The Global Program for Avian Influenza Control and Human Pandemic Preparedness and Response for Vietnam received a highly satisfactory outcome with moderate risk to development outcome.
... See More + Both the Bank and the Borrower received a satisfactory performance rating. Components were not revised during the project life, and there were no other significant changes in design, scope and scale, and implementation arrangements. The following lessons can help inform future programs that build veterinary and human public health systems for prevention and control of diseases: (1) An emergency is an opportunity to reduce risks over the medium term. This will help prevent future costly emergencies. (2) One Health approaches are effective in disease control and prevention. (3) One Health approaches are feasible when there is good leadership. (4) Behavior change takes time and resources. (5) Upstream attention to environmental impacts helps prevent problems. (6) Transition from emergency response to systemic improvements is important. (7) Successful market upgrades. (8) M&E indicators. Final outcome indicators (such as disease prevalence and the case fatality ratio) are by themselves not sufficient to evaluate progress and thus may be misleading. They need to be complemented by measures of system performance for functions that are required for disease control and prevention. (9) Technical definitions are critical for M&E. (10) Use of consultants. External expertise was essential for the highly technical task of improving laboratories and their management. (11) Decentralized implementation. This was both necessary (because disease control and prevention activities occur in numerous districts and villages) and challenging (because local capacity was uneven and alignment with national policies and programs was required). (12) Engaging stakeholders beyond Ministry of Health (MOH) and Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD). (13) Training health workers on communications, especially risk communications. This helped extend messages to communities and improved infection control in health care facilities. (14) Rule to balance expenditures on training and equipment in health care centers. (15) Quality of supervision and implementation support. Substantial implementation support was instrumental to the success of this technically complex, emergency, and multisectoral operation.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report ICR3330 DEC 23, 2014
The purpose of drafting this plan is to, through implementing the policy of prioritizing prevention and comprehensive control, to set up ten to twenty exemplary demonstration bases, introduce the conception of integrated pest management (IPM), offer IPM technique technologies trainings for farmers, grass-roots agricultural technique technologies cohorts and staff from the project office, and widely exercise large scale prevention and control against plants pests plant pests and animals diseases animal diseases.
... See More + The pests prevention and control should cut the outbreak by more than 90 percent, the utilized dosage of pesticides by over 30 percent, and the usage of chemical drugs in the core green exemplary demonstration areas by above 50 percent. We hope the average mortality of sheep and beef cattle can be lowered by 2 percent and 4 percent respectively compared with the level prior to this project. The foot-and-mouth disease and parasites among other animals epidemics of sheep and beef cattle must also be effectively contained, with certain localities reaching purification standards. Such major zoonoses as Brucella should be substantially curbed, while the prevention capacity against imported epidemics must be significantly enhanced.
See Less -
Ratings for the Avian and Human Influenza Control and Preparedness Emergency Project for Cambodia were as follows: outcomes were moderately satisfactory, the risk to development outcome was substantial, the Bank performance was moderately satisfactory, and the Borrower performance was satisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: there is also an issue with attribution when dealing with changes in the number of cases. For example, one of the initial key indicators in this project (the number of cases of avian influenza in peri-urban commercial poultry) had to be dropped because no new cases were detected in this sector during the course of the project. This was coincidental and not attributable to gains from project activities. Procurement and financial management arrangements for the engagement of the UN agencies in an emergency disease response project should be clearly established at the corporate level in advance. One of the crucial issues that remains to be addressed in Cambodia but for which some background work has been conducted (such as improved legislation and training in biosecurity for villages) is the weak control over poultry movements. Until such time as there is better control of movement of poultry within Cambodia and across borders disease outbreaks will recur. Limited controls on movement of other types of livestock also threaten the health status of livestock in the country. Detailed case investigations and monitoring provide opportunities to reduce the probability of emergence of a pandemic agent. The work undertaken by officers in Health Departments following detection of human cases provided the best possible chance of detecting any evidence of human to human transmission of the virus therefore allowing measures to be implemented to prevent its spread.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report ICR2781 OCT 27, 2014
Ratings for the Zoonoses Control Project for Nepal were as follows: outcomes were satisfactory, the risk to development outcome was Moderate, the Bank performance was satisfactory, and the Borrower performance was also moderately satisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: Government commitment to the continuation of the investment made through other HPAI projects was a crucial factor in achieving NZCPs PDOs in spite of the very short implementation period (2 years according to PAD. The Contributing factors to this success is the dedication of the Project Manager and his close collaboration with the WBs Team and continuity of the AICP project management and staff; commitment of the GoN and its provision of advance resources to allow for project startup and planning; and the recruitment of capable subject matter consultants specially the M ; E senior consultant. Centralized and strong M ; E and Planning Unit is crucial for effective technical support. The centralized system at the PMU level in Kathmandu provided two benefits; reduction of transaction cost and enhancement of intersectoral collaboration; both being crucial for the development of a cost effective OH approach. The KAP survey could be a strategic M;E tool. Intersectoral collaboration and high level GoN commitment are crucial for the development and installation of the One Health Approach. Keeping just one agency as the primary implementing partner, which is responsible for streamlining, consolidating and submitting the budgets requests, procurement plans, and audit reports have mitigated many coordination issues and delays. The concluding workshop organized by Massey University in Bhutan played an instrumental role in bringing the key regional stakeholders together and raising high level awareness on OH approach. Similar events are necessary in order to reinforce the need to form and institutionalize the OH approach to address zoonotic diseases.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report ICR3260 SEP 15, 2014
Ratings for the Avian and Human Influenza Preparedness and Response Project for Uganda were as follows: outcomes were moderately satisfactory, the risk to global environment outcome was moderate, the Bank performance was moderately satisfactory, and the Borrower performance was also moderately satisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: for civil works contracts under execution, it is important for the Borrower's contract managers to supervise the contractor regularly (such as weekly) to establish the capacity/readiness of the contractor. The frequency of visits can be increased or reduced depending upon the contractor's strengths or other measures taken for noted poor performance. Adequately engaging key parliamentarians about the project's broad scope and the varied and persistent nature of the threats addressed under the project could have potentially facilitated an expedited and favorable consideration of the project in Parliament. It is particularly important that relevant parliamentary sectoral committees be closely associated with the project preparation process. With the growing and persistent threat from zoonotic diseases, a culture and effective modi operandi of collaboration between the ministries in charge of health and livestock are critical in ensuring adequate monitoring of, and rapid response to major zoonotic disease outbreaks.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report ICR3144 JUN 30, 2014
Ratings for the Prevention and Management of Influenza Type Illness and Strengthening of Argentina's Epidemiological System Project for Argentina were as follows: outcome was satisfactory, risk to development outcome or global environment outcome was moderate, Bank performance was satisfactory, Borrower (of guaranteed loan) and implementing party performance was satisfactory, and Government performance was satisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: Argentina's adoption of a high-risk targeted vaccination strategy against A-H1N1 influenza was effective in containing the epidemic. A comprehensive (human and animal) pandemic preparedness plan will benefit from moving from a response approach using emergency instruments to one that favors preventive risk reduction and risk management through regular country program and operations. High-risk groups can only be reached through an intense communication effort. Despite a short preparation period, it is important to avoid having tunnel vision and think broadly when designing emergency loans. The execution of projects within existing technical and administrative structures has significant positive externalities. A result-based financing (RBF) model is a valuable strategy to influence subnational government policies in federal systems. The World Bank should re-evaluate the objective of the emergency recovery loan instrument and its consistency with other fiduciary policies.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report 89199 JUN 25, 2014
The purpose of drafting this plan is to, through implementing the policy of prioritizing prevention and comprehensive control, to set up ten to twenty exemplary demonstration bases, introduce the conception of integrated pest management (IPM), offer IPM technique technologies trainings for farmers, grass-roots agricultural technique technologies cohorts and staff from the project office, and widely exercise large scale prevention and control against plants pests plant pests and animals diseases animal diseases.
... See More + The pests prevention and control should cut the outbreak by more than 90 percent, the utilized dosage of pesticides by over 30 percent, and the usage of chemical drugs in the core green exemplary demonstration areas by above 50 percent. We hope the average mortality of sheep and beef cattle can be lowered by 2 percent and 4 percent respectively compared with the level prior to this project. The foot-and-mouth disease and parasites among other animals epidemics of sheep and beef cattle must also be effectively contained, with certain localities reaching purification standards. Such major zoonoses as Brucella should be substantially curbed, while the prevention capacity against imported epidemics must be significantly enhanced.
See Less -
The development objective of the Guizhou Rural Development and Poverty Alleviation Project for China is to develop and implement models for agricultural sector restructuring and modernization, improved organizational arrangements, and strengthened public service delivery in Guizhouapos;s poverty stricken areas which increase rural income in an equitable and socially acceptable way.
... See More + Some of the negative impacts and mitigation measures include: To properly settle down the problems caused by the project on the society, economy and environment and make sure the environment within the project area can meet the functional requirements of the environment; to control soil erosion due to the destruction of vegetation and soil excessive use of resources, and agricultural chemical pollution, maintain the integrity of the ecosystem, ecological balance and diversity as well as protect the rare and endangered species and ancient woods with great value; to control the emissions of noise, waste water and solid waste during the construction and operation period, and protect the air, sound and water in the surrounding environment; to meet the planting and aquaculture planning of agriculture, forestry, animal husbandry and protect the farmland, woodland and grassland in the protected areas; to respect local customs in ethnic minority areas, and protect minority activities, nature reserves, drinking water source, scenic areas, heritage areas, world heritage sites and forest parks from destroy.
See Less -
The development objective of the Guizhou Rural Development and Poverty Alleviation Project for China is to develop and implement models for agricultural sector restructuring and modernization, improved organizational arrangements, and strengthened public service delivery in Guizhouapos;s poverty stricken areas which increase rural income in an equitable and socially acceptable way.
... See More + Some of the negative impacts and mitigation measures include: To properly settle down the problems caused by the project on the society, economy and environment and make sure the environment within the project area can meet the functional requirements of the environment; to control soil erosion due to the destruction of vegetation and soil excessive use of resources, and agricultural chemical pollution, maintain the integrity of the ecosystem, ecological balance and diversity as well as protect the rare and endangered species and ancient woods with great value; to control the emissions of noise, waste water and solid waste during the construction and operation period, and protect the air, sound and water in the surrounding environment; to meet the planting and aquaculture planning of agriculture, forestry, animal husbandry and protect the farmland, woodland and grassland in the protected areas; to respect local customs in ethnic minority areas, and protect minority activities, nature reserves, drinking water source, scenic areas, heritage areas, world heritage sites and forest parks from destroy.
See Less -
The development objective of the Guizhou Rural Development and Poverty Alleviation Project for China is to develop and implement models for agricultural sector restructuring and modernization, improved organizational arrangements, and strengthened public service delivery in Guizhouapos;s poverty stricken areas which increase rural income in an equitable and socially acceptable way.
... See More + Some of the negative impacts and mitigation measures include: To properly settle down the problems caused by the project on the society, economy and environment and make sure the environment within the project area can meet the functional requirements of the environment; to control soil erosion due to the destruction of vegetation and soil excessive use of resources, and agricultural chemical pollution, maintain the integrity of the ecosystem, ecological balance and diversity as well as protect the rare and endangered species and ancient woods with great value; to control the emissions of noise, waste water and solid waste during the construction and operation period, and protect the air, sound and water in the surrounding environment; to meet the planting and aquaculture planning of agriculture, forestry, animal husbandry and protect the farmland, woodland and grassland in the protected areas; to respect local customs in ethnic minority areas, and protect minority activities, nature reserves, drinking water source, scenic areas, heritage areas, world heritage sites and forest parks from destroy.
See Less -
Disease risks to humans, animals, and plants are determined by interconnected environmental variables that affect incidence, transmission, and outbreak.
... See More + Climate change affects many of the environmental variables that lead to disease. Regardless of the species involved, the impacts can ultimately affect the health, livelihood, and economic security of humans. The objective of this World Bank economic and sector work is to build on scientific and operational knowledge of early action tools to help practitioners reduce the risks of key climate-sensitive infectious diseases by strengthening risk management systems for disease outbreaks. The report includes an assessment of known interventions such as the establishment of surveillance systems, the development of region and nation-specific disease outlooks, the creation of climate-sensitive disease risk maps, and the construction and implementation of early warning advisory systems. This research highlights the need for better understanding of the evolving interactions between the environment and emerging and reemerging disease pathogens. It also points to the inseparable interactions between animal health and human health, which climate change appears to be reinforcing and even diversifying. The assessment looks at investments that can lead to the development of these tools, working toward reducing global climate-sensitive disease risk. Because of the breadth of species affected by climate-sensitive disease, it has been helpful to select a model through which the specific impact of climate change and disease can be traced. In this instance, livestock has been chosen, given its significant global presence, economic importance, and susceptibility to disease outbreak. The livestock sector plays a vital role in the economies of many developing countries. Globally it accounts for 40 percent of agricultural gross domestic product (GDP).
See Less -
Working Paper (Numbered Series) 84956 APR 01, 2014
The development objective of the Zoonoses Control Project for Nepal is to enhance the country capacity for the prevention and control of infectious diseases that transmit between animals and humans (zoonoses) under a one health approach.
... See More + This restructuring paper, therefore, creation of a new category apos;Compensationapos; for reallocation of USD 886,000 from category apos;Trainingapos; to the newly established category.
See Less -
The development objective of the Zoonoses Control Project for Nepal is to enhance the country capacity for the prevention and control of infectious diseases that transmit between animals and humans (zoonoses) under a one health approach.
... See More + This restructuring paper, therefore, creation of a new category apos;Compensationapos; for reallocation of USD 886,000 from category apos;Trainingapos; to the newly established category.
See Less -
Ratings for the Avian Influenza Preparedness and Response Project for Bangladesh were as follows: outcomes were moderately satisfactory, risk to development outcome was high, Bank performance was moderately satisfactory, and Borrower performance was moderately satisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: the project design and scope should have been simpler by better balancing technical content against the limited local implementation capacity and tailoring the design accordingly. Bank and Borrower implementation performance can be substantially improved by a simpler project design, earlier institution of better Monitoring and Evaluation (M and E) quality, better cognizance of matching project funds and activities to already ongoing donor activities, quicker government action to recruit partner organization, if necessary for project implementation, and speedy internalization of incremental budgets associated with upgraded avian flu containment activities. Care should be taken to explicitly include all relevant agencies as implementing partners. Inadequate poultry farm biosecurity is the paramount constraint in containing avian influenza in Bangladesh, which should have been recognized during project preparation. Public awareness messaging is expensive and should be shifted from sole government financing to Public-Private Partnership (PPP) arrangements with private sector business stakeholders, under which the costs of circulating messages is borne as part of the goodwill advertising by businesses (i.e., poultry feed and drug companies, breeder farms and hatcheries). Risk-based epidemiology capacity should be developed quickly, so that the costs of disease control strategies becomes focused on the least-cost analysis of high risk areas, thereby limiting human physical resource costs whilst making interventions more effective and sustainable. Speeding up procurement in Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI) emergency operations needs full readiness for implementation prior to negotiation, greater Borrower cooperation, and more intensive Project Coordinating Unit (PCU) training. Limit the quot;sticker shockquot; of incremental operating and maintenance costs from upgraded laboratory and surveillance systems by a gradual, proportional shift from project to government funding during the projectapos;s lifespan, leading to full government financing by end of project. Emergency operations must be implemented as avian flu is a rapidly spreading infection.
See Less -
Implementation Completion and Results Report ICR2177 JUN 27, 2013
Ratings for the Avian Influenza Control and Human Pandemic Preparedness and Response Project under the Global Program for Avian Influenza (GPAI) for Romania were as follows: outcomes were unsatisfactory, risk to development outcome was significant, monitoring and evaluation was negligible, Bank performance was moderately unsatisfactory, and Borrower performance was moderately unsatisfactory.
... See More + Some lessons learned included: countries that have already effectively controlled avian influenza outbreaks in poultry many not need an emergency project, but rather long term capacity building. The real emergency issue was European Union (EU) accession, but after accession was achieved the government lost interest in the project. The evaluation also notes that following this project, avian influenza is still a threat to Romania. Avian influenza risks cannot be minimized without ensuring adequate capacity in the animal health sector and adequate biosecurity in the poultry sector. Project designs that do not improve biosecurity on commercial farms or backyard systems will miss an opportunity to reduce the likelihood of avian influenza outbreaks.
See Less -
Project Performance Assessment Report 78781 JUN 24, 2013