Skip to Main Navigation

Brazil - Belo Horizonte Inclusive Urban Development Policy Loan Project (English)

Ratings for the Belo Horizonte Inclusive Urban Development Policy Loan Project for Brazil were as follows: outcomes were moderately unsatisfactory, the risk to development outcome was moderate, the Bank performance was moderately satisfactory, and the Borrower performance was also moderately satisfactory. Some lessons learned included: in the context of multi-sector operations, it is important to ensure the coherence of the various PDOs. In the case of this DPL, PDO 3 was less connected than the other two PDOs and of a level of technical and political complexity that was incompatible with that of an integrated multi-sector operation. When there are substantial delays between approval and effectiveness, reappraisal may be warranted. In the case of this operation, almost two years elapsed between approval and effectiveness. By then, the baselines and many of the targets within the Results Framework were obsolete. Sub-national operations offer great potential for cross-fertilization and economies of scale. As illustrated by this operation, successful innovations supported under subnational operations can be easily replicated in other states and municipalities. Likewise, there is potential for vertical economies of scale and homogenization by interacting with municipal, state and federal actors simultaneously. When working at the sub-national level, it is critical to maintain close coordination with the federal government to ensure the seamless integration of federally funded programs with subnational policies. Ongoing changes in patterns in public participation and service delivery may deserve a more in-depth exploration. This operation points to an ongoing shift away from traditional in-person forms of communication (i.e., committees, assemblies, community meetings, in-person customer service) to emerging forms of online communication (i.e., on-line discussion boards and blogs, interest groups, online customer service). This presents a good opportunity for the Bank to review participatory and service provision strategies under the new citizen engagement framework that has just been set.

Details

  • Document Date

    2015/05/26

  • Document Type

    Implementation Completion and Results Report

  • Report Number

    ICR3334

  • Volume No

    1

  • Total Volume(s)

    1

  • Country

    Brazil,

  • Region

    Latin America & Caribbean,

  • Disclosure Date

    2015/06/01

  • Disclosure Status

    Disclosed

  • Doc Name

    Brazil - Belo Horizonte Inclusive Urban Development Policy Loan Project

  • Keywords

    Public Expenditure, Financial Management and Procurement;Adaptation to Climate Change;urban development;Urban Governance;mitigation of climate change;climate change mitigation;sustainable practices;fiscally sustainable;access to social protection;world economic;access to urban service;sustainable natural resource management;disaster risk management;low-income housing;long-term fiscal sustainability;disaster management strategy;point of access;early warning system;vulnerable family;land and housing;greenhouse gas emission;quality of supervision;climate change adaptation;assessment of outcome;civil society participants;sustainable urban development;quality at entry;climate action plan;lack of interest;living condition;Urban Planning;vulnerable citizen;number of works;civil society representatives;exchange of information;private sector provision;emission of pollutant;civil society participation;urban development strategy;incidence of poverty;difference in methodology;sense of ownership;average annual output;Climate Change Policy;demand for service;environmentally sustainable growth;source of pollution;source of revenue;capacity of individual;flood prone area;rapid technological change;access to information;supply of land;land use planning;public sector participation;measure output;land tenure regularization;assessment of risk;exchange rate;Exchange Rates;natural disaster management;innovative policy;social housing;social inclusion;land regularization;alert system;land management;social exclusion;green development;participatory mechanism;institutional framework;strategic areas;individual policy;household benefit;pilot program;social program;urban forestry;participatory urban;pension liabilities;municipal authority;slum area;low-income household;pension reform;actuarial deficit;evaluation activity;retirement plan;federal system;land title;housing development;urban poor;regulatory system;pension system;effective demand;sustainable livelihood;federal government;high rainfall;budget execution;retirement system;urban legislation;social vulnerability;sustainable city;Global Warming;data transmission;safety condition;federal level;solar radiation;water level;loan approval;climatological stations;drainage system;retention basin;macroeconomic environment;policy outcome;special provision;private investment;federal program;housing rehabilitation;primary author;municipal public;land supply;institution building;online service;municipal governance;flood protection;individual indicator;Fiscal Reform;participatory approach;social integration;rainfall event;external partner;contingency plan;warning signs;flood risk;increased access;strategic objective;gender study;municipal government;budgetary plan;brazilian real;transitional period;housing upgrading;regional planning;macroeconomic framework;degraded areas;green area;environmental sustainability;state capital;informal settlement;adequate housing;urban divide;beneficiary survey;stakeholder workshop;data reporting;sector specialist;budget allocation;resettlement policy;management idea;resettlement practices;fiscal framework;Fiscal policies;fiscal policy;monthly reports;minimum wage;vulnerable group;urban land;administrative procedure;cadastral map;municipal decree;Macroeconomic Stability;household income;administrative cycle;strategic management;minimal wage;Labor Market;slum upgrading;municipal practice;Indicator Target;climate resilience;billing error;connection time;ownership data;public policy;private initiative;environmental issue;social environment;environmental health;atmospheric pressure;causal link;internal change;public governance;urban bank;municipal administration;affordable land;reform effort;primary data;urban management;City Management;vulnerable sector;institutional environment;adverse events;municipal resource;

Downloads

COMPLETE REPORT

Official version of document (may contain signatures, etc)

  • Official PDF
  • TXT*
  • Total Downloads** :
  • Download Stats
  • *The text version is uncorrected OCR text and is included solely to benefit users with slow connectivity.

Citation

Brazil - Belo Horizonte Inclusive Urban Development Policy Loan Project (English). Washington, D.C. : World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/895071467986288007/Brazil-Belo-Horizonte-Inclusive-Urban-Development-Policy-Loan-Project