Skip to Main Navigation

Pakistan - Montreal Protocol Ozone Depleting Substances Phase Out Project (English)

Ratings for the Montreal Protocol Ozone Depleting Substances (ODS) Phase Out Project of Pakistan were as follows: outcomes were satisfactory, the risk to development outcome was low or negligible, the Bank performance was satisfactory, and the Borrower performance was satisfactory. Some lessons learned included: 1) During the implementation of the umbrella projects (where there were more than one enterprises involved) it would have been more appropriate that the selection of machinery be based on each individual enterprises' technical and working capability so that the equipment supplied met their working environment; 2) In projects that involve funding the private sector to transform a market, it is advantageous to have some counterpart contribution to ensure ownership; 3) In cases where subproject implementation was deliberately stalled because of a lack of enterprise commitment, it would have been helpful to the Financial Intermediary (FI) to have a "stick" to encourage enterprises to move forward in implementation; 4) The lessons drawn from the Pakistan ODS Phase-out Project support the findings that sustainable phaseout hinges upon Government policy action early on and a project design that promotes Government involvement in implementation through capacity building and other support measures; 5) Although an assessment of economic costs and benefits to the country to convert to non-ODS technology and to implement the MP is beyond the scope of this report, some broad conclusions can be made based on experiences from implementation of the ODS Project; 6) One important lesson learned was that a capacity needs assessment would have been helpful to determine what type of training NBP needed to ensure it was able to deliver on its obligations in the earlier stages of the project.

Details

  • Document Date

    2007/09/21

  • Document Type

    Implementation Completion and Results Report

  • Report Number

    ICR548

  • Volume No

    1

  • Total Volume(s)

    1

  • Country

    Pakistan,

  • Region

    South Asia,

  • Disclosure Date

    2007/10/02

  • Disclosure Status

    Disclosed

  • Doc Name

    Pakistan - Montreal Protocol Ozone Depleting Substances Phase Out Project

  • Keywords

    Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building;economic and financial analysis;introduction of cleaner technology;Assessment and Action Plan;level of consumption;financial intermediaries;building local capacity;Operational Data Store;losing market share;net present value;financial management staff;public awareness campaign;high growth rate;books of account;per capita consumption;ratings of bank;agreed incremental cost;fast economic growth;Exchange Rates;outputs by components;financial management arrangement;import of goods;financial management specialist;reduction in consumption;withdrawal of fund;Natural Resource Management;performance management framework;level of capacity;manufacturing sector;grant funding;counterpart funding;project duration;controlled substance;investment component;subproject implementation;disbursement profile;evaluation framework;quota system;eligibility criterion;equipment disposal;monitor compliance;subgrant agreement;measurable indicators;global environment;project indicator;technical appraisal;individual enterprise;disbursement rate;technology option;financial reporting;reporting obligation;subproject preparation;risk assessment;technology choice;direct supervision;internal control;causal linkage;satisfactory completion;procurement arrangement;sustainability indicator;market circumstances;industrial environment;administrative delays;safeguard policy;Safeguard Policies;monitoring responsibility;market gap;learning process;external demand;financial indicator;upper management;common denominator;sales tax;environmental awareness;Fixed Assets;subproject approval;financial ratio;project costing;exogenous factor;financial appraisal;regular operations;consumption level;institutional change;gender aspect;external factor;financial return;production method;external events;registered company;quota reduction;subproject identification;financial viability;appraisal reports;market pressure;cost differential;sustainable outcomes;travel restriction;equipment installation;government control;regulatory pressure;enterprise business;production technology;strategic approach;investment incentive;Technology Transfer;safety standard;managerial skill;global benefit;enable fund;import quota;investment grant;rolling basis;adequate training;permit program;administrative capacity;relevant market;firm exit;economic sector;data reporting;environmental strategy;special situation;annual consumption;grace period;commercial refrigeration;large enterprise;organizational change;financial incentive;significant challenge;environmental law;international community;scientific assessment;ozone layer;ultraviolet radiation;methyl bromide;environmental problem;industrial sector;customs official;external partner;environmental health;primary author;beneficiary level;moderate inflation;macroeconomic adjustment;Population Growth;results framework;beneficiary survey;stakeholder workshop;international expert;Health Regulation;safety issue;average duration;counterpart contribution;monitoring mechanism;audit measure;asset finance;

Downloads

COMPLETE REPORT

Official version of document (may contain signatures, etc)

  • Official PDF
  • TXT*
  • Total Downloads** :
  • Download Stats
  • *The text version is uncorrected OCR text and is included solely to benefit users with slow connectivity.

Citation

Pakistan - Montreal Protocol Ozone Depleting Substances Phase Out Project (English). Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/764751468146962148/Pakistan-Montreal-Protocol-Ozone-Depleting-Substances-Phase-Out-Project