Skip to Main Navigation

Learning to Navigate a New Financial Technology : Evidence from Payroll Accounts (English)

How do inexperienced consumers learn to use a new financial technology? This paper presents results from a field experiment that introduced payroll accounts in a population of largely unbanked factory workers in Bangladesh. In the experiment, workers in a treatment group received monthly wage payments into a bank or mobile money account while workers in a control group continued to receive wages in cash, with a subset also receiving an account without automatic wage payments. The results show that exposure to payroll accounts leads to increased account use and consumer learning. Those receiving accounts with automatic wage payments learn to use the account without assistance, begin to use a wider set of account features, and learn to avoid illicit fees, which are common in emerging markets for consumer finance. The treatments have real effects, leading to increased savings and improvements in the ability to cope with unanticipated economic shocks. An additional audit study provides suggestive evidence of market externalities from consumer learning: mobile money agents are less likely to overcharge inexperienced customers in areas with higher levels of payroll account adoption. This suggests potentially important equilibrium effects of introducing accounts at scale.

Details

  • Author

    Breza,Emily, Kanz,Martin, Klapper,Leora

  • Document Date

    2020/12/31

  • Document Type

    Policy Research Working Paper

  • Report Number

    WPS9495

  • Volume No

    1

  • Total Volume(s)

    1

  • Country

    Bangladesh,

  • Region

    South Asia,

  • Disclosure Date

    2020/12/14

  • Disclosure Status

    Disclosed

  • Doc Name

    Learning to Navigate a New Financial Technology : Evidence from Payroll Accounts

  • Keywords

    payroll accounts; mobile money; development research group; open account; conditional cash transfer program; low levels of education; higher level of education; pay in cash; test of equality; assignment to treatment; types of consumer; types of accounts; formal banking system; minimum balance requirement; minimum wage law; types of transactions; population of worker; demand for remittance; demand for bank; cost of access; lack of resource; government transfer payments; international labor standard; know your client; proof of identity; international supply chain; direct deposit; administrative datum; treatment group; consumer protection; account opening; standard error; formal saving; survey data; active engagement; inexperienced consumer; monthly wage; work experience; baseline survey; machine learning; marital status; account ownership; transaction cost; cash payment; banking facilities; send remittance; deposit withdrawal; summary statistic; informal saving; conventional banking; savings goal; account balance; factory premises; social barrier; informal loan; send money; savings saving; total consumption; total saving; account groups; descriptive statistic; cation analysis; export market; reliable access; phone number; account holder; consumption smoothing; factory worker; savings product; information asymmetry; garment industry; discretionary consumption; individual level; cash wage; payment transaction; account deposits; documentation requirement; manufacturing sector; positive externality; income share; account usage; low trust; several reasons; dependent children; low-income worker; smart phone; regular income; insurance cost; inclusive growth; increasing integration; worker safety; labor regulation; atm machine; multinational enforcement; direct consumption; error message; inexperienced worker; first stage; study area; regulatory resource; illicit transaction; educated consumer; behavioral biases; Credit Score; long-term credit; branch banking; positive impact; account number; real impact; behavioral change; know how; comparative advantage; workfare program; debit transaction; personnel data; account maintenance; low-income household; active participation; program account; unmet demand; Salary Grades; open bank; middle-income economy; research design; english language; transaction fee; trial period; month period; partner institution; industry standard; experimental treatment; upper bind; individual transaction; partner bank; elementary school; average score; high share; monthly remittance; mobile payments; regression results; employment relationship; government payment; physical banking; payroll control; recent years; local saving; monthly transaction; consumer access; total sample; transfer money; service charges; employment records; geographical location; hypothesis testing; traditional bank; direct payment; manufacturing industry; export industry; daily expense; stochastic error; formal employment; rural area; poverty action; exchange rate; Exchange Rates; open access; development policy; government bailout; consumer transaction; Research Support; several countries; workplace environment; global workforce; global financial; research assistance; time horizon; labor right; predatory practice; consumer knowledge; wage income; market level; economic shock; currency conversion; experimental design; household resource; limited capacity; increased supply; consumer finance

Downloads

COMPLETE REPORT

Official version of document (may contain signatures, etc)

  • Official PDF
  • TXT*
  • Total Downloads** :
  • Download Stats
  • *The text version is uncorrected OCR text and is included solely to benefit users with slow connectivity.

Citation

Breza,Emily Kanz,Martin Klapper,Leora

Learning to Navigate a New Financial Technology : Evidence from Payroll Accounts (English). Policy Research working paper,no. WPS 9495 Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/273651607459575325/Learning-to-Navigate-a-New-Financial-Technology-Evidence-from-Payroll-Accounts