Report No: ACS2258 v6 ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN BALOCHISTAN NEEDS ASSESSMENT DEVELOPMENT ISSUES AND PROSPECTS PART III – GDP: PERFORMANCE & STRUCTURE JANUARY 2013 A. GDP ESTIMATES 1991–2005 Balochistan: Estimation of Provincial GDP: 1990/91–2004/05 A.1 Background 1. The province of Balochistan was established on July1, 1970 after the then West Pakistan was bifurcated into four provinces—the Punjab, Sindh, the NWFP, and Balochistan. Prior to getting the status of a province, Balochistan was governed as an autonomous state comprising mainly four areas, i.e. Tribal, Leased, British Balochistan, and Kalat States. Kalat States included Autonomous States of Kalat, Kharan, Mekran, and Lasbela. These states were ruled by Khans, Nawabs, and Jams and enjoyed independent status until 1951. In 1951 these States joined together and formed Balochistan State Union until the dissolution of one-unit.1 2. Situated on the eastern borders of Iran and Afghanistan, Balochistan holds a strategic geo-political importance. The same borders brought into Balochistan a variety of invaders who influenced the culture and the society of the area. In terms of its size, Balochistan is the largest province of Pakistan with 44% of Pakistan’s total area. However, in terms of population, it is the smallest province with a share of only about 5% in Pakistan’s population. These two characteristics combine to give Balochistan a population density of 19 persons per sq. km. as compared to 166 for Pakistan, and 359 for Punjab. This extremely low population density is attributed mainly to the climatic conditions and the rough terrain of the province. Balochistan is hyper-arid, lacks irrigation water and is highly dependent on tubewell water. Population distribution of the Provinces Area Composition of the Provinces Is la m a ba d B a lo c his t 1% an F A TA N WF P F A TA N WF P Is la m a ba d 5% 2% 13 % 3% 9% 0% S indh 23% P unja b 26% B a lo c his t an P unja b S indh 44% 56% 18 % 3. The province, however, is rich in mineral resources, which unfortunately are not optimally exploited due to the difficult terrain, lack of infrastructure and weak finances of the provincial government. Outside these two sectors, services are the other main source of income. 1 “One unit� means that the entire territory of the present -day Pakistan was governed as a single province called “West Pakistan.� Present-day Bangladesh constituted “East Pakistan.� The details regarding Balochistan are from Muhammad Akbar Azad, Governance, Law and Customs in Balochistan. 1 A.2 Estimating Regional Accounts for Balochistan 4. To date, the Income Accounts in Pakistan are estimated only at the national level. This leaves provinces at a disadvantage not in terms of assessing the sources on provincial income and growth, but also in terms of planning for future development. Moreover, lack of regional accounts deprives the researchers of benchmark to base their analytical work on the provincial economy. As such, for the analysis of the Balochistan Economic Report to be meaningful, it was deemed necessary to construct a series of provincial accounts. However, given the limited time and resources available for this exercise, the estimates of provincial should only be considered as a first approximation. The purpose of the exercise is not to derive perfect estimates of sectoral and provincial value added, but to obtain some rough estimates of the composition of Balochistan’s economy. These rough estimates, nonetheless, provide a reasonable trend of relative changes in the provincial economy and help place each sector of the provincial economy in the national context. But it should be clear that the present exercise is no substitute for an official series of provincial accounts prepared by the Federal Bureau of Statistics. A.2.1 The Regional Accounts of Balochistan: Methodology and Data 5. Methodology: The construction of provincial GDP series is a large and complex undertaking, as disaggregated data are needed for a very large number of province-specific variables. Given time constraints and data inadequacies, as an interim measure, this process relied upon calculating Balochistan’s share in the national value-added of various economic sectors using some broad “allocators�, or national-GDP apportioning factors. 6. Nonetheless, wherever data were available in a more disaggregated form, value-added in various sectors was estimated on a similar pattern to the methodology used by the Federal Bureau of Statistics (FBS) to estimate national GDP. However, such information at the regional level was not available for all sectors and activities. Even the national data that are published by FBS are available with considerable time lag, and certain key surveys are also not conducted at regular intervals, thus leaving significant data gaps in the national series. We must therefore emphasize the approximate nature of our calculations, and stress that the derived provincial GDP estimates should only be used as broad indications of trends rather than as precise estimates for a given year. 7. Under the present exercise, provincial GDP has been estimated at 1999/2000 prices (on the pattern of National Accounts rebasing by the Federal Bureau of Statistics (FBS)) using a combination of the three traditional approaches—production, expenditure, and income. 8. More specifically, wherever detailed provincial data were available—for example, agriculture, mining and quarrying, and manufacturing—the sectoral value-added were estimated using the production approach. The expenditure approach was used to determine value-added of the construction, ownership of dwellings, electricity and gas distribution, and public administration and defense sub-sectors, whereas a variant of the income approach was applied to estimate value-added in the transport, storage, and communication, banking and insurance, and services sub-sectors. In almost all of these instances, the direct and indirect methods were combined to compute sectoral value-added by apportioning the national income to the province using appropriate allocators. 2 9. While these allocators were applied only where disaggregated data at the provincial level were not available, clearly the present exercise represents a “second-best� approach to estimate sectoral value-added at the provincial level. In what follows below, we provide a brief sector-by- sector description of the methodology and techniques used to estimate provincial GDP. 1990/91 S e rv ic e s , 2004/05 S e rv i c e s , 7 .3 4 .1 P ub l . A d m P u b l.A d m O t h e rs , O t he rs , n&D e f . , n &D e f ., 5 .2 6 .5 A g ri., A g ri . , 10 . 7 12 .7 2 9 .3 3 3 .7 O w n&D w l M a n f ., g , 1. 9 9 .2 M a nf . , O wn &D wl C o n s t ., W hl s a l &R 9 .4 T ra n s .C o Tra ns . C o g , 3 .8 Wh ls a l&R 2 .5 e t . , 19 . 0 El e c &G a s , C o ns t . , m ., 8 .3 E le c &G a s m. , 9 . 2 1. 8 e t ., 17 .2 3 .7 , 4 .6 10. Agriculture: As per the classification of national accounts of Pakistan, the agriculture sector is divided into four sub-sectors, viz. cropped agriculture, livestock, forestry and fisheries. While detailed data were available for cropped agriculture, the data on forestry, and livestock were limited and therefore value-added in these sub-sectors was estimated by applying a mix of direct and indirect (provincial allocators) methods for regional GDP. 11. Overall, the computation of value-added in crop agriculture covers 12 major crops, 27 minor crops, horticulture, fruits, vegetables and non-reported crops. The crop output data for Balochistan and for Pakistan was obtained from published sources,2 mainly those of the Federal and Balochistan Bureau of Statistics. The input costs are computed using the same methodology as used by the FBS in its rebasing exercise for National Accounts. This exercise also provides input cost of seed, fertilizer, pesticide, water, ploughing and planking, transport cost and wastage for all four provinces for 1999/00. Similarly, the base-year output and input prices were also obtained from the same rebasing exercise of the FBS. 12. The aggregate value added for major and minor crops was calculated by subtracting the input costs from the respective aggregate gross value of output.3 The major crops used in the value-added analysis are wheat, rice, cottonseed, sugarcane, maize, gram, barley, jawar, bajra, rapeseed & mustard, sesame seed, and tobacco for the years 1990/91 to 2004/05. The crops used in calculating the value-added of minor crops are all lentils, onion, chillies, coriander, fodder, garlic, groundnut, potato, etc. 13. Livestock: The livestock sub-sector includes the value-added of milk, meats, poultry, and eggs. The consumption of each of these products in Balochistan vis-à-vis national consumption was taken as the allocator to estimate provincial value-added. The consumption share was computed on the basis of per-capita monthly consumption of each product reported in various issues of the Household Income and Expenditure Surveys (HIES) conducted by FBS. The data series was extended to non-HIES years using standard interpolating techniques. The share of 2 The data are obtained from various issues of the Pakistan Statistical Yearbook, Agriculture Statistics of Pakistan, Balochistan Development Statistics, Economic Survey, Agricultural Crops and Livestock Products – Long-Term Trends, and Support Price Policy Issues of Major Crops. 3 As per the FBS’s rebasing exercise, the input cost was derived as a fixed proportion of gross value of output. 3 each product in total consumption was obtained by converting per capita monthly consumption into total annual consumption for Pakistan and the Province using estimated population shares. The weight of each product in total value-added was derived from the national accounts data.4 The weighted share of consumption for each product was then added and applied to national value-added of livestock to get Balochistan’s livestock value-added. Table A.1: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Agriculture Sector At Constant Factor Cost, 1999/2000 prices (Rs Million) Major Minor Crop Livestock Fishery Forestry Agriculture Crops Crops Value Value Added Added 1990/91 6,317 13,460 19,777 11,871 1,895 79 32,434 1991/92 6,915 12,707 19,622 11,832 1,540 33 31,299 1992/93 8,180 13,172 21,352 11,797 1,539 27 33,521 1993/94 8,597 14,628 23,226 11,818 1,688 57 35,985 1994/95 8,280 16,320 24,601 11,788 1,757 33 37,168 1995/96 9,845 17,762 27,607 14,081 1,273 24 41,734 1996/97 9,097 17,811 26,908 13,806 1,404 38 41,338 1997/98 10,863 14,499 25,362 16,037 1,139 24 42,116 1998/99 10,204 13,081 23,285 19,417 951 22 43,302 1999/00 9,267 15,482 24,749 23,673 2,109 628 51,209 2000/01 9,576 15,277 24,853 17,678 2,150 718 45,334 2001/02 9,579 14,920 24,499 18,076 2,004 747 45,367 2002/03 11,193 14,948 26,141 17,940 2,442 778 47,273 2003/04 11,473 17,095 28,568 18,116 2,361 518 49,413 2004/05 11,958 20,706 32,664 17,999 1,481 235 51,986 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. Table A.2: Balochistan Agriculture GDP Share of National GDP, At Constant Factor Cost (percent) Major Minor Crop Livestock Fishery Forestry Agriculture Crops Crops Value Value Added Added 1990/91 2.5 14.9 5.4 4.9 17.0 0.4 5.3 1991/92 2.4 13.7 4.7 4.6 13.1 0.2 4.7 1992/93 3.3 13.7 5.9 4.3 12.4 0.2 5.2 1993/94 3.5 13.5 6.3 4.1 12.3 0.3 5.3 1994/95 3.1 14.1 6.1 3.9 13.8 0.2 5.2 1995/96 3.4 14.6 6.5 3.7 10.3 0.2 5.1 1996/97 3.3 14.5 6.6 3.5 10.8 0.3 5.0 1997/98 3.7 10.9 5.8 4.0 8.3 0.2 5.0 1998/99 3.4 9.5 5.3 4.7 6.9 0.2 5.0 1999/00 2.7 12.3 5.3 5.7 13.9 2.7 5.5 2000/01 3.1 12.6 5.8 4.1 14.6 2.8 5.0 2001/02 3.2 12.7 5.9 4.0 15.5 3.1 5.0 2002/03 3.5 12.5 5.9 3.9 18.3 2.9 5.0 2003/04 3.5 13.8 6.3 3.8 17.3 2.0 5.1 2004/05 3.1 16.2 6.3 3.7 10.6 1.3 5.1 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 4 FBS authorities provided the data. 4 Table A.3: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Agriculture Sector At Current Factor Cost (Rs Million) Major Minor Crop Value Livestock Fishery Forestry Agriculture Crops Crops Added Value Added 1990/91 6,317 13,460 18,589 11,871 1,895 79 32,434 1991/92 6,915 12,707 17,894 11,832 1,540 33 31,299 1992/93 8,180 13,172 20,157 11,797 1,539 27 33,521 1993/94 8,597 14,628 22,422 11,818 1,688 57 35,985 1994/95 8,280 16,320 23,590 11,788 1,757 33 37,168 1995/96 9,845 17,762 26,356 14,081 1,273 24 41,734 1996/97 9,097 17,811 26,091 13,806 1,404 38 41,338 1997/98 10,863 14,499 24,916 16,037 1,139 24 42,116 1998/99 10,204 13,081 22,912 19,417 951 22 43,302 1999/00 9,267 15,482 24,798 23,673 2,109 628 51,209 2000/01 9,576 15,277 24,788 17,678 2,150 718 45,334 2001/02 9,579 14,920 24,539 18,076 2,004 747 45,367 2002/03 11,193 14,948 26,112 17,940 2,442 778 47,273 2003/04 11,473 17,095 28,418 18,116 2,361 518 49,413 2004/05 11,958 20,706 32,272 17,999 1,481 235 51,986 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. Table A. 4: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Agriculture Sector Share of Balochistan, at Current Factor Cost (percent) Major Minor Crop Lives Fishery Forestry Agriculture Crops Crops Value Stock Value Added Added 1990/91 6.0 26.8 12.0 11.1 35.3 0.9 11.8 1991/92 5.0 23.7 9.3 9.5 24.4 0.4 9.4 1992/93 6.4 22.2 10.7 8.1 18.3 0.3 9.5 1993/94 5.6 20.0 9.8 6.7 18.9 0.5 8.5 1994/95 4.2 19.6 8.4 5.5 19.0 0.3 7.2 1995/96 4.6 17.8 8.5 5.7 12.5 0.2 7.2 1996/97 3.9 17.0 7.7 4.0 12.5 0.3 5.9 1997/98 3.8 11.8 6.1 4.4 9.6 0.2 5.3 1998/99 3.3 9.2 5.1 5.0 6.4 0.2 5.0 1999/00 2.7 12.3 5.3 5.7 13.9 2.7 5.5 2000/01 2.9 11.7 5.4 4.0 13.0 2.7 4.8 2001/02 3.0 11.2 5.5 3.8 12.2 2.9 4.7 2002/03 3.0 11.5 5.2 3.5 14.7 2.7 4.5 2003/04 2.8 13.5 5.3 3.1 14.1 1.6 4.2 2004/05 2.4 13.4 5.0 2.6 8.5 1.0 3.8 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 14. Fishery: The provincial data for the quantity and prices of Marine and Inland Fishery is available in provincial as well as national publications on agricultural statistics. The gross value of the fishery (in constant factor cost) was calculated directly by subtracting the input cost from the aggregate gross value of output. The derived value added for the inland fishery is then adjusted to account for the under reporting of fishery output (taken to be 100% of the value reported). Input cost of 16% for inland and 36% for Marine fish has been used for estimating value added. In addition to that, 6.5% auction charges have been deducted from the gross value of Marine fish to arrive to the constant value added of Fishery sector. 5 15. Forestry: The major components of Balochistan forestry are firewood and Mazri productions. The value added of this sector is estimated by assuming that the provincial share of added in the national sectoral value added would be in the same proportion as the provin ce’s share of value of output in aggregate national value. This implicitly assumes that the technology used in the sector is the same at the provincial and national level. In other words, the provincial value-added in the forestry sector was derived from the national (sectoral) value-added by using the share of firewood and Mazri production in Balochistan to the national production as allocator. 16. Manufacturing: The manufacturing sector is sub-divided into large-scale and small-scale manufacturing. Large-scale manufacturing includes units that employ 20 or more workers on any working day during the year and use power, while the small-scale manufacturing includes those units that employ 10-19 workers in any day of the year. 17. Value-added in Balochistan’s large scale manufacturing sub-sector is estimated using the same methodology as used by FBS for estimating the sectoral value added at the national level. The FBS uses the Census of Manufacturing Industries (CMI) to derive sectoral value added in CMI years. Similarly, estimates for value added for Balochistan large-scale manufacturing sector were estimated in the benchmark years (i.e. 1990/91, 1995/96, and 2000/01) on the basis of Balochistan’s share of value-added from the CMI for the census years. For the years where data were not available, the FBS estimates national value added for the sector by interpolating the value-added using the (Quantum Index of Manufacturing (QIM). A similar exercise was undertaken to derive a complete time series for value-added in large scale manufacturing sector in Balochistan. 18. It may, however, be mentioned that provincial QIM suffers from significant deficiencies. Most notable is that QIM is calculated without full reporting of manufacturing out by the Hub industrial state. This can adversely affect the credibility and robustness of value added estimates. However, it is assumed that degree of under-reporting would remain as a fixed proportion of the value used in QIM and therefore would not lead to a large estimation error. The value added for post 2000/01 period was calculated using the fixed provincial share in national sectoral value- added (as derived from the 2000/01 CMI (at 2.1%). 19. Furthermore, the CMI data used have their own deficiencies such as time-lag, considerable non-response, under-reporting of output value and over-reporting of input cost (supposedly due to fear of taxation), and under-coverage of non-registered companies. However, despite these shortcomings the CMI data were used assuming that data problems in the any province were no different to those at the national level. The benchmark data points obtained from the CMI were then calculated from QIM growth rates. 6 Table A.5: Balochistan Manufacturing and Mining Sector Profile 1990/91-2004/05 VA in Mil Rs.; Share in Percentage Large Scale Manuf. Small Scale Manuf. Mining Value Share of Value Share of Value Share of added National added National added National 1990/91 1,781 1.5 744 1.2 11471 38.2 1991/92 2,121 1.5 877 1.2 13678 41.2 1992/93 2,375 1.6 983 1.2 14145 41.0 1993/94 2,943 1.6 1,101 1.2 16056 39.8 1994/95 3,527 1.7 1,252 1.2 16564 39.5 1995/96 4,080 1.7 1,449 1.2 17447 33.2 1996/97 4,842 1.8 1,702 1.2 17589 32.9 1997/98 4,865 1.6 1,888 1.2 21110 33.5 1998/99 5,906 1.8 2,018 1.2 24536 36.3 1999/00 7,130 2.1 2,225 1.2 28177 34.8 2000/01 8,785 2.1 2,362 1.2 36355 34.2 2001/02 8,482 2.0 2,620 1.2 36466 31.2 2002/03 9,410 2.0 2,923 1.2 38713 28.2 2003/04 11,875 1.9 3,361 1.2 49749 23.9 2004/05 14,634 1.9 3,855 1.2 34673 19.5 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates 20. The value-added in small-scale manufacturing has been estimated using the Census of Small Household Manufacturing Industries (SHMI). The urban and rural value-added breakdown for this sub-sector was only available in the 1996/97 census. The value-added in small-scale manufacturing was derived by using the share of the Balochistan in the national value-added in the small-scale industry (SHMI). This share was then applied to the national sectoral value- added.5 21. Mining: Like the agriculture, livestock, and manufacturing sub-sectors, the mining sub- sector is also estimated using the production approach. Mining consists of four main sub-sectors, i.e. crude oil, natural gas, coal and other minerals. The other mineral sector is estimated taking at least 20 minerals for all four provinces out of which 7-8 major minerals are produced in Balochistan in significant quantity. The gross value of each of the four main components (i.e. crude oil, natural gas, coal, and other minerals) was calculated using respective base-year prices. Since input costs of all these products were not available at the regional level, the share of Balochistan’s total value of mineral production to Pakistan’s value of mineral production was used as the allocator to estimate the provincial value-added for this sector. The various sources used for this sub-sector include the Energy Year Books of various years for coal, gas, and crude oil production and their respective prices, and other mineral production data from the Statistical Year Book of Pakistan. 22. Construction: Ideally, the construction sector value-added should be calculated through the expenditure approach, as is done by FBS at the national level. However, since the provincial expenditure data on construction were not available, Balochistan’s share of construction workers was used, instead, to derive estimates for 1990/91 and 2004/05. These are deemed appropriate as 5 The Federal Bureau of Statistics has calculated a growth rate of 5.31% for 1997/98, 6.86% for 1998.99, and 7.51 for 1999/00, based on the small household manufacturing index (SHMI) at national level, and a study by Quaidian Economic Consultants of Quaid-e-Azam University, Islamabad respectively. 7 a large part of construction in Pakistan is a labor-intensity activity. The missing years were then interpolated to get the full series. The data on percentage distribution of employment in construction industry in Pakistan and the Balochistan were obtained from FBS’s Labor Force Surveys of various years. 23. Electricity and Gas: In the Electricity and Gas sub-sector, value-added was estimated on the basis of electricity generation, electricity consumption, and natural gas consumption. The data were taken from various volumes of Energy Year Books (1996/97 to 2002/03) published annually by the Hydrocarbon Development Institute of Pakistan. Data for electricity generation, both for hydel and thermal electricity; were obtained from published sources. These figures were multiplied with a single year (i.e. constant) price to get constant rupee value of electricity generation. The value of electricity consumption was then taken as a proxy for value of electricity transmission and distribution. Similarly, the value of gas consumption was taken as a proxy for the value of gas distribution. Table A. 6: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Selected Sector At Constant Factor Cost (Rs Million) Construction Elec. & Gas Distrib. Trans. & Comm Fin. & Insr. 1990/91 1,723 2,092 19,633 1,108 1991/92 1,505 2,677 23,632 1,030 1992/93 1,808 3,442 27,441 978 1993/94 1,935 4,408 26,802 1,440 1994/95 1,987 6,531 26,273 1,971 1995/96 2,313 9,266 24,920 2,888 1996/97 2,730 9,185 24,302 4,138 1997/98 4,262 10,210 26,346 1,867 1998/99 4,133 10,220 27,759 1,285 1999/00 4,441 12,745 28,249 1,759 2000/01 4,881 13,844 29,211 2,127 2001/02 5,194 9,970 29,017 3,540 2002/03 5,105 7,966 30,869 2,901 2003/04 4,273 11,298 32,603 2,622 2004/05 4,782 10,866 34,430 2,818 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 24. The aggregate values of the three components (in constant prices) were then added for both Pakistan and Balochistan to get constant value generated in the sub-sector at the national and provincial level. Finally, the provincial value-added in electricity and gas was derived by applying to the national value-added estimate the derived ratio of the provincial value to national value. 8 Table A.7: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Selected Sector Share of National GDP, at constant factor cost (percent) Construction Elec. & Gas Distrib. Trans. & Comm Fin. & Insr. 1990/91 2.4 2.8 7.6 1.2 1991/92 2.0 3.3 8.3 1.1 1992/93 2.2 3.9 9.0 1.0 1993/94 2.4 4.9 8.5 1.3 1994/95 2.4 6.2 8.0 1.6 1995/96 2.7 8.0 7.5 2.1 1996/97 3.2 8.2 7.1 2.7 1997/98 4.9 8.3 7.2 1.6 1998/99 5.0 7.1 7.2 0.9 1999/00 5.1 9.1 7.0 1.3 2000/01 5.6 11.5 6.9 1.9 2001/02 5.8 8.9 6.8 2.7 2002/03 5.5 8.1 6.9 2.2 2003/04 5.2 7.3 7.1 1.8 2004/05 4.9 6.8 7.2 1.5 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 25. Transport, Storage, and Communication: The transport and storage sub-sector consists of six sub-sectors: road transport, air transport, communications, storage, and the railways. The share of value-added of this sector in the total at the provincial level was estimated from the monthly average incomes of employed households as is published in various years of HIES. Also the provincial shares in earned incomes and the sample household size of various years were used to determine the weighted provincial shares of incomes. These weighted shares were then, applied as allocators to the national value added to derive value addition of Balochistan and other provinces. 26. Wholesale and Retail Trade: Economic activities in this sub-sector include wholesale and retail trade, including import and export of goods, purchase and sale agents and brokers/auctioneering. This sector is also estimated on the pattern of transport, storage and communications i.e. the income approach. 9 Table A.8: Share of Balochistan in the Wholesale and Trade Sector At Constant Factor Cost of 1999/00 Aggregate Value Added of Agriculture and Manufacturing (Mil Rs.) Pakistan Balochistan Share (%) Allocator 1990/91 984,383 38,809 3.9 1991/92 1,062,198 38,694 3.6 1992/93 1,054,206 40,747 3.9 1993/94 1,106,795 43,214 3.9 1994/95 1,162,807 44,887 3.9 1995/96 1,277,085 50,076 3.9 1996/97 1,285,366 49,490 3.9 1997/98 1,343,731 49,843 3.7 1998/99 1,382,490 51,924 3.8 1999/00 1,446,410 60,515 4.2 2000/01 1,474,856 55,775 3.8 2001/02 1,501,274 55,594 3.7 2002/03 1,579,986 58,101 3.7 2003/04 1,692,266 61,782 3.7 2004/05 1,847,925 65,978 3.6 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. Table A.9: Balochistan Gross Value Added At Constant Factor Cost (Rs Million) Ownership & Dwellings Public Admin. & Defence Other Services 1990/91 3,486 10,790 6,129 1991/92 3,670 11,547 5,926 1992/93 3,864 12,448 5,599 1993/94 4,068 12,041 8,309 1994/95 4,283 12,034 10,925 1995/96 4,509 12,412 13,649 1996/97 4,747 12,187 17,338 1997/98 4,998 12,912 18,100 1998/99 5,261 13,487 19,035 1999/00 5,539 15,428 19,036 2000/01 5,748 16,331 19,038 2001/02 5,949 17,283 20,156 2002/03 6,143 17,655 20,741 2003/04 6,359 20,219 18,224 2004/05 6,582 22,665 15,547 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 10 Table A.10: Balochistan Gross Value Added Share of National GDP, at Constant Factor Cost (percent) Ownership & Public Admin. & Other Services Dwellings Defence 1990/91 5.0 6.5 3.4 1991/92 5.0 6.8 3.1 1992/93 5.0 7.1 2.7 1993/94 5.0 6.8 3.8 1994/95 5.0 6.6 4.7 1995/96 5.0 6.6 5.5 1996/97 5.0 6.3 6.5 1997/98 5.0 6.6 6.4 1998/99 5.0 6.7 6.3 1999/00 5.0 7.0 5.9 2000/01 5.0 7.3 5.6 2001/02 5.0 7.2 5.5 2002/03 5.0 6.8 5.3 2003/04 5.0 7.6 4.4 2004/05 5.0 8.4 3.6 Source: World Bank Staff Estimates. 27. Finance and Insurance: Since wages and salaries account for a dominant portion of value added in this sector, the income approach is probably the best one to apply to estimate total value-added in this sub-sector. 28. Ownership and Dwellings: At national level, the value-added in this sub-sector is measured by the rent accruing from ownership of dwellings (rented or self occupied). In the absence of provincial expenditures on rent data, the income approach using various HIES is applied to obtain value added for Balochistan. 29. Public Administration and Defense: This value-added in the Public Administration and Defense sector comprise mainly of wages and salaries of public sector employees. The FBS computes value added separately for the federal, each provincial and aggregated local government. The sectoral value added in Balochistan was estimated by attributing the federal and local governments value-added to Balochistan on the basis of population share and adding it to the FBS data. However, the FBS data were available only for post-1994/95 years. Provincial sectoral value-added for 1990/91 to 1994/95 were, therefore, derived from the national account data by using the share of current expenditure in Balochistan to the aggregate provincial current expenditure as an allocator. 11 Table A. 11: Intermediate calculations for estimating Public Administration and Defense Pak. Balochist District Gross an share Public Public & Local Wages & Depreciati Value- (Allocato Admin Admin Years Federal Punjab Sindh NWFP Balochistan Govts. Salaries on Added r) (constant) (current) Deflator ----------------------------------------Mil Rs.----------------------------------- (%) ---Mil Rs.--- (%) 1999/00 106956 50337 28822 15990 9415 5484 217004 3287 220291 7.0 15428 15428 1.0 2000/01 113234 52624 33031 16085 10654 6062 231690 3349 235039 6.9 16331 17048 1.0 2001/02 124163 59536 40143 19992 12689 7775 264298 3519 267817 6.5 17283 18681 1.1 2002/03 140738 62864 47739 17604 12545 8297 289787 4364 294151 6.0 17655 19474 1.1 2003/04 145366 69339 43112 19806 14545 9642 301809 6239 308048 6.6 20219 23607 1.2 2004/05 151542 76847 46818 23296 19031 10817 328351 7218 335569 6.8 22665 28949 1.3 30. Services: This sector comprises incomes of the private sector persons who are engaged in private education, medical & health professions, and other household and community services. Provincial data for these categories were not available; the value-added of Balochistan in this sector was therefore estimated on the basis of the income share of the Balochistan in the overall national income of service sector. The income data points were obtained from the various Household Income and Expenditure Surveys which were then, interpolated to get a continuous series of allocators. The allocators are finally applied to the national data series to estimate provincial value added of this sector. 12 Table A.12: Balochistan Gross Product At constant factor cost of 1999/00 Rs Million Transport Per Large Small , Storage Electricity Capita Scale Scale Manufact and Gas & WholesaleFinance Ownership Public Popula Real uring ManufactManufactr Construct Mining and DistributiCommuni & Retail and of tion Admin. & Other Balochista Income uring Agriculture ing Total Querryingion on cations Trade Dwellings Defence Servicesn GDP (000) Insurance (Rs) 1990/91 32,434 3,792 1,395 5,187 25,819 1,723 2,092 19,633 19,941 1,108 3,486 10,790 6,129 128,342 5555 23103 1991/92 31,299 4,197 1,469 5,667 28,523 1,505 2,677 23,632 21,136 1,030 3,670 11,547 5,926 136,612 5699 23971 1992/93 33,521 4,484 1,548 6,031 29,209 1,808 3,442 27,441 21,437 978 3,864 12,448 5,599 145,779 5845 24941 1993/94 35,985 4,795 1,630 6,425 29,648 1,935 4,408 26,802 21,482 1,440 4,068 12,041 8,309 152,541 5993 25452 1994/95 37,168 4,991 1,717 6,708 28,155 1,987 6,531 26,273 21,879 1,971 4,283 12,034 10,925 157,915 6144 25703 1995/96 41,734 5,281 1,809 7,090 25,372 2,313 9,266 24,920 22,566 2,888 4,509 12,412 13,649 166,717 6297 26476 1996/97 41,338 5,430 1,905 7,334 25,579 2,730 9,185 24,302 22,075 4,138 4,747 12,187 17,338 170,953 6452 26495 1997/98 42,116 5,274 2,006 7,280 24,808 4,262 10,210 26,346 21,779 1,867 4,998 12,912 18,100 174,678 6610 26427 1998/99 43,302 6,137 2,113 8,250 27,695 4,133 10,220 27,759 22,267 1,285 5,261 13,487 19,035 182,694 6770 26987 1999/00 51,209 7,130 2,225 9,355 28,177 4,441 12,745 28,249 23,303 1,759 5,539 15,428 19,036 199,242 6932 28743 2000/01 45,334 8,032 2,343 10,376 29,232 4,881 13,844 29,211 24,962 2,127 5,748 16,331 19,038 201,084 7096 28337 2001/02 45,367 7,777 2,491 10,268 28,196 5,194 9,970 29,017 26,276 3,540 5,949 17,283 20,156 201,214 7263 27706 2002/03 47,273 8,151 2,648 10,799 27,237 5,105 7,966 30,869 27,371 2,901 6,143 17,655 20,741 204,059 7431 27459 2003/04 49,413 9,407 2,812 12,219 26,625 4,273 11,298 32,603 29,128 2,622 6,359 20,219 18,224 212,982 7602 28016 2004/05 51,986 10,612 2,987 13,599 23,845 4,782 10,866 34,430 31,768 2,818 6,582 22,665 15,547 218,889 7775 28153 13 Table A.13: Balochistan Gross Domestic Product At current prices Rs Million Transport Per Large Small Electricity, Storage Capita Scale Scale Manufact and Gas & Wholesale Finance OwnershipPublic Popula Nominal ManufactManufactruring Mining andConstruct Distributi Communi& Retail and of Admin. & Other Balochista tion Income Agricultureuring ing Total Querrying ion on cations Trade InsuranceDwellings Defence Services n GDP (000) (Rs) 1990/91 14,576 1,781 744 2,525 11,471 820 1,040 7,605 9,000 739 1,620 4,382 2,797 56,575 5555 10184 1991/92 15,729 2,121 877 2,998 13,678 776 1,458 10,767 10,409 749 1,889 5,106 2,967 66,524 5699 11673 1992/93 18,466 2,375 983 3,358 14,145 1,002 1,862 14,804 11,252 768 2,193 5,944 3,054 76,848 5845 13148 1993/94 22,623 2,943 1,101 4,044 16,056 1,170 2,449 16,329 12,876 1,314 2,535 6,314 5,046 90,755 5993 15143 1994/95 26,781 3,527 1,252 4,779 16,564 1,313 4,183 17,592 15,040 2,020 2,950 7,596 7,470 106,286 6144 17299 1995/96 29,812 4,080 1,449 5,529 17,447 1,717 7,289 18,022 17,068 3,078 3,395 9,247 10,340 122,944 6297 19524 1996/97 35,379 4,842 1,702 6,544 17,589 2,305 7,693 19,844 18,429 4,779 3,937 9,558 14,685 140,743 6452 21813 1997/98 39,757 4,865 1,888 6,753 21,110 3,903 9,640 23,263 19,351 2,730 4,495 10,660 16,527 158,189 6610 23932 1998/99 43,677 5,906 2,018 7,924 24,536 3,939 10,697 25,602 20,995 1,804 5,048 12,224 18,378 174,825 6770 25825 1999/00 51,207 7,130 2,225 9,355 28,177 4,441 12,745 28,249 23,303 1,759 5,539 15,428 19,036 199,239 6932 28743 2000/01 47,435 8,785 2,362 11,147 36,355 5,260 15,295 35,493 26,587 2,213 6,238 17,048 19,880 222,952 7096 31419 2001/02 48,568 8,482 2,620 11,102 36,466 5,540 11,956 36,862 28,369 3,826 6,343 18,681 21,789 229,502 7263 31601 2002/03 53,165 9,410 2,923 12,333 38,713 5,550 9,707 42,257 30,393 3,233 6,779 19,474 22,886 244,490 7431 32900 2003/04 59,661 11,875 3,361 15,236 49,749 5,958 13,894 47,753 34,054 3,055 7,337 23,607 21,027 281,332 7602 37007 2004/05 69,594 14,634 3,855 18,490 34,673 7,468 13,935 57,223 40,981 3,589 8,299 28,949 19,602 302,802 7775 38945 Table A.14: Balochistan Gross Domestic Product at constant factor cost Annual Growth Rate Large Small Transport Pakistan - Agricultu Scale Scale Manufact Storage $ Wholesale Finance Ownership Public Total re Value Manufact Manufactr uring Mining andConstructElectricity Communi & Retail and of Admin. & Other Balochis Value Added uring ing Total Querrying ion and Gas cations Trade Insurance Dwellings Defence Services tan Added 1991/92 -3.5 10.7 5.3 9.3 10.5 -12.7 28.0 20.4 6.0 -7.0 5.3 7.0 -3.3 6.4 7.2 1992/93 7.1 6.8 5.3 6.4 2.4 20.2 28.6 16.1 1.4 -5.1 5.3 7.8 -5.5 6.7 2.5 1993/94 7.4 6.9 5.3 6.5 1.5 7.0 28.1 -2.3 0.2 47.2 5.3 -3.3 48.4 4.6 4.5 1994/95 3.3 4.1 5.3 4.4 -5.0 2.7 48.2 -2.0 1.8 37.0 5.3 -0.1 31.5 3.5 4.9 1995/96 12.3 5.8 5.3 5.7 -9.9 16.4 41.9 -5.2 3.1 46.5 5.3 3.1 24.9 5.6 7.2 1996/97 -0.9 2.8 5.3 3.5 0.8 18.0 -0.9 -2.5 -2.2 43.3 5.3 -1.8 27.0 2.5 2.1 1997/98 1.9 -2.9 5.3 -0.7 -3.0 56.1 11.2 8.4 -1.3 -54.9 5.3 5.9 4.4 2.2 2.3 1998/99 2.8 16.4 5.3 13.3 11.6 -3.0 0.1 5.4 2.2 -31.2 5.3 4.4 5.2 4.6 4.4 1999/00 18.3 16.2 5.3 13.4 1.7 7.5 24.7 1.8 4.7 36.9 5.3 14.4 0.0 9.1 3.9 2000/01 -11.5 12.7 5.3 10.9 3.7 9.9 8.6 3.4 7.1 20.9 3.8 5.9 0.0 0.9 2.0 2001/02 0.1 -3.2 6.3 -1.0 -3.5 6.4 -28.0 -0.7 5.3 66.4 3.5 5.8 5.9 0.1 3.1 2002/03 4.2 4.8 6.3 5.2 -3.4 -1.7 -20.1 6.4 4.2 -18.1 3.3 2.2 2.9 1.4 4.7 2003/04 4.5 15.4 6.2 13.2 -2.2 -16.3 41.8 5.6 6.4 -9.6 3.5 14.5 -12.1 4.4 7.5 2004/05 5.2 12.8 6.2 11.3 -10.4 11.9 -3.8 5.6 9.1 7.5 3.5 12.1 -14.7 2.8 8.6 Average (1991-2005) 3.4 7.6 5.6 7.1 -0.6 7.6 12.5 4.1 3.4 6.9 4.6 5.4 6.9 3.9 4.6 Average (2000-2005) 0.3 8.3 6.1 7.8 -3.3 1.5 -3.1 4.0 6.4 9.9 3.5 8.0 -4.0 1.9 5.1 14 Table A.15: Balochistan Gross Domestic Product at current prices Annual Growth Rate Transport Large Small , Storage Pakistan - Scale Scale Manufact & Wholesale Finance Ownership Public Total Agricultu Manufact Manufactr uring Mining and Construct Electricity Communi & Retail and of Admin. & Other Balochis Value re uring ing Total Querrying ion and Gas cations Trade Insurance Dwellings Defence Services tan Added 1991/92 7.9 19.1 17.9 18.7 19.2 -5.4 40.2 41.6 15.7 1.3 16.6 16.5 6.1 17.6 21.1 1992/93 17.4 12.0 12.1 12.0 3.4 29.1 27.7 37.5 8.1 2.5 16.1 16.4 3.0 15.5 5.5 1993/94 22.5 23.9 12.1 20.4 13.5 16.8 31.5 10.3 14.4 71.1 15.6 6.2 65.2 18.1 20.2 1994/95 18.4 19.8 13.7 18.2 3.2 12.2 70.8 7.7 16.8 53.7 16.4 20.3 48.1 17.1 22.1 1995/96 11.3 15.7 15.7 15.7 5.3 30.8 74.2 2.4 13.5 52.4 15.1 21.7 38.4 15.7 12.5 1996/97 18.7 18.7 17.5 18.4 0.8 34.2 5.5 10.1 8.0 55.3 16.0 3.4 42.0 14.5 20.9 1997/98 12.4 0.5 10.9 3.2 20.0 69.3 25.3 17.2 5.0 -42.9 14.2 11.5 12.5 12.4 14.0 1998/99 9.9 21.4 6.9 17.3 16.2 0.9 11.0 10.1 8.5 -33.9 12.3 14.7 11.2 10.5 9.2 1999/00 17.2 20.7 10.3 18.1 14.8 12.7 19.1 10.3 11.0 -2.5 9.7 26.2 3.6 14.0 5.4 2000/01 -7.4 23.2 6.2 19.2 29.0 18.4 20.0 25.6 14.1 25.8 12.6 10.5 4.4 11.9 2.3 2001/02 2.4 -3.5 10.9 -0.4 0.3 5.3 -21.8 3.9 6.7 72.9 1.7 9.6 9.6 2.9 2.4 2002/03 9.5 10.9 11.6 11.1 6.2 0.2 -18.8 14.6 7.1 -15.5 6.9 4.2 5.0 6.5 9.4 2003/04 12.2 26.2 15.0 23.5 28.5 7.4 43.1 13.0 12.0 -5.5 8.2 21.2 -8.1 15.1 10.0 2004/05 16.6 23.2 14.7 21.4 -30.3 25.3 0.3 19.8 20.3 17.4 13.1 22.6 -6.8 7.6 18.2 Average (1991-2005) 11.8 16.2 12.5 15.3 8.2 17.1 20.4 15.5 11.4 11.9 12.4 14.4 14.9 12.7 13.1 15 Table A.16: Balochistan Gross Domestic Product Sectoral shares of Balochistan GDP at current prices Percentage Transport Large Small , Storage Balochist Scale Scale Manufact & Wholesale Finance Ownership Public an - Total Agricultu Manufact Manufactr uring Mining and Construct Electricity Communi & Retail and of Admin. & Other Value re uring ing Total Querrying ion and Gas cations Trade Insurance Dwellings Defence Services Added 1990/91 25.8 3.1 1.3 4.5 20.3 1.5 1.8 13.4 15.9 1.3 2.9 7.7 4.9 100 1991/92 23.6 3.2 1.3 4.5 20.6 1.2 2.2 16.2 15.6 1.1 2.8 7.7 4.5 100 1992/93 24.0 3.1 1.3 4.4 18.4 1.3 2.4 19.3 14.6 1.0 2.9 7.7 4.0 100 1993/94 24.9 3.2 1.2 4.5 17.7 1.3 2.7 18.0 14.2 1.4 2.8 7.0 5.6 100 1994/95 25.2 3.3 1.2 4.5 15.6 1.2 3.9 16.6 14.2 1.9 2.8 7.1 7.0 100 1995/96 24.2 3.3 1.2 4.5 14.2 1.4 5.9 14.7 13.9 2.5 2.8 7.5 8.4 100 1996/97 25.1 3.4 1.2 4.6 12.5 1.6 5.5 14.1 13.1 3.4 2.8 6.8 10.4 100 1997/98 25.1 3.1 1.2 4.3 13.3 2.5 6.1 14.7 12.2 1.7 2.8 6.7 10.4 100 1998/99 25.0 3.4 1.2 4.5 14.0 2.3 6.1 14.6 12.0 1.0 2.9 7.0 10.5 100 1999/00 25.7 3.6 1.1 4.7 14.1 2.2 6.4 14.2 11.7 0.9 2.8 7.7 9.6 100 2000/01 21.3 3.9 1.1 5.0 16.3 2.4 6.9 15.9 11.9 1.0 2.8 7.6 8.9 100 2001/02 21.2 3.7 1.1 4.8 15.9 2.4 5.2 16.1 12.4 1.7 2.8 8.1 9.5 100 2002/03 21.7 3.8 1.2 5.0 15.8 2.3 4.0 17.3 12.4 1.3 2.8 8.0 9.4 100 2003/04 21.2 4.2 1.2 5.4 17.7 2.1 4.9 17.0 12.1 1.1 2.6 8.4 7.5 100 2004/05 23.0 4.8 1.3 6.1 11.5 2.5 4.6 18.9 13.5 1.2 2.7 9.6 6.5 100 16 Table A.17: Balochistan Gross Domestic Product Percentage of National GDP Percentage Large Small Transport Balochist Scale Scale Manufact , Storage Wholesale Finance Ownership Public an - Total Agricultu Manufact Manufact uring Mining and Construct Electricity & & Retail and of Admin. & Other Value re uring ing Total Quarryin ion and Gas Communi Trade Insurance Dwellings Defence Services Added 1990/91 5.3 1.5 1.2 1.4 38.2 2.4 2.8 7.6 4.2 1.2 5.0 6.5 3.4 5.1 1991/92 4.7 1.5 1.2 1.4 41.2 2.0 3.3 8.3 4.2 1.1 5.0 6.8 3.1 5.0 1992/93 5.2 1.6 1.2 1.4 41.0 2.2 3.9 9.0 4.1 1.0 5.0 7.1 2.7 5.2 1993/94 5.3 1.6 1.2 1.5 39.8 2.4 4.9 8.5 4.0 1.3 5.0 6.8 3.8 5.2 1994/95 5.2 1.7 1.2 1.5 39.5 2.4 6.2 8.0 3.9 1.6 5.0 6.6 4.7 5.2 1995/96 5.1 1.7 1.2 1.5 33.2 2.7 8.0 7.5 3.8 2.1 5.0 6.6 5.5 5.2 1996/97 5.0 1.8 1.2 1.6 32.9 3.2 8.2 7.1 3.7 2.7 5.0 6.3 6.5 5.1 1997/98 5.0 1.6 1.2 1.5 33.5 4.9 8.3 7.2 3.7 1.6 5.0 6.6 6.4 5.2 1998/99 5.0 1.8 1.2 1.6 36.3 5.0 7.1 7.2 3.6 0.9 5.0 6.7 6.3 5.2 1999/00 5.5 2.1 1.2 1.8 34.8 5.1 9.1 7.0 3.7 1.3 5.0 7.0 5.9 5.6 2000/01 5.0 2.1 1.2 1.8 34.2 5.6 11.5 6.9 3.8 1.9 5.0 7.3 5.6 5.7 2001/02 5.0 2.0 1.2 1.7 31.2 5.8 8.9 6.8 3.9 2.7 5.0 7.2 5.5 5.5 2002/03 5.0 2.0 1.2 1.7 28.2 5.5 8.1 6.9 3.9 2.2 5.0 6.8 5.3 5.4 2003/04 5.1 1.9 1.2 1.7 23.9 5.2 7.3 7.1 3.8 1.8 5.0 7.6 4.4 5.4 2004/05 5.1 1.9 1.2 1.7 19.5 4.9 6.8 7.2 3.7 1.5 5.0 8.4 3.6 4.9 17 B. GDP ESTIMATES 1999/2000–2010/11 31. For the purposes of the present report, a set of provincial GDP figures for the decade 1999/2000–2010/11 was estimated. The methodology of this estimation differs somewhat (apart from the rebasing of the series on the year 1999/2000) from that described in the earlier section. The present section sketches out the procedures used for the new estimates. 32. In the past, the World Bank has endeavored to estimates provincial GDPs by using some broad “allocators� to derive the shares of each province in sectoral value added and the national income. In doing this provincial GDP was estimated using a combination of the three traditional approaches—production, expenditure, or income. More specifically, wherever detailed provincial data were available, for example, agriculture, mining and quarrying, manufacturing, and wholesale and retail trade, sectoral value-added were estimated using the production approach. The expenditure approach was used to compute value-added of the construction, ownership of dwellings, electricity and gas distribution, and public administration and defense sub-sectors, whereas a variant of the income approach was applied to estimate value-added in the transport, storage, and communication, banking and insurance, and services sub-sectors. In almost all of these instances, the direct and indirect methods were combined to compute sectoral value-added by apportioning the national income to the province using appropriate allocators. While these allocators were applied only where disaggregated data at the provincial level were not available, clearly the present exercise represents a “second-best� approach to estimate sectoral value-added at the provincial level. 33. The analysis of estimation has been carried out to facilitate the economic assessment for the two provinces’ reports: Public Expenditure Review for Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and Development Issues and Prospects for Balochistan. Estimation Methodology 34. In order to estimate provincial GDPs for the present report, the following data sources have been used. - Agricultural Statistics of Pakistan, of various years - Pakistan Statistical Yearbook 2011 - Economic Survey of Pakistan 2010/11 - Labor Force Survey 2011 - Household Integrated Economic Surveys (HIESs) for 2005/06, 2007/08 and 2010/11 - Pakistan Energy Year Book, 2011 - National Institute of Population Studies; Estimates/forecast of annual provincial population - Livestock Census of 1996 and 2006 35. The Agricultural Statistics of Pakistan was used as the main source for actual production of the major and minor crops. The crops have been selected in compliance with the national rebasing exercise of 1999/00 done by the then Pakistan Bureau of 18 Statistics (Pakistan Bureau of Statistics as of now). The Pakistan Statistical Year Book of 2011 along with its previous years’ publications, and the Household Integrated Economic Surveys (HIESs) for 2005/06, 2007/08 and 2010/11 were used as the prime data bases.6 While the Statistical Year Books provides most of the actual data in the analysis, the HIES provides sectoral sources of household income. The Labor Force Surveys was useful to extract data on labor force and sectoral employment etc. The Energy Year Book provides information on the Energy sector production and the prices/cost of generation. Information on National GDP, its deflators, Consumer Prices, etc. is pulled together from the Economic Survey of Pakistan. The National Institute of Populations Studies provided the Bank few years back, the estimates of provincial population and it forecast for future years, based on the 1998 population census. On requesting the newer set of data on Population estimates, it was stated that since there is no new census after 1998, the same estimates are being used for various analyses. Figure B.1: Sectoral Shares of Balochistan GDP 1999/2000 and 2010/11 1999/2000 2% Agriculture 16% Mining 1% 34% Manufacturing 9% Electricity, Construction Whole Sale & Trade 16% Transport 9% 4% 8% Finance, Community Srv. Ownership of Dwellings 1% 1% 2010/11 0% Agriculture 10% 32% Mining 11% Manufacturing Electricity, Construction 20% Whole Sale & Trade Transport 17% Finance, Community Srv. 5% Ownership of Dwellings 1% 3% 36. The sector wise methodology is discussed below. 37. Agriculture: Value-added in agriculture in all provinces has been estimated by applying provincial allocators to the national value-added estimate for this sub-sector. Overall, the computation of value-added in crop agriculture is based on 12 major crops and 8 groups of minor crops. The groups are classified as pulses, vegetable, fruits, 6 For the years when no HIES was conducted, i.e. 2006/07, 2008/09 and 2009/10, the estimates were obtained by interpolation. 19 condiments, oilseed, flower and foliage, fodder, and other miscellaneous crops. The crop output data for the provinces and for Pakistan was obtained from published sources.7 Due to the non-availability of input costs of agriculture, production allocators were used to estimate value-added for the crop sub-sector. Every province share of total crop production in national output was assumed to remain the same as its share of total national value-added. These output shares (allocators) were used to estimate value- added of wheat, rice, cottonseed, sugarcane, maize, gram, barley, jawar, bajra, rapeseed & mustard, sesame seed and tobacco for major crops for the years 1999/00 to 2010/11. The simple addition of the value-added of each crop represents the total value-added of major crops. Similarly, value-added of minor crops was estimated using lentils (mash, moong, masoor), potatoes and onions, oilseeds, fruits etc. as the main minor crops. Table B.1: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Agriculture Sector At Constant Factor Cost Million Rupee Major Crops Minor Crops Livestock Forestry Fishery Total Agri 1999/00 9,214 15,566 77,732 628 1,276 104,416 2000/01 9,689 15,334 85,408 771 1,270 112,472 2001/02 9,735 15,242 95,068 327 1,101 121,473 2002/03 11,248 14,971 116,318 726 1,179 144,442 2003/04 11,496 17,112 124,486 1,568 1,187 155,849 2004/05 11,468 17,973 108,074 307 1,190 139,012 2005/06 13,276 18,599 104,089 34 1,496 137,493 2006/07 14,348 17,295 109,428 257 1,628 142,957 2007/08 12,109 20,293 121,315 271 1,619 155,606 2008/09 14,721 21,282 122,627 231 1,641 160,502 2009/10 13,746 24,108 127,728 236 1,646 167,464 2009/11 13,281 26,215 128,181 235 1,657 169,569 Table B.2: Balochistan Share of National Agriculture Value Added At Constant Factor Cost Percentage share Major Crops Minor Crops Livestock Forestry Fishery Total Agri 1999/00 2.7 12.4 18.6 2.7 8.4 11.3 2000/01 3.1 12.6 19.7 3.0 8.6 12.4 2001/02 3.2 13.0 21.2 1.3 8.5 13.4 2002/03 3.5 12.5 25.3 2.7 8.8 15.3 2003/04 3.5 13.8 26.3 6.0 8.7 16.2 2004/05 3.0 14.3 22.3 1.7 8.7 13.5 2005/06 3.6 14.7 18.5 0.2 9.0 12.6 2006/07 3.6 13.8 19.0 1.5 8.5 12.6 2007/08 3.2 14.6 20.2 1.9 7.8 13.5 2008/09 3.7 15.5 19.8 1.6 7.7 13.4 2009/10 3.5 19.1 19.7 1.6 7.6 13.9 2009/11 3.5 19.8 19.1 1.6 7.5 13.9 38. Livestock: The livestock sub-sector includes the value-added of actual livestock population, including the newborn. The census livestock population was available for 1996 and 2006 while the other years were estimated by the provincial share of livestock value of the national value of livestock in the census year under consideration. Actual data on slaughtering, poultry and milk, was also taken into account while calculating 7 The data are obtained from various issues of the Pakistan Statistical Yearbook, Agriculture Statistics of Pakistan, Provincial Development Statistics, Economic Survey, Agricultural Crops and Livestock Products – Long-Term Trends, and Support Price Policy Issues of Major Crops. 20 Livestock value of each province. The weight of each product in total value-added was derived from the national accounts data.8 39. Fishery: The provincial value added in the fishery sector is derived from the national value-added in the sector by using the provincial share in total fish production as weight. 40. Forestry: The major component of forestry is timber and firewood production. The value added of this sector was assumed to be proportionate to the timber and firewood productions shares of Pakistan production of timber and firewood. The constant share of 1999/00 is used to draw the final estimates. In other words, the provincial value-added in the forestry sector was derived from the national (sectoral) value-added by using the production share of Timber and firewood to the national shares multiply with the 1999/00 prices of these productions. 41. Manufacturing: The manufacturing sub-sector is sub-divided into large-scale and small-scale manufacturing. Large-scale manufacturing includes units that employ 20 or more workers on any working day during the year and use power, while the small- scale manufacturing includes those units that employ 10-19 workers in any day of the year. 42. Value-added in the provincial large scale manufacturing sub-sector is estimated on the pattern of national GDP calculations by PBS based on the Census of Manufacturing Industries data and the Quantum Index of Manufacturing (QIM) estimates. The provincial Bureau of Statistics conducts monthly surveys of industrial production and employment in their respective provinces and estimate QIM based on these data. The survey reports cover about 90% of the total industrial units. The methodology used to estimates the monthly index was to measure the percentage increase in the current month’s production of any item from the average monthly production of 1999/00. The weighted percentage increase was calculated with the assigned weights based on 1999/00 CMI data for each item. 43. The benchmark estimates (1999/00) of large scale manufacturing value-added are derived on the basis of the provincial shares of value-added from the CMI for the census years. The CMI data has its deficiencies of time lag, considerable non-response, under-reporting of output value and over-reporting of input cost (supposedly due to fear of taxation), and under-coverage of non-registered companies. However, despite these shortcomings the CMI data were used assuming that data problems in the all provinces were no different to those at the national level. The benchmark data points obtained from the CMI were then interpolated for the years where the CMI was not conducted using the annual percentage increase in the provincial QIMs.9 8 PBS authorities kindly provided the data. 9 The Provincial Bureau of Statistics bases the QIM on monthly surveys of industrial production and employment uniformly in all provinces. 21 Table B.3: Balochistan Manufacturing and Mining Sector Profile 1999/00-2010/11 Large Scale Manuf. Small Scale Manuf. Slaughtering Mining Value Share of Value Share of Value Share of Value Share of added(Mil National (%) added(Mil National (%) added(Mil National (%) added(Mil National Rs) Rs) Rs) Rs) (%) 1999/00 6,556 1.9 4,738 3.6 11,476 22.1 27750 34.2 2000/01 8,032 2.1 5,431 3.8 11,815 22.1 28807 33.7 2001/02 10,373 2.7 6,220 4.1 14,184 25.8 27735 30.7 2002/03 13,848 3.3 6,793 4.1 14,601 25.8 26765 27.8 2003/04 20,326 4.1 7,410 4.2 14,953 25.8 26149 23.5 2004/05 30,199 5.1 7,967 4.2 15,135 25.5 25242 20.6 2005/06 40,383 6.3 9,642 4.7 13,489 20.2 24830 19.4 2006/07 43,912 6.3 10,032 4.5 14,042 20.2 24210 18.3 2007/08 45,689 6.3 10,420 4.3 16,144 22.3 24455 17.7 2008/09 42,005 6.3 10,929 4.2 16,826 22.3 23515 17.1 2009/10 44,075 6.3 11,267 4.1 17,554 22.3 22172 15.8 2009/11 44,509 6.3 12,027 4.0 18,955 23.1 21680 15.4 44. The small scale value-added, which includes value added on Slaughtering, has been estimated based on the Census of Small Household Manufacturing Industries (SHMI). The growth for the next year was given in the survey as 5.31% at the national level. The subsequent study by the Quaidian Economic Consultants Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad in 1999/00 estimated the growth rates of 6.86% and 7.51 for the years 1998/99 and 1999/00 respectively. Due to unavailability of such surveys at provincial levels, the current analysis of SSM is based on estimating employed labor force shares of each province to the national employed labor force. The slaughtering is estimated using provincial shares of monthly expenditures on milk, all kind of meat, and eggs. The data on percentage distribution of consumption of these products has been obtained from HIES of various year.10 45. Construction: Ideally, the construction sub-sector value-added should be calculated through the expenditure approach, as is done by PBS at the national level. However, since the provincial expenditure data on construction was not available, the provincial share of construction workers was used instead to derive estimates for 1999/00 to 2010/11. The construction worker’s data was missing for some years which were then interpolated to get the full series. The data on percentage distribution of employment in construction industry in Pakistan and the provinces were obtained from PBS’s Labor Force Surveys of various years. 10 The Pakistan Bureau of Statistics has calculated a growth rate of 5.31% based on the small household manufacturing index (SHMI) at national level, until 1997/98. For 1998/99 and 1999/00 the growth rates recommended by Quaid-i-Azam University was 6.86% and 7.51% respectively. 22 Table B. 4: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Selected Sector At Constant Factor Cost (Rs Million) Construction Elec. & Gas Trans. & Fin. & Insr. Distrib. Comm 1999/00 4,431 12,832 28,249 1,759 2000/01 4,802 13,944 29,211 2,127 2001/02 5,194 10,041 29,017 3,540 2002/03 5,027 8,028 30,869 2,901 2003/04 4,328 11,788 32,603 2,622 2004/05 5,132 11,917 34,621 2,854 2005/06 3,850 9,265 20,645 6,125 2006/07 4,943 11,564 28,902 5,706 2007/08 4,798 8,965 37,566 4,863 2008/09 4,145 15,872 39,154 4,467 2009/10 5,108 18,939 40,476 3,938 2009/11 4,462 15,054 41,236 3,668 Table B.5: Balochistan Gross Value Added of Selected Sector Share of National GDP, at constant factor cost (percent) Construction Elec. & Gas Trans. & Fin. & Insr. Distrib. Comm 1999/00 5.07 9.2 7.0 1.3 2000/01 5.47 11.6 6.9 1.9 2001/02 5.82 9.0 6.8 2.7 2002/03 5.42 8.1 6.9 2.2 2003/04 5.23 7.6 7.1 1.8 2004/05 5.23 8.2 7.3 1.5 2005/06 3.56 8.6 4.2 2.3 2006/07 3.67 10.3 5.6 1.9 2007/08 3.78 10.4 7.0 1.4 2008/09 3.67 11.6 7.0 1.4 2009/10 3.52 11.8 7.1 1.4 2009/11 3.05 11.9 7.1 1.4 46. Electricity and Gas: In the Electricity and Gas sub-sector, value-added was estimated on the basis of electricity generation, electricity consumption, and natural gas consumption. The data were taken from various Energy Year Books (1999/00 to 2010/11) published annually by the Hydrocarbon Development Institute of Pakistan. Data were obtained for electricity generation for hydel and thermal electricity; these figures were multiplied with a single year (i.e. constant) price to get constant rupee value of electricity generation. The value of electricity consumption was then taken a proxy for value of electricity transmission and distribution. Similarly, the value of gas consumption was taken as a proxy for the value of gas distribution. These three constant (i.e. at a single year price) values of the three components were then added for both Pakistan and the provinces to get constant value generated in the sub-sector at the national and provincial level. Finally, the provincial value-added in electricity and gas was derived by applying to the national value-added estimate the derived ratio of the provincial value to national value. 23 47. To estimate the value added for all other sectors, the income approach has been used. The average household income from each sector and the number of surveyed household were used to get an estimate of total sample income derived from each sector in each province. The HIES uses a stratified random sampling methodology. However, in order to get more robust estimates, the survey over- samples the two smaller provinces (KP and Balochistan) and under-samples Punjab and Sindh. As such, the total household income derived from HIES need to be adjusted by “raising� factors to make sample estimates in line with national population shares. 48. 49. To make these estimates more meaningful, two additional factors have to be kept in mind. First, the HIES distinguishes between “earned� and “unearned� income. While the former includes income that a household receive as an employer, employee of through self employment; whereas the latter includes income from housing (i.e. rent) and as transfer payments. Rents, both actual and imputed, is income from “ownership of dwellings� and is a part of Pakistan’s national accounts classification. Transfers payments could be discarded for calculation of provincial GDP because if these payments originates from outside the province (i.e. from other provinces or abroad) they can be considered as “factor income from abroad�, which is part of GNP and not GDP. If these payments originate from within the province, it would imply “double counting� of income, as the source of these payments is already accounted in earned or rental income. 50. Second, as some of the earned income could be originating from outside the province (i.e. from other provinces), there is a need to make necessary adjustments. It is assumed that earned income originating outside the province is likely to be small on the net basis and therefore could be ignored for the purpose of calculating provincial GDP.11 51. The adjusted total household income (derived from each sector) for each province, and for the country, were used to derive provincial shares in each income generating sector. These shares are then applied to the national value-added in each sector to get the valued-added estimates for each province, which total up to give an estimate of provincial GDP. 11 It is assumed the, for example, that earned income originating outside Sindh but reported by Sindhi households would be more or less counterbalanced by earned income originating in Sindh but reported by household in other provinces. 24 Table 1: Gross Provincial Value Added at constant factor cost @ 1999/00 At 1999/00 Million Rupees Whole Communit Ownership Agricultur Mining Transport Finance, Growth S hare of Manufactu Electricity, Constructi S ale and y, S ocial, of Pakistan e, Fishing and and Real Estate TOTAL rate Total Pakistan's ring Gas, Water on related Personal Dwellings & Forestry Quarrying S torage etc. GDP Total GDP trade S rv. 1999/00 923,609 81,052 522,801 139,624 87,386 620,591 400,983 132,454 541,842 110,425 3,560,768 100.0 2000/01 903,499 85,528 571,357 120,464 87,846 648,532 422,195 112,455 564,589 114,593 3,631,057 2.0% 100.0 2001/02 904,433 90,431 596,841 112,026 89,241 667,662 427,296 131,761 606,870 118,604 3,745,165 3.1% 100.0 2002/03 941,942 96,418 638,044 98,932 92,789 709,031 445,552 130,081 648,215 122,466 3,923,470 4.8% 100.0 2003/04 964,853 111,473 727,439 155,078 82,818 770,366 461,276 141,768 677,446 126,764 4,219,281 7.5% 100.0 2004/05 1,027,403 122,621 840,243 146,214 98,190 866,143 477,171 185,501 705,978 131,214 4,600,679 9.0% 100.0 2005/06 1,092,098 128,288 912,953 107,391 108,195 905,382 496,073 265,056 776,176 135,820 4,927,432 7.1% 100.0 2006/07 1,137,037 132,254 988,301 111,944 134,536 949,072 519,486 304,514 835,259 140,587 5,252,990 6.6% 100.0 2007/08 1,148,851 138,047 1,036,101 85,893 127,076 991,893 539,297 338,386 889,609 145,521 5,440,674 3.6% 100.0 2008/09 1,195,002 137,348 998,846 136,591 112,884 978,254 558,703 312,818 951,520 150,629 5,532,595 1.7% 100.0 2009/10 1,201,944 140,378 1,054,276 160,706 144,985 1,023,513 574,101 277,555 1,008,301 155,916 5,741,675 3.8% 100.0 2010/11 1,216,523 140,971 1,085,440 126,780 146,169 1,061,887 581,388 260,172 1,100,779 158,707 5,878,816 2.4% 100.0 PUNJAB 1999/00 537,660 12,368 240,191 55,142 54,287 347,593 210,032 66,351 268,172 49,079 1,840,875 51.7 2000/01 522,478 12,788 259,948 52,067 54,321 359,777 220,905 56,893 279,515 50,932 1,869,624 1.6% 51.5 2001/02 519,228 13,530 274,638 48,063 54,956 369,231 223,193 67,142 300,683 52,714 1,923,379 2.9% 51.4 2002/03 533,312 13,691 297,359 42,681 56,317 388,790 231,440 65,795 324,120 54,431 2,007,935 4.4% 51.2 2003/04 538,312 13,933 341,805 66,664 49,679 416,031 238,261 71,105 340,879 56,341 2,133,010 6.2% 50.6 2004/05 603,765 14,403 399,296 64,829 58,900 478,405 246,889 91,754 356,467 58,319 2,373,028 11.3% 51.6 2005/06 637,797 16,151 436,053 48,877 60,311 551,256 270,891 143,335 409,361 72,793 2,646,826 11.5% 53.7 2006/07 665,281 15,563 473,627 52,441 79,547 585,197 280,562 156,709 437,430 77,675 2,824,032 6.7% 53.8 2007/08 659,193 16,179 492,411 40,166 78,887 619,729 288,028 165,291 462,600 82,811 2,905,296 2.9% 53.4 2008/09 686,233 15,622 477,074 63,269 70,072 612,848 300,474 163,974 498,706 85,244 2,973,517 2.3% 53.7 2009/10 688,375 15,424 507,378 73,818 91,550 643,352 310,895 155,403 532,610 87,745 3,106,550 4.5% 54.1 2010/11 700,536 15,593 523,242 54,647 94,602 670,353 317,007 154,963 585,985 88,817 3,205,744 3.2% 54.5 S INDH 1999/00 205,784 39,903 204,982 42,460 14,056 174,243 96,807 49,655 141,478 40,905 1,010,275 28.4 2000/01 195,557 42,575 230,397 31,570 14,855 182,903 99,145 41,057 145,693 42,449 1,026,202 1.6% 28.3 2001/02 185,809 47,878 232,549 32,676 15,748 183,793 97,541 46,723 154,917 43,935 1,041,568 1.5% 27.8 2002/03 188,013 54,155 243,011 28,926 16,230 192,592 102,919 47,182 169,610 45,365 1,088,003 4.5% 27.7 2003/04 205,051 69,572 273,528 46,391 14,888 219,337 107,810 52,545 179,817 46,957 1,215,895 11.8% 28.8 2004/05 207,677 80,560 311,002 42,112 17,651 245,577 110,160 70,703 191,286 48,606 1,325,334 9.0% 28.8 2005/06 230,896 82,722 326,149 29,891 23,963 218,579 118,430 72,015 203,148 41,430 1,347,224 1.7% 27.3 2006/07 240,593 84,769 353,826 28,269 27,271 225,207 125,243 93,065 219,616 41,077 1,438,936 6.8% 27.4 2007/08 252,336 88,260 371,613 22,417 23,677 229,279 131,289 114,894 234,977 40,648 1,509,389 4.9% 27.7 2008/09 262,654 89,597 353,305 35,358 21,089 222,277 135,431 100,306 251,347 42,053 1,513,416 0.3% 27.4 2009/10 262,993 89,242 371,773 42,345 27,127 229,099 138,565 83,758 266,364 43,507 1,554,775 2.7% 27.1 2010/11 263,774 84,177 382,898 34,146 23,751 234,527 139,718 73,599 290,815 44,264 1,571,668 1.1% 26.7 K.P. - 1999/00 75,759 1,031 54,859 29,190 14,612 51,050 65,895 14,689 83,615 14,902 405,601 11.4 2000/01 73,154 1,359 55,733 22,882 13,867 52,849 72,934 12,378 89,043 15,464 409,663 1.0% 11.3 2001/02 78,363 1,288 58,876 21,246 13,344 56,202 77,545 14,356 97,967 16,006 435,194 6.2% 11.6 2002/03 76,215 1,808 62,431 19,297 15,215 56,770 80,324 14,203 99,803 16,527 442,592 1.7% 11.3 2003/04 65,731 1,819 69,416 30,236 13,923 55,222 82,602 15,497 99,372 17,107 450,924 1.9% 10.7 2004/05 76,988 2,416 76,643 27,356 16,507 64,381 85,501 20,190 98,349 17,707 486,040 7.8% 10.6 2005/06 86,761 4,584 87,238 19,357 20,070 61,522 86,107 43,581 121,718 18,161 549,099 13.0% 11.1 2006/07 88,125 7,711 92,863 19,670 22,774 60,619 84,779 49,034 130,889 17,953 574,418 4.6% 10.9 2007/08 81,715 9,153 99,824 14,344 19,714 56,816 82,414 53,338 139,306 17,707 574,332 0.0% 10.6 2008/09 85,506 8,614 98,707 22,092 17,578 58,035 83,644 44,071 148,005 18,425 584,676 1.8% 10.6 2009/10 87,234 13,540 102,229 25,604 21,200 62,499 84,165 34,456 155,781 19,172 605,878 3.6% 10.6 2010/11 92,186 19,521 103,809 22,933 23,355 68,111 83,427 27,942 168,915 19,616 629,815 4.0% 10.7 BALOCHIS TAN - 1999/00 104,406 27,750 22,770 12,832 4,431 47,705 28,249 1,759 48,576 5,539 304,016 8.5 2000/01 112,311 28,807 25,278 13,944 4,802 53,002 29,211 2,127 50,337 5,748 325,568 7.1% 9.0 2001/02 121,032 27,735 30,777 10,041 5,194 58,436 29,017 3,540 53,303 5,949 345,023 6.0% 9.2 2002/03 144,402 26,765 35,243 8,028 5,027 70,879 30,869 2,901 54,682 6,143 384,940 11.6% 9.8 2003/04 155,760 26,149 42,690 11,788 4,328 79,776 32,603 2,622 57,378 6,359 419,452 9.0% 9.9 2004/05 138,973 25,242 53,301 11,917 5,132 77,781 34,621 2,854 59,875 6,582 416,276 -0.8% 9.0 2005/06 136,644 24,830 63,513 9,265 3,850 74,025 20,645 6,125 41,949 3,436 384,282 -7.7% 7.8 2006/07 143,038 24,210 67,985 11,564 4,943 78,049 28,902 5,706 47,323 3,882 415,604 8.2% 7.9 2007/08 155,608 24,455 72,253 8,965 4,798 86,069 37,566 4,863 52,726 4,355 451,658 8.7% 8.3 2008/09 160,609 23,515 69,760 15,872 4,145 85,094 39,154 4,467 53,463 4,907 460,986 2.1% 8.3 2009/10 163,342 22,172 72,896 18,939 5,108 88,563 40,476 3,938 53,546 5,492 474,472 2.9% 8.3 2010/11 160,028 21,680 75,491 15,054 4,462 88,896 41,236 3,668 55,064 6,010 471,588 -0.6% 8.0 25 Table 2: Gross Provincial Value Added at current Prices At current Million Rupees Community, Agriculture, Whole Sale Finance, Growth Share of Mining and Manufacturi Electricity, Transport Social, Ownership Pakistan Fishing & Construction and related Real Estate TOTAL rate Total Pakistan's Quarrying ng Gas, Water and Storage Personal of Dwellings Forestry trade etc. GDP Total GDP Srv. 1999/00 923,609 81,052 522,801 139,624 87,386 620,591 400,983 132,454 541,842 110,425 3,560,768 100.0 2000/01 945,301 106,370 608,132 133,089 94,670 690,755 512,997 116,997 589,473 124,359 3,922,143 10.1% 100.0 2001/02 968,291 116,952 642,850 134,350 95,197 720,862 542,828 142,424 656,009 126,454 4,146,217 5.7% 100.0 2002/03 1,059,316 137,044 725,434 120,556 100,880 787,293 609,929 144,989 715,155 135,139 4,535,735 9.4% 100.0 2003/04 1,164,751 208,290 902,486 190,713 115,497 900,651 675,623 165,230 785,316 146,264 5,254,821 15.9% 100.0 2004/05 1,314,234 182,051 1,136,634 187,267 153,333 1,102,596 759,711 236,254 894,529 165,441 6,132,050 16.7% 100.0 2005/06 1,457,222 219,682 1,370,793 153,338 179,885 1,362,783 908,409 364,320 1,058,065 184,812 7,259,310 18.4% 100.0 2006/07 1,685,240 252,541 1,567,313 168,770 225,239 1,542,170 1,012,206 447,270 1,227,819 206,166 8,334,734 14.8% 100.0 2007/08 2,017,181 301,469 1,950,522 145,874 260,340 1,942,892 1,155,873 556,679 1,464,692 239,010 10,034,532 20.4% 100.0 2008/09 2,611,526 346,412 2,069,482 284,091 294,990 2,234,243 1,587,934 621,508 1,891,393 298,789 12,240,368 22.0% 100.0 2009/10 2,978,950 371,233 2,487,069 366,827 352,530 2,618,196 1,846,735 616,116 2,237,158 345,555 14,220,369 16.2% 100.0 2010/11 3,698,658 431,907 3,167,947 326,426 396,777 3,307,163 2,132,844 649,701 2,785,634 401,687 17,298,744 21.6% 100.0 PUNJAB 1999/00 537,660 12,368 240,191 55,142 54,287 347,593 210,032 66,351 268,172 49,079 1,840,875 51.7 2000/01 547,171 15,904 275,509 57,524 58,541 383,200 268,416 59,191 291,833 55,272 2,012,561 9.3% 51.3 2001/02 554,585 17,498 295,644 57,641 58,624 398,652 283,540 72,576 325,029 56,203 2,119,992 5.3% 51.1 2002/03 601,781 19,460 361,917 52,010 61,227 431,704 316,825 73,336 357,590 60,063 2,335,912 10.2% 51.5 2003/04 652,908 26,034 450,110 81,983 69,282 486,391 348,977 82,872 395,238 65,008 2,658,802 13.8% 50.6 2004/05 772,922 21,384 530,393 83,032 91,978 609,007 393,076 116,857 451,731 73,531 3,143,912 18.2% 51.3 2005/06 840,556 27,658 641,154 69,789 100,274 829,752 496,056 197,014 558,032 99,050 3,859,335 22.8% 53.2 2006/07 970,322 29,718 734,552 79,062 133,178 950,901 546,668 230,174 643,016 113,908 4,431,498 14.8% 53.2 2007/08 1,154,764 35,332 909,086 68,215 161,616 1,213,907 617,329 271,920 761,646 136,013 5,329,827 20.3% 53.1 2008/09 1,515,235 39,402 967,080 131,591 183,114 1,399,690 854,001 325,785 991,307 169,091 6,576,295 23.4% 53.7 2009/10 1,726,950 40,790 1,159,799 168,497 222,603 1,645,725 1,000,068 344,964 1,181,724 194,469 7,685,589 16.9% 54.0 2010/11 2,191,140 47,772 1,468,742 140,702 256,797 2,087,761 1,162,954 386,973 1,482,894 224,794 9,450,530 23.0% 54.6 SINDH 1999/00 205,784 39,903 204,982 42,460 14,056 174,243 96,807 49,655 141,478 40,905 1,010,275 28.4 2000/01 205,118 52,950 247,935 34,879 16,009 194,811 120,468 42,715 152,114 46,066 1,113,066 10.2% 28.4 2001/02 200,515 61,920 251,696 39,187 16,799 198,438 123,914 50,504 167,460 46,843 1,157,275 4.0% 27.9 2002/03 211,675 76,973 276,081 35,249 17,645 213,850 140,889 52,589 187,123 50,060 1,262,133 9.1% 27.8 2003/04 246,013 129,997 339,753 57,051 20,762 256,431 157,908 61,240 208,436 54,181 1,531,772 21.4% 29.1 2004/05 265,177 119,604 424,339 53,936 27,564 312,618 175,387 90,048 242,314 61,285 1,772,271 15.7% 28.9 2005/06 312,400 141,654 497,525 42,680 39,842 329,006 216,870 98,985 276,927 56,374 2,012,263 13.5% 27.7 2006/07 363,951 161,868 569,647 42,619 45,657 365,944 244,033 136,693 322,833 60,238 2,313,484 15.0% 27.8 2007/08 447,940 192,744 715,932 38,072 48,507 449,105 281,391 189,012 386,876 66,761 2,816,340 21.7% 28.1 2008/09 574,048 225,977 751,293 73,539 55,109 507,659 384,919 199,288 499,617 83,417 3,354,867 19.1% 27.4 2009/10 648,971 236,002 902,377 96,658 65,960 586,047 445,728 185,925 590,993 96,425 3,855,087 14.9% 27.1 2010/11 791,565 257,901 1,160,493 87,917 64,471 730,416 512,560 183,792 735,937 112,032 4,637,084 20.3% 26.8 K.P. - 1999/00 75,759 1,031 54,859 29,190 14,612 51,050 65,895 14,689 83,615 14,902 405,601 11.4 2000/01 76,291 1,690 58,518 25,281 14,945 56,290 88,619 12,878 92,969 16,782 444,263 9.5% 11.3 2001/02 83,509 1,666 62,912 25,480 14,234 60,681 98,512 15,517 105,901 17,065 485,476 9.3% 11.7 2002/03 84,793 2,569 61,369 23,515 16,542 63,036 109,958 15,831 110,112 18,237 505,961 4.2% 11.2 2003/04 78,807 3,398 75,206 37,184 19,417 64,562 120,986 18,062 115,160 19,738 552,519 9.2% 10.5 2004/05 98,981 3,588 105,502 35,037 25,777 81,957 136,128 25,714 124,620 22,326 659,629 19.4% 10.8 2005/06 119,060 7,850 132,687 27,639 33,369 92,603 157,679 59,903 165,923 24,712 821,423 24.5% 11.3 2006/07 134,532 14,725 150,097 29,655 38,129 98,501 165,189 72,021 192,405 26,327 921,582 12.2% 11.1 2007/08 145,097 19,989 185,162 24,361 40,388 111,290 176,638 87,746 229,360 29,082 1,049,114 13.8% 10.5 2008/09 187,302 21,726 201,200 45,949 45,935 132,546 237,731 87,560 294,197 36,548 1,290,693 23.0% 10.5 2009/10 216,107 35,806 241,565 58,443 51,547 159,875 270,738 76,485 345,637 42,490 1,498,692 16.1% 10.5 2010/11 272,058 59,809 300,206 59,046 63,396 212,127 306,055 69,777 427,458 49,649 1,819,582 21.4% 10.5 BALOCHISTAN - 1999/00 104,406 27,750 22,770 12,832 4,431 47,705 28,249 1,759 48,576 5,539 304,016 8.5 2000/01 116,722 35,827 26,170 15,405 5,175 56,453 35,493 2,213 52,557 6,238 352,253 15.9% 9.0 2001/02 129,682 35,869 32,599 12,041 5,540 63,092 36,862 3,826 57,619 6,343 383,474 8.9% 9.2 2002/03 161,068 38,042 26,067 9,783 5,466 78,703 42,257 3,233 60,330 6,779 431,729 12.6% 9.5 2003/04 187,024 48,861 37,417 14,496 6,036 93,267 47,753 3,055 66,481 7,337 511,728 18.5% 9.7 2004/05 177,154 37,476 76,400 15,263 8,013 99,014 55,121 3,634 75,864 8,299 556,238 8.7% 9.1 2005/06 185,206 42,520 99,428 13,230 6,401 111,423 37,804 8,418 57,184 4,676 566,289 1.8% 7.8 2006/07 216,435 46,230 113,016 17,434 8,276 126,823 56,316 8,382 69,565 5,693 668,170 18.0% 8.0 2007/08 269,380 53,404 140,342 15,226 9,829 168,590 80,515 8,001 86,810 7,153 839,250 25.6% 8.4 2008/09 334,941 59,308 149,909 33,012 10,832 194,348 111,283 8,876 106,271 9,733 1,018,512 21.4% 8.3 2009/10 386,922 58,635 183,328 43,229 12,420 226,550 130,201 8,742 118,804 12,171 1,181,001 16.0% 8.3 2010/11 443,895 66,424 238,506 38,761 12,113 276,858 151,275 9,159 139,345 15,211 1,391,547 17.8% 8.0 26 Table 3: Annual Growth in Gross Provincial Value Added at constant factor cost Annual percentage growth Whole Communit Agricultur Mining Transport Finance, Ownership Manufactu Electricity, Constructi S ale and y, S ocial, Pakistan e, Fishing and and Real Estate of TOTAL ring Gas, Water on related Personal & Forestry Quarrying S torage etc. Dwellings trade S rv. 1999/00 2000/01 -2.18 5.52 9.29 -13.72 0.53 4.50 5.29 -15.10 4.20 3.77 1.97 2001/02 0.10 5.73 4.46 -7.00 1.59 2.95 1.21 17.17 7.49 3.50 3.14 2002/03 4.15 6.62 6.90 -11.69 3.98 6.20 4.27 -1.28 6.81 3.26 4.76 2003/04 2.43 15.61 14.01 56.75 -10.75 8.65 3.53 8.98 4.51 3.51 7.54 2004/05 6.48 10.00 15.51 -5.72 18.56 12.43 3.45 30.85 4.21 3.51 9.04 2005/06 6.30 4.62 8.65 -26.55 10.19 4.53 3.96 42.89 9.94 3.51 7.10 2006/07 4.11 3.09 8.25 4.24 24.35 4.83 4.72 14.89 7.61 3.51 6.61 2007/08 1.04 4.38 4.84 -23.27 -5.54 4.51 3.81 11.12 6.51 3.51 3.57 2008/09 4.02 -0.51 -3.60 59.02 -11.17 -1.38 3.60 -7.56 6.96 3.51 1.69 2009/10 0.58 2.21 5.55 17.65 28.44 4.63 2.76 -11.27 5.97 3.51 3.78 2010/11 1.21 0.42 2.96 -21.11 0.82 3.75 1.27 -6.26 9.17 1.79 2.39 PUNJAB 1999/00 2000/01 -2.82 3.39 8.23 -5.58 0.06 3.51 5.18 -14.25 4.23 3.77 1.56 2001/02 -0.62 5.80 5.65 -7.69 1.17 2.63 1.04 18.01 7.57 3.50 2.88 2002/03 2.71 1.19 8.27 -11.20 2.48 5.30 3.70 -2.01 7.79 3.26 4.40 2003/04 0.94 1.77 14.95 56.19 -11.79 7.01 2.95 8.07 5.17 3.51 6.23 2004/05 12.16 3.38 16.82 -2.75 18.56 14.99 3.62 29.04 4.57 3.51 11.25 2005/06 5.64 12.14 9.21 -24.61 2.40 15.23 9.72 56.22 14.84 24.82 11.54 2006/07 4.31 -3.64 8.62 7.29 31.89 6.16 3.57 9.33 6.86 6.71 6.70 2007/08 -0.92 3.96 3.97 -23.41 -0.83 5.90 2.66 5.48 5.75 6.61 2.88 2008/09 4.10 -3.44 -3.11 57.52 -11.17 -1.11 4.32 -0.80 7.80 2.94 2.35 2009/10 0.31 -1.27 6.35 16.67 30.65 4.98 3.47 -5.23 6.80 2.93 4.47 2010/11 1.77 1.09 3.13 -25.97 3.33 4.20 1.97 -0.28 10.02 1.22 3.19 S INDH 1999/00 2000/01 -4.97 6.69 12.40 -25.65 5.68 4.97 2.41 -17.32 2.98 3.77 1.58 2001/02 -4.98 12.46 0.93 3.50 6.01 0.49 -1.62 13.80 6.33 3.50 1.50 2002/03 1.19 13.11 4.50 -11.47 3.06 4.79 5.51 0.98 9.48 3.26 4.46 2003/04 9.06 28.47 12.56 60.37 -8.27 13.89 4.75 11.37 6.02 3.51 11.75 2004/05 1.28 15.79 13.70 -9.22 18.56 11.96 2.18 34.56 6.38 3.51 9.00 2005/06 11.18 2.68 4.87 -29.02 35.76 -10.99 7.51 1.86 6.20 -14.76 1.65 2006/07 4.20 2.47 8.49 -5.43 13.80 3.03 5.75 29.23 8.11 -0.85 6.81 2007/08 4.88 4.12 5.03 -20.70 -13.18 1.81 4.83 23.46 6.99 -1.04 4.90 2008/09 4.09 1.51 -4.93 57.72 -10.93 -3.05 3.15 -12.70 6.97 3.46 0.27 2009/10 0.13 -0.40 5.23 19.76 28.64 3.07 2.31 -16.50 5.97 3.46 2.73 2010/11 0.30 -5.68 2.99 -19.36 -12.45 2.37 0.83 -12.13 9.18 1.74 1.09 K.P. 1999/00 2000/01 -3.44 31.84 1.59 -21.61 -5.09 3.52 10.68 -15.73 6.49 3.77 1.00 2001/02 7.12 -5.20 5.64 -7.15 -3.78 6.34 6.32 15.98 10.02 3.50 6.23 2002/03 -2.74 40.34 6.04 -9.18 14.03 1.01 3.58 -1.06 1.87 3.26 1.70 2003/04 -13.76 0.62 11.19 56.69 -8.49 -2.73 2.84 9.11 -0.43 3.51 1.88 2004/05 17.13 32.86 10.41 -9.52 18.56 16.58 3.51 30.28 -1.03 3.51 7.79 2005/06 12.69 89.71 13.82 -29.24 21.59 -4.44 0.71 115.85 23.76 2.56 12.97 2006/07 1.57 68.22 6.45 1.62 13.47 -1.47 -1.54 12.51 7.54 -1.15 4.61 2007/08 -7.27 18.70 7.50 -27.08 -13.44 -6.27 -2.79 8.78 6.43 -1.37 -0.01 2008/09 4.64 -5.89 -1.12 54.01 -10.83 2.14 1.49 -17.37 6.24 4.06 1.80 2009/10 2.02 57.18 3.57 15.90 20.60 7.69 0.62 -21.82 5.25 4.05 3.63 2010/11 5.68 44.18 1.55 -10.43 10.16 8.98 -0.88 -18.90 8.43 2.32 3.95 BALOCHIS TAN 1999/00 2000/01 7.57 3.81 11.02 8.67 8.38 11.10 3.41 20.93 3.63 3.77 7.09 2001/02 7.77 -3.72 21.75 -27.99 8.16 10.25 -0.67 66.44 5.89 3.50 5.98 2002/03 19.31 -3.50 14.51 -20.04 -3.20 21.29 6.38 -18.05 2.59 3.26 11.57 2003/04 7.87 -2.30 21.13 46.83 -13.91 12.55 5.62 -9.63 4.93 3.51 8.97 2004/05 -10.78 -3.47 24.86 1.10 18.56 -2.50 6.19 8.85 4.35 3.51 -0.76 2005/06 -1.68 -1.63 19.16 -22.25 -24.97 -4.83 -40.37 114.62 -29.94 -47.80 -7.69 2006/07 4.68 -2.50 7.04 24.80 28.40 5.44 40.00 -6.83 12.81 12.98 8.15 2007/08 8.79 1.01 6.28 -22.47 -2.95 10.28 29.98 -14.77 11.42 12.19 8.68 2008/09 3.21 -3.84 -3.45 77.04 -13.60 -1.13 4.23 -8.14 1.40 12.66 2.07 2009/10 1.70 -5.71 4.50 19.32 23.23 4.08 3.38 -11.84 0.15 11.92 2.93 2010/11 -2.03 -2.22 3.56 -20.51 -12.64 0.37 1.88 -6.87 2.84 9.44 -0.61 27 Table B.9: Annual Shares of Gross Provincial Value Added to National Value Added @ current Prices Share of National GDP Whole Communit Agricultur Mining Transport Finance, Ownership Manufactu Electricity, Constructi Sale and y, Social, Pakistan e, Fishing and and Real Estate of TOTAL ring Gas, Water on related Personal & Forestry Quarrying Storage etc. Dwellings trade Srv. 1999/00 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2000/01 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2001/02 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2002/03 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2003/04 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2004/05 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2005/06 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2006/07 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2007/08 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2008/09 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2009/10 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 2010/11 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 PUNJAB 1999/00 58.2 15.3 45.9 39.5 62.1 56.0 52.4 50.1 49.5 44.4 51.7 2000/01 57.9 15.0 45.3 43.2 61.8 55.5 52.3 50.6 49.5 44.4 51.3 2001/02 57.3 15.0 46.0 42.9 61.6 55.3 52.2 51.0 49.5 44.4 51.1 2002/03 56.8 14.2 49.9 43.1 60.7 54.8 51.9 50.6 50.0 44.4 51.5 2003/04 56.1 12.5 49.9 43.0 60.0 54.0 51.7 50.2 50.3 44.4 50.6 2004/05 58.8 11.7 46.7 44.3 60.0 55.2 51.7 49.5 50.5 44.4 51.3 2005/06 57.7 12.6 46.8 45.5 55.7 60.9 54.6 54.1 52.7 53.6 53.2 2006/07 57.6 11.8 46.9 46.8 59.1 61.7 54.0 51.5 52.4 55.3 53.2 2007/08 57.2 11.7 46.6 46.8 62.1 62.5 53.4 48.8 52.0 56.9 53.1 2008/09 58.0 11.4 46.7 46.3 62.1 62.6 53.8 52.4 52.4 56.6 53.7 2009/10 58.0 11.0 46.6 45.9 63.1 62.9 54.2 56.0 52.8 56.3 54.0 2010/11 59.2 11.1 46.4 43.1 64.7 63.1 54.5 59.6 53.2 56.0 54.6 SINDH 1999/00 22.3 49.2 39.2 30.4 16.1 28.1 24.1 37.5 26.1 37.0 28.4 2000/01 21.7 49.8 40.8 26.2 16.9 28.2 23.5 36.5 25.8 37.0 28.4 2001/02 20.7 52.9 39.2 29.2 17.6 27.5 22.8 35.5 25.5 37.0 27.9 2002/03 20.0 56.2 38.1 29.2 17.5 27.2 23.1 36.3 26.2 37.0 27.8 2003/04 21.1 62.4 37.6 29.9 18.0 28.5 23.4 37.1 26.5 37.0 29.1 2004/05 20.2 65.7 37.3 28.8 18.0 28.4 23.1 38.1 27.1 37.0 28.9 2005/06 21.4 64.5 36.3 27.8 22.1 24.1 23.9 27.2 26.2 30.5 27.7 2006/07 21.6 64.1 36.3 25.3 20.3 23.7 24.1 30.6 26.3 29.2 27.8 2007/08 22.2 63.9 36.7 26.1 18.6 23.1 24.3 34.0 26.4 27.9 28.1 2008/09 22.0 65.2 36.3 25.9 18.7 22.7 24.2 32.1 26.4 27.9 27.4 2009/10 21.8 63.6 36.3 26.3 18.7 22.4 24.1 30.2 26.4 27.9 27.1 2010/11 21.4 59.7 36.6 26.9 16.2 22.1 24.0 28.3 26.4 27.9 26.8 K.P. 1999/00 8.2 1.3 10.5 20.9 16.7 8.2 16.4 11.1 15.4 13.5 11.4 2000/01 8.1 1.6 9.6 19.0 15.8 8.1 17.3 11.0 15.8 13.5 11.3 2001/02 8.6 1.4 9.8 19.0 15.0 8.4 18.1 10.9 16.1 13.5 11.7 2002/03 8.0 1.9 8.5 19.5 16.4 8.0 18.0 10.9 15.4 13.5 11.2 2003/04 6.8 1.6 8.3 19.5 16.8 7.2 17.9 10.9 14.7 13.5 10.5 2004/05 7.5 2.0 9.3 18.7 16.8 7.4 17.9 10.9 13.9 13.5 10.8 2005/06 8.2 3.6 9.7 18.0 18.5 6.8 17.4 16.4 15.7 13.4 11.3 2006/07 8.0 5.8 9.6 17.6 16.9 6.4 16.3 16.1 15.7 12.8 11.1 2007/08 7.2 6.6 9.5 16.7 15.5 5.7 15.3 15.8 15.7 12.2 10.5 2008/09 7.2 6.3 9.7 16.2 15.6 5.9 15.0 14.1 15.6 12.2 10.5 2009/10 7.3 9.6 9.7 15.9 14.6 6.1 14.7 12.4 15.4 12.3 10.5 2010/11 7.4 13.8 9.5 18.1 16.0 6.4 14.3 10.7 15.3 12.4 10.5 BALOCHISTAN 1999/00 11.3 34.2 4.4 9.2 5.1 7.7 7.0 1.3 9.0 5.0 8.5 2000/01 12.3 33.7 4.3 11.6 5.5 8.2 6.9 1.9 8.9 5.0 9.0 2001/02 13.4 30.7 5.1 9.0 5.8 8.8 6.8 2.7 8.8 5.0 9.2 2002/03 15.2 27.8 3.6 8.1 5.4 10.0 6.9 2.2 8.4 5.0 9.5 2003/04 16.1 23.5 4.1 7.6 5.2 10.4 7.1 1.8 8.5 5.0 9.7 2004/05 13.5 20.6 6.7 8.2 5.2 9.0 7.3 1.5 8.5 5.0 9.1 2005/06 12.7 19.4 7.3 8.6 3.6 8.2 4.2 2.3 5.4 2.5 7.8 2006/07 12.8 18.3 7.2 10.3 3.7 8.2 5.6 1.9 5.7 2.8 8.0 2007/08 13.4 17.7 7.2 10.4 3.8 8.7 7.0 1.4 5.9 3.0 8.4 2008/09 12.8 17.1 7.2 11.6 3.7 8.7 7.0 1.4 5.6 3.3 8.3 2009/10 13.0 15.8 7.4 11.8 3.5 8.7 7.1 1.4 5.3 3.5 8.3 2010/11 12.0 15.4 7.5 11.9 3.1 8.4 7.1 1.4 5.0 3.8 8.0 28