Skip to Main Navigation

International grain reserves and other instruments to address volatility in grain markets (English)

In the long view, recent grain price volatility is not anomalous. Wheat, rice, and maize are highly substitutable in the global market for calories, and when aggregate stocks decline to minimal feasible levels, prices become highly sensitive to small shocks, consistent with storage models. In this decade, stocks have declined due to high income growth and biofuels mandates. Recently, shocks including the Australian drought and biofuels demand boosts due to the oil price spike were exacerbated by a sequence of trade restrictions by key exporters beginning in the thin global rice market in the fall of 2007, which turned market anxiety into panic. To protect vulnerable consumers, countries intervened in storage markets and, if they were exporters, to limit trade access. Recognizing these realities, vulnerable countries are building strategic reserves. The associated expense and negative incentive effects can be controlled if reserves have quantitative targets related to the consumption needs of the most vulnerable, with distribution to the latter only in severe emergencies. More-ambitious plans manipulate world prices via buffer stocks or naked short speculation to keep prices consistent with fundamentals. Past interventions of either kind have been expensive, ineffective, and generally short-lived. Further, there is no significant evidence that prices do not reflect fundamentals, including export market access.

Details

  • Author

    Wright, Brian

  • Document Date

    2009/08/01

  • Document Type

    Policy Research Working Paper

  • Report Number

    WPS5028

  • Volume No

    1

  • Total Volume(s)

    1

  • Country

    World,

  • Region

    The World Region,

  • Disclosure Date

    2010/07/01

  • Disclosure Status

    Disclosed

  • Doc Name

    International grain reserves and other instruments to address volatility in grain markets

  • Keywords

    grain price;grain market;effect of global warming;price spike;grain reserve;consumption;Food Price Index;increase in income;exchange rate movement;commodity price volatility;minimum consumption level;international financial flows;private storage;biofuel production;impact on price;tariff import;tariff on import;foreign agricultural service;food price volatility;determination of price;sequence of events;fixed interest rate;oil price spike;demand for consumption;cost of capital;costs to producer;public employment program;crude oil price;global food supply;global food security;price of fertilizer;peer review process;globalization of market;food aid program;increase in consumption;increase in prices;agricultural commodity price;protection from competition;food and nutrition;behavior of price;sum of money;line of defense;domestic food security;distribution of food;food for work;ensuring food security;commodity price index;international price volatility;reduction in subsidies;negative incentive effect;lack of evidence;food aid flow;consumption demand;staple food;global market;future market;food grain;food market;export ban;world price;transport cost;urban consumer;landlocked country;rice price;human consumption;Commodity future;rice production;petroleum price;free market;wheat price;income growth;grain consumption;buffer stock;market demand;working level;food crisis;grain storage;working stock;food emergency;national strategic;biofuel use;cumulative effect;policy proposal;market instability;calorie consumption;price series;plant variety;commodity market;quantitative targets;supply shock;counterparty risk;fertilizer price;international market;fertilizer supply;futures position;minimum level;expected value;domestic price;wheat production;price change;public stock;aggregate consumption;market price;expected return;doctoral program;price rise;international reserve;net effect;high volatility;regional production;grain production;crisis management;options trading;price slump;agricultural economist;vulnerable consumer;domestic consumer;daily calorie;ethanol production;grain demand;crop research;increased demand;export tax;positive correlation;grain deposit;current consumption;interest cost;grain supply;marginal value;arbitrage condition;famine relief;calorie requirement;seasonal fluctuation;production increase;smooth consumption;ancient times;market environment;domestic consumption;negative effect;tropical country;efficient management;human capital;private market;international cooperation;import tariff;local food;emergency situation;local farmer;severe drought;emergency conditions;national reserves;personal communication;price effect;food distribution;vulnerable countries;emergency food;disaster relief;humanitarian disaster;strategic reserve;storage facility;regional food;strategic location;call option;speculative capital;market stock;domestic supply;capitalist economy;arbitrage equation;random variable;consumption response;econometric estimation;supply response;cultivated area;price response;empirical research;price behavior;sole source;fixed supply;economics research;corn price;stock data;public intervention;dispersed population;trend line;employment alternative;humanitarian crisis;future contract;fertilizer ingredient;world trade;internal trade;meat demand;temperate zone;relative price;supply constraint;energy cost;governmental response;maize farmers;ethanol producer;fertilizer application;world food;fertilizer use;acreage reduction;mineral deposit;global supply;cereal production;sugar price;agricultural productivity;international debate;common vision;market disturbance;production efficiency;petroleum market;population increase;Emerging economies;emerging economy;food reserve;food self-sufficiency;sugar cane;world consumption;cultivated land;regional variation;shipping cost;price fluctuation;production environment;small country;production risk;cereal trade;world rice;global population;winter wheat;stock adjustment;disincentive effect

Downloads

COMPLETE REPORT

Official version of document (may contain signatures, etc)

  • Official PDF
  • TXT*
  • Total Downloads** :
  • Download Stats
  • *The text version is uncorrected OCR text and is included solely to benefit users with slow connectivity.

Citation

Wright, Brian

International grain reserves and other instruments to address volatility in grain markets (English). Policy Research working paper ; no. WPS 5028 Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/375561468336329144/International-grain-reserves-and-other-instruments-to-address-volatility-in-grain-markets