,procedures. Leachate will continue to be gener- There may still be several decades ated after closure, although in de- before all of the waste has decom- creasing quantities providing the fi- posed. As a result, even though the nal cap remains effective. Leachate site has been capped, settlement will collection and treatment systems will continue. To maintain the domed cap need to be maintained after closure, profile, it may be necessary to back- fill areas of settlement (which appear Landfill gas will also continue to be as depressions in the top surface) with generated. Landfill gas could have cap material and soil. Settlement will disastrous consequences for local resi- be less at a site which has been oper- dents or squatter communities if al- ated as a sanitary landfill, since the lowed to migrate off-site. Even if the waste will have been well compacted gas is contained within the bound- when originally deposited. aries of the site, there are still signifi- cant risks and environmental impacts. SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 27 "j7 7 L - 7 ' j . I * Is the closure plan, which was written some years ago, still appropriate? * For how long should an aftercare programme be maintained? * A regular programme of monitoring will continue to be necessary for some time In order to abandon the practice of It is important to ensure that illegal open dumping, the municipality may dumping does not continue at any either close its open dumps when a closed dump site. A public awareness replacement upgraded landfill site is programme should be initiated to en- ready to accept wastes, or alterna- courage the use of the new landfill. tivelv it may convert its open dumps to operate as upgraded landfills. It is assumed that, in deciding to de- This latter option will only be possible if: . L PR j L * the dump is in an area where * Dumps should only be converted groundwater pollution is not if environmenital protection needs critical can be met * there is sufficient remaining * There is no point in costly void space to justify the cost and conversions for dumps with only effort of conversion a little space left If the dump is to be converted to a * Closing a dump does not end the landfill, operational practices should responsibility for it be the same as those for a new sani- tary landfill site. However, the ability to protect the groundwater beneath velop an upgraded landfill, the mu- the site will be limited. nicipality will be committing itself to moving away from the practice of open dumping. L C) '> ' D D K 170 The municipality must decide whether the dump will be closed or converted, Standards to be adopted in and if it is to be closed, whether it is remediating a closed site should be to be remediated in any way. comparable to those for completion of The decision to move towards sani- a sanitary landfill. One option for the remediation of a closed site is to re- t d w move all dumped material to a re- on a recognition that open dumping placement sanitary landfill. This is was having an unacceptable impact on the environment and on human likely to be an expensive approach un- heath and onse uelt less only a small volume of waste is simly abndo sth dumwold no involved. It will also use space m the sp a address the local hazards associated new landfill. It may also be possible to with the dump. Something needs to use bio-remediation techniques. be done to improve its condition. 28 SUMMARY: DECISION-MAKER'S GUIDE TO SOLID WASTE LANDFILLS 29 Where an open dump does, or might, Extinguishing fires, eliminating ver- contaminate a useful groundwater min and reducing groundwater and resource, it is not recommended to surface water pollution will achieve attempt to convert it to an upgraded this objective. landfill. At those open dumps in ravines, where It would be better to limit the im- waste has been tipped over a steep cliff pact on the groundwater by control- into a valley below, the main problem ling the infiltration through the site may be to stabilise the loose and dan- by means of a low-permeability cap. gerously steep slopes of waste. The Guide suggests the minimum standards that should be applied COUlNITERING ILLEGAL DUMPING when undertaking a dump conver- sion to an upgraded landfill. The open dump was probably located where it is because of convenience and proximity to urban areas. Conse- REMEDIATION' quently, closing this convenient site may require that access to the dump The objective of remediating an open be restricted. Otherwise, unwanted dump is to minimise the environmen- dumping will continue. tal health and safety problems created by the dump. SURVEYING THE DUMP The first step towards rehabilitating an open dump is to assess the condition of the site and its geographical setting. A desk study can gather a wide range of information about the site, including maps and photographs, and information about the geology of the site. Any kno wn pollution or contamination of soil, water and air at or near the site, and details of the waste types and amounts dumped can also be obtained. The site investigation survey will, where physically and safely possible, confirm the depths of dumped wastes. Boreholes will detect any pollution by leachate. A topographical survey will provide a 1:500 scale map of the site on which to prepare remediation plans. Extreme care should be taken in carrying out these surveys since open dumps can present a range of health and safety hazards to humans. These include unstable slopes, hidden voids, sharp objects, hazardous chemicals, attack from rodents or mosquitoes, hidden bodies of water and risk of injury from falling waste. These investigations will need to be undertaken before the choice can be made on whether to close or convert a site, since the findings will guide the decision. 30 CLOSURE AND CONVERSION OF OPEN DUMPS To counter this, the municipality can associated costs. Such facilities are either take steps to prevent illegal commonly provided on a permanent dumping at the same time as inform- basis in some countries as a free ser- ing the public about the new facility, vice to the local community, where or provide a waste reception area at other disposal facilities are remote. the closed site for a short period, with The service is not made available to transfer of the wastes to the new land- commercial and industrial waste gen- fill undertaken by the municipality erators who should pay transport itself. costs of their wastes. The first option requires public co- The municipality's aim should be to operation as well as enforcement mea- provide waste transfer facilities for a sures such as fencing and a watch- short period after closure, at the same man. time conducting a public awareness campaign to encourage direct use of The second option requires the pro- the new landfill site. vision of a waste transfer facility, with * Should the dump be closed or converted? * If closed, is the site to be remediated? * What standards are achievable at the dump site? * Should a waste transfer facility be offered permanently or temporarily? E i~ ' S 0 2 0g[M- COINTREAU-LEVINE, S., Private Domestic Sanitary Landfill Sites. GTZ, Sector Participation in Municipal Solid Eschborn, Germany, 1994. Waste Services in Deoeloping Countries. Volume 1: the Formal Sector. Urban RUSHBROOK PE, PUGH MP. Deci- Management Programme Discussion sion-Maker's Guide on the Planning, Sit- Paper 13. UNDP/UNCHS/World ing, Design and Operation of Sanitary Bank Urban Management Programme. Landfills in Middle and Lower-Income WORLD BANK, Washington, DC. Countries. SKAT, WORLD BANK, and USA, 1994. ISBN 0-8213-2825-5 WHO, 1997. ISBN (Pending) INTERNATIONAL SOLID WASTE SLOAN, WM. Site Selection for New ASSOCIATION. 1000 Terms in Solid Hazardous Waste Management Facilities. Waste Management. Ed: Skitt J. Inter- WHO Regional Publications, Euro- national Solid Waste Association, pean Series, No. 46. WHO Regional Copenhagen, Denmark, 1992. ISBN Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Den- 87-7751/056-9 mark, 1993. ISBN 92-890-1309-5 MINISTRY OF WATER AFFAIRS SCHUBELER P, Wehrle K, Christen J. AND FORESTRY, Minimum Require- Conceptual Framework for Municipal ments for Waste Disposal by Landfill. Solid Waste Management in Low-Income First Edition. Waste Management Se- Countries. UMP Working Paper Series ries. Ed: Ball JM, Ministry of Water No. 9. SKAT, Vadianstrasse 42, CH- Affairs and Forestry, Pretoria, South 9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland, 1996. Africa, 1994. ISBN 0621-16297-3 WORLD BANK. Environmental As- MINISTRY OF WATER AFFAIRS sessment Source Book. Volume 1 - Poli- AND FORESTRY. Minimum Require- cies, Procedures and Cross-Sectoral ments for the Handling and Disposal of Issues. World Bank Technical Paper Hazardous Waste. First edition. Waste No. 139. World Bank, Washington, Management Series. Ed: Fourie H.O. DC, USA, 1991. Ministry of Water Affairs and For- WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZA- estry, Pretoria, South Africa. ISBN TION. Landfill. Environmental Health 0621-16296-5 Planning Pamphlet series No. 9. OELTZSCHNERH,MUTZ D. Guide- WHO Regional Office for Europe, lines for an Appropriate Management of Copenhagen, Denmark, 1995. 31 THE WORLD BANK 181X II StLcet.\ .N.W NWashingiton. 1).(C. 20433. 'SA\ Iclcplihone: 2012-477-1234 Facesimiile: 2012-477-6391 kclcx: NI(-1 64145 WOR(1,I)BA\NK MCI 248423 W()IA)BANK\NI W\orld W\idc W\cb: littp://\x\wX orldbik.rl-or -miail: hooks(xx orldhank.org WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION Rcgional ()fficc tor lItiropc 8, ScherfigSvcj D)k-211)0) (,openhl.gen, 1D)eninrls 'lewlcphlonl: (45) 39 17 17 17 Faseimic: (45) 39 17 18 Is NVOrkl WN'ide t Web: http://\x\ lxxxho.dkl SWISS AGENCY FOR DEVELOPMENT AND COOPERATION Filgcrstrassc 73 300>3 lici-ii, S\\itz.cf-l.iiid 'I'elcphlonl: (41) 31 322 3344 Fascimviile: (41) 31 324 8741 SWISS CENTER FOR DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION IN TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT \VadiaInstr issc 42, ( :11 - 9(1(10) St ( allell, S\ itzcrl,nlid Iclcplionic: (41) 71 22S 5454 Faslmieilic: (41) 71 22X 5455 IB1 649