Skip to Main Navigation

Pakistan - Northern Resource Management Project (Inglês)

Although the audit agrees with the Implementation Completion Report ratings - outcome as satisfactory, institutional development as substantial, likely sustainability, and borrower performance as satisfactory - it downgrades the Bank performance rating to unsatisfactory, due to the lack of compliance with the Bank's safeguard resettlement policy. Lessons drawn from the project show that: 1) multiple component rural development projects, can work if focused on efficiency at the village level, through community participation, backed by efficient services, through institutional reform, and privatization; 2) sustainability can be enhanced, keeping community mobilization manageable, planning for post-project period, and developing non-governmental organizations capacity to play an increasing role; 3) training programs on agricultural technologies at the village level are effective technology transfer tools, even more so than routine extension visits; 4) the analysis of project, and post-project local funds demand, following comparison with budget allocations, should be explicit in the appraisal reports; 5) careful consideration of compensation arrangements, under the Involuntary Resettlement Operational Directive should be given, particularly to projects involving land acquisition; and, 6) pragmatic credit delivery should be considered in the absence of suitable credit lines.

Detalhes

  • Data do documento

    2000/06/06

  • TIpo de documento

    Relatório sobre Avaliação do Desempenho do Projeto

  • No. do relatório

    20517

  • Nº do volume

    1

  • Total Volume(s)

    1

  • País

    Madagascar,

  • Região

    Sul da Ásia,

  • Data de divulgação

    2017/11/20

  • Disclosure Status

    Disclosed

  • Nome do documento

    Pakistan - Northern Resource Management Project

  • Palavras-chave

    Institutional Reforms in the Public Sector;achievement need;efficient use of land;Administrative & Client Support;Management of Natural Resources;land use planning;efficiency of resource use;establishment of community;cost of land;sustainable resource management;environmentally vulnerable areas;support for woman;institutional development impact;grass root level;department of agriculture;per capita income;Program of Technology;education and health;average exchange rate;quid pro quo;numbers of heifers;returns to scale;cooperation and assistance;financial sector policy;service delivery arrangement;impacts on vegetation;number of beneficiaries;public sector activity;community development activities;sustainable rural livelihood;provision for drainage;Support for Agriculture;Natural Resource Management;budget line item;loss of land;animal health campaign;community development component;Technology Transfer;road improvement;road component;community participation;community group;input supply;credit line;stakeholder workshop;remote area;community mobilization;social mobilization;borrower performance;institutional strengthening;land acquisition;poultry vaccination;Vocational Training;paradigm shift;field observation;benchmark survey;environmental sustainability;productive infrastructure;land compensation;poverty alleviation;project effectiveness;community level;preparation mission;tree seedlings;resettlement issue;participatory approach;financial responsibility;input subsidy;rural area;financial sustainability;Animal Husbandry;input use;vegetable seed;distribution activity;Agricultural Technology;increasing share;community arrangements;household income;compensation arrangements;budget allocation;local funding;local funds;credit delivery;performance rating;institutional change;individual household;resettlement policy;road design;average yield;procurement procedure;local contribution;environmental aspect;vulnerable condition;water environment;regional benefits;grievance mechanism;environmental problem;environmental need;financial situation;hold land;community activity;rural welfare;road access;tree crop;positive impact;fodder production;lessons learnt;environmental matters;government transfer;appraisal mission;onward transmission;cost sharing;public expenditure;involuntary resettlement;gestation period;exit mechanism;local borrower;internal conflict;appraisal reports;road alignment;livestock specialist;project costing;forest nursery;project road;administrative support;savings account;local breed;citrus orchards;vegetable gardening;benefit stream;pilot program;poultry enterprise;food preservation;land area;research agenda;staff resource;travel delay;government staff;high transport;poor household;household level;fragile rangelands;breed improvement;sustainable management;financial constraint;gender focus;survival rate;local counterpart;agricultural benefit;seasonal opportunity;extension activity;artificial insemination;orchard crop;non-governmental organization;budgetary provision;field visits;transport cost;wheat flour;travel purpose;productive use;government budget;legislative assembly;general agreement;beneficiary survey;counterpart fund;farm activity;cultivated land;adult cow;subsistence agriculture;farm income;state land;plant material;participatory activity;rural strategy;farm activities;communal grazing;long-term conservation;cultivable wasteland;fodder crop;adaptive research;community awareness;management structure;beneficiary assessment;original amount;staff redeployment;Economics Unit;community plan;project processing;individual skill;operational design;government support;logical framework;community institution;pasture grazing;employment information;marketing support;poor village;Safeguard Policies;small stock;comparative advantage;Public Services;safeguard policy;community demand;explicit poverty;seed quality;budget datum;statistical sample;Vegetable Production;productivity gain;dairy cattle;project sustainability

Downloads

COMPLETAR RELATÓRIO

Versão oficial do documento (pode conter assinaturas, etc.)

  • PDF oficial
  • TXT*
  • Total Downloads** :
  • Download Stats
  • *A versão do texto é um OCR incorreto e está incluído unicamente em benefício de usuários com conectividade lenta.