TUZ GÖLÜ GAS STORAGE EXPANSION PROJECT RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABBREVIATIONS....................................................................................................................................... 7 GLOSSARY ................................................................................................................................................ 8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................................................... 11 1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 14 1.1. Description of the Project ..................................................................................................... 14 1.2. Minimizing Resettlement Impact .......................................................................................... 17 1.3. Project Affected Settlements ................................................................................................ 17 2. OBJECTIVES OF THE RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN ...................................................................... 23 2.1. Development of the Resettlement Action Plan .................................................................... 25 2.2. Scope of the Resettlement Action Plan ................................................................................. 25 2.3. Limitations of RAP ................................................................................................................. 26 3. LEGAL FRAMEWORK ...................................................................................................................... 28 3.1. Review of the National Legislation Governing Land Acquisition and Resettlement ................. 28 3.1.2. Expropriation Law................................................................................................................ 28 3.1.3. Resettlement Law ................................................................................................................ 30 3.2. World Bank Policies ............................................................................................................... 33 3.3. Gap Analysis between National and International Policies................................................... 34 4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BASELINE ......................................................................................................... 41 4.1. Methodology ......................................................................................................................... 41 4.1.1. Socio-Economic Household Surveys.............................................................................. 43 4.1.2. Settlement Surveys........................................................................................................ 44 4.1.3. Focus Group Discussions ............................................................................................... 44 4.1.4. In-depth Interviews ....................................................................................................... 45 4.2. Overview of the Project-Affected Population ....................................................................... 45 4.2.1. Province-District Level Overview of Project-Affected Population ...................................... 45 4.2.2. Household Socio-Economic Profile...................................................................................... 46 4.1.5. Vulnerable Groups......................................................................................................... 49 5. LAND ACQUISITION PROCESS AND REQUIREMENTS..................................................................... 55 5.1. Land Rights to be Established ................................................................................................ 56 5.2. Eligibility Criteria for Defining Various Categories of PAPs ................................................... 57 5.3. Cut-Off Date .......................................................................................................................... 58 5.4. Identification of Project Affected Persons ............................................................................ 58 5.4.1. Land Owners .................................................................................................................. 58 2 5.4.2. Land Users (Formal and Informal) ................................................................................. 58 5.4.3. Vulnerable Groups......................................................................................................... 59 6. RESETTLEMENT RELATED POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE PROJECT ................................................ 60 6.1. Impacts of Natural Gas Pipeline, Energy Transmission Lines, Fresh Water Lines, Brine Water Lines 60 6.2. Impacts of Surface Facilities and Well Areas ......................................................................... 61 6.3. Usage Limitations after Reinstatement ................................................................................. 62 7. MITIGATION MEASURES AND COMPENSATION STRATEGIES ....................................................... 63 8. INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK ....................................................................................................... 68 9. PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE ................................................................................... 72 9.1. Public Consultation and Participation during Land Acquisition Process ............................... 73 9.2. Consultation Activities during RAP Preparation .................................................................... 75 9.3. Future Consultations ............................................................................................................. 76 9.4. Document Management and Disclosure of Documents ....................................................... 76 10. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM ........................................................................................... 78 10.1. Purpose and Scope ............................................................................................................ 78 10.2. Procedure and Responsibilities ......................................................................................... 79 11. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE................................................................................................... 82 12. MONITORING AND EVALUATION .............................................................................................. 84 12.1. Monitoring Approach ........................................................................................................ 84 12.1.1. Internal Monitoring ....................................................................................................... 84 12.1.2. External Monitoring....................................................................................................... 86 12.1.3. Completion Audit .......................................................................................................... 86 12.2. Monitoring Schedule ......................................................................................................... 87 13. BUDGET ..................................................................................................................................... 88 14. REFERENCES .............................................................................................................................. 90 15. APPENDICES............................................................................................................................... 91 Appendix 1. Socio-Economic Household Survey Questionnaire ....................................................... 91 Appendix 2. Settlement Level- Mukhtar Surveys ............................................................................ 113 Appendix 3. Stakeholder List ........................................................................................................... 127 Appendix 4. A Template of Grievance Form (Register and Close out Pages).................................. 128 Appendix 5. Public Information Meeting ........................................................................................ 132 Appendix 6. Asset Inventory List .................................................................................................... 135 Appendix 7. Valuation Process According to Expropriation Law .................................................... 142 Appendix 8. Overview of the Project-Affected Population ............................................................. 166 Province-District Level Overview of Project-Affected Population .............................................. 166 3 Household Socio-Economic Profile.............................................................................................. 171 Appendix 9. RAP Fund Management Guideline .............................................................................. 187 Eligibility Criteria for Crop Payments on Unviable Lands ............................................................ 201 Land Investigation Form .............................................................................................................. 202 RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table ..................................................................................... 203 Transitional Livelihood Support Application Form ...................................................................... 204 Appendix 10. Land Entry and Land Exit Protocol Templates........................................................... 205 Appendix 11. Land Acquisition Process and Requirements ............................................................ 207 4 LIST OF TABLES Tablo 1-1 Number of Parcels and Area Hectares According to Project Components ........................... 17 Tablo 1-2 Project Affected Settlements, Districts and Provinces.......................................................... 18 Tablo 1-3 Number of Settlements and Parcels (by land type) Affected by Pipelines Components of the Project ................................................................................................................................................... 19 Table1-4 Area of Lands by Easement and Land Types (Pipelines Component) .................................... 19 Table1-5 Number of Settlements and Parcels (by land type) Affected by Well Areas and Surface Facilities of the Project .......................................................................................................................... 20 Table 1-6 Area of Lands by Ownership and Easement Rights and Land Types (Surface Facilities and Well Areas) ............................................................................................................................................ 20 Table 1-7 Number of Parcels and All Types of Users by Pipeline Affected Settlements ....................... 20 Table 1-8 Number of Parcels and All types of Users in the Settlement subject to Land Acquisition (Well Areas and Surface Facilities) ........................................................................................................ 21 Tablo 3.1-1 The Main GAPs Between Turkish Law and World Bank Group Policies ............................. 35 Tablo 4-1 Distribution of Sample Size for Socio-Economic Household Survey ..................................... 42 Tablo 4-10 Number of Pipeline Affected Parcels Expropriated for Second Time ................................. 52 Tablo 4-11 Number of Parcels Expropriated for Second Time Affected by Well Areas or Surface Facilities ................................................................................................................................................. 53 Tablo 4-12 Number of Parcels Affected by Multiple Project Components ........................................... 54 Tablo 5-1 Types of Land Rights .............................................................................................................. 56 Tablo 5-2 Number of formal and informal users in public and private lands ....................................... 59 Tablo 7-1 Entitlement Matrix ................................................................................................................ 64 Table 8-1Organizational Arrangements for RAP Management............................................................. 68 Tablo 9-1 Consultation and Informative Meetings held by BOTAŞ ....................................................... 73 Tablo 9-2Summary of Public Consultation Activities ............................................................................ 75 Tablo 9-3In-depth Interviews with Institutions ..................................................................................... 75 Tablo 10-1 Grievance Redress Mechanism .......................................................................................... 78 Tablo 13-1 Estimated Budget for RAP Implementation ........................................................................ 88 Tablo 13-2 RAP Fund Items ................................................................................................................... 88 Tablo 4-2 Population of Evren District ................................................................................................ 166 Tablo 4-3 Population of Project Affected Districts in Aksaray ............................................................ 168 Tablo 4-4 Land Assets of Aksaray Province ......................................................................................... 169 Tablo 4-5 Population of Emirgazi District ............................................................................................ 170 Tablo 4-6 Average Household Size in the Project Area ....................................................................... 171 Tablo 4-7 Healthcare Facilities in the Project Area ............................................................................. 174 Tablo 4-8 Access to Infrastructure in Project Affected Settlements ................................................... 175 Tablo 4-9 Number of Livestock Owned by PAHs ................................................................................. 180 5 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1 The Project Areas of the UGS Project and GSEP ..................................................................... 16 Figure 24 Preparation and Steps Followed for Acquisition of Private Lands (Turkey Context) . Hata! Yer işareti tanımlanmamış. Figure 25 Court Process Followed for Acquisition of Private Lands .... Hata! Yer işareti tanımlanmamış. Figure 2 Living Patterns in the Project Area ........................................................................................ 172 Figure 3 Education Profile of Project- Affected Population ................................................................ 172 Figure 4 Number of Students in PAHs ................................................................................................. 173 Figure 5 Employment Status in the Project Area ................................................................................ 173 Figure 6 Social Insurance Ownership Status of Project-Affected Population ..................................... 173 Figure 7 Ownership Status of Houses ................................................................................................. 175 Figure 8 Most Used Heat Sources in PAHs .......................................................................................... 176 Figure 9 Type of Land Owned by Households (Number of PAHs) ....................................................... 177 Figure 10 Average size of lands by type owned by households .......................................................... 178 Figure 11 Type of CropsPlanted by PAHs in the Project Area ............................................................. 178 Figure 12 Vehicle Ownership by Households in the Project Area ....................................................... 179 Figure 13 Usage Purposes of Affected Public Lands (Treasury, Pasture, Forest, etc.) ........................ 179 Figure 14 Income Sources of PAHs in the Project Area ....................................................................... 180 Figure 15 Average Monthly and Annual Expenditures of PAHs in the Project Area ........................... 181 Figure 16 Did Any Household Member Receive Loan? ....................................................................... 181 Figure 17 Most Important Deficiencies/Problems of the Settlements According to PAPs ................. 182 Figure 18 Livelihood Restoration/Improvement Preferences............................................................. 183 Figure 19 Type of Livelihood Development Courses Preferred by PAPs for Women and Youth ........ 183 Figure 20 Information Sources Preferred by PAPs .............................................................................. 184 Figure 21 Potential Positive Impacts of the Project ............................................................................ 185 Figure 22 Potential Negative Impacts of the Project .......................................................................... 185 Figure 23 Measures Preferred by PAPs for Mitigating Potential Adverse Impacts............................. 186 6 ABBREVIATIONS BOTAŞ Petroleum Pipeline Corporation CRF Complaint Register Form DPs Displaced persons ESIA Environmental and Social Impact Assessment ETL Energy Transmission Line GLAC Guide to Land Acquisition and Compensation GRM Grievance Redress Mechanism GSEP Gas Storage Expansion Project IFC International Finance Corporation IFIs International Financing Institutions LAC Land Acquisition NGO Non-Governmental Organization OP Operational Policy PAH Project Affected Households PAP Project Affected Person PAV Project Affected Village PR Performance Requirement PS Performance Standard RAP Resettlement Action Plan RPF Resettlement Policy Framework SEP Stakeholder Engagement Plan SIA Social Impact Assessment SMP Social Management Plan TUIK Turkish Statistical Institute WB World Bank WBCSD World Business Council for Sustainable Development 7 GLOSSARY Census: A complete and accurate count of the population that will be affected by land acquisition and related impacts. Census means a field survey carried out to identify and determine the number of Project Affected Persons (“PAP”), their assets, and potential impacts. Compensation: Payment in cash or in kind for an asset or a resource that is acquired or affected by a project at the time the asset needs to be replaced. Cut-off date: Date of completion of the census and assets inventory of persons affected by the project. Persons occupying the project area after the cut-off date are not eligible for compensation and/or resettlement assistance. Similarly, fixed assets (such as built structures, crops, fruit trees, and woodlots) established after the date of completion of the assets inventory, or an alternative mutually agreed on date, will not be compensated. WB OP 4.12, endnote 22 reads “Normally, this cut-off date is the date the census begins. The cut-off date could also be the date the project area was delineated, prior to the census, provided that there has been an effective public dissemination of information on the area delineated, and systematic and continuous dissemination subsequent to the delineation to prevent further population influx. Displacement: The physical, economic, social and/or cultural uprooting of a person, household, social group or community as a result of the GSEP. Displaced persons: are defined as persons who are affected in any of the ways described in OP 4.12. The word thus connotes all those people who lose land or the right to use land or who lose access to legally designated parks and protected areas resulting in adverse impacts on the livelihoods. The term displaced persons are synonymous with “project-affected persons” and is not limited to those subjected to physical displacement. Economic displacement: Loss of income streams or means of livelihood resulting from land acquisition or obstructed access to resources (land, water, or forest) resulting from the construction or operation of a project or its associated facilities. Eligibility: Refers to criteria identifying which affected persons are entitled to receive compensation, resettlement assistance and/or other benefits as a result of resettlement. Usually established either by law or via policies of International Financial Institutions (IFIs). Entitlements: The compensation offered to persons, households, groups and/or communities affected by the GSEP. This includes: financial compensation, preferential right to certain employment, the right to participate in livelihood restoration programmes, housing, service provision, transport assistance, and other short-term assistance required to move from one site to another. Host population: Any community receiving displaced persons. People living in or around areas to which people physically displaced by a project will be resettled who, in turn, may be affected by the resettlement. Household: Refers to community consisting of one or more people who live in the same house or in a part of the same house, whether they have a kinship tie or who meet basic needs together. Informal User: Refers to people who have no recognizable legal right or claim to the land they are occupying for residential, business and/or other purposes. They are not eligible for land compensation 8 but qualify for compensation for loss of structures and improvements, loss of crops and transitional livelihood support. Involuntary resettlement: Involuntary resettlement refers both to physical displacement (relocation or loss of shelter) and to economic displacement (loss of assets or access to assets that leads to loss of income sources or other means of livelihood) as a result of project-related land acquisition and/or restrictions on land use. Resettlement is considered involuntary when affected persons or communities do not have the right to refuse land acquisition and restrictions on land use that result in physical or economic displacement. Land acquisition: Includes both outright purchases of property and/or acquisition of access rights, such as easements or rights of way. Land expropriation: Process whereby a public authority, usually in return for compensation, requires a person, household, or community to relinquish rights to land that it occupies or otherwise uses. Livelihood restoration: In order to mitigate the economic displacement caused by involuntary resettlement, livelihood restoration process establishes the entitlements of affected persons and/or communities, and ensures that these are provided in a transparent, consistent, and equitable manner and that they are provided with adequate opportunity to re-establish their livelihoods. Market value: The value that is required to enable affected persons and communities to replace lost assets with new assets of similar value. Mitigation measure: Refers to the measures to be taken in order to minimize the negative effects of impacts on livelihoods of the affected people. Project: Refers to BOTAŞ Gas Storage Expansion Project, including all its sub-projects, components and phases. Project affected household (“PAH”): All members of a household, whether related or not, operating as a single economic unit, who are affected by a project. Project affected person (“PAP”): Any person who, as a result of the implementation of a project, loses the right to own, use, or otherwise benefit from a built structure, land (residential, agricultural, or pasture), annual or perennial crops ad trees, or any other fixed or moveable asset, either in full or in part, permanently or temporarily. Physical displacement: Loss of residential land, or loss of shelter and assets resulting from the acquisition of land associated with a project that requires the affected person(s) to move to another location. Replacement cost: The rate of compensation for lost assets must be calculated at full replacement cost, that is, the market value of the assets plus transaction costs. With regard to land and structures, IFC defines “replacement costs” as follows: o agricultural land—the market value of land of equal productive use or potential located in the vicinity of the affected land, plus the cost of preparation to levels similar to or better than those of the affected land, plus the cost of any registration and transfer taxes; o land in urban areas—the market value of land of equal size and use, with similar or improved public infrastructure facilities and services preferably located in the vicinity of the affected land, plus the cost of any registration and transfer taxes; 9 o household and public structures—the cost of purchasing or building a new structure, with an area and quality similar to or better than those of the affected structure, or of repairing a partially affected structure, including labor and contractors’ fees and any registration and transfer taxes. In determining the replacement cost, depreciation of the asset and the value of salvage materials are not taken into account, nor is the value of benefits to be derived from the project deducted from the valuation of an affected asset. Resettlement: Covers all direct economic and social losses resulting from land taking and restriction of access, together with the consequent compensatory and remedial measures. Resettlement is not restricted to its usual meaning—physical relocation. Resettlement can, depending on the case, include (a) acquisition of land and physical structures on the land, including businesses; (b) physical relocation; and (c) economic rehabilitation of displaced persons, to improve (or at least restore) incomes and living standards. Resettlement Action Plan (“RAP”): The document in which a project sponsor or other responsible entity specifies the procedures that it will follow and the actions that it will take to mitigate adverse effects, compensate losses, and provide development benefits to persons and communities affected by an investment project. Resettlement assistance: Support provided to people who are physically displaced by a project. Assistance may include transportation, food, shelter, and social services that are provided to affected people during their relocation. Assistance may also include cash allowances that compensate affected people for the inconvenience associated with resettlement and defray the expenses of a transition to a new locale, such as moving expenses and lost work days. Resettlement Policy Framework (“RPF”): A resettlement policy framework is required for projects with subprojects or multiple components that cannot be identified before project World Bank’s appraisal. This instrument may also be appropriate where there are valid reasons for delaying the implementation of resettlement, provided that the implementing party provides an appropriate and concrete commitment for its future implementation. The policy framework should be consistent with the principles and objectives of WB OP 4.12- Involuntary Resettlement. Stakeholders: Any and all individuals, groups, organizations, and institutions interested in and potentially affected by a project or having the ability to influence a project. Vulnerable groups: People who by virtue of gender, ethnicity, age, physical or mental disability, economic disadvantage, or social status may be more adversely affected by resettlement than other and who may be limited in their ability to claim or take advantage of resettlement assistance and related development benefits. 10 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) has been prepared to identify and evaluate the resettlement impacts of the Tuz Golu Natural Gas Underground Storage Expansion Project (herein after “GSEP” and / or “Project”). GSEP aims to increase the capacity of the existing Underground Gas Storage Project (UGS Project) of BOTAŞ in the same region, which had been put into practice with the aim of regulating seasonal natural gas fluctuations, fulfilling purchase and sale commitments, ensuring flexibility in gas purchase-sale agreements and thus raising the bargaining power, ensuring uninterrupted gas supply and efficient pipeline operation, meeting the excessive demand during summer months due to electricity generation, creating a strategic reserve against unforeseeable technical disruptions in gas supply and providing service to all consumers in the natural gas system of Turkey. BOTAŞ commits to promote sustainable development and social welfare in the areas in which it operates. The design and implementation of this RAP will be in line with Turkish law and the World Bank Operational Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (WB OP 4.12) which have been captured in the GSEP RPF approved by the World Bank during Project preparation. In case of any discrepancy between Turkish Law and WB OP 4.12, the provisions of OP 4.12 shall apply. The Tuz Golu Underground Natural Gas Storage (UGS ) Project is located in Sultanhani locality of Aksaray Province, at about 40 km south of Tuz Golu and consists of several components such as pipelines (fresh water line from Hirfanli Dam to Underground Gas Storage (UGS) Sites, brine discharge line from UGS sites to Tuz Golu, and natural gas branch line to Eastern Anatolia Natural Gas Main Transmission Line), pump stations and storage tanks, energy transmission lines, surface facilities and UGS Sites. The land acquisition (LAC) process of UGS Project was initiated by the Department of Land Estate and Expropriation within BOTAŞ in accordance with Approval number 1423 on October 3, 2007. First compensation payments were made in December 2012. The existing UGS Project continues and shows good progress; drilling of all twelve caverns has been completed, leaching and first gas filling activities are being undertaken. The caverns are located approximately at the depth of 1100 - 1450 m below ground surface. Each cavern will have a geometrical cavern volume of 630.000 m3 - 750.000 m3. The first three caverns have been operational since 2017, and the storage capacity has reached to 0.25 bcm. All twelve caverns will be ready for operation in 2021 and the storage capacity will reach to 1.2 bcm. (GSEP) is planned to increase the capacity of the existing UGS Project from 1.2 bcm to 5.4 bcm by constructing additional salt caverns with similar properties of the existing caverns. In addition to the existing UGS Project facilities, the following components will be constructed:  40 + 8 (spare) caverns with 4.2 bcm storage capacity,  1 surface facility,  1 natural gas connection pipeline (between Kayseri–Konya–Seydişehir sections (at app. 23 km north of the Project site) of the existing Eastern Anatolia Natural Gas Main Transmission Line to the Project site)  1 freshwater pipeline,  1 brine discharge pipeline,  Field pipelines,  4 pump stations,  Energy transmission lines (ETLs),  Access roads and other associated structures. 11 The construction phase of the Project is planned to start in the second quarter of 2019 and to be completed in last quarter of 2023. After the completion of the Project construction phase, it is planned to have an estimated 30 years of operation phase. This Plan includes the assessment of Project’ impacts regarding physical and economic displacement and the development of mitigation measures or compensation strategies. Following the World Bank approval of this RAP, the land acquisition process will begin. One of the main approaches of the Project is not to cause a physical displacement. Thus, physical displacement was avoided in the Project design and no physical displacement will take place as observed in the site studies. The land requirements of the above-mentioned components of the Project are anticipated to result only in economic displacement. A total of 28 settlements have been are affected by the land acquisition of Project. These 28 settlements are located within the boundaries of 8 districts of 3 provinces. One of these 28 settlements is located in the borders of Ankara and another in the province of Konya. The remaining 27 26 settlements are located in the province of Aksaray. 26 settlements out of 28 are affected by pipelines where lands are acquired through easement rights whereas 3 settlements out of 28 are affected by well areas and surface facilities where lands are acquired through ownership rights or permanent easement rights. As seen in table given below, one of these 28 settlements are affected by both pipelines and well areas. The first part of the RAP provides an overview of the Project activities and information on the land acquisition requirements of the Project. This introduction also provides a general description of the Project and its area of influence; listing the Project components in relation to their impacts on land. Main efforts of the Project on minimizing resettlement is also detailed in this section. Chapter 2 includes information on the development process, scope and objectives of this RAP together with its limitations on the preparation process. Chapter 3 describes the national legislation and institutional framework related to the development and the implementation of RAP. This section also describes applicable international standards and policies that form the RAP framework. The legislation scope of involuntary resettlement and land use restrictions and the nature of the compensation related to both the valuation methodology and the timing of payment are considered in this section. Applicable legislative and administrative procedures, including a description of the existing solutions in the judicial process for displaced persons the legal timeframe for these procedures and the current grievance redress mechanisms that may be relevant to the Project, are set forth under this chapter. The chapter provides information on the institutions responsible for the implementation of the resettlement activities. Chapter 4 initially provides the methodology applied during the preparation of this RAP and then evaluates the socio-economic baseline status of region and communities on the basis of Census and socio-economic survey. Key data and potential project impacts in terms of land acquisition; affected people (PAPs) / communities including vulnerable persons and vulnerable groups are evaluated in this section. Chapter 5 describes basic principles of the Resettlement Program including principles that will govern the land acquisition process of the Project, the main objectives of the resettlement policy, land acquisition and resettlement process, valuation methodologies, calculations for compensation payments, types of land rights to be established, eligibility criteria for defining various categories of PAPs, cut-off date and identification of PAPs. 12 Chapter 6 presents and evaluates the resettlement related impacts of the Project identified during the RAP studies, impact types according to each Project component, usage limitations after reinstatement. Chapter 7 presents the mitigation strategy. The general approach to mitigation strategy, compensation of losses, definition of affected assets, valuation methodology and compensation, support under the RAP Fund, eligibility criteria and appropriate PAPs, types of subsistence support, entitlement matrix are described in this section. Chapter 8 sets out the institutional framework which includes the proposed steps for determining the institution(s) responsible for resettlement activities, evaluating the institutional capacity of these institution(s), recommended measures to increase the institutional capacity and the regulations for the resettlement management are listed in this section. Chapter 9 describes public consultation and disclosure activities. A description of the consultation and participation strategy in the design and implementation of the resettlement activities; a summary of the opinions expressed in the preparation of the resettlement plan and consideration of these opinions, the resettlement alternatives presented and the choices made by the displaced persons, the institutional arrangements to ensure PAPs can raise their concerns to the project authorities during the planning and implementation and measures to ensure the representation of vulnerable groups are considered here. Chapter 10 provides information on the grievance mechanism. The plan describes accessible procedures for resolving third party disputes arising from displacement or resettlement. Such grievance mechanisms will take account of the judicial application and the existence of society and the traditional dispute resolution mechanisms. Chapter 11 comprises of implementation schedule. It provides an application program that provides the estimated dates for displacement and the estimated start and completion dates for all resettlement activities. The schedule will show how resettlement activities are linked to the implementation of the project. Chapter 12 provides information on the monitoring approach. To provide full and objective information, third party observers considered to be eligible under OP 4.12, regulations for monitoring the relocation and resettlement activities by the implementing organization; performance monitoring indicators that measure the inputs, outputs and outputs of relocation activities; the inclusion of internally displaced persons in the monitoring process; the evaluation of the results for a reasonable period after completion of all resettlement activities is evaluated in this section. Chapter 13 includes the budget table showing cost categorized for all resettlement activities. Finally, in the Appendices Chapter, copies of the census and survey instruments; information on all stakeholder consultations; a template of grievance form; asset inventory and valuation; RAP Fund Management Guideline; Examples of formats to be used for monitoring and reporting RAP implementation are also included in this section. 13 1. INTRODUCTION This Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) has been prepared to identify and evaluate the resettlement impacts of the Tuz Golu Natural Gas Underground Storage Expansion Project (herein after “GSEP” and / or “Project”). GSEP aims to increase the capacity of the existing Underground Gas Storage Project (UGS Project)1 of BOTAŞ in the same region, which had been put into practice with the aim of regulating seasonal natural gas fluctuations, fulfilling purchase and sale commitments, ensuring flexibility in gas purchase-sale agreements and thus raising the bargaining power, ensuring uninterrupted gas supply and efficient pipeline operation, meeting the excessive demand during summer months due to electricity generation, creating a strategic reserve against unforeseeable technical disruptions in gas supply and providing service to all consumers in the natural gas system of Turkey. BOTAŞ commits to promote sustainable development and social welfare in the areas in which it operates. Therefore, the GSEP will carry out its activities in a manner that protects the environment and communities in line with the concerning international safeguard policies. In the current phase of the project, in addition to the national Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Report which was approved by the Turkish Ministry of Environment and Urbanization (MoEU) on 10.03.2017, the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) and Resettlement Policy Framework (RPF) documents were also prepared to meet the WB requirements. The ESIA Report of the Project including its relevant management plans2 was prepared in 2018. The management plans prepared include environmental and social impact mitigation and management measures to be implemented. The construction contract of the GSEP was signed on 25.03.2019, but it is not yet effective. GSEP is funded by World Bank (IBRD) and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB). The design and implementation of this RAP will be in line with Turkish law and the World Bank Operational Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (WB OP 4.12) which have been captured in the GSEP RPF approved by the World Bank during Project preparation. In case of any discrepancy between Turkish Law and WB OP 4.12, the provisions of OP 4.12 shall apply. 1.1. Description of the Project The Tuz Golu Underground Natural Gas Storage (UGS) Project is located in Sultanhani locality of Aksaray Province, at about 40 km south of Tuz Golu and consists of several components such as pipelines (fresh water line from Hirfanlı Dam to UGS Sites, brine discharge line from UGS sites to Tuz Golu, and natural gas branch line to Eastern Anatolia Natural Gas Main Transmission Line), pump stations and storage tanks, energy transmission lines, surface facilities and UGS Sites. The land acquisition (LAC) process of UGS Project was initiated by the Department of Land Estate and Expropriation within BOTAŞ in accordance with Approval number 1423 on October 3, 2007. First compensation payments were made in December 2012. The LAC process was finalized when compensation payments were completed in March 2015. All project components including the construction of the natural gas, water and brine pipelines, the pumping stations and 12 storage wells had required the acquisition of 749 hectares (ha) of land, either temporarily (382 ha) or permanently (367 ha). 44% of total land acquired for UGS Project was public and 56% was private, affecting a total of 4,061 landowners. The number of private land subject to acquisition was 1,036 plots. The land 1 For more detail on this existing Project, please refer to the Project Background section in the Gas Storage Expansion Project Final ESIA Report disclosed on March 26, 2018 on BOTAS official website: https://www.botas.gov.tr/index/tur/kurumsal/duyurular/duyurular.asp 2 For more detail, please see https://www.botas.gov.tr/index/tur/kurumsal/duyurular/duyurular.asp 14 acquisition process of UGS Project was carried out in line with the Turkish Legal Framework as well as World Bank Policy (OP 4.12) on Involuntary Resettlement. UGS Project aims to regulate seasonal natural gas fluctuations, fulfilling purchase and sale commitments, ensuring flexibility in gas purchase-sale agreements and thus raising the bargaining power, ensuring uninterrupted gas supply and efficient pipeline operation, meeting the excessive demand during summer months due to electricity generation, creating a strategic reserve against unforeseeable technical disruptions in gas supply and providing service to all consumers in the natural gas system of Turkey. The existing UGS Project continues and shows good progress; drilling of all twelve caverns has been completed, leaching and first gas filling activities are being undertaken. The caverns are located approximately at the depth of 1100-1450 m below ground surface. Each cavern will have a geometrical cavern volume of 630.000 m3-750.000 m3. The first three caverns have been operational since 2017, and the storage capacity has reached 0.25 bcm. All twelve caverns will be ready for operation in 2021 and the storage capacity will reach 1.2 bcm. GSEP is planned to increase the capacity of the existing UGS Project from 1.2 bcm to 5.4 bcm by constructing additional salt caverns with similar properties of the existing caverns. In addition to the existing UGS Project facilities, the following components will be constructed: • 40 + 8 (spare) caverns with 4.2 bcm storage capacity, • 1 surface facility, • 1 natural gas connection pipeline (between Kayseri–Konya–Seydişehir sections (at app. 23 km north of the Project site) of the existing Eastern Anatolia Natural Gas Main Transmission Line to the Project site) • 1 fresh water pipeline, • 1 brine discharge pipeline, • Field pipelines, • 4 pump stations, • Energy transmission lines (ETLs), • Access roads and other associated structures. The UGS project and planned Project areas are shown in Figure 1. 15 Figure 1 The Project Areas of the UGS Project and GSEPThe construction phase of the Project is planned to start in the second quarter of 2019 and to be completed in last quarter of 2023. After the completion of the Project construction phase, it is planned to have an estimated 30 years of operation phase. This Plan includes the assessment of Project’ impacts regarding physical and economic displacement and the development of mitigation measures or compensation strategies. Following the World Bank approval of this RAP, the land acquisition process will begin. One of the main approaches of the Project is not to cause physical displacement. Thus, physical displacement was avoided in the Project design and no physical displacement will take place as observed in the site studies. The land requirements of 16 the above-mentioned components of the Project are anticipated to result only in economic displacement. 1.2. Minimizing Resettlement Impact GSEP is committed to comply with local, regional and national requirements as a minimum, and will go beyond these requirements when needed. In order to minimize land acquisition-induced impacts of Project on people and communities, the most suitable and feasible project design with respect to the project components were developed. To say explicitly;  While selecting locations of the well areas, BOTAŞ considered to keep away from residential areas in order not to cause any physical displacement.  The GSEP avoids full expropriation of the lands between the well locations leaving it for the use of PAPs;  In order to decrease the number of new lands to be expropriated due to pipeline construction, the existing pipeline routes were considered as much as possible.  Less ownership rights but more easement rights were preferred as a land acquisition method where possible to allow for maximum use of land after Project implementation. 1.3. Project Affected Settlements Total of 993 parcels will be affected by the land acquisition of fresh water, brine water, gas pipeline, well areas and surface facilities. 810 parcels in total are private land and remaining 183 parcels are registered as public land. Distribution of total number of parcels according to project components is given in the table below. Tablo 1-1 Number of Parcels and Area Hectares According to Project Components NUMBER OF PARCELS3 AREA (Ha) # OF PROJECT COMPONENTS TEMPORARY PERMANENT TOTAL PUBLIC PRIVATE LANDOWNERS EASEMENT EASEMENT Freshwater line (from Hirfanlı Dam to Kayseri-Seydişehir brach 832 101 731 104,2 282,4 2144 connection) Freshwater line+natural gas line (from Kayseri-Seydişehir brach 10 5 5 1,0 10,0 29 connection to brine discharge connection) Freshwater line+brine water line+ natural gas line (from brine 50 27 23 0,3 72,6 93 discharge connection to surface facilities) Brine water line (from brine discharge connection to 22 22 0 0,5 27,0 1 discharge point) SUB-TOTAL 1 914 155 759 108 392 2267 PROJECT COMPONENTS NUMBER OF PARCELS AREA (Ha) 3The number of parcels given may be subject to changes during the basic engineering studies as the Project footprint will be made definite. 17 OWNERSHIP PERMANENT # OF TOTAL PUBLIC PRIVATE RIGHT EASEMENT LANDOWNERS Surface Facilities 10 5 5 30 TBD 3 Well Locations 69 23 46 49 TBD 96 Other Areas4 TBD TBD TBD - TBD TBD SUB TOTAL-2 79 28 51 79 TBD 99 GENERAL TOTAL 993 183 810 N/A 542 2366 No residential areas or units are present in the 54 m study corridor of fresh water, brine water and natural gas pipeline. A total of 28 settlements are affected by the land acquisition of Project. These 28 settlements are located within the boundaries of 8 districts of 3 provinces. One of these 28 settlements is located in the borders of Ankara and another in the province of Konya. The remaining 26 settlements are located in the province of Aksaray. 26 settlements out of 28 are affected by pipelines where lands are acquired through easement rights whereas 3 settlements out of 28 are affected by well areas and surface facilities where lands are acquired through ownership rights or permanent easement rights. As seen in table given below, one of these 28 settlements are affected by both pipelines and well areas. Distribution of the affected settlements by province and project components are given in the table below: Tablo 1-2 Project Affected Settlements, Districts and Provinces No Affected Settlements Project Component Province District Village/Quarter 1 Ankara Evren Center Pump station and freshwater line 2 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Center Freshwater line 3 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Boğazköy Pump station and Freshwater line 4 Aksaray Ağaçören Kütüklü Freshwater line 5 Aksaray Ağaçören Center Pump station and Freshwater line 6 Aksaray Ağaçören Camili Pump station and Freshwater line 7 Aksaray Ağaçören Kederli Freshwater line 8 Aksaray Ağaçören Abdiuşağı Freshwater line 9 Aksaray Ağaçören Çatalçeşme Freshwater line 10 Aksaray Ortaköy Hacımahmutuşağı Freshwater line 11 Aksaray Ortaköy Hacıibrahimuşağı Freshwater line 12 Aksaray Ortaköy Hıdırlı-Fakıcık Freshwater line 13 Aksaray Ortaköy Pınarbaşı Freshwater line 14 Aksaray Ortaköy İshaklı Karapınar Freshwater line 15 Aksaray Ortaköy Camuzluk Freshwater line 16 Aksaray Merkez Bostanlık Freshwater line 17 Aksaray Merkez Cerit Freshwater line 18 Aksaray Merkez Altınkaya Freshwater line 19 Aksaray Merkez Hanobası Freshwater line 20 Aksaray Merkez Sapmaz Freshwater line 21 Aksaray Merkez Baymış Freshwater line 22 Aksaray Merkez Yeşiltepe Town Freshwater line 23 Aksaray Merkez Yeşilova Town Freshwater line 24 Aksaray Merkez Yenikent Town Freshwater line 25 Aksaray Eskil Center Brine discharge line Freshwater line, brine discharge line, natural gas 26 Aksaray Sultanhanı Center line, well areas and surface facilities 27 Aksaray Eskil Güneşli Well areas and surface facilities 28 Konya Emirgazi Besci Well areas and surface facilities 4 Other areas include energy transmission lines including pole locations, access roads, pump stations and connection lines between UGS sites. 18 The private and public lands belonging to the settlements shown in the above table shall be affected by the Project. The following table provides information on the settlements affected by fresh water, brine water and natural gas pipelines of the Project. Total of 914 parcels are affected by the construction of pipelines component of the Project while 79 parcels are affected by the well areas and surface facilities which requires permanent land acquisition on lands. Out of the 914 parcels affected by pipelines, 759 are private lands which constitute the highest portion of total. 76 parcels are registered as common public lands (mostly pastures) and 50 parcels are registered as treasury. Total number of landowners on the affected private lands are 2.267, however it should be noted that the number of formal/informal users on lands are quite lower than the number of landowners since it represents multiple ownership on most affected lands. Tablo 1-3 Number of Settlements and Parcels (by land type) Affected by Pipelines Components of the Project Public Total Total Institutions No. of No. of Comm (Municipali Total No. land formal/ Villag Numbe on ties, Of user informa e legal No. Of r of public BOTAŞ, Landowner among l land entity Affected affecte land State s land user Village/Q d Water owners PROVINCE DISTRICT uarter parcels Private Treasury Works etc.) AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ 2 124 119 0 1 3 1 411 42 45 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN 6 209 189 14 5 0 1 730 43 55 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY 6 111 108 2 1 0 0 505 33 54 AKSARAY MERKEZ 9 343 297 25 9 8 4 529 71 129 SULTANHAN 1 106 43 6 53 2 2 90 4 35 AKSARAY I AKSARAY ESKİL 1 7 0 0 7 0 0 0 - - ANKARA EVREN 1 14 3 3 0 8 0 2 1 1 26 914 759 50 76 21 8 2267 194 319 TOTAL The total permanent easement area for the pipelines component the Project is 22.166 ha while the total temporary easement area is 4.616 ha. The distribution of the land areas based on the easement and land type is given in the table below. Table1-4 Area of Lands by Easement and Land Types (Pipelines Component) Type of Land Permanent Easement Area Temporary Easement Area Private 902.733,69 m2 391.179,84 m2 Public 222.650,37 m2 64.407,17 m2 Pasture 1.061.761,30 m2 0,00 m2 Institution 29.250,89 m2 5.987,83 m2 BOTAŞ 194,19 m2 54,78 m2 TOTAL 2.216.590,44 m2 461.629,62 m2 The information on lands to be expropriated for well areas and surface facilities are given in the table below (Table1-5 Number of Settlements and Parcels (by land type) Affected by Well Areas and Surface Facilities of the Project ). Total area required as permanent for these Project components is 79 ha. 19 Table1-5 Number of Settlements and Parcels (by land type) Affected by Well Areas and Surface Facilities of the Project Total Total No. No. of of land formal/in user formal among land user Number land of owners Affected affected Total No. Of NO Province District Village/Quarter parcels Private Treasury Pasture Institution BOTAŞ Landowners 21 10 1 AKSARAY SULTANHANI Center 61 36 3 22 0 0 72 3 - 2 AKSARAY ESKİL Güneşli 5 3 0 2 0 0 3 10 3 3 KONYA KARAPINAR Besci 13 12 0 1 0 0 24 34 13 TOTAL 3 79 51 3 25 0 0 99 Table 1-6 Area of Lands by Ownership and Easement Rights and Land Types (Surface Facilities and Well Areas) Type of Land Permanent Easement Right Area Ownership Right Area Private TBD* 34 Public TBD 0,19 Pasture TBD 44,81 Institution TBD 0 BOTAŞ TBD 0 TOTAL - 79 *Since the exact locations of connection lines between UGS sites are not yet determined, land acquisition data is not available at this stage. Distribution of number of owners/tenants, users according to the settlements affected by the Project is given in following tables (Table 1-7 and Table 1-8). Total of 28 settlements are affected by the different components of the Project. While 26 settlements are affected by pipelines, 3 settlements are affected by well areas and surface facilities. Sultanhanı Center is affected by both pipelines and well areas/surface facilities. Table 1-7 Number of Parcels and All Types of Users by Pipeline Affected Settlements Affected Settlement Number Number of Number Number of Number Number of of PAPs Owners of of Users PAPs (formal of PAPs ( owner (informal No Quarter/Villa Acquired of users – Province District Parcels users) users) ge Private Acquired renters) Acquired interviewed interview Parcels5 Parcels interviewed ed 1 Ankara Evren Merkez 14 2 2 - 1 2 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Merkez 51 93 46 4 1 1 3 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Boğazköy 73 318 41 8 4 4 4 Aksaray Ağaçören Kütüklü 25 57 13 6 2 5 Aksaray Ağaçören Merkez 52 139 15 4 1 1 6 Aksaray Ağaçören Camili 30 78 18 5 2 - 7 Aksaray Ağaçören Kederli 54 202 23 8 - 1 8 Aksaray Ağaçören Abdiuşağı 26 167 12 2 1 1 9 Aksaray Ağaçören Çatalçeşme 22 87 17 2 2 Hacımahmutu 10 Aksaray Ortaköy 29 153 21 3 1 2 şağı Hacıibrahimuş 11 Aksaray Ortaköy 7 17 6 2 - - ağı 5 Landowners exist only on private lands while land users can be identified both on private and public lands. 20 12 Aksaray Ortaköy Hıdırlı-Fakıcık 26 75 14 3 1 13 Aksaray Ortaköy Pınarbaşı 20 65 17 1 1 - İshaklı 14 Aksaray Ortaköy 23 130 23 5 1 - Karapınar 15 Aksaray Ortaköy Camuzluk 6 65 6 3 - 16 Aksaray Merkez Bostanlık 24 58 21 3 1 2 17 Aksaray Merkez Cerit 37 76 19 7 3 18 Aksaray Merkez Altınkaya 22 28 12 6 1 19 Aksaray Merkez Hanobası 11 26 8 2 - - 20 Aksaray Merkez Sapmaz 114 130 58 8 1 1 21 Aksaray Merkez Baymış 29 28 18 5 - 1 Yeşiltepe 22 Aksaray Merkez 75 157 60 11 2 5 Beldesi Yeşilova 23 Aksaray Merkez 7 3 2 1 - - Beldesi Yenikent 24 Aksaray Merkez 24 23 2 1 - - Beldesi 25 Aksaray Eskil Center 7 - - - - - 26 Aksaray Sultanhanı Center 106 90 39 13 1 TOTAL 914 2.267 513 113 16 30 Table 1-8 Number of Parcels and All types of Users in the Settlement subject to Land Acquisition (Well Areas and Surface Facilities) N Affected Settlement Number of Number of o Number of PAPs Number Number of Number of PAPs Owners/Te (formal of Users of PAPs (owner (informal nants of users- Provinc Quarter/Villag Parcels Acquired users) users) District Acquired renters) e e Acquired Parcels interviewed interviewe Parcels interviewe d d 1 Aksaray Sultanhan Center 8 61 72 31 20 1 ı 2 Aksaray Eskil Güneşli 5 3 3 1 1 3 Konya Emirgazi Besci 13 24 13 10 3 TOTAL 79 99 47* 44 *The field study was carried out with full census method in lands acquired through ownership rights and permanent easement rights as stated in Table 1-4. p. However, the total number of users identified in the expropriation data could not been reached due to reasons such as death, no longer being active in agricultural activity, living abroad etc. The development and operation of the GSEP will have both positive and negative impacts in the local socio-economic environment, district, province and national level. The positive impacts are mainly related to the economic advantages associated with the Project. These positive impacts include the employment opportunities, local procurement, business opportunities and community development. The negative impacts are mainly related to the economic displacement of the affected communities. The Resettlement Action Plan was prepared in order to evaluate these adverse effects and to develop mitigation measures. In particular, physical resettlement was avoided when designing the Project and no impact of the Project causing physical displacement is foreseen. 21 Figure 2 The Project Well Areas 22 Figure 3 The Project Surface Facilities 2. OBJECTIVES OF THE RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN BOTAŞ commits to promote sustainable development and social welfare in the areas in which it operates. Therefore, the (GSEP) will carry out its activities in a manner that protects the environment and communities. GSEP will assess the social, health, safety and environmental related impacts of its activities and integrate these assessments into its planning, design and operational decisions. This RAP describes the objectives, principles, procedures and measures to be adopted prior to, during and after displacement of people and assets affected by the Project. GSEP commits to follow WB OP 4.12 in the development and implementation of RAP. The objectives of this RAP are as follows; 23 i. Develop and implement a fair, transparent and negotiated resettlement process where all stakeholders and affected parties can participate; ii. To define compensation and mitigation measures in line with national law and Bank policies that allows to minimize the land acquisition induced impact; iii. To establish appropriate management procedures and systems for RAP implementation; iv. To ensure consistency with Bank requirements in the implementation of resettlement and compensation activities; v. To implement all resettlement activities with the affected parties; vi. To ensure involvement of stakeholders in a participatory way to the planning, implementation and monitoring processes of RAP through disclosure of this RAP to stakeholders and on-going consultations throughout the resettlement process; vii. Develop and implement appropriate grievance procedures and mechanisms; viii. Monitoring (and, if necessary, revising) resettlement and restoration activities during and after resettlement; ix. To ensure that vulnerable people/groups receive additional assistance when necessary. The ESIA Report of the Project was prepared in 2018. Within the scope of the ESIA Report6, management plans have been also prepared and are being implemented through the environmental and social impact mitigation and management measures presented in this report. The land acquisition induced impacts of the Project have been introduced in the ESIA and fundamentals of mitigating these impacts have been set out in the Project’s RPF. This RAP serves to provide detail on land based impacts of the Project and defines the approach and measures to be adopted to avoid or minimize these impacts. The local socio-economic context of the RAP is based on the findings of the field survey conducted in March 2019. The scope of the RAP is determined within the framework of the project design parameters described in the approved ESIA. RAP is prepared to incorporate the resettlement impacts into the Project. In the current phase of the Project, RAP discusses the resettlement impacts associated with the Project activities. GSEP acts in accordance with WB OP 4.12 to minimize the impact on affected people and describes how to implement measures to minimize the resettlement impacts of the Project with this RAP, and how to monitor the success of mitigation measures. The objectives set out in this RAP will be applicable to all Project activities developed in relation to the construction and operation of the Project elements within the EIA permit area. This plan is a living document. Therefore, the changes to the Project’s Environmental and Social Management System (ESMS) may also cause updates and changes to this RAP which will be approved by the Bank. This RAP is part of a series of plans prepared earlier for the Project. This plan therefore has overlaps and cross-links with the following documents prepared for the Project: i. Resettlement Policy Framework ii. Stakeholder Engagement Plan iii. Community Health and Safety Management Plan iv. Labor Influx Management Plan v. Occupational Health and Safety Management Plan vi. Noise and Vibration Management Plan vii. Air Quality Management Plan 6 For more information please see: https://www.botas.gov.tr/docs/ihaleler/2018/ddb_GSEP_ESIA_Report.pdf 24 viii. Erosion and Sediment Control Plan 2.1. Development of the Resettlement Action Plan The steps followed in the development of the RAP are listed below: i. Evaluation of the scope of resettlement impacts ii. Consultations and information disclosure with affected communities iii. On-going consultations with PAPs and other stakeholders iv. Disclosing of cut-off dates for compensation eligibility v. Carrying out asset inventory studies vi. Developing compensation strategies and mitigation measures, vii. Devoloping a RAP implementation and budget timeline, viii. Executing public consultation and disclosure activities for RAP in line with the Project SEP. 2.2. Scope of the Resettlement Action Plan Chapter 1 of the RAP provides an overview of the Project activities and information on the land acquisition requirements of the Project. This introduction also provides a general description of the Project and its area of influence; listing the Project components in relation to their impacts on land. Main efforts of the Project on minimizing resettlement is also detailed in this section. Chapter 2 includes information on the development process, scope and objectives of this RAP together with its limitations on the preparation process. Chapter 3 describes the national legislation and institutional framework related to the development and the implementation of RAP. This section also describes applicable international standards and policies that form the RAP framework. The legislational scope of involuntary resettlement and land use restrictions and the nature of the compensation related to both the valuation methodology and the timing of payment are considered in this section. Applicable legislative and administrative procedures, including a description of the existing solutions in the judicial process for displaced persons the legal timeframe for these procedures and the current grievance redress mechanisms that may be relevant to the Project, are set forth under this chapter. The chapter provides information on the institutions responsible for the implementation of the resettlement activities. Chapter 4 initially provides the methodology applied during the preparation of this RAP and then evaluates the socio-economic baseline status of region and communities on the basis of Census and socio-economic survey. Key data and potential project impacts in terms of land acquisition; affected people (PAPs) / communities including vulnerable persons and vulnerable groups are evaluated in this section. Chapter 5 describes basic principles of the Resettlement Program including principles that will govern the land acquisition process of the Project, the main objectives of the Resettlement Policy, land acquisition and resettlement process, valuation methodologies, calculations for compensation payments, types of land rights to be established, eligibility criteria for defining various categories of PAPs, cut-off date and identification of PAPs. Chapter 6 presents and evaluates the resettlement related impacts of the Project identified during the RAP studies, impact types according to each Project component, usage limitations after reinstatement. Chapter 7 presents the mitigation strategy. The general approach to mitigation strategy, compensation of losses, definition of affected assets, valuation methodology and compensation, support under the 25 RAP Fund, eligibility criteria and appropriate PAPs, types of subsistence support, entitlement matrix are described in this section. Chapter 8 sets out the institutional framework which includes the proposed steps for determining the institution(s) responsible for resettlement activities, evaluating the institutional capacity of these institution(s), recommended measures to increase the institutional capacity and the regulations for the resettlement management are listed in this section. Chapter 9 describes public consultation and disclosure activities. A description of the consultation and participation strategy in the design and implementation of the resettlement activities; a summary of the opinions expressed in the preparation of the resettlement plan and consideration of these opinions, the resettlement alternatives presented and the choices made by the displaced persons, the institutional arrangements to ensure PAPs canraise their concerns to the project authorities during the planning and implementation and measures to ensure the representation of vulnerable groups are considered here. Chapter 10 provides information on the grievance mechanism. The plan describes accessible procedures for resolving third party disputes arising from displacement or resettlement. Such grievance mechanisms will take account of the judicial application and the existence of society and the traditional dispute resolution mechanisms. Chapter 11 comprises of implementation schedule. It provides an application program that provides the estimated dates for displacement and the estimated start and completion dates for all resettlement activities. The schedule will show how resettlement activities are linked to the implementation of the project. Chapter 12 includes the budget table showing cost estimates categorized for all resettlement activities, including emergency, expenditure sources. Chapter 13 provides information on monitoring and evaluation. To provide full and objective information, third party observers considered to be eligible under OP 4.12, regulations for monitoring the relocation and resettlement activities by the implementing organization; performance monitoring indicators that measure the inputs, outputs and outputs of relocation activities; the inclusion of internally displaced persons in the monitoring process; the evaluation of the results for a reasonable period after completion of all resettlement activities is evaluated in this section. Finally, in the Annexes Chapter, copies of the census and survey instruments; information on all stakeholder consultations, including announcements and programs of public meetings, meeting minutes and participant lists. Examples of formats to be used for monitoring and reporting RAP implementation are also included in this section. 2.3. Limitations of RAP A number of limitations have been encountered during preparation of this RAP which are as follows:  Scope of this RAP doesn’t include the following Project components; energy transmission lines including pole locations, access roads, pump stations and connection lines between UGS sites. It is envisaged that an addendum to RAP will be prepared for such components. Table 2-1 Estimated table of energy transmission lines including pole locations, access roads, pump stations and connection lines between UGS sites Project Component Expected Land Acquisition Type of Land Acquisition 26 Pump Stations and Storage Tanks 10 locations Ownership Rights 50m*50m=2500 m2 each 2,5 ha in total Access Roads 1,4 ha in total Ownership Rights ETL (Freshwater Pipeline) 184 poles Ownership Rights 5m*5m=25 m2 each 0,5 ha in total 130 km long Permanent Easement 130,000m*20m=160 ha in total ETLs (NSF) 63 poles Ownership Rights 5m*5m=25 m2 each 0,15 ha in total 18 km long Permanent Easement 18,000m*20m=36 ha in total Total estimated land to be acquired for pump stations, water storage tanks, access roads and ETLs including pole locations are, 4,55 ha and 196 ha with ownership rights and permanent easement, respectively.  National statistics are not allowed to make assessment at micro level, particularly, land-based livelihood patterns at household level, average household size on a village base, household composition in terms of occupation, sex, age, education and more importantly, income sources cannot be obtained from national statistics. Therefore, a comprehensive household survey had to be designed and conducted via a field study within the scope of this RAP.  There might be difficulties in accessing landowners due to remarkable out-migration in rural areas like this Project-affected area; however, this possible limitation could have been overcome during field study by focusing on actual land users living in the area.  Existence of seasonal workers nearby the Project-affected area is another social fact to be considered. No direct adverse impact on these groups is anticipated as their accommodation sites are not located on the Project-affected lands. On the other hand, the lands to be acquired for the Project might be the areas where they will work however, it was learned in the field study that they have a chance to work on other available agricultural lands that will not be acquired. Limitation on this issue was that no interview could be conducted with seasonal workers directly because none of them had arrived in the region as it is now out of cultivation season. For this reason, disclosure and consultation activities with these groups need to be carried out when they arrive in the region for work. 27 3. LEGAL FRAMEWORK This section outlines the legislative framework that pertains to land acquisition, expropriation and involuntary resettlement in Turkey as it applies to BOTAŞ. It provides a summary of the relevant Turkish legislations and WB/IFC policies. 3.1. Review of the National Legislation Governing Land Acquisition and Resettlement The Turkish Constitution, Article 46, under Subsection 3 of the Section 3 with the heading of “Social and Economic Rights and Responsibilities”, addresses expropriation issues. The article states that whenever a development project serves public interest, the government is authorized to initiate and execute an expropriation process. All hydropower, airport, highway and other roads, and similar large- scale infrastructure projects are considered to be in public interest and provide the basis for Article 46. The Article refers to the Expropriation Law. 3.1.2. Expropriation Law The specific article of Constitution states that except special cases the compensation value and the decreed increased value will be paid in full and cash to the users. The compensation of the farmers farming the acquired land is paid in full and cash, in any case. Private users cannot benefit from the expropriation of public lands and assets without paying compensation to the public at large. Even when land is acquired for public interest, expropriation agencies cannot benefit from the expropriation of private lands and assets without paying into a private bank account, in advance of actual land appropriation and project construction, the value of the expropriated assets. Expropriation Law sets the procedures to be followed during; if and when it is required for public interest;  the expropriation of immovable owned by real persons or legal identities subject to private law,  the calculation of the expropriation fee,  registration of the immovable asset and its appurtenances in the name of the expropriation administration,  reclamation of the unused immovable assets, mutual rights and obligations as well as the procedures and methods for the settlement of the conflicts pertaining to them. Article 3 - Requirements for Expropriation For the implementation of large projects that concern issues such as energy, irrigation and afforestation etc., administrations may expropriate by paying the fee for the immovables, resources and their easement rights in cash or as down payment in equal instalments, as required for the conduct of public services or interventions they are obliged to provide according to laws. Article 7 - Initial Procedures to be performed for Expropriation and Administrative Annotation The administration that is to perform the expropriation prepares or commissions a scaled plan indicating the borders, surface area and type of the immovable assets of resources on which expropriation is to be constituted or appurtenances is to be constituted by way of expropriation, enables that the owners of the expropriated immovable asset, the ownerships if no title deed 28 registrations are present and their addresses by binding them to documents through an inquiry it would conduct on the land registry, tax and population registry records as well as additional inquiries. After the administration takes the decision on expropriation, the related annotation of the expropriation in the title deed is notified to the title deed administration where the mentioned immovable asset is registered. If the owner changes after the notification date, the title deed administration is obliged to notify the administration of any changes to occur in the ownership or in the rights in kind that are separate from the ownership. If the document to be obtained from the court indicating that a request for the identification of the expropriation fee and the registration in the name of the administration as per the Article 10 is not submitted to the title deed administration within six months starting on the annotation date, this annotation is ex officio deleted from the title deed records. Article 8 – Procurement Procedure According to Article 8, after the expropriation decision is made, the administration will appoint one or more valuation commissions (consisting of at least 3 people) to identify the value of immovable. Additionally, one or more negotiation commissions (again consisting of at least 3 people) will be assigned for negotiations. After the administration has notified the owner of its intent to take over the immovable, shall the owner or its representative apply to the administration (within 15 days after notification) with the intent of selling the immovable, negotiation meetings are held on the date identified by the commission and if an agreement is reached on an amount that is not more than the estimated value, an official report is signed. The administration prepares the amount stated in the report within forty days and asks the owner to transfer the ownership rights in the name of the administration on the date specified in the title deed. The expropriation fee is paid as soon as the transfer of rights is realized. In cases where an agreement is not reached or transfer is not realized, action is taken as per the Article 10 of this Law. Article 10 – Identification of the Expropriation Fee by Court and Registration of Immovable in the Name of the Administration Article 10 states that, if the expropriation cannot be realized through procurement, the administration applies to the court of first instance in the locale of the immovable and requests that the expropriation fee for the immovable asset be identified and decision be made for its registration in the name of the administration in return for the payment of this fee. Within 30 days of the application of the administration, the Court notifies the owner of the immovables through an annotated invitation on the date of hearing. To those whose addresses could not be found after inquiries an announcement is made according to Notification Law (No. 7201) inviting them to attend the hearing. The Court also publishes information on the expropriation at least once in a local newspaper (if there is any) issued in the location of the immovable and in one of the newspapers circulated across Turkey. On the day of the hearing, the judge invites the parties to reach an agreement on the value of the immovable. If an agreement is reached, the judge considers this fee to be the expropriation fee. In cases where an agreement is not reached, the judge schedules an expedition (within ten days) to identify the value of the immovable asset and a date for the second hearing (within thirty days after the expedition). On the second hearing, if the parties fail to agree on the value once again, the judge will assign a new expert commission for the valuation within fifteen days and then identifies a fair and equitable expropriation fee by referencing both the reports and statements of the parties and experts. The identified fee is the expropriation fee of the immovable, resource or its easement rights. The Court grants fifteen days to the administration for the fee to be deposited in a bank on behalf of the owner. In cases where the right holder could not be identified, the court decides on the registration of the immovable in the name of the administration under the circumstances that the bank receipt indicating 29 the amount was blocked to be given to the right holder to be revealed in the future and that this decision is notified to the title deed department and the bank where the fee was deposited. The provision on registration is definitive and the parties reserve their rights for appeal pertaining to the fee. Article 27 – Urgent Expropriation The Expropriation Law (Article 27) states that, subject to a Council of Ministers Decree for national defense or in case of emergency, any immovable property may be expropriated by the administration undertaking expropriation for public interest. Such a Council of Ministers Decree has already been obtained by BOTAŞ with respect to the Project. To apply the emergency clause of the law and to urgently acquire land through this mechanism, the value of the immovable property and asset (crop values are determined and paid prior to land entry) in question must be appraised by the valuation commission (established within the expropriation agency consist of relevant discipline experts) according to the article 11 of the Expropriation Law within seven days. The expropriation shall be made after the appraised value of the immovable is fully deposited by the administration in the name of the owner. Article 27 of the law allows the expropriation body to enter the field earlier as compared to the timing of entry under the standard expropriation procedures, but the article does not limit the claims of the owner on valuation of land and fixed assets. The valuation process is done by the court or court nominated experts within one week. This article will only be used when other avenues have failed. 3.1.3. Resettlement Law Resettlement activities are regulated by Resettlement Law no 5543 and Regulation for the Execution of Resettlement Law. Resettlement Law deals with the families applying to related governmental agencies in the project region and requesting government assisted resettlement. Resettlement assistance of the government is provided for entitled families while expropriation compensation payments are paid to all individuals possessing immovable properties in the project area. According to the Article 3 of the Law, three types of resettlement can be applied as for that the choices and requests of affected families. Article 3 of the Law reads this point as follows; “ARTICLE 3 – (1) a) Agricultural resettlement: Agricultural resettlement is implemented through providing a family with the following; agricultural land at the amount of envisaged in special resettlement project prepared by Ministry of Environment and Urbanization (MoEU), house, management building, animal, agricultural devices and tools, workbench and credits one or more. b) Non – agricultural resettlement: This type of resettlement is implemented through providing a family with the following: building plot at the amount provisioned in special resettlement project, house, devices, tools, workbench and loans one or more. c) Physical settlement: This type of resettlement is implemented through providing construction credit support to a family within the amount of loan determined by the Ministry (MOEU) for the aim of re- building (moving) of villages because of unsuitability of a village centers or consolidating of villages because of dispersed settlement or villages which are fragmented as a result of disasters; after selling land (house plot) from village development areas to people in need”. Article 12 of the Law refers to the resettlement of persons whose immovable assets are expropriated, and specifies eligibility criteria for government assisted resettlement as follows: 30 “(1) Due to the construction of a dam, an area adjacent to the dam, an area under protection, airport, highway, railway, plant and other facilities related to national economy and defense will be erected by public institutions and organizations; and due to the implementation of special laws and in order to protect historical and natural valuables; a) The families who have to leave their locations/places as a result of partial or full expropriation of their immovable properties, b) The families who do not own any immovable property, but who reside in the expropriation area at least for three years before the beginning of the calendar year, in which the resettlement planning studies were commenced, will be resettled to the locations/places indicated by the Ministry (MoEU) according to the provisions of this Law, provided that they request. (2) However, the families who own immovable properties to be expropriated but left their places before the commencement date of resettlement planning studies shall not be resettled. Within the last three years as of this date, the families who sold their immovable properties without any compulsory situation and did not purchase immovable property with the equal or higher value shall not be resettled even if they did not leave their places. The compulsory situations mentioned above shall be determined by the regulations. (3) Among the families residing in the expropriation area, those who are affected from the expropriation implemented by the public institutions and organizations, can be resettled by the Ministry to a location indicated within their village boundaries upon their written application if they do not want to be resettled by the government in any other place, provided that the suggestion of relevant Governorate and the approval of the Ministry of Interior are obtained. (4) Among the families included in the scope of this article, and requested to be resettled by the Government; the families who do not apply within the ninety-day following the ending date of the announcement of resettlement, and the families who do not commit to deposit the amount determined by the Ministry (MoEU) from their expropriation compensation they received or will receive, or their full expropriation compensation and additional increase awarded by court in the case that the amount of expropriation compensation is lower than the amount (determined by the Ministry) into the account of the Central Account Unit of the Ministry, shall not be resettled. This article states that the affected family (entitled to expropriation compensation) requesting government assisted resettlement has to commit to deposit a certain amount of this compensation to the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization. The Regulations/Instructions for implementation of Resettlement Law defines this amount as 120 times of the gross monthly (30 days) minimum wage of any worker who is older than 16 years. If the affected household requesting government assisted resettlement is not entitled to expropriation compensation, then they are not required to pay down payment (as deposit) to the Ministry. Upon the completion of resettlement construction process the cost of resettlement shall be paid by the household to the Ministry within 15 years after a 5-year grace period and without interest. Naturally, the amount of down payment shall be taken into account (deducted). The amount of down payment is updated as of this netting date. Furthermore, according to regulations of the Law, if there are workers or persons with pension from any social security organization in the family, total annual amount of their wage/pension should be less than 18 times of monthly minimum gross wage. 31 Resettlement Assistance; Article 9 of Resettlement Law explains the resettlement assistance (which is similar to WB Standards) as follows: a) “At first, house and its’ house - plot (for building), b) For craftsmen, artisans and tradesmen: workplace and its’ building plot and operation credit to enable them providing for their livelihood, c) For farmers, land, necessary agricultural inputs, agricultural structures or plot of structure, and in kind and in cash operation and equipment credits as envisaged in agricultural resettlement project (specific), d) In case of the request of the right holder families (entitled to resettlement), resettlement credits can be given to the families collectively or individually, if the house, workplace and agricultural land are found by themselves and their suggestions are approved by MoEU.” Other assistances can be summarized as follows; “Transportation (moving) of those entitled families to the resettlement areas (sites) shall be provided free of charge by the government according to the “Transportation (moving) Project” to be prepared (specifically) by the Ministry,” In sum, landless families, renters of houses and/or workplaces, tenant users of the land, formal/informal users of treasury or forest areas and artisans including itinerant peddlers without immovable property but living in that area can be entitled to government assisted resettlement for which they might be eligible. The Resettlement Law and Regulation for the Execution of Resettlement Law provides for government- assisted resettlement in the rural and urban areas. For now, no residential areas or units are present in the 48m study corridor of fresh water, brine water lines and natural gas pipeline. However, since the well locations are not exactly determined yet, it is not possible to say whether there will be impacted residential areas/units or not. It is quite likely that a residential area or unit to be found on the well points since there are many scattered and small settlements within the Project area. If found, the Project will need to act according to the Resettlement Law and to entitle those who are forced to relocate as a result of land acquisition for investments in public interest. In addition to compliance with national law, BOTAŞ will also comply with the World Bank’s OP 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement in order to address any gaps that are found in Section 3.3 regarding resettlement entitlements. Consultation Requirements for Land Acquisition of the Legal Instruments The key legal instruments that regulate land expropriation and resettlement require different levels of consultation with the affected populations; the consultation requirements of these laws and their reference to stakeholder engagement do not correspond to international standards. The Expropriation Law focuses primarily on the provision of information to the affected owners of immovable assets. The Law also requires consultations and negotiations for the valuation of the expropriated assets; this requirement instructs the expropriation agency to work together with all relevant local institutions, including branches of the Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock, other government departments and real estate firms, as well as with the affected populations. The Resettlement Law incorporates a level of consultation with affected persons and communities that goes beyond mere information provision. These concern the choice of resettlement sites rather than on encompassing broader aspects of the resettlement process, such as house design, community layout, etc. Consultation with the affected people is essential in the framework of Government assisted 32 resettlement since the compensation payments for residential structures, together with other immovable assets on them, are kept by the resettlement agency to finance the new resettlement arrangements. Because the resettlement homes are often more costly than the traditional homes the affected people reside prior to the project, the difference between the value of affected assets and the actual costs of new residential units are paid by the affected people over a period of time. Thus, the concept of replacement cost that is privileged by the WB and IFC is not used in Government assisted resettlement arrangements. As a result, owners of affected assets often reject Government assisted resettlement; only those families that use (but do not own) the Project affected homes consider participation in such arrangements. Regulation for the Execution of Resettlement Law states that the disclosure shall be held by written notification and be posted for 30 days at an apparent place (such as schools, mosques, cooperative buildings etc.) The Cadastral Law (No. 3402) determines the boundaries and legal status of immovable assets based on the national coordinate system and the cadastral or the topographic cadastral maps in order to register land and to constitute the basis of the spatial information system as the Civil Law (No. 4721) stipulates. In accordance with the Cadastral Law, the regions to be surveyed shall be notified via the Official Gazette, radio, television and local newspapers and other traditional ways, 30 days prior to the beginning of cadastral works. At least 15 days prior to the cadastral surveys, the Cadastral Manager shall notify the village to be surveyed and the adjacent village and municipalities by traditional ways. The Cadastral Technicians shall inform the villagers by the traditional ways, about the place to be surveyed, seven days before they start the cadastral survey. 3.2. World Bank Policies Involuntary resettlement may cause severe long-term hardship, impoverishment, and environmental damage unless appropriate measures are carefully planned and carried out. For these reasons, the overall objectives of the World Bank's policy OP 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement are the following:  Involuntary resettlement should be avoided where feasible, or minimized, exploring all viable alternative project designs.  Where it is not feasible to avoid resettlement, resettlement activities should be conceived and executed as sustainable development programs, providing sufficient investment resources to enable the persons displaced by the project to share in project benefits. Displaced persons should be meaningfully consulted and should have opportunities to participate in planning and implementing resettlement programs.  Displaced persons should be assisted in their efforts to improve their livelihoods and standards of living or at least to restore them, in real terms, to pre-displacement levels or to levels prevailing prior to the beginning of project implementation, whichever is higher. To address the impacts covered under involuntary settlements of this policy, the borrower (BOTAŞ) prepares a resettlement plan or a resettlement policy framework that covers the following:  The resettlement plan or resettlement policy framework includes measures to ensure that the displaced persons are o informed about their options and rights pertaining to resettlement; o consulted on, offered choices among, and provided with technically and economically feasible resettlement alternatives; and o provided prompt and effective compensation at full replacement cost for losses of assets attributable directly to the project. 33  If the impacts include physical relocation, the resettlement plan or resettlement policy framework includes measures to ensure that the displaced persons are o provided assistance (such as moving allowances) during relocation; and o provided with residential housing, or housing sites, or, as required, agricultural sites for which a combination of productive potential, locational advantages, and other factors is at least equivalent to the advantages of the old site, compensation for their losses at full replacement cost and assistance in improving their former living standards, income earning capacity and production levels or at least restoring them. OP 4.12 requires that no land shall be acquired, or assets be lost before compensation is paid in full to the affected people and, where applicable, resettlement sites and moving allowances have been provided. Moreover, OP 4.12 requires the Project to create and implement a resettlement plan, the preparation of which involves the involuntary resettlers and hosts in planning. In this regard, OP 4.12 requires the Project to systematically inform and consult resettlers about their options and rights during the preparation of the resettlement plan. “Replacement cost” is the method of valuing assets endorsed by OP 4.12, and entails the following:  Paying special attention to the adequacy of the legal arrangements concerning land title, registration, and site occupation;  Publicizing among people to be displaced the laws and regulations on valuation and compensation;  Establishing criteria for determining the resettlement eligibility of affected households; and  The grievance procedures available for dispute over land acquisition. OP 4.12 also recognizes that some types of loss, such as access to public services, customers and suppliers, grazing or forest areas, cannot easily be compensated for in monetary terms and, therefore, requires the Project to attempt to identify alternative ways to fully restore pre-project levels of livelihoods. While OP 4.12 covers all affected people, it calls on the Project to pay particular attention to the needs of the poorest groups to be resettled and specifically states that the absence of legal title to land should not bar compensation to the population adversely affected by the Project, indigenous groups, ethnic minorities and pastoralists who may have usufruct or customary rights to the land or resources taken for the project. 3.3. Gap Analysis between National and International Policies There are several gaps between international and local standards in regard to the preparation of RAP. First, under Turkish law, RAP is not a requirement for investments that cause economic and physical displacement. Similarly, an Environmental and Social Impact Assessment is a requirement under international policy, but only an Environmental Impact Assessment is required under Turkish law. In addition, within the national legal framework, there is a lack of specific requirements for consultation and disclosure of RAP and Social Impact Assessment (SIA). The activities relevant to RAP consultations and disclosure are less explicit in Turkish national legislation, thus requiring the application of WB policies. The main gaps between Turkish Law and World Bank Group Policies are summarized in the table below. 34 Tablo 3.1-1 The Main GAPs Between Turkish Law and World Bank Group Policies Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs Adverse direct and indirect livelihood BOTAŞ commits to apply international requirements impacts of the land acquisition and other through a Resettlement Action Plan. immovable assets identified and minimized. There is no provisioning in the Turkish Law for livelihood restoration. In cases where land-based livelihood impacts are found to Lost livelihoods and decreased living be major a Livelihood Restoration Plan will be developed standards are restored and improved. and implemented. An assets inventory is prepared. Inventory of assets are required by Turkish Affected populations and impacts should Identification of Potentially Law. Representative socio-economic household survey is be: Adverse Impacts of Land conducted for the lands affected by the lines (fresh water, Acquisition Land acquisition through expropriation brine water and gas) and a full census is conducted for the  identified through thematic requires the preparation of a census of licensed area where the lands will be taken permanently. maps, a census, affected immovable assets, and a list of  an inventory of affected assets, their owners. Surveys, GIS and Corine database are analyzed.  socio-economic surveys and studies, No studies, surveys and consultations are Consultations in line with the SEP document are carried  analysis of surveys and studies, required. Consultations for negotiated out in different stages with a range of stakeholders.  consultation with affected purchase of immovable assets are required populations. Extensive consultations will form the basis of negotiated by Article 8 of Expropriation Law. settlements. There is no provision regarding the All project specific alternatives are evaluated and the Involuntary resettlement should be avoided minimization of resettlement in Turkish alternative that would result in a minimal level of physical or minimized where feasible. Laws. resettlement is selected. Resettlement entitlements are limited to Effect on dwellings will be eliminated through design. If certain categories of PAPs. dwellings are affected, will be handled individually for each case in accordance with this RPF and WB OP 4.12. Physical Displacement Each nuclear family within affected dwellings is entitled to a resettlement BOTAŞ has established a RAP Fund to compensate physical All PAPs losing homes are entitled to home; this provisioning exceeds and economic displacement of all PAPs including informal resettlement international standards. users who are not entitled to resettlement in Turkish legislation. Article 12 of Resettlement Law states that the families who do not own any immovable All PAPs will be entitled to different types of compensation property, but who reside in the in accordance with this RAP and WB OP 4.12. expropriation area at least for three years 35 Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs before the beginning of the calendar year, in which the resettlement planning studies were commenced, will be resettled to the locations/places indicated by the Ministry (MoEU) according to the provisions of this Law, provided that they request. According to The Turkish Civil Law No. 4721, Article 713; "A person who holds an immovable property that is not registered in the title deed and who has possession of the immovable property for two decades without any trial and ownership as an owner may request that the right of ownership on the whole, one part or one part of the immovable property be registered in the title deed". In accordance with this provision, possession by usucaption is only for immovable property which is not registered in the title deed. No legal provisioning forces the project proponents to prepare social impact Resettlement Policy Framework has been prepared by assessment and/or resettlement action plan BOTAŞ since the specific locations of Project components Resettlement plans should be developed in under Turkish Law. are not known at the time of project appraisal. cases where displacement is unavoidable. Resettlement Law 5543 provides Resettlement Action Plan(s) will be prepared in accordance resettlement options to displaced PAPs by with WB policies once the specific locations are asking their preferences for urban versus determined. rural resettlement. Cash compensation will be provided at unit price which Homes and residential land will be Lost homes are not compensated by use of covers all transaction costs as defined by WB OP 4.12 plus compensated by use of replacement value. replacement value. the cost of any registration and the transfer taxes. Amortization is not allowed. Depreciation of the asset will not be taken into account. 36 Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs Rural, urban and residential land is Homes are compensated by use of their In brief, the compensation for lands and structures will be compensated by use of market prices. cost of construction with high quality at replacement cost as defined in the OP 4.12. material in the market. Amortization is taken into account. Residential land is compensated by its market prices, by using net capitalization method. Economic displacement is implicit in the Expropriation Law that allows compensation for lost assets based on discounted net The loss of assets or access to assets that income. International requirements will be applied through results in loss of income or other means of Valuation of agricultural land, trees, Resettlement Action Plan(s) and where necessary via a livelihood should be restored. vineyards etc. is based on net income Livelihood Restoration Plan. capitalization method and will consider additional factors that may have an impact on the immovable asset. Entitlements for economically displaced PAPs are identified as transitional livelihood support, crop payment Economic Displacement Economically displaced (loss of income as a for orphan lands, cash compensation for loss of structures, No legal provisioning is made in the Turkish water wells, and livestock pens, transportation costs, title result of land acquisition) PAPs and/or legislation except for those that opt for deed costs and payments regarding the loss of common communities should be compensated and State-Assisted Resettlement. lands such as grazing lands. offered other assistance where required. Those entitlements will be paid from RAP Fund since there is no legal provisioning made in Turkish legislation. Only the legal owners can receive monetary All PAPs will be entitled to compensation. Project related losses of the affected compensation (via the expropriation of people should be compensated in full and Owners as well as users will be compensated for assets lands). in cash prior to the actual acquisition of and standing crops. immovable assets. Users rights on public and private property are recognized due to recent changes in the Compensation measures that exceed provisions of All transaction costs should be paid. national law will be covered by BOTAŞ through RAP Fund. Turkish Law. 37 Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs Not only title deed holders, but also Traditional rights are recognized (with the customary owners, tenants, public land exception of forest lands that do not users and squatters are entitled to recognize user rights). compensation. No legal provisioning is made in the Turkish Compensation payments regarding the economic International policies require compensation legislation. livelihood losses arising from not being able to use Common Property for livelihood losses of individuals and common lands for grazing purposes will be elaborated in a Resources communities that result from acquisition of The pasture and meadow losses of the LRP and provided by RAP Fund. pasturelands. families or the associated income losses of villages cannot be compensated. BOTAŞ will retain an independent, recognized expert/consultant to verify its monitoring efforts shortly after the completion of the RAP. Procedures to monitor and evaluate the Monitoring and Evaluation implementation of a Resettlement Action No legal provisioning is made. BOTAŞ will also internally monitor its RAP implementation Plan will be established. process regularly. A final RAP completion audit will be conducted by the independent expert/consultant. A grievance mechanism will be established to receive and facilitate resolution of concerns and grievances of affected people and communities about the Project. In order to resolve concerns promptly, an understandable and transparent BOTAŞ has established a Grievance Mechanism to receive The use of a grievance mechanism is not Grievance Resolution consultative process that is culturally and facilitate resolution of concerns in accordance with provisioned. appropriate and readily accessible should WB policies. be used. Affected Communities and people will be informed about the grievance mechanism in the course of the stakeholder engagement process. 38 Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs Current international standards of Stakeholder All people affected by land acquisition There is no provision regarding to public Engagement will be met by BOTAŞ. activities and other key stakeholders should participation in Turkish Laws. There is no BOTAŞ has prepared a Stakeholder Engagement Plan for be consulted and involved in resettlement requirement for Stakeholder Engagement the implementation of all consultations throughout planning. Plan. Project. BOTAŞ will conduct physical consultation meetings Consultation / Participation with all people affected by land acquisition activities. The Resettlement Law allows consultation Resettlement will be avoided as much as possible. The resettlement site must be chosen in the process of selecting the resettlement Consultations with PAPs, who will be physically impacted through consultation with all displaced sites to those who opt for State-Assisted by the Project, will be carried out according to people and host communities. Resettlement. internationally accepted principles. Vulnerable groups in the Project-affected area are identified in Chapter 7.4. Vulnerable people will be precisely found out to evaluate their losses in terms of livelihood restoration during the Particular attention is to be paid to the negotiation and land acquisition process. needs of vulnerable groups, especially Living standards are not specifically Vulnerable Groups Livelihood impacts on these vulnerable groups will be those below the poverty line, the landless, considered. the elderly woman and children. assessed and compensation will be provided by RAP Fund where necessary. Special effort will be made to encourage female owners and users to attend to negotiations and to register their entitlements. Customary law in the Project areas may International policies address gender- deny women the right to ownership and BOTAŞ will ensure that compensation arrangements differentiated aspects of impacts and management of cultivated lands. should be issued in the names of both spouses or heads of opportunities, as well as gender-responsive households. Gender consultation processes. These customs are not recognized by the Civil Law, which states that all siblings and Project’s consultation process will capture both men’s and The use of land and natural resources extended family members, regardless of women’s views, if necessary through separate forums or affected by the Project should be assessed gender and age, have similar inheritance engagements. in gender inclusive manner and specifically rights. 39 Gap Subject World Bank Group Policies Turkish Legislation Measures to bridge the GAPs consider women’s role in the management and use of these resources. Human rights issues are embedded in resettlement planning. The sponsor should ensure that the Human Rights safeguarding of personnel and property is There are no provisions in the Turkish laws. BOTAŞ will recognize Human Rights principles. carried out in accordance with relevant human rights principles and in a manner that avoids or minimizes risks to the Affected Communities. 40 4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC BASELINE The aim of this chapter is to demonstrate the socio-economic baseline status of the PAPs which are based on field studies performed within RAP preparation. 4.1. Methodology The field study was carried out between March 2-10, 2019 March to consult with PAP’s in Ankara, Aksaray and Konya provinces. This study, which aims to identify the potential social impacts that may be caused by land acquisition requirements of the Project and thus gather the necessary data for the planning and development of alternative policies, was carried out by taking the opinions and evaluations of the PAPs and other related stakeholders. Field study includes;  The quantitative socio-economic household survey with owners and users of immovable properties;  The surveys consisting of both quantitative and qualitative methods applied to the Mukhtars of the settlements directly affected by the Project;  Qualitative focus group discussions with vulnerable groups in the settlements affected by the project's land acquisition;  Qualitative in-depth interviews and comprehensive discussion meetings with other stakeholders.  Interviews with Project workers The aim of the field studies outlined in these categories was,  To identify the PAPs (including vulnerable groups) and to determine their socio-economic profiles;  To understand the ownership status of land and other assets and to evaluate the land use models and income generation from the lands affected by the Project;  To evaluate the demographic profiles of households and to bring about their income and expenditures. In addition, it is aimed to collect data on the impacts on the livelihoods of PAPs due to land loss caused by the Project. The study also identified vulnerable groups; stakeholder participation level to the Project; perceptions of PAPs on the Project; the concerns of PAPs regarding the social development and the restoration of livelihoods. Investigation of PAPs within the framework of the variables described above is important in terms of understanding the results of the Project on PAPs, especially in terms of land acquisition and other impacts.The study not only aims to focus on private lands and legal owners / users, but also on public land and their use, as well as on informal land users and vulnerable groups. Thus, it has been ensured that site-specific data are obtained in order to develop particularly effective mitigation measures. The study method is mainly composed of four stages: “desktop studies”, “developing field survey programme and data tools”, “field work / data collection phase”, “assessment/reporting phase”. These steps are briefly explained below: 41 i. Desktop studies: During this stage, the secondary data related to the Project were reviewed, written documents were compiled and data on land acquisition were evaluated in order to be able to plan and conduct the field research in a proper way. ii. Developing field survey program and data tools: Potential stakeholders were identified at this stage and survey tools (household and Mukhtar questionnaire forms, focus group discussion and other interview forms) were prepared. Prior to the field survey, first contacts were made with local public authorities, Mukhtars, the owners/users of the immovable properties and the planned field survey was explained. Surveyors were subjected to a one-day training during this phase. iii. Field Survey and Data Collection: The field survey team consisted of 11 people: a field coordinator, 2 expert researchers and 5 surveyors and 3 support personnel. During the field studies conducted between 2nd-10th of March 2019 in Ankara, Aksaray and Konya provinces, surveys were carried out with Project-affected settlement heads and PAPs. Focus group discussions were carried out with vulnerable groups. Face to face in-depth interviews were conducted with stakeholders defined in the field program. iv. Data Analysis, Assessment and Reporting: Following this field study, data entry of surveys, which are applied to households with loss of land and other immovable and settlements heads, was performed by a Specialist using software for statistical analysis. Similarly, focus group and face-to-face interview data were prepared and analyzed. Finally, considering all desktop reviews and field survey data, potential impacts were assessed and reported together with mitigation and compensation strategies. Census and Sampling Method for Socio-Economic Household Survey Representative socio-economic household survey has been conducted for the lands affected by the lines (fresh water, brine water and gas) and a full census has been conducted for the lands affected by well areas and surface facilities. Full census is aimed at all parcels to be acquired as permanent and all land-owner users, formal and informal land users were reached during the census. Sampling method used for the socio-economic household survey is explained in following paragraph. Project-affected lands are mostly jointly-owned with high numbers of owners in a single parcel; however, most of the landowners are not active farmers/landusers because they are living outside the project affected area. There are total of 2,267 landowners of 882 affected parcels. Out of total 2,267 affected land owners the sample size was calculated (by a Statistician Expert) as 150 with a 90% reliability rate and ±0.065 error margin. This sample size for the socio-economic survey was distributed by calculating the percentage distribution of the total number of affected / identified users in the settlements. The actual sample distribution was weighted in proportion to the number of users to avoid any deviation that may be caused by weighting the sample size to the number of land owners. Distribution of sample size according the settlements is given in the table below. Tablo 4-1 Distribution of Sample Size for Socio-Economic Household Survey Number of Province / Percentage distribution Distribution of Number of Village / Quarter Affected / District within the total sample size conducted surveys Identified Users Ankara / Merkez 2 0,39 0,6 1 Evren Aksaray / Merkez 46 8,97 13,5 6 Sarıyahşi Aksaray / Boğazköy 41 7,99 12,0 16 Sarıyahşi Kütüklü 13 2,53 3,8 8 Merkez 15 2,92 4,4 6 Aksaray / Camili 18 3,51 5,3 7 Ağaçören Kederli 23 4,48 6,7 9 Abdiuşağı 12 2,34 3,5 4 42 Çatalçeşme 17 3,31 5,0 4 Hacımahmutuşağı 21 4,09 6,1 6 Hacıibrahimuşağı 6 1,17 1,8 2 Pınarbaşı 17 3,31 5,0 2 Aksaray / Fakıcık 14 2,73 4,1 4 Ortaköy İshaklıkarapınar 23 4,48 6,7 6 Camuzluk 6 1,17 1,8 3 Bostanlık 21 4,09 6,1 6 Cerit 19 3,70 5,6 10 Altınkaya (Yeni 12 2,34 3,5 7 Köyü) Hanobası 8 1,56 2,3 2 Aksaray / Sapmaz 58 11,31 17,0 10 Merkez Baymış 18 3,51 5,3 6 Yeşiltepe 60 11,70 17,5 18 Yeşilova 2 0,39 0,6 1 Yenikent 2 0,39 0,6 1 Aksaray / Merkez 39 7,60 11,4 14 Sultanhanı Aksaray / Merkez - - - - Eskil TOTAL 513 %100 150 159 4.1.1. Socio-Economic Household Surveys The quantitative socio-economic household survey applied to the PAPs, who are owners/users of immovable assets or lands affected by the Project, is prepared on the basis of land acquisition data shared by BOTAŞ and focused on the socio-economic current status of PAPs. This survey was applied to all informal and formal land user in settlements where permanent land acquisition results in loss of land and / or immovable property, while it was applied to a sample in the settlements where temporary land acquisition is in question. The survey aimed to identify the demographic structures of the household, socio-economic indicators, the impact of the Project on the immovables and participation level of stakeholders. The survey included close ended questions as well as open ended questions to better understand the livelihoods, socio-economic status of PAPs and their concerns, perceptions and expectations from the Project. Open ended questions in the survey were analyzed under frequency based main headings and recoded in SPSS. Socio-economic household survey collected data on the following subjects: i. Demographic profile of the settlement and household demographic profile (residence status, household size, gender, age, marital status, education information, number of employees and their occupations, social security status, disability status, etc.). ii. Information about the dwellings, iii. Information about the infrastructure of settlement iv. Commercial activities in the region and affected settlements. v. Used energy sources, energy costs. vi. Main livelihood activities of PAPs vii. Average incomes and expenses, their perceptions on livelihoods viii. The most important problems/deficiencies of settlements and PAPs’ expectations ix. Information on improving the livelihood activities x. Information on Project-affected lands and other immovable of owners/users xi. Information on land structure and land use profile of the settlement. xii. Identification of vulnerable groups xiii. The level of Project’ impact on household xiv. Knowledge level of PAPs on the Project xv. PAPs attitudes, negative/positive perceptions to the Project 43 xvi. Employment opportunities in the Project xvii. PAPs’ recommendations and expectations from the Project 4.1.2. Settlement Surveys Along with the socio-economic household surveys, as mentioned above, surveys were conducted with the heads (Mukhtars) of settlements affected by the land acquisition of the Project. In these surveys, it was aimed to gather information about the community in the settlements. This study, using a combination of qualitative and quantitative techniques, has gathered information on the following subjects: i. Demographic profile of the settlement ii. Administrative management iii. Local economy and livelihoods iv. Access to and use of natural sources v. Infrastructure facilities of the settlement vi. Community perceptions to the Project vii. Evaluations about vulnerable groups likely to be exposed migration and danger viii. Information about owners and users of lands affected by the Project In depth interviews with village headmen were held in 27 villages. The interviews were deciphered and then coded into SPSS in order to summarize the main findings. The results of the village headmen qualitative interviews are used in this chapter to complement the results of the socio-economic surveys. 4.1.3. Focus Group Discussions Focus groups discussions (FGDs) were conducted with vulnerable groups in order to reveal their collective attitudes, values and perspectives. These groups included women and elderly people because in rural communities, the most crowded and accessible population is women or elderly. Considering the Project-induced factor (being also affected by land acquisition in addition to their existing vulnerabilities), it is only possible to find these vulnerable groups easily and get them together for FGD. Furthermore, people with disabilities living in one settlement are very few so it is better to engage them via interviews Introduction questions and motif arguments were prepared to motivate the discussion. Thus, it is aimed to reach the information that cannot be reached by surveys. Information was collected through focus group discussions and semi-structured interviews on: i. Demographic profile ii. The level of Project’ impact on PAPs iii. Employment, livelihoods and usage of natural resources iv. Public services and infrastructure facilities v. Health and education facilities vi. Development problems of the community vii. Perceptions to the Project Focus group meetings with women were conducted in 20 settlements while the focus group discussions with elderly people were conducted in 21 settlements to depict their perception of economic displacement and their concerns regarding the GSEP Project. The focus group discussion results are discussed under this chapter. 44 4.1.4. In-depth Interviews Semi-structured interviews were conducted with Mayors, District Governors, education, health and agriculture officials, private sector, contract farmers, media and NGO representatives of the districts affected by the Project. Semi-structured interviews were designed to provide specific information on each institution's own expertise and responsibility area and to understand the suggestions, expectations and concerns of these local institutions within the framework of the problem-centered interview technique. 4.2. Overview of the Project-Affected Population The data obtained from both field study and the literature review is given below. While the province and district level data is analyzed by desktop studies, the demographic and socio-economic characteristics of the PAPs are explained based on findings from the census and socio-economic survey. The overall aim of this chapter is to demonstrate the socio-economic baseline status of the PAPs. The data presented in this chapter is the summarized version while the detailed baseline data is given in Appendix-7. 4.2.1. Province-District Level Overview of Project-Affected Population Looking at the settlements affected by the land acquisition of the Project at the district level, land acquisition is planned in a total of 8 districts including Evren district in Ankara province; Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Merkez, Sultanhanı and Eskil districts in Aksaray province, and Emirgazi districts in Konya province. Land acquisition is planned for 14 parcels in Evren district (Pump stations and pipelines) and 13 parcels in Emirgazi district (well areas and surface facilities). Therefore, land acquisition impacts of the Project are very limited in these two districts. Evren district is located in the first region which also includes Ankara, Bala, Evren, Haymana and Şereflikoçhisar districts. This region, where population density is low and agriculture constitutes the basis of economic activities, covers the south and southeast parts of Ankara. Evren is the city with the lowest population in Ankara and its population is declining by years. While the population has been decreasing from 2014 to 2018, there has been an increase in 2018. The most important vulnerability related to migration in the districts around Ankara is the loss of population in rural areas. In the period of 2007-2012, the population of Çamlıdere, Bala, Evren, Haymana, Kalecik and Güdül districts decreased by 18% to 30%. In the province of Aksaray, which has a young population, mostly small districts, especially Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören districts are migrating. Movements outside the province are mostly targeted to large and close provinces such as Konya and Ankara. As identified in the field study, the districts with the highest population movements inside the province and towards the other provinces are Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Güzelyurt and Ortaköy in Aksaray. Considering the direction of population movements among the districts, it is observed that the settlements located on the mountainous terrain, which presents geographically challenging production conditions, and which are problematic in terms of transportation to the center, are migrating to the provinces and metropolitan cities rather than from the center of the province. The socio-economic structure of Aksaray is based on agriculture and animal husbandry. 70% of the active population is actively engaged in agriculture and livestock. 7% of the economically active population of Aksaray, which is estimated to be approximately 150.000 people between the ages of 15-64, is employed in the industrial sector. 45 Emirgazi district, with 88.326,61 hectares, covers 2,16% of Konya and 0.11% of Turkey. 85.10% of the total area of the district is agricultural lands; this ratio is above the average of Turkey and Konya average. 8.78% of the total area is reserved for meadow and pasture areas. The forest area constitutes 1.63% of the total area. The population of the Besci settlement in Emirgazi district affected by the land acquisition of the Project is 422 people according to TUIK 2018 data. The economy of Emirgazi district is entirely based on agriculture. Although it has very large agricultural areas, it is one of the districts which have the most adverse conditions as underground and surface water level. The region is also is the least rainfall areas of Turkey. 4.2.2. Household Socio-Economic Profile The demographic data gathered from household socio-economic survey applied to the land owners are summarized in this chapter. According to the results of the field study, the average household size is 4.30. The households in the sample mostly reside in the settlement throughout the year. Especially during the interviews conducted with settlement heads, it was stated that the settlements had a huge emigration in the past but recently it slowed down and became stagnant. The fact that the households in the settlements reside in the same place throughout the year also points to this situation. The average age value of the interviewed households is 36.61 while the level of education is very low. The low ratio of high school or higher education graduates indicates this situation while most PAPs in the interviewed households are primary school graduates. The results of the field study indicate that the number of illiterate people in the population above the age of 65 is quite high. In terms of employment opportunities of the Project, low education level of Project-affected populations causes a disadvantage. Students in PAHs mostly benefit from education with transportation support provided by the Ministry of Education because there are no educational institutions at village level settlements. Children in all households, except those living in the districts and towns, go to school with transport support. Interviewed households consist mainly of housewives, farmers, students and retirees. Thus, retirement salary is an important input for PAHs. On the other hand, farming is the main livelihood source in the project area. Labor and civil servants are much less common as income generating employment. As indicated in other consultations conducted in the field survey, housewives are also highly engaged in husbandry and agriculture activities, but they have not identified themselves from this aspect in the surveys. Women's participation in the labor force is an important issue because their contribution to the economy is not visible. In terms of health facilities, there are generally family health centers in the affected settlements and doctors, nurses and midwives are employed in these facilities. Settlements without health facilities apply to hospitals and health centers in district centers. The majority of the households surveyed are the owners of the houses that they live in. The average size of the houses is 155 m2. It is important to note that there is no central sewerage system in the plateaus of Sultanhanı Centre. The drinking water sources of the households are mainly provided from the main water lines. During the interviews, settlement heads stated that the infrastructure facilities of the settlements are not located within the boundaries of project construction area. It is observed that the participants gave more than one answer as heating sources. Households are mainly heated with wood and coal, and animal fuels are also used in rural settlements. Natural gas is used in the district centers. There are only 4 households heated by electricity and solar energy. 46 As stated by stakeholders in the consultations, the main livelihoods in the region are agriculture and animal husbandry activities. In addition to the market-oriented production of products such as beet, chickpea and sunflower as agricultural activities, fodder crops also cultivated to support households' husbandry activities. About half of the land that PAHs’ own is irrigated while the other half is dry. Some households also cultivate the treasury lands around their lands for agricultural purposes. This type of treasury lands that are cultivated around the fields have no legal status. Besides, the lands of the households who have migrated from the settlements and who have left agricultural activities are cultivated with rental agreements. The interviewed households in the settlements mostly plant their lands themselves. Only 7 households had rented their land to someone else. 2 households stated that they are paying to daily workers to plant their lands. Detailed information about the formal and informal users in the project- area is given in Section 5.4.2. Pasture lands in Turkey, cannot be used for agricultural purposes other than grazing. However, it has been determined that mostly forage crops such as alfalfa are planted by the users especially in the pasture lands located in the Sultanhanı region and around the well areas. Therefore, there are two types of impacts regarding the use of common property lands in the Project area; loss of common grazing lands and loss of pasture lands used for agricultural purposes by informal users. Loss of common grazing lands will be compensated and the compensation will aim at supporting or improving livestock activities in accordance with the joint decision of the settlement (eg, fodder provision, animal shading and watering trough support). Users who cultivate the pasture lands for agricultural purposes will be evaluated as informal users and will be compensated through the RAP Fund. The irrigation sources of the households mainly consist of wells. 71 of the households responding to this question stated that they were irrigating their lands with well water. The number of households using ponds or streams as irrigation sources is 33. 85 of the respondents find the water resource insufficient while 87 of them stated that water resource is sufficient. Barley, wheat, clover, chickpea, sugar beet, sunflower, corn, common vetch, tomatoes, beans are respectively most cultivated products by PAPs. These products are planted once in a year and crop substitution is carried out in the region. 118 of the respondents who answered the question stated that they left their land lie fallow while 81 of them did not. 45% of the respondents stated that they were members of an agricultural cooperative, and 55% stated that they were not members of any cooperative. Apart from individual private lands and planted crops, usage purposes of common lands such as pasture, treasury and forest land is also a significant area of concern. The most common type of land use of common lands is grazing activities which are followed by self-agricultural purposes. Other usage purposes are very less common but “not-used” answer has the highest rate among all answers. 58% of the households interviewed stated that they are engaged in animal husbandry while 42% do not carry out husbandry activities. 119 out of total 205 households surveyed have ownership of animals. All of these animal owners have a barn/stable. Sheep/goat breeding is more common among households engaged in animal husbandry activities. As a general pattern, households use the barn/stable next to their homes to feed their animals in winter season. With the arrival of spring, animals are taken to meadows and pastures. The common pastures of the settlements, treasury lands and private farmlands after the harvest are also used for animal grazing. The Project will ensure the sustainability of animal husbandry activities by organizing meetings with settlement heads and animal owners so that livestock activities and grazing routes are not affected by construction activities. Most households have poultry to meet their own needs, but these products are not offered to the market. 47 One of the most important results obtained in field studies is that PAHs have income diversity. Regular retirement salary or paid workers' salaries generally supply the income from agriculture and animal husbandry and make household income more stable. Animal husbandry activities bring more income than crop production. When the household income structure is assessed, it is understood that agricultural income (plant production + husbandry) constitutes about half of the income of the households engaged in agriculture. When livelihoods are distributed among households, it is seen that there is a highly balanced distribution between paid labor income, retirement salary and agricultural-husbandry income. Half of the households interviewed stated that they sold animals in the last year. It is seen that the highest expenses of households are related with livestock expenses which is also highest income generating activity. Agricultural expenses are much lower than both livestock expenses and heating expenses of households. According to the results of the field study, more than half of the surveyed households have an on-going loan. The types of these loans are consumer, mortgage, agriculture, livestock and trade loans. 26 households received consumer loans, while 6 households used mortgage loans, 66 households’ agricultural loans and 3 households used trade loans. The interviewees stated that the most effective investment to increase the income they derive from agriculture and animal husbandry is to develop irrigation resources. The second choice was to reduce input costs for husbandry and agriculture. 40% of the households participating in the field study stated that they could hardly or very hardly meet the needs of the household. On the other hand, 53% stated that they could meet their needs. Compared to the previous year, total of 114 households stated that their economic situation got worse, while 77 stated that their economic situation remained the same or is better. 56 of the households surveyed said that there was no change compared to the previous year. Households were asked what issues they had prioritized in improving livelihoods. Looking at the results, it is observed that households mostly prefer the supports for agricultural inputs and irrigation activities, followed by livestock inputs. It is known that agricultural activities have been abandoned by many people due to the recent increase in agricultural costs and the results appear to confirm this situation. 173 of the surveyed households stated that they had information about the project while 32 of them had no knowledge. PAPs were also asked how they were informed about the Project. The basic information sources of the PAPs were the visits of Project personnel, television broadcasts and settlement heads. Other sources of information are indicated as family members, Municipality, District Governorates and social media. Almost all settlement heads attended the informative meeting held by the Project personnel while 53 of the surveyed households participate in these meetings. PAPs were also asked about which information they want to get about the Project. PAPs were generally interested in; expropriation process, employment opportunities, environmental impacts, whether the fresh water pipeline can be used for agricultural irrigation after the completion of the Project life etc. Public information meetings held regularly by the Project will continue in a participatory manner allowing for PAPs to raise their concerns and get answers to their questions. The question “Have your lands been taken or expropriated for any other projects before?” was answered as No by 121 PAPs and as Yes by 69 PAPs, respectively. Therefore, a multiple project effect can be considered for these settlements. 48 Questions related to the grievance mechanism of the Project were also included in the survey. The answers of PAPs to the question of who will be contacted to get information about the Project or to forward a complaint are listed in the table below. 25% of participants stated that they would contact company personnel for such cases while 19% answered as “Mukhtar” to the question. Those who have no idea about contact channels consist 9% of the sample. 19% of the interviewed households are aware of the communication channels such as phone line and the contact person that the Project is applying for Grievance Mechanism while 66% of participants are not aware of these contact channels. A Grievance Mechanism has been established for the GSEP Project. Face to face interviews and consultations have been going on since the beginning of Project. With the commencement of the Project activities on site, Public Relations Units of both BOTAŞ and Construction Contractor(s) will carry out its activities within the framework of the Grievance Management Mechanism and the Stakeholder Engagement Plan. The most important positive impact of the Project was to support local employment according to PAPs. This was followed by the contribution to the local development.28% of the respondents stated that the project will contribute to the national economy. This response was followed by those who stated that the Project would not have any positive contribution to the region (27%). Regarding the negative impacts of the Project, the outstanding response is that the affected-lands and neighbor lands will be damaged during the construction phase. This response is followed by damage to crops especially in neighbor lands. Thus, it can be seen that the PAPs expect a decrease in their income sources. They also believe that livestock activities will be adversely affected by the Project activities. Damage to agricultural products and livestock activities due to construction activities will be avoided. However, in cases of damages to any property, the loss will be compensated by the CC. The PAPs were also asked what could be done to reduce these adverse effects. Supporting agricultural activities and livestock activities has been the primary response. This was followed by answers such as improvement of roads, prioritization of local employment in the Project. Most of the muhtars (14 out of 27) stated that they would like to benefit from natural gas to be connected to their settlements. In the questions designed for measuring the employment expectation in the Project, 29% of participants stated that there are job seekers in their households who could work in the Project. On the other hand, 62% of the respondents said that they would not prefer to work in the Project or that there is no job seeker in their household to work in the Project. 2 interviewees have declared that there are already people in their households employed by the Project. Public Relations Units of BOTAŞ and Contractor(s) will visit the settlements and inform them about employment opportunities and application processes in the pre-construction phase. 4.1.5. Vulnerable Groups The main objective of the RAP is to ensure that living standarts of those who have encountered land acquisition-induced displacement are restored and improved to pre-Project conditions where possible. However, some may be more adversely affected by displacement than others because they may have limited capacity to cope with resettlement-related issues due to their existing vulnerabilities (gender, age, disabilities etc.). In addition to their non-project related existing vulnerabilities, there might be some vulnerabilities specific to the Project that would lead to their livelihoods being worse off after land acquisition takes place. Therefore, all vulnerabilities need to be considered for the preparation of any assistance that will be provided through the RAP Fund for livelihood restoration. 49 During the field survey, in-depth interviews were conducted with focus group discussions in order to understand the perceptions and expectations of women, the elderly and other vulnerable groups on the Project and to assess potential impacts of the Project on their living conditions. Some vulnerable groups7 have been identified during the social baseline studies of ESIA: i. Women, in particular female-headed households ii. Elderly iii. People with disabilities iv. Seasonal workers v. Groups subject to Cumulative Impacts a. PAPs whose land will be expropriated for the second time b. PAPs whose land will be affected by multiple project components vi. Contract farming8 4.1.5.1. Women In the field study, 2 land user women were identified to be impacted by permanent land take whereas 17 land user women were identified for temporary land acquisition. Focus group discussions were conducted with women during the field survey. The main issues raised by the Project in the discussions with women are: i. Potential damages on land and crops due to Project activities, ii. Compensation of those damages, iii. Land acquisition process, iv. Problems related to Project’ traffic v. Lack of information about the Project The potential negative impact on agricultural lands and pastures due to Project activities has been highlighted by women during discussions. They emphasized that the construction site (expropriated area) should not be exceeded and any damage to the crops on neighbor lands should be prevented. Many women said that it is crucial to reinstate the lands properly to its former conditions after construction because some of them expressed their unsatisfaction about the condition of lands after reinstatement of the existing Project. It is understood that some PAPs had problems on their lands after reistatement process of UGS Project and it leads concerns and worries on the GSEP too. In particular, older women stated that young people could compensate for possible losses in agricultural lands and pastures by working in other alternative jobs, but that they would not be able to do anything other than agriculture and animal husbandry, they would be affected much more than younger women. Women were asked about their previous experiences on the presence of workers in the close region during the UGS Project and whether they have concerns on the same issue which might occur in the GSEP. The general opinion was that there would be no problem because they did not experience any problems during the UGS Project. Even some women mentioned that they had good relationships with workers coming to the region especially for shopping such as buying local products such as chicken, 7 During the field survey no PAPs were identified to be left landless after land acquasition. 8 Contract farming involves agricultural production being carried out on the basis of an agreement between the buyer and farm producers. Sometimes it involves the buyer specifying the quality required and the price, with the farmer agreeing to deliver at a future date. More commonly, however, contracts outline conditions for the production of farm products and for their delivery to the buyer’s premises. The farmer undertakes to supply agreed quantities of a crop or livestock product, based on the quality standards and delivery requirements of the purchaser. In return, the buyer, usually a company, agrees to buy the product, often at a price that is established in advance. The company often also agrees to support the farmer through, e.g., supplying inputs, assisting with land preparation, providing production advice and transporting produce to its premises. 50 eggs, cheese etc. Many women mentioned that the workers have been always respectful and sensitive in their communications with local people. During the field study, it was observed that women in project-affected settlements have lower level of knowledge about the Project rather than men. During discussions with women, the idea that future informative meetings to be held mainly for women should be done by a female expert. Many women stated that they could not attend a meeting where men would attend. In general, women mentioned that the Project activities will be in the distance from the settlement and that they would not encounter any special problems due to construction activities. Traffic-related impacts were raised in several settlements where the construction activities of the previous Project were quite close to settlement area. Potential increase in the traffic due to Project vehicles and security risks for their children were mentioned, and measures were requested to be taken in this regard. This concern will be handled in according to primarly Traffic Management Plan prepared within the scope of ESMS and the same plan to be prepared by the construction contractor. Women approached the employment opportunities to be provided by the Project with a general hesitation. However, in some settlements, women stated that they could work in the Project if appropriate work, service and regular working hours were provided. Women generally do not know about the expropriation process and the payments since they are mostly dependent on the men on those issues. Women have no information about where to apply in case they experience any problems due to Project activities, so they prefer to raise their problems to the settlement heads. 4.1.5.2. Elderly In the field study, 5 elderly (over 65 years old) land users were identified on lands to be permanently acquired and 29 elderly land users were determined on lands subject to temporary land acquisition. One of the most important vulnerable groups in the Project impact area is the elderly people. As discussed in the relevant chapters above, the Project site has a demographic structure with an over- age population. There are also households where only the elderly live. For this reason, single-headed households with an old head is another social fact multiplying the vulnerability. The minimum age defined for being an elder is accepted as the retirement age in Turkey, which is 65. Elderly people are considered as vulnerable since they are more likely to leave their land based livelihood if they are economically displaced. During the field survey, no such potential was identified; however, in the forthcoming days of RAP implementation some elderly landusers especially those who are affected by permanent land acquisition may prefer not to continue agricultural activities due to several reasons. This possibility should be considered throughout internal monitoring. In case of its occurrence, special assistance to these vulnerable people should be provided in a timely and appropriate manner. The Project Social Team of BOTAŞ will visit the households of the elderly and inform them about the Project, especially monitoring and evaluation procedures, and determine their needs. 4.1.5.3. People with disabilities In the field study (Household Survey Questionnaire and Mukhtar Surveys), 1 land user with disabilitiy was identified on parcels to be permanently acquired and 1 land user with disability was determined on parcels subject to temporary land acquisition. People with disabilities may be encountered in the Project impact area of and they may be more likely to have difficulties in access to information, raising their grievances or concerns, finding other jobs to sustain their livelihoods etc. The Project team will monitor these households closely during the monitoring process. In case of its occurrence, special assistance to these vulnerable people should be provided in a timely and appropriate manner. 51 4.1.5.4. Seasonal workers The settlements located in the study area receive seasonal workers predominantly from the southern side of Turkey or Syria for harvesting or other agricultural work. The majority of the seasonal workers come from Hatay, Kilis, Şanlıurfa provinces of Turkey or from Syria to work between April and September, and the majority of these workers are Syrian refugees. They are working in agriculture as uninsured and low-paid. The seasonal workers coming to the region usually stay in their own tents set up near the fountains or along the roads and do not pay for their accommodation. Seasonal workers on agricultural lands may be indirectly affected in terms of livelihood loss by the Project’s land acquisition and other construction activities. Consultations could not have been carried out with these households since they did not yet come to the region at the time of field survey. However, during the interviews with Mukhtars, the potential impacts on their tent settlements and livelihood conditions od seasonal workers have been specifically questioned. During the interviews, it was revealed that the areas where the tents were established had no connection with the expropriation areas where the construction activities of the Project will be carried out. In addition, Mukhtars indicated that the interruption of agricultural activities in the expropriation areas would not lead to a decrease in their livelihoods. As a reason, they stated that the expropriation areas would cover only a very small portion of the existing agricultural production areas and that agricultural activities would continue in the same way on remaining land. However, with the commencement of agricultural season and the arrival of seasonal workers in the region, informative consultations for seasonal workers will be provided by the Public Relations Unit of the Project. During these consultations, the Project teams will work to understand how seasonal workers will be affected from their own perspectives. For the time being, no adverse impacts are anticipated for this group and therefore, they are considered to be “potential” vulnerable groups. In any case, during RAP implementation, their conditions in relation to the Project impacts will be monitored to take mitigation measures in a timely manner. 4.1.5.5. Cumulative Impact Groups PAPs whose land will be expropriated for the second time Since the pipeline route of the GSEP is very close and parallel to the existing UGS Project route, a significant portion of the parcels affected by the current Project are also affected by GSEP and will be expropriated second time. PAPs whose land will be expropriated for the second time are considered as vulnerable since they may not have enough land left to continue agricultural activity or the residual lands may not be economically viable anymore. Out of total 961 parcels affected by the construction of pipelines, well areas and surface facilities, total of 560 parcels (58%) will be expropriated for the second time. Distribution of parcels by affected settlements is given in the table below (Tablo 4-2 Number of Pipeline Affected Parcels Expropriated for Second Time ). It can be seen that there are parcels expropriated for the second time in almost all settlements affected by the Project except Kütüklü. None of Project-affected parsels in Kütüklü village was expropriated before for the current Project. Tablo 4-2 Number of Pipeline Affected Parcels Expropriated for Second Time Affected Settlement Number of parcels Number of Parcels No expropriated for Acquired Province District Quarter/Village second time 1 Ankara Evren Merkez 14 3 2 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Merkez 51 6 3 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Boğazköy 73 61 52 4 Aksaray Ağaçören Kütüklü 25 - 5 Aksaray Ağaçören Merkez 52 43 6 Aksaray Ağaçören Camili 30 19 7 Aksaray Ağaçören Kederli 54 40 8 Aksaray Ağaçören Abdiuşağı 26 18 9 Aksaray Ağaçören Çatalçeşme 22 16 10 Aksaray Ortaköy Hacımahmutuşağı 29 26 11 Aksaray Ortaköy Hacıibrahimuşağı 7 4 12 Aksaray Ortaköy Hıdırlı-Fakıcık 26 20 13 Aksaray Ortaköy Pınarbaşı 20 18 14 Aksaray Ortaköy İshaklı Karapınar 23 21 15 Aksaray Ortaköy Camuzluk 6 6 16 Aksaray Merkez Bostanlık 24 22 17 Aksaray Merkez Cerit 37 19 18 Aksaray Merkez Altınkaya 22 15 19 Aksaray Merkez Hanobası 11 10 20 Aksaray Merkez Sapmaz 114 53 21 Aksaray Merkez Baymış 29 27 22 Aksaray Merkez Yeşiltepe Beldesi 75 58 23 Aksaray Merkez Yeşilova Beldesi 7 2 24 Aksaray Merkez Yenikent Beldesi 24 26 25 Aksaray Eskil Merkez 7 - 26 Aksaray Sultanhanı Merkez 106 20 TOTAL 914 553 The distribution of parcels to be expropriated for the second time among the parcels affected by well areas and surface facilities is given in the table below. Only 7 parcels are identified to be expropriated for the second time by the Project. The reason of low number of parcels compared to pipelines is that the locations of well areas and surface facilities are not likely to overlap with the current project expropriation area. Tablo 4-3 Number of Parcels Expropriated for Second Time Affected by Well Areas or Surface Facilities Affected Settlement Number of parcels Number of Parcels No expropriated for Acquired Province District Quarter/Village second time 1 Aksaray Sultanhanı Merkez 61 7 2 Aksaray Eskil Güneşli 5 - 3 Konya Emirgazi Besci 13 - TOTAL 79 7 53 PAPs whose lands will be affected by multiple Project components PAPs whose land will be affected by multiple Project components such as surface facilities, well areas and pipelines, more than one Project component, are also considered as vulnerable since they may not be able to use their lands due to loss of considerably high sizes of lands permanently and temporary usage limitations. These PAPs were also identified during the RAP preparation process and they will also be considered for additional compensation as defined in the Entitlement Matrix. Tablo 4-4 Number of Parcels Affected by Multiple Project Components Affected Settlement Number of Parcels Number of No Affected by Multiple Landusers Province District Quarter/Village Project Components 1 Aksaray Sultanhanı Esgimarul 5079 - 2 Aksaray Sultanhanı Esgimarul 5173 1 3 Aksaray Sultanhanı Esgimarul 8335 1 4.1.5.6. Contract farming During the field study, it was determined that some farmers made contract farming agreements with the private sector companies in the region. Farmers have undergone certain commitments with these contracts with the companies, but also have been the beneficiaries of certain quotas. In case of failure of the contracts or failure of the farmer to deliver the product in quantity and quality specified in the contract, a loss of rights in terms of quota ownership will be experienced by the farmers. In such cases, the companies may not sign a contract with the farmer the following year. The farmer may suffer from premium loss and may be fined for a few times the premium. In case of incomplete delivery, farmer may lose the quota defined in the agreement. This type of contract farming cases were identifed in the project area, especially in sugarbeet and sunflower production. During field visit 12 contract farmers were identified in the Project area. These examples are located in different areas of the Project including camp site, well areas and pipeline routes. In order to resolve this possible problem in compliance with WB OP 4.12, the approach should be primarily to avoid the occurance of the problem. To achieve this, re-scheduling the start date of construction on these lands might be an option. Considering the interviews during field survey, these farmers might be significantly affected in case construction activities start on their lands before mid- October 2019 (before harvesting). If it is not possible to postpone the construction start date on these lands, change in the locations of some project components like camp sites might be another option to miminize the impact on these farmers’ livelihood. On the other hand, in case that this potential impact is not avoidable, it should be mitigated through compensation measures against livelihood losses. It would be better to determine the appropriate compensation methods by BOTAS through mutual negotiation with the farmers. 54 5. LAND ACQUISITION PROCESS AND REQUIREMENTS The main objective of the RAP is to establish the resettlement and compensation principles, organizational arrangements and design criteria to be applied to meet the needs of the people who may be affected by the Project. It is inevitable that GSEP’s construction activities will lead to either land acquisition and/or denial of, restriction to or loss of access to economic assets and resources and therefore, ultimately to the land acquisition and compensation and, possibly, resettlement of people. Since the RPF has detailed section that includes land acquisition process and requirements, this Chapter has been formed to include summary information about the process and detailed information (valuation/calculations for compensation payments, temprorary easements, methods of valuing crops/trees etc.) has been given in Hata! Başvuru kaynağı bulunamadı. Resettlement program will be adhered to both the country’s laws for land acquisition and resettlement and WB OP 4.12. Where gaps exist between the country's laws and the WB OP 4.12, gap filling measures provided in this RAP will prevail. The following principles will govern land acquisition and easement to be conducted under the Project: i. BOTAŞ will aim to achieve negotiated agreements on land acquisition with all PAPs based on the principles set out in this RAP. BOTAŞ will negotiate fairly and openly with all PAPs to reach mutually acceptable agreements on compensation. Expropriation or easement imposition will only be undertaken as a last resort where negotiation fails. ii. All land acquisition and resettlement activities will be managed through RAPs, including when there is physical displacement9 which means relocation or loss of shelter or structure and/or when there is loss of economic displacement which means loss of income or livelihood. Implementation results will be documented, monitored and, after completion, evaluated. iii. Involuntary resettlement will be conceived as an opportunity for improving the livelihoods of the affected people and undertaken accordingly. iv. Engagement and compensation will be carried out with equal consideration of women and men. v. Particular attention will be paid to households headed by women and other vulnerable groups, and appropriate assistance will be provided to help them improve their status. vi. BOTAŞ will establish a grievance mechanism to receive and facilitate resolution of concerns regarding resettlement issues. This mechanism will allow women, disabled people, the elderly to reach BOTAŞ easily. vii. Land acquisition and RAP will be conceived and executed as a part of the Project, and the full costs of compensation will be included in Project costs and benefits. viii. Draft land acquisition and resettlement plans will be consulted with affected people and other stakeholders, and their inputs will be taken into account in finalizing them. ix. Compensation for lost assets will be at full replacement cost. x. Compensation and resettlement subsidies will be fully provided prior to clearance of right of way / ground levelling and demolition. xi. Upon completion of construction, land will be restored as best as possible to its original condition in the event of temporary disruption so as to enable landowners/users/lessees to resume their pre-project activities. 9 According to field studies, it is foreseen that the Project does not cause physical displacement. 55 xii. All PAPs, without regard to legal status of property, will receive support of various kinds, as per the principles set out in the Entitlement Matrix included in this RAP. Lack of legal title will not be a barrier to compensation and/or rehabilitation. xiii. BOTAŞ will provide and prepare the plans for grievance redress and monitoring in line with WB policies and guidelines. The main objective of the resettlement policy is to ensure that the people affected by land acquisition and resettlement under this project are able to improve or at least restore their incomes and standards of living after land acquisition/resettlement. In line with the process described in detail in the Appendix 10, land acquisition and resettlement process of BOTAŞ GSEP will also follow the same procedure in terms of national requirements and on top will comply with WB policies both in term of land acquisition and resettlement. Lands will be acquired and made available for the Project before the construction begins. No construction can take place unless the valuation is completed, certified attempts are made to negotiate the transfer of ownership rights, temporary and permanent easement rights from the private owners, and full payment is made to the accounts of owners. 5.1. Land Rights to be Established The project requires four different types of land rights to be established: Tablo 5-1 Types of Land Rights Project Component Land Right Provision Duration Responsibili ty Surface facilities, well Ownership Land acquisition is permanent and ownership Permanent areas, pole locations Rights right is registered in the name of BOTAŞ. As of energy permanent facility shall be constructed on the transmission lines referred land, it shall not possible for the former land owner to use the land. Natural gas pipeline, Temporary BOTAŞ will hold the right to use land during 2 years fresh water lines, Easement construction, while the ownership rights will brine water lines Rights remain with the landowner(s). Once construction is complete the land is handed back to landowner. When the construction is BOTAŞ completed, the land shall be reinstated and shall be returned to the land owner with limitations (see Section 8.3) Natural gas pipeline, Permanent The ownership rights remain registered in the Permanent fresh water lines, Easement name of landowner(s). The land owner brine water lines, Rights recovers its right to use the land, upon connection lines completion of the construction and between UGS sites, restoration of the land, with specific energy transmission limitations such as not to build structures, lines buildings or to plant trees. Temporary Facilities Contractual Subject land is rented for a certain duration During Contractor (Camp and Stock Rights through under mutually agreed terms and rates. Once Contract Areas) Rental the contract expires, land is handed back to Period Agreements owner after being reinstated to former conditions. 56 Ownership Rights (Permanent land acquisition): Ownership rights refer to permanent acquisition of land and are established by BOTAŞ on privately owned lands, where permanent Above Ground Facilities will be installed onto the land surface. This includes all Above Ground Facilities such as Surface facilities, well areas and pole locations of energy transmission lines as specified in the Project design. Temporary Easement Rights: The temporary easement right applies to natural gas pipeline, fresh water lines and brine water lines. Temporary easement rights are established by BOTAŞ for areas of the construction corridor and other workspaces and areas required for the performance of the construction works. Temporary easement rights can also be established by BOTAŞ for additional areas that are temporarily needed for the performance of the construction activities. Temporary easement rights will be obtained for a period of 2 years. Once the construction is over in the corridor, the construction area will be reinstated to its original condition and handed back to the initial owner(s) with limitations. Permanent Easement Rights: The permanent easement rights will apply to natural gas pipeline, fresh water lines, brine water lines, connection lines between UGS sites and energy transmission lines. After the completion of the construction activities (including the fullreinstatement of the land surface) the areas for which permanent easement rights have been established will be handed back to the initial owners. The re-use of the land will be permitted with limitations on agriculture practices (i.e. depth of ploughing), the planting of trees and shrubs, the building of houses and other structures, the performance of excavations, pile driving, the passage of heavy vehicles and others as specified by BOTAŞ. Contractual Rights through Rental Agreements: Rental agreements are concluded between the Contractors or sub-contractors and individual landowners for the temporary use of areas required for construction activities. Rental agreements may be concluded for any duration and are typically established for intermediate camp sites, storage areas, additional work spaces and others. After the termination of the rental agreements the land will be fully re-instated and handed back to the land owner(s). Rental agreements are subject to Project specific requirements with regard to the site selection, i.e. engineering and geo-hazard assessment, environmental assessment, as well as with regard to the implementation of rules, regulations and policies for land compensation and interaction with third parties and Project. 5.2. Eligibility Criteria for Defining Various Categories of PAPs The World Bank’s OP 4.12 suggests the following three criteria for eligibility; i. Those who have formal rights to land, ii. Those who do not have formal legal rights to land at the time the census begins but have a claim to such land or assets provided that such claims are recognized under the national law, iii. Those who have no claim to land they are occupying or using.10 Those covered under first and second category are entitled to be either compensated or resettled for their losses according to the national legislation and will be compensated as per this RAP and future RAPs. Those covered under third category do not have legal rights according to national legislation, but they will also be provided with livelihood supports as stated in the RAP to achieve the objectives set out in OP 4.12 through a RAP Fund established for this purpose. The RAP Fund will cover additional supports such as; transitional livelihood support, occupational educational support, crop payment for orphan lands, cash compensation for loss of structures, water wells, and livestock pens of informal 10 World Bank OP 4.12 - Involuntary Resettlement 57 users, transportation costs, title deed costs etc. All project affected persons, irrespective of their status or whether they have formal titles, legal rights or not, will be eligible for some kind of assistance, if they occupied the land before the entitlement cut-off date. 5.3. Cut-Off Date Practically, the cut-off date will be the date at which the census and asset inventory is completed because the cut-off date is critical to prevent unrightful claims and discourage encroachers. Since the Project consists of different components as anticipated and stated in the RPF, the cut off dates for the well locations and the pipelines were different. BOTAŞ ensured that the cut-off dates for different components were well communicated prior to the realization of assets inventory and census. BOTAŞ has declared the cut-off-date for settlements on the pipelines in late January and early February as February 15, 2019, but before the census. For the surface facilities and well areas, it was declared in late February as March 8, 2019. Eventhough there will be a length of time between these declared cut off dates and the commencement date of construction, compensation fees will be paid according to the current situation on the affected lands just before the construction activities. Any changes that may occur until the construction phase starts will be taken into consideration and expropriation payments including compensation of crops lost will be made according to the latest situation on the land. This is a positive approach in practice. Thus, people who settle in the project area after the designated cut-off date will be ineligible for any compensation or assistance. To ensure that all project affected persons (regardless of their legal status of ownership) are informed in a timely manner, BOTAŞ adopted an effective and proactive public consultation and engagement approach for the dissemination of information on the cut-off date. In each project-affected settlement, the cut-off-dates were announced via posters on the common places. On the other hand, information disclosure will not be limited with the announcement made before the census. Further stakeholder engagement activities to keep the project-affected persons informed on the project progress, land acquisition process including repeating the cut-off-dates for the relevant components of the Project will continue. The next step will be the dissemination of a brochure11 giving a detailed information on these issues with the social point of contacts throughout the project lifecycle. 5.4. Identification of Project Affected Persons 5.4.1. Land Owners People who have legal title to land and other assets (such as structures, trees, crops etc.) on subject land will be identified in the early stages of land acquisition process through official records obtained from the local and national Registry Offices. By law, all land owners are eligible for the compensation of their immovable assets. There is no provisioning for the compensation of livelihood losses for land owners in national law. Such losses will be covered through the RAP Fund. 5.4.2. Land Users (Formal and Informal) Land users can be categorized under two groups; formal and informal. Formal land users can exist both on private and public lands and will have a rental agreement with the owner of land (private entity or state) setting the duration and conditions to use the subject land. Such users have been identified both from land registry records (for public lands) and during the census and assets inventory surveys carried 11 Guide to Land Acquisition and Expropriation Payments. 58 out with land users. Number of identified formal and informal users on public and private lands is given in the table below. Such users are compensated for their assets on both public and private lands by law. There is no provisioning for the compensation of livelihood losses for formal users in national law. Such losses will be covered through the RAP Fund. Informal users however, do not hold a legal document (title deeds, contractual agreements) to the private or public land they use. Such PAPs were identified during the ESIA baseline studies. Depending on the type of public land they use (with the exception of pasture and forest lands), informal users are compensated for some of their assets by prevailing law. Informal users occupying pasture and forest land are not entitled to compensation and therefore are very likely to be affected adversely by the Project. Herders, who use pasture land in the project area, without formal rights, are also considered to be informal users. Such informal users will be identified during the census and assets inventory surveys as well as during the negotiation process carried out by BOTAŞ with land owners. During the consultations with landowners, the presence of formal or informal users, tenants, seasonal workers or any structure/shelter will also be questioned. There is no provisioning for the compensation of livelihood losses for informal users in national law. Such losses will be covered through the RAP Fund. Tablo 5-2 Number of formal Public Private and informal users in public Surface facilities Surface facilities Pipelines Pipelines and private lands and well areas and well areas (Sample) (Sample) (Full census) (Full census) Formal users - - 16 2 Informal users 7 5 25 6 5.4.3. Vulnerable Groups Some vulnerable groups have been identified during the social baseline studies of ESIA and the definition is informed by an understanding of the study area. However, during RAP preparation, additional categories of vulnerable people identified and added to the list provided below.The field work findings and detailed explanations about this subject are given in the related section (see Section4.1.5). i. Women, in particular female-headed households ii. Elderly iii. People with disabilities iv. Seasonal workers v. PAPs whose land will be expropriated for the second time vi. PAPs whose land will be affected by multiple project components vii. Contract farming 59 6. RESETTLEMENT RELATED POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE PROJECT Most of the land affected by the multiple components of the Project is owned by individuals and mostly used for agricultural production. The affected lands are registered as arable land, pasture land, vineyard, trashing field, road, marshy land, fountain, garden, cemetery, raw earth, drilling area, pole location, grass land, grove or willow grove in the Cadastral records. As indicated in the figure below, about 76% of the lands affected by the Project are arable lands, followed by pasture lands (14%) and vineyards (2%). Grain production is predominant in arable lands in the region. Wheat and barley are the mostly cultivated products in the region. Irrigated agriculture has been observed to increase along the pipeline route and within the license area; products such as corn, beet, and clover are produced commonly in the irrigated lands. There are titles of affected agricultural lands, but informal uses are especially common on the pasture or public lands within license area for the purposes of building residential area or livelihood stocks. PAPs were identified, who reside in rural settlements within the license area that do not have titles to land where they have residential houses. The following Project activities can potentially affect land ownership, land use and livelihoods in PACs; i. The pre-construction, construction, operation and post-operation of natural gas pipeline, energy transmission lines, fresh water lines, brine water lines ii. The pre-construction, construction, drilling and leaching, operation and post-operation of surface facilities and well areas These two types of facilities entail different modalities of land access and different types and durations of impacts as a result. Anticipated categories of impacts for each project component are detailed under the titles below. 6.1. Impacts of Natural Gas Pipeline, Energy Transmission Lines, Fresh Water Lines, Brine Water Lines Temporary and permanent easement rights will be established for these Project components in which BOTAŞ has a right to use land during construction while the ownership rights will remain registered in the name of landowner(s). Although the linear nature of these project components is expected to create minimal impacts (low to negligible and short term) on affected parcels, several impacts born from land acquisition requirements can be listed as follows: i. Temporary loss of land for agricultural cultivation: Landowners and users will not be able to temporarily use land along the pipeline routes during construction. But it is identified that there are very few settlements in the region (which are quite far from the construction area) where the fresh water, brine water and natural gas pipelines pass, and that these lines mostly pass through arid lands. Therefore, it is expected that the impacts of these project components will be lower than that of the well area. However, some agricultural lands which are far from settlements remain within the construction area of lines (brine water, freshwater, natural gas), thus creating a temporary impact during construction on the agricultural activities and land based income to the easement that will be established on land. ii. Loss of standing crops and trees due to construction activities: It is expected that crops and trees planted on land will be lost due to construction activities, but this impact will be low as BOTAS will aim to commence construction after harvest. In cases where construction is initiated before harvest, owners/users will be compensated based on the market value of the 60 crops and trees on long term easement acquired land after valuation by a specialized commission.12 iii. Damages to crops in plots neighboring the pipeline construction corridor due to, for example, spillover of soil or intrusion of equipment: During operations, and in addition to restrictions upon land discussed previously, the most likely potential impact would be damages to crops in the pipeline corridor or nearby resulting from maintenance activities or vehicular access. Damages to crops will be compensated based on the market value. iv. Temporary disruption to grazing activities and/or reduced access to agricultural land and pastures: Pasture areas above the lines may be temporarily unavailable due to construction work, or access to pasture areas may be restricted temporarily which can pose important impacts for livestock activities. Leaving the transition points at certain intervals during the construction will ensure that this impact on grazing activities is low. v. Permanent restrictions on land use under ETLs or above pipelines: Restrictions will be made for the protection of all lines. Property owners and users will continue to carry on their agricultural activities on the grounds, but will not be able to continue activities that will damage or threathen the pipeline. Some of these limitations are expected to be but will not be limited to; building of structures or outbuilding on the corridor, planting rooted trees, constructing irrigation and drainage channels on the corridor, drilling holes for any reason, making any changes to the surface profile, making changes that will affect the material of the soil surrounding the line, reducing land covering pipeline, including archaeological activities and pouring materials such as garbage, waste, sand and rubble on the corridor. In addition to impacts within the designated and compensated corridor, pipeline construction may cause disruption, severance and damage to neighboring, uncompensated pieces of land, in the following situations: i. Interruption of irrigation or drainage affecting crops in uncompensated plots ii. Severance of access to cultivated plots during construction, impeding farmers’ access to a plot and resulting in total or partial loss of crop iii. Loss of agricultural productivity of the land during the Project construction period and the reinstatement period can be both a primary and secondary impact (agricultural lands will be reinstated before handover to the landowner in accordance with the Reinstatement Plan (Appendix-7.9 of ESIA report) iv. Accidents to livestock as a result of Project activities resulting in livelihood loss 6.2. Impacts of Surface Facilities and Well Areas In the subject lands of well areas, ownership rights will be established for the 100x100 mt area around the well and permanent easement rights will be established for 50 mt along the connection lines between UGS sites. Ownership rights will be acquired for surface facilities. Unlike the construction of the pipeline, the surface facilities and well areas will not be constructed with a linear principle. Owners of the parcels, that surface facilities and well areas will be established on, will be fully acquired and compensated at replacement cost. 12On the lands to be acquired, if the crops identified in, it is recorded first indicating its type and status and then production value of crops and the crop loss is determined by a commission composed by BOTAŞ, head of village (muhtar) and experts from official agricultural institutions. Payment for compensation is done in accordance with this assessment and valuation record. 61 The possible impact categories could be loss of lands and livelihoods (cultivated lands, grazing lands for animals), loss of standing crops and trees etc. which may lead to physical or economic displacement or both. Physical displacement has been avoided in the Project design and no physical displacement will take place as observed in the site studies. i. Loss of land and land-based income: According to the data obtained from baseline studies carried out in the ESIA stage, irrigated and dry farming is common in the region and is the most important livelihood source. The affected plots are used primarily for cultivation and most landowners use all their land, including the portion affected, for direct income generation. Baseline data shows that in recent years in the region, farmers have taken irrigation pipes by borrowing credits to do irrigated agriculture. Therefore, losing their lands will directly cause a reduction in their agricultural income. ii. Loss of standing crops and trees: Crops and trees planted on lands which are subject to acquisition for well areas and surface facilities will be lost. iii. Loss of grazing and pasture lands: Grazing and pasture lands, which are located within the license area of GSEP, will be permanently lost due to the construction of well areas and surface facilities these project components. However, this impact is considered as insignificant; as detailed in ESIA Report Section 4.10.2. Use of Pasture Lands, pasture lands within the license area have quite large areas and have the capacity to meet current livestock grazing exceedingly. There are also alternative pasture lands used by PAPs which are not affected by the Project components or less likely to be affected. 6.3. Usage Limitations after Reinstatement Restrictions will be made for the protection of all lines (natural gas, fresh water, brine water pipelines and connection lines between UGS sites) where permanent and temporary easement rights will be established. Such restrictions will also be processed in the land registry of immovables subject to expropriation. Property owners and users will continue to carry on their agricultural activities on the grounds, but will not be able to carry out the following actions throughout the operation (project life) of the Project: i. Having activities that will damage the pipeline ii. Building any structure or outbuilding on the corridor iii. To plant rooted trees iv. To construct irrigation and drainage channels on the corridor v. Drill holes for any reason vi. Make any changes to the surface profile vii. Make changes that will affect the material of the soil surrounding the line viii. Reducing land covering pipeline, including archaeological activities ix. Pouring materials such as garbage, waste, sand and rubble on the corridor 62 7. MITIGATION MEASURES AND COMPENSATION STRATEGIES The Entitlement Matrix presented in this section provides an overview of all rights under the RAP. The Project will endeavor to minimize in-voluntary resettlement and to improve or at least re-establish livelihoods and living standards for displaced persons. Compensation for project-affected parties will be based on transparent, consistent and fair compensation measures. The entitlements defined under this RAP will be in accordance with local legislation and OP 4.12. Where applicable, entitlements include additional measures to comply with the specific requirements of OP 4.12. Eligible persons within the scope of the RAP include owners and users of all affected lands, immovable, trees and crops which are identified during asset inventory and socio-economic field survey. After the completion of the asset inventory study, any person will not be entitled to compensation, unless proved otherwise. In case of improvement of assets after the cut-off date, those improvements will also not be included in the compensation payments. Owners and/or users of the affected lands will be given the opportunity to harvest their crops before land acquisition. Furthermore, all the materials of the structures will be allowed to be evaluated by their owners. If applicable, transitional allowances and additional supports will be provided to eligible PAPs. Project impacts may include the following, but are not limited to: i. Permanent or temporary loss of lands; ii. Loss of dwellings or other structures, crops, trees or other assets; iii. Small businesses or production; iv. Loss of livelihoods due to Project activities v. Loss of common resources 63 Tablo 7-1 Entitlement Matrix No Impact Category Entitled Person Entitlements (Compensation, Assistance, Support) 1 Loss of land for Permanent Land Acquisition (Surface Private landowners Cash compensation at full replacement cost for loss of land due to permanent land acquisition in facilities and well areas13) surface facilities and well areas If the remaining portion of the permanently acquired land becomes economically unfit, these sections are also expropriated.14 Real Estate Transaction Tax to be paid at the title deed offices in case a new immovable property is purchased with the expropriation amount collected (up to 2% of the expropriation amount, by submission of bank receipt, from RAP fund) 2 Loss of land for Temporary and Permanent Easement Private landowners Easement value for permanent and temporary easement right which is determined in accordance Rights (Energy transmission lines, natural gas pipeline, with criteria specified by law. fresh water, brine water lines and other components15) 3 Loss of structures (physical displacement of house; Private landowners Cash compensation at full replacement cost for loss of residential houses, livestock pens, water wells movement of livestock pen(s)) Formal users on etc.). private or public Compensation for transportation costs. land Informal users on Cash compensation at full replacement cost to be paid from the RAP Fund or by national law private or public (depending on the type of land; such as Treasury) for loss of residential houses, livestock pens, water land wells etc.) Compensation to be paid from RAP Fund for transportation costs 4 Loss of crops, trees, water wells etc. Private landowners Cash compensation for lost annual/perennial crops or plants (based on the market value of the crops and trees after valuation by a specialized commission) Payments in relation with misidentification of the actual land user (crop owner) Formal users on Cash compensation for lost annual/perennial crops or plants to be paid from RAP Fund (based on the private or public market value of the crops and trees after valuation by a specialized commission) land Payments in relation with misidentification of the actual land user (crop owner) 13 Permanent access roads may also be required after the final design of the Project. 14 In cases where a portion of the expropriated property is not available for utilization, it is obligatory in cases where the administrative court is not sued for expropriation to expropriate the remaining property upon the written application within thirty days following the notification of the expropriation decision of the property owner. Permanent acquisition of remaining portion is not applicable for the temporarily affected parcels along the right of way of the pipeline. 15 Other components which may be required after final design such as temporary access roads, soil, and material storage areas, etc. 64 No Impact Category Entitled Person Entitlements (Compensation, Assistance, Support) Informal users on Cash compensation for lost annual/perennial crops or plants to be paid from RAP Fund (based on the private or public market value of the crops and trees after valuation by a specialized commission) land Payments in relation with misidentification of the actual land user to be paid from RAP Fund (crop owner) 5 Temporary or permanent loss of livelihoods that may be Formal and Transitional Livelihood Support equaling to minimum wage the provided by RAP Fund for duration of caused by loss of land, access to land, physical relocation informal users on six (6) months to formal and informal land users, who do not have regular wage based income with a of residential areas and other livelihood related private or public job at which they work more than one (1) year and whose livelihood depends on agriculture or other structures, lands being unviable due to expropriation lands income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc.(only for lands subject to etc. permanent land acquisition for above ground installations) Support for participation in occupational educational courses held by governmental agencies Crop payments to be paid from RAP Fund for “unviable lands” (where farming activities cannot be carried out in the area outside the Construction Corridor due to construction activities during the construction of pipelines) Livelihood restoration assistance in the form of permanent and temporary employment opportunities during the construction and operation phase particularly in job positions such as housekeeping, driving, security, cooking, etc. Private landowners Transitional Livelihood Support equaling to minimum wage to be provided for a duration of six (6) months, to the land owners who do not have regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one (1) year, whose livelihood depends on agriculture or other income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc. and whose land take amount is more than 20% of the entire land (only for lands subject to permanent land acquisition for above ground installations) Support for participation in occupational educational courses hold by governmental agencies. Crop payments for “unviable lands” (where farming activities cannot be carried out in the area outside the Construction Corridor due to construction activities during the construction of pipelines) Livelihood restoration assistance in the form of permanent and temporary employment opportunities during the construction and operation phase particularly in job positions such as housekeeping, driving, security, cooking, etc. Vulnerable groups Vulnerable groups identified in Section 5.7.3. are likely to be encountered during RAP implementation process. Additional income restoration measures may be also designed, including provision of employment in the Project. 65 No Impact Category Entitled Person Entitlements (Compensation, Assistance, Support) Measures are identified in Section Hata! Başvuru kaynağı bulunamadı. will be taken prior to construction activities and during the construction to ensure the vulnerable groups are not negatively affected by the Project. Transitional Livelihood Support equaling to minimum wage will be provided by RAP Fund for duration of six (6) months to formal and informal land users of lands affected by multiple components of the Project, who do not have regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one (1) year and whose livelihood depends on agriculture or other income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc. (for lands subject to permanent and temporary land acquisition due to construction of multiple components such as well areas, surface facilities, pipelines, etc.) For requests approved by QHSE Management regarding contract farming, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the price of the crop which can not be cultivated due to the expropriation of land. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. In addition, cash support equal to minimum wage for six (6) months is added to the compensation amount. In case that this additional cash support’s amount is lower than the quota penalty to be paid by the farmers, the difference between two amounts will also be compensated. However it can not be estimated because it depends on each farmers conditions of their contract . 6 Loss of Common property resources (community lands) Village Legal Entity Payments regarding the economic livelihood losses arising from not being able to use common lands for grazing purposes (In this case payment is made to Village Legal Entity). The common grazing land losses of PAPs will be compensated and the compensation will be aimed at supporting or improving livestock activities in accordance with the joint decision of the settlement (eg, fodder provision, animal shading and watering trough support). Unidentified Impacts - If any new category of impact is encountered, they will be mitigated as per principles of the RAP. 66 Transitional Livelihood Support to formal and informal land users, who do not have regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one year and whose livelihood depends on agriculture or other income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc., will cover providing minimum wage for duration of 6 (six) months. Transitional Livelihood Support to private land owners, who do not have regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one year, whose livelihood depends on agriculture or other income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc. and whose land take amount is more than 20% of the entire land, will cover providing minimum wage for a duration of 6 (six) months. Transitional livelihood support will be provided through applications made to BOTAŞ Head or Site offices staff by means of a letter or via CİMER System (see Appendix 3- Application form of Transitional Livelihood Support). The above land users will also be supported to participate in occupational educational courses held by governmental agencies. Crop payment on unviable lands will be based on eligibility criteria which will be evaluated after submitting the Evaluation Form of Crop Payments on Orphan Lands (see Appendix-4). The eligibility criteria defined in the evaluation form is as follows: i. If the subject land can no longer be used for agricultural purposes since the remaining area of the land after the expropriation is less than 1000 m2 ii. If the remaining area cannot be plowed due to its geometric shape and cannot be harvested iii. If access to subject land is blocked due to pipe stringing and trenching activities iv. If irrigability of subject land is blocked during construction activities v. Inability to use the land for agricultural purposes due to more than 10% slope during project construction vi. If the land is sensitive to the risk of flood and erosion vii. If the land is rented to the third person by the landowner (directly affecting the land user in means of harvesting the land and indirectly affecting the landowner’s rent / profit ratio) viii. In case the Project construction disrupts the cultivation of products, the application for the state incentive cannot be done or limited (this will be proved by the presentation of the claim) ix. If the subject land cannot be used for agricultural purposes due to a reason that is not stated above, it will be recorded by mutual negotiation of landowner/user, settlement head and BOTAŞ authorities The remaining area of expropriated land shall be paid based on crops’ current market value, provided that at least 2 (two) of the above criteria are covered. Compensation for transportation costs of people who are physically displaced, who have to move livestock pen or other livestock stuff, will be paid by BOTAŞ from the RAP Fund by submission of transportation bill. BOTAŞ will coordinate with the affected parties and assist them in submitting a transportation bill which will be reimbursed. Likewise, Real Estate Transaction Tax to be paid at the title deed offices in case a new immovable property is purchased with the expropriation amount collected will be paid up to 2% of the expropriation amount by submission of bank receipt. 67 8. INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK BOTAŞ is solely responsible for the preparation and implementation of the RAP in cooperation with the public institutions and other stakeholders at the village, quarter, district and province levels. The Project’s land acquisition activities will be performed in compliance with the national Expropriation Law and World Bank’s OP 4.12. National Laws and international safeguard policies will guide the Project’s land acquisition activities. The decision of Public Interest has been taken by the Ministry of Energy for the UGS Project. The decision allows the application of the Expropriation Law. There will be several parties that will take place in the preparation, implementation and monitoring of RAP activities. With respect to the Turkish legislation, BOTAŞ is responsible for the implementation of all land acquisition and resettlement activities of the Project. BOTAŞ has a separate expropriation unit in Konya16 that will be in charge of the land acquisition works carried out on site. The social team of BOTAŞ (comprising of 3 staff at Head Office and 2 staff at site) will work closely with this unit and monitor land acquisition activities to ensure that land acquisition activities are executed in line with all relevant national legislation and international policies. Other key responsibilities of social team will be ensuring that necessary mitigation measures/actions are implemented for the implementation of RPF/RAP, ensuring that proper approaches and tools are being used to conduct site activities in compliance with BOTAŞ RPF/RAP as well as other Project requirements, coordinating stakeholder engagement activities as specified in Project’s Stakeholder Engagement Plan (SEP), coordinating interface and reporting to/from World Bank in relation to implementation of RAP, measuring and reporting RAP performance of the Project as defined under related Project plans, procedures and requirements, providing support for coordination of RAP related programs as deemed necessary. The social team, in collaboration with the Consultants’ and the EPC Contractor’s social team will ensure the completion of all resettlement activities in relevant sections prior to the start of civil works. Detailed roles and responsibilities for the issues related with RAP management are provided in table below. Table 8-1Organizational Arrangements for RAP Management Staff Responsibility BOTAŞ Head QHSE Manager  Implements and improves processes related to grievance Office (Storage mechanism, RAP Fund management, RAP and stakeholder Department) engagement issues  Expedites, monitors, follows up social team for proper implementation of processes related to grievance mechanism, RAP Fund management, RAP and stakeholder engagement issues  Coordinates with parties for proper implementation of processes related to grievance mechanism, RAP Fund management, RAP and stakeholder engagement issues Social Expert  Receives and records the RAP Fund applications/complaints/request from the entitlement person under grievance mechanism regarding social issues and reports these to relevant units. Helps relevant units in taking required actions  Follows up and is informed about disclosure activities carried out within the scope of the RAP Fund applications/complaints/request received regarding social issues 16 Kayseri office could support the Konya office for handling expropriation files and negotiations. 68 Staff Responsibility  Participates in interviews with environmental and Social Monitoring Consultant social team staff, and others involved in land acquisition, compensation disbursement or livelihood restoration activities to review progress and identify critical issues  Prepares RAP Monitoring Plan  Monitors and reports on progress made with regards to commitments defined in RAP(s)  Does any other activities required to realize the objectives of RAP implementation?  Examines whether RAP Fund applications are eligible or not  Prepares GLAC and other informative materials when needed. Community Relations  Consults with affected households and with community leaders Specialist through brief questionnaires to ascertain their feedback on compensation payment, livelihood impact and delivery of other resettlement and rehabilitation assistance. Also interacts with various stakeholders to hear their views on RAP implementation  By submitting required materials, informs the entitled person defined within the scope of RAP Fund in a planned way or in case of need Expropriation Department  Communicates regularly with land owners/users to inform about their rights and the land acquisition process  Identifies formal/informal land users on affected lands  Collects and records grievances pertaining to land acquisition  Hands over any grievances associated with RAP Fund to Storage Department  Performs all processes regarding land acquisition (BOTAŞ Land Acquisition Department manages and executes all land acquisition activities in conformity with the relevant Turkish Legislation)  Provides regular land acquisition data to BOTAŞ including grievances and logs of negotiation meetings etc. Site QHSE Chief Engineer  Takes actions to resolve land acquisition induced grievances in coordination with land acquisition experts. (BOTAŞ)  Monitors activities of the construction contract and administers payments made for overspill and additional land rentals  Participates in interviews with environmental and Social Monitoring Consultant social team staff, and others involved in land acquisition, compensation disbursement or livelihood restoration activities to review progress and identify critical issues  Examines whether RAP Fund applications are eligible or not  Studies community level responses to loss of community resources  Verifies that livelihood restoration measures are implemented and assess their effectiveness Community Liaison Officer  Gives information to the Project affected community about grievance mechanism, entitlements, construction works and schedule, community safety, compensation of economic losses, RAP Fund management  Implements processes related to grievance mechanism, RAP Fund management, RAP and stakeholder engagement issues  Receives and records the RAP Fund applications/complaints/request from the entitlement person under grievance mechanism regarding social issues  Helps filling application form samples that are created in case the entitled person wishes to apply 69 Staff Responsibility  Disseminates GLAC and other informative materials when needed. Land Acquisition Experts of  Communicate regularly with land owners/users to inform BOTAS Konya Provincial about their rights Directorate  Identify informal land user on Public Lands  Collect and records grievances pertaining to land acquisition  Hand over any grievances associated with RAP Fund to RAP Fund Evaluation Committee  Perform all processes regarding land acquisition (BOTAŞ Land Acquisition Department manages and executes all land acquisition activities in conformity with the relevant Turkish Legislation)  Provide regular land acquisition data including grievances and logs of negotiation meetings etc.  Disseminates GLAC and other informative materials when needed. Site Community Relations  Holds interviews with BOTAŞ social team staff, and others Specialist involved in land acquisition, compensation disbursement or (Environmental livelihood restoration activities to review progress and identify and Social critical issues Monitoring  Consults with affected households and with community leaders Consultant) through brief questionnaires to ascertain their feedback on compensation payment, livelihood impact and delivery of other resettlement and rehabilitation assistance. Also interacts with various stakeholders to hear their views on RAP implementation  Reviews grievance records to illustrate significant non- compliance issues or recurring problems regarding the land acquisition activities and coming up with actions  Monitors and reports on progress made with regards to commitments defined in RAP(s)  Performs any other activities required to realize the objectives of RAP implementation  Examines whether RAP Fund applications are eligible or not Resettlement and  Monitors all the resettlement activities of the Project as Livelihood Restoration specified in the RAP Specialist  Reviews internal monitoring activities, records and reports to verify compliance with commitments in RAP(s) and identify problematic areas in RAP implementation and suggest ways of resolving those  Holds interviews with BOTAŞ social team staff, and others involved in land acquisition, compensation disbursement or livelihood restoration activities to review progress and identify critical issues  Consults with affected households and with community leaders through brief questionnaires to ascertain their feedback on compensation payment, livelihood impact and delivery of other resettlement and rehabilitation assistance. Also interact with various stakeholders to hear their views on RAP implementation  Examines whether RAP Fund applications are eligible or not  Studies community level responses to loss of community resources  Monitors RAP Fund implementation and assess the appropriateness of Fund financed activities, including community-based programs  Verifies that livelihood restoration measures are implemented and assess their effectiveness 70 Staff Responsibility  Provides advice on corrective actions and measures to improve the implementation of RAP  Reports on the progress in key result indicators related to social impacts outlined in the World Bank’s PAD and RAPs  Monitors and reports on progress made with regards to commitments defined in RAP(s)  Performs any other activities required to realize the objectives of RAP implementation  Prepares and submits a RAP Completion Report at the end of the resettlement activities  Provides all relevant materials, documents and data collected from implementation of RAP(s) to the External Auditors, who will be appointed by BOTAŞ and will be responsible of doing an External RAP Progress Audit and an External RAP Completion Audit. The External RAP Progress Audit will cover all RAP(s) that are in progress by then and the timing of this will be decided by BOTAŞ and the World Bank. The External RAP Completion Audit is a separate document from the RAP Completion Report. The latter will be conducted by the ESIA and RAP Monitoring Consultant to summarize all resettlement activities undertaken and completed in the Project. The former assignment will be undertaken by external independent auditors (to be appointed by BOTAŞ) to carry out a third-party independent audit 71 9. PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE The Project Environmental and Social Impact Assessment document was prepared in 2018. Within the scope of the ESIA, management plans have been also prepared and implemented, including environmental and social impact mitigation and management measures. One of these management plans is the Stakeholder Engagement Plan (SEP) and the stakeholder engagement process of RAP is mainly implemented in line with the SEP prepared by BOTAŞ. The owners and users of affected properties and vulnerable groups that are directly affected by the Project are mainly focused in the stakeholder engagement process of RAP. In addition, Stakeholder Engagement also includes regulatory agencies that are expected to be involved in the development and implementation of the RAP process. BOTAŞ was and will be in active communication with the stakeholders as determined in SEP throughout the life of the project. The methods and materials clarified in SEP (public participation meeting, consultation meetings, focus group discussions, presentations, local media announcements, brochures, grievance mechanism, free hotline etc.) are being used within the scope of the engagement starting from the scoping stage of the project until the operation and closure stages. This section describes stakeholder engagement activities undertaken during RAP preparation and to be undertaken during RAP Implementation as it is a continuous process throughout the project lifecycle. According to WB OP 4.12, BOTAŞ as the borrower is will inform potentially displaced persons at an early stage about the resettlement aspects of the project and take their views into account. In line with this RAP, communities likely to be affected by the Project; particularly landowners and land users have and will be informed about the Project. Moroever, the displaced persons will be informed about land acquisition process and their rights and options, and grievance mechanism of the Project by introducing the community relations contact person of BOTAS for any concerns, questions and complaints about the Project, in particularly land acquisition process. Project’s Stakeholder Engagement Plan (SEP) that has already been developed in the process of ESIA serves also for this aspect of this Operational Policy. In this respect, stakeholder engagement process shall continue during:  Disclosure of information about the Project and RAP and ensuring the participation of the affected parties to the RAP,  Implementation of compensation strategies,  Planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of resettlement and livelihood restoration activities. The identified stakeholders of the project include the affected local community, local public authorities, NGOs and other community representatives. Transparent consultation and public disclosure processes are an indispensable component of ensuring participation in the preparation and implementation of a RAP. GSEP has prepared and implements a Stakeholder Engagement Plan for this purpose. The stakeholder engagement plan is a living document to be developed in stages and needs to be updated as the project progresses through the lessons learned and through the planning and implementation stages through understanding the project activities and risks identified in the stakeholder engagement process. 72 The primary stakeholders for the project are identified as follows:17  National and local state institutions and organizations (The Ministry of Environment and Urbanization, Aksaray Governorship, Sultanhanı Municipality etc.)  PAPs including non-organized groups with particular areas of interest or that may be vulnerable (i.e., elderly, people with disabilities, ethnic minorities, etc.). PAPs include land owners and residents that may formally and/or informally use communal/state/treasury land  Seasonal workers and herders  Interest groups, such as universities and their foundations, cooperatives, local business establishments, business associations, chambers of commerce and others (i.e., labor, youth, religious, businesses etc.)  Project and contractors’ employees and  Media 9.1. Public Consultation and Participation during Land Acquisition Process Public information and consultancy activities on land acquisition were initiated by BOTAŞ in January and February 2019. At this stage visual materials were not yet ready and the GLAC had not yet been finalized. In addition, asset inventory and census on land acquisition were not yet completed in all settlements. For these reasons, the initial information and consultation meetings were held only in the settlements mentioned in following table: Tablo 9-1 Consultation and Informative Meetings held by BOTAŞ Date Location Consulted Settlements 29 January 2019 Sarıyahşi District Governorship Sarıyahşi Center Boğazköy Village 29 January 2019 Evren District Governorship Evren ilçesi 30 January 2019 Ağaçören District Governorship Ağaçören Center Kütüklü Village Camili Village Kederli Village Abdiuşağı Village Çatalçeşme Village 31 January 2019 Ortaköy District Governorship Hacımahmutuşağı Village Hacıibrahimuşağı Village Hıdırlı/Fakıcık Village Pınarbaşı Village İshaklıkarapınar Village Camuzluk Village 1 February 2019 Yenikent Municipality Yenikent Town 1 February 2019 Yeşilova Municipality Yeşilova Town 17 The detailed list of stakeholders is presented in RPF, Appendix-5. 73 1 February 2019 Yeşiltepe Municipality Yeşiltepe Town 4 February 2019 Village House of Baymış Settlement Baymış Village 4 February 2019 Village House of Sapmaz Settlement Sapmaz Village 4 February 2019 Village House of Bostanlık Settlement Bostanlık Village 4 February 2019 Village House of Cerit Settlement Cerit Village 5 February 2019 Village House of Hanobası Settlement Hanobası Village 6 February 2019 Village House of Altınkaya Settlement Altınkaya Village Prior to these meetings, the information of the parcels, which will be subject to land acquisition, was communicated to the settlements and an official letter was sent for the participation of the land owners and users. No participant list was kept at the meetings, only photographs were taken. In these meetings; the land requirements of the Project and then the land acquisition process were explained to participants. PAPs were informed that the expropriation process would be initiated soon on the parcels mentioned in the announcements, and that the expropriation process will be carried out similar to the process carried out within the scope of the existing UGS Project, that there will be no permanent acquisition of any property for the pipelines of the Project only permanent easement and temporary easement rights will be taken, that the lands subject to acquiring of temporary easement rights can be used without restriction after construction activities and that the lands subject to permanent easement right can be used with limitations of building any structure and the cultivating root plants. It has been stated during these meetings that BOTAŞ expropriation teams will visit all settlements and will identify land users and an inventory of the assets along the expropriation corridor would be made, that it is important for the users to come forward, and that their participation will be crucial in completing full inventory of the assets. Finally, contact information for any questions, comments, suggestions and appeals has been re-shared with PAPs. It was observed that participants were aware of the existing UGS Project and many of them have concerns if they could provide water from fresh water line for irrigation purposes. In response to them, it was stated that the fresh water lines will be used in the melting of the salt layer as part of the UGS project and GSEP, and therefore it will not be possible to provide irrigation water during the construction of the Project. However, they were informed that the water lines will become idle when the melting process is completed and if they share their request with relevant authorities, it may be possible for for the lines to be utilized for providing irrigation water for agriculture. Again, in many settlements, complaints were raised about the problems during top-soil stripping, preserving and reinstatement stages of the existing UGS Project, the land not being fully reinstated, the area being left uneven, and that they had to reinstate the lands by their own means again. Regarding the reinstatement of lands, PAPs were informed that the construction activities of the Contractor will be closely monitored by BOTAŞ, land access protocols will be prepared before entering the lands, and that the construction period would not be accepted as finished before the land was confirmed to be reinstated properly. After these meetings, asset inventory and census are completed for all affected parcels and settlements while asset valuation studies are still on-going. In May 2019; asset valuation, visual materials and GLAC will be finalized. After the finalization of GLAC, information and consultation meetings will be re-performed in all affected settlements. Land owners and users will be invited to the 74 meetings and the results of the asset inventory and valuation studies will be shared with them along with the prepared GLAC document. Separate meetings will be held for vulnerable groups. The information on the legal process and rights of the PAPs, authorities, RAP Fund, grievance mechanism and contact channels will be disclosed to PAPs again. These meetings will be recorded with participant lists and photographs documenting the participation of the PAPs. 9.2. Consultation Activities during RAP Preparation The Project initiated community participation by providing information to settlement heads and community member, including PAPs. During this process, informative meetings with local authorities, stakeholder consultation meetings and interviews with PAPs were conducted. During the RAP process, PAPs and directly affected communities were reached out and consulted about the Project. Informative meetings, household surveys, in-depth interviews and focus group discussions were held with stakeholders. Consultations were held with public authorities, national government and non-governmental organizations in the project area. Tablo 9-2Summary of Public Consultation Activities Number of Number of PAPs Number of Number of Land consultations Landowners Users (Formal- Informal) Number of PAPs (owners/tenants/users) surveyed - 203 144 59 Focus group discussions with 21 45 25 6 elderly people Focus group discussions with 20 67 33 5 women Settlement Head Surveys 27 27 NA NA In-depth interviews with public institutions/ private NA NA sector/ NGOs /etc. Interviews with workers 3 10 - - Semi-structed in-depth interviews were conducted with stakeholder groups defined in the following table such as Municipalities, Governorships, education, helath and agricultural institutions and NGOs. Following table presents detailed information about the negotiated stakeholders. Tablo 9-3In-depth Interviews with Institutions No Type Institutions 1 Public Sarıyahşi District Governorship 2 Public Ağaçören District Governorship 3 Public Ortaköy District Governorship 4 Public Aksaray Governorship 5 Public Sultanhanı District Governorship 6 Public Sarıyahşi Municipality 7 Public Ağaçören Municipality 8 Public Ortaköy Municipality 9 Public Aksaray Municipality 10 Public Sultanhanı Municipality 11 Public Evren Municipality 12 Public Sultanhanı District Directorate of Agriculture 13 NGO Agricultural Producers Association 14 Private Sector Balküpü Sugar Factory 15 Media Sultanhanı Municipality Local Media 16 Cooperative Villages Agricultural Development Cooperatives 75 9.3. Future Consultations In the RAP implementation, the following participation activities will be required: I. Negotiations on the RAP implementation with affected people, households and communities. II. Public disclosure of the RAP to the relevant local public institutions, NGOs, affected communities, host communities as well as the public. III. Developing measures to monitor implementation progress and monitoring the effectiveness of livelihood improvement measures for vulnerable groups in consultation with stakeholders and PAPs. BOTAŞ Social Team will work closely with BOTAŞ land acquisition teams on site and Construction Contractors to ensure that the requirements on stakeholder engagement are met throughout the Project lifetime. Below are means of engagement to be utilized during the RAP implementation to promote transparent involvement in all resettlement activities and livelihood activities. Community-Consultation Committee: It is a committee to be established and responsible of providing a mechanism to feedback to the BOTAŞ social team on the concerns/grievances of the community. It will support the social team in receiving grievances and finding resolutions that are mutually agreed with all parties. Public Information Meetings: Information sharing meetings will be held locally to provide stakeholders with up-to-date project information and to address issues and concerns. These meetings will be held at the Project site and open to all public. Project Brochures and other informative materials: In the project informative brochures that will be presented to the stakeholders regularly, general information about the project and the RAP process as well as information about grievance mechanism and liaison channels will be provided. Open Days: Stakeholders can visit the offices of the Project and get information. Web Access: Stakeholders will be able to access the Project web site, obtain Project documentation from this site and raise their comments, concerns or questions to the Project. The website will provide information about the progress of the RAP implementation. The website will also provide contact information of the responsible person or department for grievance management. 9.4. Document Management and Disclosure of Documents GSEP is obliged to implement a document management system to manage all documentation related to land acquisition, consultations with stakeholders, census, questionnaire and asset databases, compensation contracts and payments and legal documents related to RAP. Once the draft version is complete, this RAP will be disclosed during the public consultations according to the Operational Policy 4.12. Any feedback received during this consultation will be integrated to the RAP and submitted for final approval of the World Bank. After the approval of the World Bank, BOTAŞ will share RAP with all other relevant Ministries, Local Governments and Institutions as well as disclosing both Turkish and English versions of the document on its official website. The final RAP will also be disclosed on the external website of World Bank. Any addendum to RAP developed in further stages of the Project will also be approved by the World Bank and be disclosed both on BOTAŞ’s official and World Bank’s external 76 websites. The RAP shall also be presented through public consultation meetings to PAPs prior to the commencement of the land acquisition process, particularly to vulnerable groups in order to inform on the land-based impacts of the project, legal rights and entitlements, RAP Fund and Project GRM. 77 10. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM 10.1. Purpose and Scope A grievance mechanism will be established to receive and address in a timely fashion specific concerns about compensation and relocation that are raised by displaced persons, including a recourse mechanism designed to resolve disputes in an impartial manner. This mechanism will be functional throughout resettlement planning and implementation. It is essential for the grievance management mechanism to be in place at the time the census is undertaken so that all affected persons can respond if any findings from the census are incorrect. Establishing project level Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM) within the body of BOTAŞ, which is open to the usage of all stakeholders that may be affected directly or indirectly by the GSEP, is very important to solve all worries and complaints of the stakeholders regarding the project in time, to prevent misunderstandings and to prevent material and non-material losses which are hard to compensate for. The Grievance Redress Mechanism is established as the following table illustrates. Tablo 10-1 Grievance Redress Mechanism Level Authority Form of Application Activities Duration Local BOTAŞ Office The question or complaints are assessed. Face to face application, Phone: 0(382) 242 40 04 The person is provided 1 phone call, 30 days Address: Tuz Gölü Doğal Gaz Depolama with feedback. correspondence Tesisi, Besci Köyü Yolu 18. km, If not resolved, it is Sultanhanı-AKSARAY directed to legal ways. BOTAŞ Head Office Hakan ERTEN Phone: (0312) 297 2991 E-mail: hakan.erten@botas.gov.tr The question or Asrım AKKAŞOĞLU complaints are assessed. Phone: (0312) 2972964 Phone call, The person is provided 2 e-mail:asrim.akkasoglu@botas.gov.tr correspondence, e-mail, 15-30 days with feedback. If not online application resolved, it is directed to Address: Bilkent Plaza A-1 Blok 06800 legal ways. Bilkent/Ankara - Turkey) Online application: https://www.cimer.gov.tr Toll free number: 152 It takes place within the On the Legal 3 Civil Court of First Instance With correspondence framework of legal Process legislation. Framework 78 10.2. Procedure and Responsibilities Recording and follow up of grievances (including environmental issues) will be the primary responsibilities of the BOTAŞ’s social team. The social team will follow the Grievance Redress Mechanism established by BOTAŞ to record and resolve all complaints from the stakeholders and follow up corrective actions taken. Contact information of toll-free number (152) will be provided via Project website, through public information meetings, consultation meetings and Project brochures to raise awareness and offer transparency of how stakeholders can voice their grievances. Project staff (social team) has the primary role in resolving complaints as part of their day to day activities as they interact with community members. Staff members who receive complaints verbally must put them in writing for them to be considered. Various channels for stakeholders to vocalize their grievances formally include:  Telephone (Stakeholders can call BOTAŞ’s Head Office on 0312 297 2991 - 0312 297 29 64 or Local Office 0382 242 40 04 and request to speak to a contact officer)  E-mail (Grievances can be sent to info@botas.gov.tr)  Face to face (Stakeholders can voice their grievance to social team of BOTAŞ at local office)  Complaint register form (CRF) (Stakeholders can fill the forms that will be distributed to them in advance to voice their grievances) (see Appendix-4)  Online application (Stakeholders can fill the forms online at https://www.cimer.gov.tr) Grievance mechanism established by BOTAŞ includes both environmental and social issues as well as grievances of workers. Workers may transmit their grievances by means of grievance mechanism. The steps to be followed during the grievance management will be as follows; Receiving & Registering of Grievance:  All Grievances received by all level of Project Staff; Contractor and sub-contractors of Project, are registered by using Complaint Register Form (CRF) and a hard copy of the form is provided to Complainant. The completed form is delivered to BOTAŞ social team within the same business day. Other hard copies of the CRF are distributed by BOTAŞ social team to relevant disciplines, if needed.  If the CRF cannot be filled out, following basic information is recorded and provided to social team by e-mail or by an acceptable correspondence: o Name and surname of the Complainant o Subject of the Grievance o Location of the Grievance o Contact details (phone/mobile number, address, e-mail etc.) o Organization name (if related) o Date and time  BOTAŞ social team completes the CRF according to given information and registers the complaint.  All corrective actions suggested by Complainant are taken under registration via CRF.  Grievance Monitoring Table is filled out by BOTAŞ social team according to the received information. Assessment of the Grievance:  All Grievances are reviewed to be classified whether they are genuine and related to Project activities or not. If the issues/disputes raised are not related to Project, guidance is provided 79 to the Complainant to contact relevant party. Eligible complaints are responded according to Project social and environmental requirements which are identified in ESMPs and ESIA Report.  All Grievance received through the Toll-Free Number (152), direct phone calls, e-mails and face-to-face meetings/communications are taken under registration and BOTAŞ social team gets contact with the Complainant within two (2) business days following registration in order to explain the Project response process to Grievance.  BOTAŞ has ten (10) business days to investigate and respond the Complaints. If the case requires a more complex investigation, updated information is provided to the Complainant explaining the actions required to resolve Grievance, and the likely timeline.  Responses aligning with the Project social mitigation measures and compensation items are defined beforehand according to the Project standards. Resolving the Grievance:  Necessary corrective actions shall satisfy the Complainant.  All parties get an agreement on the corrective actions during solution process.  BOTAŞ social team aims to solve each complaint within thirty (30) business days after response, and this period is subject to extend upon written consent of Head of Department. If mutually agreed with PAPs, Consultation Committee will be established and responsible of providing a mechanism to feedback to the BOTAŞ social team on the concerns/grievances of the community. It will support the social team in receiving grievances and finding resolutions that are mutually agreed with all parties.  When the Complainants are not satisfied with the decision of BOTAŞ and/or Contractors on their complaints, they may apply to court. Close Out of the Grievance: Proof documents of the corrective actions taken (photos from Site in subject or other evidence documents) are collected and a "grievance closure protocol" is signed by BOTAŞ and the complainant. Monitoring of Grievances: Monitoring of grievances is made by filling out Grievances Monitoring Table including following headings:  complaint register number  how complaint is received (grievance form, community meeting, telephone, other)  level at grievance (contractor level, local BOTAŞ office level, through BOTAŞ Headquarters)  date of complaint received  location of complaint received  name of person in charge  coordinates of the area subject to complaint  land parcel number (if complaint is related to land)  complaint information o name, surname o telephone/e-mail o village-district-province o gender  project component related to complaint  grievance category 80 o expropriation/land acquisition related grievances o environmental issues o damages to crops and structure etc.  complaint summary  grievance status o open o closed and o pending/in process  action taken o responsible person/department o action planned o due date of the addressing the grievance o date of action taken  supporting documents for grievance close out (bank receipt for compensation, grievance closure protocol) 81 11.IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE The activities specified in the Implementation Schedule for RAP process of GSEP are grouped below. These activities will continue until the RAP Completion Audit. 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Main Activities Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 1. Management RAP Preparation Approval of RAP Preparation of RAP Monitoring Plan Team organization 2. Stakeholder Engagement Establishment of Grievance Redress Mechanism Public Disclosure and Negotiation Meetings Information Disclosure (general) Consultation Meetings on RAP Fund 3. Land Acquisition Taking Decision for Public Interest Asset Inventory & Valuation Identification of Landowners/Users Negotiations Payments to Landowners/users Access to Land through land entry Land exit 4. RAP Fund Implementation Disclosure of RAP Fund Collection of Applications/Complaints Evaluation of Eligibility of Applicants Delivery of RAP Fund to Eligible PAPs 5. Monitoring & Evaluation Internal Monitoring RAP Completion Report External Monitoring RAP Completion Audit 82 Table36 Implementation Schedule Estimated Due Date 83 12. MONITORING AND EVALUATION The aim of the RAP is primarily to avoid any negative impacts on the living conditions of the affected communities. In this section, monitoring and evaluation process, reporting frequency, internal and external monitoring content, internal and external monitoring indicators and the responsible groups for the integration of feedback from external monitoring into the Project implementation process are defined. 12.1. Monitoring Approach The purpose of the RAP monitoring is to ensure that the measures developed to compensate the negative impacts caused by the land acquisition for the Project are effective in PAPs’ efforts to restore, and where possible improve their living standards after loss of land due to the Project. Moreover, the effectiveness of the grievance mechanism provided by Project as one of the major tools of stakeholder engagement for the success of RAP implementation will also be monitored. To achieve this purpose, a mutually complementary monitoring mechanism which consists of internal and external monitoring with a completion audit is established as below: i. Internal monitoring to be conducted by the BOTAŞ Social Team in collaboration with ESIA and RAP Consultant’s experts to be responsible for RAP and LRP activities; ii. External monitoring to be conducted by an independent third party (ESIA and RAP Monitoring Consultant); and iii. RAP Completion Audit to be conducted by another independent third-party consultant. The main principle of the whole monitoring process is to undertake each monitoring activity in a participatory way by using the appropriate techniques such as one-to-one depth interviews with PAPs or community leaders, focus group discussions with vulnerable groups or communities for impacts and relevant mitigation actions taken at community level in addition to observation and visits of the impacted areas together with PAPs. Considering this framework, BOTAŞ Social Team will prepare a RAP Monitoring Plan which covers the entire RAP implementation activities in relation to all project components, lists all indicators to be both internally and externally monitored and provide resources including responsible persons or institutions to carry out the monitoring activities in line with the framework defined respectively and the planned monitoring schedule in the following section will be initiated after the RAP Monitoring Plan is ready. 12.1.1. Internal Monitoring Internal monitoring is also known as monitoring the Project’ performance. It monitors and measures the progress of RAP activities. The GSEP's social team recruited in BOTAŞ will be responsible for this process, with support of Consultant’s experts assigned to this process. As shown in the Table under section 12.2 Monitoring Schedule it is planned that internal monitoring results will be semiannually reported and the first Internal Monitoring Report (IMR) will be prepared by the end of third quarter of 2019 and then, in every six months (1st quarter and 3rd quarter of the following years), IMRs will be submitted to World Bank by the Social Team of BOTAŞ. The social team will also; in collaboration with the Consultant’s social experts ensure the completion of all resettlement activities in relevant sections prior to the start of civil works. Following the completion of construction phase of the Project, the internal monitoring process will be finished with the RAP Completion Report to be prepared by ESIA & 84 RAP Consultant’s experts as defined in the Table 8.1 on Organizational Arrangement for RAP Management. The data collection tools proposed for an efficient monitoring will be:  Reports on meetings or interviews held to inform and / or communicate with stakeholders;  The data collected by BOTAŞ during the land acquisition process;  Progress report of the Project which includes land acquisition progress and expenditures;  Site visits reports of relevant experts; and  Grievance Records received within the framework of the institutional grievance mechanism The focus points of the internal monitoring activity are defined as follows: i. To follow the land acquisition process to ensure that all landowners whose lands are acquired for the Project receive compensation for their losses, ii. To ensure that all landusers (formal and informal) are compensated in a timely and appropriate manner for loss of livelihood through RAP Fund, iii. To enable all PAPs; especially vulnerable people, to raise readily any concerns throughout the RAP Implementation process and BOTAŞ to be responsive to all PAPs in a timely manner, iv. To ensure that the grievance mechanism is transparent and accessible to all, v. To follow closely whether all planned RAP Implementation activities are on track in respect to schedule and budget, vi. To plan the next actions to be taken in detail by making consultation with relevant responsible parties of the RAP Implementation, and getting approval of the QHSE Manager. Considering the performance monitoring parameters listed below, a number of indicators will be determined while developing the RAP Monitoring Plan: • Number and types of Project components in respect to land acquisition requirements, • Number of households and individuals economically displaced by the project component and/or type of land acquisition, • Number of public discussions and consultations as needed during RAP Implementation including land acquisition and livelihood restoration, • Number of completed compensation payments, • Amount and percentage of payments made for negotiated settlements and payments made through court cases, • Number of open court cases out of the total cases, • Number and type of grievances related to land acquisition and compensation process, • Status of grievances (open, closed), duration of closure and quality of resolution, • Number of PAPs received any compensation payment and/or livelihood support from RAP Fund, • Number of stakeholders engaged throughout the RAP Implementation with respect to types of stakeholders, issues raised / discussed, and gender, • Percentage of feedback from consultations, • Number and type of assistances provided to vulnerable groups of PAPs Regular and continuous monitoring and evaluation is critical to the success of the RAP Implementation and to make the process more effective. Its major function is to allow BOTAŞ to make changes in the 85 mitigation measures planned and implemented to achieve the objectives. In accordance with this purpose, a regular and continuous internal monitoring mechanism is established. All IMRs to be prepared in each year will be used as the main input for the external RAP monitoring to be undertaken at the end of each year until the completion of the construction in 2023. After that time, a RAP Completion Report will be prepared by the Consultant’s experts as planned and submitted by BOTAŞ Social Team to World Bank in mid-2024. This RAP Completion Report will be the main input for External RAP Completion Audit to be carried out towards the end of 2024 by another independent consultant as requested by the World Bank. 12.1.2. External Monitoring An independent third party will be contracted to conduct external RAP monitoring annually to be initiated as of 2019. The overall purpose of the external evaluation will be to determine whether the RAP and its implementation comply with the requirements of WB OP 4.12. The external evaluation for all the Project settlements will place special attention on livelihood restoration (both measures and effects) as this is potentially complex and adverse while at the same time beneficial. Together with that, grievance redress mechanism will also be reviewed to assess whether it is effective in registering all concerns/complaints of PAPs and resolving them in a timely and appropriate manner. In parallel to that, stakeholder engagement activities with regard to RAP will be evaluated in terms of its effective, accessibility, transparency and appropriateness. Furthermore, corrective actions to bridge the gaps, if identified any, will be recommendated. Indicators of external monitoring will be defined in the RAP Monitoring Plan in line with this aim. During the field visits to be annually organized for external monitoring, external monitoring experts will visit Project-affected settlements to be selected according to the criteria that will serve the scope of external monitoring. In these visits, in-depth interviews and consultations with PAPs, community leaders in addition to social staff responsible for RAP Implementation will be conducted. Before site visits, the external monitoring consultants will review the internal RAP monitoring reports and they will be updated about the Project progress, land acquisition and other resettlements/livelihood activities by the Social Team of BOTAŞ. At the end of site visits, preliminary observation and feedback will be shared with BOTAŞ Social Team and QHSE Manager. 12.1.3. Completion Audit The RAP completion audit, which completes both the internal and external monitoring processes of the project, will provide the final indication that livelihood restoration is sustainable, and no further interventions are required. Both internal and external monitoring will end with RAP Completion Audit. The RAP will be considered complete when the negative impacts of land acquisition are dealt with in a manner consistent with the national legislation and international standards. BOTAŞ will assign a third- party independent auditor for the Resettlement Action Plan to assess whether the provisions of the international standards and relevant plan have been met. BOTAŞ representatives and Consultant’s staff will support the preparation of the RAP Completion Audit. The timing and table of content of this audit will be agreed between BOTAŞ and WB; however, it is now proposed that External RAP Completion Audit can be undertaken one year after the completion of construction as planned in 2024. As stated in the RPF, the External RAP Completion Audit is a separate document from the RAP Completion Report. The latter will be conducted by the ESIA and RAP Monitoring Consultant to summarize all resettlement activities undertaken and completed in the Project. 86 Once the mitigation measures have been substantially completed and sufficient opportunities and assistance are provided for economically displaced persons to recover their livelihoods in a sustainable manner, a completion audit will be carried out after an agreed monitoring period. Completion audit will include a comparison of the results of the implementation with the agreed purposes and an assessment of whether the monitoring process to be terminated. Completion of the corrective actions identified in the completion audit will end the responsibility of BOTAŞ for the compensation, restoration of livelihoods and development assistance. 12.2. Monitoring Schedule As set forth above, internal and external monitoring of RAP Implementation activities of GSEP will be carried out periodically and end up with completion studies. It is planned RAP monitoring process of the Project to be started in parallel to the commencement of civil works (2019) and to be ended up via Completion Audit one year later (2024 estimated) at latest after the completion of construction (2023). Internal monitoing will be carried out semi-annually and the first report will be prepared by the end of 2019 while external monitoring report will be undertaken annually. Both will continue until the end of construction phase of the Project. Considering this, the planned RAP monitoring schedule is given below: Types of 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Monitoring Reports Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Preparation of RAP Monitoring Plan Internal Monitoring Reports RAP Completion Report External Monitoring Reports External RAP Completion Audit 87 13. BUDGET The detailed budget table in this section shows the actual costs for all resettlement activities, including the development, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the RAP. In addition to a breakdown of the total costs of the RAP, expenditures and funding sources are also presented in the table. Tablo 13-1 Estimated Budget for RAP Implementation No Budget Items Estimated Total Budget Resource 1 Land Acquisition * 2.500.000 USD 1.1. expropriation and easement rights** 2.000.000 USD 1.2. crop payments on private lands to land users** 250.000 USD 1.3. administrative cost 250.000 USD 2 RAP Fund (100,000 USD per year)*** 500.000 USD 3 RAP Monitoring 750.000 USD BOTAŞ 3.1. RAP Preparation 50.000 USD 3.2. Internal Monitoring 250.000 USD 3.3. External Monitoring 450.000 USD Administrative Cost 4 (for publication, translation etc.) 25.000 USD 5 Contingency**** (3%) 382.500 USD TOTAL 4.157.500 USD * This budget item was determined by considering valuation of assets completed; however, it doesn’t include other components of the Project which have not been determined and related assets have not been evaluated, yet. For details, see Appendix 6. ** The number of private parcels affected by the land acquisition process is 810 (993 in total). Total number of landowners and land users on these affected private parcels are 2366 and 560, respectively. (For more information, please refer to Tables 1.1, 1.3, 1.5, 1.7 and 1.8) *** As stated in RPF, 100,000 USD for a year was reserved for RAP Fund and it will be revised annually. Considering that construction phase of the Project is planned to be completed in 2023, total RAP Fund was calculated for the following 5 years of RAP Implementation. RAP Fund items is given in detail in the following table and details of RAP Fund items, targeted PAPs and its implementation are given under Appendix 7 of this RAP **** Contingency is calculated by excluding the total budget for land acquisition. The total cost allocated for the development and implementation of RAP Fund includes the following items: Tablo 13-2 RAP Fund Items No Items Unit A Temporary Economic Losses 1 Crop payment for unviable land Individual 2 Crop payment to Informal Land Users on Public Land Individual 3 Payment in relation with misidentification of the actual land user (crop owner) Individual 4 Transportation Costs where consent agreement is reached Individual 5 Payments regarding the common lands used for grazing Community 6 Payments for seasonal income losses Individual 7 Payments to land owner regarding land consolidation Individual 8 Additional Compensation payment to land users affected by cumulative impacts Individual 88 Other Livelihood Assistances (provision of assets on farming or animal husbandry and special Individual 9 assistance, if needed) for vulnerable people B Permanent Economic Losses 1 Crop payment to Informal Land Users on Public Lands Individual 2 Real estate transaction tax Individual 3 Livelihood Restoration/Enhancement Supports Both Transitional Livelihood Support for contractor farmers and land users who lost majority of their Individual 3.1. lands (more than 20%) 3.2. Other Livelihood Assistances (compensation for income loss) for contractor farmers Individual Other Livelihood Assistances (provision of assets on farming or animal husbandry and special Individual 3.3. assistance, if needed) for vulnerable people Other Livelihood Assistances (cash assistance for restoring common loss and improving living Community 3.4. standards) for communities 89 14. REFERENCES Ahiler Kalkınma Ajansı, 2013. TR71 Bölgesi İlçeleri Sosyo-Ekonomik Gelişmişlik Analizi. Ankara Kalkınma Ajansı, 2017. İstatistiklerle Ankara. The Equator Principles, June 2013. A financial industry benchmark for determining, assessing and managing environmental and social risk in projects. International Finance Corporation, 2002. Handbook for Preparing a Resettlement Action Plan. Washington, DC. International Finance Corporation, 2012. International Finance Corporation’s Guidance Notes: Performance Standards on Environmental and Social Sustainability. Washington, DC. International Finance Corporation, 2012. “Performance Standard 5: Land Acquisition and Involuntary Resettlement” in: IFC Performance Standards on Environmental and Social Sustainability, pp. 36-41. Washington, DC. Mevlâna Kalkınma Ajansı, 2014. Emirgazi İlçe Raporu. The World Bank, 2004. Involuntary Resettlement Sourcebook. Planning and Implementation in Development Projects. Washington, DC. The World Bank, 2013. Operational Manual OP 4.12 - Involuntary Resettlement. Washington, DC. 90 15. APPENDICES Appendix 1. Socio-Economic Household Survey Questionnaire GAS STORAGE EXPANSION PROJECT SOCIAL-ECONOMIC SURVEY REGARDING AFFECTED LAND OWNERS AND USERS SURVEY EXPLANATION Gas Storage Expansion Project belongs to BOTAŞ (Petroleum Pipeline Company). This project will be conducted within the borders of Sultanhanı, Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Eskil and central districts of Aksaray province and also Emirgazi district of Konya and Evren district of Ankara in Central Anatolia Region. Locations to be affected by the project consist of agricultural lands and pasture areas in general. Affected lands will be expropriated permanently or temporarily according to the needs of the project components. This interview is conducted to collect information about the settlements affected by the project, to record the feedbacks provided by the residents regarding the project and to draw up New Settlement Action Plan. Information to be provide will help to understand the area where the project is conducted and contribute to the decision-making processes. The information to be provided by you shall be used in only this project, and your name and all information you will share with us shall be kept confidential. This survey takes approximately one hour. Thank for your participation and sparing your time. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SURVEYOR This survey shall be applied on land owner (or someone from landowner home who can give information) or the person who is not land owner but uses the land. Land registration number, the list of land owners and drawing of the land have been submitted to you. If the person whom you meet is not land owner, does not know the land owner or does not use the land, please explicitly state this in the interview form, thank this person and then end the interview. While recording the answers, please write every number as it is. All questions must be answered; if it is not answered, it must be marked fit to this situation. For questions with the statement “More than one answer can be given.”, more than one answer is allowable. In case that the person whom the interview is conducted refuses to answer the question, this situation must be stated with its reason. 91 SURVEYOR INFORMATION SURVEY NO: SURVEYOR: DATE: PROVINCE: DISTRICT: VILLAGE/QUARTER: PRELIMINARY INFORMATION FORM FOR THE LAND (The person conducting the interview shall fill this section together with the survey supervisor. To fill this section, data of parcel database and also information obtained from interviewed land owner or the user of the land shall be used.) Province District Village / Quarter / Location Total Area of Parcel Name of Parcel Owner Parcel Rate Number of Parcel Owners Number of Female Owners Name of Parcel User (If available) Is the parcel user one of the owner of the If it is ………. parcel? If it is not …………. Quality of the land ( available for irrigated farming, available for dry farming, vineyard/orchard, pasture etc.) Is the parcel mortgaged? Yes ( ) No ( ) Is the parcel subjected to the land consolidation Yes ( ) No ( ) 92 INFORMATION ABOUT THE PERSON ANSWERING THE SURVEY Name-Surname of the I accept the survey to be Person Answering the conducted. Survey Signature Gender (1) Male ………. (2) Female ………… Date of Birth Phone Number the Person Answering the Survey (……….) 1 The interview was carried out with the owner (whose name written above) of the land affected by the project. (……….) 2 The interview was carried out with one of close family members. The interview was carried out with the land user who paid for the land. (……….) 3 How many years has the land been used? …………………… The interview was carried out with the land user who did not pay for the land. (……….) 4 How many years has the land been used? …………………… (1) Permanently (2) Periodically Province-District of Residence ............................. Residence Situation: 03 Rarely Province-District of Residence ............................. (only during Eid, etc. ) (4) Not reside here Province-District of Residence ............................. If the survey was rejected or the interview was not completed, please write below the reason. 93 A. HOUSEHOLD INFORMATION A1. A2. Can you write the A3. Degree of A4. A5. A6. A7. Educational A8. Student if A9. Educational A10. Work status? A11. Social A12. Disability persons living in your kinship with Status (Persons aged available status (Primary Security Status Status RANK home? the person Gender Age? Marital 4 and older, school, secondary (MORE THAN ONE OPTION CAN BE whom the Status? individuals except school, high MARKED. IF IT IS NOT PROPER TO YOU NO interview is students) school), (for PLEASE PUT HYPHEN (-) conducted? persons aged 4 and older) ( For persons aged 15 and older) NO (HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS (Please write 01 MARRIED 01 NOT LITERATE STUDENTSHIP 01 NORMAL 01 FARMER 01 NOT 01 NOT who generally live at current age) 02 LITERATE STATUS 02 CRAFTSMAN/MERCHANT/SELF- PRESENT DISABLED home but have not been 02 SINGLE 03 LEFT PRIMARY 10 PRESCHOOL 02 MOBILE EMPLOYED present at home for a SCHOOL 11 PRIMARY 03 BOARDING 03 OFFICER 02 SOCIAL 02 PHYSICALLY while shall be included.) 03 WIDOW GRADUATION SCHOOL (REGIONAL 04 WORKER SECURITY DISABLED 04 PRIMARY SCHOOL 12 SECONDAY BOARDING 05 DAILY/SEASONAL WORKER İŞÇİ INSTITUTION 04 DIVORCED 05 SECONDAY SCHOOL SCHOOL) (BUILDING, AGRICULTURE, ETC) 03 GENERAL 03 MENTALLY SCHOOL 13 HIGH SCHOOL 04 BOARDING 06 HOUSEWIFE HEALTH DISABLED 05 UNDER 18 (HOME/RELATIVES) INSURANCE 06 VOCATIONAL HIGH 14 COLLEGE / YEARS OLD 05 NOT GO TO THE 07 RETIRED 04 GREEN 04 CHRONIC SCHOOL UNIVERSITY 07 HIGH SCHOOL 15 OTHER SCHOOL 08 STUDENT CARD PATIENT, HAS 08 COLLEGE 09 UNEMPLOYED 05 PRIVATE HEALTH 09 UNIVERSITY 16 NOT STUDENT 10 OLD AGE/DISABILITY PENSION INSURANCE PROBLEMS 10 I DO NOT KNOW. 11 OTHER……………. 06 OTHER... 05 AGED 11 NOT VALID PERSON IN NEED OF CARE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 A.13. TOTAL number of person= 94 B. HOME AND INFRASTRUCTURE 1. Does your home belong to you? 01 Yes, it belongs to us only 02 It is shared but we use it 03 No, it belongs to our close relatives and we live there without paying rent 04 No, we are lessee (How much money are they paying?) 05 Other…………… 2. How long have you been living in this village/quarter? (On yearly basis) 01 We have been living here always 02……………………………..year 03 We came here from ................................... 3. Do you live in this village/quarter during the year? 01 Yes 02 No If no, how many months do you live here?...................Month(s) 4. How many square meter (m2) is your home?: ……………………m2 5. How many rooms are there in your house have? (Including saloon, excluding kitchen, bathroom) ........................... Room(s) 6. What is the source of potable water in the house? 01 City water supply 02 Water reservoir 03 Well water 04 Spring water 05 Artesian water, water pump 06 Other ………………….. 7. Is potable water source adequate? If it is not, why not? 01 Yes 02 No, because …………………….. 8. Where is the toilet in your home? 01 Within the house 95 02 Out of the house 03 Both within the house and out of the house 04 There is no toilet. 9. What kind of energy source do you use to get warmer? (Sort it according to the commonly used.) 01 Wood 02 Coal 03 Electricity 04 bottled gas 05 Cow dung 06 Other ………….. 10. Do you have any other house and/or shop except the home where you currently live/use? ( If not, cross the 13th question.) 01. Yes – house Its location ……………………………………….. 02. Yes – shop Its location ………………………………………… 03. No 11. For what purpose is you use your other property (house-shop) used? 01 Permanently (Using it by herself/himself) 02 Investment (Leasing it) 03 Summer or winter house (Using it by herself/himself) 04 Other……………………………. 12. If you build a house similar to your current house, how much will it cost? ……..……. TL …………... I do not know. 13. What is the primary source that you apply to get information about national and local issues? (The answerer is allowed to mark maximum 3 Television 01 options.) Radio 02 Gazette 03 Internet / Social Media 04 96 Family / Friends / Relatives 05 Mukhtar 06 Imam 07 School 08 Other, please state 98 C. ANIMAL HUSBANDRY 14. Do you have an animal? 01 Yes 02 No (If he/she does not have any animal, cross the following D section.) 15. Which animal(s) do you feed? How many are they? Animal Number Bovine animal (Calf, veal, bullock, cow, water buffalo, all included) Ovine animals (Sheep, goat) Bee (Number of bee hives) Barnyard fowl (Chicken, Available Unavailable turkey, goose) 16. Do you have any barn? 01 Yes ………… (if yes, ………… m2) 02 No 17. Where do you feed your animals during the year generally? (More than one answer can be given.) Please mark In which periods In the barn near the home ( ) ( ) In the village pasture ( ) ( ) In public land ( ) ( ) In the pasture land belonging to legal entity of the village ( ) ( ) In the forest land ( ) ( ) In special agriculture land after the harvest ( ) ( ) 97 Mixed feed ( ) ( ) Other ( ) ( ) D. AGRICULTURE 18. Do you state your land property? (Property which you have shared or allodial certificate of ownership) Kind Current decare If available, decare purchased/expropriated by other (If there is no land, write zero 0) project(s) (Write the name/names of the project(s)) ………………………………. 1.Vineyard 2. Garden 3.Farm Dry (Decare): Dry (Decare): Irrigated (Decare): Irrigated (Decare): Total (Decare): Total (Decare): 4.Orchard 5.Wood land (Poplar, etc.) 6.Other 7. Total 8. Do not have any land property 19. Do you have any other land where you do not have certificate of ownership but use? (If not, please write 0.) 98 Current dry Current Current total If available, decare land irrigated land land (Decare) purchased/expropriated by other (Decare) (Decare) project(s) (Write the name/names of the project(s)) ................................................ ................................................ Dry Irrigated Total (Decare) (Decare) (Decare) Public land Leased Belonging to another (neighbor- relative, etc.) Total 20. How do you use your land? (More than one answer can be given.) 01 We plant it 02 It is empty 03 We lease it (If it is, name of the tenant ………………………………………..) 04 We are performing share cropping (If it is, name of the share cropper.………………………………………) 05 We are performing animal husbandry feed animals 06 We left the land, we do not know what happened to it 07 We provided it to be planted by casual workers, we buy the product (If he/she states casual worker option, ask and record where are these workers coming from and how many workers are they employing averagely.) 08 Other (State……………………………………..) 21. What is your irrigation source? 01 Well, ………………… quantity 02 River/Brook/Stream/Pool 03 Irrigation channel 04 City water 05 Other (State………………………………..) 22. The source that you use to irrigate is adequate, what do you think? 01 Yes 02 No 23. If there is a tree on the land, please state the kind of this tree and the number of all trees in the land. Kind of Tree How many trees are there on If available, how many were there in land the current land? (If there is no purchased/expropriated by other project(s) none, write 0) (Write the name/names of the project(s)) (If there is no tree, write 0) 99 Citrus fruits (lemon, mandarin, orange) Sour cherry Apricot Pear Cherry Wild pear tree Turpentine tree Quince Plum Walnut Apple Oak Linden Poplar Pine Cedar/ ladin or other forest trees Fig Olive Chestnut Peach Vineyard Other fruits Other 24. Which agricultural products do you plant on the land? Product name Is it present on the current If available, how many were there in land land? Yes or No (If there is no purchased/expropriated by other project(s) none, write 0) (Write the name/names of the project(s)) Yes or No (If there is no tree, write 0) Wheat Barley Sugar beet Bean Chickpea Rice Hazelnut Pistachio Melon/watermelon Tomato Corn Sunflower Trefoil Fig 100 sainfoin Other (Please write on below lines.) 25. How many times do you plant your land in a year? If available, I plant land I plant current land purchased/expropriated by other project(s) ……….. times …………. times 26. Do you fallow your land? If available, I fallow land I fallow current land purchased/expropriated by other project(s) Yes No Yes No 27. Are you a member of any cooperative? (1) Yes ………. (2) No ………. Please write its name ………. 28. Do you or anyone of your family have one of wares written below? Wares of Family Quantity (If not available, put 0) (1) Automobile (2) Truck (3) Minibus (4) Tractor (5) Combine Harvester (6) Bus (7).... E. EXPENSES 29. How much money did you spent to get warmer on 2017 (wood, coal, natural gas etc.) ………. TL 101 ……….. I do not know. 30. How much money did you spent for bottled gas on previous month (January 2018)? ………. TL ……….. I do not know. 31. State how much money you have paid for your last electric bill. If the answers are like 3-6 months period, the person conducting the interview, please state this…. ………. TL ………. I do not know. 32. State how much money you paid for your last water bill. If the answers are like 3-6 months period, the person conducting the interview please state this…. ………. TL ………. I do not know. 33. How much money did you pay for the kitchen expenses at previous month (for food & beverage)? ………. TL ………. I do not know. 34. How much money did you pay for the monopoly products at previous month? ………. TL 35. What is average cost per decare for a land which is close to your affected land and irrigable? (Water, electricity, fertilizer, machine rent payment, diesel, daily wage etc.) ………. TL ……….. I do not know. 36. What is average cost per decare for a land which is close to your affected land and fed with rain water? (Fertilizer, machine rent payment, diesel, daily wage etc.) ……….. TL ……….. I do not know. 37. How much money did you spent for your animals (Veterinary/ feed/barn improvement etc.)? ……….. TL (if they have no animal, write “0”) ………… I do not know. 38. How much money did you spent for clothes/transportation/health/etc.? 102 ……….. TL ………… I do not know. 39. How much cash money did you spent on previous month? ………… TL ………… I do not know. 40. Did anyone from your family use credit which is still being repaid? 01 Yes 02 No 03 I do not know. 41. If yes, what kind of credit did he/she use? State the credit amount. 01 Consumer ……………………………………….. 02 House …………………………………………… 03 Agriculture …………………………………………… 04 Artisan …………………………………………… 05 Other……………………………………………. F. INCOMES 42. What kind of incomes does your family have? What are the house incomes?(If possible please write the amount.) Income Sources Yes 01 No 00 1. income of paid employment (employee) 2.Income of salaried employment (officer) 3.Income of artisan/craftsman/trade 4. Retirees 6.Periodic/seasonal workers 7.Sent by children/relatives 8. Agricultural income (Field crops) 9.Agricultural income (fruit growing, vineyard cultivation, etc.) 10.Animal husbandry income (animal sale) 11.Animal production (Egg, milk, cheese, etc.) 12.Rental income (House, parcel of land, shop, land) 13.( )Widow /( )Orphan /( )Disability /( ) Old-age Pension 14. Unemployment pay 15.Working Program for Benefit of Society 16.Other (State……………………………………………………..………….) 43. Do you sell animal? 01 Yes 103 02 No 44. Can you write the number of animals and the animal products that you have sold in a year? (If there is no sale, write 0) (If possible, write monetary amount.) Animal Kind The number of animals Animal products sale that have been sold in a year 01 Yes 00 No 1.Sheep 2.Goat 3.Ram 4.Lamp 5.Calf 6.Veal 7.Cow 8.Bullock 9.Chicken 10.Horoz 11.Cock 12.Goose 13. Apiculture The amount of honey that has been sold in a year …………………. 14.Other…………………. 45. How much income can someone averagely gain from 1 decare of irrigable land annually (the amount after fertilizer, irrigation expenses are extracted)? Average income/decare ………. TL Minimum income amount ………. TL Maximum income amount ………. TL 46. How much money did you earn from animal sale or animal products sale in previous month? ……….. TL (If there is no sale, write zero “0”) ……….. I do not know. 47. How much money did you earn from animal sale or animal products sale on 2018? ……….. TL (If there is no sale, write zero “0”) ……….. I do not know. 104 48. How much money did you earn from all agricultural production in previous year (on your all land)? ……….. TL ………… I do not know. 49. How many of your animals are fed on the land where will be affected by the project? ………… (If none, write zero “0”) ………… I do not know. 50. Is your village close to the forest? a. Yes ……….. b. No ……….. (Cross the 52nd question.) 51. Please state/mark those given below regarding using of the forest. The person conducting the interview, please read all categories and put mark near the those for which the participant said yes. We collect the wood that we use to get warmer. We collect fungi/plant/spice etc. to use. We collect fungi/plant/spice etc. to sell. We work as paid worker in the forest. We pasture our animals. 52. If the village has money, in which field will the villagers invest to increase income obtained from the agriculture? What will their second option be? A............................................................................................................ B............................................................................................................ 53. If the village has money, in which field will the villagers invest to increase income obtained from animal husbandry? What will their second option be? A............................................................................................................ B............................................................................................................ G. SELF PERCEPTION 54. In which level do you meet basic requirements of your home? 01 Easy 02 Medium 03 Hard 04 Very hard 05 I do not know. 55. What do you think of your economic status compared to the previous year? 01 Same 02 Worse 03 Better 04 I do not know. 105 56. How do you consider your future 5 years? 01 It will be better 02 It will be worse 03 Nothing will change 04 Other……………………………………………… 57. Do you want your children to grow up or live in this village? Yes 01 No 02 57 -A- If “Yes”, why? (Please do not the options.) They must live 01 Its weather is clean 02 The people are helpful 03 Everyone knows each other 04 This region will develop 05 Other, please state 06 57 -B-If “No”, why? (Please do not the options.) No work 01 Opportunities are limited (education…, etc.) 02 I do not want my children to become villager. 03 Other, please state 98 H. THE MOST IMPORTANT PROBLES OF RESIDENCES 58. What are the most important problems of the village/quarter, what do you think? (If there is no problem, cross the other question.) Problems (more than one option can be Order of Priority (1 start with the most selected.) important one) 01 Unemployment 02 Economy (financial difficulty, low income) 03 Poverty 04 Deficient/inadequate infrastructure(electric/canalization) 05 Irrigation 06 Access to the city 07 Access to the farm 08 Educational services 09 Health services 10 Communication (internet, mobile phone system) 11 Garbage 12 Social facilities (football field, vb.) 13 Inadequate harboring conditions/heating conditions 14 Unrest due to relatives and neighbors 15 Inadequacy of pasture/highland 16 Inadequacy of farms 17 Inadequate potable water infrastructure 99 other ................... İ. ENHANCING OF SOURCES OF LIVING 106 59. What are the issues which will be more useful to you in enhancing sources of living? (Maximum 5 options, starting with 1 according to the order of priority) Issues Priority 01 Bovine breeding 02 Ovine breeding 03 Apiculture (Bee hive and materials) 04 Animal husbandry inputs (Cheep feed, etc., veterinary services) 05 Animal facilities (barn building/modification) 06 Greenhouse cultivation 07 Field crops inputs (cheap seed, drug, fertilizer, etc.) 08 Irrigated farming 09 Fruit growing/Gardening 10 Fishery 11 Poultry breeding 12 Domestic economy supports 13 Cooperation (Type............................................................) 14 Vocational assistance courses (State....................................................) 15 Establishing a business (..................................................) 16 Other................................................................... 60. What kind of courses must be organized for women and young people? (Maximum 5 options, starting with 1 according to the order of importance) Issues Women Priority Young People Priority 01 Computer 02 Domestic Economy 03 Clothing, needlecraft 04 Agriculture 05 Animal husbandry 06 Apiculture 08 Foreign language 09 Vocational assistance courses (…………………….) 10 Other (…………………………………. ) J. INFORMATION ABOUT THE PROJECT 61. Do you know Salt Lake Natural Gas Storage Project? 107 (1) ……….. No, I do not know (2) ……….. Yes, I do–How did you know? /By whom was you informed? (Circle multiple answers)? 01 Family member 02 Mukhtar 03 Municipality 04 Visits, meetings of company representatives 05 Workers working in the firm 06 TV/Radio 07 Internet 08 Gazettes 09 Brochure 10 District Governorship /Governorate 11 From previous project 12 Other………………………………………………………………………………… 62. Did you or one of your family members attend in informing/public participation meetings? 01 Yes 02 No 03 I did not hear Participant ………………….. 63. What are the issues which you want to get information and find out in this project? 64. Has your land been purchased or expropriated for any other project or projects before? 01 ……….. Yes, it yes which project(s) and how many? 02 ………... No 65. Has any immovable property, which your family has purchased or used, been purchased or expropriated for any other project or projects before? 01 ………. Yes, if yes which property. 02 ……….. No 66. What do you want to learn about land achievement? (More than one answer can be given.) K. COMPLAINT MECHANISM 67. Whom will you inform when you want to get information about the project or have a complaint? 01 Company representatives 02 Mukhtar 03 Municipality 04 District Governorship /Governorate 05 I do not know 06 Other…………………………………………………………….. 108 68. Do you know contact channels such as phone number, responsible attendant, etc. which the project applies for complaint notification? 01 Yes 02 No 99 I do not know…………………………………………………… 69. Have you ever made a complaint regarding the project? 01 Yes 02 No 70. If you made a complaint, was it solved? 01 Yes 02 No 99 I do not know …………………………………………………… 71. What do you think of complaint system? 01 I was satisfied 02 I was not satisfied 03 My complaint has not been solved yet, I am not sure 04 I do not want to answer 05 I do not know L. APPROACH TO THE PROJECT 72. What is the biggest advantages/disadvantages of the project, what do you think? (Scale 1 to 5 according to the order of priority). 01 Contribution to the national economy 02 Contribution to district development 03 Development of village/quarter 04 Local employment 05 No beneficial/positive side 06 It was harmful 07 Other………………………………………………………… 73. What is the most negative effects of the project, what do you think? (Maximum 5 options, starting from 1 according to the order of priority). Issues Priority 01 Income sources decrease 02 The land gets harmed/becomes useless 03 Roads substantially get harmed 04 Products and trees on the land get harmed. 05 Pasture areas get harmed/decrease as they affect the houses economically 06 Animal husbandry activities (grazing land, etc.) get harmed 07 Transhumance activities get harmed 109 08 Infrastructure gets harmed 09 Sources of living are affected negatively 10 Dust occurs/increases 11 Noise occurs/increases 12 Traffic risk increases 13 Human, society and animal health are affected negatively 14 Other…………………………………………………………. 74. What can be done to decrease negative effects, what do you think? (Maximum 5 options, starting from 1 according to the order of priority). Issues Priority 1. Activities (agriculture-animal husbandry) providing income to come in the residential areas 2. Enhancing agricultural activities 3. Enhancing animal husbandry activities 4. Local employment 5. Opening vocational assistance courses 6. Opening social course (woman, child, young) 7. Fulfilling infrastructure deficiencies (electricity, canalization) 8. Fulfilling potable water deficiencies 9. Road building/recondition (village-village, village-city, quarter-quarter, quarter-district, etc.) 10. Building school, enhancing educational infrastructure 11. Enhancing health services, increasing health services 12. Building commonly uses social facilities (wedding salon, football area, etc.) 13. Other……………………………………………… 75. Has your village been provided any help within the project until this time? If yes, what were the most positive support and helps? 01 No help/support 02 I do not know 03 Support provided, these are,………………………………………………………………. 14 LOCAL EMPLOYMENT 76. Is there anyone who can work or want to work in the project at your home? 77. Is there anyone still working in the project at your home? 01 Yes………………………………..Person…………………... How long has she/he been working? (Month)………………………………… 02 No 78. Are there family members who have worked in the project during the last one year but now do not work and are unemployed now? 01 Yes………………………………..Person…………………... How long has she/he been working? (Month)………………………………… 02 No 110 79. Are there family members at your home who have achieved professional skill/certificate (for example, construction equipment operator, security guard, etc.) due to her/his employment in the project? 01 If yes Person Abilities/certificates achieved: 1. 2. 3. 4. 02 No 15 INFORMATION ABOUT THE COMMON LAND AFFECTED BY THE PROJECT 80. Do you know anything about common land affected by the project? 01 Yes 02 No 03 I do not know 81. How do you use village/quarter common lands (treasury, pasture, forestry, etc.) affected by the project? (More than one option can be marked.) 01 We pasture our animals together with other villagers 02 We plant it by ourselves 03 We collect meadow, grass 04 We use with the intend of highland 05 We turn them into wood 06 We collect products of trees (fruit tree, etc.) 07 We have a picnic 08 We use to congratulate each other’s Eid 09 We celebrate traditional Eid and festivals 10 Other………………………………………………………………. 11 We do not use 82. Is there any tree, which can provide income and you use on the land affected by the project? 02 No 01 If yes Tree Kind Number 03 I do not know 111 83. Is there any outbuilding (shed, well, wall, tandoori, barn, etc.) which you use on the land affected by the project? 01 No 02 If yes Outbuilding Quantity Area(m2) Certificate of ownership status Available (….) Unavailable (…) Available (….) Unavailable (…) Available (….) Unavailable (…) Available (….) Unavailable (…) 03 I do not know 84. Do common lands affected by the project contribute to the house incomes? How? If available, what is its estimated annual income? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………TL 85. How do you use other common land not affected by the project? 01 We pasture our animals together with other villagers 02 We plant it by ourselves 03 We collect meadow, grass 04 We use with the intend of highland 05 We turn them into wood 06 We collect products of trees (fruit tree, etc.) 07 Other………………………………………………………………. 08 We do not use 86. Is other common land not affected by the project adequate for your activities (animal husbandry, agriculture, etc.)? If not, why? 01 Yes, it is 02 No it is not, because …………………………. 87. What are the biggest changes (positive/negative) that may occur in your status regarding common lands will be affected by the project? 16 RECOMMENDATIONS AND THOUGHTS Do you want to say or add anything about this project and/or research? Thank you; End of the Survey 112 Appendix 2. Settlement Level- Mukhtar Surveys GAS STORAGE EXPANSION PROJECT MUKHTAR SURVEY REGARDING AFFECTED RESIDENTIAL AREA SURVEY EXPLANATION Natural Gas Underground Storage Project belongs to BOTAŞ (Petroleum Pipeline Company). This project will be conducted within the borders of Sultanhanı, Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Eskil and central districts of Aksaray province and also Emirgazi district of Konya and Evren district of Ankara in Central Anatolia Region. Locations to be affected by the project consist of agricultural lands and pasture areas in general. Affected lands will be expropriated permanently or temporarily according to the needs of the project components. This interview is conducted to collect information about the settlements affected by the project, to record the feedbacks provided by the residents regarding the project and to draw up New Settlement Action Plan. Information to be provide will help to understand the area where the project is conducted and contribute to the decision-making processes. The information to be provided by you shall be used in only this project, and your name and all information you will share with us shall be kept confidential. This survey takes approximately one hour. Thank for your participation and sparing your time. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SURVEYOR This survey shall be applied on mukhtar of residential area. If the person whom you meet is not mukhtar or mukhtar member, please explicitly state this in the interview form, thank this person and then end the interview. While recording the answers, please write every information as they are. All questions must be answered; if it is not answered, it must be marked fit to this situation. For questions with the statement “More than one answer can be given.”, more than one answer is allowable. In case that the person whom the interview is conducted refuses to answer the question, this situation must be stated with its reason. Name of Surveyor Survey No: Date: 113 Province District Village/Quarter Name of Mukhtar I agree the survey to be conducted. Signature Contact Information of Mukhtar 114 DEMOGRAPHY A.1. How many houses are there in the village (living there for 12 months)? A.2. How many people are living in the village (living there for 12 months)? A.3. How many houses are there in the village during summer/winter? 01 Winter ……………….. 02 Summer ……………….. A.4. How is distribution of population in the village? 01 Aged population (Above 65 years) ………………….….. person 02 Workable population (16-65) ………..…..…… person 03 Child (0-16) ……………………. person A.5. How many people who may work in this project or expect to work in this kind of project are there in the village approximately? MAN WOMAN TOTAL A.6. Have people ever immigrated in this village? 01 If yes, how many immigrated land owners are there (such as half, many, 10 houses) 02 Why did they go? ……………… 03 In which years the immigration occurred mainly? 04 No 05 Very few people have immigrated A.7. What are the provinces and districts where people have immigrated?(They shall be written by being sorted according to peak immigration data.) 01 02 03 115 04 A.8. If people have immigrated, what are the reasons of this immigration? A.9. Is the immigration still continuing? 01 Yes 02 No, the population is stable 03 The population is increasing (explain) …………… A.10. Do people migrate into this village? 01 Yes 02 If yes, where are people immigration from and why, when and how many? 03 No A.11. How many houses in which house members gain retirement pension are there in the village? Including the source of retirement pension. Social Security Social Security State Retirement Social Organization for Organization for Fund Insurance Artisans and the Artisans and the Institution Self-Employed Self-Employed- Farmer Number of Houses A.12. Does temporary/seasonal agricultural worker or forest worker work in the village? 01 If, Yes …………… their qualifications and numbers …………….. 02 No …………. A. SENSITIVE GROUPS B.1. How many very poor people or houses in need of helps of others are there in the village? Person ……………. House ……………. B.2. How many physically/mentally disabled people are there in the village and how many houses are they living? 116 …………….. Person ……………. House B.3. How many houses or people, who do not have any land but use lands of other people (by paying rent or without rent payment), are there in the village? Person …………….. House ……………….. If available, names and contact information of these persons: B.4. How many houses or people using public lands are there in the village? Person …………………… House If available, names and contact information of these persons: B.5. How many old people, who are older than 65 years old, living alone and in need of care, are there in the village? Female ……………… Male ………………. B.6. How many widows are there in the village? Female …………….. Male ………………. B.7. How many people or houses receiving in-kind/financial aid from General Directorate of Social Assistance are there in the village? Person …………….. House ……………….. B.8. Are there people whose lands are affected by previous project of BOTAŞ (Petroleum Pipeline Corporation) in the village? Are the lands of these people affected by current project? If yes, what are their names? B.9. Are there people whose lands are affected by other infrastructure or investment projects (highway, railway, petroleum or natural gas pipelines) carried out in the region, in the village? Are the lands of these people affected by current project? If yes, what are their names? B. EDUCATION C.1. Is there a school in the village? (Write the schools.) 01 If yes, is it open? 117 Yes ……….. No…………. What is total student number? ……………………. 02 No C.2. In how many houses are there children who go to school out of the village every day? How many children are using mobile teaching in the village? Where are they receiving education (in which quarter, district, village…)? C.3. How many houses are sending their children to the boarding school? If there are children going to the boarding school, how many are they? What are these schools and where are they? C. HEALTH D.1. Is there any health center in the village? 01 Yes, if yes If yes; Does doctor or/and other health personnel come to you village regularly? how often? 02 No If no, how many kilometer is the nearest health center/hospital far away? D.2. Is there anybody with private health problems in the residential area? 01 If yes how many are they? 02 No D. ECONOMY E.1. What are basic economic activities of the village? Please sort them according to the order of importance; Economic Activity Order of Importance (1 is the most şmortant) Agriculture Animal Husbandry Forestry Sessional worker (construction, etc.) 118 Retirement Official service Workmanship Other E.2. Which products are planted in your village? Product Name Yes or No If there is no one write 0 Wheat Barley Sugar beet Bean Chickpea Rice Hazelnut Pistachio Melon/watermelon Tomato Corn Sunflower Trefoil Fig sainfoin Other (Please write on below lines.) E.3. State five basic products planted in the village (According to the order of importance): 1 ……………………………… 2 ……………………………… 3 ……………………………… 4 ……………………………… 5 ……………………………… E.4. (Used for first basic product) what is the harvest of land with 1 decare?………………..… /decare 119 (Used for second basic product) what is the harvest of land with 1 decare?…………….………..… / decare (Used for third basic product) what is the harvest of land with 1 decare?…………………..… / decare ((Used for fourth basic product) what is the harvest of land with 1 decare?……………. / decare (Used for fifth basic product) what is the harvest of land with 1 decare?………………… / decare E.5. What percentage of cultivated land is irrigated? E.6.Is there any official irrigation union(cooperative? If yes, what is its name, year of establishment, number of members? E.7. How many houses are performing irrigated farming? E.8. What percentage of lands fit to irrigated farming is irrigated? E.9. What are the sources that the houses use when irrigating? 1. Well Its number ? 2. Irrigation channel How many people are using ? 3. Lake/river How many people are using ? 4. Other……………. E. FOREST F.1. How do you benefit from the forest? For what purpose are villagers using this land? (For example, wood, forest products, collecting and selling fungi, etc.) F.2. Are there people using the lands which will be used as forest land by the project, in the village? How are they using them? F.3.Is there any person working as forest worker in the village/quarter? If yes, how many? F.4.Is there any forestry cooperative? If yes what is its name? 120 F. ANIMAL HUSBANDRY G.1. How many bovine animals in total are there in the village? How many houses are performing bovine animal husbandry? G.2. How many animals does the house with maximum bovine animals in the village have? G.3. How many animals does the house with minimum bovine animals in the village have? G.4. How many ovine animals in total are there in the village? How many houses are performing ovine animal husbandry? G.5. How many houses in the village are performing poultry animals with commercial purpose? G.6. How many houses in the village are performing apiculture business with commercial purpose? G.7.How many decare are pasture land in the village? G.8.Do you have any pasture land affected by the project? If yes, how many decare of the land are affected? G.9. If it is affected, are there other lands around which may be used as pasture? G.10. What are the types and size of other lands belonging to the village? Are these lands affected by the project? How and how much of them? G. TRADE H.1.What is main agricultural product which is marketed as commercial product? What are their total amount in annual basis? Where and how is marketed this product? H.2. What percentage of houses in the village is performing agricultural or animal production with the intend of subsistence farming, in other words, with the intend of consumption by the house (not for marketing), what do you think? H.3. Is there any grocer/market/store/bazaar in the village? 121 H. INSFRACTURE İ.1. Please give information about the infrastructure of the village. For example, is there any central canalization system in the village? İ.2.Is the electricity provided regularly or the electricity is cut frequently? İ.3.Is there good quality of potable water? If not, what can be done to fix this situation? İ.4. Do internet and phone lines work in the village? İ.5. How many days in a year are village roads are closed? İ.6. What are main problems in the village, what do you think? Please sort them starting from the most important one. İ.7.What can 3 things, which will especially may make the life easier in this village, be? 1 ……………….. 2 ………………... 3 ………………… İ. CADASTRE J.1.Were cadaster and land registry works completed in the village? J.2. Has any complaint been made regarding cadaster and land registry works? (Wrong measure, land registry on wrong person, missing writing, etc.) J.3.What do you think about land consolidation? What kinds of advantages/disadvantages can land consolidation bring to you and local people? J. LAND K.2.What is average sale price of irrigatable land with 1 decare in good condition (in other words, accessible, without slope, qualified agriculture land)? 122 K.3.What is renting price for irrigated land with 1 decare in good condition? K.4.What is average sale price of dry land with 1 decare in good condition (in other words, accessible, without slope, qualified agriculture land)? K.5.What is renting price for dry land with 1 decare in good condition? K.6.How many houses in the house dis purchase or sell land on 2018? Is land sale performed in the village? 01 The houses purchasing the land ………….. 02 The houses selling the land ………… K.7.Many land owners do not live in their villages anymore. What percentage of land owners in this village have already left the village? K.8. Who are using the lands whose owners do not perform farming business and how are they using these lands? K.9.Does legal entity of the village land affected by the project? 01 Yes ……….. 02 No (The person conducting the interview: if the answer is yes, please collect all details regarding the land.) K.11.Are there persons in position of share croppers, lessee, tenant farmer, etc. who use lands of other people? If yes, whose lands are in this position? K. INFORMATION FLOW L.1. What is your primary source that you Television 01 use to get information about national and Radio 02 local issues? Gazette 03 (The answerer is allowed to mark Internet 04 maximum 3 options.) Family / Friends / Relatives 05 Mukhtar 06 Imam 07 School 08 Other, please state 98 123 L. SELF PERCEPTION M.1. Do you want your children to grow Yes 01 up and live in this village? No 02 M.2. If “Yes”, why? (Please do not read the options.) Its weather is beautiful. 01 People are helpful. 02 Everyone knows each other. 03 This region will develop 04 Other, please state 05 M.3. If “No”, why? (Please do not read the There is no work 01 options.) Opportunities are limited (education…, etc.) 02 I do not want my children become villager 03 Other, please state 98 M.4. Are there very poor houses in the village? If yes, how many are they? What percentage of these houses can you consider as very poor? M.5. Are there rich houses in the village? If yes, how many are they? What percentage of these houses can you consider as rich? M. ENHANCING SOURCE OF LIVING AND COURSES N.1.What are the issues which will be useful in highest level for you in enhancing sources of living? (Maximum 5 options, starting from 1 according to the order of importance) Issues Priority 01 Bovine breeding 02 Ovine breeding 03 Apiculture (Bee hive and materials) 04 Animal husbandry inputs (Cheep feed, etc., veterinary services) 05 Animal facilities (barn building/modification) 06 Greenhouse cultivation 07 Field crops inputs (cheap seed, drug, fertilizer, etc.) 08 Irrigated farming 09 Fruit growing/Gardening 10 Fishery 11 Poultry breeding 124 12 Domestic economy supports 13 Cooperation (Type............................................................) 14 Vocational assistance courses (State....................................................) 15 Establishing a business (..................................................) 16 Other................................................................... N.2. Related to the question given above, are there people attempting regarding these issues in the village? Or is there this kind of attempt story in the past? Or is there anybody planning to attempt? N.3.Which kinds of courses must be organized for women and children? (Maximum 5 options, starting from 1 according to the order of importance) Issues Priority 01 Computer 02 Domestic Economy 03 Clothing, needlecraft 04 Agriculture 05 Animal husbandry 06 Apiculture 08Foreign language 09 Vocational assistance courses (Please explain …………………….) 10 Other (Please explain…………………………………. ) N. INFORMATION ABOUT THE PROJECT O.1.Do you know the project? If yes, how did you get this information? O.2.Did you attend in informing meetings? If the informing meeting was done, do you remember its date? 125 O.3.Are there other projects in your region or around? If yes, what are they? O.4.If there are, can you express your experiences regarding these projects? O.5.Do you have special question regarding Salt Lake Natural Gas Storage Project? If yes, what are these questions? What are the issues for which you want to learn? O.6.Have you ever had any complaint about the project? If yes, whom and how did you deliver your complaint? Was the complaint was concluded and how was it concluded? Do you know relevant expert of the project? O.7.What can you say about positive effects of this project? O.7.What can you say about negative effects of this project? O.8. What were like the social, economic and infrastructure situations of your village/quarter in 3 years ago compared to this moment? (better, good, bad, worse) O.9.What will the social, economic and infrastructure situations of your village/quarter be 3 years later, what do you think? (better, good, bad, worse) O.10.What do you add regarding the project? The interview is over; Thank you 126 Appendix 3. Stakeholder List National state institutions and organizations - Ministry of Environment and Urbanization - Ministry of Culture and Tourism - Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock - Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources Local state institutions and organizations - Governorships of Aksaray, Ankara and Konya - General Directorate of Land Registry and Cadastral of Aksaray, Ankara and Konya - District Governorships of Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Eskil and Central District of Aksaray - District Governorships of Emirgazi District of Konya Province and Evren District of Ankara Province - Municipalities of Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Eskil and Central District of Aksaray - Municipalities of Emirgazi District of Konya Province and Evren District of Ankara Province - Provincial Directorates of Environmental and Urbanization of Ankara, Konya and Aksaray Provinces - Provincial Directorates of Culture and Tourism of Ankara, Konya and Aksaray Provinces - Provincial Directorates of Food, Agriculture and Animal Husbandry of Ankara, Konya and Aksaray Provinces - Provincial Directorates of Public Health of Ankara, Konya and Aksaray Provinces PAPs including non-organized groups with particular areas of interest or that may be vulnerable (i.e., - Settlements; Besci Quarter, Bucak Plateau, Mağrul elderly, people with disabilities, ethnic minorities, Plateau, Bezirci Village (Güneşli quarter), Tömü etc.) Plateau, Enver Kara Plateau, Cülcülü Plateau, Gazi Quarter (Sultanhanı Town), Eminleryurdu Plateau, Büyükekşi Plateau, Bekmezci Plateau, Sapmaz village - Landowners in the project area - Common land users, both formal and informal, in the project area - Seasonal workers and herders Interest groups, such as universities and their foundations, cooperatives, local business - Aksaray University, Konya Selçuk University establishments, business associations, chambers of - Aksaray Chamber of Commerce and Industry commerce and others - No. 753 Aksaray Agricultural Credit Cooperative - No. 0845 Sultanhanı Agricultural Credit Cooperative - No. 1162 Eskil Agricultural Credit Cooperative - No. 1392 Sarıyahşi Agricultural Credit Cooperative - Association of Aksaray Livestock Cooperatives - Aksaray Civil Society Platform - Aksaray Social Assistance and Solidarity Foundation 127 Appendix 4. A Template of Grievance Form (Register and Close out Pages) Complaint Register Form should be shared in the project site and village head's office in order to collect written complaints from the locals. If the complaint is received via phone or verbally through meetings and visits to BOTAŞ (either in headquarters or site) grievance form must be filled by the BOTAŞ representative. If the complaint is received via mail or e-mail, grievance form can be filled by the BOTAŞ representative, or the e-mail print-out or mail can be attached to the close-out form. 128 BOTAŞ GAS STORAGE EXPANSION PROJECT ŞİKÂYET KAYIT FORMU / COMPLAINT REGISTER FORM Şikâyetin Alındığı Yer / Tarih / Loc on of Complaints Date Received Alan Yetkilisinin Adı / Şikâyet Kayıt No / Name of Person In charge Complaint Register Number Şikâyete Konu Alanın Koordinatları / Coordinates of the area subject to complaint Arazi parsel numarası (Şikâyet arazi konulu ise) / Land Parcel Number (If complaint is related to land) ŞİKÂYET SAHİBİ HAKKINDA BİLGİ / COMPLAINANT INFO Ad Soy ad / Şikâyetin Geliş Yolu / Name Surname Form of Complaint: TC Kimlik No/ Identification Number Telefon hattı/ Phone line Telefon / E-posta Telephone / E-mail Halk Toplantısı / Community meeting Köy- İlçe- İl / Village – District - Province Dilekçe / Petition ŞİKAYET DETAYLARI / DETAILS OF COMPLAINT Şikayet Konusu / Complaint 129 Şikayet sahibi tarafından talep edilen çözüm / Solution requested by the Complainant Şikâyeti Alan Yetkilinin Ad Soyad ve İmzası / Şikâyet Sahibinin Ad Soyad ve İmzası / Name Surname and Signature of the Registerer Name Surname and Signature of Complainant Grievance Close-out Form must be filled by BOTAŞ representative. ŞİKÂYET KAPATMA FORMU / GRIEVANCE CLOSE-OUT FORM 130 Haneye veya geçim kaynaklarına zarar / Damages to □ households or livelihoods Çevresel ve sosyal / Environmental and social □ ŞİKÂYETİN DEĞERLENDİRİLMESİ / ASSESSMENT OF THE GRIEVANCE Kamulaştırma / Expropriation □ İşe alım / Employment □ Diğer / Other □ Tazminat Gerekli mi? / Compensation Required: □YES □NO SONUÇ / RESULT KAPATMA / CLOSE OUT This part will be filled in and signed by the complainant and the company responsible when he/she receives the compensation or file is closed-out. (Instead of taking the signature of the complainant, bank receipt can be documented with the form) Yetkili / Responsible Şikâyet Sahibi / Complainant Adı Soyadı / Name-Surname Adı Soyadı / Name-Surname Tarih ve İmza / Date and Signature Tarih ve İmza / Date and Signature (If possible. Reasons of non-signing should be explained) 131 Appendix 5. Public Information Meeting 132 133 134 Appendix 6. Valuation Table A6.1. Unit Prices by Provinces for Crops Compensated Unit Price Province District Crop TL/m2 Ankara Evren Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Ağaçören Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Ağaçören Barley 0,49 Aksaray Eskil Alfalfa 0,83 Aksaray Merkez Melon 1,83 Aksaray Merkez Sugar Beet 1,47 Aksaray Merkez Maize 0,87 Aksaray Merkez Alfalfa 0,83 Aksaray Merkez Sunflower 0,73 Aksaray Merkez Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Merkez Barley 0,49 Aksaray Merkez Chickpea 0,44 Aksaray Ortaköy Sugar Beet 1,47 Aksaray Ortaköy Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Ortaköy Barley 0,49 Aksaray Ortaköy Chickpea 0,44 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Melon 1,83 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Sugar Beet 1,47 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Alfalfa 0,83 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Barley 0,49 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Chickpea 0,44 Aksaray Sarıyahşi Cumin 0,42 Aksaray Sultanhanı Sugar Beet 1,47 Aksaray Sultanhanı Maize 0,87 Aksaray Sultanhanı Alfalfa 0,83 Aksaray Sultanhanı Sunflower 0,73 Aksaray Sultanhanı Wheat 0,60 Aksaray Sultanhanı Barley 0,49 Aksaray Sultanhanı Chickpea 0,44 Konya Emirgazi Wheat 0,60 Konya Emirgazi Barley 0,49 Valuation Procedure Valuation is the process of identifying the value placed on an asset for the purpose of calculating compensation. This is often regulated by national legislation but sometimes needs to be aligned with WB OP 4.12.18 In acquiring affected immovable assets BOTAŞ will devote maximum effort to negotiate willing/buyer arrangements. BOTAŞ will adopt the valuation procedure that is compliant with both the 18 Operational Policy, OP 4.12-Involuntary Resettlement, December 2001. 135 Court’s valuation methodology (legal requirements) and with World Bank’s OP 4.12. By considering these two methodologies and standards, BOTAŞ ensures that the valuation results will comply with local procedures and international standards. Under the Turkish legal framework, a valuation commission consisting of a minimum of three persons internally appointed by the agency responsible for land acquisition determines the estimated value of the immovable property to be expropriated, having regard to the information and documents to be obtained from expert persons, institutions and authorities (such as Provincial Directorate for Food, Agriculture and Livestock), the Ministry of Science, Industry and Technology, where necessary, and from local real estate agencies as per Article 8 of the Expropriation Law. Number of commissions can be more than one. The valuation commission determines the estimated ceiling values of immovable properties in the expropriation area. During the valuation of immovable assets or resources, valuation commission (and the expert commission designated by the Court) has to take into account the following valuation criteria, which are mentioned in Article 11 of the Expropriation Law: i. The nature of the immovable property or resource ii. The size of the immovable property or resource iii. All the characteristics and elements, which could affect the value of the immovable property or resource, including the individual value of each element iv. Tax declaration, if any v. Previous values of property determined by official bodies at the date of expropriation vi. For lands, the net income that could be derived from the immovable property or resource (without undertaking any changes, using the immovable property or resource in the same conditions as of the expropriation date) vii. For house plots, the amount for which equal (similar) house plots have been sold without any special purpose, prior to the date of expropriation viii. For structures, official unit prices (annually issued by the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization) at the expropriation date, calculations of the cost of building, and depreciation for wear and tear, and ix. Any other objective criteria that could affect the value of the property or resource The legal framework protects the affected people in particular by ensuring that: i. No land will be used until compensation is paid ii. Compensation is paid to a national bank account, or a trust account to be paid in three monthly periods in the event of disputed ownership to be paid to the person proved the ownership iii. Market-based interest rates are charged for the value of the compensation if for any reason payment of compensation is deferred iv. All ownership is recognized, including customary and traditional ownership v. Costs of due process are borne by BOTAŞ, not by the affected people Value of compensation for easement right establishment corresponds to the decrease in the value of asset or resource stemming from this expropriation. The easement value (compensation) of the land includes income losses. This compensation is determined by expropriation experts of responsible organization. The Law requires that potential income that can be generated from the affected immovable assets is taken into consideration in the valuation process; however, the concept of “replacement cost” is not reflected and depreciation is taken into account. Therefore, BOTAŞ will explicitly allow for full replacement cost for buildings and will ensure that lost income is fully restored via the RAP Fund throughout the compensation process. For those vulnerable and with meager assets, additional 136 income restoration measures may be designed, including provision of employment in construction works. Calculations for Compensation Payments Appraisal for Expropriation: Appraisal can be defined as a branch of science that teaches principles and criteria regarding properties, incomes and rights, to be followed on the basis of scientific methods. The measures used for appraisal are called appraisal criteria. Appraisal criteria vary according to the type, purpose and marketing status of the property subject to appraisal. There are 2 criteria used for appraisal: i. Market price criterion ii. Income capitalization criterion Both criteria are jointly used for appraisal during expropriation and partial expropriation proceedings. The appraisal expert will use a direct comparison method and take account of the latest purchasing/sales prices of plots similar to that subject to appraisal. Factors affecting the value of a plot include: i. location ii. shape iii. physical structure of the soil iv. road frontage v. width of the road by the plot vi. restraining provisions of the city plan A price survey is done by keeping in mind all the criteria listed above. A site visit will be conducted by a committee and will determine the prices. Agricultural engineers, civil engineers and property experts shall be assigned every year to form the committee. Appraisal experts will evaluate the average price per square metre – to be calculated on the basis of purchasing/sales prices of similar plots- by taking account of all the positive and negative features affecting the value of the plot subject to appraisal. In addition to the land market price, the committee will take into account the crop on the land and compensates crop loss without seed expense. The formula used during valuation of the agricultural lands is K = R / f, where; K = value (expropriation compensation) R = net income (gross income-production costs) and f = the capitalization rate (risk related to the capital invested in agricultural land) After the market value is determined, additional fees for buying land will be considered and included before reaching the final replacement cost. Going forward, each land owner will be surveyed and assessed for severity of impact and vulnerability. If land owner states that he/she will be vulnerable / not be able to maintain income after land acquisition, additional measures will be taken in line with the entitlement matrix to help them restore their income. This could include finding replacement land if they are farmers and claim to need help to get comparable land or other measures to help restore lost income. A key factor determining land prices in small towns and city centers is their proximity to the city centre or a road. Land or land parcels close to the city center or a road are more expensive than the others. 137 In metropolitan areas, the value of a plot will be influenced by its location and, in particular its visibility and exposure to traffic. A plot situated at an intersection or featuring a broader angel of vision will be more valuable. Shape is also important, on the basis that well-shaped plots are more convenient for construction and soil characteristics will influence costs associated with preparing the land for foundations. Soil characteristics will also determine the need for the construction of an entrance floor and basement. Income Capitalization Criterion According to this criterion, the value of a property is calculated as the accumulation of the capitalization of net income or the total of average future incomes from that property up until the time of appraisal. Income capitalization criterion is often used for appraisal of agricultural lands. The most significant issue in conjunction with this criterion is the accurate determination of the yield of the land (net income) subject to appraisal and of the capitalization interest rate. Net income (yield) Net income is generally defined as the financial returns gained from the use of production items having a natural characteristic over a defined period of time. In other words, it is the revenue from a certain amount of money invested in works or rented lands over a defined period of time. During the calculation of net income from agricultural lands, production value is determined on the basis of the yield of cultivated crops per declare and unit price of the crop. Net income is calculated by deducting total expenses necessary for the production of that crop from the resulting production value. According to the existing rotational cultivation system applied in the land subject to appraisal; gross production value is calculated by multiplying crop output with the prices prevalent in the relevant year; net income is calculated by subtracting expenses associated with the product (annual operating expenses + 10% unknown expenses + 3% administration share + agricultural capital interest provision) from gross production value; annual net income is calculated by dividing the total net income by number of crops in the rotational cultivation system and the bare land value is calculated by capitalizing the net income (dividing by capitalization interest rate). Since expropriation proceedings are realized over each parcel, land yield is calculated instead of farm yield. In relation to annual plants, land expropriation value is calculated over annual yield, and over total periodical yield gained throughout their economic lives for perennial plants. i. The formula used for capitalizing the net income from annual plants is, So = s / f ii. The formula used for capitalizing perennial periodical fixed income is, Po = p / qn-1 The right to use unit capital invested in the land is called capitalization interest rate. In order to determine the actual land yield; data on crop output, unit prices and costs should be collected from the producers in the region and Official Institutions. This way, after the land prices and yields close to actual values are determined, average capitalization interest rate will be calculated by dividing land yields by land sales prices (the same number of yields and land sales prices). Since land value and capitalization interest rate are in inverse proportion, land value will increase as capitalization interest rate decreases, provided that yield is stable. According to the Decision of Court of Appeals 18th Civil Panel, of July 01, 1993 No: 1993/262-531, capitalization interest rate ranges from 3% to 15% nationwide. 138 Land capitalization interest rate is significantly lower than the interest rates of industrial and commercial investments due to the fact that land is more reliable in yielding long-lasting revenue. In order to determine a healthy, reliable and accurate capitalization interest rate, sales prices and yields of many lands should be known. The calculated capitalization interest rate is the average interest rate and the appraiser will decide on increases or decreases by taking account of the positive and negative effects on capitalization interest rate of the land. Positive aspects of the land will decrease the capitalization interest rate while negative aspects will increase the same. Factors positively affecting capitalization interest rate and therefore decreasing the interest rate are as follows: i. Proximity to a city or town ii. Proximity to access roads (land, railway, airport) iii. Favourable health conditions iv. Favourable transportation conditions v. Buildings (if any) in good condition vi. Undivided land vii. Geometrically well–shaped land viii. Property safety ix. Ease of purchasing and selling x. Safety of landowner xi. Land registered before the cadastral office xii. High population densities xiii. Easily changeable rotational cultivation system xiv. Favourable irrigation conditions if it is an irrigated land xv. Small surface area To ensure accurate calculations, appraisers firstly visit the expropriation area and in taking account of its current status of use, determine all the factors (soil structure, status of use, topography, climate, proximity to settlements and roads, favorable transportation conditions, location, current pattern of rotating plants in the region and whether or not irrigated and dry agricultural activities are carried out) that may affect the value of the relevant immovable property in accordance with Article 11 of the Expropriation Law. For long term easement, the plot price determination for compensation is 35% of value of the market price if the land were sold. This represents the top allowable price according to Turkish law and seems reasonable given the fact that applicable restrictions will not affect the dry land cultivation going on in these areas. There is no change in ownership and restrictions are removed when the use of the area ends. In order to ensure that valuation of assets is in compliance with OP 4.12, in addition to the Turkish legal requirements listed above, BOTAŞ will follow the Entitlement Matrix in Chapter 7 which details the entitlements that will be necessary for each type of loss that can be suffered by project affected persons. Valuation for Temporary Easement 139 As a basic principle for the indemnification of temporarily acquired land, the landowner shall be compensated for the restricted access and usage rights as well as the loss of productivity and income experienced during the period of limited or restricted land usage. The temporary usage rights are acquired during construction period. The offered compensation value offered constitutes 20% of the value determined for permanent land expropriation of equivalent land parcels. Hence, the land is evaluated according to the methodology described for permanent land evaluation and 20% ofthe final value is proffered to the landowner for the temporary acquisition. This level of compensation is consistent with current court decisions, which have been issued during the acquisition process for the easement rights for a natural gas pipeline in Turkey. i. The 20% compensation factor has been determined on the basis of the following: ii. Loss of long-term land productivity: 10% iii. Usage right during construction: 7% iv. Future Restrictions: 1% v. Loss of net income for two years: 2% (first year’s crop is paid upon land entry) The 20% factor does not include the additional evaluation and indemnification for assets and seasonal crops that are destroyed or damaged during each land entry in the process of opening the Construction Corridor, or for the performance of additional works after initial reinstatement and return of the land to the landowner. Methods of valuing crops/trees etc. Annual average net income of the land; will be the difference between the average gross production value calculated according to the alternation systems and the production costs excluding land rent. The average annual net income of the land is divided by the capitalization interest rate adjusted according to the properties of the parcel, and the bare value of the land is calculated. This value is added to the values of the complementary parts on the land, if any. The value of the crop, including the value of time needed to reproduce such a crop, and the replacement cost for any investment made (input, labour etc.) will be considered for all requiring crop compensation. On the lands to be acquired, if the crops identified in, it is recorded first indicating its type and status and then production value of crops and the crop loss is determined by a committee composed by BOTAŞ, headman of village (muhtar) and experts from Official agricultural Institutions. Payment for compensation is done in accordance with this assessment and valuation record. Owners/users will be compensated based on the market value of the crops on permanently and long- term easement acquired land. Valuation of trees are made according to the Junge method which considers the type/age of trees, rest of their economic lives, productivity, price, annual total income and coefficient according to income. Orchards and vineyards are not frequent, but individual fruit trees are more likely to come across on the affected lands. In such cases, the value found for the trees will need to be added to the bare value of the land. Payments for trees, vineyards, etc. are made based on a calculation of the expected income from these for the rest of their lives; with the recent changes, the Turkish law allows the payments to be made to both to the owners and users except in forest areas. As per international policies and the recent private sector practice in Turkey, people who have encroached to public and/or private land and planted trees and crops (or built immovable assets) are compensated for these assets (but not for the land). 140 The rental or easement payments are considered to compensate for the inability of affected people to plant for the duration of the lease period. When permission is obtained to enter land, either through willing buyer/seller arrangements or through the court process, there may be standing crops on land. Standing crops may also be damaged from construction activity on land which was not included in the land acquisition process. 141 Appendix 7. Asset Inventory List of Assets (Pipelines) HASAR NO. İL İLÇE KÖY/MAH ADA PARSEL CINSI KULLANICI _BABA ÜRÜN HİSSE ALAN 1 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 104 21 TARLA İLHAN GÖRGÜLÜ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 3159,16 2 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 1 TARLA MUTTALİP ÇELİK HASAN ARPA 1 924,51 3 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 2 TARLA İSRAFİL GÖRGÜLÜ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 351,1 4 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 3 TARLA HİKMET ALTUNTAŞ MEVLÜT ARPA 1 1684,09 5 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 4 TARLA MUTTALİP ÇELİK HASAN ARPA 1/2 3523,88 6 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 4 TARLA MÜSLÜM EROĞLU İBRAHİM ARPA 1/2 3523,88 7 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 7 TARLA DEDE AYDOĞDU KAMİL ARPA 1 1081,03 8 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 105 8 TARLA YAŞAR ŞAHAN HASAN ARPA 1 1708,94 9 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 108 1 TARLA ÇAPAN YILDIRIM BAHRİ ARPA 1 2575,63 10 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 110 29 TARLA CUMA YILDIRIM AHMET ARPA 1 3039,52 11 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 110 30 TARLA CUMA YILDIRIM AHMET ARPA 1 47,69 12 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 112 3 TARLA CUMA YILDIRIM AHMET ARPA 1 421,77 13 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 112 4 TARLA HİKMET ALTUNTAŞ MEVLÜT ARPA 1 703,31 14 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 112 5 TARLA HAYRULLAH EROĞLU İBRAHİM ARPA 1 3762,32 15 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 7 TARLA İSRAFİL GÖRGÜLÜ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 373,96 16 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 8 TARLA YAŞAR ŞAHAN HASAN ARPA 1 462,5 17 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 9 TARLA İLHAN GÖRGÜLÜ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 332,21 18 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 10 TARLA İSRAFİL GÖRGÜLÜ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 417,22 19 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 11 TARLA HAYYRULLAH EROĞLU İBRAHİM ARPA 1/2 751,4 20 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 11 TARLA MUTTALİP EROĞLU YUNİS ARPA 1/2 751,4 21 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 12 TARLA HİKMET ALTUNTAŞ MEVLÜT ARPA 1 654,66 22 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 113 40 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 8331,45 23 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 130 52 TARLA ÇAPAN YILDIRIM BAHRİ ARPA 1 2429,26 24 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 130 53 TARLA ÇAPAN YILDIRIM BAHRİ ARPA 1 636,89 25 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 130 61 TARLA İSRAFİL GÖRGÜLÜ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 222,46 26 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 130 62 TARLA İSRAFİL GÖRGÜLÜ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 2075,16 27 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ABDİUŞAĞI 130 63 TARLA ZEKERİYA ÇELİK MUTTALİP ARPA 1 2168,63 28 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 0 1932 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 3654,58 29 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 0 1933 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 812,4 30 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 0 2385 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 339,55 31 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 220 1 ARSA İSHAK BEKLEVİÇ DAVUT ARPA 1 2385,16 32 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 224 3 ARSA DAVUT BEKLEVİÇ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 1994,27 33 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 471 1 TARLA SALİH BAYSAL NEŞET ARPA 1 1545,39 34 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 486 5 TARLA DEDE YİĞİT VELİ ARPA 1 63,95 35 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 486 6 TARLA DEDE YİĞİT VELİ ARPA 1 101,71 36 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 486 7 TARLA DEDE YİĞİT VELİ ARPA 1 347,34 37 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 486 8 TARLA MEHMET EROĞLU SAFFET ARPA 1/2 24,77 38 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 486 8 TARLA SULTAN BAYSAL HIZIR ARPA 1/2 24,77 39 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 488 3 TARLA İSMAİL YÜCEL MEHMET ARPA 1 330,68 40 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 489 2 TARLA DOĞAN EROĞLU DEDE ARPA 1 5490,64 BOŞ(KULLA 41 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 489 5 TARLA NILMAZ) 1796,5 142 42 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 1 TARLA ZEYNEP ATAK MUHARREM ARPA 1 1796,5 43 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 2 BAĞ YAŞAR ERDAL ALİ ARPA 1 2352,44 44 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 3 BAĞ YILMAZ ERDAL RAMAZAN ARPA 1 975,24 45 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 4 BAĞ İSMAİL EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1 306,55 46 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 5 BAHÇE İSMAİL EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1/2 549,61 47 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 5 BAHÇE KUDDUSİ EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1/2 2001,34 48 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 491 6 BAĞ KUDDUSİ EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1 683,53 49 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 492 6 BAHÇE KUDDUSİ EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1 2055,87 50 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 492 7 BAHÇE İSMAİL EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1 617,43 51 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 492 8 BAHÇE NEVZAT ÇATOĞLU İSMAİL ARPA 1/3 1539,32 52 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 492 8 BAHÇE DEDE EROĞLU MEHMET ARPA 1/3 1539,32 53 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 492 8 BAHÇE İSMAİL EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1/3 1539,32 54 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 493 7 BAHÇE CAFİYE ÇATOĞLU DURMUŞ ARPA 1 739,2 55 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 493 8 BAHÇE KUDDUSİ EROĞLU MEMDUH ARPA 1 312,68 56 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 494 1 BAHÇE HİKMET ÇATOĞLU MEHMET ARPA 1 1534,36 57 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 494 6 BAHÇE AHMET EROĞLU MEHMET ARPA 1 3087,11 58 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 495 1 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 774,04 59 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 499 2 TARLA SALİH BAYSAL NEŞET ARPA 1 658,21 60 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN CAMİLİ 499 3 TARLA DOĞAN EROĞLU DEDE ARPA 1 4545,03 61 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 103 4 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 16835,73 62 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 103 11 TARLA MİKAİL ÇETİN REMZİ ARPA 1 873,68 63 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 103 12 TARLA TAHSİN ÇETİN RAMAZAN ARPA 1 1675,03 64 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 29 TARLA İRFAN KILIÇ MUSTAFA ARPA 1/2 1125,77 65 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 29 TARLA DAĞISTAN KILIÇ HACI ARPA 1/2 1125,77 66 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 30 TARLA DEDE YILDIZ HAYDAR ARPA 1 1103,54 ABDÜRRAHM ARPA 67 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 31 TARLA MEHMET ALİ YIDIZ AN 1/2 1103,54 68 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 31 TARLA MUSTAFA YILDIZ MUSA ARPA 1/2 1788,72 BOŞ(KULLA 69 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 105 32 TARLA NILMAZ) 138,73 70 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 5 TARLA DURMUŞ TORAMAN İDRİS ARPA 1 1177,23 71 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 8 TARLA AHMET ÖZBAYIR VELİ ARPA 1 448,5 BOŞ(KULLA 72 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 9 TARLA NILMAZ) 1465,81 73 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 10 TARLA SALİH ÇETİN DEDE ARPA 1 2786,59 74 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 16 TARLA SALİH ÇETİN DEDE ARPA 1 2284,2 75 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 18 TARLA YAŞAR ŞAHAN FEVZİ ARPA 1 2217,81 76 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 23 TARLA ZİYA KARTAL ARPA 1 1360,37 77 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 24 TARLA RAMAZAN BAŞHÖYÜK İBRAHİM ARPA 1 2195,87 78 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 25 TARLA MEHMET ÇELİK MUSTAFA ARPA 1 215,45 79 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 26 TARLA YAKUP BAŞHÖYÜK ŞAHİN ARPA 1 686,34 80 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 27 TARLA HAMİT BAŞHÜYÜK DEDE ARPA 1 1464,82 81 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 106 31 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 42,8 82 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 107 16 TARLA RAMAZAN BAŞHÖYÜK İBRAHİM ARPA 1 1914,51 83 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 107 17 TARLA HAMDİ TORAMAN DERVİŞ ARPA 1 1216,03 TARLA 84 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN ÇATALÇEŞME 107 18 ÇAYIRLIK RAMAZAN BAŞHÖYÜK İBRAHİM ARPA 1 978,65 85 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 95 TARLA HÜLİSİ EROĞLU HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 817,79 86 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 96 TARLA BAYRAM ALICI NİZAMETTİN ARPA 1 798,67 143 87 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 97 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1001,57 88 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 98 TARLA DEDE KELEŞ KAZIM ARPA 1 2029,18 89 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 100 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 2176,35 90 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 101 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 484,63 91 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 112 TARLA HAMZA AÇIKEL DEDE ARPA 1 1516,97 92 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 113 TARLA İSMAİL GÜNDOĞDU MEHMET ARPA 1 1433,39 93 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 114 TARLA HAMZA AÇIKEL DEDE ARPA 1 1357 94 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 116 TARLA İSMAİL GÜNDOĞDU MEHMET ARPA 1 452,74 BOŞ(KULLA 95 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 197 TARLA NILMAZ) 1154,11 96 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 199 TARLA YÜKSEL AÇIKEL DEDE ARPA 1 1550,96 97 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 201 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 265,56 98 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 203 TARLA MERYEM EROĞLU DEDE ARPA 1 1667,4 99 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 205 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 2142,74 100 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 207 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 886,81 101 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 208 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 1260,43 102 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 215 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 110,47 103 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 216 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 1797,07 104 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 217 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 1608,17 105 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 218 TARLA YÜKSEL AÇIKEL DEDE ARPA 1 1029,37 106 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 252 TARLA ERHAN KILIÇASLAN RECEP ARPA 1 339,31 107 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 413 TARLA İSMAİL KILIÇ EVLİYA ARPA 1 2064,81 108 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 418 TARLA KAZIM KELEŞ ŞAMMAS ARPA 1 417,93 109 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 419 TARLA KADİR KELEŞ HACI ARPA 1 2377,04 110 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 450 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 2544,52 111 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 454 TARLA YAŞAR KELEŞ SİNAN ARPA 1 992,48 112 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 455 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 568,05 113 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 456 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 480,83 114 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 457 TARLA KADİR KELEŞ HACI ARPA 1 1114,81 115 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 101 458 TARLA KADİR KELEŞ HACI ARPA 1 393,18 116 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 6 TARLA RAMAZAN DOĞAN ALİ ARPA 1 325,73 117 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 7 TARLA RAMAZAN DOĞAN ALİ ARPA 1 4653,61 118 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 8 TARLA ALİ RIZA ERDOĞDU HASAN ARPA 1 1556,78 119 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 22 TARLA ZAFER DOĞAN ALİ ARPA 1 1918,78 120 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 23 TARLA EMRULLAH DOĞAN NİYAZİ ARPA 1 1184,07 121 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 113 24 TARLA ZAFER DOĞAN ALİ ARPA 1 1858,01 122 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 114 11 TARLA MURAT ÖZTÜRK HACI ARPA 1 2000,18 123 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 114 14 TARLA İSMAİL GÜNDOĞDU MEHMET ARPA 1 2392,32 124 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 114 52 TARLA İSMAİL GÜNDOĞDU MEHMET ARPA 1 4508,61 125 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 115 18 TARLA İSMAİL EROL CELİL ARPA 1 3569,35 126 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 115 32 TARLA LOKMAN ÖZTÜRK DEDE ARPA 1 2664,78 127 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 115 33 TARLA MURAT ÖZTÜRK HACI ARPA 1 360,23 128 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 115 68 TARLA ADNAN GÜNDOĞDU AHMET ARPA 1 1464,92 129 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 115 69 TARLA BAKİ GÜNDOĞDU ALİ ARPA 1 3034,51 BOŞ(KULLA 130 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 3 TARLA NILMAZ) 1224,9 131 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 5 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 713,54 132 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 7 TARLA HÜLİSİ EROĞLU HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 589,09 144 133 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 8 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 481,54 134 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 9 TARLA NUREDDİN EROĞLU NAİL ARPA 1 515,9 135 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 10 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 532,64 136 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 143 11 TARLA RAMAZAN EROĞLU KEMAL ARPA 1 901,79 137 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KEDERLİ 144 1 TARLA ERHAN KILIÇASLAN RECEP ARPA 1 825,98 138 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 122 1 TARLA RAFETTİN BİLECEN BAYRAM ARPA 1 466,2 139 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 122 2 TARLA RAFETTİN BİLECEN BAYRAM ARPA 1 5488,1 140 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 2 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 17422,35 141 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 3 TARLA RAMAZAN ARKAN RIZA ARPA 1 132,4 142 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 4 TARLA KÖKSAL YALMAN ABDULLAH ARPA 1 2391,39 143 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 5 TARLA RAFETTİN BİLECEN BAYRAM ARPA 1 220,69 144 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 6 TARLA KADİR KÜTÜK HACI MEHMET ARPA 1 315,69 145 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 7 TARLA HIZIR ALIÇ FAHRETTİN ARPA 1 1184,03 146 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 123 8 TARLA KÖKSAL YALMAN ABDULLAH ARPA 1 1064,45 BOŞ(KULLA 147 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 125 1 TARLA NILMAZ) 1688,08 BOŞ(KULLA 148 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 132 1 TARLA NILMAZ) 2839,47 149 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 132 2 TARLA HIZIR ERDİL MUSTAFA ARPA 1 2518,12 150 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 132 3 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 6186,2 BOŞ(KULLA 151 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 149 9 TARLA NILMAZ) 8701,44 152 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 149 11 TARLA EKREM ACAR İSHAK ARPA 1 1578,5 153 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 149 12 EKREM ACAR İSHAK ARPA 1 824,36 154 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 163 6 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 1868,15 155 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 1 BAHÇE FAHRETTİN EKMEN ABDÜSSELAM ARPA 1 868,26 BOŞ(KULLA 156 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 6 TARLA NILMAZ) 1024,93 157 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 15 TARLA MERYEM ALICI MUHARREM ARPA 1 857,91 158 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 16 BAĞ MARİE EKMEN MEHMET ARPA 1/3 810,62 159 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 16 BAĞ SAMİ EKMEN HÜSEYİN ARPA 1/3 810,62 160 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 164 16 BAĞ BEHÇET EKMEN KAMİL ARPA 1/3 810,62 161 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 165 7 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 1367,51 162 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 166 1 BAĞ YAŞAR AKTİ EREN ARPA 1 1921,04 163 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 166 2 BAĞ EKREM ACAR İSHAK ARPA 1 1220,05 164 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN KÜTÜKLÜ 166 39 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 1437,61 165 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1687 TARLA NİHAT AYDIN HACI İSA ARPA 1 2022,5 166 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1698 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1396,28 167 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1699 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 639,83 168 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1700 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 579,93 169 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1701 TARLA KADİR GÖRGÜLÜ İZZET BUĞDAY 1 151,2 170 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1702 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1041,49 171 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1779 TARLA HAYATİ GÖKTAŞ AHMET ARPA 1 1079,84 BOŞ(KULLA 172 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1780 BAHÇE NILMAZ) 101,16 SÖĞÜTLÜ 173 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1782 K TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 465,97 174 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1784 BAHÇE TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 439,6 175 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1937 TARLA SALİH ÖZBEK RIFAT ARPA 1 3070,35 176 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1946 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 2934,78 177 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1955 TARLA VEYSEL ÜNSAL MEHMET ARPA 1 1087,84 145 178 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1958 TARLA VEYSEL ÜNSAL MEHMET ARPA 1 1322,02 HAM 179 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 1964 TOPRAK TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 613,43 180 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2028 TARLA AHMET AYDIN İBRAHİM ARPA 1 1385,36 181 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2029 TARLA RECEP AYDIN ŞEVKET ARPA 1 741,68 182 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2030 TARLA KADİR GÖRGÜLÜ İZZET ARPA 1 824,52 183 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2031 TARLA HALİL SERİN ARPA 1 704,34 184 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2032 TARLA YAKUP ÖZTÜRK DEDE ARPA 1 631,78 185 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2037 TARLA AHMET AYDIN İBRAHİM ARPA 1 1138,7 186 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2038 TARLA KADİR GÖRGÜLÜ İZZET ARPA 1 1288,54 187 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2039 TARLA RECEP AYDIN ŞEVKET ARPA 1 933,72 188 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2068 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1958,74 189 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2070 MERA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1 1609,7 190 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2161 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 935,14 191 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2174 TARLA BURHAN ÜNSAL OSMAN BUĞDAY 1 189,82 192 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2180 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1701,69 193 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2180 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1701,69 194 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2180 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1701,69 195 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2181 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1772,21 196 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2182 TARLA FAZLI EROĞLU İBRAHİM ARPA 1 1641,99 197 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2187 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 2549,14 198 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2191 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 632,01 199 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2192 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1129,98 200 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2193 TARLA NİHAT AYDIN HACI İSA ARPA 1 2274,03 201 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2194 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 223,44 202 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2203 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1963,75 203 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2204 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1373,58 204 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2301 TARLA VEYSEL ÜNSAL MEHMET ARPA 1 329,26 BOŞ(KULLA 205 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2302 TARLA NILMAZ) 2387,24 BOŞ(KULLA 206 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2303 TARLA NILMAZ) 436,69 207 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2304 TARLA YAŞAR ERDAL ALİ ARPA 1 959,79 BOŞ(KULLA 208 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 2305 TARLA NILMAZ) 1277,42 209 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3312 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 284,42 210 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3313 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ BOŞ 1206,18 211 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3314 TARLA TESPİT EDİLEMEDİ ARPA 1130,69 212 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3489 TARLA ALİ EROĞLU DURSUN ARPA 1 105,53 213 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3911 TARLA DOĞAN BEKLEVİÇ AREFE ARPA 1 529,02 214 AKSARAY AĞAÇÖREN MERKEZ 0 3915 TARLA SEFA BEKLEVİÇ İSHAK ARPA 1 2482,34 215 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2961 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 20510,19 216 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2973 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 14016,6 217 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2977 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 3387,28 218 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2978 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 39469,06 219 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2983 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 13844,57 220 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2985 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 44020,22 221 AKSARAY ESKİL MERKEZ 0 2988 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 35042,78 ALTINKAYA(Y 222 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 30 TARLA DURDANE ATUĞ ARPA 1 2445,48 146 ALTINKAYA(Y AHMET MÜCAHİT 223 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 32 TARLA ATUĞ MEHMET ALİ ARPA 2/3 67,71 ALTINKAYA(Y 224 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 32 TARLA ÖMER FARUK ATUĞ BUĞDAY 1/3 67,71 ALTINKAYA(Y BOŞ(KULLA 225 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 33 TARLA NILMAZ) 2799,2 ALTINKAYA(Y 226 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 34 TARLA MURAT ATUĞ ŞABAN BOŞ 1 3334,28 ALTINKAYA(Y 227 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 35 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 136,56 ALTINKAYA(Y HAM 228 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 40 TOPRAK MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 736,83 ALTINKAYA(Y 229 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 67 TARLA ÖMER DEDE MEHMET ALİ BOŞ 1 696,22 ALTINKAYA(Y 230 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 68 TARLA ÖMER DEDE MEHMET ALİ BOŞ 1 1924,41 ALTINKAYA(Y 231 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 69 TARLA ELİF AYGÜN DURMUŞ BOŞ 1 2091,02 ALTINKAYA(Y 232 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 75 TARLA CENGİZ ALTINSOY ARPA 1 2622,07 ALTINKAYA(Y 233 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 76 TARLA İHSAN AYAS ALİ BOŞ 1/2 980,19 ALTINKAYA(Y 234 AKSARAY ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 76 TARLA ÇAPAN AYAS ALİ BOŞ 1/2 980,19 ALTINKAYA(Y 235 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 77 TARLA MUHARREM ALTINOK BOŞ 4/16 1083,19 ALTINKAYA(Y 236 AKSARAY ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 77 TARLA ELİF AYGÜN DURMUŞ BOŞ 3/16 1083,19 ALTINKAYA(Y 237 AKSARAY ENİ KÖYÜ) 339 77 TARLA ALİ ÇETİN HAZİM BOŞ 9/16 1083,19 ALTINKAYA(Y 238 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 340 17 TARLA MUHARREM ALTINOK BOŞ 4/16 1280,2 ALTINKAYA(Y 239 AKSARAY ENİ KÖYÜ) 340 17 TARLA ELİF AYGÜN DURMUŞ BOŞ 3/16 1280,2 ALTINKAYA(Y 240 AKSARAY ENİ KÖYÜ) 340 17 TARLA ALİ ÇETİN HAZİM BOŞ 9/16 1280,2 ALTINKAYA(Y 241 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 341 28 TARLA MUSA AYAS ESAT BOŞ 1 635,13 ALTINKAYA(Y BOŞ(KULLA 242 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 341 29 TARLA NILMAZ) 354,54 ALTINKAYA(Y BOŞ(KULLA 243 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 341 30 ÇAYIRLIK NILMAZ) 776,69 ALTINKAYA(Y BOŞ(KULLA 244 AKSARAY MERKEZ ENİ KÖYÜ) 356 1 ARSA NILMAZ) 28,67 BOŞ(KULLA 245 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1314 TARLA NILMAZ) 866,65 ABDURRAHMAN AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 246 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1315 TARLA TAŞKIN ABDULLAH KİLECEK) 1 983,58 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 247 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1317 TARLA AYŞE AK NİYAZİ KİLECEK) 1 764,61 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 248 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1318 TARLA AYŞE AK NİYAZİ KİLECEK) 1 690,97 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 249 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1319 TARLA TUNCER ÇELEBİ MEHMET KİLECEK) 1 1374,36 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 250 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1320 TARLA ORHAN ÇELEBİ MEHMET KİLECEK) 1 3386,51 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 251 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1321 TARLA ARİF ŞİŞMAN BEKİR KİLECEK) 1 808,42 252 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1323 TARLA HAKAN ARIBAŞ YÜKSEL BUĞDAY 1 581,23 253 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1324 TARLA HAKAN ARIBAŞ YÜKSEL BUĞDAY 1 482,88 254 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1325 TARLA HAKAN ARIBAŞ YÜKSEL BUĞDAY 1 450,12 255 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1326 TARLA SEDAT ARIBAŞ BUĞDAY 1 482,21 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 256 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1327 TARLA HAMZA ŞİŞMAN MUHSİN KİLECEK) 1 304,3 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 257 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1328 TARLA BEKİR ŞİŞMAN MUHSİN KİLECEK) 1/2 2167,92 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 258 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 1328 TARLA YAŞAR ÖZTÜRK KİLECEK) 1/2 2167,92 259 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1329 TARLA HAMZA ŞİŞMAN MUHSİN BUĞDAY 1 1279,87 260 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1330 TARLA SELAHATTİN ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1 3809,71 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 261 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1391 TARLA ÖZER ORUÇ HASAN KİLECEK) 1 302,22 147 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 262 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1392 TARLA ÖZER ORUÇ HASAN KİLECEK) 1 1018,29 263 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1393 TARLA MUHAMMER ÇAKIR NADİ BUĞDAY 1 3025,46 264 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1394 TARLA MAHMUT ARIBAŞ MISIR 1 4146,98 265 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1406 TARLA HAMZA ŞİŞMAN BUĞDAY 1 310,96 266 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1407 TARLA BURHAN ARIBAŞ TAHİR ARPA 1 1160,59 267 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1408 TARLA BURHAN ARIBAŞ TAHİR ARPA 1 1526,1 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 268 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1409 TARLA BEYTULLAH ARIBAŞ DERVİŞ KİLECEK) 1 2411,63 269 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1770 TARLA BEKİR ŞİŞMAN MUHSİN BUĞDAY 1 1171,75 270 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1771 TARLA RECEP VARLI OSMAN BOŞ 1 434,91 271 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1772 TARLA RECEP VARLI OSMAN BOŞ 1 363,48 272 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1780 TARLA TARIK ARIBAŞ TURGUT BUĞDAY 1 492,55 273 AKSARAY MERKEZ BAYMIŞ 0 1781 TARLA ARİF ŞİŞMAN BEKİR BOŞ 1 748,2 274 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 66 TARLA SULTAN ÖZKİŞİ RAMAZAN BOŞ 1 152,88 275 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 69 TARLA ABDİ ÖZKİŞİ ŞABAN ARPA 1 8759,9 276 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 70 TARLA ABDİ ÖZKİŞİ ŞABAN BOŞ 1 6168,09 277 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 76 TARLA MEHMET ÇAT HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 959,62 278 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 77 TARLA HAYATİ ÇAT AHMET ARPA 1 1011,47 279 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 105 TARLA HAYATİ ÇAT AHMET ARPA 1 3447,47 280 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 151 TARLA HÜSEYİN ÖZÇİFÇİ İZZET BOŞ 1 47,39 281 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 152 TARLA ERDOĞAN ÖZÇİFTÇİ ZİYA BOŞ 1 2053,95 282 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 154 TARLA MEHMET AKKAYA HALİL BOŞ 1/2 1202,68 283 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 154 TARLA BAYRAM AKKAYA HALİL BOŞ 1/2 1202,68 284 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 156 TARLA FATMANA GÜL RESUL BOŞ 1 1005,18 285 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 160 TARLA AHMET AKKAYA HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1/3 2476,61 286 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 160 TARLA EMRULLAH AKKAYA ŞABAN BOŞ 1/3 2476,61 287 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 160 TARLA HIZIR AKKAYA HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1/3 2476,61 288 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 161 TARLA ABDULLAH SERİN FAHRİ ARPA 1 3175,59 289 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 162 TARLA TURGUT ÖZÇİFTÇİ HİCABİ ARPA 1 834,5 290 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 165 TARLA HAYATİ ÇAY AHMET ARPA 1 1534,55 291 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 166 TARLA BAYRAM ALİ AKPINAR HACI HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1 1327,56 292 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 167 TARLA HAYATİ ÇAT AHMET ARPA 1 1494,15 BOŞ(KULLA 293 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 171 TARLA NILMAZ) 2564,03 294 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 172 TARLA İBRAHİM ÖZTORUN SALİH ARPA 1 1167,78 295 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 173 TARLA ADNAN ÖZTORUN HANİFİ ARPA 1 1126,39 296 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 174 TARLA NEZAHAT ÖZTORUN İSMAİL ARPA 1 7156,44 297 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 178 TARLA RECEP ÇAT SADETTİN ARPA 1 1526,45 298 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 179 TARLA SULTAN KILIÇ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 2051,3 299 AKSARAY MERKEZ BOSTANLIK 107 180 TARLA FADİME ÇAT SADETTİN ARPA 1 184,89 300 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 191 TARLA DURAN OLGUN ARPA 1 2008,03 301 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 192 TARLA SAFFET ÖZÇİFTÇİ ARPA 1 1790,14 302 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 193 TARLA SEYİT HÜYÜKLÜ RAMAZAN ARPA 1 2169,8 303 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 194 TARLA MEVLÜT ÇIRÇIR İDRİS ARPA 1 1460,77 304 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 195 TARLA ERDOĞAN ÖZÇİFTÇİ ZİYA ARPA 1 1661,58 305 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 196 TARLA NECMİ ÇAT TAHSİN ARPA 1 359,66 306 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 205 TARLA YUSUF ÖZDEMİR MEVLÜT ARPA 1 3908,77 307 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 210 TARLA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 412,63 148 308 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 220 TARLA NİHAT ÖZDEMİR ŞERAFETTİN ARPA 1 1035,18 309 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 221 BAĞ SEYİT HÜYÜKLÜ RAMAZAN ARPA 1 1208,35 310 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 222 BAĞ NİHAT ÖZDEMİR ŞERAFETTİN ARPA 1 654,53 311 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 223 BAĞ NİHAT ÖZDEMİR ŞERAFETTİN ARPA 1 543,52 312 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 225 TARLA MEVLÜT ÇIRÇIR İDRİS ARPA 1 3447,92 TARLA VE 313 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 227 BAĞ VEDAT ÖZDEMİR NAFİZ ARPA 1 997,7 314 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 238 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 8513,58 315 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 239 TARLA AŞIR KAŞLI BAYRAM BOŞ 1/2 6003,33 316 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 239 TARLA VEDAT ÖZDEMİR NAFİZ BOŞ 1/2 6003,33 317 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 242 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 801,26 318 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 253 TARLA AŞIR KAŞLI BAYRAM BOŞ 1 1590,04 319 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 256 TARLA ŞABAN ÖZTORUN VELİ ARPA 1 1899,34 320 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 258 TARLA ŞABAN ÖZTORUN VELİ ARPA 1 594,48 321 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 760 TARLA YAŞAR KAŞLI OSMAN ARPA 1 2567,71 322 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 761 TARLA KAMİL ÇOLAK İSA ARPA 1 2070,35 323 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 762 TARLA KAMİL ÇOLAK İSA ARPA 1 1001,34 324 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 764 TARLA KAMİL ÇOLAK İSA ARPA 1 795,67 325 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 765 TARLA KAMİL ÇOLAK İSA ARPA 1 687,85 326 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 770 TARLA İBRAHİM ÖZTORUN ARPA 1 6744,84 HARMAN 327 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 771 YERİ KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 868,34 328 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 772 TARLA KAMİL ÇOLAK İSA ARPA 1 766,17 329 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 778 TARLA İSMET KARAKÜLAH ÖMER ARPA 1 4019,57 330 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 787 TARLA EVLİYA ÖZCAN MİKDAT ARPA 1 371,49 331 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 788 TARLA İSMET KARAKÜLAH ÖMER ARPA 1 989,53 332 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 789 TARLA RIZA ÇETİN AŞIR ARPA 1 1209,47 333 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 960 TARLA MEVLÜT ÇIRÇIR İDRİS ARPA 1 2384,76 334 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 963 TARLA SEYİT ÖZDEMİR RAMAZAN ARPA 1 1056,7 335 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 966 TARLA ERDOĞAN ÖZÇİFTÇİ ZİYA ARPA 1 612,59 336 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 968 TARLA ABDİ ÖZDEMİR YAŞAR BOŞ 1 2842,99 337 AKSARAY MERKEZ CERİT KÖYÜ 0 970 BAĞ YAŞAR KAŞLI OSMAN ARPA 1 765,11 338 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 15 TARLA YILMAZ KARATAY RIFAT BOŞ 1 2125,04 339 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 16 TARLA TEMİR ACAR HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1 350,72 340 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 20 TARLA YUSUF ACAR BOŞ 1 1215,79 341 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 21 TARLA OSMAN ATUĞ ALİ BOŞ 1 1421,37 342 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 22 TARLA ALİ ÇETİN AŞIR BOŞ 1 835,79 343 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 23 TARLA EKREM ÇIRÇIR BUĞDAY 1 1733 344 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 24 TARLA AHMET GÜNEY ARPA 1 1361,25 345 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 251 27 TARLA MEHMET ACAR ŞABAN BOŞ 1 1722,61 346 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 253 2 TARLA AHMET GÜNEY ARPA 1 616,76 BOŞ(KULLA 347 AKSARAY MERKEZ HANOBASI 253 3 TARLA NILMAZ) 1791,9 348 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1940 TARLA HAMZA ŞİŞMAN MUHSİN BUĞDAY 1 772,55 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 349 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1942 TARLA İBRAHİM CEYLAN HACI AHMET KİLECEK) 1 6433,88 HASAN 350 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1965 TARLA KEZİBAN KILIÇ HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 1045,98 351 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1966 TARLA ARİF ŞİŞMAN BEKİR BUĞDAY 1 4676,62 352 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1975 TARLA FATMA ALBAYRAK ÇAPAN BOŞ 1 2423,53 353 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 1976 TARLA SİNAN ÇİÇEK HALİL ARPA 1 1490,93 149 354 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2009 TARLA SARE ALTINKAYA OSMAN ARPA 1 3337,94 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 355 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2036 TARLA EKREM YILMAZ REŞAT KİLECEK) 1 3178,41 356 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2037 TARLA ENVER ALTINSOY ALİ ARPA 1 1013,45 357 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2070 TARLA RAŞİT ÖZDEMİR OSMAN ARPA 1 2734,15 BOŞ(KULLA 358 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2071 TARLA MEHMET BABUR MUSTAFA NILMAZ) 1 1167,71 359 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2101 TARLA ZEKİ ÖZTÜRK KAZIM ARPA 1 1506,51 360 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2102 TARLA ŞABAN ÖZTÜRK BOŞ 1 5568 361 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2103 TARLA ÖMER ÖZTÜRK ABDULLAH BOŞ 1 315,38 362 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2117 TARLA YAŞAR ÖZTÜRK FEYZULLAH ARPA 1 4815,18 363 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2121 TARLA İBRAHİM AKBULUT HAMİT ARPA 1/2 4126,85 364 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2121 TARLA HACI BALCI MEHMET ARPA 1/2 4126,85 MUHAMMED 365 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2122 TARLA ÖZKARACA SELAHATTİN ARPA 1 2292,1 366 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2170 TARLA MAHMUT ÖZTÜRK İZZET ARPA 3/5 3419,34 367 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2170 TARLA RECEP ARPA 2/5 3419,34 NOHUT(EKİ 368 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2185 TARLA UĞUR LECEK) 1 590,91 369 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2186 TARLA BOTAŞ BOŞ 1 248,97 NOHUT(EKİ 370 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 0 2187 TARLA UĞUR LECEK) 1 1776,32 371 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 1 TARLA HACI İSA USLU OSMAN ARPA 1 1349,04 372 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 2 TARLA ALİ İHSAN USLU OSMAN ARPA 1 1053,36 373 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 5 TARLA MUSTAFA BALCI HALİS ARPA 1 2922,5 374 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 8 TARLA MUSTAFA BALCI HALİS ARPA 1 1921,87 375 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 10 TARLA HADİ ÖLMEZ BÜNYAMİN ARPA 1 2133,98 376 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 102 11 TARLA MEHMET SERİN RAŞİT ARPA 1 1769,53 377 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 1 TARLA SİNAN ÇİÇEK HALİL BOŞ 1 3622,62 378 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 24 TARLA YAŞAR ÖZTÜRK FEYZULLAH ARPA 1 2921,35 379 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 25 TARLA İSMET TOSUN İHSAN ARPA 1 4401,96 380 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 59 TARLA MURAT TOSUN ADEM ARPA 1 3394,9 381 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 63 TARLA BAYRAM ÇELEBİ MEMDUH BOŞ 1 1848,68 382 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 64 TARLA MEHMET ÇELEBİ YUSUF ARPA 1/3 7161,6 383 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 64 TARLA ABDULKADİR ÇELEBİ YUSUF ARPA 1/3 7161,6 HASAN HÜSEYİN 384 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 64 TARLA ÇELEBİ YUSUF ARPA 1/3 7161,6 385 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 74 TARLA AYŞE YILMAZ MEHMET ARPA 1/2 2097,52 386 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 74 TARLA GÜLESER YILMAZ MEHMET ARPA 1/2 2097,52 387 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 80 TARLA RAMAZAN TOSUN ASIM ARPA 1 1974,87 388 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 83 TARLA MEHMET ÖZTÜRK FEYZULLAH ARPA 1 2820,12 389 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 86 TARLA MEHMET ÖZTÜRK FEYZULLAH ARPA 1 1711,72 390 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 87 TARLA MECBURE AŞCI YUSUF BOŞ 1 758,1 391 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 88 TARLA MUSTAFA ÇELEBİ HALİL ARPA 1 1514,56 392 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 89 TARLA HACI BALCI MEHMET ARPA 1 4577,21 393 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 91 TARLA İSMAİL KILIÇ HACI ARPA 1 4094,1 394 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 93 TARLA MALİK YILMAZ YUSUF ARPA 1 1822,07 HACI 395 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 103 94 TARLA BÜNYAMİN ÇELEBİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 4363,35 HACI 396 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 107 2 TARLA BÜNYAMİN ÇELEBİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 3027,93 397 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 107 3 TARLA ALİ ÇELEBİ KAZIM ARPA 1 5750,96 150 398 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 111 1 TARLA YASİN KILIÇ ALİ ARPA 1 2758,13 399 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 111 2 TARLA ABDULLAH AKBULUT HAMİT ARPA 1 4407,64 400 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 111 3 TARLA ABDULLAH AKBULUT HAMİT ARPA 1 3252,03 Ham 401 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 111 4 Toprak MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 2156,21 402 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 119 1 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1360,91 403 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 119 2 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1128,87 404 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 119 3 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 789,75 405 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 119 4 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 691,02 406 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 119 5 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 633,8 407 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 123 2 TARLA SİNAN ÇİÇEK HALİL ARPA 1 3936,31 408 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 123 3 TARLA ALİ ALTINSOY HİKMET ARPA 1 2293,24 409 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 1 BAĞ ALİ ALTINSOY MUSTAFA BOŞ 1 1013,74 BAĞ VE 410 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 2 TARLA ALİ ALTINSOY HİKMET ARPA 1 872,71 BAĞ VE 411 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 3 TARLA ALİ ALTINSOY HİKMET ARPA 1 1182,71 BAĞ VE 412 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 4 TARLA ÇAPAN ALTINSOY MEHMET ARPA 1 76,87 413 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 18 TARLA MALİK YILMAZ YUSUF ARPA 1 1717,92 414 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 21 BAĞ SİNAN ÇİÇEK HALİL ARPA 1 928,1 HAM 415 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 22 TOPRAK MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 366,22 HAM 416 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 26 TOPRAK MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 198,76 BAĞ VE BOŞ(KULLA 417 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 27 TARLA HİLMİ ALBAYRAK ÖMER NILMAZ) 1 5958,35 418 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 31 BAĞ KADİRHAN KILIÇ RAMAZAN ARPA 1 326,89 HACI 419 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 43 TARLA BÜNYAMİN ÇELEBİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 954,98 420 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 46 TARLA ALİ ÇELEBİ KAZIM ARPA 1 1790,7 HACI 421 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 124 47 TARLA BÜNYAMİN ÇELEBİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 1345,27 422 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 127 1 TARLA ALİ ÇELEBİ KAZIM BOŞ 1 585,57 SAPMAZ KÖY TÜZEL 423 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 128 1 SULAKİYE KİŞİLİĞİ BOŞ 1 1422,28 TARLA VE 424 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 128 2 BAHÇE YASİN KILIÇ ALİ ARPA 1 189,55 SAPMAZ KÖY TÜZEL 425 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 189 1 SULAKİYE KİŞİLİĞİ BOŞ 1 7190,25 426 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 189 3 BAHÇE VEYSEL ALBAYRAK HASAN ARPA 1 854,01 427 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 189 8 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 4237,58 BOŞ(KULLA 428 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 189 9 TARLA ELİFE DÜZGÜN HULUSİ NILMAZ) 1 4240,45 429 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 199 2 TARLA MUSTAFA ÇİÇEK ŞAMMAS ARPA 1 4236,46 430 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 199 3 TARLA ALİ İHSAN USLU OSMAN ARPA 1 1907,22 431 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 199 4 TARLA YAŞAR ÖZTÜRK VEHBİ ARPA 1 3152,69 432 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 199 6 TARLA MUSTAFA ÖZTÜRK VEDAT ARPA 1 534,37 MEZARLI SAPMAZ KÖY TÜZEL 433 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 16 K KİŞİLİĞİ BOŞ 1 1269,81 434 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 17 TARLA SİNAN ÇİÇEK HALİL ARPA 1 182,64 AYFER ORUÇ BOŞ(KULLA 435 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 18 TARLA YUMUŞAK HÜSEYİN NILMAZ) 1 504,25 436 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 19 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1613,24 437 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 20 TARLA MAHMUT ÖZTÜRK İZZET ARPA 1 342,75 438 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 31 TARLA HAKAN ALBAYRAK KADİR ARPA 1 1678,8 151 439 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 32 TARLA MAHMUT ÖZTÜRK İZZET ARPA 1 795,96 440 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 33 TARLA MAHMUT ÖZTÜRK İZZET ARPA 1 630,34 441 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 41 TARLA MEHMET ÖZKARACA FEYZULLAH ARPA 1 3899,15 442 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 200 43 TARLA TENZİLE ÖLMEZ SALİH ARPA 1 308,06 BOŞ(KULLA 443 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 207 1 TARLA FADİME AKTAŞ DERVİŞ NILMAZ) 1 1030,92 NOHUT(EKİ 444 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 208 1 TARLA EKREM YILMAZ NEŞET LECEK) 1 1912,1 BOŞ(KULLA 445 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 208 3 TARLA RAMAZAN BALCI MUSTAFA NILMAZ) 1 1215,1 446 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 209 9 TARLA MEMİŞ BALCI MEHMET BOŞ 1 432,98 447 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 213 2 TARLA MUSTAFA ÖZTÜRK İSMAİL ARPA 1 1011,41 448 AKSARAY MERKEZ SAPMAZ 213 4 TARLA MUSTAFA ÖZTÜRK İSMAİL ARPA 1 494,68 449 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1411 MERA YENİKENT BELEDİYESİ BOŞ 1 2096,35 450 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1414 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 3963,85 451 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1420 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 1419,16 452 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1431 TARLA SÜLEYMAN KONUKÇU MUSTAFA YONCA 1 368,61 453 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1432 TARLA SÜLEYMAN KONUKÇU MUSTAFA YONCA 1 861,41 454 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1440 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 1924,56 455 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1441 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 352,01 456 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1443 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 1463,86 457 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 1444 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 191,02 458 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2292 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 128,08 459 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2724 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 217,98 460 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2726 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 2179,39 461 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2727 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 1537,36 462 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2728 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 531,61 463 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2729 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 2191,92 464 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 2730 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 1936,44 465 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3016 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 8796,78 466 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3017 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 4354,52 467 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3019 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6571,71 468 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3020 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 8773,01 469 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3022 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 7707,42 470 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3431 MERA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 6571,71 471 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3487 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 826,13 472 AKSARAY MERKEZ YENİKENT 0 3490 TARLA MEHMET AKDERE MEHMET YONCA 1 5222,05 473 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 0 6056 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 124601,2 474 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 429 1 TARLA BAYRAM AYDIN MEHMET ARPA 1 2469,62 475 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 429 2 TARLA TAMER BAYRAKDAR OSMAN ARPA 1 1699,32 476 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 429 3 TARLA TAMER BAYRAKDAR OSMAN ARPA 1 1402,3 477 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 429 4 TARLA TAMER BAYRAKDAR OSMAN ARPA 1 2562,92 478 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 429 5 TARLA TAMER BAYRAKDAR OSMAN ARPA 1 333,64 479 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLOVA 430 1 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 3753,09 480 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 28 TARLA ABDULBAKİ BATI MEHMET BUĞDAY 1 1101,72 481 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 29 TARLA ADNAN KOZAN ALİ BUĞDAY 1/3 2533,39 482 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 29 MUHAMMET KOZAN ALİ BUĞDAY 1/3 2533,39 483 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 29 YUSUF KOZAN ALİ BUĞDAY 1/3 2533,39 PANCAR(EKİ 484 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 30 TARLA FARUK BATI ABDULBAKİ LECEK) 1 1442,85 152 485 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 31 TARLA MUSTAFA ARSLAN MEHMET BUĞDAY 1 1169,1 486 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 32 TARLA HÜSEYİN ÖZKARACA ALİ ARPA 1 268,72 BOŞ(KULLA 487 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 33 TARLA NILMAZ) 944,47 488 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 34 TARLA ORHAN KILIÇ MEVLÜT BUĞDAY 1/2 1936,46 489 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 34 YAŞAR AKDOĞAN MEVLÜT BUĞDAY 1/2 1936,46 490 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 123 35 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 756,78 491 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 9 TARLA MUSTAFA DOĞAN DEDE BUĞDAY 1 909,88 492 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 10 TARLA ŞAHAP AYDOĞDU ABDULLAH BUĞDAY 1/9 2179,61 MUAMMER 493 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 10 AYDOĞDU ABDULLAH BUĞDAY 1/9 2179,61 494 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 10 NİYAZİ AYDOĞDU ABDULLAH BUĞDAY 7/9 2179,61 495 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 11 TARLA ABDULLAH AYDOĞDU NİYAZİ BOŞ 1 931,54 496 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 12 TARLA ADEM KOÇAK FEVZİ BUĞDAY 1 733,26 497 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 13 TARLA ADEM KOÇAK FEVZİ BUĞDAY 1 1231,47 498 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 14 TARLA ALİM AYDOĞDU ALİ BUĞDAY 1/2 1588,18 499 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 14 TARLA ADEM KOÇAK ALİ BUĞDAY 1/2 1588,18 500 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 15 TARLA ALİ DURGUT HAMZA BUĞDAY 1 730,63 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 501 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 16 TARLA AHMET ÖZ SÜLEYMAN KİLECEK) 1 1448,04 PANCAR(EKİ 502 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 124 17 TARLA MENDERES ARSLAN ABİDİN LECEK) 1 662,31 PANCAR(EKİ 503 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 1 TARLA BİROL BÜLBÜL SADİ LECEK) 1 2013,74 504 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 2 TARLA ARİFE ATASOY VEHBİ ARPA 1 713,61 505 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 3 TARLA İLHAN BÜLBÜL FARUK BUĞDAY 1 1255,69 506 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 4 TARLA RECEP VARLI OSMAN BOŞ 1 863,69 NURİ AYÇİCEĞİ(E 507 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 5 TARLA ALİ BİLGE MEHMET KİLECEK) 1 586,91 508 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 6 TARLA AYHAN TANRIVER HÜSEYİN BUĞDAY 1/3 2228,21 NURİ 509 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 6 TARLA LEYLA ERGÜN MEHMET BUĞDAY 2/3 2228,21 510 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 7 TARLA AYHAN TANRIVER HÜSEYİN BUĞDAY 1 1325,36 511 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 125 8 TARLA KEMAL GÖKDUMAN VELİ BOŞ 1 870,22 512 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 127 5 TARLA MUHAMMET ARSLAN AŞİL BOŞ 1 2639,66 513 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 128 4 TARLA AHMET ÖZ SÜLEYMAN BOŞ 1 2504,18 514 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 136 1 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 4084,6 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 515 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 137 5 TARLA SABRİ SUERİ AHMET KİLECEK) 1/2 1035,48 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 516 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 137 5 TARLA BASRİ SUERİ AHMET KİLECEK) 1/2 1035,48 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 517 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 137 6 TARLA KEMAL GÖKDUMAN VELİ KİLECEK) 1 2909,6 518 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 137 7 TARLA İSMAİL ARSLAN ŞAHİN BOŞ 1 1135,48 BOŞ(KULLA 519 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 138 2 TARLA NILMAZ) 706,64 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 520 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 138 3 TARLA MUSTAFA GÖNEN NİYAZİ KİLECEK) 1 119,09 521 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 378 6 TARLA MAHSUT VARLI OSMAN ARPA 1 1286,87 522 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 378 7 TARLA ŞAMMAS ÇELİK SÜLEYMAN ARPA 1 2026,55 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 523 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 3 TARLA ABDULLAH TANRIVER BÜNYAMİN KİLECEK) 1 2167,31 MEHMET ALİ 524 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 4 TARLA DÜZGÜN MUSTAFA BOŞ 1 1984,27 PANCAR(EKİ 525 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 5 TARLA BİROL BÜLBÜL SADİ LECEK) 1 674,85 PANCAR(EKİ 526 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 6 TARLA BİROL BÜLBÜL SADİ LECEK) 1 572,1 PANCAR(EKİ 527 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 7 TARLA BİROL BÜLBÜL SADİ LECEK) 1 543,88 153 PANCAR(EKİ 528 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 8 TARLA BİROL BÜLBÜL SADİ LECEK) 1 728,54 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 529 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 9 TARLA İSMAİL AKPINAR HÜNKAR KİLECEK) 1 1135,98 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 530 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 10 TARLA HACI BEKİR DİNLER AŞIR KİLECEK) 1 651,71 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 531 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 11 TARLA MUSTAFA ARSLAN MEHMET KİLECEK) 1 1420,79 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 532 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 12 TARLA HACI DOĞAN MEHMET ALİ KİLECEK) 1 1112,67 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 533 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 13 TARLA İSMAİL AKPINAR HÜNKAR KİLECEK) 1 1433 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 534 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 14 TARLA AHMET BÜLBÜL HALİL KİLECEK) 1 592,11 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 535 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 380 15 TARLA HASAN AK MUZAFFER KİLECEK) 1 726,12 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 536 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 383 4 TARLA ZÜBEYİR ATICI ŞAMMAS KİLECEK) 1 482,39 537 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 384 1 TARLA EREN ATICI ŞAMMAS BUĞDAY 1 1327,94 MEHMET ALİ 538 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 384 2 TARLA DAĞDELEN YUSUF BUĞDAY 1 1715,27 539 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 384 3 TARLA CEMAL KARA NİYAZİ BUĞDAY 1 4304,99 MEHMET ALİ HASAN 540 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 803 19 TARLA BOZKURT HÜSEYİN BUĞDAY 1 1662,63 541 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 3 TARLA ENES AKBULUT YUSUF ARPA 1 1788,01 AYÇİCEĞİ(E 542 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 4 TARLA MUSTAFA ERGÜN KEMAL KİLECEK) 1 972,07 543 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 5 TARLA MUSTAFA DÜZGÜN ŞABAN BUĞDAY 1 254,35 ABDURRAHMAN 544 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 6 TARLA DÜZGÜN HASAN BUĞDAY 1 497,75 545 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 7 TARLA HAKKI ACAR AHMET BUĞDAY 1 491,74 546 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 8 TARLA HAKKI ACAR AHMET BUĞDAY 1 310,83 547 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 9 TARLA MUHAMMET TURGUT NİYAZİ BOŞ 1 486,78 548 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 10 TARLA MUSTAFA ACAR HÜSEYİN KAVUN 1 1177,18 549 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 11 TARLA İBRAHİM ARSLAN ÖMER BUĞDAY 1 723,64 550 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 12 TARLA FARUK DÜZGÜN RAMAZAN BOŞ 1 1091,26 551 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 13 TARLA MUSTAFA DÜZGÜN MAHMUT BOŞ 1 247,78 552 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 14 TARLA TARIK BÜLBÜL MAZHAR BUĞDAY 1 576,27 553 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 15 TARLA MENDERES ARSLAN ABİDİN BOŞ 1 516,97 554 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 16 TARLA CANAN KOÇAK ABİDİN BOŞ 1 551,1 555 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 17 TARLA MENDERES ARSLAN ABİDİN BOŞ 1 560,85 556 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 18 TARLA İBRAHİM ARSLAN ÖMER BUĞDAY 1 174,32 557 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 804 20 TARLA ABDULBAKİ BATI MEHMET BUĞDAY 1 1273,12 BOŞ(KULLA 558 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 805 18 TARLA HATİCE AKDOĞAN SÜLEYMAN NILMAZ) 1 4370,44 559 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 806 15 TARLA İSMAİL AKPINAR HÜNKAR BUĞDAY 1 3016,29 560 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 807 16 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 4097,48 561 AKSARAY MERKEZ YEŞİLTEPE 823 1 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1408,92 562 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 270 TARLA EKREM SÖĞÜTLÜ SEYİT BOŞ 1 2167,87 563 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 271 TARLA İSMAİL SÖĞÜTLÜ DURMUŞ BOŞ 1 3280,09 564 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 279 TARLA HULUSİ KARAKÜLAH ÖMER BOŞ 1 762,23 565 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 280 TARLA EROL KARAKÜLAH ÇAPAN BOŞ 1 1097,69 566 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 281 TARLA EKREM ÇIRÇIR ARPA 1 980,43 567 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY CAMUZLUK 0 297 TARLA İSHAK KARAKÜLAH ESEF BOŞ 1 482,46 568 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 107 75 TARLA MUSTAFA ÇİMEÇ CELAL BOŞ 1 2440,62 BOŞ(KULLA 569 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 3 TARLA NILMAZ) 987,57 154 BOŞ(KULLA 570 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 4 TARLA NILMAZ) 1060,6 BOŞ(KULLA 571 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 17 TARLA NILMAZ) 449,47 572 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 18 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 487,78 BOŞ(KULLA 573 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 19 TARLA NILMAZ) 1415,44 BOŞ(KULLA 574 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 108 20 TARLA NILMAZ) 2878,96 HAM 575 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 129 1 TOPRAK MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 335,19 576 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 129 2 TARLA TANER GÜL RAFET ARPA 1 3382,29 577 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 10 TARLA MUHARREM NAVRUZ MUSTAFA ARPA 1 984,2 578 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 12 TARLA ALİ GÜL TAHİR ARPA 1 1266,99 579 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 13 TARLA MEHMET ÇAL İZZET ARPA 1 2074,09 580 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 15 TARLA BAYRAM DEMİR ŞUAYİP ARPA 1 557,27 581 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 17 TARLA MUSA GÜL ALİ ARPA 1 1691,63 582 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 130 18 TARLA ALTAN GÜL KADİR ARPA 1 1369,74 583 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 63 TARLA MURAT GÜL NECİP ARPA 1 1096,25 584 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 64 TARLA İBRAHİM GÜL TURGUT ARPA 1 922,37 585 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 65 TARLA İBRAHİM GÜL TURGUT ARPA 1 597,79 586 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 78 TARLA HASİBE DEMİR HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1 1725,82 587 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 79 TARLA BAYRAM ALİ GÜL MEHMET ARPA 1 1015,96 588 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 80 TARLA ALİ GÜL İBRAHİM ARPA 1 219,05 589 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 81 TARLA ALİ GÜL İBRAHİM ARPA 1 1196,69 590 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 84 TARLA DÜNYAMİN ÇİMENLİ MEHMET ARPA 1 1821,64 591 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY FAKICIK 131 85 TARLA REFİK SOĞUKÇEŞME DEDE ARPA 1 373,09 HACIİBRAHİM 592 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 113 6 TARLA EYÜP ÇAKIROĞLU HAYRULLAH BOŞ 1 2349,97 HACIİBRAHİM 593 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 113 7 TARLA SAVAS GÜR HACI BOŞ 1 1337,14 HACIİBRAHİM 594 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 113 8 TARLA ALİ AKDAĞ MUHARREM BOŞ 1 3026,33 HACIİBRAHİM ABDULLAH 595 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 113 9 TARLA KÜÇÜKBURUN MUSTAFA BOŞ 1 242,05 HACIİBRAHİM 596 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 114 24 TARLA MEHMET AKDAĞ ALİ ARPA 1 842,54 HACIİBRAHİM HASAN 597 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY UŞAĞI 114 25 TARLA YONUS GÜR HÜSEYİN ARPA 1 2381,21 HACIMAHMU 598 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 1 TARLA İHSAN ATAK MEVLÜT ARPA 1/2 1985,55 HACIMAHMU 599 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 1 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR ARPA 1/2 1985,55 HACIMAHMU 600 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 2 TARLA ZEYNEP AKYÜZ BEKTAŞ ARPA 1/2 393,59 HACIMAHMU 601 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 2 TARLA AHMET ÖZBAYIR ARPA 1/2 393,59 HACIMAHMU 602 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 3 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR ARPA 1/2 1301,23 HACIMAHMU MEHMET ALİ 603 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 3 TARLA ALBAYRAK İHSAN ARPA 1/2 1301,23 HACIMAHMU 604 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 4 TARLA ETEM AKÇA ALİ ARPA 1/3 3175,65 HACIMAHMU 605 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 4 TARLA FAİK AKÇA ÇELEBİ ARPA 1/3 3175,65 HACIMAHMU 606 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 4 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR ARPA 1/3 3175,65 HACIMAHMU 607 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 5 TARLA YAKUP ATAK HÜDAVERDİ ARPA 1 2616,01 HACIMAHMU 608 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 26 TARLA DÜNYAMİN ALKAN ZÖHTÜ ARPA 1 157,31 HACIMAHMU 609 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 32 TARLA DURAN ÖZBAYIR ARPA 1 4103,5 HACIMAHMU 610 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 33 TARLA MUHAMMED AKYÜZ İSMET ARPA 1 1163,59 155 HACIMAHMU NOHUT(EKİ 611 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 120 34 TARLA YUSUF ALBAYRAK ŞÜKRÜ LECEK) 1 3889,15 HACIMAHMU NOHUT(EKİ 612 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 121 1 TARLA MUSTAFA AKÇA HASAN LECEK) 1 352,68 HACIMAHMU 613 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 15 TARLA DÜNYAMİN ALKAN ZÖHTÜ BOŞ 1 4062,76 HACIMAHMU NOHUT(EKİ 614 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 16 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR LECEK) 1 1968,34 HACIMAHMU NOHUT(EKİ 615 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 17 TARLA ÜÇLER KARASAKAL MEHMET LECEK) 1 697,92 HACIMAHMU 616 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 20 TARLA HALİL ALBAYRAK CELAL ARPA 1 4923,4 HACIMAHMU 617 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 33 TARLA MUSA AKÇA DURAN ARPA 1 2413,95 HACIMAHMU 618 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 34 TARLA MUSTAFA AKÇA HASAN ARPA 1 228,61 HACIMAHMU 619 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 98 TARLA SULTAN AKÇA HANİFİ BOŞ 1 1598,46 HACIMAHMU 620 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 99 TARLA MUSTAFA AKÇA HASAN BOŞ 1 3866,9 HACIMAHMU 621 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 100 TARLA EYÜP AKYÜZ ALİ ARPA 1/3 2214,2 HACIMAHMU 622 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 100 TARLA CEBRAİL ÇİFTÇİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1/3 2214,2 HACIMAHMU 623 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 100 TARLA İSMAİL ÇİFTÇİ MUSTAFA ARPA 1/3 2214,2 HACIMAHMU NOHUT(EKİ 624 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 101 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR LECEK) 1 1663,23 HACIMAHMU 625 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 123 141 TARLA MUSTAFA AKÇA HASAN ARPA 1 651,23 HACIMAHMU 626 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 15 TARLA ETEM AKÇA ALİ ARPA 1 1419,06 HACIMAHMU 627 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 16 TARLA ZEYNEP AKYÜZ ÖMER ARPA 1/2 1839,24 HACIMAHMU 628 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 16 TARLA AHMET ÖZBAYIR ARPA 1/2 1839,24 HACIMAHMU 629 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 22 TARLA MENDERES ULUSOY HALİL ARPA 1 1132,39 HACIMAHMU 630 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 23 TARLA ZEYNEP AKYÜZ ÖMER ARPA 1/2 3890,46 HACIMAHMU 631 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 23 TARLA BÜNYAMİN YÜZBAŞI ALİ ARPA 1/2 3890,46 HACIMAHMU 632 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 25 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR ARPA 1 882,76 HACIMAHMU 633 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY TUŞAĞI 124 26 TARLA HALİL ALBAYRAK CELAL ARPA 1 1572,46 İSHAKLIKARA 634 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 107 2 TARLA FİKRİ ÇIRÇIR KEMAL ARPA 1/2 199,87 İSHAKLIKARA 635 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 107 2 TARLA EKREM ÇIRÇIR HAYRULLAH ARPA 1/2 199,87 İSHAKLIKARA 636 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 107 4 ÇAYIRLIK HASAN HÜSEYİN GÜL İSMAİL BOŞ 1 96,83 İSHAKLIKARA 637 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 107 5 TARLA AHMET GÜL İSHAK BOŞ 1 130,93 İSHAKLIKARA 638 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 108 1 TARLA MUSTAFA ÖZCAN CEMAL ARPA 1/2 1486,5 İSHAKLIKARA 639 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 108 1 TARLA EKREM ÇIRÇIR HAYRULLAH ARPA 1/2 1486,5 İSHAKLIKARA 640 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 108 2 TARLA MİKDAT ÖZCAN NAFİS ARPA 1 1117,9 İSHAKLIKARA 641 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 164 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 749,37 İSHAKLIKARA 642 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 202 BAĞ MEVLÜT ÇIRÇIR İDRİS ARPA 1 546,16 İSHAKLIKARA 643 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 203 ÇAYIRLIK MEVLÜT ÇIRÇIR İDRİS ARPA 1 614,99 İSHAKLIKARA 644 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 204 ÇAYIRLIK EKREM ÇIRÇIR HAYRULLAH BOŞ 1 601,85 İSHAKLIKARA 645 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 204 ÇAYIRLIK FİKRİ ÇIRÇIR KEMAL BOŞ 1 601,85 İSHAKLIKARA 646 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK YUNUS ÖZSEVGİÇ AZMİ BOŞ 1/16 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 647 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK HASAN HÜSEYİN GÜL İSMAİL BOŞ 1/8 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 648 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK İSMAİL ÖZSEVGİÇ AZMİ BOŞ 1/16 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 649 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK ÖMER ÖZSEVGİÇ AZMİ BOŞ 1/16 564,86 156 İSHAKLIKARA 650 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK MURAT GÜL NECİP BOŞ 1/4 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 651 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK MEHMET ÖZSEVGİÇ ALİ İHSAN BOŞ 1/4 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 652 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK EMİRASLAN ÖZSEVGİÇ AZMİ BOŞ 1/16 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 653 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 205 ÇAYIRLIK FİKRET GÜL İSHAK BOŞ 1/8 564,86 İSHAKLIKARA 654 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 211 TARLA NURETTİN ÇIRÇIR İSMET BOŞ 1 1939,14 İSHAKLIKARA 655 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 212 TARLA PENPE ÇIRÇIR RÜSTEM ARPA 1 1131,14 İSHAKLIKARA 656 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 216 TARLA ABDULLAH ÇIRÇIR ÖMER ARPA 1 545,45 İSHAKLIKARA NOHUT(EKİ 657 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 217 TARLA ÖMER ÇIRÇIR MEVLÜT LECEK) 1 740,59 İSHAKLIKARA NOHUT(EKİ 658 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 220 TARLA DEDE ÇIRÇIR KEMAL LECEK) 1 1050,7 İSHAKLIKARA 659 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 227 TARLA CEYLAN ÖZCAN MEVLÜT BOŞ 1 1503,77 İSHAKLIKARA 660 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 228 TARLA MİKDAT ÖZCAN NAFİZ BOŞ 1/4 2297,23 İSHAKLIKARA 661 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 228 TARLA ALİ OSMAN ÖZCAN NAFİZ BOŞ 3/4 2297,23 İSHAKLIKARA 662 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 237 TARLA SALİH ÖZCAN ADEM ARPA 1 1376,46 İSHAKLIKARA 663 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 241 TARLA CEYLAN ÖZCAN MEVLÜT BOŞ 1 1597,79 İSHAKLIKARA 664 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 242 TARLA CEYLAN ÖZCAN MEVLÜT BOŞ 1 1228,06 İSHAKLIKARA 665 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 243 TARLA DURAN ÖZCAN ŞAMMAS BOŞ 1 174,05 İSHAKLIKARA 666 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 244 TARLA NURETTİN ÇIRÇIR İSMET BUĞDAY 1 1717,03 İSHAKLIKARA 667 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINAR 110 245 TARLA ALİ OSMAN ÖZCAN NAFİS BOŞ 1 1487,44 668 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 113 17 TARLA MEHMET YÜZBAŞI RIZA ARPA 1 612,47 BOŞ(KULLA 669 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 114 1 TARLA NILMAZ) 1335,31 670 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 116 7 TARLA YAHYA KELEŞ YAŞAR ARPA 1 858,36 671 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 116 8 TARLA İSMAİL AKYÜZ HALİL ARPA 1 1641,43 672 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 116 9 TARLA ZİYA ATDERE HAYRULLAH ARPA 1 1036,34 673 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 116 10 TARLA ZEYNEL AYDIN ÇAPAN ARPA 1 1424,62 674 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 6 TARLA MENDERES ULUSOY HALİL ARPA 1 1877,8 BOŞ(KULLA 675 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 18 TARLA MAHSULE ULUSOY ZEKERİYA NILMAZ) 1 322,66 676 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 19 TARLA FATİH ULUSOY SERVET ARPA 1 608,51 ABDURRAHMAN NOHUT(EKİ 677 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 20 TARLA DUMAN İSMAİL LECEK) 1 2212,86 BOŞ(KULLA 678 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 23 TARLA NILMAZ) 1100,34 679 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 24 TARLA MENDERES ULUSOY HALİL ARPA 1 700,75 HASAN 680 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 25 TARLA KAMİL DUMAN HÜSEYİN ARPA 1/2 797,86 HASAN 681 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 25 TARLA AVNİ DUMAN HÜSEYİN ARPA 1/2 797,86 682 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 26 TARLA CEMAL DOĞAN İSHAK ARPA 1 843,14 683 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 29 TARLA OSMAN AKDAĞ ALİ ARPA 1 1017,13 PANCAR(EKİ 684 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 30 TARLA ERDOĞAN AYDIN ZEYNEL LECEK) 1 1949,69 PANCAR(EKİ 685 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 31 TARLA RAMAZAN ULUSOY ŞANBAZ LECEK) 1 585,35 686 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 117 38 TARLA MENDERES ULUSOY HALİL ARPA 1 1043,16 ABDURRAHMAN 687 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 118 23 TARLA AYDIN İSMAİL ARPA 1 2928,82 688 AKSARAY ORTAKÖY PINARBAŞI 119 1 TARLA BAYRAM ATDERE HAYRULLAH ARPA 1 2337,8 689 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 298 TARLA NURİ ÖZDEMİR BOŞ 1 210,4 157 HASAN 690 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 299 TARLA NURİ BULAT HÜSEYİN BOŞ 1 959,62 691 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 300 TARLA HANİFE CÖMERT DERVİŞ BOŞ 1 1215,03 692 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 311 TARLA YAKUP DEMİREL BAYRAM BOŞ 1 2109,26 693 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 312 TARLA FADİME BARAN BUĞDAY 1 1849,24 694 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 319 TARLA SONER DEMİREL KİMYON 1 826,9 MEHMET 695 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 323 TARLA HAVA DEMİREL EMİN BOŞ 1 100,44 696 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 324 TARLA FATMA ATAK BOŞ 1 1903,46 697 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 337 TARLA GÜLER YAZICI BOŞ 1 2222,49 DELİ HÜSEYİN 698 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 338 TARLA VERESESİ BOŞ 1 589,56 DELİ HÜSEYİN 699 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 339 TARLA VERESESİ BOŞ 1 832,71 700 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 340 TARLA HİDAYET ÖZTUNÇ MEHMET BOŞ 1 1421,13 701 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 568 TARLA GÜRCÜ CALAYİR HALİL BOŞ 1 920,81 702 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 569 TARLA RAMAZAN ÖZTUNÇ BUĞDAY 1/2 2415,37 703 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 569 TARLA ALİ İHSAN KARAKAYA BUĞDAY 1/2 2415,37 704 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 573 TARLA ZEYNEP YAZICI OSMAN BOŞ 1 2850,09 705 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 578 TARLA AZİZ ÜNVER OSMAN BOŞ 1 2972,77 706 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 626 TARLA ALİ İHSAN ÖZDEMİR KİMYON 1 922,71 707 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 632 TARLA EKREM ÇELİK SEYİT BOŞ 1 1312,35 NOHUT(EKİ 708 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 634 TARLA ŞABAN SERİN BEKİR LECEK) 1 2271,23 709 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 637 TARLA ALİYE CÖMERTOĞLU ALİ BOŞ 1 1999,74 710 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 858 TARLA FATMA ÜNVER BABAOĞLAN BOŞ 1 1610,51 711 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 883 TARLA AHMET ÇELİK ENVER BUĞDAY 1 516,45 712 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 884 TARLA OSMAN DEMİREL BAYRAM BOŞ 1 2463,27 713 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 885 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 390,98 714 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 886 TARLA ZEKİ ÇELİK ABDULKADİR BOŞ 1 1119,52 715 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 894 TARLA IŞIN MUTLU REMZİ BOŞ 1 3327,63 716 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 895 TARLA AYŞE ÜNLÜ BOŞ 1 2132,75 717 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 896 TARLA CEVAT ÖZBEK BOŞ 1 1397,93 718 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 897 TARLA YAŞAR DEMİREL NECİP BOŞ 1 1859,92 719 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 976 TARLA DOYDUK YILDIZ MEHMET BOŞ 1 1611,19 720 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1085 TARLA YAŞAR BOZKURT KEMAL BOŞ 1 533,8 721 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1086 TARLA CEVRİYE BOZKURT HAMZA YONCA 1 3723,68 722 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1087 TARLA ERDOĞAN CÖMERT SADETTİN BUĞDAY 1 839,61 723 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1088 TARLA CEVRİYE BOZKURT HAMZA KAVUN 1 454,51 724 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1089 TARLA CEVRİYE BOZKURT HAMZA KAVUN 1 741,24 725 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1090 TARLA ERDOĞAN CÖMERT SADETTİN BOŞ 1 589,57 726 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1091 TARLA SERVET CÖMERT HALİLİBRAHİM BOŞ 1 2337,2 727 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1092 TARLA ÜMİT ATAK BUĞDAY 1 2857,35 728 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1093 TARLA ÖMER POLAT MAHMUT BOŞ 1 2028,08 729 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1113 TARLA MEHMET ALİ ÖZTAŞ BUĞDAY 1 2274,08 730 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1115 TARLA HASAN BASRİ DEMİR YAKUP BOŞ 1 1385,34 731 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1116 TARLA YILMAZ ÖZDEMİR YUSUF BOŞ 1 1627,45 732 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1117 TARLA HANİFİ ÖZDEMİR BUĞDAY 1 558,29 733 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1126 TARLA DEDE DEMİREL ŞAKİR BOŞ 1 843,41 734 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1127 TARLA ALİ BOZKURT BOŞ 1 1728,6 158 735 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 1128 TARLA MUSTAFA VERESESİ BOŞ 1 1945,8 736 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 6369 TARLA TAHİR ÖZDEN HACI YAKUP BOŞ 1 1196,16 737 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 6371 TARLA KERİM BULAT NEŞET BOŞ 1 1182,73 738 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 6514 TARLA VAHİDE MUTLU YUSUF BOŞ 1 1071,66 739 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 6524 TARLA AYŞE ÖZDEMİR CELAL BOŞ 1 195,99 740 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ MERKEZ 0 6526 TARLA OSMAN BARAN HASAN BOŞ 1 546,58 741 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 1 TARLA OSMAN EBER ARPA 1 2102,74 PANCAR(EKİ 742 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 2 TARLA RAHMİ EKER LECEK) 1 53,27 743 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 4 TARLA CENGİZ AKDOĞAN BUĞDAY 1 198,56 744 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 5 TARLA AHMET ÖZBAŞ BUĞDAY 1 718,17 745 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 6 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 731,17 746 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 7 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 815,91 747 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 8 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 2230,32 748 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 12 TARLA SULTAN BOZKURT İBRAHİM BUĞDAY 1 1899,61 RÜSTEM 749 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 13 TARLA HAYATİ BALCI RASİM BUĞDAY 1 644,4 750 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 15 TARLA REMZİ BOZKURT MURTAZA BUĞDAY 1 1017,83 751 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 21 TARLA ERCAN ERDEN BUĞDAY 1 35 RÜSTEM 752 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 25 TARLA HAYATİ BALCI RASİM BUĞDAY 1 450,74 BOĞAZKÖY TÜZEL 753 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 28 TARLA KİŞİLİĞİ BOŞ 1 1135,68 NOHUT(EKİ 754 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 29 TARLA METİN BULAT LECEK) 1 2620,42 755 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 119 TARLA DURMUŞ SAYIN RİFAT BUĞDAY 1 2010,81 756 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 120 TARLA ERDAL AKDOĞAN BUĞDAY 1 1033,85 BOŞ(KULLA 757 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 126 TARLA NAZMİYE BALCI RECEP NILMAZ) 1 46,64 BOŞ(KULLA 758 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 127 TARLA BERKAY BALCI RECEP NILMAZ) 1 2023,47 759 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 128 TARLA DURMUŞ SAYIN BUĞDAY 1 580,08 760 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 130 TARLA FADİME DENİZ ŞÜKRÜ BOŞ 1 1856,86 761 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 131 TARLA ALİ KOÇAK BUĞDAY 1 1159,66 762 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 227 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 63,42 763 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 232 TARLA BEKTAŞ SARSILMAZ REFAHADDİN BUĞDAY 1 2078,85 764 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 233 TARLA BEKTAŞ SARSILMAZ REFAHADDİN BUĞDAY 1 1254,33 765 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 235 TARLA OSMAN EKER BUĞDAY 1 1926,58 766 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 236 TARLA İSMAİL GÜRBÜZ BUĞDAY 1 1090,59 767 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 237 TARLA HAYATİ BALCI BUĞDAY 1 782,35 768 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 258 TARLA OSMAN EKER BUĞDAY 1 2207,35 MUHARREM 769 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 260 TARLA BOZYİGİT BUĞDAY 1 830,94 770 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 261 TARLA HİCRET ERASLAN BUĞDAY 1 1097,46 771 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 263 TARLA OSMAN EKER BUĞDAY 1 545,01 772 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 264 TARLA BEKTAŞ SARSILMAZ REFAHADDİN BUĞDAY 1 1355,74 773 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 265 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 735,77 774 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 286 TARLA YILMAZ EBİL BUĞDAY 1 1731,71 775 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 288 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 139,15 776 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 289 TARLA HAMİT EMEKTAR BUĞDAY 1 1948,86 777 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 290 TARLA TAYFUN AKDOĞAN BUĞDAY 1 2622,91 778 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 291 TARLA FADİMANA BALCI SEYİT BOŞ 1 3144,84 779 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 292 TARLA MEHMET BULDUK ABDULLAH BUĞDAY 1 591,3 159 780 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 293 TARLA ERCAN BİLGE BUĞDAY 1 1562,29 781 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 298 TARLA ALAADDİN YILMAZ OSMAN BOŞ 1 2718,86 782 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 419 TARLA ALİ İHSAN KARTAY İMDAT BUĞDAY 1 3165,25 783 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 443 TARLA ERCAN ERDEM BUĞDAY 1 465,89 784 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 444 TARLA ERCAN ERDEM BUĞDAY 1 778,39 785 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 446 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 1381,47 786 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 447 TARLA MUSTAFA KOÇAK BUĞDAY 1 2208,8 787 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 455 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 208,07 788 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 458 TARLA EROL BALIBEY REMZİ BUĞDAY 1 2045,22 789 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 459 TARLA İMRAN KARAKUŞ BUĞDAY 1 935,03 790 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 461 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK CEMAL BUĞDAY 1 3107,38 791 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 600 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 4126,63 792 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 604 TARLA DURMUŞ SAYIN BUĞDAY 1 2310,16 793 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 605 TARLA EMİN ŞAYİR BUĞDAY 1 152,52 794 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 606 TARLA TAHİR ARSLAN İSMAİL BOŞ 1 22,69 795 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 794 TARLA ERCAN BİLGE BUĞDAY 1 1204,59 796 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 833 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 914,98 797 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 834 TARLA HİCRET ERASLAN BUĞDAY 1 1545,44 798 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 835 TARLA OSMAN EKER BUĞDAY 1 2552,44 799 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 837 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 1320,57 800 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 838 TARLA YILMAZ ERDİL BUĞDAY 1 1427,87 801 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 840 TARLA MUSTAFA EMEKTAR BUĞDAY 1 6136,88 802 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 841 TARLA DURMUŞ SAYIN BUĞDAY 1 1017,42 803 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 885 TARLA OSMAN EKER BUĞDAY 1 758,12 804 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 886 TARLA İBRAHİM BEKLEVİÇ BUĞDAY 1 1397,58 805 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 888 TARLA MUSTAFA KOÇAK BUĞDAY 1 1549,14 806 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 891 TARLA OSMAN EKER TAŞ BUĞDAY 1 346,09 807 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 896 TARLA ERCAN BAYRAK BUĞDAY 1 3406,39 808 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 897 TARLA ANİŞ TOSUN MEHMET BOŞ 1 1582,96 809 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 902 TARLA HİCRET ERASLAN BUĞDAY 1 7543,07 BOŞ(KULLA 810 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 3411 TARLA MEHMET İNEL HASAN NILMAZ) 1 2383,41 811 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 3806 TARLA AYDEMİR BALIBEY BUĞDAY 1 1120 812 AKSARAY SARIYAHŞİ BOĞAZKÖY 0 3851 TARLA MUSTAFA KOÇAK BUĞDAY 1 1130,62 813 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 1758 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 36257,5 814 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 2848 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 36452,22 815 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 2860 TARLA İBRAHİM KOYUNCU MEHMET ARPA 1 3938,29 816 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3060 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 240,93 817 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3061 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 19318,73 818 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3082 TARLA SÜLEYMAN MUTLU MEVLÜT ARPA 1 1335,61 819 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3085 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 7818,02 820 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3087 TARLA HASAN ÖZBAY VELİ YONCA 1 9743 821 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3090 TARLA TOSUN ŞANLI AHMET ARPA 1 14798,57 822 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3091 TARLA HACI VELİ ALAN HASAN YONCA 1/2 3261,69 823 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3091 TARLA MUSTAFA ŞANLI RECEP YONCA 1/2 3261,69 824 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3097 TARLA YAHYA SÖYLEMEZ İBRAHİM ARPA 1 16084,87 825 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3122 TARLA HASAN YUMUŞAK MEHMET ARPA 1 120,66 160 826 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3123 TARLA SÜLEYMAN BÖGE BUĞDAY 1 689,01 827 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3125 TARLA TAHSİN SOLAK CELAL YONCA 1 4067,17 828 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3126 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 11860,62 829 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3127 TARLA MUSTAFA YUMUŞAK VELİ ARPA 3/4 7524,41 830 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3127 TARLA SÜLEYMAN ÖZBAY BOŞ 1/4 7524,41 831 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3134 TARLA MEHMET YUMUŞAK İBRAHİM ARPA 1 898,61 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 832 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3135 TARLA HASAN YUMUŞAK MEHMET KİLECEK) 1 6027,18 833 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3136 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6695,76 834 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3161 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 13173,62 835 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3187 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1868,95 836 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3272 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 7582,38 837 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3276 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6515,35 838 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3277 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 15161,67 839 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3279 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 31295,28 840 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3280 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 9201,21 841 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3370 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 3627,33 842 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3377 TARLA FERAT GÖRMEZ İBRAHİM BUĞDAY 1 2084,38 843 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3428 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 11661,55 844 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3432 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 26722,17 845 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3434 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 4645,52 846 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3435 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6989,72 847 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3685 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 21649,38 848 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3688 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 24331,98 849 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3689 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 25312,33 850 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3690 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 2925,43 851 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3691 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 44483,27 PANCAR(EKİ 852 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3852 TARLA VEYİS BÖGE HACI OSMAN LECEK) 1 1549,17 853 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 3853 TARLA YAHYA SÖYLEMEZ ARPA 1 2929,96 854 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4043 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 16803,98 855 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4047 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6791,03 856 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4050 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 4325,42 857 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4052 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6497,35 858 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4061 TARLA HİDAYET SOLAK MEMİŞ YONCA 1 4214,74 859 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4062 TARLA HİDAYET SOLAK MEMİŞ YONCA 1 2737,1 860 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4067 TARLA CUMA SARI HALİL ARPA 1 2503,15 861 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4068 TARLA MEHMET SARI YONCA 1 4105,1 862 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4093 TARLA ABDİ ASLANHAN İHSAN YONCA 1 4732,02 863 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4094 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 79,11 864 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4096 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 57,18 865 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4097 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 10650,62 MUHAMMET 866 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4173 TARLA SÖYLEMEZ MEHMET YONCA 1 5993,63 867 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4537 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6788,74 868 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4538 TARLA MUSTAFA AĞIR HANİFİ YONCA 1 5997,35 869 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4544 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 21101,34 870 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4545 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 4514,09 161 PANCAR(EKİ 871 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4550 TARLA OSMAN KÜRKCÜ İBRAHİM LECEK) 1 9134,9 872 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4551 TARLA MEHMET SARI SAMİ ARPA 1 5198,84 873 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4564 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 22144,23 874 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4937 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 6656,08 875 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4940 TARLA BAYRAM ALİ BÖGE SÜLEYMAN BUĞDAY 1 1161,87 876 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4957 TARLA OSMAN KOYUNCU CAFER YONCA 1 8764,69 877 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4958 TARLA HÜSEYİN BÖGE YONCA 1 74,88 878 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4963 TARLA ERGÜN BÖGE TAHİR ARPA 1 1984,25 NOHUT(EKİ 879 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4970 TARLA HANİFİ AKALIN HALİL LECEK) 1 1025,89 MUHAMMED SAİT 880 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4986 TARLA SOLAK ALİ ARPA 1 363,38 881 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 4995 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 2050,65 882 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5023 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 1636,71 883 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5025 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 483,66 884 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5026 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 3589,79 885 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5079 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 486,56 886 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5114 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 5895 887 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5116 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 5685,66 888 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5117 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 1576,06 889 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5118 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 3685,54 AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 890 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5119 TARLA MEVLÜT DÜZGÜN BAYRAM KİLECEK) 1 12664,37 HACI MEVLÜT 891 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5124 TARLA BEKMEZCİ KEMAL YONCA 1 1578,04 892 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5125 TARLA ÖMER SOLAK MUSTAFA ARPA 1 1257,15 893 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5127 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 15572,3 894 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 5128 TARLA İSMAİL KAŞ MEHMET YONCA 1 5823,05 895 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6374 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 116110,73 896 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6375 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 18224,31 897 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6391 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 3813,12 898 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6418 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 233,06 899 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6419 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 1540,83 900 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6420 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 13706,44 901 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6421 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 623,83 902 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6429 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 835,16 903 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6431 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 9753,85 904 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6433 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 2539,31 905 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 6434 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 5287,71 906 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7131 TARLA BAYRAM KOYUNCU TAYFUR YONCA 1 1188,74 907 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7892 Tarla MURAT AĞIR MAHMUT YONCA 1 8523,83 908 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7893 TARLA MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 25781,27 MUHAMMET 909 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7900 TARLA SÖYLEMEZ MEHMET YONCA 1 7681,21 910 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7901 TARLA HÜSEYİN AĞIR VEYİS YONCA 1 20925,73 911 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7922 TARLA SÜLEYMAN OĞUZ İSMAİL BOŞ 1 20912,44 912 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7923 TARLA YUSUF DAĞLI MUSTAFA ARPA 1 6871,25 913 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 7972 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ 1 152376,71 162 SULTANHANI 914 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 8124 YOL BELEDİYESİ BOŞ 1 545,61 SULTANHANI 915 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 8125 ARSA BELEDİYESİ BOŞ 1 15805,29 916 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 8335 TARLA MEHMET ALİ ŞANLI BİLAL YONCA 1 5664,43 ABDURRAHM AYÇİÇEĞİ(E 917 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 8337 TARLA MUHARREM ATAR AN KİLECEK) 1 7308,72 918 AKSARAY SULTANHANI MERKEZ 0 8363 TARLA AHMET TELLİ HALİL YONCA 1 2447,64 HAM 919 ANKARA EVREN MERKEZ 0 3507 TOPRAK MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 648,7 920 ANKARA EVREN MERKEZ 0 3545 TARLA TOSUN KOÇAK HANİFİ BOŞ 1 719,23 MÜFREZ HAM 921 ANKARA EVREN MERKEZ 0 4838 TOPR MALİYE HAZİNESİ BOŞ 1 1106,85 922 ANKARA EVREN MERKEZ 0 5048 TARLA MÜŞERREF ÖCAL BUĞDAY 1 505,91 923 ANKARA EVREN MERKEZ 0 5049 TARLA MÜŞERREF ÖCAL BUĞDAY 1 2463,19 List of Assets (New Surface Facilities) NO. İL İLÇE KÖY/MAH ADA PARSEL CINSI KULLANICI ÜRÜN HİSSE HASAR ALAN 1 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4960 TARLA MEHMET KOYUNCU ARPA TAM 12994,22 2 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5013 TARLA KAZIM KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 78,77 3 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5014 TARLA KAZIM KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 3982,91 4 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5037 TARLA KAZIM KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 29132,45 5 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5039 TARLA AHMET TELLİ ARPA TAM 9024,22 6 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5121 MERA MEHMET KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 19791,03 7 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5122 MERA MEHMET KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 59676,79 8 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5160 MERA İSMAİL AYDIN YONCA TAM 7109,14 9 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5164 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 89347,18 10 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5165 TARLA MEHMET KOYUNCU YONCA 1/2 73566,29 11 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5165 TARLA BAYRAM KOYUNCU YONCA 1/2 73566,29 List of Assets (Well Areas) NO. İL İLÇE KÖY/MAH ADA PARSEL CINSI KULLANICI ÜRÜN HİSSE HASAR ALAN 1 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 170 TARLA ZEYNEP KARA BUĞDAY 14/20 11753,22 2 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 173 TARLA AHMET ÖZUSLU BOŞ TAM 551,32 3 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 174 TARLA GÖKHAN ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 1115,5 4 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 177 TARLA KAZIM ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 13120,73 5 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 180 TARLA HAMDİ GÜNGÖR ARPA 2/3 10386,86 6 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 180 TARLA SÜLEYMAN YILDIZ BUĞDAY 1/3 10386,86 7 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 282 TARLA BAYRAM ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 7426 8 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 283 TARLA ZEHRA KARA ARPA TAM 3219,67 9 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 292 TARLA ABDULLAH ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 1942,39 10 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 293 TARLA AHMET ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 9240,92 11 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 300 TARLA AYŞE ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 760,6 12 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 301 TARLA CUMA EMRE ARPA 1/12 52533,11 13 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 301 TARLA YUSUF KARA ARPA 6/72 52533,11 163 14 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 301 TARLA BAĞDAT AYDEMİR ARPA 6/72 52533,11 15 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 301 TARLA FARUK ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1/4 52533,11 16 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 301 TARLA MUSTAFA ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1/2 52533,11 17 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 307 TARLA HALİL ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1/3 12551,02 18 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 307 TARLA İSA ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1/3 12551,02 19 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 307 TARLA HÜSEYİN ÖZTÜRK ARPA 1/3 12551,02 20 AKSARAY EMİRGAZİ BESCİ 0 433 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 12880,9 21 AKSARAY ESKİL GÜNEŞLİ 145 23 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 24256,95 22 AKSARAY ESKİL GÜNEŞLİ 148 2 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 4840,97 23 AKSARAY ESKİL GÜNEŞLİ 150 2 TARLA İSMET AKBAL YONCA 1/2 11207,88 24 AKSARAY ESKİL GÜNEŞLİ 150 2 TARLA ŞAMİL AKBAL YONCA 1/2 11207,88 25 AKSARAY ESKİL GÜNEŞLİ 151 3 TARLA ABDİ AĞIR YONCA TAM 3941,45 26 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA TAHİR ALTINSOY BOŞ 13/28 6282,4 27 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA İSMAİL ALTINSOY ARPA 3/28 6282,4 28 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA AHMET ALTINSOY ARPA 3/28 6282,4 29 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA FETTAH ALTINSOY YONCA 3/28 6282,4 30 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA ÖMER ALTINSOY YONCA 3/28 6282,4 31 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3285 TARLA AYŞE ALTINSOY BOŞ 3/28 6282,4 32 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3398 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 3261,91 33 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 3399 TARLA ZİYA TELLİ ARPA TAM 24,24 34 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4125 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU ARPA 1/3 6224,34 MISIR(EKEC 35 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4125 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU 1/3 6224,34 EK) 36 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4125 TARLA MUSTAFA KOYUNCU ARPA 1/3 6224,34 37 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4660 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 4152,72 38 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4664 TARLA RAMAZAN KOYUNCU YONCA 1/2 1750,38 MISIR(EKEC 39 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4664 TARLA RAMAZAN KOYUNCU 1/2 1750,38 EK) 40 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4689 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 20169,17 41 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4690 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 8573,21 42 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4700 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 4899,49 43 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4705 TARLA ŞERİFE ALAN ARPA TAM 10005,05 44 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4707 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU ARPA 1/3 1031,59 MISIR(EKEC 45 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4707 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU 1/3 1031,59 EK) HACI OSMAN 46 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4707 TARLA YONCA 1/3 1031,59 KOYUNCU 47 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4708 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU BUĞDAY 1/2 3660,84 48 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4708 TARLA MUSTAFA KOYUNCU ARPA 1/2 3660,84 49 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4719 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 1154,19 50 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4720 MERA İSMET KÜRÜK ARPA TAM 8289,93 51 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4726 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU ARPA 9/280 10861,76 52 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4744 TARLA FAHRİYE KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 10121,43 53 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4747 TARLA HACI MUSA KOYUNCU BUĞDAY TAM 8036,8 54 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4749 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 1019,26 PANCAR(EK 55 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4752 TARLA HAŞİM KOYUNCU TAM 11266,53 ECEK) 56 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4764 TARLA MEVLÜT DÖLEK BUĞDAY TAM 6442,85 57 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4767 TARLA ALİ DÖLEK YONCA TAM 4312,47 MISIR(EKEC 58 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4775 TARLA MUSTAFA AKİN 2/3 9146,44 EK) 164 59 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4775 TARLA HAYDAR AKİN ARPA 1/3 9146,44 60 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4775 TARLA ALİ AKİN 1/3 9146,44 PANCAR(EK 61 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4776 TARLA YAKUP ATAR TAM 512,33 ECEK) CELALETTİN AYÇİÇEĞİ(EK 62 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4778 TARLA TAM 10895,93 KOYUNCU ECEK) 63 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4779 TARLA OSMAN KOYUNCU YONCA 3/28 10974,99 64 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4779 TARLA BAYRAM KOYUNCU YONCA 3/28 10974,99 MISIR(EKEC 65 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4779 TARLA FAHRİYE KOYUNCU 22/28 10974,99 EK) 66 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 4780 TARLA ALİ DÖLEK YONCA 1/2 426,11 67 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5035 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 2222,16 MISIR(EKEC 68 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5144 MERA RAMAZAN KOYUNCU TAM 3684,26 EK) 69 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5156 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 9388,06 70 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5173 TARLA MEHMET ALİ ŞANLI YONCA TAM 7425,2 71 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5198 MERA ALİ DÖLEK YONCA 1/3 12631,32 72 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5198 MERA İSMAİL DÖLEK YONCA 1/3 12631,32 73 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5198 MERA HALİL DÖLEK YONCA 1/3 12631,32 74 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5236 TARLA İSMAİL ALTINSOY YONCA 1/4 10492,51 75 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5245 TARLA ÜNAL KARA BUĞDAY TAM 1920,24 76 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5375 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 7906,54 77 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5379 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 1554,62 78 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5380 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 1679,73 79 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5381 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 7790,31 80 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 5506 TARLA ÜNAL KARA BUĞDAY TAM 9046,87 81 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 6282 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 10392,62 82 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7722 TARLA HAYDAR ACAR ARPA TAM 9308,28 MALİYE 83 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7723 TARLA BOŞ TAM 699,72 HAZİNESİ(BOTAŞ) 84 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7752 TARLA MEHMET KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 1178,71 MALİYE 85 KONYA SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7753 TARLA BOŞ TAM 46,07 HAZİNESİ(BOTAŞ) 86 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7915 TARLA RAMAZAN KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 10960,54 87 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7916 TARLA VEHBİ KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 181,09 88 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7926 TARLA MEHMET KOYUNCU YONCA TAM 4218,89 89 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7927 TARLA MEHMET KÖRÜK ARPA TAM 7100,58 90 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 7930 TARLA ALAATTİN ÖZTÜRK ARPA TAM 10030,05 91 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 8178 MERA KAMU ORTA MALI BOŞ TAM 1353,49 92 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 8335 TARLA MEHMET ALİ ŞANLI YONCA TAM 9412,33 93 AKSARAY SULTANHANI SULTANHANI 0 8357 TARLA DOĞAN DÖLEK YONCA TAM 437,1 165 Appendix 8. Overview of the Project-Affected Population The data obtained from both field study and the literature review is given below. While the province and district level data is analyzed by desktop studies, the demographic and socio-economic characteristics of the PAPs are explained based on findings from the census and socio-economic survey. Province-District Level Overview of Project-Affected Population Looking at the settlements affected by the land acquisition of the Project at the district level, land acquisition is planned in a total of 8 districts including Evren district in Ankara province; Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Merkez, Sultanhanı and Eskil districts in Aksaray province, and Emirgazi districts in Konya province. Land acquisition is planned for 14 parcels in Evren district (Pump stations and pipelines) and 13 parcels in Emirgazi district (well areas and surface facilities). Therefore, land acquisition impacts of the Project are very limited in these two districts. Development agencies were established in 2006 with the law numbered 5449 on the purpose of creation of regional development plans in Turkey, the implementation and monitoring of these plans at the local level within the framework of policies and programs. Statistical data showing the social and economic status of the regions and development planning at the local level within the framework of these data are made through these agencies. The development agencies related to the Project are Ankara (Evren) located in the TR51 sub-region, Aksaray (Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Merkez, Sultanhanı and Eskil districts) located in the TR 71 sub-region and Konya (Emirgazi district) in the TR52 sub-region. Evren District of Ankara Province Evren district is located in the first region which also includes Ankara, Bala, Evren, Haymana and Şereflikoçhisar districts. This region, where population density is low and agriculture constitutes the basis of economic activities, covers the south and southeast parts of Ankara. Apart from Şereflikoçhisar, there are problems in terms of physical infrastructure as well as basic social services in the region which has a high population loss. Improvement of education, health, transportation and accommodation facilities; increasing the value-added agricultural production; development of rural industries; planning alternative tourism types to be activated in and around Salt Lake and Hirfanlı Dam Lake are considered at the districts of region which are also located at lower levels in development rankings. The population of Evren district according to the Address Based Population Registration System (ABPRS) is presented below. Evren is the city with the lowest population in Ankara and its population is declining by years. While the population has been decreasing from 2014 to 2018, there has been an increase in 2018 (Tablo 15-1). Tablo 15-1 Population of Evren District Gender Years TOTAL POPULATION Men Women 2018 1.776 1.830 3.606 2017 1.365 1.388 2.753 2016 1.369 1.415 2.784 2015 1.401 1.446 2.847 2014 1.407 1.494 2.901 166 Source: Address Based Population Registration System (ABPRS), TUIK The most important vulnerability related to migration in the districts around Ankara is the loss of population in rural areas. In the period of 2007-2012, the population of Çamlıdere, Bala, Evren, Haymana, Kalecik and Güdül districts decreased by 18% to 30%. Deficiencies of infrastructure in rural areas; limitations of social services such as education and health; the lack of sector diversity; the loss of population fed by reasons such as the low return on the agricultural sector; the aging of the population in the rural area of Ankara leads to consequences such as the reduced agricultural areas and the agricultural population. When the ratio of the elderly population to the total population of the district is examined in the districts of Ankara, one of the districts with the oldest population is Evren. According to population projections, the median age in Ankara will be 36 in 2023. The population of Ankara is two years older than the general population of Turkey; youngert han Izmir, older than Istanbul. When the overall population of Ankara is analyzed, the trends indicate that the rates of the elderly population will increase. It is seen that elderliness is an important problem in the perimeter districts such as Evren in the current situation. The impacts and results of the increasing elderly population in districts such as Çamlıdere, Güdül and Evren are already seen today. When the poverty rate of TR5 Region where Ankara is located together with Konya and Karaman provinces is examined, it is seen that 22.9% of the population experienced a significant decrease in the year after in 2006 and this value changed between 19-22% during 2008-2015. As of 2016, 92.93% of the population in Ankara has social security. Compared with values in Ankara, Turkey and the developed countries, the increase in the average electricity consumption of households can be read as an increase in welfare. While the average consumption of Ankara in districts such as Çankaya, Gölbaşı, Etimesgut and Yenimahalle was the highest; the indicator value in the less developed districts such as Çamlıdere, Bala, Evren, Güdül is very low. Districts of Aksaray Province (Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Ortaköy, Merkez, Sultanhanı and Eskil) Aksaray province, where the project will affect the 6 districts due to the land acquisition activities, was a “sanjak” of Konya until the Republican period in history. In 1920, province status was granted to Aksaray. In 1933, the province status was abolished and connected to Niğde as a district. Aksaray became a province again on June 15, 1989. Aksaray province has 7 districts, 41 towns and 151 villages. Aksaray is located in the central Kızılırmak section of the Central Anatolia where the North and South Anatolian mountains are separated from each other. The city is surrounded by Nevşehir in the east, Niğde in the southeast, Konya in the west, Ankara in the north and Kırşehir in the northeast. Aksaray province has a cold semi continental climate type. Summers are dry. Snowfall starts in November and ends in April. Aksaray's natural vegetation consist of spring grasses, poppies, daisies, keven and other herbs, leaves with a steep appearance and semi-arid plants. Since the hot and arid climate structure prevails in summer, the grasses that grow in spring, dries in autumn and take the steppe structure of the land. There are oak groves on the Hasandağı and Ekecik Mountains. The important mountains of Aksaray are Hasandağı, Küçük Hasandağı and Ekecik Mountain. There are plateaus formed by volcanic mountains and lava like Hasandığı, Melendiz Mountains and Ekecik Mountain in the region. A large part of the Konya plain is within the boundaries of Aksaray. Uluırmak, which flows from the Melendiz Mountains to the Tuz Gölü, creates a wide plateau. There is no other lake in Aksaray than Turkey's second largest lake in the Salt Lake (2400 km2). The area around the lake is surrounded by marshes and the terrain outside the marsh has been barren. The deepest part of the lake does not exceed 1 167 meter. There are two types of water resources in and around Aksaray. There are numerous fault and valley sources in the north and east. Water sources in the vicinity of Hasandağı are generally valley sources. The resources in the Salt Lake and Konya Plain are mostly artesian wells. In the northern part of the Obruk plateau, there are marshes in Eskil and Yenikent. The city center of Aksaray is connected to the surrounding provinces and other parts of the country through four state roads. In the north, there are connections with Ankara via E-90, to Nevşehir in the east, to Konya in the west and by E-90 on the south by way of Niğde and Adana. Average household size is 3.54 in Aksaray province according to ADNKS 2018 data. The population sizes of the districts affected by the land acquisition of the Project are given in the table below. Tablo 15-2 Population of Project Affected Districts in Aksaray 2016 2017 2018 District Men Women Total Men Women Total Men Women Total Ağaçören 1413 1339 2752 1406 1306 2712 1560 1474 3034 Eskil 8645 8500 17145 8693 8601 17294 8794 8620 17414 Merkez 105563 107525 213088 109444 111015 220459 110412 112754 223166 Sultanhan 5215 4870 10085 5054 4864 9918 5220 4988 10208 Ortaköy 9136 9401 18537 9059 9455 18514 9678 10280 19958 Sarıyahşi 1708 1685 3393 1667 1675 3342 2119 2141 4260 Source: Address Based Population Registration System (ABPRS), TUIK In the province of Aksaray, which has a young population, mostly small districts, especially Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören districts are migrating. Movements outside the province are mostly targeted to large and close provinces such as Konya and Ankara. As identified in the field study, the districts with the highest population movements inside the province and towards the other provinces are Sarıyahşi, Ağaçören, Güzelyurt and Ortaköy in Aksaray. Considering the direction of population movements among the districts, it is observed that the settlements located on the mountainous terrain, which presents geographically challenging production conditions, and which are problematic in terms of transportation to the center, are migrating to the provinces and metropolitan cities rather than from the center of the province. Intense migration from the areas where transportation, housing, communication, health, education and social security services cannot be delivered or inadequate, especially in mountainous remote rural areas of the province, to the nearest provinces and metropolitan cities, also points to the developmental differences within the region. The socio-economic structure of Aksaray is based on agriculture and animal husbandry. 70% of the active population is actively engaged in agriculture and livestock. 7% of the economically active population of Aksaray, which is estimated to be approximately 150.000 people between the ages of 15-64, is employed in the industrial sector. The rest of the population is employed in the service sector. In terms of competitive capacity, agriculture and financial indicators, it is noteworthy that the center of Aksaray is in the first place.19 As observed in the field study, there are seasonal workers especially working in agricultural sector in the areas affected by Project land acquisition. The majority of the seasonal workers come from Hatay, Kilis, Şanlıurfa provinces of Turkey or from Syria to work between April and September, and the majority of these workers are Syrian immigrants. They are working in agriculture as uninsured and low- paid. The seasonal workers coming to the region usually stay in their own tents set up near the 19 Ahiler Development Agency, 2013.TR71 Region Districts Socio-Economic Development Analysis. 168 fountains or along the roads and do not pay for their accommodation. They don’t have access to any infrastructure (such as toilets, clean water etc.). 54.4% of Aksaray lands are suitable for agriculture and the remaining 45.6% are meadows, pastures, defective forests and unproductive forests. In agricultural areas with 420,430 hectares; cereals, legumes, industrial plants, tuberous plants, fruits and vegetables are grown. 86% of arable land is dry and 14% is irrigated. Tablo 15-3 Land Assets of Aksaray Province Type of Land Ha % Agricultural Land 420.430 54,46 Pasture 277.803 35,97 Forest Land 12.528 1,62 Non-agricultural land (including settlements) 10.376 1,34 Total Water Surfaces (Including Ponds) 51.048 6,61 Total 772.185 100 Crop production is concentrated on cereals and alternation systems are used in agricultural land use. Cereals are cultivated in 50,9% of the 420,430 hectares of agricultural land in Aksaray. The largest cultivation area in cereals production is wheat and later barley. Fodder crops for animal production are made in 1.5% of cultivated areas. This rate is 3.25% in Turkey, and below the average Aksaray Turkey. Industrial plants such as sugar beet and sunflower production are also produced. In Turkey, the fruit production areas constitute 5% of the total agricultural area. In Aksaray, this rate is 1.3%. In general, cultivation of apple, pear, apricot, cherry, walnut, grape and plum fruit species are made in the province. In recent years, there has been a tendency towards walnut without marketing and storage problems. While the vegetable production is made in 3% out of the total agricultural areas in Turkey, vegetable production in Aksaray remains at 1%. Vegetable production is generally carried out in irrigated lands. In Aksaray, animal husbandry is carried out together with crop production as in other surrounding provinces. Aksaray has a significancy in terms of cattle population among the surrounding provinces although the level of specialization in rural economic structure is low and traditional production structure is predominant. Aksaray is above the Turkey average (80%) in terms of culture and hybrid cattle population, and under the average of Turkey (20%) in terms of the domestic cattle population. 96% of the small cattle are the domestic and merino sheep breed, while the remaining 4% are mohair and hair goats. There are two meat integrated plants belonging to one private sector and one municipality. Poultry farming in the province is made in the form of small enterprises with limited facilities. The production of eggs and meat chickens cannot meet their needs. Turkey, goose, duck production is carried out in the form of household production. Most of the egg production is performed in the city center. This case is also one of the reasons for out-migration and poses a great risk for the future. Insufficient groundwater and drought risks the sustainability of irrigated agricultural production in the agricultural areas of the region, pose a threat to particularly rural people whose livelihoods depend on agriculture. 169 Emirgazi District of Konya Province Konya, located in the TR52 Region, is the province with the least emigration in its region. The city is surrounded by Aksaray at north, Eregli at south, Karapinar district in the west and Niğde province in the east. The area of the district is 883.2 km². There are two villages and seven villages of Emirgazi. The transportation infrastructure of the district is based on the highway. The district is connected to Konya and Adana provinces by Ereğli-Karapınar highway. Karapinar district is 39 km away and Konya city center is 141 km away. The distance of the district to the nearest airport is 147 km. The lands of the Emirgazi district in the Central Anatolian Basin are generally covered with plains and steppes. The districts, which are very poor in terms of geographical resources, have a clayey and calcareous structure. The only forested area of the district is the oak in the southern part of Karacadağ. Emirgazi district, with 88.326,61 hectares, covers 2,16% of Konya and 0.11% of Turkey. 85.10% of the total area of the district is agricultural lands; this ratio is above the average of Turkey and Konya average. 8.78% of the total area is reserved for meadow and pasture areas. The forest area constitutes 1.63% of the total area. The population of the Besci settlement in Emirgazi district affected by the land acquisition of the Project is 422 people according to TUIK 2018 data. The table showing the population of Emirgazi district is given below. As can be seen in the table, the Emirgazi population has a tendency to decrease in the last four years. Tablo 15-4 Population of Emirgazi District 2015 2016 2017 2018 District Men Women Total Men Women Total Men Women Total Men Women Total Emirgazi 4444 4495 8939 4394 4368 8762 4351 4334 8685 4505 4444 8949 Source: Address Based Population Registration System (ABPRS), TUIK According to ABPRS data, 59.03% of the population of Emirgazi is in the 15-64 age group which can be defined as active population. This rate is lower than the average of Konya and Turkey. The elderly population which is over 65 years is above Konya and Turkey with an average rate of 8.81%. The economy of Emirgazi district is entirely based on agriculture. Although it has very large agricultural areas, it is one of the districts which have the most adverse conditions as underground and surface water level. The region is also is the least rainfall areas of Turkey. The total land cultivated in Emirgazi is 427.754 decares. Field agriculture is carried out in 75.1% of these lands. Since dry farming is generally performed in the district, it is observed that the area allocated for fallow is 24.9%. 92.98% of the total cultivated land of the Emirgazi district is dry land and 7.02% of it is irrigated lands. Dry land ratio is well above the rate of dry land in Konya and Turkey.Vegetable activities in the district is not much done, fruit processing activity is almost negligible.20 The most grown crops in Emirgazi are wheat, barley and corn. Among these products, the highest cultivation area is wheat with 60.21%. Wheat yield (254 kg / da) in the district is below the average of Konya (324 kg / da). Barley yield is also below the average in Konya.The corn cultivated area constitutes 0.69% of the total area and yields 1.070 kg / da. Vegetable growing is not performed in the district. 20 Mevlana Kalkınma Ajansı, 2014. Emirgazi İlçe Raporu. 170 While apple production is made in 20.15% of the area allocated for fruit cultivation in the district, viticulture is made in 72.24% of lands. In Emirgazi district, 84,33% of total meadow-pasture and forest areas are meadow-pasture area and 15,67% is forest area. Grassland area ratio in the district is significantly greater than thegrassland rates of Konya and Turkey. However, due to the fact that the pasture areas in the district are mostly barren, the yield is low. There are 12.850 decares of fodder crops in the district, 31.1% of this area is clover, 50.6% of silage corn, 18.3% of the vetch is grown. Fodder cropproduction area in the district consists 2.40% of Konya fodder crop cultivation area and 1.7% of fodder crops cultivation area of the region.2% of Konya alfalfa plantation area, 3,1% of silage corn planting area and 1,8% of vetch area is located in Emirgazi district. As of 2013, there are a total of 22,142 bovine animals in the district. The cattle in the district constitutes 3,09% of the Konya cattle population and 2,86% of the cattle population of the region. The potential for cattle in the district is very low compared to Konya and the Region. The reason for this is that due to the insufficient production of fodder crops, the use of concentrated feed increases the costs and the low number of animals due to the low meadow-pasture yield. As of 2013, there are 56.400 sheep and 2.470 goats in the district. All of the sheep in the district is a domestic breed and the goats are all hair goats. The rates of goat presence in Konya and Region goats are decreasing by years. There is no agricultural industrial facility in the district that receives its input directly from the district or outside the district. In Emirgazi district, there is no production activity for any of the branches of industry providing input to agriculture. Agricultural inputs such as fertilizers, pesticides, seeds, seedlings and agricultural tools and machinery are supplied from Ereğli, Karapınar and Konya. There are 15 elementary and 2 secondary schools in Emirgazi district. 97 teachers and 1770 students in primary education and 22 teachers and 214 students in secondary education are continuing education. Drinking water is available in all villages and towns of the district. There is no sewerage system in the quarters and villages. There are 1 health center in Işıklar and Demirci Quarters and 112 Emergency Services in the district center. Household Socio-Economic Profile Demographic Profile The demographic data gathered fromhousehold socio-economic survey applied to the land owners are given in the tables below. According to the results of the field study, the average household size is 4.30. This indicator shows that households consist of about 4-5 people. Tablo 15-5 Average Household Size in the Project Area Number of interviewed households Total number of household members Average household size 205 882 4.30 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The households in the sample mostly reside in the settlement throughout the year. Especially during the interviews conducted with settlement heads, it was stated that the settlements had a huge emigration in the past but recently it slowed down and became stagnant. The fact that the households 171 in the settlements reside in the same place throughout the year also points to this situation. Following table (Figure 2) shows the living patterns in the Project-affected area. Figure 2 Living Patterns in the Project Area 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Continually Seasonally Rarely Not living in the project area Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The average age value of the interviewed households is 36.61 while the level of education is very low. The low ratio of high school or higher education graduates indicates this situation while most PAPs in the interviewed households are primary school graduates. The results of the field study indicate that the number of illiterate people in the population above the age of 65 is quite high. In terms of employment opportunities of the Project, low education level of Project-affected populations causes a disadvantage. Figure 3 Education Profile of Project- Affected Population 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 Students in PAHs mostly benefit from education with transportation support provided by the Ministry of Education because there are no educational institutions at village level settlements. Children in all households, except those living in the districts and towns, go to school with transport support. Following figure shows the number of students in the interviewed households (Figure 4). 172 Figure 4 Number of Students in PAHs 50 46 45 46 46 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 6 3 5 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 As seen in the figure below, interviewed households consist mainly of housewives, farmers, students and retirees. Thus, retirement salary is an important input for PAHs (Figure 5). On the other hand, farming is the main livelihood source in the project area. Labor and civil servants are much less common as income generating employment. As indicated in other consultations conducted in the field survey, housewives are also highly engaged in husbandry and agriculture activities, but they have not identified themselves from this aspect in the surveys. Women's participation in the labor force is an important issue because their contribution to the economy is not visible. Figure 5 Employment Status in the Project Area 250 219 229 189 200 150 114 100 44 45 50 31 26 15 7 17 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The social insurance ownership status of the PAHs is given in the figure below. PAPs have a high ownership degree of social insurance, and agricultural insurance is the most important source of this assurance. Figure 6 Social Insurance Ownership Status of Project-Affected Population 173 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Uninsured Social General Green Card Private Other Insurance Health Insurance Institution Insurance Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 In terms of health facilities, there are generally family health centers in the affected settlements and doctors, nurses and midwives are employed in these facilities. Settlements without health facilities apply to hospitals and health centers in district centers. The table below shows whether there is a health facility in the settlements and, if not, the distance to the nearest health center. Most of the PAPs surveyed indicated no health problems. Those with chronic diseases are mostly elderly people. Tablo 15-6 Healthcare Facilities in the Project Area Settlements Settlements that Proximity to the donot have Settlement that have healthcare healthcare facilities nearest healthcare in the region facilities in the region centre (km) Evren Center ✔ Sarıyahşi Center ✔ Sarıyahşi Boğazköy ✔ Ağaçören Kütüklü ✖ 5 km Ağaçören Center ✔ Ağaçören Camili ✔ Ağaçören Kederli ✔ Ağaçören Abdiuşağı ✖ 13 km Ağaçören Çatalçeşme ✖ 16 km Ortaköy Hacımahmutuşağı ✖ 11 km Ortaköy Hacıibrahimuşağı ✔ Ortaköy Hıdırlı-Fakıcık ✖ 12 km Ortaköy Pınarbaşı ✖ 9 km Ortaköy İshaklı Karapınar ✖ 15 km Ortaköy Camuzluk ✖ 15 km Merkez Bostanlık ✖ 38 km Merkez Cerit ✖ 25 km 174 Merkez Altınkaya ✔ Merkez Hanobası ✖ 50 km Merkez Sapmaz ✔ Merkez Baymış ✖ 5 km Merkez Yeşiltepe Town ✔ Merkez Yeşilova Town ✔ Merkez Yenikent Town ✔ Sultanhanı Center ✔ Eskil Güneşli ✔ Emirgazi Besci ✖ 35 km Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP – Settlement Head Surveys, March 2019 Home and Amenities The majority of the households surveyed are the owners of the houses that they live in as seen in the figure below. The average size of the houses is 155 m2. When asked about the construction cost of a house equivalent to the house they were living in, the average responses were around 160,000 TL. Figure 7 Ownership Status of Houses 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Owner of the Tenants of joint Owned by close Rented Other house venture relatives, rent- free Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The table below presents basic information about the infrastructure facilities in the settlements. It is important to note that there is no central sewerage system in the plateaus of Sultanhanı Merkez which is not included in this table. The drinking water sources of the households are mainly provided from the main water lines. During the interviews, settlement heads stated that the infrastructure facilities of the settlements are not located within the boundaries of project construction area. Before the construction phase of the project, meetings will be held in the settlements and information will be obtained about the damages that can be given to the infrastructure and the measures that will be taken to prevent any damage to facilities will be explained to PAPs. Tablo 15-7 Access to Infrastructure in Project Affected Settlements Lack of Poor Quality Road Blocks Insufficient Settlement Intermittent telephone Centralized Drinking in 175 Sewerage Electric Water Winters Due and internet Supply To infrastructure Snow Evren Center ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Sarıyahşi Center ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Sarıyahşi Boğazköy ✔ ✔ ✖ ✔ ✖ Ağaçören Kütüklü ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✖ Ağaçören Center ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ağaçören Camili ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ağaçören Kederli ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ağaçören Abdiuşağı ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✖ Ağaçören Çatalçeşme ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ortaköy Hacımahmutuşağı ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✖ Ortaköy Hacıibrahimuşağı ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ortaköy Hıdırlı-Fakıcık ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ortaköy Pınarbaşı ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Ortaköy İshaklı Karapınar ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✖ Ortaköy Camuzluk ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Bostanlık ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Cerit ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Altınkaya ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Hanobası ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Sapmaz ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Baymış ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Yeşiltepe Town ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Yeşilova Town ✖ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Merkez Yenikent Town ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Sultanhanı Center ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Eskil Güneşli ✖ ✔ ✖ ✔ ✔ Emirgazi Besci ✖ ✔ ✖ ✔ ✔ Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP – Settlement Head Surveys, March 2019 The heating sources of the households are shown in the figure below. It is observed that the participants gave more than one answer as heating sources. Households are mainly heated with wood and coal, and animal fuels are also used in rural settlements. Natural gas is used in the district centers. There are only 4 households heated by electricity and solar energy. Figure 8 Most Used Heat Sources in PAHs 176 160 147 140 126 120 100 80 66 60 40 20 14 2 2 0 Wood Coal Electricity Cow dung Natural gas Solar energy Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP – Settlement Head Surveys, March 2019 Economic Profile Agriculture As stated by stakeholders in the consultations, the main livelihoods in the region are agriculture and animal husbandry activities. In addition to the market-oriented production of products such as beet, chickpea and sunflower as agricultural activities, fodder crops also cultivated to support households' husbandry activities. Figure 9 Type of Land Owned by Households (Number of PAHs) 140 122 115 120 100 80 60 40 36 40 26 16 21 20 4 0 About half of the land that PAHs’ own is irrigated while the other half is dry. Some households also cultivate the treasury lands around their lands for agricultural purposes. Some of the users who are cultivating a part of the treasury lands adjacent to their own agricultural lands are not legally recognized. Besides, the lands of the households who have migrated from the settlements and who have left agricultural activities are cultivated with rental agreements. The interviewed households in the settlements mostly plant their lands themselves. Only 7 households had rented their land to someone else. 2 households stated that they are paying to daily workers to plant their lands. Detailed information about the formal and informal users in the project-area is given in Section 5.4.2. Pasture lands in Turkey, can not be used for agricultural purposes other than grazing. However, it has been determined that mostly forage crops such as alfalfa are planted by the users especially in the 177 pasture lands located in the Sultanhanı region and around the well areas. Therefore, there are two types of impacts regarding the use of common property lands in the Project area; loss of common grazing lands and loss of pasture lands used for agricultural purposes by informal users. Loss of common grazing lands will be compensated and the compensation will aim at supporting or improving livestock activities in accordance with the joint decision of the settlement (eg, fodder provision, animal shading and watering trough support). Users who cultivate the pasture lands for agricultural purposes will be evaluated as informal users and will be compensated through the RAP Fund. Figure 10 Average size of lands by type owned by households 160 139,53 140 128,32 120 100 80 60 37 40 20 9,54 10,08 4,42 2,55 0 Vineyard Orchard Dry Land Irrigated Fruit Woody Other Land orchard Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The irrigation sources of the households mainly consist of wells. 71 of the households responding to this question stated that they were irrigating their lands with well water. The number of households using ponds or streams as irrigation sources is 33. 85 of the respondents find the water resource insufficient while 87 of them stated that water resource is sufficient. The distribution of the crops planted by the households is given in the figure below (Figure 11). The products in the table are planted once in a year and crop substitution is carried out in the region. 118 of the respondents who answered the question stated that they left their land lie fallow while 81 of them did not. Figure 11 Type of CropsPlanted by PAHs in the Project Area 180 169 160 145 140 120 100 80 52 50 60 41 44 31 36 40 22 25 20 10 8 3 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 178 45% of the respondents stated that they were members of an agricultural cooperative, and 55% stated that they were not members of any cooperative. Ownership of transportation and agricultural vehicles among households is shown in the figure below. Multiple answers are marked for the ownership of more than one vehicle. It is seen that 76% of the households owns automobiles while 69% owns a tractor. The figure indicates that the number of households owned both automobiles and tractors is quite high among the sample. Figure 12 Vehicle Ownership by Households in the Project Area 180 157 160 141 140 120 100 80 60 40 14 15 20 4 1 1 4 1 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 Apart from individual private lands and planted crops, usage purposes of public lands such as pasture, treasury and forest land is also a significant area of concern. As seen in the Figure 13, the most common type of land use of public lands which are commonly used is grazing activities which are followed by cultivation. Other usage purposes are very less common but “not-used” answer has the highest rate among all answers. Figure 13 Usage Purposes of Affected Public Lands (Treasury, Pasture, Forest, etc.) 120 96 100 80 60 50 40 22 20 9 2 3 1 0 Used for Used for Used for Used as Used for Other Not-used common self common common wood grazing agricultural grass plateau collecting purposes purposes cutting purposes Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 179 Livestock Production 58% of the households interviewed stated that they are engaged in animal husbandry while 42% do not carry out husbandry activities. Following table shows the number of livestock by types owned by PAHs in the project area. Tablo 15-8 Number of Livestock Owned by PAHs Type of Animals Average Numbers TOTAL Cattle/bovine 19.87 2225 Sheep/goat 85.23 6307 Bee (number of beehives) 4.38 289 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 119 out of total 205 households surveyed have ownership of animals. All of these animal owners have a barn/stable. Sheep/goat breeding is more common among households engaged in animal husbandry activities. As a general pattern, households use the barn/stable next to their homes to feed their animals in winter season. With the arrival of spring, animals are taken to meadows and pastures. The common pastures of the settlements, treasury lands and private farmlands after the harvest are also used for animal grazing. The Project will ensure the sustainability of animal husbandry activities by organizing meetings with settlement heads and animal owners so that livestock activities and grazing routes are not affected by construction activities. Most households have poultry to meet their own needs, but these products are not offered to the market. Household Income and Expenditures One of the most important results obtained in field studies is that PAHs have income diversity. Regular retirement salary or paid workers' salaries generally supply the income from agriculture and animal husbandry and make household income more stable. Animal husbandry activities bring more income than crop production. When the household income structure is assessed, it is understood that agricultural income (plant production + husbandry) constitutes about half of the income of the households engaged in agriculture. When livelihoods are distributed among households, it is seen that there is a highly balanced distribution between paid labor income, retirement salary and agricultural-husbandry income. Half of the households interviewed stated that they sold animals in the last year. Figure 14 Income Sources of PAHs in the Project Area 180 200 183 180 160 140 120 103 90 89 100 80 60 33 38 40 14 21 17 20 4 8 8 1 1 2 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 Following figure presents the average monthly and annual expenditures of PAHs by types. It can be seen that the highest expenses of households are related with livestock expenses which is also highest income generating activity. Agricultural expenses are much lower than both livestock expenses and heating expenses of households. Figure 15 Average Monthly and Annual Expenditures of PAHs in the Project Area Average Monthly Expenditure Average Annual Expenditure Clothing, transportation, health and other expenses 2.290 Livestock expenses 34.227 Sprinkler irrigation land expenses (water, electricity,… 829 Irrigated land expenses (water, electricity, fertilizer… 1.095 Tobacco or alcohol 285 Kitchen expenses 906 Water 75 Elektricity 126 Bottled gas 126 Wood, coal, natural gas etc. 2.716 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 According to the results of the field study, more than half of the surveyed households have an on-going loan. The types of these loans are consumer, mortgage, agriculture, livestock and trade loans. 26 households received consumer loans, while 6 households used mortgage loans, 66 households agricultural loans and 3 households used trade loans (Figure 16). Figure 16 Did Any Household Member Receive Loan? 181 120 101 100 88 80 60 40 20 14 2 0 Yes No I dont know Not-answered Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The interviewees stated that the most effective investment to increase the income they derive from agriculture and animal husbandry is to develop irrigation resources. The second choice was to reduce input costs for husbandry and agriculture. 40% of the households participating in the field study stated that they could hardly or very hardly meet the needs of the household. On the other hand, 53% stated that they could meet their needs. Compared to the previous year, total of 114 households stated that their economic situation got worse, while 77 stated that their economic situation remained the same or is better. 56 of the households surveyed said that there was no change compared to the previous year. 146 households stated that they did not prefer their children to stay in this settlement due to lack of job opportunities and lack of education services. The surveyed households were asked to rank the most important problems of the settlement. The following table shows these answers. Figure 17 Most Important Deficiencies/Problems of the Settlements According to PAPs 90 80 80 70 60 53 50 44 40 36 31 28 30 23 19 20 16 16 6 5 7 7 10 4 1 1 1 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 182 Among the answers, irrigation problems, which are one of the most important issues for agricultural activities, were mentioned most, followed by unemployment. Due to the limited employment opportunities in settlements, young people migrate to metropolitan and urban centers. A significant number of the interviewees had no idea about this and did prefer not to give an answer to that. Households were asked what issues they had prioritized in improving livelihoods. Looking at the results, it is observed that households mostly prefer the supports for agricultural inputs and irrigation activities, followed by livestock inputs. It is known that agricultural activities have been abandoned by many people due to the recent increase in agricultural costs and the results appear to confirm this situation. Figure 18 Livelihood Restoration/Improvement Preferences 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 The interviewees were asked what kinds of courses could be organized and activities could be carried out to improve their livelihoods. As shown in the table below, vocational courses were the most preferred topic. The following issues are related to agriculture and animal husbandry. Figure 19 Type of Livelihood Development Courses Preferred by PAPs for Women and Youth 70 60 53 56 50 45 40 30 30 24 16 20 9 8 10 1 0 Women Youth Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 183 Public Consultations and Information Sharing 173 of the surveyed households stated that they had information about the project while 32 of them had no knowledge. PAPs were also asked how they were informed about the Project. The basic information sources of the PAPs were the visits of Project personnel, television broadcasts and settlement heads. Other sources of information are indicated as family members, Municipality, District Governorates and social media. Almost all settlement heads attended the informative meeting held by the Project personnel while 53 of the surveyed households participate in these meetings. PAPs were also asked about which information they want to get about the Project. PAPs were generally interested in; expropriation process, employment opportunities, environmental impacts, whether the fresh water pipeline can be used for agricultural irrigation after the completion of the Project life etc. Public information meetings held regularly by the Project will continue in a participatory manner allowing for PAPs to raise their concerns and get answers to their questions. The question “Have your lands been taken or expropriated for any other projects before?” was answered as No by 121 PAPs and as Yes by 69 PAPs, respectively. Therefore, a multiple project effect can be considered for these settlements. Questions related to the grievance mechanism of the Project were also included in the survey. The answers of PAPs to the question of who will be contacted to get information about the Project or to forward a complaint are listed in the table below. 25% of participants stated that they would contact company personnel (the social point of contact on behalf of the Project) for such cases while 19% answered as “Mukhtar” to the question. Those who have no idea about contact channels consist 9% of the sample. Figure 20 Information Sources Preferred by PAPs 60 52 50 39 40 35 32 30 20 20 14 10 0 Company Mukhtar Municipality Governorship No idea Other personnel Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 19% of the interviewed households are aware of the communication channels such as phone line and the contact person that the Project is applying for Grievance Mechanism while 66% of participants are not aware of these contact channels. A Grievance Mechanism has been established for the GSEP Project. Face to face interviews and consultations have been going on since the beginning of Project. With the commencement of the Project activities on site, Public Relations Units of both BOTAŞ and Construction Contractor(s) will carry out its activities within the framework of the Grievance Management Mechanism and the Stakeholder Engagement Plan. 184 Potential Impacts of the Project According to Socio-Economic Survey The approaches of the surveyed households to the Project were also questioned during field survey. The respondents gave the following answers regarding the positive impacts of the Project. The most important positive impact of the Project was to support local employment according to PAPs. This was followed by the contribution to the local development.28% of the respondents stated that the project will contribute to the national economy. This response was followed by those who stated that the Project would not have any positive contribution to the region (27%). Figure 21 Potential Positive Impacts of the Project 70 58 57 60 50 40 30 18 20 11 12 10 5 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 PAPs evaluated the possible negative effects of the project as in the figure below. The participants were able to select more than one answer option. The outstanding response is that the affected-lands and neighbor lands will be damaged during the construction phase. This response is followed by damage to crops especially in neighbor lands. Thus, it can be seen that the PAPs expect a decrease in their income sources. They also believe that livestock activities will be adversely affected by the Project activities. Damage to agricultural products and livestock activities due to construction activities will be avoided. However, in cases of damages to any property, the loss will be compensated by the CC. Figure 22 Potential Negative Impacts of the Project 100 91 90 80 66 70 60 47 50 40 30 23 18 16 20 6 2 5 1 1 2 10 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 185 The PAPs were also asked what could be done to reduce these adverse effects. The answers are listed in the figure below. Supporting agricultural activities and livestock activities has been the primary response. This was followed by answers such as improvement of roads, prioritization of local employment in the Project. Most of the muhtars (14 out of 27) stated that they would like to benefit from natural gas to be connected to their settlements. Figure 23 Measures Preferred by PAPs for Mitigating Potential Adverse Impacts 100 91 90 80 70 66 60 47 50 40 30 23 18 16 20 10 6 5 2 1 1 2 0 Source: Socio-Economic Field Study for RAP - Household Survey- March 2019 In the questions designed for measuring the employment expectation in the Project, 29% of participants stated that there are job seekers in their households who could work in the Project. On the other hand, 62% of the respondents said that they would not prefer to work in the Project or that there is no job seeker in their household to work in the Project. 2 interviewees have declared that there are already people in their households employed by the Project. Public Relations Units of BOTAŞ and Contractor(s) will visit the settlements and inform them about employment opportunities and application processes in the pre-construction phase. 186 Appendix 9. RAP Fund Management Guideline GENERAL Purpose and Scope The scope of this document is to set forth the entitlement criteria and methods of payment to be made under RAP Fund to land owners/users and legal entities who are affected from pipeline RoW, Energy Transmission Lines (ETL) and Above Ground Installations (Above Ground Facilities). Custodian of the Document The custodian of this Guideline is the Quality, Health and Safety and Environment (QHSE) Manager. The custodian is responsible for organizing regular review of this document in addition to ensure updating of identified improvements. The custodian is to be contacted for any reasons of changes. Abbreviations, Acronyms BOTAŞ Boru Hatları ile Petrol Taşıma Anonim Şirketi ELCO Expropriation Local Contact Office ESIA Environmental and Social Impact Assessment ETL Energy Transmission Line GSEP Gas Storage Expansion Project OP 4.12 Operational Policy 4.12 - Involuntary Resettlement QHSE Quality, Health and Safety, Environment PAP Project Affected People RAP Resettlement Action Plan RoW Right of Way RPF Resettlement Policy Framework TL Turkish Lira WB World Bank Definitions The following definitions may appear within the text of this document and shall have meaning as described below for the purpose of this document. Definitions Meaning Above Ground Installations Include surface facilities, well areas, pumping & storage stations, valve chambers BOTAŞ Departments BOTAŞ Departments described under BOTAŞ Organizational Chart Compensation Payments made by those causing specified and agreed loss to those who suffer the impairment of access to land, waters and other critical natural 187 resources or livelihoods, or damage to, or destruction of community members’ individual or collective assets of any kind, whether accidental or planned due to Project related works Contract The contract established by and between BOTAŞ and the contractor to provide materials/goods/services to BOTAŞ Common Lands State owned land used collectively by a number of persons Economic Displacement Loss of assets or access to asset that leads to loss of income sources of other means of livelihood as a result of Project related land acquisition and, or restrictions on land use Eligibility/Eligible Those who are entitled for any described compensation type in BOTAŞ RAP(s) and its complementary documents (LRP documents) in compliance with BOTAŞ’s commitment to the WB policies. Eligibility Criteria Criteria for determining eligibility for land acquisition and livelihood restoration entitlements Energy Transmission Lines Structures used in electric power transmission and distribution to transmit electrical energy along large distances Entitlement The range of measures comprising cash or in-kind compensation, transaction cost, income restoration, livelihood assistance, and various other allowances such as transportation assistance Expropriation Local Contact Office of BOTAŞ working in Konya that is responsible to execute all land Office (ELCO) acquisition activities of GSEP in line with Land Acquisition Law (Law No: 2942 and amended with Law No:4650) and other relevant national legislations e-Devlet System The electronic offering of services normally rendered to citizens by the Government Finance Department The Finance Department of BOTAŞ Grievance Mechanism The Grievance Mechanism of BOTAŞ (A grievance mechanism is constituted by instruments, methods and processes by which a resolution to a grievance is sought and provided) Grievance A concern or complaint raised by an individual or a group within communities/stakeholders affected by the Project General Manager The General Manager of BOTAŞ Head Office The Head Office of BOTAŞ located in Ankara Land User Those who are the actual users of the Project affected lands for any land based livelihood activity 188 Land Consolidation Land Consolidation is the reallocation of parcels with the aim the landowners to obtain larger parcels at one or more places in exchange of their former smaller and fragmented land plots Land Acquisition Refers to all methods of obtaining land for project purposes, which may include outright purchase, expropriation of property and acquisition of access rights, such as easement or rights of way (Land may also include: (a) acquisition of unoccupied or unutilized land whether or not the landholder relies upon such land for income or livelihood purposes; (b) repossession of public land that is used or occupied by individuals or households; and (c) project impacts that result in land being submerged or otherwise rendered unusable or inaccessible) (‘’Land’’ includes anything growing on or permanently affixed to land, such as crops, buildings and other improvements, and appurtenant water bodies) Livelihood Restoration The measures required to ensure that project affected persons have the resources to at least restore, if not improve their livelihoods Pasturelands Land used to feed livestock such as cattle, horses, and sheep by means of grazing Project Gas Storage Expansion Project of BOTAŞ QHSE Manager The Quality, Health and Safety and Environmental Manager of BOTAŞ Resettlement Action Plan The document which specifies the procedures that will be followed and the (RAP) actions that will be taken to mitigate adverse effects, compensate losses, and provide development benefits to persons and communities affected by an investment project RAP Fund The RAP Fund of BOTAŞ established by BOTAŞ’s Board of Directors to cover land acquisition-induced impacts of Project on livelihoods that are not covered by national law but should be covered in compliance to WB standards that apply to BOTAŞ RAP Fund Application A tailor-made register table developed by BOTAŞ for keeping all records Monitoring Table (complaints, applications or notification) related to RAP Fund Payment Items and monitoring the evaluation process in a written form RAP Monitoring Consultant Company that monitors RAP and gives support for evaluation of eligibility of the applicant RAP Semi-Annually Internal The report prepared on a quarterly basis to present progress on RAP Monitoring Report implementation with respect to BOTAŞ’s commitments made under its RAP(s) Replacement Cost The market value of the assets plus transaction costs Real Estate Transaction Tax Tax born from the purchase and sale transactions of an immovable Resettlement Policy Document that sets forth the policy of BOTAŞ regarding resettlement of Framework (RPF) PAPs within the scope of GSEP Site The land areas where topographic works, site survey, soil investigations, archaeological works, earthworks, material storage, social areas, accommodation, dormitories, offices, construction, erection, commissioning activities are executed for realization of the BOTAŞ facilities/system 189 Title Deed Directorate The authority that carries out all procedures relating to title deed issue in accordance with the applicable laws Turkish Legislation Mean the Turkish Laws, regulations, decrees, circulars and others officially issued in Turkish Official Gazette Transitional Livelihood Support provided to economically displaced persons who are eligible for Support additional monetary support (transitional payment) as defined in the RAP(s) Treasury Lands State owned land (The Treasury may have land registered with land registry offices and land, which are not so registered, mountains, hills, rocks, lakes, rivers, and streams are also deemed to be owned by the Treasury) (Registered land is classified as land subject to the Treasury’s general ownership) Unviable Lands Pieces of land which remain on a property after a portion of the property has been acquired for the project and are of considerable importance in communities’ and/or household’s livelihoods References  Turkish Expropriation Law  RAP Fund Management Directive of BOTAŞ  World Bank’s OP 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement  Resettlement Policy Framework (RPF) DESCRIPTION RAP Fund’s principles of usage and establishment have been determined in the light of requirements of the “World Bank’s OP 4.12 on Involuntary Resettlement”. The RAP Fund is implemented taking into consideration the following principles:  Fair and transparent evaluation  Compensation of loss at replacement cost  Method of compensation of economic loss not regulated under applicable Turkish Legislation  Timely information through the proper method with sufficient content  Open communication and easy access  Accountability RAP Fund is a supplementary fund formed by BOTAŞ based on international standards and good practices in order to compensate economic losses sustained and to be sustained by persons who are affected from Project’s acquisition activities but who are not eligible as per Turkish legislation. The purpose of this RAP Fund is to compensate various economic losses of the entitled persons who are affected from pipeline RoW and Above Ground Facilities in different ways, but those losses are not compensated under applicable Turkish Legislation, and to help facilitate economic transition from pre- Project period to commencement of commercial operation period. BOTAŞ will carry out a pro-active approach in informing the PAPs and impacted settlements through active engagement tools such as the GLAC (Guide to Land Acquisition and Compensation) and ensure that all impacted people are aware and informed timely of their rights to compensation which are not covered by Law. 190 A person who asks to be compensated from the RAP Fund for their economic losses, first applies to BOTAŞ’s relevant social experts and convey the issue via grievance mechanism. BOTAŞ may also initiate the compensation process directly by the social team if the eligible PAPs do not apply for compensation. Received applications (complaint record) and supportive reports are gathered in QHSE Management and whenever required, by relevant experts, to decide whether applicant/complainant is eligible or not. If it is considered eligible, necessary supports from RAP Fund are provided to the entitled person as described in “Entitlement Matrix” in the RPF Document. Application is closed upon the release signed by parties verifying that economic loss compensated and consent of the applicant/complainant is received. Should the application/complaint be rejected, necessary explanation is given to the applicant/complainant in an appropriate way. All concerns should be kept in RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES Entity General Role & Responsibility Head of Storage Department  Ensure that the process mentioned in this guideline is implemented  Provide necessary resources for proper implementation of the process mentioned in this guideline Expropriation Department of  Manages and executes all land acquisition activities in BOTAŞ conformity with the relevant Turkish Legislation  Provides regular land acquisition data including grievances and logs of negotiation meetings etc. ELCO  Communicate regularly with owners/users to inform about their rights  Identification of informal land users on public lands QHSE Manager  Works together with the social experts in head office Management  Checks the works performed by Social Experts working at head (Head Office) office Social Experts  Enters the applications made to QHSE Management to RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table  Evaluate applications received via grievance mechanism regarding RAP Fund  In some cases, receives support from RAP Monitoring Consultant in order to determine that the application is eligible or not  Exchanges letters with related Public Institutions  Sends letter to Finance Department to pay the estimated compensation amount  Send letter to the applicant about the result of the application  Follows up and disclosure activities carried out within the scope of RAP Fund and applications received and relevant results QHSE Chief Chief Engineer  Works together with the social experts at site Engineering  Checks the works performed by Social Experts working at site (Site) Social Expert  Helps filling application form samples that are created in case the entitled person wishes to apply  Enters the applications made to QHSE Chief Engineering to RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table  Informs QHSE Management about the applications 191 Related Public Institutions  They are Aksaray Provincial Directorate of Food, Agriculture and Livestock and Aksaray Provincial Directorate of Environment and Urbanization  Determine the value of assets regarding application, like structures, tress etc. and notifies QHSE Management BOTAŞ Finance Department  Makes payments for compensation to related bank account RAP Monitoring Consultant  Examines whether the application is eligible or not according to eligibility criteria (Appendix 1) by visiting site BOTAŞ RAP FUND MANAGEMENT PROCESSS RAP Fund is the source allocated to cover economic losses that arise in connection with pipelines RoW and Above Ground Facilities and cannot be compensated within the scope of Legal Legislation of Turkey (Expropriation Law no. 2942). Rap Fund under the Project is used to compensate such cases whenever required for compensation of economic losses within the scope provided below.  BOTAŞ Fund Management Process in case of temporary economic loss resulting from easements of pipelines and energy transmission lines a. Fund Payment Items i. Crop payment for unviable lands: Compensation for crop and other assets losses on the remaining portions of the divided land for construction activities as the remaining part becomes economically unviable. Relevant criteria are given in Appendix 1. ii. Payments for Public Lands (Treasury Lands, Forest Lands, Pasturelands and Lands owned by Village Legal Entity) used for agricultural activities by informal land users: Compensation of loss related to crops and trees or other immovables such as houses, water wells, animal shelters to users who are not legal entitled person, which is paid in case Treasury Lands, Forest Lands, Pasturelands and land that belong to Village Legal Entity is used for agricultural activities without making legal payment. iii. Payments in relation with misidentification of the actual land user (crop owner): Compensation of any losses that may arise from any improper identification of actual land user is carried out. iv. Transportation Costs where consent agreement is reached: Payment made to cover travelling costs that land owner, with whom an agreement is reached during land acquisition process. v. Payments regarding the common lands used for grazing: Payments made to compensate livelihood loss arising from not being able to use publicly owned land for grazing purposes during construction activities. vi. Payments for seasonal income losses of the person of the entity carrying out seasonal economic activities in areas nearby the project area: Payments made to compensate income losses of persons or organizations that carry out seasonal economic activities, who are located within the Project impact area which is defined in ESIA Report and RPF. vii. Payments regarding change of parcel and land owner depending on land consolidation: Compensation paid for losses that arise due to change of owners and land area as the result of land consolidation. 192 viii. Payment for PAPs who are affected by cumulative impacts: Payments made to compensate losses that arise due to expropriation of the land second time. ix. Payments regarding the contract farming: Payments made to compensate losses that arise due to contract farming. b. Entitled PAPs/Entities i. Land users/land owners of unviable lands, who meet the eligibility criteria stated in Appendix 1. ii. Informal land users on public lands, who carry out agricultural activities on treasury lands, forest lands, pasturelands and land that belong to village legal entity without legal rental or making legal payment as required by applicable Turkish Legislation. iii. People who were underpaid due to misidentification of crop or who could not be compensated as there was a mistake in identifying the actual land user. iv. Land owners with whom an agreement on the expropriation amount is reached during land acquisition process. v. The villages that incur economic loss as they cannot temporarily use a part of pastureland and other land that they had been using for grazing because of the Project activities. The entitled party here is the Village Legal Entity. vi. People/entity that carry out seasonal economic activities such as beekeeping, within the Project impact area which is defined in ESIA Report and RPF. vii. The new land owners that emerge as the result of land consolidation activities carried out in villages in the project area where a change in ownership or land area occurs. viii. The land owners/users whose land is expropriated second time. ix. The land owner/user who made a contract farming agreement with buyers before expropriation of the land. c. Implementation i. The land outside the construction area becomes unviable for agricultural activity throughout the construction period: Whether or not the applicants (actual land user) that apply via grievance mechanism for payment of compensation for crops on unviable lands, meet eligibility criteria or not, are kept in RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table by QHSE Management. Afterwards, applications are sent to RAP Monitoring Consultant to decide whether the applicant/complainant is entitled or not with respect to Eligibility Criteria (Appendix 1). The result of the evaluation is entered on the “Land Investigation Form” (Appendix 2). Monitoring consultant informs QHSE Management whether the application is eligible or not. 1. If the application is considered eligible, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic loss incurred due to crops that the person could not cultivate. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is 193 closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. ii. Payments made to informal users who have crops, trees and structures on public lands: Whether or not an informal land user of public lands identified during identification works or through a grievance registered to grievance mechanism is eligible per this guideline for its standing crops, trees and structures are determined through an identification document issued by ELCO. The identification works are kept in RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table and sent to QHSE Management to be evaluated. 1. For requests approved, loss of crops or other assets, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic loss. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. iii. Payments in relation with misidentification of actual land user (crop owner): Applications collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management. QHSE Management evaluates the complaint that arise as a result of the payment made for standing crops to the wrong person. 1. For requests approved by QHSE Management regarding loss of crops, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic loss. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. For requests not approved by QHSE Management, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. iv. Transportation costs: Applications collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. (Payment for transportation costs is limited to 1000 TL and submission of invoice is needed) QHSE Management evaluates the application. 194 1. For requests approved, QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. v. Payments regarding the common lands used for grazing: These losses that are sustained by settlements with village status are identified during activities carried out on site by ELCO. Identification documents are sent to QHSE Management. 1. QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic losses. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the bank account of Village Legal Entity by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the Village Legal Entity is informed formally. vi. Payments for loss of seasonal Income: A person or an entity that used to carry out seasonal activities within the Project impact area, which is defined in ESIA Report and RPF, that incurred economic loss as they had to change their location of activity temporarily or that can no longer carry out economic activities for other reasons due to construction activities, claim for compensating their income losses via grievance mechanism. Claims for compensation are kept in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and evaluated case by case. 1. For requests approved by QHSE Management, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic losses. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. vii. Payments for change of parcel and land owner depending on land consolidation: Application collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. QHSE Management evaluates the application. In order for BOTAŞ to identify the losses in areas that are subject to land consolidation, the status ownership and the land area prior to and after consolidation is compared. 195 1. For requests approved by QHSE Management regarding economic loss arising from land consolidation, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the amount of economic loss. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the calculated amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. viii. Payment for PAPs who are affected by cumulative impacts: Application collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. QHSE Management evaluates the application. 1. For requests approved by QHSE Management regarding economic loss arising from cumulative impacts, QHSE Management calculates the compensation amount and submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. Application collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. QHSE Management evaluates the application. ix. Payments regarding the contract farming: Application collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. QHSE Management evaluates the application. 1. For requests approved by QHSE Management regarding contract farming, QHSE Management sends a letter to the related public institution in order to calculate the price of the crop which can not be cultivated due to the expropriation of land. Related public institution sends the calculated amount to QHSE Management by means of a letter. In addition, cash support equal to minimum wage for six (6) months is added to the compensation amount. QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of overall compensation amount. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. 196  BOTAŞ Fund Management Process in case of permanent economic loss resulting from land take for Above Ground Facilities a. RAP Fund Payment Items All RAP Fund payment items listed in Section 3.1.1, with the exception of part (A) Crop payment for unviable Lands, are valid. Furthermore, following payments are within the scope of RAP Fund. i. Payments for public lands (treasury land, forest land, pasturelands and lands owned by Village Legal Entity) used for agricultural activities by informal users: Compensation of loss related to crops and trees to users who are not legal entitled person, which is paid in treasury land, forest land, pasturelands and lands owned by Village Legal Entity is used for agricultural activities without making legal payment. Also, transitional livelihood support equaling to minimum wage to be provided for a duration of six (6) months to land users in case these lands are affected from construction activities. ii. Real estate transaction tax to be paid at the title deed offices in case a new immovable property is purchased with the expropriation amount collected: Land owners whose lands used for agricultural activities, who have been expropriated permanently due to construction of Above Ground Facilities are able to buy a new land using the expropriation amount paid to them, in order to continue their agricultural activities. iii. Transitional Livelihood Support and other livelihood restoration assistances to be provided to PAPs whose livelihood depends on the permanently acquired land and therefore, may face with economic difficulty: In areas where Above Ground Facilities of the Project are built, significant and permanent loss of income and accordingly, difficulty in land based livelihoods are arisen when the land owners’ or users of public lands (whom main source of income are the agricultural activities they carry out on these lands but may be supplemented by other income activities such as livestock, beekeeping, seasonal works etc.) and when they lose all or major portion of their land due to expropriation. In such cases, cash support equal to minimum wage is provided to these people for six (6) months and this support is referred to as “Transitional Livelihood Support”. b. Entitled PAPs/Entity All RAP Fund payment items listed in Section 3.1.2, with the exception of part (A) Land users/land owners of unviable lands, are valid. Furthermore, following entitled PAPs/entities are within the scope of RAP Fund. i. Persons that carry out agricultural activities on public lands like treasury land, forest land, pastureland and lands that belong to village legal entities, without paying a legal rent or legal payment as required by applicable Turkish Legislation and persons not having regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one (1) year; ii. Land owners whose lands for agricultural activities have been expropriated permanently due to construction of Above Ground Facilities 197 iii. Entitlements for land users that benefit from Transitional Livelihood Support differ depending on land affected from Above Ground Facilities being private or public land. 1. Entitlements for users of the private lands are as follows: a. Being owner of lands that are subject to permanent and land acquisition due to Above Ground Facilities, this is not applicable for land acquisition where easement rights are established. b. Land users whose significant portion of livelihood depends on the land acquired for Above Ground Facilities c. Land users not having regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one (1) year. d. Land take for the Above Ground Facilitie amounts to be more than twenty percent (20%) of the entire land by area in agricultural production including animal husbandry of the concerned land user, thus the land take for Above Ground Facilities has the potential to affect his livelihood. 2. Entitlements for users of the public lands are as follows: a. Informal land users of public lands affected by Above Ground Facilities b. Land users whose livelihood depends mainly on agricultural activity income generated from the land c. Land users not having regular wage based income with a job at which they work more than one (1) year. c. Implementation i. Payments for public lands (treasury land, forest land, pasturelands and lands owned by Village Legal Entity) used for agricultural activities by informal users: Crops and trees payments are made as explained under article 3.1.1 (A). In addition to this, persons that carry out agricultural activities on public lands apply to QHSE Chief Engineer or social experts working on site, together with below documents and filling the form attached in “Appendix 4”, and describing their current conditions with a reasonable fact: 1. Certificate of residence to be obtained from “muhtar” office or “e- devlet system” 2. Title deed registry obtained from Title Deed Directorate or “e-devlet system” showing the total number of areas of parcels belongs to him/her in the same location 3. Social Security Institution service scheme 4. Identification document signed by “muhtar” and his/her associates, or legal payment or rent document if proclaimed, provided that land affected by the Above Ground Facilities and used for agricultural activities purposes. This application and relevant documents that are entered into records via grievance mechanism and sent to QHSE Management for investigation and evaluation after keeping them in RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table. Along with this documents, QHSE Management also examines the current status of RAP studies in order to evaluate whether 198 main source of livelihood of the applicant in connection with the public land to be used for the Project is highly impacted from the Project or not and if necessary, it carries out investigation to obtain additional data. 5. If the application is eligible, QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the amount equal to minimum wage for the next six (6) months. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 6. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. ii. Real estate transaction tax to be paid at the title deed offices in case a new immovable property is purchased with the expropriation amount collected where there is permanent acquisition: A person whose land is expropriated and who purchases a new land with the expropriation value paid, applies for compensation of the real estate transaction tax that arises when a new land is purchased, with bank receipt of real estate transaction tax payment. Applications collected via grievance mechanism is sent to QHSE Management with related documents. QHSE Management evaluates the application. 1. If the application is approved, QHSE Management QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the amount written in receipt. Payment is limited to 2% of the expropriation amount paid. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 2. If the application is not approved, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant. iii. Transitional Livelihood Support and other livelihood restoration assistances to be provided to PAPs whose livelihood depends on the permanently acquired land and therefore, may face with economic difficulty: Land owners/land users who claim that they meet the criteria stated under “Section 3.2.2.(C)” and who request this additional Transitional Livelihood Support applies to QHSE Chief Engineer or social experts working on site, together with below documents and filling the form attached in “Appendix 4”, and describing their current conditions with a reasonable fact: 1. Certificate of residence to be obtained from “muhtar” office or “e- devlet system” 2. Title deed registry obtained from Title Deed Directorate or “e-devlet system” showing the total number of areas of parcels belongs to him/her in the same location 3. Social Security Institution service scheme 199 4. Identification document signed by “muhtar” and his/her associates, or legal payment or rent document if proclaimed, provided that land affected by the Above Ground Facilities, and used for agricultural activities purposes. This application and relevant documents that are entered into records via grievance mechanism and sent to QHSE Management for investigation and evaluation after keeping them in RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table. Along with this documents, QHSE Management also examines the current status of RAP studies in order to evaluate whether main source of livelihood of the applicant in connection with the public land to be used for the Project is highly impacted from the Project or not and if necessary, it carries out investigation to obtain additional data. 5. If the application is eligible, QHSE Management submits a letter to Finance Department for the payment of the amount equal to minimum wage for the next six (6) months. Payment is deposited to the applicant’s bank account by Finance Department. After payment is made, together with the transaction receipt, the complaint is closed and entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” (Appendix 3) and the applicant is informed formally. 6. If the application is considered ineligible, applicant is informed on the ineligibility of the application. Application is entered in “RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table” as rejected. The reasons for rejection are communicated to the applicant.  BOTAŞ Fund Management Process in case of temporary economic loss resulting from construction of temporary installations. All payment items listed under Section 3.1., all entitlement categories and relevant steps of implementation are valid for the temporary installations (camp, pipe stockyards etc.). MONITORING AND REPORTING QHSE Management prepares a RAP Semi-Annually Internal Monitoring Report. This report is prepared in English and shared with World Bank and consultants that monitor RAP externally as well as relevant units and management of BOTAŞ. Additionally, all relevant issues are kept by QHSE Management in the RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table. Deliverables In cases where RAP Fund is used, following documents will be recorded by BOTAŞ as evidence for payments and expenditure  Release: Document signed by parties verifying that economic loss compensated and consent of the applicant/complainant is received.  Identification Document: Document prepared by ELCO during identification process of land users/land owners and their crops/assets etc.  Land Investigation Form: Form filled out by RAP Monitoring consultant in order to record and support the evaluation of the eligibility of the relevant land for RAP Fund. 200  Application Form for Transitional Livelihood Support: Form filled out and signed by the person who applies to Transitional Livelihood Support.  RAP Semi-Annually Internal Monitoring Report: Report prepared by BOTAŞ on a quarterly basis to present progress on RAP implementation with respect to BOTAŞ’s commitments made under its RAP(s) Eligibility Criteria for Crop Payments on Unviable Lands i. Remaining area during construction activities is not viable for agricultural purposes due to the fact that the conditional area has less than 1000sqm area ii. Geometric condition of the remnant area is not viable for agricultural purposes such as ploughing or harvesting iii. Land loses its accessibility capacity throughout the construction iv. The remnant area loses its irrigation capacity throughout the construction v. The remnant area, during construction, cannot be used for agricultural purposes due to a high slope (more than 10%) with respect to certain construction activities vi. Remnant area is susceptible to flood, high water risk or erosion potential vii. While the remnant area is rented for agricultural purposes by its owner and used by third party, potential direct loss of the user in terms of crop harvesting in direct loss of the owner in terms of rent/profit from harvest due to construction activities viii. Limited or no incentive application capacity for government supplied promotions due to prevented agricultural activities with regard to construction (to be verified with documentation) ix. Any other impact that is not listed here but may prevent agricultural implementation due to construction activities on remnant areas; where the condition is undersigned by the BOTAŞ Team, beneficiary and the village headmen Cases that qualify any two of them at the same time will be considered to be an agricultural loss on the remnant land and compensated in accordance with prevailing crop unit value. 201 Land Investigation Form 202 RAP Fund Application Monitoring Table 203 Transitional Livelihood Support Application Form 204 Appendix 10. Land Entry and Land Exit Protocol Templates TUZ GÖLÜ DOĞAL GAZ YERALTI DEPOLAMA GENİŞLEME PROJESİ ARAZIYE GİRİŞ İZİN BELGESİ İL KP İLÇE KOORDİNAT KÖY MEVKİİ ADA/PARSEL TARİH Yukarıda bilgileri bulunan arazi üzerinde, boru hattı güzergahında yapilacak çalışmalar esnasında kullanılan alanda yapılacak tespitler neticesinde zirai ürün olması durumunda, iş bitiminde gerekli ölcüm yapılması ve zarar verilen ürünün ilgili İl Tarım Müdürlüğüi’nce belirlenmiş bedelinin BOTAŞ tarafindan ödenmesi koşulu ile çalışmaların başlamasına arazinin sahibi / kullanıcısı gerekli izni işbu belgeyi imzalayarak vermiştir. Araziye giriş nedeni (geciş yolu, ilgili şikayet no vb.): Düşünceler: Not: BOTAŞ tarafindan gerçeklestirilecek olan çalışmalar hakkında gerekli bilgilendirme BOTAŞ Sosyal Uzmanı tarafından yapılmıştır. Ekler: Adı Soyadı Tarih İmza Malik Hak Sahibi Arazi Kullanıcısı Köy Muhtarı BOTAŞ Sosyal Uzmanı Müteahhit Temsilcisi 205 TUZ GÖLÜ DOĞAL GAZ YERALTI DEPOLAMA GENİŞLEME PROJESİ ARAZİDEN ÇIKIŞ PROTOKOLÜ İL KP İLÇE KOORDİNAT KÖY MEVKİİ ADA/PARSEL TARİH Müteahhit Tuz Gölü Doğal Gaz Yeraltı Depolama Genişleme Projesi kapsamındaki çalışmalar için kullanılan arazinin eski haline getirilmesi işlerini tamamlamış ve yukarıda belirtilen arazi mal sahibine geri verilmiştir. Mal sahibi/Kullanıcı hiçbir hak ve alacağı kalmadığını beyanla BOTAŞ Müteahhitini ibra eder. İşbu protokol, Müteahhite kendisi ve BOTAŞ arasındaki müteahhitlik anlaşmaları kapsamında bir garanti veya bir hak talebi vermez. Düşünceler: Not: Tamir edilen veya eski haline getirilen yerler listelenmeli, fotoğraflanmalı, ürün bedeli ödenmiş ise “Ürün Bedeli Ödeme İbranamesi” doldurulmalı ve bu protokole eklenmelidir. (Bkz. Araziye Giriş İzin Formu) Ekler: Adı Soyadı Tarih İmza Malik Hak Sahibi Arazi Kullanıcısı Köy Muhtarı BOTAŞ Sosyal Uzmanı Müteahhit Temsilcisi 206 Appendix 11. Land Acquisition Process and Requirements Basic Principles of the Resettlement Program The impacts due to involuntary resettlement from development projects, may give rise to economic, social and environmental risks resulting in production systems being dismantled, people facing impoverishment when their productive assets or income sources are lost, people being relocated to environments where their productive skills may be less applicable and the competition of resources increases; community institutions and social networks being weakened; kin groups being dispersed; and cultural identity, traditional authority, and the potential for mutual help being diminished or lost. Any part of the land to be taken, the people who have a structure on that land, who use that land for agriculture activities, for grazing of animals and irrigation purposes, etc. may be adversely affected. It is therefore important that the losses that may occur to the affected persons are addressed and compensated through means developed in consultation with and based on the meaningful participation of the affected people. Resettlement program will be adhered to both the country’s laws for land acquisition and resettlement and WB OP 4.12. Where gaps exist between the country's laws and the WB OP 4.12, gap filling measures provided in this RAP will prevail. The objective of the RAP is to ensure the adequate management of land acquisition and easement required for the project in accordance to international standards including in particular WB OP 4.12. The RAP establishes a standard approach for the treatment of land acquisition and easements, as well as livelihood restoration in all Project activities in line with Turkish regulations and the WB OP 4.12, and considering the IFC PS5 as reference of good practice. It identifies procedures and requirements to guide BOTAŞ in dealing with people who experience land and property losses or economic displacement due to the Project-related land requirements. The following principles will govern land acquisition and easement to be conducted under the Project: i. BOTAŞ will aim to achieve negotiated agreements on land acquisition with all PAPs based on the principles set out in this RAP. BOTAŞ will negotiate fairly and openly with all PAPs to reach mutually acceptable agreements on compensation. Expropriation or easement imposition will only be undertaken as a last resort where negotiation fails. ii. All land acquisition and resettlement activities will be managed through RAPs, including when there is physical displacement21 which means relocation or loss of shelter or structure and/or when there is loss of economic displacement which means loss of income or livelihood. Implementation results will be documented, monitored and, after completion, evaluated. iii. Involuntary resettlement will be conceived as an opportunity for improving the livelihoods of the affected people and undertaken accordingly. iv. Engagement and compensation will be carried out with equal consideration of women and men. v. Particular attention will be paid to households headed by women and other vulnerable groups, and appropriate assistance will be provided to help them improve their status. vi. BOTAŞ will establish a grievance mechanism to receive and facilitate resolution of concerns regarding resettlement issues. This mechanism will allow women, disabled people, the elderly to reach BOTAŞ easily. 21 According to field studies, it is foreseen that the Project does not cause physical displacement. 207 vii. Land acquisition and RAP will be conceived and executed as a part of the Project, and the full costs of compensation will be included in Project costs and benefits. viii. Draft land acquisition and resettlement plans will be consulted with affected people and other stakeholders, and their inputs will be taken into account in finalizing them. ix. Compensation for lost assets will be at full replacement cost. x. Compensation and resettlement subsidies will be fully provided prior to clearance of right of way / ground levelling and demolition. xi. Upon completion of construction, land will be restored as best as possible to its original condition in the event of temporary disruption so as to enable landowners/users/lessees to resume their pre-project activities. xii. All PAPs, without regard to legal status of property, will receive support of various kinds, as per the principles set out in the Entitlement Matrix included in this RAP. Lack of legal title will not be a barrier to compensation and/or rehabilitation. xiii. BOTAŞ will provide and prepare the plans for grievance redress and monitoring in line with WB policies and guidelines. Objectives of the Resettlement Policy The main objective of the resettlement policy is to ensure that the people affected by land acquisition and resettlement under this project are able to improve or at least restore their incomes and standards of living after land acquisition/resettlement. The other objectives of the resettlement policy are as follows: i. Involuntary resettlement and land acquisition will be avoided or minimized. ii. Where involuntary resettlement and land acquisition is unavoidable, resettlement and compensation activities will be conceived and executed as sustainable development programs, providing sufficient investment resources and ensuring that the procedures and requirements outlined in this RAP will be followed. RAP is designed to minimize adverse impacts. iii. Assets and properties belonging to affected people will be compensated at their replacement value, if it is not possible to compensate them legally, resettlement assistance will be provided. iv. Affected people will be assisted to improve their livelihoods and standards of living or at least to restore them, in real terms, to levels prevailing prior to the beginning of project implementation. v. All PAPs will be meaningfully consulted and be active participants in the negotiated settlements and will have access to adequate and accessible grievance redress mechanisms. Consultations will consider gender issues and take into account the needs of stakeholders who may be considered vulnerable. PAPs, according to the World Bank’s OP 4.12, refer to people who are directly affected socially and economically by World Bank-assisted investment projects caused by: i. relocation or loss of shelter ii. loss of assets or access to assets iii. loss of income sources or means of livelihood, whether or not the affected persons must move to another location; or iv. the involuntary restriction or access to common resources such as pasturelands that result in adverse impacts on the livelihood of the displaced persons. The policy applies to all affected persons regardless of 208 i. the total number affected, ii. the severity of the impact and iii. whether or not they have legal title to the land. Particular attention will be paid to the needs of vulnerable groups such as but not limited to: those below the poverty line, the landless, the elderly, women and children, single women-headed households, disabled, elderly, illiterate, ethnic minorities, or other affected persons who may not be protected through national land compensation legislation. Land Acquisition and Resettlement Process Land Acquisition The expropriation process of private and public lands within the scope of the Underground Gas Storage Project started in 2005.22 The stages followed in the land acquisition process are as follows;  Taking the decision of Public Interest by the Ministry of Energy for the Tuz Gölü Natural Gas Storage Project (the decision allows the application of the Expropriation Law)  Identification of affected plots, assets and owners (asset inventory study)  Identification of landowners and title deed records  Land valuation process o Establishment of the valuation commission o Letter of notification o Official reply period o Establishment of the negotiations commission  Mutual agreement / non-agreement (in case of non-agreement between Negotiations Commission and landowners, BOTAŞ applies to the Court for land appraisal and registration of the land in the name of BOTAŞ with rights of use. Urgent expropriation will only be used when other avenues have failed. As per OP 4.12, the taking of land and related assets may only proceed if the Borrower sets aside funds equal to the amount offered plus 10 percent in an escrow or other interest-bearing account.)  Payments after agreements were reached and legal proceedings for title deed registrations have been concluded  Access to land (either by negotiated settlement or through court) has been confirmed prior to the start of construction. Steps followed for the preparation of land acquisition for private lands and legal procedures followed after a court case is filed are as shown in following Figures respectively. Figure 24 Preparation and Steps Followed for Acquisition of Private Lands (Turkey Context) 22 A Land Acquisition Plan (LAP) was prepared for the Underground Gas Storage Project in June 2005 which describes the framework and procedures that the Project will follow for the acquisition and compensation of land and assets, both for permanent and temporary uses. The 2005 LAP was disclosed in BOTAŞ’s web page and World Bank’s info shop in June 2005. 209 All Steps for plot and ownership identification completed All assets on plots identified and inventory prepared Addresses of all owners for each plot obtained Valuation commission established, each plot is visited, all agencies contacted as specified by the Law to provide information relevant for land valuation Negotiation commission established Land owners contacted to attend negotiations Land owners non-responsive Land owners attend negotiations No agreement possible Agreement on land transition reached Land owner certifies Land owner refuses to disagreement certify disagreement Owner is notified that case will be submitted to Court Court Road to acquisition open Figure 25 Court Process Followed for Acquisition of Private Lands 210 Expropriation Law No 2942 (D. 4650) Owners certifies Owners does not certify disagreement disagreement Authority Informs Owner of Decision in writing Authority Prepares Files Invitation for negotiation 30 days Court 1st Court Session 10 days Disagreement Agreement 1st Inspection by the Court Appointed Valuation Commission 15 days Valuation Report 30 days 2nd Court Session Agreement 15 days Disagrees 15 days 2nd Inspection by the Valuation Report Court Appointed Valuation 15 days Appeals to the decision of this session can be made only to the High Court 3rd Court Session 10 days Court Decision Value of Land Deposited in the Bank 15 days 15 days If necessary, additional time for bank deposit Deed transfer made 15 days Access to Land Granted In line with the above described process, land acquisition and resettlement process of BOTAŞ GSEP will also follow the same procedure in terms of national requirements and on top will comply with WB policies both in term of land acquisition and resettlement. Lands will be acquired and made available for the Project before the construction begins. No construction can take place unless the valuation is completed, certified attempts are made to negotiate the transfer of ownership rights, temporary and permanent easement rights from the private owners, and full payment is made to the accounts of owners. 211