79441 Nicaragua & IDA: An Enduring Partnership A HISTORIC PARTNERSHIP September 1962 First IDA Credit to Nicaragua Managua Water Supply Project $3 million May 1973 Earthquake Reconstruction Project of $20 million 1979-1980 IDA supports Nicaragua’s new government with urban reconstruction and agriculture and industrial rehabilitation 1991 IDA resumes engagement with Nicaragua 1991- 1995 IDA supports macroeconomic stabilization efforts with a series of Economic Recovery Credits 1995-2002 IDA supports state reform and institution building for private sector development December 1998 IDA responds to Hurricane Mitch with Emergency Project of $50 million 2001 IDA supports privatization of ENITEL, public telephone company IDA approves one of the first Learning and Innovation Loans for Competitiveness and the first National Disaster and Vulnerability Reduction Projects for Nicaragua and Honduras January 2004 Nicaragua achieves Enhanced HIPC Completion Point and qualifies for one of the largest debt relief programs under the initiative 2004 IDA supports Nicaragua’s preparation for the Dominican Republic-Central America-United States Free Trade Agreement (DR CAFTA) signed in August 2006 IDA launches MDRI for Nicaragua March 2008 IDA responds to Hurricane Felix with $17 million Emergency Project 2011-2012 IDA portfolio achieves record disbursement of 37% and leverages IDA resources more than twofold July 2013 2nd IDA17 Replenishment Meeting held in Managua IDA IS SUPPORTING NICARAGUA’S EFFORTS TO SCALE-UP INNOVATIVE APPROACHES FOR TACKLING POVERTY Nicaragua has made an impressive economic turnaround over the past 20 years, after suffering from decades of macroeconomic instability, violent conflicts, as well as major natural disasters. Nicaragua has also achieved some promising success in its innovative approach to delivering basic services to poor households. IDA is focused on scaling-up the country’s more successful innovations for reaching the rural poor. IDA’s investment and knowledge portfolio cuts across many sectors and is anchored on long-term engagement for lasting results in terms of poverty reduction and shared prosperity. MACROECONOMICS, POVERTY, SHARED PROSPERITY Decades of political instability and a series of catastrophic natural disasters led Nicaragua to a difficult macroeconomic situation, including public debt amounting to 350 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 1991. Half of all Nicaraguans were living in poverty and one-fifth in extreme poverty by 1993. In the mid-1990s, significant gains were made in stabilizing the economy, improving basic infrastructure and raising private investment. Then in 1998, the devastating effects of Hurricane Mitch set the country back again. Despite these challenges, Nicaragua has made strong progress in restoring and sustaining macroeconomic stability. Real GDP growth has averaged 3.7 percent since 1998, and real per capita growth, 2.3 percent. Inflation fell from 3-digit levels in 1991 to less than 8 percent in 2012. Alongside these improvements, private investment grew from 18 to 25 percent of GDP between 1998 and 2012. The economy has demonstrated strong resilience to shocks, with a relatively modest contraction (1.5 percent) during the 2009 global crisis, followed by a quick recovery in 2010 to 3.6 percent growth. Since then, Nicaragua has sustained moderately high growth rates of 5.3 percent during 2011-12 and strong fiscal results that have helped to further reduce public debt to 54 percent of GDP. Exports have been growing steadily by 16 percent per year over the last decade. IDA Development Policy Lending Approved US$m Economic Recovery Credit Sep 1991 $110 Economic Recovery Credit II Jun 1994 $60 Programatic Structural Adjustment Credit Mar 2003 $15 Poverty Reduction Support Credit I Jan 2004 $70 Poverty Reduction Support Credit II Nov 2006 $25 Debt Reduction Facility – Debt Buy Back July 2007 $45 Development Policy Credit Sep 2008 $20 $6.4 13 billion percent in combined debt of GDP in poverty Pte. info relief from interna- Pte. info related public tional lenders. spending in 2011. General poverty headcount Shared Properity: Mean Income Growth (% of population) 6% 80 Bottom 40% General Population 70.3 70 63.3 5% 60 4% 48.3 50 42.5 40 3% 30.9 26.8 30 2% 20 10 1% 0 0% 2005 2009 2005 2009 2005 2009 C.America 2006-11LAC, 2006-11Nicaragua 2005-09 IDA has been a steady partner in Nicaragua since 1991, representing in recent years about one-fifth of the country’s development aid. In 2002, IDA helped launch a debt relief effort that resulted in $ 6.4 billion of debt relief (equivalent to Nicara- gua’s annual GDP). This created the fiscal space to allow Nicaragua to increase annual spending on poverty reduction programs to almost 13 percent of GDP in 2011. Despite debt relief efforts, improved macroeconomic performance, and increased spending, by 2005 the poverty rate had only decreased by 2 percentage points and social indicators were showing only very gradual improvements. It appeared that poverty-related spending was not reach- ing the more remote rural communities where almost 80 percent of Nicaragua’s poor households live. Given the tumultuous history and persistence of poverty, there was a broad consensus that “business as usual� was not closing the gaps. Since then, Nicaragua has been a virtual innovation lab—across government administrations and within civil society—of programs to rapidly reach and improve the lives of its rural poor. Today poverty is falling faster. Over the last decade, the Government’s rural programs have made significant progress in improving service delivery to the poor- est. Between 2005-09, poverty fell by nearly 6 percentage points (or around 230,000 fewer poor people) and by 7 percentage points in rural areas. Extreme poverty fell from 17.2 to 14.6 percent and, despite previous concerns, a significant number of MDGs are now back on track. And Nicaragua is sharing the prosperity. Nicaragua stands out in the region in terms of progress towards shared growth. Mean per capita income grew by 1.0 percent and the growth rate of the bottom 40 was 4.8 percent, which surpasses both the Latin America and the Caribbean region and Central America (4.0 and 0.6 percent, respectively). 7 4.8 percentage percent point decline in growth in per capita rural poverty between income for the bottom 2005 and 2009. 40 percent. RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE Scaling up in rural roads. In 1998, Hurricane Mitch reversed much of Nicaragua’s earlier gains in road infrastructure. IDA has since invested over $256 million in improving the country’s secondary and rural roads. The Government has combined an old road-building technique using cobblestones with an expanded version of IDA’s Community-Driven Development approach. This innovative mechanism helped rehabili- tate and pave their road segments, up to 29 km long with lower unit costs. Community involvement in mobilizing and managing a local workforce, and “laying the roads by hand�, has created a strong ownership for maintenance and local management of traffic speeds, vehicle loads, etc. This community model has attracted interest from other developing countries, such as Paraguay and Liberia. Additionally, the Government was able to blend the new $35 million IDA grant with a $50 million loan from Central American Bank for Economic Integration (CABEI) and provide more coverage in poor rural areas. Creating time and space for rural women late to sell to the hotels and restaurants nearby. With their SHS, Marcia now can start milking at 4 am, finish by 8 am and sell all the milk before 9 am. This gives her plenty of time for her other activities of the day. … and space to sell. Inspired by the paving of the road, Jeannette de los Angeles and Maria Baez Rios contemplates the days Yalila Can Medina now run a small ice before her solar home system cream stall in the Las Flores community of Time to milk…. Marcia and her husband Masaya. “Two things motivated us to start make a living through their 20 milk- this business: first we did not have cold or producing cows in Nueva Guinea. In 2002, frozen dairy products before. To sell these under IDA's Off-Grid Rural Electrification things you need hygienic conditions and Project, they became owners of a 150Wp the dust was very bad along the road. And solar home system (SHS). Before, Marcia the second, the paving of the road brought needed to wait until daylight to milk the more traffic and more business�. cows. By the time she finished, it was too IDA Commitments Approved US$m Telecommunication Reform Nov 1999 $16 Off-Grid Rural Electrification May 2003 $12 Rural Telecom Apr 2006 $7 Rural Telecom AF Jun 2012 $5 460,000 more people with 40 microenterprises access to all-weather developed to maintain roads and 2400km 65,000 of roads. temporary jobs generated in community works. Connecting the poor. After providing financ- ing and technical assistance for the telephone company privatization in 2001, IDA has focused on improving rural access to telecom- munications. During 2005-06, IDA helped develop the Telecom Investment Fund, which provided telephone services to 500,000 people in 365 small towns. The ongoing Rural Telecom Project is helping to bring telephony and inter- net to remote communities. Today, all of Nicaragua’s municipal heads boast an internet connection and more than 500 communities now have their first public telephone. The project is also financing 37 communications towers, which have already connected 60,000 more people and will complete the country’s high-speed coverage. Off-Grid Rural Electrification Project • Three alternative energy supplier firms accredited and marketing household photo- voltaic systems nationwide. • Seven microfinance institutions with active rural electrification portfolios. • $1million loans issued to 1,200 clients for household connections, PV systems and minigrids. • 3MW of hydropower constructed in 6 community plants run by private concessions and regulatory framework developed. • 110,000 tons of CO2 abated by the end of the project. IDA Commitments Approved US$m Road Rehabilitation and Maintenance May 1996 $25 Road Rehabilitation and Maintenance II Jun 1998 $47 Road Rehabilitation and Maintenance III Feb 2001 $75 Roads Rehabilitation and Maintenance IV Jun 2006 $60 Roads Rehabilitation and Maintenance IV AF Jun 2010 $39 Rural Roads Infrastructure Improvement Dec 2011 $35 7,900 69 solar home systems percent with 468kW installed increase in rural in remote rural access to public communities. telephones from 2006-2012. HUMAN DEVELOPMENT A broad social agenda. Nicaragua’s approach to the social sectors stands out for its integrated delivery of public services. Nicaragua’s National System of Social Welfare comprises of the Community and Family Health Care Services, the new Educa- tion Sector Plan with a special focus on early childhood education, and the flagship social protection Programa Amor for at-risk families. Each of these elements is supported by an IDA project. The Second Education Sector Support Project aims to improve quality and completion rates in basic schools and has leveraged $54 million in trust funds from the EU and the Global Program for Education which are focusing on early childhood and secondary education. The Community and Family Health Care Services project is helping to introduce results-based financing so that community health networks can use more flexible approaches to lower maternal mortality. The Social Sector Project supports the consolidation and scale up of the Programa Amor platform for collaboration on children at risk and early child- hood development at the community level. Casas maternas for better maternal health Since 1998, IDA has supported the in the casas maternas, located near expansion of the innovative casas maternas health units, and receive support with in rural communities. From these casa breast-feeding, early parenting skills and maternas, networks of community family planning. IDA has helped to volunteers identify pregnant women in expand the number of casas maternas remote areas and bring them an array of from 12 in 2000 to over 80 in 2012, services, including pre-natal checkups, birth reaching over 20,000 women. Maternal plans, and post-natal follow up. Around mortality has fallen from 170 per 100,000 the time of delivery, the women stay live births in 1990 to around 95 in 2010, and the share of women receiving post-partum care has risen by 4 percent- age points. 1.2 10 million percent textbooks produced increase in 9th grade for all primary grades Spanish scores on and in indigenous standardized testing languages during during 2009-10. 2010-12. One Government…. Nicaragua is tackling a challenge which many developed country social systems continue to face – coordinating inter-sectoral service delivery at the local level – and is already seeing results. The Government has introduced many home-grown innovations: community volunteers that help to identify and draw in families at risk, joint home visits by health and social work- ers and community-run "escuelas de valores". … so one IDA country program. In turn, the Bank is following the client’s lead and adjusting our program to link activities across distinct projects. Each of the three projects is: • supporting the development of the National Registry of Beneficiaries, digitalizing information in the Ministries of Health and Education and compiling beneficiary information in the Ministry of the Family. • contributing to the design of a platform to monitor the Early Childhood Development program with health, education, and social welfare indicators • providing technical inputs to the Sistema Nacional de Desarollo de Infantil Temprano, e.g. for community handbooks, training materials for the volun- teers. IDA Social Sector Lending Approved US$m Health Sector Reform Dec 1993 $15 Health Sector Modernization Credit Jun 1998 $24 Health Services Extension and Modernization Apr 2005 $11 Response to Epidemiological Emergencies Dec 2009 $5 Improving Community and Family Health Care Dec 2010 $21 Basic Education Mar 1995 $34 Basic Education Supplemental Credit Jan 1999 $13 Basic Education II Aug 1999 $53 Support to the Education Sector Sep 2004 $15 Support to the Education Sector II Jan 2012 $25 Social Protection Feb 2011 $20 7 45 percent percent increase in the share decline in maternal of births attended by mortality from health professionals in 1990-2010. medical institutions during 2010-12. AGRICULTURE During the 1990s, Nicaragua drastically reduced government intervention in agriculture to free up space for private sector involvement. However, this left many farming households with limited access to financial and technical services, and most agricultural producers without resources to invest in research or train- ing in modern technologies. Since 1993, IDA has invested $80 million in the three agricultural technology projects and leveraged $23 million in co-financing to provide rural small and medium-sized producers with better access to sustainable agricultural, forestry and natural resource management services and technological innovations, and to strengthen links between agricultural training and research. One-third of small and medium-size farmers were in direct contact with extension services, and 70-90 percent report being satisfied with the quality of services and having adopted recommended improved technologies. Over 240 new entities (NGOs, producer groups and others) became involved in agricultural research and services, and 193 new agricultural technologies were developed and disseminated. IDA Commitments Approved US$m Agricultural and Industrial Rehabilitation Dec 1979 $10 Agricultural Technology & Land Management Jul 1993 $44 Sustainable Forestry Investment Jan 1999 $9 Agricultural Tech & Rural Technical Education Jun 2000 $24 Agricultural Technology II Nov 2005/May 2010 $22 38 42,500 percent producers received technical assistance, increase in yields of basic staples – rice, maize and beans – by 37 percent of them 2012. women. WATER AND SANITATION Social media, ICT and marketing for rural water and sanitation. IDA is helping Nicaragua to bring water and sanitation to urban slums and remote rural communities. So far, over 30,000 households have been reached with these new services. But the programs are not just financing civil works and training local teams to operate them. IDA is helping Nicaragua to pilot social programs to teach the benefits of hand washing, water conservation, and sewerage treatment using a range of social learning techniques, including community theater. It is also investing in mobile ICT to help monitor the operations of the rural systems. And with the Water and Sanitation Program, Nicaragua is undertaking a sanitation marketing pilot to find better ways of engaging the local private sector in providing new improved latrines to rural households. In a current example of South-South exchange, a recent delegation from Indonesia visited Nicaragua to learn how these innovations might be replicated in Indonesia’s more remote islands and communities. IDA Commitments Approved US$m Managua Water Supply Sep 1962 $3 Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Jun 2008 $20 Greater Managua Water and Sanitation Dec 2008 $40 Rural Water Supply and Sanitation AF Jan 2013 $6 40,000 more people with 44,900 people with better access to improved sanitation services in water sources in rural rural areas and areas and 17,600 new piped 17,400 new urban sewer connections in low connections by 2013. income urban areas by 2013. LAND ADMINISTRATION Empowering vulnerable communities. “It finally satisfied the ancestral Nicaragua’s indigenous peoples and demands of these people, who Afro-descendant ethnic communities are part of our multi-ethnic and represent roughly 12 percent of the popu- pluri-cultural state… lation. IDA has invested around $80 million in land administration in Nicaragua, and recently approved a new $40 million project in March 2013. Under this program, 15 of Nicaragua’s 21 indigenous territories in Atlantic Regions were titled and registered (roughly 17 percent of the national territory), benefitting over 104,000 people from 214 communities in five major ethnic groups. The process succeeded in resolving several historical disputes and has helped to improve relations between local groups and private investors. IDA has helped to revamp the legal frame- ...the modernization of the entire work and registration system for land and public land registry system has been one of the greatest achieve- property in Nicaragua. Thirteen thousand ments of the first stage of the km2 of property (10 percent of national project.� territory) was registered in the first stage. -Hernán Estrada, Attorney General The new project will add 9,000 km2 to reach 25 percent of the national territory registered. Close to 70,000 property titles have been delivered so far, 24,000 of which came from a cadastral sweep that helped register 224,000 plots. The new project aims to provide titles to a further 90,000 poor families in rural and urban areas. Half of these recipients are women. Meanwhile, the number of days to register property in the National Cadastre fell from 30 in 2006 to 10 in the targeted municipalities in 2012. IDA Commitments Approved US$m Agricultural Technology and Land Management Jul 1993 $44 Land Administration Jun 2002 $33 Land Administration AF Feb 2010 $10 Land Administration II Mar 2013 $40 25 percent of national territory 104,000 indigenous people in and 214 communities with lands 224,000 titled and registered, plots registered. 17 percent of national territory. FINANCE AND THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Expanding rural financial services. IDA’s support for Nicaragua’s burgeoning microfinance sector has helped to expand rural financial services. Since 2005, the number of financial service points in rural areas has increased by 25 percent while the number of borrowers expanded by 45 percent. In 2006, establishment of the country’s first credit bureau covered microcredits and included over 1.85 million debtors. The microcredit portfolio has almost doubled over the last decade, despite the difficul- ties during and after the global financial crisis. Today, the majority (65 percent) of micro- credit clients are women. IDA has also supported the development of the new Microfinance Law 2011 and has helped several large lenders to transform into special regulated institutions. ProNicaragua, developing a successful export promotion agency. IDA supported the establishment of ProNicaragua in 2002 with a Competitiveness Learning and Innovation Loan. In collaboration with MIGA, over 300 staff mem- bers were trained in investment and export promotion, and the fledgling agency was able to attract just under $140 million in investments and create 12,000 jobs during 2003-2005 (significantly beyond the targets of $27 million in investments and 5,000 jobs). From 2007 to 2012, over 20 microfinance institutions and 100 cooperatives received training and technical support in accounting, finance and risk manage- ment. Since then, the agency has been recognized several times by the Global Investment Promotion Benchmarking and in 2012 was the only agency to achieve the distinction of “best practice� in every dimension. IDA Commitments Approved US$m Financial Sector Adjustment Apr 1998 $70 Pension and Financial Market Reform TA May 2000 $8 Competitiveness Learning & Innovation Loan Jan 2001 $5 Broad-Based Access to Financial Services May 2004 $7 Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise Development Jun 2008 $20 23,000 25 micro, small and medium-sized percent enterprises receiving increase in financial business development service points in services by 2012. rural areas. DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT (DRM) Since the catastrophic earthquake that leveled Managua at the end of 1972, IDA has been supporting Nicaragua in disaster recovery and disaster risk manage- ment. The devastating impact of Hurricane Mitch in 1998 brought to light the very limited public awareness on prevention, the lack of local emergency preparedness and vulnerability assessments, and the absence of a system for financing disaster mitigation measures. This drew attention to the need for a national system for disaster risk management and a coordinating agency to plan for disaster prevention and emergency response. In 2001, IDA approved the World Bank’s first Natural Disaster and Vulnerability Reduction Project for Nicaragua. Today, the country boasts solid legal and institutional arrangements for disaster risk management and a well-performing National System for Disaster Prevention, Mitigation and Response (SINAPRED). Awareness programs run through the public education system, municipalities utilize preventative land use plans, annual financing is secured in the budget and disaster risk mitigation is featured in Nicaragua’s national development strategy. Indeed, the experience from the later, albeit smaller, Hurricane Felix in 2008 demonstrated the power of the improved disaster risk management to save lives and reduce damages. IDA Commitments Approved US$ Earthquake Reconstruction May 1973 $20 Urban Construction Dec 1979 $22 Hurricane (Mitch) Emergency Dec 1998 $50 Natural Disaster Vulnerability Reduction Apr 2001 $14 Hurricane Felix Emergency Recovery Mar 2008 $17 Response to Epidemiological Emergencies Dec 2009 $5 Hurricane Felix Emergency Recovery AF Nov 2012 $5 Land Administration II: IRM component Mar 2013 $8 National System for Disaster 3,985 roofs rehabilitated and Preparedness, Mitigation and 71 Response fully communities trained in operational and improved building performing well. techniques after Hurricane Felix between 2008-2012. CLIMATE CHANGE Adapting to climate change. Nicaragua is using grant resources 60 hurricane resistant from the Special Climate Change Fund bamboo houses to help rural communities find ways to designed and protect their water supplies, given constructed. expected increasing volatility in rainfall. This program is being piloted in 4 municipalities and includes modern impact evaluation techniques so that the lessons can be applied more broadly. Mitigating climate change. Nicaragua has paid its first BioCarbon Fund credits under the Precious Woods project, which is expected to reduce around 300,000 tons of CO2 emissions and has been approved for a Forest Carbon Partnership Facility REDD readiness grant. Collaborating on renewable energy. The Government of Nicaragua is shifting to 74 percent generation of electricity from renewables by 2018, and 91 percent by 2027. To support these efforts, IFC and MIGA will take the lead through investments and guarantees in renewable generation projects -- wind, geothermal and hydropower, while IDA provides technical assistance and analytical work to backstop these investments, in particular on sector financing, and strategies for accelerating geothermal investments. INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT IDA has supported the development of Nicaragua’s public financial management system since 1995. Today, Nicaragua has a Medium Term Expenditure Framework in place in all central government and decentralized agencies, and is strengthening the links between planning and budgeting. Nicaragua improved its score in the Open Budget Index from 21 in 2006 to 37 in 2010, on par with the Central America average. An IDA project is working hand-in-hand with the European Union and InterAmerican Development Bank to modernize the current financial management information system, developed under an earlier IDA project. All government IDA Commitments Approved US$m agencies included in Institutional Development Mar 1995 $23 the Medium Term Economic Management Technical Jan 2000 $21 Expenditure Public Sector Technical Assistance Mar 2004 $24 Framework and new Public Financial Mgmt Mod Dec 2010 $10 information system being developed. Partnering for measurement….. IDA has provided statistical capacity building and technical support for all Nicaragua's Living Standards Measure- ment Surveys over the last decade, in 1993, 1998, 2001, 2005 and again in 2009, and in March 2012 approved financing for the 2014 survey as well. In recent years, IDA has also supported the 2012 Demographic and Health Survey and the 2011 Agricultural Census (together with Canadian trust fund). ….and evaluation IDA has also supported the impact evaluation of a 2006 pilot program in Nicaragua to help rural households to diversify beyond small-scale farming. This long-term study has successfully measured the impact of the various types of assistance on key aspects of rural household welfare: children's cognitive development, climate resilience and income generation. Very powerful results continue to emerge from this pilot that are helping Nicaragua to refine its social interventions. • Two years after the program, families who received investment grants or vocational training were better protected against weather “shocks� than those who only qualified for conditional cash transfers or didn’t receive anything. • Contrary to recent academic findings, the poorest households were the ones who saw the largest impact of investment grants on their income generation. • Creates personal motivation from interacting with role models or simply being selected into the program had a greater impact on income than the cash transfers themselves. Learn more about the work of the World Bank in Nicaragua: www.worldbank.org/nicaragua Visit us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/worldbank Be updated via Twitter: www.twitter.com/WorldBankLAC For our YouTube channel: www.youtube.com/lacregion2010